Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / DoctorWhoS30E11TurnLeft

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ApocalypseHow: In the AlternateTimeline, the crises escalate into a ApocalypseHow/Class1 fallout over the course of less than two years. Britain ends up under martial law with the whole of Southern England flooded with radiation after the ''Titanic'' obliterates London, the many who are displaced from this are crowded into designated houses, and eventually the "[[ANaziByAnyOtherName England for the English]]" Law gets passed. Never mind France closing its borders after getting overwhelmed with refugees, or sixty million of America's population getting turned into Adipose.

to:

* ApocalypseHow: In the AlternateTimeline, the crises fallout of the various alien crises' alternate resolutions (or lack thereof) without the Doctor's intervention escalate into a ApocalypseHow/Class1 fallout over the course of less than within two years. Britain ends up under permanent martial law with the whole of Southern England flooded with radiation after the ''Titanic'' obliterates London, the many who are displaced from this are crowded into designated houses, and eventually the new emergency government pass an "[[ANaziByAnyOtherName England for the English]]" Law gets passed.Law. Never mind France closing its borders after getting overwhelmed with refugees, or sixty million of America's population getting turned into Adipose.



* SeriesContinuityError: "[[Recap/DoctorWho2007CSVoyageOfTheDamned Voyage of the Damned]]" stated, in no uncertain terms, that the crash of the starship ''Titanic'' into the Earth would wipe out humanity- if not ''all life on the planet''- in short order, thanks to the explosion of the ship's engines. In this episode's timeline we see the ship crash, and while the impact ''does'' irradiate a big chunk of England, the world beyond the British isles seems to be just fine (or rather, not ''fine'', but suffering for unrelated reasons). No explanation is given for the change in this scenario.

to:

* SeriesContinuityError: "[[Recap/DoctorWho2007CSVoyageOfTheDamned Voyage of the Damned]]" stated, in no uncertain terms, that the crash of the starship ''Titanic'' crashing into the Earth would wipe out humanity- be a global extinction event -- if not ''all life on the planet''- ''total'' biosphere extinction -- in short order, thanks to the explosion of the ship's engines. In this episode's timeline we see the ship crash, and while the impact ''does'' irradiate a big chunk of England, the world beyond the British isles Isles seems to be just fine (or rather, not ''fine'', but suffering for unrelated reasons). No explanation is given for the change in this scenario.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Doctor, without Donna, wasn't willing to save himself during the business with the Racnoss. It's implied that the Doctor was feeling so depressed and alone after of the events of [[Recap/DoctorWhoS28E13Doomsday the previous episode]] that he doesn't really care whether he lives or dies, which would explain why he is killed permanently. Meeting Donna eased that loneliness and allowed him to reconnect with the world, which is why Donna was able to snap him back, so he wouldn't die with the Racnoss. Creator/RussellTDavies confirmed that this is the case; the Doctor chose not to regenerate. UNIT speculated that it happened "too fast for him to regenerate" (which has never been raised as a possibility before short of disintegration), but of course they wouldn't know the whole story.

to:

** The Doctor, without Donna, wasn't willing to save himself during the business with the Racnoss. It's implied that the Doctor was feeling so depressed and alone after of the events of losing Rose in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS28E13Doomsday the previous episode]] that he doesn't really care whether he lives or dies, which would explain why he is killed permanently. Meeting Donna eased that loneliness and allowed him to reconnect with the world, which is why Donna was able to snap him back, so he wouldn't die with the Racnoss. Creator/RussellTDavies confirmed that this is the case; the Doctor chose not to regenerate. UNIT speculated that it happened "too fast for him to regenerate" (which has never been raised as a possibility before short of disintegration), but of course they wouldn't know the whole story.



* SoleSurvivor: Oliver Morgenstern is the only survivor of the Royal Hope Hospital Incident thanks to Martha giving him the last of her oxygen.

to:

* SoleSurvivor: Oliver Morgenstern is the only survivor of the Royal Hope Hospital Incident incident thanks to Martha giving him the last of her oxygen.

Changed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Doctor, without Donna, wasn't willing to save himself during the business with the Racnoss. It's implied that the Doctor was feeling so depressed and alone after of the events of [[Recap/DoctorWhoS28E13Doomsday the previous episode]] that he doesn't really care whether he lives or dies, which would explain why he is killed permanently. Meeting Donna eased that loneliness and allowed him to reconnect with the world, which is why Donna was able to snap him back, so he wouldn't die with the Racnoss. Russell T Davies confirmed that this is the case; the Doctor chose not to regenerate. UNIT speculated that it happened "too fast for him to regenerate" (which has never been raised as a possibility before short of disintegration), but of course they wouldn't know the whole story.

to:

** The Doctor, without Donna, wasn't willing to save himself during the business with the Racnoss. It's implied that the Doctor was feeling so depressed and alone after of the events of [[Recap/DoctorWhoS28E13Doomsday the previous episode]] that he doesn't really care whether he lives or dies, which would explain why he is killed permanently. Meeting Donna eased that loneliness and allowed him to reconnect with the world, which is why Donna was able to snap him back, so he wouldn't die with the Racnoss. Russell T Davies Creator/RussellTDavies confirmed that this is the case; the Doctor chose not to regenerate. UNIT speculated that it happened "too fast for him to regenerate" (which has never been raised as a possibility before short of disintegration), but of course they wouldn't know the whole story.



* RealLifeWritesThePlot: The reason Donna doesn't have anything to make her cling to her life in this alternative universe is that Creator/RussellTDavies gave up on his original idea of her having children during the middle of this havoc, since she already had a good marriage and children in Creator/StevenMoffat's [[Recap/DoctorWhoS30E9ForestOfTheDead episode]], which would air two weeks earlier. Also, the Doctor hints that there's something strange about the multiple alternative universes popping up around her because Russell and Steven were both using the same idea. It was worked into the plot after they exchanged e-mails about the episodes.

to:

* RealLifeWritesThePlot: The reason Donna doesn't have anything to make her cling to her life in this alternative universe is that Creator/RussellTDavies gave up on his original idea of her having children during the middle of this havoc, since she already had a good marriage and children in Creator/StevenMoffat's [[Recap/DoctorWhoS30E9ForestOfTheDead episode]], which would air two weeks earlier. Also, the Doctor hints that there's something strange about the multiple alternative universes popping up around her because Russell Davies and Steven Moffat were both using the same idea. It was worked into the plot after they exchanged e-mails about the episodes.



* TakeThat: Donna's family and the soundtrack both treat moving to Leeds [[FauxHorrific as a horrible fate]]. Russell T Davies considers rival northern city Manchester as his second home.

to:

* TakeThat: Donna's family and the soundtrack both treat moving to Leeds [[FauxHorrific as a horrible fate]]. Russell T Davies Creator/RussellTDavies considers rival northern city Manchester as his second home.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The whole JustBeforeTheEnd meets KitchenSinkDrama feel hearkens back to ''Film/TheWarGame'' and Davies' own ''Series/TheSecondComing''.

to:

** The whole JustBeforeTheEnd meets KitchenSinkDrama feel hearkens back to ''Film/TheWarGame'' ''Film/TheWarGame'', its spiritual successor ''Film/{{Threads}}'' (complete with a similar shot of everyday Britons paralyzed with fear at the sight of a mushroom cloud in the distance), and Davies' own ''Series/TheSecondComing''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BeautyIsNeverTarnished: Despite stepping in front of a speeding lorry, Donna is apparently untouched on the ground.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ManlyTears: Rocco and Wilf break down in tears saying goodbye to one another as the former is hauled off to a "labour camp".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Then the stars start going out.

Added: 4

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->[[ArcWords Bad Wolf!]]

to:

->[[ArcWords -->''[[ArcWords Bad Wolf!]]Wolf!]]''
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The one where Rose [[TheBusCameBack returns]] and we find out what the universe's like without the Doctor in it.

to:

The JustForFun/{{The one where w|ith}}here Rose [[TheBusCameBack returns]] and we find out what the universe's like without the Doctor in it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

--> '''Wilf''': "Work camps". That's what they called them [[UsefulNotes/TheHolocaust last time!]]"

Added: 232

Changed: 715

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlanetOfHats: Shan Shen is basically FriendlyLocalChinatown on a planet wide scale. The banners, the fortune tellers, the ethnicity of its people, etc. Downplayed as we don't know if the whole planet is like this, or just one area.

to:

* OppressiveImmigrationEnforcement: Following the numerous disasters in a world without the Doctor that cause Britain to become increasingly [[PoliceState restrictive and oppressive]], it climaxes in the new government implementing "[[ANaziByAnyOtherName England for the English]]" laws, but being unable to deport them due to borders being closed leads to armed soldiers rounding up immigrants (including Donna's Italian housemate [[RambunctiousItalian Mr. Colasanto]] and his entire family) to send them to "Labour Camps", the sight of this causing her grandfather Wilf to break down to tears.
* PlanetOfHats: Shan Shen is basically FriendlyLocalChinatown on a planet wide planet-wide scale. The banners, the fortune tellers, the ethnicity of its people, etc. Downplayed as we don't know if the whole planet is like this, this or just one area.

Added: 365

Removed: 365

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alphabetization


* TakeThat: Donna's family and the soundtrack both treat moving to Leeds [[FauxHorrific as a horrible fate]]. Russell T Davies considers rival northern city Manchester as his second home.



* TheWorldIsAlwaysDoomed: Played for genuine drama and horror. The disasters of Series 3 and 4 still happen and, without the Doctor to stop them, the world goes straight to hell.


Added DiffLines:

* TakeThat: Donna's family and the soundtrack both treat moving to Leeds [[FauxHorrific as a horrible fate]]. Russell T Davies considers rival northern city Manchester as his second home.


Added DiffLines:

* TheWorldIsAlwaysDoomed: Played for genuine drama and horror. The disasters of Series 3 and 4 still happen and, without the Doctor to stop them, the world goes straight to hell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FinalSolution: It's heavily implied in the episode (and confirmed in ''Magazine/DoctorWhoMagazine'') that the military government is systematically killing non-white, non-English residents as part of their "England for the English" Law. World War II veteran Wilfred quickly catches onto this after Mr. Colasanto is shipped off, and is reduced to tears by the knowledge that another Holocaust is occurring.

to:

* FinalSolution: It's heavily implied in the episode (and confirmed in ''Magazine/DoctorWhoMagazine'') that the military government is systematically killing non-white, non-white and/or non-English residents as part of their "England for the English" Law. World War II veteran Wilfred quickly catches onto this after Mr. Colasanto is shipped off, and is reduced to tears by the knowledge that another Holocaust is occurring.

Added: 407

Changed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing a chained sinkhole and replacing the WWII pothole with a Holocaust one, as that's what the line is referring to.


* DeadlyEuphemism: Wilfred (who lived through World War Two) readily recognizes that the emergency government's references to "labour camps" are actually a codeword for genocide.

to:

* DeadlyEuphemism: Wilfred (who lived through World War Two) II) readily recognizes that the emergency government's references to "labour camps" are actually a codeword for genocide.



* FinalSolution: It's heavily implied in the episode (and confirmed in ''Magazine/DoctorWhoMagazine'') that the military government is systematically killing non-white, non-English residents as part of their "England for the English" Law. World War II veteran Wilfred quickly catches onto this after Mr. Colasanto is shipped off, and is reduced to tears by the knowledge that another Holocaust is occurring.



--->"[[ANaziByAnyOtherName 'Labour camps']]. [[UsefulNotes/NaziGermany That's what they called them]] [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarII last time.]]"

to:

--->"[[ANaziByAnyOtherName 'Labour camps']]. That's what [[UsefulNotes/NaziGermany That's what they they]] called them]] [[UsefulNotes/WorldWarII them [[UsefulNotes/TheHolocaust last time.]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadlyEuphemism: Wilfred readily recognizes that the emergency government's references to "labour camps" are actually a codeword for genocide.

to:

* DeadlyEuphemism: Wilfred (who lived through World War Two) readily recognizes that the emergency government's references to "labour camps" are actually a codeword for genocide.



* PlanetOfHats: Shan Shen is basically FriendlyLocalChinatown on a planet wide scale. The banners, the fortune tellers, the ethnicity of its people, etc.

to:

* PlanetOfHats: Shan Shen is basically FriendlyLocalChinatown on a planet wide scale. The banners, the fortune tellers, the ethnicity of its people, etc. Downplayed as we don't know if the whole planet is like this, or just one area.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigBad: The Time Beetle is responsible for creating the [[CrapsackWorld parallel world]] around Donna.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''Original air date:''' June 21, 2008
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Donna and her family sing [[Music/{{Queen}} "Bohemian Rhapsody"]] with the Colasantos.

to:

** Donna and her family sing [[Music/{{Queen}} [[Music/QueenBand "Bohemian Rhapsody"]] with the Colasantos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TerminalTransformation: Without the Doctor around to stop Foster, millions of overweight Americans were fatally transformed into Adipose babies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TookALevelInJerkass: It's made extremely clear that Donna's mellowing out was due to the Doctor — she's just as stubborn and obnoxious as she was in the Christmas special.

to:

* TookALevelInJerkass: It's made extremely clear that Donna's mellowing out was due to the Doctor — she's just as stubborn and obnoxious as she was in her first episode. Sylvia also ups her verbal abuse of Donna after the Christmas special.England for the English movement is passed, to show just how hopeless the world has become when Donna barely reacts.



* WithholdingTheirName: Rose never tells Donna her name, or her UNIT allies for that matter. She explains that if she says the wrong word, it could "destabilise an entire causal nexus" (I.E. screw up the timeline). It also helps delay the Doctor's panicked reaction when Donna tells him about her experiences.

to:

* WithholdingTheirName: Rose never tells Donna her name, or her UNIT allies for that matter. She explains that if she says the wrong word, it could "destabilise an entire causal nexus" (I.E. screw up the timeline).timeline), but Captain Magambo implies Rose is actually being secretive for the fun of it. It also helps delay the Doctor's panicked reaction when Donna tells him about her experiences.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TakeThat: Donna's family and the soundtrack both treat moving to Leeds [[FauxHorrific as a horrible fate]]. Russell T Davies considers rival northern city Manchester as his second home.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreaterScopeVillain: [[spoiler: The Daleks.]]

to:

* GreaterScopeVillain: [[Series/TheSarahJaneAdventures The Trickster]] is the one behind the Fortune Teller’s actions. On a broader scale, [[spoiler: The Daleks.the Daleks and Davros are the reason the stars are going out.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GreaterScopeVillain: [[spoiler: The Daleks.]]

Added: 996

Changed: 198

Removed: 430

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The dialogue during that scene does more to imply that "labour camps" is a Deadly Euphemism for genocide considering the blatantly ethnonationalist views of the British government in this timeline.


* DeadlyEuphemism: Wilfred readily recognizes that the emergency government's references to "labour camps" are actually a codeword for genocide.



* EverybodyDiesEnding: The Doctor, Martha, [[Series/TheSarahJaneAdventures Sarah Jane, Maria, Clyde, Luke]], [[Series/{{Torchwood}} Gwen, Ianto]]; it's also heavily implied that a huge chunk of Britain's minority population died in a second Holocaust. With Donna and Rose the main characters of the episode, Jack immortal and Owen and Tosh already dead, that's every character that's ever had billing in all three series. Since this all gets reversed by the end of the episode, it's also an example of the SecondLawOfMetafictionalThermodynamics.



* KillEmAll: The Doctor, Martha, [[Series/TheSarahJaneAdventures Sarah Jane, Maria, Clyde, Luke]], [[Series/{{Torchwood}} Gwen, Ianto]]. With Donna and Rose the main characters of the episode, Jack immortal and Owen and Tosh already dead, that's every character that's ever had billing in all three series. Since this all gets reversed by the end of the episode, it's also an example of the SecondLawOfMetafictionalThermodynamics.



* ANaziByAnyOtherName: The "England for the English" law, passed by the new emergency government, involves labour camps for minorities.

to:

* ANaziByAnyOtherName: The "England for the English" law, passed by the new emergency government, involves labour camps "labour camps" for minorities.minorities; Wilfred immediately recognizes their actual intentions.



** Wilfred massively freaks out when he hears that Britain's minorities are being shipped off to "labour camps." As someone who lived through UsefulNotes/WorldWarII, he fully knows [[UsefulNotes/TheHolocaust what that means]], and is reduced to a pained whimper when he realizes that "it's happening again."



''[cut to the perpetually optimistic Mr Colasanto, who is hugging his wife and breaking down in tears as they are hauled away]''[[note]]During the Second World War many Italian families were put to work in labour camps due to Italy being allies with Germany.[[/note]]

to:

''[cut to the perpetually optimistic Mr Mr. Colasanto, who is hugging his wife and breaking down in tears as they are hauled away]''[[note]]During the Second World War many Italian families were put to work in labour camps due to Italy being allies with Germany.[[/note]]away]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Awkward sentence


* FakeShemp: Creator/DavidTennant didn't actually play the Doctor when he was lying on the stretcher when his body from the Thames.

to:

* FakeShemp: Creator/DavidTennant didn't actually play the Doctor when he was lying on the stretcher when his body after being pulled from the Thames.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Retcon}}: In ''Voyage of the Damned'', it was stated that the ''Titanic's'' nuclear storm engines would wipe out 6 billion humans (everyone on Earth) if she crashed. Here, the crash "only" destroys London and the southeast of England.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Retcon:}} In ''Voyage of the Damned'', it was stated that the ''Titanic's'' nuclear storm engines would wipe out 6 billion humans (everyone on Earth) if she crashed. Here, the crash "only" destroys London and the southeast of England.

to:

* {{Retcon:}} {{Retcon}}: In ''Voyage of the Damned'', it was stated that the ''Titanic's'' nuclear storm engines would wipe out 6 billion humans (everyone on Earth) if she crashed. Here, the crash "only" destroys London and the southeast of England.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Retcon:}} In ''Voyage of the Damned'', it was stated that the ''Titanic's'' nuclear storm engines would wipe out 6 billion humans (everyone on Earth) if she crashed. Here, the crash "only" destroys London and the southeast of England.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* AdultFear: Great Britain devolves into a police state and things get increasingly bleak with economic depression. It's made all the worse by the obvious Holocaust parallels at one point. The government sends foreigners away to "labour camps" as they're unable to simply deport them. Donna, while agitated, clearly doesn't grasp the situation in full. Her grandfather, Wilfred, lived through WWII and cries as he watches history repeat itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SeriesContinuityError: "[[Recap/DoctorWho2007CSVoyageOfTheDamned Voyage of the Damned]]" stated, in no uncertain terms, that the crash of the starship ''Titanic'' into the Earth would wipe out humanity- if not ''all life on the planet''- in short order, thanks to the explosion of the ship's engines. In this episode's timeline we see the ship crash, and while the impact ''does'' irradiate a big chunk of England, the world beyond the British isles seems to be just fine (or rather, not ''fine'', but suffering for unrelated reasons). No explanation is given for the change in this scenario.

Top