Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / ArrowS4E19CanaryCry

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: Ruve is heard discussing the development of the sewer system over the phone. Two weeks later, we learn just what it is she's been ''really'' building underground.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Retcon}}: A pretty large one with [[spoiler: flashbacks to just after Tommy's death showing Oliver not attending Tommy's funeral, Laurel being relatively upbeat and optimistic, Oliver and Laurel kissing and getting back together, Laurel planning their future and then Oliver dumping her again and heading to Lian Yu. The comics that accompany the TV show - and were considered canon - previously showed Oliver speaking at Tommy's funeral and Laurel too grief-stricken to see Oliver. Their scenes in 2x01 also implied they hadn't spoken since the Season 1 finale and had ''Laurel'' being the one to say they can't get back together. (Plus Laurel was broken-hearted over Tommy for much of Season 2). The retcon unfortunately makes it look like Laurel was relatively unaffected by Tommy's death and her Season 2 spiral was more over Oliver ditching her again.]]

to:

* {{Retcon}}: A pretty large one with [[spoiler: the flashbacks to just after Tommy's death showing Oliver not attending Tommy's funeral, Laurel being relatively upbeat and optimistic, Oliver and Laurel kissing and getting back together, Laurel planning their future and then Oliver dumping her again and heading to Lian Yu. The comics that accompany the TV show - and were considered canon - previously showed Oliver speaking at Tommy's funeral and Laurel too grief-stricken to see Oliver. Their scenes in 2x01 also implied they hadn't spoken since the Season 1 finale and had ''Laurel'' being the one to say they can't get back together. (Plus Laurel was broken-hearted over Tommy for much of Season 2). The retcon unfortunately makes it look like Laurel was relatively unaffected by Tommy's death and her Season 2 spiral was more over Oliver ditching her again.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Retcon}}: A pretty large one with [[spoiler: flashbacks to just after Tommy's death showing Oliver not attending Tommy's funeral, Laurel being relatively upbeat and optimistic, Oliver and Laurel kissing and getting back together, Laurel planning their future and then Oliver dumping her again and heading to Lian Yu. The comics that accompany the TV show - and were considered canon - previously showed Oliver speaking at Tommy's funeral and Laurel too grief-stricken to see Oliver. Their scenes in 2x01 also implied they hadn't spoken since the Season 1 finale and had ''Laurel'' being the one to say they can't get back together. (Plus Laurel was broken-hearted over Tommy for much of Season 2). The retcon unfortunately makes it look like Laurel was relatively unaffected by Tommy's death and her Season 2 spiral was more over Oliver ditching her again.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RewatchBonus: During the first scene when the camera pans past the main characters in the hospital hallway, a random young woman wanders right through the middle of them, unusually prominent for an extra. We later recognize her as Evelyn, and this was likely the moment that set the whole episode into motion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoSell: A member of the task force gets the jump on Oliver. Oliver knocks him out without even turning his head.

Added: 491

Changed: 28

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Dinah finally makes another appearance, after Alex Kingston's unavailability forced some awkward writing on how she found out about Sara's resurrection.
** Oliver's former campaign assistant makes his return.

to:

** Dinah finally makes another appearance, after Alex Kingston's Creator/AlexKingston's unavailability forced some awkward writing on how she found out about Sara's resurrection.
** Alex, Oliver's former campaign assistant assistant, makes his return.



* CallBack: The events of the [[Recap/ArrowS4E9DarkWaters mid-season finale]] is connected to the Black Canary poser's backstory.



* DueToTheDead: The main premise of the episode.



* NotNamedInOpeningCredits: Grant Gustin is not credited for his role as Barry Allen at the end of the episode. Justified, however, because the footage was shot for [[Recap/ArrowS4E1GreenArrow the season premiere]] and was simply re-used here.
* OffscreenBreakup: An interesting subversion in that the flashbacks shown are Oliver and Laurel's OffscreenBreakup between the Season 1 finale and the Season 2 premiere.

to:

* NotNamedInOpeningCredits: Grant Gustin Creator/GrantGustin is not credited for his role as Barry Allen at the end of the episode. Justified, however, because the footage was shot for [[Recap/ArrowS4E1GreenArrow the season premiere]] and was simply re-used here.
* OffscreenBreakup: An interesting subversion in that the flashbacks shown are Oliver and Laurel's said OffscreenBreakup between the Season 1 finale and the Season 2 premiere.



* OutlivingOnesOffspring: The episode deals with Quentin and Dinah (the former, especially) coming into terms regarding Laurel's death.
* OutOfOrder: This episode takes place after Barry regained his SuperSpeed. The ''Flash'' episode that aired the previous night ends with the planning of regaining said power.



* WouldHitAGirl: Diggle pistol-whips Ruvé Adams in the face.

to:

* WouldHitAGirl: Diggle pistol-whips Ruvé Adams in the face.face.

----

Added: 1407

Changed: 221

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlliterativeTitle: '''C'''ana'''ry''' '''Cry'''



* BookEnds: In her final flashback scene, Laurel is wearing the exact same clothes she was wearing in her very first scene in the pilot.



** Oliver's former campaign assistant makes his return.
* ButNowIMustGo: Oliver decides to return to Lian Yu in the flashbacks to deal with his self-loathing and gried regarding Tommy's death.



* CryCute: The always proud and poised Nyssa breaks down from sympathy for Quentin and her own grief.
* DoubleMeaningTitle: Aside from the obvious that the episode deals with the effects of Laurel's death had for her loved ones, the other main conflict of the episode is about the retrieval of her eponymous weapon that was stolen.



* FondMemoriesThatCouldHaveBeen: The flashbacks shown leaves many thoughts regarding the different paths that Oliver and Laurel could have taken if they didn't chose to end it (or rather, if Oliver didn't chose to end it).



* KickTheSonOfABitch: Diggle pistol-whips Ruvé Adams, Dahrk's SmugSnake evil wife.



* ManlyTears: Every single major male character sans Damien Dahrk shed them throughout the episode.



* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Felicity is actively encouraging Oliver to kill Darhk, a sign of how much Laurel's murder affected her.

to:

* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: OffscreenBreakup: An interesting subversion in that the flashbacks shown are Oliver and Laurel's OffscreenBreakup between the Season 1 finale and the Season 2 premiere.
* OOCIsSeriousBusiness:
** Diggle, who is TheHeart of Team Arrow and consistently its OnlySaneMan, goes on a RoaringRampageOfRevenge.
**
Felicity is actively encouraging Oliver to kill Darhk, a sign of how much Laurel's murder affected her.



** Oliver chews out Diggle for trying to kill Ruvé, pointing out it won't achieve anything to kill Star City's new and powerful mayor.

to:

** Oliver chews out Diggle for trying to kill Ruvé, pointing out it won't achieve anything to kill Star City's new and powerful mayor.mayor.
* WouldHitAGirl: Diggle pistol-whips Ruvé Adams in the face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeroWithBadPublicity: Thanks to John and Evelyn's rash actions, Ruvé is able to turn the city against Team Arrow. However, Oliver tells everyone at Laurel's funeral that she was the real Black Canary, in order to persevere her legacy.

to:

* HeroWithBadPublicity: Thanks to John and Evelyn's rash actions, Ruvé is able to turn the city against Team Arrow. However, Oliver tells everyone at Laurel's funeral that she was the real Black Canary, in order to persevere preserve her legacy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BackFromTheDead: Averted. No matter how badly Quentin wants to evoke this, Laurel ain't coming back.

to:

* BackFromTheDead: Averted. No matter how badly Quentin wants to evoke this, Laurel ain't will not be coming back.back by any means known at the time in the Arrowverse.

Added: 1093

Changed: 1430

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CosmicPlaything: The Lance Family.

to:

* CosmicPlaything: The Lance Family. This is the ''third'' time that Quentin and Dinah have lost one of their daughters, and unlike Sara, Laurel [[KilledOffForReal isn't coming back]].
* FiveStagesOfGrief: Quentin spends a good chunk in denial before he has to accept that Laurel isn't ever coming back.



* HeroWithBadPublicity: Thanks to John and Evelyn's rash actions, Ruve is able to turn the city against Team Arrow. However, Oliver tells everyone at Laurel's funeral that she was the real Black Canary, in order to persevere her legacy.
* FiveStagesOfGrief: Quentin spends a good chunk in denial before he has to accept that Laurel isn't ever coming back.

to:

* ForegoneConclusion: Oliver's comment about never being able to defeat the idol's magic suggests that his flashback arc for this season won't have a happy ending.
* GodzillaThreshold: Darhk's murder of Laurel has convinced Oliver to dispense with his [[ThouShaltNotKill usual]] policy and just ''kill'' him.
* HeroWithBadPublicity: Thanks to John and Evelyn's rash actions, Ruve Ruvé is able to turn the city against Team Arrow. However, Oliver tells everyone at Laurel's funeral that she was the real Black Canary, in order to persevere her legacy.
* FiveStagesOfGrief: Quentin spends a good chunk in denial before he has to accept that Laurel isn't ever coming back.
legacy.



* LegacyCharacter: Evelyn Sharp spends part of this episode as the second Black Canary. Her actions nearly ruin the reputation of the real Black Canary, but Oliver manages to redeem the name at Laurel's funeral.



* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Diggle's attacking Ruve, gives her an excuse to reform the Anti-Vigilant Taskforce.

to:

* MythologyGag: Evelyn Sharp's middle name is "Crawford", a reference to Evelyn Crawford/Starling, a character from ''ComicBook/BirdsOfPrey''.
* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Diggle's attacking Ruve, Ruvé, gives her an excuse to reform the Anti-Vigilant Anti-Vigilante Taskforce.



* PlotHole: It's never explained how Evelyn managed to bypass Cisco's security lock on the Canary Cry or how she connects Ruve to Hive.
* TheReveal: We finally find out who Oliver said he'd kill in the premiere - Laurel's murderer Damian Darhk.

to:

* PlotHole: It's never explained how Evelyn managed to bypass Cisco's security lock on the Canary Cry or how she connects Ruve Ruvé to Hive.
* ThePowerOfLegacy: A major focus in this episode is Laurel' legacy as the Black Canary. Team Arrow fears that Evelyn's actions in Laurel's costume will leave the Black Canary remembered as nothing but a murderer. To make sure that both Laurel and her secret identity get the legacy they deserve, Oliver reveals that Laurel was the Black Canary at her funeral, causing her to be remembered as the hero she truly was. Laurel's epitaph even reads "The Black Canary" as a reflection of this.
* RealityEnsues: Ruvé working with the bad guys doesn't change the fact that she's the lawful mayor of Star City. Diggle's attack on her gives Ruvé everything she needs to issue an arrest warrant for all of Team Arrow.
* TheReveal: We finally find out who Oliver said he'd kill in the premiere - Laurel's murderer Damian Damien Darhk.



* VillainWithGoodPublicity: Ruve, since there's no official connection between her and Darhk.

to:

* UngratefulBastard: The first words out of Ruvé's mouth after Oliver talks Evelyn out of killing her? "Arrest him!"
* VillainWithGoodPublicity: Ruve, Ruvé, since there's no official connection between her and Darhk.



** Oliver chews out Diggle for trying to kill Ruve, pointing out it won't achieve anything to kill Star City's new and powerful mayor.

to:

** Oliver chews out Diggle for trying to kill Ruve, Ruvé, pointing out it won't achieve anything to kill Star City's new and powerful mayor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Averted with Oliver, who notes that he ''use'' to think this way, but he makes it clear that he blames Darhk and he's going to kill him.

to:

** Averted with Oliver, who notes that he ''use'' ''used'' to think this way, but he makes it clear that he blames Darhk and he's going to kill him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InvincibleVillain: Discussed. Oliver believes that Darhk's magic makes him too powerful to defeat but Felicity refuses to believe it.


Added DiffLines:

* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: Felicity is actively encouraging Oliver to kill Darhk, a sign of how much Laurel's murder affected her.

Added: 108

Changed: 53

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCameo: Barry at Laurel's funeral.

to:

* TheCameo: Barry at Laurel's funeral.funeral, although it's just footage reused from the premiere.


Added DiffLines:

* TheReveal: We finally find out who Oliver said he'd kill in the premiere - Laurel's murderer Damian Darhk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCameo: Barry at Laurel's funeral.



* VillainWithGoodPublicity: Ruve, since there's no official connection between her and Darhk.

to:

* VillainWithGoodPublicity: Ruve, since there's no official connection between her and Darhk.Darhk.
* WhatTheHellHero:
** Evelyn chews the Green Arrow for being so focused on rescuing his friends, that he neglected to save anyone else from Hive's base at Reddington Industries. Oliver concedes her point, but Diggle tells him those people were there of their own free will.
** Oliver chews out Diggle for trying to kill Ruve, pointing out it won't achieve anything to kill Star City's new and powerful mayor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Reason Ollie chewed out Dig for hunting Ruve was not He Who Fights Monsters, it was that she was a mayor and was too influential to be targeted.


* {{Hypocrite}}. Oliver once again, who scolds John for going after Ruve in order to find Andy and [[HeWhoFightsMonsters stepping down to the same level his enemies are]]....only for himself to promise later that he will kill Darhk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbsenteeActor: Merlyn, Darhk, and Andy are absent from this episode.

to:

* AbsenteeActor: Merlyn, Darhk, and Andy are absent from this episode. As are Baron Reiter and Taiana from the flashbacks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Hypocrite}}. Oliver once again, who scolds John for going after Ruve in order to find Andy and [[HeWhoFightsMonsters stepping down to the same level his enemies are]]....only for himself to promise later that he will kill Darhk.

Added: 197

Changed: 39

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBusCameBack: Nyssa comes back to attend the funeral.

to:

* TheBusCameBack: TheBusCameBack:
**
Nyssa comes back to attend the funeral.funeral.
** Dinah finally makes another appearance, after Alex Kingston's unavailability forced some awkward writing on how she found out about Sara's resurrection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LittleMissBadass: As Felicity describes Evelyn Sharp, she is a 16 year old badass who excels both at academics and fitness.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NotNamedInOpeningCredits: Grant Gustin is not credited for his role as Barry Allen at the end of the episode. Justified, however, because the footage was shot for [[Recap/ArrowS4E1GreenArrow the season premiere]] and was simply re-used here.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StrangerBehindTheMask: We learn fairly quickly on that the impostor Black Canary is not anyone we already know, but a new [[MonsterOfTheWeek threat of the week]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Flashback}}: While each season has at least one episode where the flashback is something other than Oliver's adventures five years ago, this is notable in that it actually takes place ''during'' the events of the series--specifically, between [[Recap/ArrowS1E23Sacrifice the 1st season finale]] and [[Recap/ArrowS2E1CityOfHeroes the 2nd season premiere]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, the opening scene appears at first to be Laurel's, but it's actually a flashback to Tommy's.

to:

** Also, the opening scene appears at first to be Laurel's, Laurel's funeral, but it's actually a flashback to Tommy's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: When Nyssa has to tell Quentin she destroyed the Lazarus Pit, you can tell from her face that she regrets it, especially since it was especially since it was just to spite Merlyn.

to:

* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: When Nyssa has to tell Quentin she destroyed the Lazarus Pit, you can tell from her face that she regrets it, especially since it was especially since it was just to spite Merlyn.

Added: 93

Changed: 33

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlotHole: It's never explained how Evelyn managed to bypass Cisco's security lock on the Canary Cry.
* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: Evelyn wants revenge on Hive for killing her parents in their gas chambers.

to:

* PlotHole: It's never explained how Evelyn managed to bypass Cisco's security lock on the Canary Cry.
Cry or how she connects Ruve to Hive.
* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: Evelyn wants revenge on Hive for killing her parents in their gas chambers.chambers.
* VillainWithGoodPublicity: Ruve, since there's no official connection between her and Darhk.

Added: 747

Changed: 312

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaitAndSwitch: For a brief moment, we some how think that Laurel some how survived, but it's just some girl who stole her gear.

to:

* BaitAndSwitch: BaitAndSwitch:
**
For a brief moment, we some how think that Laurel some how survived, but it's just some girl who stole her gear.



* TheBusCameBack: Nyssa comes back to attend the funeral.



* CosmicPlaything: The Lance Family.
* HeroWithBadPublicity: Thanks to John and Evelyn's rash actions, Ruve is able to turn the city against Team Arrow. However, Oliver tells everyone at Laurel's funeral that she was the real Black Canary, in order to persevere her legacy.



* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: When Nyssa has to tell Quentin she destroyed the Lazarus Pit, you can tell from her face that she regrets it.

to:

** Averted with Oliver, who notes that he ''use'' to think this way, but he makes it clear that he blames Darhk and he's going to kill him.
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: When Nyssa has to tell Quentin she destroyed the Lazarus Pit, you can tell from her face that she regrets it.it, especially since it was especially since it was just to spite Merlyn.



* PlotHole: It's never explained how Evelyn managed to bypass Cisco's security lock on the Canary Cry.

to:

* PlotHole: It's never explained how Evelyn managed to bypass Cisco's security lock on the Canary Cry.Cry.
* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: Evelyn wants revenge on Hive for killing her parents in their gas chambers.

Added: 444

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbsenteeActor: Both Merlyn, Darhk, and Andy are absent from this episode.

to:

* AbsenteeActor: Both Merlyn, Darhk, and Andy are absent from this episode.


Added DiffLines:

** Also, the opening scene appears at first to be Laurel's, but it's actually a flashback to Tommy's.


Added DiffLines:

* InternalReveal: At Laurel's funeral, Oliver tells everyone that she was the Black Canary, in order to preserve her memory in both identities.
* ItsAllMyFault:
** Diggle spends most of the episode convinced that Laurel's death is his fault, for trusting Andy.
** Felicity blames herself for not being with the team during Laurel's final mission.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

As Team Arrow is grieving for their fallen comrade, a mysterious girl has taken up Laurel's mantle.
----
* AbsenteeActor: Both Merlyn, Darhk, and Andy are absent from this episode.
* BackFromTheDead: Averted. No matter how badly Quentin wants to evoke this, Laurel ain't coming back.
* BaitAndSwitch: For a brief moment, we some how think that Laurel some how survived, but it's just some girl who stole her gear.
* ContinuityNod: Quentin in his grief is quick to name all the people in the Arrowverse who were thought to be dead, but weren't.
* FiveStagesOfGrief: Quentin spends a good chunk in denial before he has to accept that Laurel isn't ever coming back.
* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: When Nyssa has to tell Quentin she destroyed the Lazarus Pit, you can tell from her face that she regrets it.
* NiceJobBreakingItHero: Diggle's attacking Ruve, gives her an excuse to reform the Anti-Vigilant Taskforce.
* PlotHole: It's never explained how Evelyn managed to bypass Cisco's security lock on the Canary Cry.

Top