Follow TV Tropes

Following

History PlayingWith / MyBelovedSmother

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on works content

Added DiffLines:

** Alice blames herself (rightfully or otherwise) for something that happened to Charlie, and she is acting out of guilt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alice is a [[HandsOffParenting "hands off" parent]] who lets Charlie go completely after he leaves the house.

to:

** Alice is a [[HandsOffParenting "hands off" parent]] who lets Charlie go completely after he leaves the house.house, even when he's just a child who has no idea of what he's doing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV tropes cannot be played with.


** Charlie has a [[AmbiguousDisorder mental disability]]

to:

** Charlie has a [[AmbiguousDisorder mental disability]]disability.

Added: 501

Changed: 263

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Played For Horror''': Alice's unrelenting, decades-long smothering has turned Charlie into a copycat of [[Film/{{Psycho}} Norman Bates]]. Maybe even, like Norman, Charlie killed Alice to try to make her ''shut up'' once and for all, but her nagging still hounds him as hallucinations.

to:

* '''Played For Horror''': Horror''':
**
Alice's unrelenting, decades-long smothering has turned Charlie into a copycat of [[Film/{{Psycho}} Norman Bates]]. Maybe even, like Norman, Charlie killed Alice to try to make her ''shut up'' once and for all, but her nagging still hounds him as hallucinations.hallucinations.
** Alternatively, they're the creepy VillainousMotherSonDuo which Alice is a EvilMatriarch who encourages Charlie, her PsychopathicManchild son to commit several crimes and violent things, which Alice always keeps an eye on his actions.

Changed: 37

Removed: 60

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Overprotective Dad has been disambiguated


* '''Gender Flip''':
** OverprotectiveDad
** Alan is overly protective of Charlie.

to:

* '''Gender Flip''':
** OverprotectiveDad
**
Flip''': Alan is overly protective of Charlie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''Played For Drama''': Charlie is 55 and every single second he's awake he's got to withstand his mother lecturing him about anything he does (and blinking too hard at any point of those lectures leads to the standard "I raised an inconsiderate son!" rant). Charlie would ''really'' like to holler at a BigShutUp, but he doesn't want to risk [[MadeOutToBeAJerkass someone misrepresenting it as an abusive episode and calling the cops]].

to:

* '''Played For Drama''': Charlie is 55 and every single second he's awake he's got to withstand his mother lecturing him about anything he does (and blinking too hard at any point of those lectures leads to the standard "I raised an inconsiderate son!" rant). Charlie would ''really'' like to holler at out a BigShutUp, but he doesn't want to risk [[MadeOutToBeAJerkass someone misrepresenting it as an abusive episode and calling the cops]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Charlie is brainwashed frequently by Alice that she is overprotective because she is the only one who actually loves him, he tried to call her out several times in his younger years but failed, so he gives up on it, several years later, [[{{Manchild}} he still acts like a little kid]] [[SpoiledBrat who demand EVERYTHING from his mom]], he [[BasementDweller still living with her]] since she never allows him to move anywhere, he can't keep a job for more than a few months before he gets fired for NoSocialSkills and doing something stupid, and he never quite learned to do basic life skills by himself such as how to clean his house and manage his bank accounts because his mom already does everything for him. As time goes by, Alice [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realizes that she has bred an absolute]] PsychopathicManchild who consumes both her energy and her saved money from the pension, and affects her health as well.

to:

** Charlie is brainwashed frequently by Alice that she is overprotective because she is the only one who actually loves him, he tried to call her out several times in his younger years but failed, so he gives up on it, and [[MommasBoy lets his mom controls his life]], several years later, [[{{Manchild}} he still acts like a little kid]] [[SpoiledBrat who demand EVERYTHING from his mom]], he [[BasementDweller still living with her]] since she never allows him to move anywhere, he can't keep a job for more than a few months before he gets fired for NoSocialSkills and doing something stupid, and he never quite learned to do basic life skills by himself such as how to clean his house and manage his bank accounts because his mom already does everything for him. As time goes by, Alice [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realizes that she has bred an absolute]] PsychopathicManchild who consumes both her energy and her saved money from the pension, and affects her health as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Charlie is a really dependent person who needs attention and help from his parents even as he gets older.

to:

** Charlie is a really dependent person who needs attention and help helps from his parents even as he gets older.



** Charlie complains about his mother's overbearing nature to everyone in earshot; when she finally appears, it's revealed he was [[EmoTeen exaggerating]] [[BrattyTeenageSon wildly]] and she's a perfectly normal mother.

to:

** Charlie complains about his mother's overbearing nature to everyone in earshot; when she finally appears, it's revealed he was [[EmoTeen exaggerating]] [[BrattyTeenageSon [[UnreliableNarrator lying or exaggerating wildly]] and she's a perfectly normal mother.



** Alice will come into Charlie's work place and call him constantly, cooing over him and even spies on Diane, Charlie's girlfriend, [[KnightTemplarParent to make sure that everything is fine for him]].

to:

** Alice will come into Charlie's work place workplace and call him constantly, cooing over him and even spies spying on Diane, Charlie's girlfriend, [[KnightTemplarParent to make sure that everything is fine for him]].



** Charlie is brainwashed frequently by Alice that she is overprotective because she is the only one who actually loves him, he tried to call her out several times in his younger years but failed, so he gives up from it, several years later, [[{{Manchild}} he still acts like a little kid]] [[SpoiledBrat who demand EVERYTHING from his mom]], he [[BasementDweller still living with her]] since she never allows him to move anywhere, he can't keep a job for more than a few months before he gets fired for NoSocialSkills and doing something stupid, and he never quite learned to doing basic life skills by himself such as how to cleaning his house and managing his bank accounts because his mom already do everything for him. As times goes by, Alice [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realizes that she has bred an absolute]] PsychopathicManchild who consume both her energy and her saved money from the pension, and affect her health as well.

to:

** Charlie is brainwashed frequently by Alice that she is overprotective because she is the only one who actually loves him, he tried to call her out several times in his younger years but failed, so he gives up from on it, several years later, [[{{Manchild}} he still acts like a little kid]] [[SpoiledBrat who demand EVERYTHING from his mom]], he [[BasementDweller still living with her]] since she never allows him to move anywhere, he can't keep a job for more than a few months before he gets fired for NoSocialSkills and doing something stupid, and he never quite learned to doing do basic life skills by himself such as how to cleaning clean his house and managing manage his bank accounts because his mom already do does everything for him. As times time goes by, Alice [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realizes that she has bred an absolute]] PsychopathicManchild who consume consumes both her energy and her saved money from the pension, and affect affects her health as well.

Added: 150

Changed: 907

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[MissingCHild Charlie was kidnapped as a child]], so Alice's smothering is an emotional reaction to it.

to:

** [[MissingCHild [[MissingChild Charlie was kidnapped as a child]], so Alice's smothering is an emotional reaction to it.



** Alice forgets about her own life because she worries about Charlie's before her own, and Charlie is an UngratefulBastard.

to:

** Charlie is brainwashed frequently by Alice that she is overprotective because she is the only one who actually loves him, he tried to call her out several times in his younger years but failed, so he gives up from it, several years later, [[{{Manchild}} he still acts like a little kid]] [[SpoiledBrat who demand EVERYTHING from his mom]], he [[BasementDweller still living with her]] since she never allows him to move anywhere, he can't keep a job for more than a few months before he gets fired for NoSocialSkills and doing something stupid, and he never quite learned to doing basic life skills by himself such as how to cleaning his house and managing his bank accounts because his mom already do everything for him. As times goes by, Alice [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone realizes that she has bred an absolute]] PsychopathicManchild who consume both her energy and her saved money from the pension, and affect her health as well.
** Alice forgets about her own life because she worries about Charlie's before her own, and Charlie is an UngratefulBastard.UngratefulBastard, or even AbusiveOffspring.

Added: 292

Changed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Charlie complains about his mother's overbearing nature to everyone in earshot; when she finally appears, it's revealed he was [[EmoTeen exaggerating wildly]] and she's a perfectly normal mother.

to:

** Charlie complains about his mother's overbearing nature to everyone in earshot; when she finally appears, it's revealed he was [[EmoTeen exaggerating exaggerating]] [[BrattyTeenageSon wildly]] and she's a perfectly normal mother.



** Or her "normal" behavior is just faking.



** Demetra, Alice's old friend, after seeing everything in her family finally gives her an AntiSmotherLoveTalk, which prompts Alice to loose her grip over Charlie,

to:

** Demetra, Alice's old friend, after seeing everything in her family finally gives her an AntiSmotherLoveTalk, which prompts Alice to loose lose her grip over Charlie,



** After Alice dies, Charlie gains the actual freedom of his own life, and raises his own son in a more {{Open Minded|Parent}} way in the fear that [[IAmNotMyMother if he smothers his son in the same way with his mom, the son will end up like him.]]



* '''Played For Drama''': Charlie is 55 and every single second he's awake he's got to withstand his mother lecturing him about anything he does (and blinking too hard at any point of those lectures leads to the standard "I raised an inconsiderate son!" rant). Charlie would ''really'' like to holler a BigShutUp, but he doesn't wants to risk [[MadeOutToBeAJerkass someone misrepresenting it as an abusive episode and calling the cops]].
* '''Played For Horror''': Alice's unrelenting, decades-long smothering has turned Charlie into a copy-cat of [[Film/{{Psycho}} Norman Bates]]. Maybe even, like Norman, Charlie killed Alice to try to make her ''shut up'' once and for all, but her nagging still hounds him as hallucinations.

to:

* '''Played For Drama''': Charlie is 55 and every single second he's awake he's got to withstand his mother lecturing him about anything he does (and blinking too hard at any point of those lectures leads to the standard "I raised an inconsiderate son!" rant). Charlie would ''really'' like to holler at a BigShutUp, but he doesn't wants want to risk [[MadeOutToBeAJerkass someone misrepresenting it as an abusive episode and calling the cops]].
* '''Played For Horror''': Alice's unrelenting, decades-long smothering has turned Charlie into a copy-cat copycat of [[Film/{{Psycho}} Norman Bates]]. Maybe even, like Norman, Charlie killed Alice to try to make her ''shut up'' once and for all, but her nagging still hounds him as hallucinations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[AdultFear Charlie was kidnapped as a child]], so Alice's smothering is an emotional reaction to it.

to:

** [[AdultFear [[MissingCHild Charlie was kidnapped as a child]], so Alice's smothering is an emotional reaction to it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternately: Alice forgets about her own life because she worries about Charlie's before her own, and Charlie is an UngratefulBastard.

to:

** Alternately: Alice forgets about her own life because she worries about Charlie's before her own, and Charlie is an UngratefulBastard.

Top