Follow TV Tropes

Following

History OfficerAndAGentleman / Literature

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Given the medievalesque setting of LOTR, Faramir is more of a Knight In Shining Armor


* Faramir from ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' fits this trope perfectly. An officer and gentleman, he is extremely honorable (to the point he wouldn't lie even to an orc) and impeccably courteous (even toward his war prisoners).

Added: 6160

Changed: 9696

Removed: 3543

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%
%%
%%
%%
%% This list of examples has been alphabetized. Please add your example in the proper place. Thanks!
%%
%%
%%
%%
%%



* Commissar ''Literature/CiaphasCain'' ([[FakeUltimateHero HERO OF THE IMPERIUM!]]) does his best to be seen as one.
* Despite being a [[YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters rabble-rousing populist]], General Nortier of ''Literature/TheCountOfMonteCristo'' provides a good example of a gentleman soldier behaving honorably to those of the same class, even if on opposing sides. In the backstory which led to Dantes' imprisonment, Franz d'Epinay's father, a Royalist, was caught [[DressingAsTheEnemy infiltrating]] the group of pro-Napoleon soldiers Nortier belonged to and seeing that d'Epinay was a fellow gentleman, Nortier allowed him to duel to the death instead of simply killing him outright.



* Faramir from ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' fits this trope perfectly. An officer and gentleman, he is extremely honorable (to the point he wouldn't lie even to an orc) and impeccably courteous (even toward his war prisoners).
* One of the primary themes of ''Literature/StarshipTroopers''.
* In Creator/LoisMcMasterBujold's Literature/VorkosiganSaga, all Barrayaran officers are expected to be, and sometimes they even are:
** Aral and Miles play this trope to a tee. However, Aral's reputation as [[RedBaron "The Butcher of Komarr"]] does not.
** Cordelia--as a captain in the Betan Expeditionary Force -- is the female equivalent… as contrasted with Cordelia's prior tour in the Betan Astronomical Survey, where being captain was more like being TeamMom.
** A young example (and lampshade) is Lieutenant Miles Vorkosigan in ''Cetaganda'' who early in the book reminds himself that he is "an officer and a nobleman."
** Miles' relative Ivan also shows quite a few traits of this. Ivan--a soldier in the Barrayaran Imperial Service--employs some irony when asked, "Are you a hired killer?" He replies, "Well, [[LiteralMinded in a ''sense'']]." Further, although he has the manners and breeding for this trope, he ends up being the beleaguered enlisted man to Miles most of the time.
** Being a blend of Samurai and Prussian Junkers, the Vor of Barrayar are expected to act this way whether or not they are technically officers, being a class (excuse me, [[InsistentTerminology 'warrior caste']]) of Officers and Gentlemen.
* Ista from Bujold's ''Literature/PaladinOfSouls'' is attracted to a man who fits the trope before ending up with that guy's younger brother who behaves much more casual and considers himself [[TheMinnesotaFats second best at everything]]. Of course, the older one was taken [[spoiler:and undead]].
* The ChasteHero Captain Avery in the book ''Literature/ThePyrates'' which is a DeconstructorFleet of pirate movie cliches fits this description perfectly.

to:

* Faramir from ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' fits this trope perfectly. An officer and gentleman, he is extremely honorable (to The armies of Victorian Europe in the point he wouldn't lie even to an orc) and impeccably courteous (even toward his war prisoners).
* One
''{{Literature/Flashman}}'' novels are full of the primary themes of ''Literature/StarshipTroopers''.
* In Creator/LoisMcMasterBujold's Literature/VorkosiganSaga, all Barrayaran
officers who are expected to be, jovial, charming, considerate of their men, and sometimes they even are:
** Aral and Miles play
thoroughly chivalrous. Naturally, our FakeUltimateHero protagonist despises every last one of them.
* Creator/RudyardKipling's ''Gentlemen Rankers'' describes those who failed to be
this trope to a tee. However, Aral's reputation as [[RedBaron "The Butcher of Komarr"]] does not.
trope.
** Cordelia--as a captain in the Betan Expeditionary Force -- is the female equivalent… as contrasted with Cordelia's prior tour in the Betan Astronomical Survey, where being captain was more like being TeamMom.
** A young example (and lampshade) is Lieutenant Miles Vorkosigan in ''Cetaganda'' who early in the book reminds himself that he is "an officer and a nobleman."
** Miles' relative Ivan
Kipling also shows quite a few traits of this. Ivan--a soldier in the Barrayaran Imperial Service--employs some irony when asked, "Are you a hired killer?" He replies, "Well, [[LiteralMinded in a ''sense'']]." Further, although he has the manners and breeding for poked fun at this trope, he ends up being the beleaguered enlisted man to Miles noting how ''useless'' most of that book-learnin', college degrees, and gentlemanly chivalry actually are on the time.
** Being
battlefield.
-->''A scrimmage in
a blend Border Station-''
-->''A canter down some dark defile''
-->''Two thousand pounds
of Samurai and Prussian Junkers, education''
-->''Drops to a ten-rupee'' jezail[[note]]a home-made (and very accurate) Afghan rifle[[/note]].
-->''The Crammer's boast,
the Vor of Barrayar are expected to act this way whether or not they are technically officers, being Squadron's pride,''
-->''Shot like
a class (excuse me, [[InsistentTerminology 'warrior caste']]) of Officers and Gentlemen.
* Ista
rabbit in a ride!''
-->''No proposition Euclid wrote''
-->''No formulae the text-books know,''
-->''Will turn the bullet
from Bujold's ''Literature/PaladinOfSouls'' is attracted to a man your coat,''
-->''Or ward the tulwar's downward blow.''
-->''Strike hard
who fits cares - shoot straight who can''
-->''The odds are on
the trope before ending up with that guy's younger brother who behaves much more casual and considers himself [[TheMinnesotaFats second best at everything]]. Of course, cheaper man.''
--->--"Arithmetic on
the older one was taken [[spoiler:and undead]].
* The ChasteHero Captain Avery in the book ''Literature/ThePyrates'' which is a DeconstructorFleet of pirate movie cliches fits this description perfectly.
Frontier" (1886)



* Despite being a [[YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters rabble-rousing populist]], General Nortier of ''Literature/TheCountOfMonteCristo'' provides a good example of a gentleman soldier behaving honorably to those of the same class, even if on opposing sides. In the backstory which led to Dantes' imprisonment, Franz d'Epinay's father, a Royalist, was caught [[DressingAsTheEnemy infiltrating]] the group of pro-Napoleon soldiers Nortier belonged to and seeing that d'Epinay was a fellow gentleman, Nortier allowed him to duel to the death instead of simply killing him outright.
* Several examples in ''Literature/WarAndPeace''. Two prominent ones are the French captain [[PunchClockVillain Ramballe]] and Field Marshal Kutuzov. War isn't very personal; most prisoners throughout the book are treated relatively well, even equally.
* Capt. Laurence, of ''Literature/{{Temeraire}}''. He was originally a British Navy captain--where such is apparently expected--before harnessing Temeraire and is still more polished and formal than most of his crew and fellow officers, the Aerial Corps almost necessarily being much less formal. His own crew, out of admiration for him, started taking after his example. He, in turn, began to shed the stiffness in his manners as he embraced his new life.
* Peter D'Alembord from ''Literature/{{Sharpe}}'', a charming, elegant, and well-educated gentleman (who only joined the army because he killed a man in a duel). The title character is often pointed out to not be a gentleman, though an officer, although his conduct towards women is usually better than most of his well-born peers.
** Captain Fredrickson is a bit rougher around the edges than D'Alembord, but is a highly capable leader of skirmishers who also speaks fluent Spanish, French and German, and spends his free time admiring church architecture, sketching landscapes in pencil, and discussing the merits and flaws of republican governments with American expatriates and French prisoners of war.
* Commander Mitth'raw'nuruodo, of the Franchise/StarWarsExpandedUniverse novel ''Literature/OutboundFlight'', qualifies as one, if one given to somewhat underhanded tactics and his own set of morals. However, [[Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy later-set books]] have him as an [[AffablyEvil Affably Imperial]] CulturedWarrior.
* The hares of the Long Patrol army in the ''Literature/{{Redwall}}'' series behave like this (even some of the ones who aren't actually in the Long Patrol). The Long Patrol itself didn't appear by name in the first few books, but grew in importance eventually taking centre stage in (naturally) ''The Long Patrol''.

to:

* Despite Richard Hannay, the hero of John Buchan's thriller novels, joins the army and serves as an officer in ''Literature/{{Greenmantle}}'' and ''Literature/MrStandfast'', retiring with distinction at war's end.
* ''Literature/HonorHarrington'' has its fair share.
** On the Manticoran side, the most prominent are probably Hamish Alexander and Michael Oversteegen.
*** Oversteegen is particularly notable in that he has every known trait of a Manticoran UpperClassTwit, belongs to the previously self-serving Conservative party, and seemingly got his first major command because his idiotic, cowardly, self-serving cousin was the Prime Minister. Yet he kicks a truly monumental amount of villainous backside while
being a [[YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters rabble-rousing populist]], General Nortier good, honorable, dedicated, responsible, brave, hardworking, and generally brilliant officer who believes in aristocratic ''responsibility'' as much as he does aristocratic ''privilege'' and has no patience for his incompetent relatives.
*** Hamish Alexander is a completely straight example: Earl
of ''Literature/TheCountOfMonteCristo'' provides a good example White Haven, brilliant tactician, fleet commander, etc.
** The Havenite side has its share:
*** Javier Giscard, Admiral and [[spoiler:romantic partner
of a future President Eloise Pritchart]].
*** Warner Caslet, who sadly [[spoiler:defects to the Manties after his sojourn with Honor on Hades]].
*** Thomas Theisman, the man who [[spoiler:shot Oscar Saint-Just]] and arguably the most gentlemanly
gentleman soldier behaving honorably to those in the whole Republic, with a depth of patriotism and loyalty that is quite simply staggering.
** Grayson Officer Commissions specifically say that the bearer is an OfficerAndAGentleman. This causes a minor plot point in one short story when someone points out that they never actually changed the wording when they first recruited female officers so technically speaking the female officers are also considered gentlemen rather than ladies (the semi-feudal nature of Grayson law means that the term Gentleman does have some limited legal standing).
* Frequent theme
of the same class, even if on opposing sides. works of German author/philosopher Ernst Jünger. In the backstory which led to Dantes' imprisonment, Franz d'Epinay's father, a Royalist, was caught [[DressingAsTheEnemy infiltrating]] the group of pro-Napoleon soldiers Nortier belonged to and seeing that d'Epinay was a fellow gentleman, Nortier allowed him to duel to the death instead of simply killing him outright.
* Several examples in ''Literature/WarAndPeace''. Two prominent ones are the French captain [[PunchClockVillain Ramballe]] and Field Marshal Kutuzov. War isn't very personal; most prisoners throughout the book are treated relatively well, even equally.
* Capt. Laurence, of ''Literature/{{Temeraire}}''. He was originally a British Navy captain--where such is apparently expected--before harnessing Temeraire and is still more polished and formal than
most of his crew and fellow officers, works of fiction, the Aerial Corps almost necessarily being much less formal. His own crew, out of admiration for him, started taking after his example. He, in turn, began to shed the stiffness in his manners as he embraced his new life.
* Peter D'Alembord from ''Literature/{{Sharpe}}'', a charming, elegant, and well-educated gentleman (who only joined the army because he killed a man in a duel). The
title character is often pointed an officer and gentleman from a royal background. (Especially Heliopolis and the marble cliffs.) The villains of his works are frequently villainous because they violate the nobleman's obligue.
** Jünger frequently criticized that this attitude dies
out because of modernism and the enlightenment, paving ways for war crimes and genocides.
* ''Literature/{{Kydd}}'': [[Main/SubvertedTrope Subverted]] with Kydd during ''Quarterdeck'' and ''Tenacious'', as well as other "tarpaulin" officers who "came up aft through the hawsehole". While certainly very good at their jobs through experience, they're considered crude by the standards of those who play this trope straight, which is why Kydd begins
to not resent his fellow officers in ''Quarterdeck''.
-->'''Kydd:''' [[Main/TearJerker I'd rather
be cream o' the shit than shit o' the cream, dammit.]]
** Played straight with Renzi during those two books, highlighting his status as
a {{Main/Foil}} to Kydd.
* Faramir from ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' fits this trope perfectly. An officer and
gentleman, though he is extremely honorable (to the point he wouldn't lie even to an officer, although orc) and impeccably courteous (even toward his conduct towards women is usually better than most of his well-born peers.
**
war prisoners).
*
Captain Fredrickson (later Admiral) John Geary, protagonist of ''Literature/TheLostFleet'' is a bit rougher around lone positive example amid a veritable sea of negative ones.
* The ''Literature/McAuslan'' series depicts Lieutenant Dand [=McNeill=] as a typical young gentleman Scottish officer: walking
the edges than D'Alembord, but is thin line between managing a highly capable leader platoon of skirmishers who also speaks fluent Spanish, French largely Glaswegian soldiers effectively, and German, and spends his free time admiring church architecture, sketching landscapes in pencil, and discussing doing so to the merits and flaws of republican governments with American expatriates and French prisoners of war.
* Commander Mitth'raw'nuruodo,
satisfaction of the Franchise/StarWarsExpandedUniverse novel ''Literature/OutboundFlight'', qualifies as one, if Colonel, a much older gentleman officer one given to somewhat underhanded tactics step away from retirement. McNeill is hailed by his men as a "fly man" - a cunning bastard who leads with style and his own set of morals. However, [[Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy later-set books]] have him as an [[AffablyEvil Affably Imperial]] CulturedWarrior.
essential decency.
* The hares of In Creator/GeneStrattonPorter's ''Literature/MichaelOHalloran'' (published 1915), cited to counter the Long Patrol army in argument of a RoyalBrat that gentlemen don't work.
-->''If
the ''Literature/{{Redwall}}'' series behave like this (even some world has any gentlemen it surely should be those born for generations of royal and titled blood and reared from their cradles in every tradition of their rank. Europe is full of them, and many are superb men. I know a few. Now, will you tell me where they are to-day? They are down in trenches six feet under ground, shivering in mud and water, half dead for sleep, food, and rest, trying to save the ones land of their birth, the homes they own, to protect the women and children they love. They are marching miles, being shot down in cavalry rushes, and blown up in boats they are manning, in their fight to save their countries.''
* Ista from Bujold's ''Literature/PaladinOfSouls'' is attracted to a man
who aren't actually in fits the Long Patrol). The Long Patrol itself didn't appear by name in trope before ending up with that guy's younger brother who behaves much more casual and considers himself [[TheMinnesotaFats second best at everything]]. Of course, the first few books, but grew in importance eventually taking centre stage in (naturally) ''The Long Patrol''.older one was taken [[spoiler:and undead]].



** More famously subverted by Wickham in ''Literature/PrideAndPrejudice''.
*** Played dead straight with Colonel Fitzwilliam and Colonel Forster.
** Also played straight with Colonel Brandon from ''Literature/SenseAndSensibility''.
* Literature/{{Sten}} mocks this trope with the [[GeneralFailure incompetent Admiral van Doorman]], who prides himself on spit-and-polish while sneering at Army-trained Sten. Yet Sten himself embodies this trope to a certain degree. His [[CombatPragmatist Combat Pragmatism]] is never really seen with regard to women, to the point that it's an InformedAttribute. Doubtless it's to preserve the sympathy of readers who have yet to reach the egalitarian attitudes of the future.
* The armies of Victorian Europe in the {{Literature/Flashman}} novels are full of officers who are jovial, charming, considerate of their men, and thoroughly chivalrous. Naturally, our FakeUltimateHero protagonist despises every last one of them.
* The same author wrote semi-autobiographical short stories about his time as a subaltern in the Gordon highlanders, shortly after [=WW2=]. The ''Literature/McAuslan'' series depicts Lieutenant Dand McNeill as a typical young gentleman Scottish officer: walking the thin line between managing a platoon of largely Glaswegian soldiers effectively, and doing so to the satisfaction of the Colonel, a much older gentleman officer one step away from retirement. McNeill is hailed by his men as a "fly man" - a cunning bastard who leads with style and essential decency.
* Commissar Literature/CiaphasCain ([[FakeUltimateHero HERO OF THE IMPERIUM!]]) does his best to be seen as one.
* In Creator/GeneStrattonPorter's ''Literature/MichaelOHalloran'' (published 1915), cited to counter the argument of a RoyalBrat that gentlemen don't work.
-->''If the world has any gentlemen it surely should be those born for generations of royal and titled blood and reared from their cradles in every tradition of their rank. Europe is full of them, and many are superb men. I know a few. Now, will you tell me where they are to-day? They are down in trenches six feet under ground, shivering in mud and water, half dead for sleep, food, and rest, trying to save the land of their birth, the homes they own, to protect the women and children they love. They are marching miles, being shot down in cavalry rushes, and blown up in boats they are manning, in their fight to save their countries.''
* Creator/RudyardKipling's Gentlemen Rankers describes those who failed to be this trope.
** Kipling also poked fun at this trope, noting how ''useless'' most of that book-learnin', college degrees, and gentlemanly chivalry actually are on the battlefield.
-->''A scrimmage in a Border Station-''
-->''A canter down some dark defile''
-->''Two thousand pounds of education''
-->''Drops to a ten-rupee'' jezail[[note]]a home-made (and very accurate) Afghan rifle[[/note]].
-->''The Crammer's boast, the Squadron's pride,''
-->''Shot like a rabbit in a ride!''
-->''No proposition Euclid wrote''
-->''No formulae the text-books know,''
-->''Will turn the bullet from your coat,''
-->''Or ward the tulwar's downward blow.''
-->''Strike hard who cares - shoot straight who can''
-->''The odds are on the cheaper man.''
--->--"Arithmetic on the Frontier" (1886)
* ''Literature/HonorHarrington'' has its fair share.
** On the Manticoran side, the most prominent are probably Hamish Alexander and Michael Oversteegen.
*** Oversteegen is particularly notable in that he has every known trait of a Manticoran UpperClassTwit, belongs to the previously self-serving Conservative party, and seemingly got his first major command because his idiotic, cowardly, self-serving cousin was the Prime Minister. Yet he kicks a truly monumental amount of villainous backside while being a good, honorable, dedicated, responsible, brave, hardworking, and generally brilliant officer who believes in aristocratic ''responsibility'' as much as he does aristocratic ''privilege'' and has no patience for his incompetent relatives.
*** Hamish Alexander is a completely straight example: Earl of White Haven, brilliant tactician, fleet commander, etc.
** The Havenite side has its share:
*** Javier Giscard, Admiral and [[spoiler:romantic partner of future President Eloise Pritchart]].
*** Warner Caslet, who sadly [[spoiler:defects to the Manties after his sojourn with Honor on Hades]].
*** Thomas Theisman, the man who [[spoiler:shot Oscar Saint-Just]] and arguably the most gentlemanly gentleman in the whole Republic, with a depth of patriotism and loyalty that is quite simply staggering.
** Grayson Officer Commissions specifically say that the bearer is an OfficerAndAGentleman. This causes a minor plot point in one short story when someone points out that they never actually changed the wording when they first recruited female officers so technically speaking the female officers are also considered gentlemen rather than ladies (the semi-feudal nature of Grayson law means that the term Gentleman does have some limited legal standing).
* Captain (later Admiral) John Geary, protagonist of ''Literature/TheLostFleet'' is a lone positive example amid a veritable sea of negative ones.
* [[Main/SubvertedTrope Subverted]] with Kydd during ''Quarterdeck'' and ''Tenacious'', as well as other "tarpaulin" officers who "came up aft through the hawsehole". While certainly very good at their jobs through experience, they're considered crude by the standards of those who play this trope straight, which is why Kydd begins to resent his fellow officers in ''Quarterdeck''.
-->'''Kydd:''' [[Main/TearJerker I'd rather be cream o' the shit than shit o' the cream, dammit.]]
** Played straight with Renzi during those two books, highlighting his status as a {{Main/Foil}} to Kydd.
* Frequent theme of the works of German author/philosopher Ernst Jünger. In most of his works of fiction, the title character is an officer and gentleman from a royal background. (Especially Heliopolis and the marble cliffs.) The villains of his works are frequently villainous because they violate the nobleman's obligue.
** Jünger frequently criticized that this attitude dies out because of modernism and the enlightenment, paving ways for war crimes and genocides.

to:

** More famously * Famously subverted by Wickham in ''Literature/PrideAndPrejudice''.
*** ** Played dead straight with Colonel Fitzwilliam and Colonel Forster.
** Also played * The ChasteHero Captain Avery in the book ''Literature/ThePyrates'' which is a DeconstructorFleet of pirate movie cliches fits this description perfectly.
* The hares of the Long Patrol army in the ''Literature/{{Redwall}}'' series behave like this (even some of the ones who aren't actually in the Long Patrol). The Long Patrol itself didn't appear by name in the first few books, but grew in importance eventually taking centre stage in (naturally) ''The Long Patrol''.
* Played
straight with Colonel Brandon from ''Literature/SenseAndSensibility''.
* Literature/{{Sten}} Peter D'Alembord from ''Literature/{{Sharpe}}'', a charming, elegant, and well-educated gentleman (who only joined the army because he killed a man in a duel). The title character is often pointed out to not be a gentleman, though an officer, although his conduct towards women is usually better than most of his well-born peers.
** Captain Fredrickson is a bit rougher around the edges than D'Alembord, but is a highly capable leader of skirmishers who also speaks fluent Spanish, French and German, and spends his free time admiring church architecture, sketching landscapes in pencil, and discussing the merits and flaws of republican governments with American expatriates and French prisoners of war.
* One of the primary themes of ''Literature/StarshipTroopers''.
* Commander Mitth'raw'nuruodo, of the Franchise/StarWarsExpandedUniverse novel ''Literature/OutboundFlight'', qualifies as one, if one given to somewhat underhanded tactics and his own set of morals. However, [[Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy later-set books]] have him as an [[AffablyEvil Affably Imperial]] CulturedWarrior.
* ''Literature/{{Sten}}''
mocks this trope with the [[GeneralFailure incompetent Admiral van Doorman]], who prides himself on spit-and-polish while sneering at Army-trained Sten. Yet Sten himself embodies this trope to a certain degree. His [[CombatPragmatist Combat Pragmatism]] is never really seen with regard to women, to the point that it's an InformedAttribute. Doubtless it's to preserve the sympathy of readers who have yet to reach the egalitarian attitudes of the future.
* The armies Capt. Laurence, of Victorian Europe in the {{Literature/Flashman}} novels are full of officers who are jovial, charming, considerate of their men, ''Literature/{{Temeraire}}''. He was originally a British Navy captain--where such is apparently expected--before harnessing Temeraire and thoroughly chivalrous. Naturally, our FakeUltimateHero protagonist despises every last one of them.
* The same author wrote semi-autobiographical short stories about his time as a subaltern in the Gordon highlanders, shortly after [=WW2=]. The ''Literature/McAuslan'' series depicts Lieutenant Dand McNeill as a typical young gentleman Scottish officer: walking the thin line between managing a platoon of largely Glaswegian soldiers effectively,
is still more polished and doing so to the satisfaction of the Colonel, a much older gentleman officer one step away from retirement. McNeill is hailed by his men as a "fly man" - a cunning bastard who leads with style and essential decency.
* Commissar Literature/CiaphasCain ([[FakeUltimateHero HERO OF THE IMPERIUM!]]) does his best to be seen as one.
* In Creator/GeneStrattonPorter's ''Literature/MichaelOHalloran'' (published 1915), cited to counter the argument of a RoyalBrat that gentlemen don't work.
-->''If the world has any gentlemen it surely should be those born for generations of royal and titled blood and reared from their cradles in every tradition of their rank. Europe is full of them, and many are superb men. I know a few. Now, will you tell me where they are to-day? They are down in trenches six feet under ground, shivering in mud and water, half dead for sleep, food, and rest, trying to save the land of their birth, the homes they own, to protect the women and children they love. They are marching miles, being shot down in cavalry rushes, and blown up in boats they are manning, in their fight to save their countries.''
* Creator/RudyardKipling's Gentlemen Rankers describes those who failed to be this trope.
** Kipling also poked fun at this trope, noting how ''useless'' most of that book-learnin', college degrees, and gentlemanly chivalry actually are on the battlefield.
-->''A scrimmage in a Border Station-''
-->''A canter down some dark defile''
-->''Two thousand pounds of education''
-->''Drops to a ten-rupee'' jezail[[note]]a home-made (and very accurate) Afghan rifle[[/note]].
-->''The Crammer's boast, the Squadron's pride,''
-->''Shot like a rabbit in a ride!''
-->''No proposition Euclid wrote''
-->''No formulae the text-books know,''
-->''Will turn the bullet from your coat,''
-->''Or ward the tulwar's downward blow.''
-->''Strike hard who cares - shoot straight who can''
-->''The odds are on the cheaper man.''
--->--"Arithmetic on the Frontier" (1886)
* ''Literature/HonorHarrington'' has its fair share.
** On the Manticoran side, the most prominent are probably Hamish Alexander and Michael Oversteegen.
*** Oversteegen is particularly notable in that he has every known trait of a Manticoran UpperClassTwit, belongs to the previously self-serving Conservative party, and seemingly got his first major command because his idiotic, cowardly, self-serving cousin was the Prime Minister. Yet he kicks a truly monumental amount of villainous backside while being a good, honorable, dedicated, responsible, brave, hardworking, and generally brilliant officer who believes in aristocratic ''responsibility'' as much as he does aristocratic ''privilege'' and has no patience for his incompetent relatives.
*** Hamish Alexander is a completely straight example: Earl of White Haven, brilliant tactician, fleet commander, etc.
** The Havenite side has its share:
*** Javier Giscard, Admiral and [[spoiler:romantic partner of future President Eloise Pritchart]].
*** Warner Caslet, who sadly [[spoiler:defects to the Manties after his sojourn with Honor on Hades]].
*** Thomas Theisman, the man who [[spoiler:shot Oscar Saint-Just]] and arguably the most gentlemanly gentleman in the whole Republic, with a depth of patriotism and loyalty that is quite simply staggering.
** Grayson Officer Commissions specifically say that the bearer is an OfficerAndAGentleman. This causes a minor plot point in one short story when someone points out that they never actually changed the wording when they first recruited female officers so technically speaking the female officers are also considered gentlemen rather
formal than ladies (the semi-feudal nature of Grayson law means that the term Gentleman does have some limited legal standing).
* Captain (later Admiral) John Geary, protagonist of ''Literature/TheLostFleet'' is a lone positive example amid a veritable sea of negative ones.
* [[Main/SubvertedTrope Subverted]] with Kydd during ''Quarterdeck'' and ''Tenacious'', as well as other "tarpaulin" officers who "came up aft through the hawsehole". While certainly very good at their jobs through experience, they're considered crude by the standards of those who play this trope straight, which is why Kydd begins to resent his fellow officers in ''Quarterdeck''.
-->'''Kydd:''' [[Main/TearJerker I'd rather be cream o' the shit than shit o' the cream, dammit.]]
** Played straight with Renzi during those two books, highlighting his status as a {{Main/Foil}} to Kydd.
* Frequent theme of the works of German author/philosopher Ernst Jünger. In
most of his works of fiction, crew and fellow officers, the title character is an officer and gentleman from a royal background. (Especially Heliopolis and Aerial Corps almost necessarily being much less formal. His own crew, out of admiration for him, started taking after his example. He, in turn, began to shed the marble cliffs.) The villains of stiffness in his works are frequently villainous because they violate the nobleman's obligue.
** Jünger frequently criticized that this attitude dies out because of modernism and the enlightenment, paving ways for war crimes and genocides.
manners as he embraced his new life.



* Richard Hannay, the hero of John Buchan's thriller novels, joins the army and serves as an officer in ''Literature/{{Greenmantle}}'' and ''Literature/MrStandfast'', retiring with distinction at war's end.

to:

* Richard Hannay, In Creator/LoisMcMasterBujold's ''Literature/VorkosiganSaga'', all Barrayaran officers are expected to be, and sometimes they even are:
** Aral and Miles play this trope to a tee. However, Aral's reputation as [[RedBaron "The Butcher of Komarr"]] does not.
** Cordelia--as a captain in
the hero of John Buchan's thriller novels, joins Betan Expeditionary Force -- is the army and serves female equivalent… as an contrasted with Cordelia's prior tour in the Betan Astronomical Survey, where being captain was more like being TeamMom.
** A young example (and lampshade) is Lieutenant Miles Vorkosigan in ''Cetaganda'' who early in the book reminds himself that he is "an
officer in ''Literature/{{Greenmantle}}'' and ''Literature/MrStandfast'', retiring with distinction at war's end.a nobleman."
** Miles' relative Ivan also shows quite a few traits of this. Ivan--a soldier in the Barrayaran Imperial Service--employs some irony when asked, "Are you a hired killer?" He replies, "Well, [[LiteralMinded in a ''sense'']]." Further, although he has the manners and breeding for this trope, he ends up being the beleaguered enlisted man to Miles most of the time.
** Being a blend of Samurai and Prussian Junkers, the Vor of Barrayar are expected to act this way whether or not they are technically officers, being a class (excuse me, [[InsistentTerminology 'warrior caste']]) of Officers and Gentlemen.
* Several examples in ''Literature/WarAndPeace''. Two prominent ones are the French captain [[PunchClockVillain Ramballe]] and Field Marshal Kutuzov. War isn't very personal; most prisoners throughout the book are treated relatively well, even equally.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheAliceNetwork'': Captain Cameron is an honorable, kind soldier who would never leave a lady in distress. His gentlemanly qualities only make him more attractive to Eve, who rarely encounters kindness in the course of her life and her short-lived spying career.
* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'':
** Subverted in ''Literature/{{Jingo}}'' in the form of Willikins, Vimes' [[BattleButler butler-turned-sergeant]]. When addressing Vimes, Willikins is the picture of politeness - so far so good - but when talking to the men under his charge he turns into a [[DrillSergeantNasty bellowing, foul-mouthed authoritarian.]] Also played straight with Lord Rust, who is the negative, incompetent, "BlueBlood who is polite to equals and superiors only" variety, with [[HonorBeforeReason lots of "honor" and not a lot of reason]], utterly convinced that their enemy (who has spent the last several decades fighting a variety of enemies and getting ''really good at it'') will "turn and flee the minute they taste cold steel"; he is described in ''Literature/{{Night Watch|Discworld}}'' as following the "subtract the enemy's casualties from thine own, and if the number is positive, then it was a Glorious Victory" school of strategy.
** Sergeant Jackrum of ''Literature/MonstrousRegiment'' fame would tell you that, as a sergeant, Wilikins is neither an officer or a gentleman. Sergeants are crafty bastards, and he would know. Lieutenant Blouse from the same book ''would'' fit this trope if it were any other kind of story--he's an officer, a gentleman, and honorable to a fault -- but war is a very ugly thing that has no time for honor and chivalry.
* Faramir from ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings'' fits this trope perfectly. An officer and gentleman, he is extremely honorable (to the point he wouldn't lie even to an orc) and impeccably courteous (even toward his war prisoners).
* One of the primary themes of ''Literature/StarshipTroopers''.
* In Creator/LoisMcMasterBujold's Literature/VorkosiganSaga, all Barrayaran officers are expected to be, and sometimes they even are:
** Aral and Miles play this trope to a tee. However, Aral's reputation as [[RedBaron "The Butcher of Komarr"]] does not.
** Cordelia--as a captain in the Betan Expeditionary Force -- is the female equivalent… as contrasted with Cordelia's prior tour in the Betan Astronomical Survey, where being captain was more like being TeamMom.
** A young example (and lampshade) is Lieutenant Miles Vorkosigan in ''Cetaganda'' who early in the book reminds himself that he is "an officer and a nobleman."
** Miles' relative Ivan also shows quite a few traits of this. Ivan--a soldier in the Barrayaran Imperial Service--employs some irony when asked, "Are you a hired killer?" He replies, "Well, [[LiteralMinded in a ''sense'']]." Further, although he has the manners and breeding for this trope, he ends up being the beleaguered enlisted man to Miles most of the time.
** Being a blend of Samurai and Prussian Junkers, the Vor of Barrayar are expected to act this way whether or not they are technically officers, being a class (excuse me, [[InsistentTerminology 'warrior caste']]) of Officers and Gentlemen.
* Ista from Bujold's ''Literature/PaladinOfSouls'' is attracted to a man who fits the trope before ending up with that guy's younger brother who behaves much more casual and considers himself [[TheMinnesotaFats second best at everything]]. Of course, the older one was taken [[spoiler:and undead]].
* The ChasteHero Captain Avery in the book ''Literature/ThePyrates'' which is a DeconstructorFleet of pirate movie cliches fits this description perfectly.
* Very prevalent on both the American and Japanese sides in ''Literature/TheGreatPacificWar''. Prisoners are treated fairly, ships go out of their way to rescue enemy survivors, etc. Especially notable for the Japanese as it was uncommon to portray them as noble warriors rather than brutish savages.
* Despite being a [[YourTerroristsAreOurFreedomFighters rabble-rousing populist]], General Nortier of ''Literature/TheCountOfMonteCristo'' provides a good example of a gentleman soldier behaving honorably to those of the same class, even if on opposing sides. In the backstory which led to Dantes' imprisonment, Franz d'Epinay's father, a Royalist, was caught [[DressingAsTheEnemy infiltrating]] the group of pro-Napoleon soldiers Nortier belonged to and seeing that d'Epinay was a fellow gentleman, Nortier allowed him to duel to the death instead of simply killing him outright.
* Several examples in ''Literature/WarAndPeace''. Two prominent ones are the French captain [[PunchClockVillain Ramballe]] and Field Marshal Kutuzov. War isn't very personal; most prisoners throughout the book are treated relatively well, even equally.
* Capt. Laurence, of ''Literature/{{Temeraire}}''. He was originally a British Navy captain--where such is apparently expected--before harnessing Temeraire and is still more polished and formal than most of his crew and fellow officers, the Aerial Corps almost necessarily being much less formal. His own crew, out of admiration for him, started taking after his example. He, in turn, began to shed the stiffness in his manners as he embraced his new life.
* Peter D'Alembord from ''Literature/{{Sharpe}}'', a charming, elegant, and well-educated gentleman (who only joined the army because he killed a man in a duel). The title character is often pointed out to not be a gentleman, though an officer, although his conduct towards women is usually better than most of his well-born peers.
** Captain Fredrickson is a bit rougher around the edges than D'Alembord, but is a highly capable leader of skirmishers who also speaks fluent Spanish, French and German, and spends his free time admiring church architecture, sketching landscapes in pencil, and discussing the merits and flaws of republican governments with American expatriates and French prisoners of war.
* Commander Mitth'raw'nuruodo, of the Franchise/StarWarsExpandedUniverse novel ''Literature/OutboundFlight'', qualifies as one, if one given to somewhat underhanded tactics and his own set of morals. However, [[Literature/TheThrawnTrilogy later-set books]] have him as an [[AffablyEvil Affably Imperial]] CulturedWarrior.
* The hares of the Long Patrol army in the ''Literature/{{Redwall}}'' series behave like this (even some of the ones who aren't actually in the Long Patrol). The Long Patrol itself didn't appear by name in the first few books, but grew in importance eventually taking centre stage in (naturally) ''The Long Patrol''.
* Creator/JaneAusten's ''Literature/{{Persuasion}}'' plays this straight with Captain Wentworth.
** More famously subverted by Wickham in ''Literature/PrideAndPrejudice''.
*** Played dead straight with Colonel Fitzwilliam and Colonel Forster.
** Also played straight with Colonel Brandon from ''Literature/SenseAndSensibility''.
* Literature/{{Sten}} mocks this trope with the [[GeneralFailure incompetent Admiral van Doorman]], who prides himself on spit-and-polish while sneering at Army-trained Sten. Yet Sten himself embodies this trope to a certain degree. His [[CombatPragmatist Combat Pragmatism]] is never really seen with regard to women, to the point that it's an InformedAttribute. Doubtless it's to preserve the sympathy of readers who have yet to reach the egalitarian attitudes of the future.
* The armies of Victorian Europe in the {{Literature/Flashman}} novels are full of officers who are jovial, charming, considerate of their men, and thoroughly chivalrous. Naturally, our FakeUltimateHero protagonist despises every last one of them.
* The same author wrote semi-autobiographical short stories about his time as a subaltern in the Gordon highlanders, shortly after [=WW2=]. The ''Literature/McAuslan'' series depicts Lieutenant Dand McNeill as a typical young gentleman Scottish officer: walking the thin line between managing a platoon of largely Glaswegian soldiers effectively, and doing so to the satisfaction of the Colonel, a much older gentleman officer one step away from retirement. McNeill is hailed by his men as a "fly man" - a cunning bastard who leads with style and essential decency.
* Commissar Literature/CiaphasCain ([[FakeUltimateHero HERO OF THE IMPERIUM!]]) does his best to be seen as one.
* In Creator/GeneStrattonPorter's ''Literature/MichaelOHalloran'' (published 1915), cited to counter the argument of a RoyalBrat that gentlemen don't work.
-->''If the world has any gentlemen it surely should be those born for generations of royal and titled blood and reared from their cradles in every tradition of their rank. Europe is full of them, and many are superb men. I know a few. Now, will you tell me where they are to-day? They are down in trenches six feet under ground, shivering in mud and water, half dead for sleep, food, and rest, trying to save the land of their birth, the homes they own, to protect the women and children they love. They are marching miles, being shot down in cavalry rushes, and blown up in boats they are manning, in their fight to save their countries.''
* Creator/RudyardKipling's Gentlemen Rankers describes those who failed to be this trope.
** Kipling also poked fun at this trope, noting how ''useless'' most of that book-learnin', college degrees, and gentlemanly chivalry actually are on the battlefield.
-->''A scrimmage in a Border Station-''
-->''A canter down some dark defile''
-->''Two thousand pounds of education''
-->''Drops to a ten-rupee'' jezail[[note]]a home-made (and very accurate) Afghan rifle[[/note]].
-->''The Crammer's boast, the Squadron's pride,''
-->''Shot like a rabbit in a ride!''
-->''No proposition Euclid wrote''
-->''No formulae the text-books know,''
-->''Will turn the bullet from your coat,''
-->''Or ward the tulwar's downward blow.''
-->''Strike hard who cares - shoot straight who can''
-->''The odds are on the cheaper man.''
--->--"Arithmetic on the Frontier" (1886)
* ''Literature/HonorHarrington'' has its fair share.
** On the Manticoran side, the most prominent are probably Hamish Alexander and Michael Oversteegen.
*** Oversteegen is particularly notable in that he has every known trait of a Manticoran UpperClassTwit, belongs to the previously self-serving Conservative party, and seemingly got his first major command because his idiotic, cowardly, self-serving cousin was the Prime Minister. Yet he kicks a truly monumental amount of villainous backside while being a good, honorable, dedicated, responsible, brave, hardworking, and generally brilliant officer who believes in aristocratic ''responsibility'' as much as he does aristocratic ''privilege'' and has no patience for his incompetent relatives.
*** Hamish Alexander is a completely straight example: Earl of White Haven, brilliant tactician, fleet commander, etc.
** The Havenite side has its share:
*** Javier Giscard, Admiral and [[spoiler:romantic partner of future President Eloise Pritchart]].
*** Warner Caslet, who sadly [[spoiler:defects to the Manties after his sojourn with Honor on Hades]].
*** Thomas Theisman, the man who [[spoiler:shot Oscar Saint-Just]] and arguably the most gentlemanly gentleman in the whole Republic, with a depth of patriotism and loyalty that is quite simply staggering.
** Grayson Officer Commissions specifically say that the bearer is an OfficerAndAGentleman. This causes a minor plot point in one short story when someone points out that they never actually changed the wording when they first recruited female officers so technically speaking the female officers are also considered gentlemen rather than ladies (the semi-feudal nature of Grayson law means that the term Gentleman does have some limited legal standing).
* Captain (later Admiral) John Geary, protagonist of ''Literature/TheLostFleet'' is a lone positive example amid a veritable sea of negative ones.
* [[Main/SubvertedTrope Subverted]] with Kydd during ''Quarterdeck'' and ''Tenacious'', as well as other "tarpaulin" officers who "came up aft through the hawsehole". While certainly very good at their jobs through experience, they're considered crude by the standards of those who play this trope straight, which is why Kydd begins to resent his fellow officers in ''Quarterdeck''.
-->'''Kydd:''' [[Main/TearJerker I'd rather be cream o' the shit than shit o' the cream, dammit.]]
** Played straight with Renzi during those two books, highlighting his status as a {{Main/Foil}} to Kydd.
* Frequent theme of the works of German author/philosopher Ernst Jünger. In most of his works of fiction, the title character is an officer and gentleman from a royal background. (Especially Heliopolis and the marble cliffs.) The villains of his works are frequently villainous because they violate the nobleman's obligue.
** Jünger frequently criticized that this attitude dies out because of modernism and the enlightenment, paving ways for war crimes and genocides.
* ''Literature/TheUnknownSoldier'' has the archetypal Captain Kariluoto, who starts as a WhitePrince EnsignNewbie, and Lieutenant Koskela, who started as WorkingClassHero and owes his gentlemanly nature not to BlueBlood, but to being a FarmBoy.
* Richard Hannay, the hero of John Buchan's thriller novels, joins the army and serves as an officer in ''Literature/{{Greenmantle}}'' and ''Literature/MrStandfast'', retiring with distinction at war's end.

Top