Follow TV Tropes

Following

History NightmareFuel / PokemonDetectivePikachu

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The scene where Lucy is [[spoiler: taking photographic evidence of illegal experimenting with Pokemon on her cellphone]] in a darkened laboratory hallway with several closed hatches reminiscent of cryogenic chambers. Then they open, as a Greninja's webbed hand emerges out of one of them.

to:

* The scene where Lucy is [[spoiler: taking photographic evidence of illegal experimenting with Pokemon on her cellphone]] cellphone in a darkened laboratory hallway with several closed hatches reminiscent of cryogenic chambers. Then they open, as a Greninja's webbed hand emerges out of one of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And finally, [[UncertainDoom she's never seen again]] after her ShapeshifterSwanSong.

to:

** And finally, [[UncertainDoom she's never seen again]] after her ShapeshifterSwanSong.ShapeshifterSwanSong (though likely only because it fainted).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's also the matter of what happens to the Pokemon in this scenario. Pokemon are much closer to human intelligence than a real life animal when they aren't explicitly of human intelligence in the case of Psychic types like Mewtwo. They're so intelligent that Howard mentions the R gas is necessary because it shuts off the Pokemon's higher thought processes to make room for a human mind. Howard's plan might be be scary for humans but it's utterly nightmarish for Pokemon, who are living through an animal version of Film/GetOut
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And finally, [[NothingIsScarier she's never seen again]] after her ShapeshifterSwanSong.

to:

** And finally, [[NothingIsScarier [[UncertainDoom she's never seen again]] after her ShapeshifterSwanSong.

Changed: -5

Removed: 317

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per Characterization Tags, no characterization tags are allowed on the wiki. Also deleting an entry that seems more Fridge Horror than Nightmare Fuel.


* The scene in the climax, where Howard!Mewtwo is merging humans with random Pokémon. While this might not seem that scary, considering how awesome Pokémon can be, and [[VillainHasAPoint Howard does have a point]] that Pokémon are superior to humans in certain ways. One has to remember that these people ''were forced into Pokémon bodies against their will''. Not to mention that Pokémon come in all shapes and sizes, imagine how traumatizing it must be to be trapped in a four-legged stance, to be smaller than a human hand, heck, even being enlarged in size can be percieved as BalefulPolymorph.
** And some of the Pokemon weren't owned or merged with humans as shown with the Pidgeot who got R'ed but not merged when Pikachu was riding on it. Imagine a Pidgeot, who is wild, seeing a Caterpie and wanting to gobble it up for a snack. Imagine that it's not just a Caterpie, but a Caterpie merged with a ''human.''

to:

* The scene in the climax, where Howard!Mewtwo Howard-as-Mewtwo is merging humans with random Pokémon. While this might not seem that scary, considering how awesome Pokémon can be, and [[VillainHasAPoint Howard does have a point]] that Pokémon are superior to humans in certain ways. One has to remember that these people ''were forced into Pokémon bodies against their will''. Not to mention that Pokémon come in all shapes and sizes, imagine how traumatizing it must be to be trapped in a four-legged stance, to be smaller than a human hand, heck, even being enlarged in size can be percieved as BalefulPolymorph.
** And some of the Pokemon weren't owned or merged with humans as shown with the Pidgeot who got R'ed but not merged when Pikachu was riding on it. Imagine a Pidgeot, who is wild, seeing a Caterpie and wanting to gobble it up for a snack. Imagine that it's not just a Caterpie, but a Caterpie merged with a ''human.''
BalefulPolymorph.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Greninja prop suffers similarly from being too realistic; a close up on its head reveals the texture of its tongue scarf in horrifying detail, complete with tastebuds that look quite a bit too human for comfort...

to:

** The Greninja prop suffers similarly from being too realistic; a close up on its head reveals the having an odd texture of choice; its tongue scarf in horrifying detail, complete with has tastebuds that make it look quite a bit too human for comfort...human, unlike a smooth frog tongue...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And some of the Pokemon weren't owned or merged with humans as shown with the Pidgeot who got R'ed but not merged when Pikachu was riding on it. Imagine a Pidgeot, who is wild, seeing a Caterpie and wanting to gobble it up for a snack. Imagine that it's not just a Caterpie, but a Caterpie merged with a ''human.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And then ''Mewtwo'', of all Pokémon, makes an appearance. And it makes its appearance by bursting out of a Pikachu parade float that it apparently lit on fire with its mind.

to:

** And then ''Mewtwo'', of all Pokémon, makes an appearance. And it makes its appearance by bursting out of a Pikachu parade float that it apparently lit on fire with its mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mewtwo takes the cake just on how unnervingly, unnaturally ''smooth'' it looks. It's not the hairless wrinkled skin or sparsely-furred velvety texture many fan interpretations have thought for a realistic Mewtwo: it's got a shiny, plastic-ish look of polished rubber.

to:

** Mewtwo takes the cake just on how unnervingly, unnaturally ''smooth'' it looks. It's not the hairless wrinkled skin or sparsely-furred velvety texture many fan interpretations have thought for a realistic Mewtwo: it's got a shiny, plastic-ish plastic-like look of polished rubber.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The scene in the climax, where Howard!Mewtwo is merging humans with random Pokémon. While this might not seem that scary, considering how awesome Pokémon can be, and [[VillainHasAPoint Howard does have a point]] that Pokémon are superior to humans in certain ways. One has to remember that these people ''were forced into Pokémon bodies against their will''. Not to mention that Pokémon come in all shapes and sizes, imagine how traumatizing it must be to be trapped in a four-legged stance, to be smaller than a human hand, heck, even being enlarged in size can be percieved as BalefulPolymorph.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Charizard has nothing on freaking ''[[https://nintendosoup.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/pokemon-detective-pikachu-gyarados-mar252019.jpg Gyarados]]'', every bit the terrifying sea monster spoken of in the Dex entries. And even ''Charizard'' ends up [[OhCrap cowering]] before Gyarados's Surf attack.[[note]]And it has every right to be cowering, considering the type disadvantage.[[/note]]

to:

** The Charizard has nothing on freaking ''[[https://nintendosoup.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/pokemon-detective-pikachu-gyarados-mar252019.jpg Gyarados]]'', every bit the terrifying sea monster spoken of in the Dex entries. And even Even ''Charizard'' ends up [[OhCrap cowering]] before Gyarados's Surf attack.[[note]]And it has every right to be cowering, considering the type disadvantage.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Charizard has nothing on freaking ''[[https://nintendosoup.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/pokemon-detective-pikachu-gyarados-mar252019.jpg Gyarados]]'', every bit the terrifying sea monster spoken of in the Dex entries.

to:

** The Charizard has nothing on freaking ''[[https://nintendosoup.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/pokemon-detective-pikachu-gyarados-mar252019.jpg Gyarados]]'', every bit the terrifying sea monster spoken of in the Dex entries. And even ''Charizard'' ends up [[OhCrap cowering]] before Gyarados's Surf attack.[[note]]And it has every right to be cowering, considering the type disadvantage.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The scene where Lucy is frantically doing something on her phone in a darkened laboratory hallway with several closed hatches reminiscent of cryogenic chambers. Then they open, as a Greninja's webbed hand emerges out of one of them.

to:

* The scene where Lucy is frantically doing something [[spoiler: taking photographic evidence of illegal experimenting with Pokemon on her phone cellphone]] in a darkened laboratory hallway with several closed hatches reminiscent of cryogenic chambers. Then they open, as a Greninja's webbed hand emerges out of one of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And in a little FridgeHorror, note how the Torterra basically just rise up for a few moments before laying down again. They can ''barely move'' due to how unnaturally big they are, and the scientists have pretty much condemned them to be pinned in place for the rest of their lives.

to:

** And in a little FridgeHorror, note how the Torterra basically just rise up for a few moments before laying down again. They can ''barely move'' due to how unnaturally big they are, and the scientists have pretty much condemned them to be pinned in place for the rest of their lives.lives (unless Roger is able to find a way to return them to normal size).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It gets worse, Ditto is shown to be ''extremely'' intelligent (thanks in part to how extensively she's been altered genetically), moreso than any other Pokémon in the movie except Pikachu and Mewtwo - even capable of communicating via human language (through text), something Pokémon are ''explicitly'' stated to not understand throughout the film, and tries to ''murder'' Tim at the end. Unlike normal Ditto, she's also able to mimic Pokémon and people that ''aren't'' physically present, and her Ms. Norman form isn't seen anywhere else except her, meaning it's entirely possible she's not mimicking anyone and has simply ''made up'' that form (which also raises the question of what other forms could she take if she doesn't ''have'' to mimic).
** And finally, [[NothingIsScarier she's never seen again]] after her ShapeshifterSwanSong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And in a little FridgeHorror, note how the Torterra basically just rise up for a few moments before laying down again. They can ''barely move'' due to how unnaturally big they are, and the scientists have pretty much condemned them to be pinned in place for the rest of their lives.


Added DiffLines:

** And Mewtwo ''walking'', especially since we're just so used to seeing Mewtwo flying and floating with psychic power,
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Pikachu takes advantage of Psyduck's powers by causing him a headache that turns into a HUGE shockwave of psychic powers that wipes out the crazed Greninja following him and his friends. While awesome, it's unsettling to know that a goofy, innocuous-looking creature possesses such a dangerous, barely controlled power. Especially since other scenes show that Psyduck is aware of it and is happy to threaten others to get what it wants. To sum it up, Lucy spends every day with a living bomb and probably also has to cater to its every whim... what would happen if either Psyduck or its trainer (or both) were bad guys?

Added: 433

Changed: 38

Removed: 436

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A preview clip reveals that Charizard's scar was caused by ''Pikachu'' before the film began.

to:

* A preview clip reveals that The scar on Charizard's scar face was caused by ''Pikachu'' before the film began.



* After the heroes narrowly escape from the Greninja, the ground starts to warp around them and begin closing in on them. Eventually, it's revealed what's causing the ground to move: they're on top of a gigantic Torterra and that the "mountains" around the lab are even more of them. It's horrifying to see just how much these experiments have mutated Pokémon.
-->'''Pikachu:''' ''[[OhCrap This]]'' [[OhCrap is the Torterra Garden!]]



* After the heroes narrowly escape from the Greninja, the ground starts to warp around them and begin closing in on them. Eventually, it's revealed what's causing the ground to move: the ground was actually gigantic Torterra the size of ''cities'' as a result of the growth experiments. It's horrifying to see just how much these experiments have mutated Pokémon.
-->'''Pikachu:''' ''[[OhCrap This]]'' [[OhCrap is the Torterra Garden!]]

Added: 992

Changed: 160

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The "Realistic textures" make the Pokémon resemble UglyCute [[AnimatedToys stuffed animals]] at best. At worst, they look like taxidermy.
** Machamp looks almost like SpecialEffectFailure. While Machamp and its family are supposed to have skin, the textures seem to be synthetic, meaning that it looks like one took a model from an [=PS1=]-early [=PS2=]-era Full Motion Video and placed it into the movie willie nilly. It looks ''heavily'' out of place.



*** Compared to the expressive eyes of Pikachu or the other eyes that have detail on them, Pokémon with highly stylized eyes look even ''worse''. Ludicolo's eyes look like googly-eyes. This varies between {{Narm}} and UncannyValley when they suddenly ''move''.

to:

*** Compared to the expressive eyes of Pikachu or the other eyes that have detail on them, Pokémon with highly stylized eyes look even ''worse''. Ludicolo's eyes look like googly-eyes. This varies between {{Narm}} and UncannyValley when they suddenly ''move''. What's more, Ludicolo has a visibly lazy eye. In the common reaction image, it looks like it's begging for death.



*** The textures look absolutely ''nothing'' like a duck. The result is that it looks more like a piñata.
** Emolga's head is ''way'' too big for its body. coupled with its lack of visible joints, it looks almost ''taxidermied''.
** Loudred's mouth is already way too big. But it looks even weird when you consider that, as a Pokémon, it has no internal structure.
** Bulbasaur's head is just ''too big''. Its legs have no visible joints, and it has no fingers. Meaning it looks like it is walking on fleshy digitless stumps for feet.



** The Pokémon look weird in motion, too. When something has realistic texture, it just makes the fact that they walk on digit-less stumps with no joints stick out even ''more''. When they're next to humans walking normally, seeing their giant heads looks... ''WRONG''.
** Even the Pokémon based off of inanimate objects and plants look weird. They look almost ''inflated'' like balloons.

to:

** The Pokémon look weird in motion, too. When something has realistic texture, it just makes the fact that they walk on digit-less stumps with no joints stick out even ''more''. When they're next to humans walking normally, seeing their giant heads looks...and jointless arms look... ''WRONG''.
** Even the Pokémon based off of inanimate objects and plants look weird. They look almost ''inflated'' like balloons. Balloons with a fleshy texture.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Pikachu:''' ''[[OhCrap This]]'' [[OhCrap is the Torterra Garden!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* After the heroes narrowly escape from the Greninja, the ground starts to warp around them and begin closing in on them. Eventually, it's revealed what's causing the ground to move: the ground was actually gigantic Torterra the size of ''cities'' as a result of the growth experiments. It's horrifying to see just how much these experiments have mutated Pokémon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While has several shots of Pokémon getting ready to hunt humans, special mention goes to the Aipom who apparently snuck its way into Tim's office, screams, attacks the camera and looks like it wants to tear Tim's throat out with its teeth. Which are ''all'' incisors.

to:

* While the film has several shots of Pokémon getting ready to hunt humans, special mention goes to the Aipom who apparently snuck its way into Tim's office, screams, attacks the camera and looks like it wants to tear Tim's throat out with its teeth. Which are ''all'' incisors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** His voice also has a VoiceOfTheLegion quality to it, which can have him come off as creepier than in his past speaking incarnations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mewtwo actually talking instead of using its' psychic powers to communicate is an unnerving thing to see. Possibly deliberate to show how unnatural the forced mental takeover is.

to:

* Mewtwo actually talking instead of using its' its psychic powers to communicate is an unnerving thing to see. Possibly deliberate to show how unnatural the forced mental takeover is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Mewtwo actually talking instead of using its' psychic powers to communicate is an unnerving thing to see. Possibly deliberate to show how unnatural the forced mental takeover is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the film itself, Cubone resists the Pokéball to the point it pops out and chases its attempted user, growling and snarling the entire way. Though in the end its played for laughs, Cubone laughing as it leaves since Tim was going to fail from the start by not bonding with it properly.

to:

** In the film itself, Cubone resists the Pokéball to the point it pops out and chases its attempted user, growling and snarling the entire way. Though in the end its played for laughs, Cubone laughing as it leaves since Tim was going to fail from the start by not bonding convincing it properly to stay with it properly.him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the film itself, Cubone resists the Pokéball to the point it pops out and chases its attempted user, growling and snarling the entire way.

to:

** In the film itself, Cubone resists the Pokéball to the point it pops out and chases its attempted user, growling and snarling the entire way. Though in the end its played for laughs, Cubone laughing as it leaves since Tim was going to fail from the start by not bonding with it properly.

Changed: 170

Removed: 202

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** (Pictured) The hyper-realistic Charizard opening its jaws to bite (eat?) Pikachu at the end of the trailer is terrifying.
*** Not only that but the later trailers depict that the realistic scales resemble pieces of EVA Foam than scales. It looks ''very'' weird.

to:

** (Pictured) The hyper-realistic Charizard opening its jaws to bite (eat?) Pikachu at the end of the trailer is terrifying.
*** Not only that but the later trailers depict that the realistic scales resemble pieces of EVA Foam more than scales. It looks ''very'' weird.



** Realistic glistening tongue textures return with the appearance of Lickitung in the second release trailer.

to:

** Realistic glistening tongue textures return with the appearance of Lickitung in the second release trailer.train to Ryme City.



*** [[FromBadToWorse Even worse?]] As shown in a later trailer, it ''is'' normally a RidiculouslyCuteCritter that just happens to make a pretty mean face. ''Something'' must have pissed off that monkey.



* The second trailer briefly shows a scene where Lucy is frantically doing something on her phone in a darkened laboratory hallway with several closed hatches reminiscent of cryogenic chambers. Then they open, as a Greninja's webbed hand emerges out of one of them.

to:

* The second trailer briefly shows a scene where Lucy is frantically doing something on her phone in a darkened laboratory hallway with several closed hatches reminiscent of cryogenic chambers. Then they open, as a Greninja's webbed hand emerges out of one of them.



* In the same trailer, we have a shot of a Cubone getting caught. Not scary yet? Well how about the poor thing's expression, it's terrified and is actively trying to run away! It's AllForNothing, because it gets hit in the head hard enough to flinch and get sucked inside the Pokéball. The look on Cubone's face right before capture does NOT help.

to:

* In The scene in the same trailer, we have a shot of a beginning with Cubone getting caught. Not scary yet? Well how about the poor thing's expression, it's terrified and is actively trying to run away! It's AllForNothing, because it gets hit in the head hard enough to flinch and get sucked inside the Pokéball. The look on Cubone's face right before capture does NOT help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Pokémon seen in the first trailer retain their cartoonish proportions while going for a more realistic texture, in order to make them look more like real-life creatures and less like cartoon characters. This strategy achieves...[[UncannyValley mixed results]]; some Pokémon look fine (with many praising how adorable Detective Pikachu's fluffier design is), while others look much less so. Some examples of the latter group:

to:

* The Pokémon seen in the first trailer retain their cartoonish proportions while going for a more realistic texture, in order to make them look more like real-life creatures and less like cartoon characters. This strategy achieves...[[UncannyValley mixed results]]; some Pokémon look fine (with many praising how adorable Detective Pikachu's fluffier design is), while others look much less so. Some examples of the latter group:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Psyduck's vacant, too-far-apart eyes (that are just blank dots) can be pretty unsettling.

to:

** Psyduck's vacant, too-far-apart eyes (that are just (they appear to be blank dots) dots, but closer inspection reveals that it has white irises) can be pretty unsettling.

Top