History NightmareFuel / OneyPlays

* In part 1 of ''VideoGame/MarioArtist: Paint Studio'', after goofing around with Mario Artist by adding horror elements to a drawn Nostalgia Critic, which is already creepy, but also NightmareRetardant since the "creepy" elements are just cliche creepypasta tropes like bleeding eyes, but when Ding Dong starts spamming the blur tool, the Critic gets an increasingly [[NightmareFace creepy face]] that's getting worse with each application of the blur tool (see above).

** Part 17: another Japanese commercial, where a model of Crash has his skin and eyeballs explode off of him.

-->'''Chris:''' ''[[SurpriseCreepy WHY DOES IT]]'' ''[[LampshadeHanging LOOK SO SCARY!?]]''

* [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r3PTdQ8Lzpc The final episode of the]] [[VideoGame/PokemonRed Pok&eacutemon Red]] let's play, where they decide to catch [=MissingNo=]. Things start off pretty standard, with the boys having their usual banter as they play the game. Then comes the second half of the video, which is a nightmarish, glitchy mess with the entire video itself glitching out and distorted, echoed voices in the background instead of any commentary. The whole thing comes off as a video game version of JustForFun/CandleCove.

* In part 1 of ''VideoGame/MarioArtist: Paint Studio'', after goofing around with Mario Artist by adding horror elements to a drawn Nostalgia Critic, which is already creepy, but also NightmareRetardant since the "creepy" elements are just cliche creepypasta tropes like bleeding eyes, but when [=DingDong=] starts spamming the blur tool, the Critic gets an increasingly [[NightmareFace creepy face]] that's getting worse with each application of the blur tool.
--> '''Chris:''' ''[[SurpriseCreepy WHY DOES IT]]'' ''[[LampshadeHanging LOOK SO SCARY!?]]''

* [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r3PTdQ8Lzpc The final episode of the]] [[VideoGame/PokemonRed Pokemon Red]] let's play, where they decide to catch [=MissingNo=]. Things start off pretty standard, with the boys having their usual banter as they play the game. Then comes the second half of the video, which is a nightmarish, glitchy mess with the entire video itself glitching out and distorted, echoed voices in the background instead of any commentary. The whole thing comes off as a video game version of JustForFun/CandleCove.
** Though some NightmareRetardant exists if you listen closely; at one point, among the echoed voices in the background, you can hear [=DingDong=] ask, "What the heck is this?" followed by "[[LampshadeHanging Is this a creepypasta, is that what we're doing?]]" Other users have also pointed out that many of the echoed voices is actually just the infamous Hitler Clone Argument, reversed and garbled.

* A minor example is the artpiece they used for the thumbnails of their VideoGame/KingdomHeartsII playthrough. It has Chris and [=DingDong=] cosplaying Sora and WesternAnimation/DonaldDuck respectively, but Julian as WesternAnimation/{{Goofy}} [[BodyHorror is depicted as Julian's head and a single arm merged with the nose of a deformed version of Goofy who has nipples for eyes]], with [=DingDong=] understandably disturbed at him.
* Another thumbnail related example is the one used for [[VideoGame/MarioArtist Mario Artist: Paint Studios]], which depicts Oney, Julian, and [=DingDong=], [[AndIMustScream all trapped inside of a painting with horrified looks on their faces]] by a ''really'' weird and ugly looking Mario with a... [[NightmareFace very disturbing expression of glee]] [[SlasherSmile on his face]].

** Though some NightmareRetardant exists if you listen closely; at one point, among the echoed voices in the background, you can hear [=DingDong=] ask, "What the heck is this?" followed by "[[LampshadeHanging Is this a creepy pasta, is that what we're doing?]]" Other users have also pointed out that many of the echoed voices is actually just the infamous Hitler Clone Argument, reversed and garbled.

* A minor example is the artpiece they used for the thumbnails of their VideoGame/KingdomHearts2 playthrough. It has Chris and [=DingDong=] cosplaying Sora and WesternAnimation/DonaldDuck respectively, but Julian as WesternAnimation/{{Goofy}} [[BodyHorror is depicted as Julian's head and a single arm merged with the nose of a deformed version of Goofy who has nipples for eyes]], with [=DingDong=] understandably disturbed at him.

* In part 1 of ''VideoGame/MarioArtist: Paint Studio'', after goofing around with Mario Artist by adding horror elements to a drawn Nostalgia Critic, which is already creepy, but also NightmareRetardant since the ''creepy'' elements are just cliche creepypasta tropes like bleeding eyes, but when [=DingDong=] starts spamming the blur tool, the Critic gets an increasingly [[NightmareFace creepy face]] that's getting worse with each application of the blur tool.

* Ding Dong's Pizza Guy Story in American Truck Simulator is an extreme case. Basically, a Pizza Delivery Guy who was unsatisfied with the tip Ding Dong gave intentionally ruined their pizza. Naturally, the two sent in a complaint about it, and they found that the delivery guy had received multiple complaints despite being a new employee. The two avoided ordering pizza from that place for two months. When they did order pizza from there again, not only is it the same Delivery Guy, but he's still bitter about their last encounter. He asks Ding Dong to open the box and inspect it, to which he sees nothing wrong with it. Just when it seems like Ding Dong is being paranoid by saying he didn't trust the pizza, they then revealed that they actually did all experience a severe stomach flu the day after eating the pizza, with them all waking up to feeling nauseous and having diarrhea.

* Ding Dong's Pizza Guy Story in American Truck Simulator is an extreme case of AdultFear. Basically, a Pizza Delivery Guy who was unsatisfied with the tip Ding Dong gave intentionally ruined their pizza. Naturally, the two sent in a complaint about it, and they found that the delivery guy had received multiple complaints despite being a new employee. The two avoided ordering pizza from that place for two months. When they did order pizza from there again, not only is it the same Delivery Guy, but he's still bitter about their last encounter. He asks Ding Dong to open the box and inspect it, to which he sees nothing wrong with it. Just when it seems like Ding Dong is being paranoid by saying he didn't trust the pizza, they then revealed that they actually did all experience a severe stomach flu the day after eating the pizza, with them all waking up to feeling nauseous and having diarrhea.

* Although Chris himself isn't too bothered about it, the fact that he ate ice cream with [=sirtom93=] (a Website/{{Newgrounds}} user who became infamous for attempting to burn down his school with gasoline, which was only prevented by the fact that he publicly posted about it on the forums, letting another user warn the police) can be rather disturbing to imagine from his perspective; one moment you're spending some time with a friend, only to find out some time later that they snapped with barely any warning or reason and tried to go on a rampage.

* A minor example is the artpiece they used for the thumbnails of their VideoGame/KingdomHearts2 playthrough. It has Sora and [=DingDong=] cosplaying Sora and WesternAnimation/DonaldDuck respectively, but Julian as WesternAnimation/{{Goofy}} [[BodyHorror is depicted as Julian's head and a single arm merged with the nose of a deformed version of Goofy who has nipples for eyes]], with [=DingDong=] understandably disturbed at him.