Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / WishingForMoreWishes

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Anime/RanmaOneHalf'', during the Anime version of the Wishing Sword arc, Genma gets Kuno's Wishbringer. But as only one wish is left, he asks for 10 more wishes first. A foot appears from the sword kicking him in the face for rule violation. It wouldn't have worked anyway; Genma fails the magical voice recognition too.

to:

* In ''Anime/RanmaOneHalf'', ''Manga/RanmaOneHalf'', during the Anime version of the Wishing Sword arc, Genma gets Kuno's Wishbringer. But as only one wish is left, he asks for 10 more wishes first. A foot appears from the sword kicking him in the face for rule violation. It wouldn't have worked anyway; Genma fails the magical voice recognition too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WebAnimation/{{RWBY}}'': When learning that the Relic of Knowledge (which looks like an ornate lantern) can answer up to three questions per century, Nora excitedly asks if they can "Ask for more questions" to which Ren tiredly tells her that's not how it works.

to:

* ''WebAnimation/{{RWBY}}'': When learning that the Relic of Knowledge (which looks like an ornate lantern) can answer up to three questions per century, Nora excitedly asks if they can "Ask for more questions" to which Ren tiredly tells her that's not how it works.
that they aren't ''wishes''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Mr. Crocker and Norm the Genie team up to kill Timmy, Norm explains to Crocker that while genies say that people can't wish for more wishes, they actually can do so (as Norm puts it, "[genies] have been bluffing for centuries"). Crocker uses the effectively unlimited wishes to set up Wile. E. Coyote-esque traps for Timmy- and just like Wile. E, none of them work, making him use more wishes to fix his self-inflicted injuries.

to:

** When Mr. Crocker and Norm the Genie team up to kill Timmy, Norm explains to Crocker that while genies say that people can't wish for more wishes, they actually can do so (as Norm puts it, "[genies] have been bluffing for centuries").centuries"), due to the wishes being rule free. As a compromise, Norm only allows Crocker to wish for three wishes per third wish. Crocker uses the effectively unlimited wishes to set up Wile. E. Coyote-esque traps for Timmy- and just like Wile. E, none of them work, making him use more wishes to fix his self-inflicted injuries.

Added: 269

Changed: 230

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/BruceCovillesBookOf Spine Tinglers'': Miranda Alice uses her first wish to get a thousand wishes in ''Those Three Wishes''.

to:

* ''Literature/BruceCovillesBookOf ''Literature/BruceCovillesBookOf'':
** ''Bruce Coville's Book of
Spine Tinglers'': Miranda Alice uses her first wish to get a thousand wishes in ''Those "Those Three Wishes''.
Wishes".
** ''Bruce Coville's Book of Magic'': {{Discussed|Trope}} in "Visions" when a group of girls find a trinket that can grant one wish -- they fear that asking for more wishes would only dilute the original wish's power, such that 100 wishes would each only be 1% granted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/TheSoulmateTimeline'': As in the regular [[Anime/PuellaMagiMadokaMagica canon]], Kyubey can grant nearly any singular wish as long as the would-be Magical Girl has enough magical potential to cover it, and you can use LoopholeAbuse to get multiple effective results from it, but it's still just ''one'' wish. When Sayaka [[spoiler:who doesn't need to wish for Kyosuke's hand to be healed since Mami is using her own magic to slowly do so]] half-jokingly admits she's the type of girl to try and use her wish to get multiple wishes, Kyubey immediately and in no uncertain terms spells out that's not how the contract works, leading Sayaka to conclude she isn't the first in Kyubey's [[TimeAbyss long history]] to try and play that card on him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mr. Crocker rubs a genie lamp, releasing the genie and earning ThreeWishes. However, since genie wishes have no limitations, [[LoopholeAbuse every third wish involves him for wishing three more]]. The genie, named Norm, explains to Crocker that while genies say that people can't wish for more wishes, they actually can do so (as Norm puts it, "[genies] have been bluffing for centuries"). Norm's the one who ultimately convinces Crocker to keep wishing more wishes so they can work together to get revenge against Timmy Turner. Crocker uses the wishes to set up Wile. E. Coyote-esque traps for Timmy- and just like Wile. E, none of them work.

to:

** When Mr. Crocker rubs a genie lamp, releasing and Norm the genie and earning ThreeWishes. However, since genie wishes have no limitations, [[LoopholeAbuse every third wish involves him for wishing three more]]. The genie, named Norm, Genie team up to kill Timmy, Norm explains to Crocker that while genies say that people can't wish for more wishes, they actually can do so (as Norm puts it, "[genies] have been bluffing for centuries"). Norm's the one who ultimately convinces Crocker to keep wishing more wishes so they can work together to get revenge against Timmy Turner. Crocker uses the effectively unlimited wishes to set up Wile. E. Coyote-esque traps for Timmy- and just like Wile. E, none of them work.work, making him use more wishes to fix his self-inflicted injuries.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the children's novel ''[[http://www.amazon.com/Three-Many-Wishes-Jason-Reid/dp/1550376535 The Three And Many Wishes of Jason Reid]]'', the titular character meets a rare wish-granter who ''hasn't'' already encountered the oldest trick in the book and is actually forced to grant him extra wishes. However, his magic is not inexhaustible, and the more and larger wishes he grants, the more exhausted he becomes. In the end, Jason "gives back" all of his previous wishes in exchange for one final wish that he really, ''really'' wants.

to:

* In the children's novel ''[[http://www.amazon.com/Three-Many-Wishes-Jason-Reid/dp/1550376535 The Three And Many Wishes of Jason Reid]]'', ''Literature/TheThreeAndManyWishesOfJasonReid'', the titular character meets a rare wish-granter who ''hasn't'' already encountered the oldest trick in the book and is actually forced to grant him extra wishes. However, his magic is not inexhaustible, and the more and larger wishes he grants, the more exhausted he becomes. In the end, Jason "gives back" all of his previous wishes in exchange for one final wish that he really, ''really'' wants.



* Played with in ''Wishing Season'' by Creator/EstherFriesner. It is standard for a genie to say that wishing for more wishes isn't allowed in his or her preamble, but BrilliantButLazy Student Genie Khalid forgets on his first time out, and is enslaved by a mortal for several years till he is rescued.

to:

* Played with in ''Wishing Season'' ''Literature/WishingSeason'' by Creator/EstherFriesner. It is standard for a genie to say that wishing for more wishes isn't allowed in his or her preamble, but BrilliantButLazy Student Genie Khalid forgets on his first time out, and is enslaved by a mortal for several years till he is rescued.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PlayedForDrama in ''ComicBook/{{WITCH}}'': anyone capturing a Banshee will have three wishes granted in the limits of the particular banshee's powers, and [[BenevolentGenie if the Banshee cannot grant the wish she'll merely state so and it won't count for the number]]... But the Banshee is effectively enslaved to her captor until she has granted all wishes, so when Ari, angry at Yua (the most powerful Banshee) for her inability to grant his ''real'' wish and cure his son from his vaguely defined disorder, wishes for her to grant ''all'' his wishes he turned her into a slave until he dies or she finds a way to get free. [[spoiler:Eventually [[MalevolentGenie Yua twists a wish in such a way to leave him helpless in front of the Guardians expecting they'll kill him]], only to be caught by surprise when they just walk away and free her directly]].

to:

* PlayedForDrama in ''ComicBook/{{WITCH}}'': anyone capturing a Banshee will have three wishes granted in the limits of the particular banshee's powers, and [[BenevolentGenie if the Banshee cannot grant the wish she'll merely state so and it won't count for the number]]... But the Banshee is effectively enslaved to her captor until she has granted all wishes, so when Ari, angry at Yua (the most powerful Banshee) for her inability to grant his ''real'' wish and cure his son from his vaguely defined disorder, wishes for her to grant ''all'' his wishes he turned her into a slave until he dies or she finds a way to get free. [[spoiler:Eventually [[MalevolentGenie [[spoiler:Eventually, [[JackassGenie Yua twists a wish in such a way to leave him helpless in front of the Guardians expecting they'll kill him]], only to be caught by surprise when they just walk away and free her directly]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Manga/AssassinationClassroom: When the cast challenges class 3-A, the sides agree that the losing team must obey one request from the victor. Naturally, class 3-A's planned request is "Follow all the rules put forth in this {{Doorstopper}} of a document, which also includes the provison 'Do Whatever We Tell You To'".

to:

* Manga/AssassinationClassroom: ''Manga/AssassinationClassroom'': When the cast challenges class 3-A, the sides agree that the losing team must obey one request from the victor. Naturally, class 3-A's planned request is "Follow all the rules put forth in this {{Doorstopper}} of a document, which also includes the provison 'Do Whatever We Tell You To'".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/WonderWoman1984''. Maxwell Lord gets around the one-wish limit by wishing to ''become'' the Dreamstone, thereby ensuring his supply of wishes is only limited by the number of people he can trick into wishing for something he also wants to happen. Furthermore, it also allows him to choose what costs are paid by the wishers, so he profits on both ends of the scale.

to:

* ''Film/WonderWoman1984''. Maxwell Lord gets around the one-wish limit by wishing to ''become'' the Dreamstone, thereby ensuring his supply of wishes is only limited by the number of people he can trick into wishing for something he also wants to happen. Furthermore, it also allows him to choose what costs are paid by the wishers, so he profits on both ends of the scale. The downside is that his health deteriorates the longer he goes between wishes, so every so often he has to take someone else’s health as his payment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Web Comics]]

to:

[[folder:Web Comics]][[folder:Webcomics]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/BobsBurgers'': Inverted in "[[Recap/BobsBurgersS13E4CometyOfErrors A Comet-y of Errors]]" when Gene and Louise get their hands on a ton of wishing paper. When they start running out of ideas for wishes, Gene wishes for ''less'' wishes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Fanfic/OppositesDestroy'', Genie mentions that a previous master found a way around the inability to wish for more wishes and used his original third wish to wish for more genies, resulting in the Genie that would befriend Aladdin meeting Djinn, a genie of the necklace who hated being forced to serve humans. While Djinn made a habit of twisting his masters' wishes to threaten them, Genie often prevented Djinn from doing as much damage as he would have liked, which earned Genie Djinn's long-term hatred and made him a target for Djinn's vendetta.
* In ''Fanfic/TheMermaidAndTheGenie'', Ursula finds a way around this by using her third wish to wish that Genie has to obey her so long as she's holding the lamp, essentially drawing out her third wish in perpetuity rather than actually wishing for more wishes outright.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ComicStrip/PhoebeAndHerUnicorn'': When Phoebe first meets Marigold, the unicorn offers the girl a wish for rescuing Marigold from her reflection, and Phoebe's first wish is infinity wishes. Marigold tells her she can't do that, to which Phoebe wishes for infinity dollars.
--> '''Marigold:''' World peace is not even in your top two?
--> '''Phoebe:''' I'm a fourth grader.

Added: 646

Changed: 646

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''WesternAnimation/TheFairlyOddParents'', Mr. Crocker rubs a genie lamp, releasing the genie and earning ThreeWishes. However, since genie wishes have no limitations, [[LoopholeAbuse every third wish involves him for wishing three more]]. The genie, named Norm, explains to Crocker that while genies say that people can't wish for more wishes, they actually can do so (as Norm puts it, "[genies] have been bluffing for centuries"). Norm's the one who ultimately convinces Crocker to keep wishing more wishes so they can work together to get revenge against Timmy Turner. Crocker uses the wishes to set up Wile. E. Coyote-esque traps for Timmy- and just like Wile. E, none of them work.

to:

* In ''WesternAnimation/TheFairlyOddParents'', ''WesternAnimation/TheFairlyOddParents'':
**
Mr. Crocker rubs a genie lamp, releasing the genie and earning ThreeWishes. However, since genie wishes have no limitations, [[LoopholeAbuse every third wish involves him for wishing three more]]. The genie, named Norm, explains to Crocker that while genies say that people can't wish for more wishes, they actually can do so (as Norm puts it, "[genies] have been bluffing for centuries"). Norm's the one who ultimately convinces Crocker to keep wishing more wishes so they can work together to get revenge against Timmy Turner. Crocker uses the wishes to set up Wile. E. Coyote-esque traps for Timmy- and just like Wile. E, none of them work.

Top