History Main / WhyAreYouNotMySon

11th Sep '17 9:50:58 PM thestormtrooper
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* In ''the Boy Who Drew Monsters'', both Jack's parents see Nick more as the normal son, which they could have had and favor him in many circumstances, not that this even bothers Jack in any way (too involved with his drawings), Tim (the father) especially envisions Nell (Nick's mother) as the wife he could have had and Nick as the son he could have had, in the life he could have had, Holly, in contrast, envisions her life at one point without any son, or any husband for that matter. True, both parents essentially blame Jack for ruining their lives with the troubles he has caused them and their marriage, it is quite clear that they both still love their son and acknowledge him as such. They even refer to him numerous times as their son, their 'baby boy.'

to:

* In ''the Boy Who Drew Monsters'', both Jack's parents see Nick more as the normal son, which they could have had and favor him in many circumstances, not that this even bothers Jack in any way (too involved with his drawings), Tim (the father) especially envisions Nell (Nick's mother) as the wife he could have had and Nick as the son he could have had, in the life he could have had, Holly, in contrast, envisions her life at one point without any son, or any husband for that matter. True, both parents essentially blame Jack for ruining their lives with the troubles he has caused them and their marriage, it is quite clear that they both still care for and love their son son, and acknowledge him as such. They even refer to him numerous times as their son, their 'baby boy.'boy', the boy that they want back.
11th Sep '17 8:27:56 AM thestormtrooper
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* In ''the Boy Who Drew Monsters'', both Jack's parents see Nick more as the normal son, which they could have had and favor him in many circumstances, not that this even bothers Jack in any way (too involved with his drawings), Tim (the father) especially envisions Nell (Nick's mother) as the wife he could have had and Nick as the son he could have had, in the life he could have had, Holly, in contrast, envisions her life at one point without any son, or any husband for that matter. True, both parents essentially blame Jack for ruining their lives with the troubles he has caused them and their marriage, it is quite clear that they both still love their son and acknowledge him as such. They even refer to him numerous times as their son, their 'baby boy.'



* In ''the Boy Who Drew Monsters'', both Jack's parents see Nick more as the normal son, which they could have had and favor him in many circumstances, not that this even bothers Jack in any way (too involved with his drawings), Tim (the father) especially envisions Nell (Nick's mother) as the wife he could have had and Nick as the son he could have had, in the life he could have had, Holly, in contrast, envisions her life at one point without any son, or any husband for that matter. True, both parents essentially blame Jack for ruining their lives with the troubles he has caused them and their marriage, it is quite clear that they both still love their son and acknowledge him as such. They even refer to him numerous times as their son, their 'baby boy.'
11th Sep '17 8:27:04 AM thestormtrooper
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* In ''the Boy Who Drew Monsters'', both Jack's parents see Nick more as the normal son, which they could have had and favor him in many circumstances, not that this even bothers Jack in any way (too involved with his drawings), Tim (the father) especially envisions Nell (Nick's mother) as the wife he could have had and Nick as the son he could have had, in the life he could have had, Holly, in contrast, envisions her life at one point without any son, or any husband for that matter. True, both parents essentially blame Jack for ruining their lives with the troubles he has caused them and their marriage, it is quite clear that they both still love their son and acknowledge him as such. They even refer to him numerous times as their son, their 'baby boy.'
28th Aug '17 11:28:26 AM Allronix
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Used as a joke in an early episode of ''WesternAnimation/JonnyQuestTheRealAdventures''. The team is exploring in the polar regions. Jonny is eager to go out and test the new equipment, including upgraded (and fast) snowmobiles. Jessie segues into reminding him about the scientific purpose and importance of their mission. Race raises an eyebrow, turns to Dr. Quest and asks if they somehow managed to swap kids.
3rd Aug '17 7:39:56 AM StFan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


-> '''Norman Osborn''': Peter! Good to see you! Here to help Harry, eh?
-> '''Peter Parker''': We help each other, Mr. O.
-> '''Norman Osborn''': Now, now, Peter, modesty doesn't become men like ''us''. Smart, driven, responsible. Self-made.
-> '''Peter Parker''': I'm...more of a work in progress.
-> '''Norman Osborn''': (''With a significant glance at Harry'') At least you're ''making'' progress.

to:

-> '''Norman Osborn''': ->'''Norman Osborn:''' Peter! Good to see you! Here to help Harry, eh?
->
eh?\\
'''Peter Parker''': Parker:''' We help each other, Mr. O.
->
O.\\
'''Norman Osborn''': Osborn:''' Now, now, Peter, modesty doesn't become men like ''us''. Smart, driven, responsible. Self-made.
->
Self-made.\\
'''Peter Parker''': I'm...Parker:''' I'm... more of a work in progress.
->
progress.\\
'''Norman Osborn''': (''With Osborn:''' ''[with a significant glance at Harry'') Harry]'' At least you're ''making'' progress.



[[folder:Anime and Manga]]

to:

[[folder:Anime and & Manga]]



* This was the FreudianExcuse of 90s ''Franchise/{{Superman}}'' enemy Kenny Braverman / Conduit (''ComicBook/TheDeathOfClarkKent''), who was convinced Clark was always one step ahead of him as teens because his powers had already manifested. Superman was pretty disgusted to find Kenny's dad still disparaging him after his death.

to:

* This was the FreudianExcuse of 90s '90s ''Franchise/{{Superman}}'' enemy Kenny Braverman / Conduit (''ComicBook/TheDeathOfClarkKent''), who was convinced Clark was always one step ahead of him as teens because his powers had already manifested. Superman was pretty disgusted to find Kenny's dad still disparaging him after his death.



[[folder:Film]]

to:

[[folder:Film]][[folder:Films -- Live-Action]]



[[folder:{{Literature}}]]

to:

[[folder:{{Literature}}]][[folder:Literature]]



-->'''Mayor Prentiss''': You were always the truer son, Todd. The one with the potential, the one with the power, [[WeCanRuleTogether the one I'd be proud to have serve by my side.]]\\

to:

-->'''Mayor Prentiss''': Prentiss:''' You were always the truer son, Todd. The one with the potential, the one with the power, [[WeCanRuleTogether the one I'd be proud to have serve by my side.]]\\



[[folder:Live Action TV]]

to:

[[folder:Live Action [[folder:Live-Action TV]]



* Subverted in the episode dealing with Daedalus and Icarus in ''Series/TheStoryteller''. Daedalus is frustrated by his son Icarus' clumsiness and lack of inventive genius. A cousin comes to stay with them who does have this brilliance and attracts Daedalus' favor. The twist, is that although he acts like a WellDoneSonGuy towards Icarus, Daedalus "accidentally-on-purpose" kills his nephew, both because he reminds him of disappointment in his own son, and because he sees him as a rival.
** This also happened in the actual myths and was much less "accidental."
* In ''Series/{{Kings}}'', the ruling King Silas prefers David to his son [[DepravedHomosexual Jack]] because Jack's homosexuality and generally hedonistic lifestyle prevents him from being capable of taking over the kingdom.
** The plot being lifted from the story of Saul, Jonathan, and David from ''The Bible'' makes this Older Than Feudalism.

to:

* Subverted in the episode dealing with Daedalus and Icarus in ''Series/TheStoryteller''. Daedalus is frustrated by his son Icarus' clumsiness and lack of inventive genius. A cousin comes to stay with them who does have this brilliance and attracts Daedalus' favor. The twist, is that although he acts like a WellDoneSonGuy towards Icarus, Daedalus "accidentally-on-purpose" kills his nephew, both because he reminds him of disappointment in his own son, and because he sees him as a rival.
**
rival. This also happened in the actual myths and was much less "accidental."
* In ''Series/{{Kings}}'', the ruling King Silas prefers David to his son [[DepravedHomosexual Jack]] because Jack's homosexuality and generally hedonistic lifestyle prevents him from being capable of taking over the kingdom.
**
kingdom. The plot being lifted from the story of Saul, Jonathan, and David from ''The Bible'' makes this Older Than Feudalism.



[[folder:Video games]]

to:

[[folder:Video games]]Games]]



* Hwang in the VideoGame/SoulSeries. Seung Han Myong basically treats him like the son he never had, and whilst he loves his daughter Seung Mina, will not allow her to go out to fight because it wasn't considered proper for a woman to do so in Korea at the time.

to:

* Hwang in the VideoGame/SoulSeries.''VideoGame/SoulSeries''. Seung Han Myong basically treats him like the son he never had, and whilst he loves his daughter Seung Mina, will not allow her to go out to fight because it wasn't considered proper for a woman to do so in Korea at the time.



[[folder:Webcomics]]
* [[http://www.channelate.com/2012/04/04/question-for-mom/ This]] ''{{Channelate}}'' strip takes it to hilarious extremes.
* ''WebComic/DragonBallMultiverse'': U18 Vegeta appears to have this briefly when he see's how strong U16 Bra is, and gets annoyed with his own daughter when she rejects his suggestion for her to train to get as strong as her counterpart.

to:

[[folder:Webcomics]]
[[folder:Web Comics]]
* [[http://www.channelate.com/2012/04/04/question-for-mom/ This]] ''{{Channelate}}'' ''Webcomic/ChannelAte'' strip takes it to hilarious extremes.
* ''WebComic/DragonBallMultiverse'': ''Webcomic/DragonBallMultiverse'': U18 Vegeta appears to have this briefly when he see's how strong U16 Bra is, and gets annoyed with his own daughter when she rejects his suggestion for her to train to get as strong as her counterpart.



* Yet another Spider-Man example: Norman thinks this of Peter in ''WesternAnimation/UltimateSpiderMan'', though it's somewhat mitigated by the fact that this version Norman does care about his own son, Harry. Becomes blatant in the episode "Carnage" though:
-->'''Goblin/Norman''': Ah, Welcome home, son.\\
'''Peter''': What do you want? Let me go. Did you just say "son"?\\
'''Goblin''': The son I've always wanted. Harry and I share a few recessive genes, but nothing more. You're smarter, more driven. And as a wimpy, defenseless kid, you appreciate power. You can be a greater creation than the late, great Spider-Man."

to:

* Yet another Spider-Man ''Spider-Man'' example: Norman thinks this of Peter in ''WesternAnimation/UltimateSpiderMan'', though it's somewhat mitigated by the fact that this version Norman does care about his own son, Harry. Becomes blatant in the episode "Carnage" though:
-->'''Goblin/Norman''': -->'''Goblin/Norman:''' Ah, Welcome home, son.\\
'''Peter''': '''Peter:''' What do you want? Let me go. Did you just say "son"?\\
'''Goblin''': '''Goblin:''' The son I've always wanted. Harry and I share a few recessive genes, but nothing more. You're smarter, more driven. And as a wimpy, defenseless kid, you appreciate power. You can be a greater creation than the late, great Spider-Man."



* On ''WesternAnimation/YoungJustice,'' [[AnIcePerson Icicle Sr.]] praises Tommy Terror (actually ComicBook/{{Superboy}} in disguise) and compares him favorably to his son, Tommy/Superboy's cellmate [[WellDoneSonGuy Icicle Jr.]]

to:

* On ''WesternAnimation/YoungJustice,'' ''WesternAnimation/YoungJustice'':
**
[[AnIcePerson Icicle Sr.]] praises Tommy Terror (actually ComicBook/{{Superboy}} in disguise) and compares him favorably to his son, Tommy/Superboy's cellmate [[WellDoneSonGuy Icicle Jr.]]



* ''WesternAnimation/{{Arthur}}'': In "The Perfect Brother", Brain stays over at Arthur's house for the weekend, and Arthur's family constantly compliments him on his polite and helpful behavior, such as eating his food neatly and offering Arthur's dad a cooking tip. This leads Arthur to become slightly angry at Brain...until Arthur decides to come over to Brain's house and notices that Brain's room is actually as messy as his own room. Brain's parents even start complimenting Arthur on ''his'' good behavior.
-->'''Arthur''': I don't believe it! You were so neat at my house.\\
'''Brain''': Yeah, and it almost ''killed'' me! I was a guest in your house, I had to be polite.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/{{Arthur}}'': In "The Perfect Brother", Brain stays over at Arthur's house for the weekend, and Arthur's family constantly compliments him on his polite and helpful behavior, such as eating his food neatly and offering Arthur's dad a cooking tip. This leads Arthur to become slightly angry at Brain... until Arthur decides to come over to Brain's house and notices that Brain's room is actually as messy as his own room. Brain's parents even start complimenting Arthur on ''his'' good behavior.
-->'''Arthur''': -->'''Arthur:''' I don't believe it! You were so neat at my house.\\
'''Brain''': '''Brain:''' Yeah, and it almost ''killed'' me! I was a guest in your house, I had to be polite.



17th Jul '17 11:25:26 AM SpongySpongyLiam
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/ChaosWalking'' [[MagnificentBastard Mayor Prentiss]] makes it clear multiple times that he prefers the protagonist, Todd, over his own son [[TheUnfavorite Davy]]. He even goes as far as saying so right after he [[spoiler: [[OffingTheOffspring shoots Davy]] to stop Todd using him as leverage in a stand-off.]]
-->'''Mayor Prentiss''': You were always the truer son, Todd. The one with the potential, the one with the power, [[WeCanRuleTogether the one I'd be proud to have serve by my side.]]\\
11th Jun '17 2:46:09 PM StarTropes
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* A variation on ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine''--while Nog's father Rom is fully supportive of his son's desire to join Starfleet, Uncle Quark isn't.
--> '''Quark:''' Why can't you take after your friend here? ''(motions to Jake)'' He knows enough to stay out of Starfleet.
30th Oct '16 2:12:29 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* They aren't necessarily friends, but in Shakespeare's ''HenryIV Part 1'', the titular king openly compares his son Harry to rebel leader Hotspur and considers the latter far superior.

to:

* They aren't necessarily friends, but in Shakespeare's ''HenryIV ''Theatre/HenryIV Part 1'', the titular king openly compares his son Harry to rebel leader Hotspur and considers the latter far superior.
16th Sep '16 9:48:25 AM Plactus
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Done lightly on ''Series/PrettyLittleLiars'': When Emily stays with Hanna while her parents move to Texas, she cooks breakfast the first morning as a "thank you," and Hanna's mom jokes about considering keeping the "daughter upgrade."
12th Sep '16 9:11:01 AM nighttrainfm
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''WesternAnimation/TheSpectacularSpiderMan'' also uses the Norman Osborn/Green Goblin preferring Peter Parker to his son Harry plot.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/TheSpectacularSpiderMan'' also uses the Norman Osborn/Green Goblin preferring Peter Parker to his son Harry plot. This version of Norman is by far the most blatant, contrasting the two of them right to Harry's face.
This list shows the last 10 events of 106. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Main.WhyAreYouNotMySon