Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / Titanic

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Fiery Redhead: Rose has traces of this.

to:

* Fiery Redhead: {{Fiery Redhead}}: Rose has traces of this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FlippingTheBird

to:

* FlippingTheBirdFlippingTheBird: Rose to Lovejoy, as she and Jack are escaping him in the elevator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Cameron offered the role of Old Rose to [[KingKong Fay Wray]], who turned it down thinking it would have been "a tortuous experience altogether."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The'' movie of [[TheNineties 1997]] (actually due to its December release, ''the'' movie of 1998). It was a darling of most critics at the time, a commercial splash, won 11 Oscars including Best Picture, and quickly became a source of many StockParodies. Unadjusted for inflation, it's the second-highest-grossing movie ever, recently beaten out by [[JamesCameron Cameron's]] own ''{{Film/Avatar}}''. (If you adjust for inflation, ''Titanic'' drops six slots, but even so it's still one of the highest-grossing films ever.) In all likelihood, Cameron now has roughly enough money to raise the Titanic and fire it toward Pandora. Currently, the film is [[DeaderThanDisco facing a bit of a backlash]], due both to its being schmaltzy and [[ItsPopularNowItSucks the fact that it made loads of money]], but the same could be said of many such films. We're not going to go further than that other than to say YourMileageMayVary.

to:

''The'' movie of [[TheNineties 1997]] (actually due to its December release, ''the'' movie of 1998). It was a darling of most critics at the time, a commercial splash, won 11 Oscars including Best Picture, and quickly became a source of many StockParodies. Unadjusted for inflation, it's the second-highest-grossing movie ever, recently beaten out by [[JamesCameron Cameron's]] own ''{{Film/Avatar}}''. (If you adjust for inflation, ''Titanic'' drops six slots, but even so it's still one of the highest-grossing films ever.) [[SarcasmMode In all likelihood, Cameron now has roughly enough money to to]] [[DontExplainTheJoke raise the Titanic and fire it toward Pandora. Pandora.]] Currently, the film is [[DeaderThanDisco facing a bit of a backlash]], due both to its being schmaltzy and [[ItsPopularNowItSucks the fact that it made loads of money]], but the same could be said of many such films. We're not going to go further than that other than to say YourMileageMayVary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Firey Redhead: Rose has traces of this.

to:

* Firey Fiery Redhead: Rose has traces of this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** About 3 times you also see a tan, curcly headed girl named Cora, who doesn't look much older than 7. [[spoiler: You don't see her death on-screen, but in the final scence where Rose is surrounded by all those who perished on the Titanic, she's the first person you see.]]

to:

** About 3 times you also see a tan, curcly headed girl named Cora, who doesn't look much older than 7. [[spoiler: You don't see her death on-screen, but in the final scence where Rose is surrounded by all those who perished on the Titanic, she's the first person you see.]]]] A deleted scene shows her and her parents, crying and screaming, being submerged by water. Cameron explains it was cut because it was just a bit too upsetting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[ManicPixieDreamGirl Manic Pixie Dream Guy]]: Jack.

to:

* [[ManicPixieDreamGirl Manic Pixie Dream Guy]]: Jack. A shining example of the ManicPixieDreamGirl trope done well, regardless of gender, and extra rare as the character is male.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Cameron originally wanted Drew Barrymore to play Rose, but execs told him that she wouldn't be right for the role.
** Johnny Depp also admitted in an interview that he was offered the lead role in the movie but turned it down, and considers it a big regret.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** More seriously, though, the film goes out of its way to trash the image of one William Murdoch, who (aside from being implicated in the Titanic hitting the iceberg) variously takes a bribe from Cal Hockley, shoots people as the ship sinks, and then finally kills himself. This might have been an AcceptableTarget for demonstrating incompetence by the ship's crew had there not actually ''been'' a William Murdoch who was on Titanic and who actually ''had'' the position the William Murdoch who appears on screen did. There were eyewitness reports from the Titanic's survivors that Murdoch killed no one, did not suicide, and was alive in the water when the ship went down, fighting hard to loose more lifeboats right to the bitter end. Murdoch's surviving relatives complained when they saw the film, and the vice president of the entire Fox Network eventually flew out personally to apologise for the gaffe, donating five thousand pounds to a British school's William Murdoch Memorial Prize.
*** Though, to be fair, the one person Murdoch shot was by accident, or at least out of reflex rather than actually taking aim and pulling the trigger. Additionally, prior to that incident in the movie, he literally throws Cal's money back in his face with the line "Your money can't save you any more than it can save me."
**** Plus he seemed to stare at Cal in disbelief when he shoved the money at him.
***** In addition, there are a number of survivor accounts of an officer shooting himself on the forward end of the starboard Boat Deck. If this did happen, it would have had to been either Chief Officer Wilde or First Officer Murdoch, as all the other officers are accounted for elsewhere. Murdoch seems to be the more likely one.
***** And now Cameron has issued a public apology to Murdoch's relatives. Cameron says, "I think I have come to the realization that it was probably wrong to portray a specific person, in this case First Officer Murdoch, as the one who fired the weapon. First Officer Murdoch has a family and they took exception to that, and I think rightly so."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He's keeping Rose's debris balanced and a deleted scene shows him guarding that float from other survivors.


Added DiffLines:

*** [[spoiler: If Rose didn't stay with Jack, he would have been sucked down by the ship since he's not wearing any life vest. Also, if Rose remained with her mother, she wouldn't have escaped her miserable life and promise Jack to "hold on."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If Rose had just stayed on the lifeboat she actually boarded, it seems [[spoiler: like Jack would have had a much better chance of survival, for one, he wouldn't have been chased back below deck by Cal and submerged in the freezing waters again (something that in real life would have only exacerbated his hypothermia even if he got back out) but presumably he would have done the same thing he did with Rose, that is, ride the ship down then find the floating door. Then they both could have both survived.]]

to:

** If Rose had just stayed on the lifeboat she actually boarded, it seems [[spoiler: like Jack would have had a much better chance of survival, for one, he wouldn't have been chased back below deck by Cal and submerged in the freezing waters again (something that in real life would have only exacerbated his hypothermia even if he got back out) but presumably he would have done the same thing he did with Rose, that is, ride the ship down then find the floating door. Then they both could have both survived.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


"First Officer Murdoch has a family and they took exception to that, and I think rightly so."

Added: 439

Changed: 128

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** More seriously, though, the film goes out of its way to trash the image of one William Murdoch, who (aside from being implicated in the Titanic hitting the iceberg) variously takes a bribe from Cal Hockley, shoots people as the ship sinks, and then finally kills himself. This might have been an AcceptableTarget for demonstrating incompetence by the ship's crew had there not actually ''been'' a William Murdoch who was on Titanic and who actually ''had'' the position the William Murdoch who appears on screen did. Whilst there are a number of survivor accounts of an officer shooting himself, and Murdoch seems to be the more likely one, there were eyewitness reports from the Titanic's survivors that Murdoch killed no one, did not suicide, and was alive in the water when the ship went down, fighting hard to loose more lifeboats right to the bitter end. Murdoch's surviving relatives complained when they saw the film, and the vice president of the entire Fox Network eventually flew out personally to apologise for the gaffe, donating five thousand pounds to a British school's William Murdoch Memorial Prize.

to:

** More seriously, though, the film goes out of its way to trash the image of one William Murdoch, who (aside from being implicated in the Titanic hitting the iceberg) variously takes a bribe from Cal Hockley, shoots people as the ship sinks, and then finally kills himself. This might have been an AcceptableTarget for demonstrating incompetence by the ship's crew had there not actually ''been'' a William Murdoch who was on Titanic and who actually ''had'' the position the William Murdoch who appears on screen did. Whilst there are a number of survivor accounts of an officer shooting himself, and Murdoch seems to be the more likely one, there There were eyewitness reports from the Titanic's survivors that Murdoch killed no one, did not suicide, and was alive in the water when the ship went down, fighting hard to loose more lifeboats right to the bitter end. Murdoch's surviving relatives complained when they saw the film, and the vice president of the entire Fox Network eventually flew out personally to apologise for the gaffe, donating five thousand pounds to a British school's William Murdoch Memorial Prize.



***** In addition, there are a number of survivor accounts of an officer shooting himself on the forward end of the starboard Boat Deck. If this did happen, it would have had to been either Chief Officer Wilde or First Officer Murdoch, as all the other officers are accounted for elsewhere. Murdoch seems to be the more likely one,

to:

***** In addition, there are a number of survivor accounts of an officer shooting himself on the forward end of the starboard Boat Deck. If this did happen, it would have had to been either Chief Officer Wilde or First Officer Murdoch, as all the other officers are accounted for elsewhere. Murdoch seems to be the more likely one,one.
***** And now Cameron has issued a public apology to Murdoch's relatives. Cameron says, "I think I have come to the realization that it was probably wrong to portray a specific person, in this case First Officer Murdoch, as the one who fired the weapon. First Officer Murdoch has a family and they took exception to that, and I think rightly so."

"First Officer Murdoch has a family and they took exception to that, and I think rightly so."

Added: 333

Changed: 105

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** More seriously, though, the film goes out of its way to trash the image of one William Murdoch, who (aside from being implicated in the Titanic hitting the iceberg) variously takes a bribe from Cal Hockley, shoots people as the ship sinks, and then finally kills himself. This might have been an AcceptableTarget for demonstrating incompetence by the ship's crew had there not actually ''been'' a William Murdoch who was on Titanic and who actually ''had'' the position the William Murdoch who appears on screen did. Whilst there were rumours one of the officers did suicide, there were eyewitness reports from the Titanic's survivors that Murdoch killed no one, did not suicide, and was alive in the water when the ship went down, fighting hard to loose more lifeboats right to the bitter end. Murdoch's surviving relatives complained when they saw the film, and the vice president of the entire Fox Network eventually flew out personally to apologise for the gaffe, donating five thousand pounds to a British school's William Murdoch Memorial Prize.

to:

** More seriously, though, the film goes out of its way to trash the image of one William Murdoch, who (aside from being implicated in the Titanic hitting the iceberg) variously takes a bribe from Cal Hockley, shoots people as the ship sinks, and then finally kills himself. This might have been an AcceptableTarget for demonstrating incompetence by the ship's crew had there not actually ''been'' a William Murdoch who was on Titanic and who actually ''had'' the position the William Murdoch who appears on screen did. Whilst there were rumours one are a number of survivor accounts of an officer shooting himself, and Murdoch seems to be the officers did suicide, more likely one, there were eyewitness reports from the Titanic's survivors that Murdoch killed no one, did not suicide, and was alive in the water when the ship went down, fighting hard to loose more lifeboats right to the bitter end. Murdoch's surviving relatives complained when they saw the film, and the vice president of the entire Fox Network eventually flew out personally to apologise for the gaffe, donating five thousand pounds to a British school's William Murdoch Memorial Prize.


Added DiffLines:

***** In addition, there are a number of survivor accounts of an officer shooting himself on the forward end of the starboard Boat Deck. If this did happen, it would have had to been either Chief Officer Wilde or First Officer Murdoch, as all the other officers are accounted for elsewhere. Murdoch seems to be the more likely one,
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CrazyJealousGuy: Cal
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentalAimingSkills: Rose with the axe. Not only was her aim bad, but her eyes were closed.

to:

* AccidentalAimingSkills: Rose with the axe. Not only was her aim bad, but her eyes were closed.She even hit Jack's wrist if you look carefully.But the chain broke anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Being drunk might (and in reality probably did) help stave off panic, which also would go a long way to surviving in that situation--he was high enough not to stop and think what an insane survival strategy it was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He never actually says he's her father--he says "I have a child" (true, he's certainly holding one) and "I'm all she has in the world" (apparently true as whoever was responsible for her left her sitting behind something on the deck bawling. What the Hell, Parent/Guardian?) If Cal hadn't grabbed her to use as his ticket on the lifeboat, she'd have sat 'til she drowned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: William Murdoch goes from an upstanding officer to shooting two men trying to rush the lifeboats. Second Officer Lightoller becomes a nervous martinent instead of a hero who kept a couple dozen people alive on an overturned life raft. J. Bruce Ismay is shown displaying total disregard for safety by pushing for a speed record ''White Star already knew it couldn't win.'' The entire purpose of the three massive luxury ships was to beat Cunard and other rivals on luxury and technological novelties, not speeed, as they knew they couldn't do that. Pretty much all the crew except Smith (who ironically held the most responsibility for not understanding how to captain a vessel Titanic's size) are depicted as incompetant at best and outright negligent or cruel at worst.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ScienceMarchesOn: The breaking up of the ship is now thought to not have happened as depicted in the movie.
** Also, the French Blue (the royal diamond that in the film was recut into the [[MacGuffin Heart of the Ocean]]) was real, and newly-discovered records and a lead jeweler's model of it have shown that in all probability it was, as theorized, cut down after its theft into what is now known as the Hope Diamond.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****But even if A is true, it's pretty safe to assume that B would occur if Rose were to die.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If Rose had just stayed on the lifeboat she actually boarded, it seems [[spoiler: like Jack would have had a much better chance of survival, for one, he wouldn't have been chased back below deck by Cal and submerged in the freezing waters again (something that in real life would have only exacerbated his hypothermia even if he got back out) but presumably he would have done the same thing he did with Rose, that is, ride the ship down then find the floating door. Then they both could have both survived.]]

Added: 611

Removed: 611

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DawsonCasting: Kate Winslet (21 during the filming) was portraying a seventeen-year-old.
* DemotedToExtra: Remember the blonde chick who dances with Fabrizio in 3rd class? She was written as a opposite counterpart to Rose, a girl who finds her love interest in her class and follows her strict parents' orders without question (down to refusing to go with Fabrizio once the ship begins to sink, despite the fact that he knows the way to the lifeboats better). [[spoiler: She's also the blonde girl who hangs on the railing before falling to her death]].



* DiamondsInTheBuff Kate Winslet posing for her portrait.



* DawsonCasting: Kate Winslet (21 during the filming) was portraying a seventeen-year-old.
* DemotedToExtra: Remember the blonde chick who dances with Fabrizio in 3rd class? She was written as a opposite counterpart to Rose, a girl who finds her love interest in her class and follows her strict parents' orders without question (down to refusing to go with Fabrizio once the ship begins to sink, despite the fact that he knows the way to the lifeboats better). [[spoiler: She's also the blonde girl who hangs on the railing before falling to her death]].
* DiamondsInTheBuff Kate Winslet posing for her portrait.

Added: 81

Changed: 54

Removed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DemotedToExtra: Remember the blonde chick that dances with Fabrizzio in 3rd class? She was written as a opposite counterpart to Rose, a girl that finds her love interest in her class and follows her strict parents' orders without question (down to refusing to go with Fabrizzio once the ship begins to sink, despite he knows better the way to the lifeboats). [[spoiler: She's also the blonde girl that hangs on the railing before falling to her death]].

to:

* DemotedToExtra: Remember the blonde chick that who dances with Fabrizzio Fabrizio in 3rd class? She was written as a opposite counterpart to Rose, a girl that who finds her love interest in her class and follows her strict parents' orders without question (down to refusing to go with Fabrizzio Fabrizio once the ship begins to sink, despite the fact that he knows better the way to the lifeboats). lifeboats better). [[spoiler: She's also the blonde girl that who hangs on the railing before falling to her death]].



* FakeIrish: Victor Garber (Jewish Canadian) as Belfastman Thomas
Andrews.

to:

* FakeIrish: Victor Garber (Jewish Canadian) as Belfastman Thomas
Thomas Andrews.



**Fabrizio curses quite a bit in Italian, especially when [[spoiler:Tommy]] dies.



** About 3 times you also see a tan, curcly headed girl named Coral, who doesn't look much older than 7. [[spoiler: You don't see her death on-screen, but in the final scence where Rose is surrounded by all those who perished on the Titanic, she's the first person you see.]]

to:

** About 3 times you also see a tan, curcly headed girl named Coral, Cora, who doesn't look much older than 7. [[spoiler: You don't see her death on-screen, but in the final scence where Rose is surrounded by all those who perished on the Titanic, she's the first person you see.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Firey Redhead: Rose

to:

* Firey Redhead: RoseRose has traces of this.

Added: 28

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FakeIrish: Victor Garber (Jewish Canadian) as Belfastman Thomas Andrews.

to:

* FakeIrish: Victor Garber (Jewish Canadian) as Belfastman Thomas Andrews.Thomas
Andrews.
*Firey Redhead: Rose
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It's possible he in fact did ''not'' know. It's been reported, with varying degrees of credibility, that not only were many passengers unaware the ship was doomed up until the bow actually went under, but many on the lifeboats actually believed the stern section was going to remain afloat after the expansion joints broke and the ship snapped in half. When you consider the fact that there are entire '''towns''' that are nowhere near as big or populous as the ''Titanic'', and that it took around two hours for the disaster to reach its zenith...


Added DiffLines:

*** It's [[TearJerker more heartwarming]] [[spoiler: if you choose B.]]

Changed: 286

Removed: 297

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved example to Chekhov\'s Skill.


* ChekhovsSkill: spittin' like a man

to:

* ChekhovsSkill: Earlier in the film, Jack teaches Rose how to "spit like a man," and she doesn't do too badly for a first try. Much later in the film, when the ship is sinking, Cal grabs her by the arm and refuses to let her go to Jack. So what does she do in order for him to let go of her? She goes spittin' like a manman.



** Earlier in the film, Jack teaches Rose how to "spit like a man," and she doesn't do too badly for a first try. Much later in the film, when the ship is sinking, Cal grabs her by the arm and refuses to let her go to Jack. So what does she do in order for him to let go of her? Spits in his face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Earlier in the film, Jack teaches Rose how to "spit like a man," and she doesn't do too badly for a first try. Much later in the film, when the ship is sinking, Cal grabs her by the arm and refuses to let her go to Jack. So what does she do in order for him to let go of her? Spits in his face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FreudWasRight: "[[LampshadeHamging I think you'll find his insight on the male preoccupation with size quite interesting.]]"

to:

* FreudWasRight: "[[LampshadeHamging "[[LampshadeHanging I think you'll find his insight on the male preoccupation with size quite interesting.]]"

Top