Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ThatManIsDead

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In El Filibusterimo, the follow-up to Jose Rizal's Noli me Tangere, Juan Crisostomo Ibarra returns to the Philippines under the name Simoun. The former goody-two shoes ilustrado is now a terrorist. Lovely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Harvey Dent in ''Batman'' nowdays won't respond to his birth name. He insists on being called Two-Face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->“Your name is—.â€ï¿½ The name I used then is not important anymore. I will let it die.

to:

-->“Your name is—.â€ï¿½ â€? The name I used then is not important anymore. I will let it die.




to:

* When confronted in DragonAge: Origins, Wynne will claim the [[DemonicPossession abomination]] Uldred has [[YoureInsane gone mad]]. In response, he chuckles and says "Uldred? He is gone! I am Uldred and not Uldred. I am MORE than he was."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Inverted in the current ''DoomPatrol''; the current incarnation of the Negative Man insists that he ''is'' Larry, even though he secretly suspects he's just an energy being who happens to have Larry's memories.

Added: 151

Changed: 39

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*General Grevous in ''DarthAndDroids'':
-->'''Obi-Wan''': Oh my god. You were once [[spoiler:Valorum, the Chancellor]].\\
'''Grevous''': Irrelevent! That name no longer has any meaning for me.

Added: 248

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In "{{Going Postal}}", Albert Spangler died, but Moist von Lipwig woke up in Vetinari's office. Mind you, that was VERY forced as Moist never wanted to stop being Albert, but what can you do when an Angel presents himself?

to:

* In "{{Going Postal}}", ''Discworld/{{Going Postal}}'', Albert Spangler died, but Moist von Lipwig woke up in Vetinari's office. Mind you, that was VERY forced as Moist never wanted to stop being Albert, but what can you do when an Angel presents himself? himself?
**The stock phrase does crop up, though; when Vetinari causally points out that the money the gods left to Moist ''just happens'' to be equal to the estimated haul of a noted fraudster, Moist replies "Albert Spangler? They hanged him. I was there."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ScoobyDooMysteryInc''. Unfortunately...:
-->'''Fred''': Daphne! Now I need to talk to her!\\
'''Daphne''': Daphne's gone, call me Crush.\\
'''Fred''': Darn it, lady, I'm serious! Where is she?\\
'''Daphne''': Fred, it's me, okay?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "'Frank'? Who's 'Frank'?" (generally only for the insane)

to:

* "'Frank'? Who's 'Frank'?" (generally only for the insane)
insane)
* "Clark's not here... he never was." if the person everyone thought they knew was a mask.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** You can also invoke it literally when attempting to convince Samantha (a friend from your living days) that you're not...you.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: However, this became an aversion in a later episode when Clayface saw the error of his ways and became Ethan Bennett again]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->'''Venkman:''' ''I want to talk to Dana now, okay? Dana.''
->'''Dana/Zuul:''' '''[[EvilSoundsDeep THERE IS NO DANA; ONLY ZUUL]].'''
->'''Venkman:''' ''[[DeadpanSnarker What a lovely singing voice you must have!]]''
--->-- ''{{Ghostbusters}}''

to:

->'''Venkman:''' ''I want to talk to Dana now, okay? Dana.-->'''[[TheDon Carl Grissom]]:''' ''Jack, listen! Maybe we can cut a deal!''
-->'''TheJoker:''' ''Jack? Jack is dead, my friend. You can call me... Joker. And as you can see, I'm a lot happier.
''
->'''Dana/Zuul:''' '''[[EvilSoundsDeep THERE IS NO DANA; ONLY ZUUL]].'''
->'''Venkman:''' ''[[DeadpanSnarker What a lovely singing voice you must have!]]''
--->-- ''{{Ghostbusters}}''
-->--''{{Film/Batman}}''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Anakin/Vader puts himself in the "still redeemable" category shortly afterward when he responds to Luke's continued pleas with a sad, "It is too late for me, son."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->Don't call me Christopher! That name no longer has meaning to me! Christopher Reeve was someone who lived his life in a wheelchair, always relying on others to help him. The old Christopher Reeve is dead. From now on, I am... '''''Chris!'''''

to:

-->Don't call me Christopher! That name no longer has meaning to me! Christopher Reeve was someone who lived his life in a wheelchair, always relying on others to help him. [[HarsherInHindsight The old Christopher Reeve is dead. dead.]] From now on, I am... '''''Chris!'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also ImNotKakarotto, when one forsakes not just his name, but his very culture and ''heritage'' in favor of a kinder and more noble one.

to:

See also ImNotKakarotto, when one forsakes not just his name, but his very culture and ''heritage'' in favor of a kinder and more noble one.
Compare DoNotCallMePaul.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:{{Theatre}}]]
* Played with in ''ManOfLaMancha''. After Alonso Quijana/Don Quixote dies, Aldonza says:
-->'''Aldonza''': A man died. He seemed a good man, but I did not know him.\\
'''Sancho''': But--\\
'''Aldonza''': Don Quixote is not dead. Believe, Sancho, believe.\\
'''Sancho''' (in confused hope): Aldonza?\\
'''Aldonza''': My name is Dulcinea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When Lieutenant John Dunbar of the United States of Army cooly tells his captors and former comrades in ''Lakota'' rather than English that "My name is DancesWithWolves, and I have nothing to say to you" when they offered him his life in return for betraying his new family, his transformation into a true American Indian is finally complete.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also ImNotKakarotto, when one forsakes not just his name, but his very culture and ''heritage.''

to:

See also ImNotKakarotto, when one forsakes not just his name, but his very culture and ''heritage.''''heritage'' in favor of a kinder and more noble one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


See also ImNotKakarotto, when one forsakes not just his name, but his very culture and ''heritage.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He's not the only one, either; Sandman, Rhino and Doctor Octopus all get That Man Is Dead moments.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''ZenAndTheArtOfMotorcycleMaintenance'' [[spoiler: the narrator says that Phaedrus is gone, killed by electric shock, and he seems to legitimately believe it. Unlike most examples, the narrator gives his ex-personality a different name than his own (which is not revealed).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* He doesn't take a new name, but [[{{Night}} Eliezer]] describes his [[{{Determinator}} spiritual hardening]] in these terms after he watches a cart dump children into a firepit. He's lucky enough to be spared, but ""[T]he student of the Talmud, the child that I was, had been consumed in the flames. There remained only a shape that looked like me."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
made the DMFA link in italics


* [[DanAndMabsFurryAdventures DMFA]] has a switch from CompleteMonster to RetiredCompleteMonster in this way, as the the phoenix oracles say that "The life of Destania has ended at the hands of Daniel Ti'Fiona" (the latter being her son). In a flahback shortly after Dan's birth, Destania says to her husband:

to:

* [[DanAndMabsFurryAdventures DMFA]] ''[[DanAndMabsFurryAdventures DMFA]]'' has a switch from CompleteMonster to RetiredCompleteMonster in this way, as the the phoenix oracles say that "The life of Destania has ended at the hands of Daniel Ti'Fiona" (the latter being her son). In a flahback shortly after Dan's birth, Destania says to her husband:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
made DMFA into a pot link to Dan And Mabs Furry Adventures


*DMFA has a switch from CompleteMonster to RetiredCompleteMonster in this way, as the the phoenix oracles say that "The life of Destania has ended at the hands of Daniel Ti'Fiona" (the latter being her son). In a flahback shortly after Dan's birth, Destania says to her husband:

to:

*DMFA * [[DanAndMabsFurryAdventures DMFA]] has a switch from CompleteMonster to RetiredCompleteMonster in this way, as the the phoenix oracles say that "The life of Destania has ended at the hands of Daniel Ti'Fiona" (the latter being her son). In a flahback shortly after Dan's birth, Destania says to her husband:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Most heroes in ''FreedomForce'' retain some ties to their original identity, but [[NinetiesAntiHero Tombstone]] completely refuses to be [[StevenUlyssesPerhero Nathan Graves]], as is observed when he's introduced.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* [[TheShining "Danny isn't here, Mrs. Torrance."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The original identity of the BigBad of ''{{Bleach}}'' "''[[BitchInSheepsClothing never even existed]]''".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''DrZhivago'': Strelnikov, the brutal [[RedsWithRockets Bolshevik commander]] who has his own [[LawOfChromaticSuperiority bright red war-train]]. No one has seen his face. Only... he's [[spoiler:the [[bishonen]] love interest, Pasha Antipov from earlier in the film]] who suffered a HeroicBSOD after [[spoiler:[[BusCrash being run over by Cossacks]]]]! Now he has GoodScarsEvilScars and no one may call him by his past name. But he [[YouWillBeSpared lets Dr. Zhivago live]] anyway.

to:

* ''DrZhivago'': Strelnikov, the brutal [[RedsWithRockets Bolshevik commander]] who has his own [[LawOfChromaticSuperiority bright red war-train]]. No one has seen his face. Only... he's [[spoiler:the [[bishonen]] {{bishonen}} love interest, Pasha Antipov from earlier in the film]] who suffered a HeroicBSOD after [[spoiler:[[BusCrash being run over by Cossacks]]]]! Now he has GoodScarsEvilScars and no one may call him by his past name. But he [[YouWillBeSpared lets Dr. Zhivago live]] anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''DrZhivago'': Strelnikov, the brutal [[RedsWithRockets Bolshevik commander]] who has his own [[LawOfChromaticSuperiority bright red war-train]]. No one has seen his face. Only... he's [[spoiler:the [[bishonen]] love interest, Pasha Antipov from earlier in the film]] who suffered a HeroicBSOD after [[spoiler:[[BusCrash being run over by Cossacks]]]]! Now he has GoodScarsEvilScars and no one may call him by his past name. But he [[YouShallBeSpared lets Dr. Zhivago live]] anyway.

to:

* ''DrZhivago'': Strelnikov, the brutal [[RedsWithRockets Bolshevik commander]] who has his own [[LawOfChromaticSuperiority bright red war-train]]. No one has seen his face. Only... he's [[spoiler:the [[bishonen]] love interest, Pasha Antipov from earlier in the film]] who suffered a HeroicBSOD after [[spoiler:[[BusCrash being run over by Cossacks]]]]! Now he has GoodScarsEvilScars and no one may call him by his past name. But he [[YouShallBeSpared [[YouWillBeSpared lets Dr. Zhivago live]] anyway.

Changed: 484

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''DrZhivago'': Strelnikov, the brutal [[RedsWithRockets Bolshevik commander]] who has his own [[LawOfChromaticSuperiority bright red war-train]]. No one has seen his face. Only... he's [[spoiler:the [[bishonen]] love interest, Pasha Antipov from earlier in the film]] who suffered a HeroicBSOD after [[spoiler:[[BusCrash being run over by Cossacks]]]]! Now he has GoodScarsEvilScars and no one may call him by his past name. But he [[YouShallBeSpared lets Dr. Zhivago live]] anyway.

Added: 232

Changed: 213

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Roger Smith''': Are you Michael Seebach?
-->'''Man in mummy bandages''': Michael Seebach has vanished from this world. Go and tell that to your masters!
-->'''Roger Smith''': All righ, so, what name you go by?
-->'''Man in mummy bandages''': By the time being, you can call me [[NietzscheWannabe Schwarzwald]].
-->'''Roger Smith''': Black Forrest?
-->'''Man in mummy bandages''': Report this to your masters: You can tell them ([[EvilLaugh Evil Laugh]]) that they will never see their darling reporter in this city again! ([[LaughingMad Deranged Evil Laugh]]).

to:

-->'''Roger Smith''': Are you Michael Seebach?
-->'''Man
Seebach?\\
'''Man
in mummy bandages''': Michael Seebach has vanished from this world. Go and tell that to your masters!
-->'''Roger
masters!\\
'''Roger
Smith''': All righ, right, so, what name you go by?
-->'''Man
by?\\
'''Man
in mummy bandages''': By the time being, you can call me [[NietzscheWannabe Schwarzwald]].
-->'''Roger
Schwarzwald]].\\
'''Roger
Smith''': Black Forrest?
-->'''Man
Forrest?\\
'''Man
in mummy bandages''': Report this to your masters: You can tell them ([[EvilLaugh Evil Laugh]]) that they will never see their darling reporter in this city again! ([[LaughingMad Deranged Evil Laugh]]).



--->'''Roger Smith''': We all know that newspaper reporter Michael Seebach no longer exists in this city
--->'''[[CorruptCorporateExecutive Paradigm Group Executive]]''': Michael Seebach is dead, but the agitator who calls himself Schwarzwald has returned.

to:

--->'''Roger -->'''Roger Smith''': We all know that newspaper reporter Michael Seebach no longer exists in this city
--->'''[[CorruptCorporateExecutive
city\\
'''[[CorruptCorporateExecutive
Paradigm Group Executive]]''': Michael Seebach is dead, but the agitator who calls himself Schwarzwald has returned.



--> '''Belldandy:''' No, Urd!
--> '''[=LOT=]!Urd:''' Urd...? She no longer exists, and that name is now forgotten.

to:

--> '''Belldandy:''' No, Urd!
-->
Urd!\\
'''[=LOT=]!Urd:''' Urd...? She no longer exists, and that name is now forgotten.



-->'''Green Arrow''': GreenLantern!
-->'''Hal Jordan''': Not Green Lantern, Arrow. Not anymore. I've taken the name Parallax.

to:

-->'''Green Arrow''': GreenLantern!
-->'''Hal
GreenLantern!\\
'''Hal
Jordan''': Not Green Lantern, Arrow. Not anymore. I've taken the name Parallax.



-->'''Spidey:''' "Brock..."
-->'''Venom:''' [Actually ''covers Spider-Man's mouth with his hands.'' It was cooler than it sounds.] "Stop calling us that! We are Venom now!"

to:

-->'''Spidey:''' "Brock..."
-->'''Venom:'''
"\\
'''Venom:'''
[Actually ''covers Spider-Man's mouth with his hands.'' It was cooler than it sounds.] "Stop calling us that! We are Venom now!"



*Adrian Chase also used a variant of this phrase in his reminiscence in Vigilante#50, feeling as if the bomb that slew his family and triggered his emergence as the Vigilante also slew him. However, Chase partially subverted the usual intent of the phrase, in that he maintained his work as New York district attorney and his dual identity as Adrian Chase during much of his tenure as the Vigilante.

to:

*Adrian Chase also used a variant of this phrase in his reminiscence in Vigilante#50, feeling as if the bomb that slew his family and triggered his emergence as the Vigilante also slew him. However, Chase partially subverted the usual intent of the phrase, in that he maintained his work as New York district attorney and his dual identity as Adrian Chase during much of his tenure as the Vigilante. \n
* ''[[TheLeagueOfExtraordinaryGentlemen League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: The Black Dossier]]'':
--> '''M''': "[[JamesBond Jim]], you can call me M. Behind my back, you can even call me [[TheAvengers Mother]]. But [[TheThirdMan Harry]]...Harry died a long time ago in the sewers under Vienna. Let's leave it like that, shall we?"



---> '''Jack''': Gonna be a lot of questions, whoever we run into...what do we tell them about you?
---> '''Riddick''': Tell them Riddick's dead. He died somewhere back on that planet.

to:

---> '''Jack''': Gonna be a lot of questions, whoever we run into...what do we tell them about you?
--->
you?\\
'''Riddick''': Tell them Riddick's dead. He died somewhere back on that planet.



-->'''River/''[[SpaceshipGirl Serenity]]''''': "I'm not on the ship. I'm in the ship. I am the ship."
-->'''Simon''': "River-"
-->'''River''': "River's gone."
-->'''Early''': "Then who exactly are we talking to?"
-->'''River''': "Talking to Serenity. And Early? ''[[CreepyMonotone Serenity is very unhappy]]''."

to:

-->'''River/''[[SpaceshipGirl Serenity]]''''': "I'm not on the ship. I'm in the ship. I am the ship."
-->'''Simon''': "River-"
-->'''River''':
"\\
'''Simon''': "River-"\\
'''River''':
"River's gone."
-->'''Early''':
"\\
'''Early''':
"Then who exactly are we talking to?"
-->'''River''':
to?"\\
'''River''':
"Talking to Serenity. And Early? ''[[CreepyMonotone Serenity is very unhappy]]''."



-->Pink isn't well, he stayed back at the hotel
-->And they sent us along as a surrogate band

to:

-->Pink isn't well, he stayed back at the hotel
-->And
hotel\\
And
they sent us along as a surrogate band



-->'''Yuffie''': I think you might've overdone it, Squall!
-->'''Leon''': It's ''Leon''.

to:

-->'''Yuffie''': I think you might've overdone it, Squall!
-->'''Leon''':
Squall!\\
'''Leon''':
It's ''Leon''.



-->'''Waspinator:''' Wasp... forgive Bumble-bot.
-->''(Bumblebee smiles hopefully)''
-->'''Waspinator:''' ... but ''Waspinator'' NEVER forgive!

to:

-->'''Waspinator:''' Wasp... forgive Bumble-bot.
-->''(Bumblebee
Bumble-bot.\\
''(Bumblebee
smiles hopefully)''
-->'''Waspinator:''' ...
hopefully)''\\
'''Waspinator:''' ...
but ''Waspinator'' NEVER forgive!



-->'''Vlad:''' You wouldn't turn your back on an old friend, would you?
-->'''Jack:''' An old friend, no. You? ''YES!''

to:

-->'''Vlad:''' You wouldn't turn your back on an old friend, would you?
-->'''Jack:'''
you?\\
'''Jack:'''
An old friend, no. You? ''YES!''



-->'''Sally''': "But you're the Pumpkin King!"
-->'''Jack''': "Not anymore!" *breaks picture* "I feel ''so'' much better now!"

to:

-->'''Sally''': "But you're the Pumpkin King!"
-->'''Jack''':
King!"\\
'''Jack''':
"Not anymore!" *breaks picture* "I feel ''so'' much better now!"



-->'''Grace''': "Harvey" *puts her hand on his arm*
-->'''Harvey''': *Looks away from her and pulls away* "My name is Two-Face now..."

to:

-->'''Grace''': "Harvey" *puts her hand on his arm*
-->'''Harvey''':
arm*\\
'''Harvey''':
*Looks away from her and pulls away* "My name is Two-Face now..."



-->'''Leela:''' I have to admit, I was afraid you wouldn't make it.
-->'''Fry:''' That was the old Fry. He's dead now.

to:

-->'''Leela:''' I have to admit, I was afraid you wouldn't make it.
-->'''Fry:'''
it.\\
'''Fry:'''
That was the old Fry. He's dead now.

Top