Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / MutantDraftBoard

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the StarWarsExpandedUniverse, during the time of the Sith Empire's war with the Old Republic, all Force-sensitives in the Empire are by law required to be given over to the Sith Academy to be trained to serve TheEmperor. The attempt of one droid-maker to keep her daughter out of the hands of the Sith is a major plot point in the novel ''Fatal Alliance''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*{{Traveller}} : Averted. It is illegal in the Imperium to have a psi school and presumably one can't accidently develop psi powers to the point where they are dangerous. Among the Zho, psis are an oligarchy and don't need such things. An AlternativeCharacterInterpretation might be that they are a MutantDraftBoard that existed so long that it is the essence of the ruling class.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
\"Darwinist\" has been renamed to \"The Social Darwinist\"


At one level this makes some sense. The sudden presence of [[PsychicPowers telepaths, telekinetics, teleporters, phasers, etc]]. could throw society into chaos as long held concepts of privacy and security might be in danger of being thrown onto the scrap heap. But the new organization will almost always [[DrunkWithPower go overboard]] as it was initially formed out of [[GullibleLemmings panic]]. The normals who control the organization will start to see the supers as [[PersonOfMassDestruction weapons or tools to be exploited]]. Eventually an organization composed mainly of superhuman mutants may [[TranshumanTreachery start looking at the normals around it as an impediment]] to their [[{{Darwinist}} natural supremacy]]. Things will [[ItGotWorse go rapidly downhill from there]].

to:

At one level this makes some sense. The sudden presence of [[PsychicPowers telepaths, telekinetics, teleporters, phasers, etc]]. could throw society into chaos as long held concepts of privacy and security might be in danger of being thrown onto the scrap heap. But the new organization will almost always [[DrunkWithPower go overboard]] as it was initially formed out of [[GullibleLemmings panic]]. The normals who control the organization will start to see the supers as [[PersonOfMassDestruction weapons or tools to be exploited]]. Eventually an organization composed mainly of superhuman mutants may [[TranshumanTreachery start looking at the normals around it as an impediment]] to their [[{{Darwinist}} [[SocialDarwinist natural supremacy]]. Things will [[ItGotWorse go rapidly downhill from there]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Many versions ''do'' keep it voluntary, however; ''UltimateXMen'' has Professor Xavier asking characters no more than once if they would like to join up, then leaving them completely alone, even when they've fought alongside them in the past (Dazzler is a good example). He only seems to insist that they stick around if they've actually been official members of the team for some time (such as Beast). In the X-Men's second incarnation, Professor Xavier is seen offering several characters a chance to join up (including Colossus, Nightcrawler, and Wolverine), and although they all accept, nothing indicates he would have pestered them had they not done so. (In the case of Nightcrawler, for example, he isn't even physically present).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Changed: 867

Removed: 580

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** "The Initiative" shows its strong arm tendencies in the very first issue. A girl (mutant?) called Cloud 9, who can fly and control a thick cloud like substance, is caught by War Machine who proceeds to tell her to join or he'll blow away the cloud she's flying on, WHILE SHE'S A THOUSAND FEET IN THE AIR!
*** Here's an idea people, don't name your evil organizations to control that which you don't understand or trust after [[TooDumbToLive evil organizations to control that]] [[ShoutOut which you don't understand or trust from ]] [[BuffyTheVampireSlayer works of fiction]].



** This was part of the point of sharing the power among thousands of Slayers, avoiding the "girl with the weight of the world thrust on her shoulders" setup of the past. With so many Slayers, some of them are bound to ''want'' to be full-time world-savers, and the rest can live more normally than Buffy did.
*** Though, when you think about it, it would make sense for some spells to be made more powerful with a Slayer sacrifice not to mention the fact that Slayer blood is said to give a [[OurVampiresAreDifferent Vamp]] a sort of high. Those who don't join lack both backup and a Watcher. In other words, they disappear and nobody notices. To sum it up, don't join and you're easy pickings for a Vamp or evil Magic user.

to:

** This was part of * A relatively benevolent form appears in ''JudgeDredd'' - any and all psychics found are rounded up and enrolled in the point Academy of sharing the power among thousands of Slayers, avoiding the "girl with the weight of the world thrust on her shoulders" setup of the past. With Law so many Slayers, some of them are bound to ''want'' to be full-time world-savers, and the rest can live more normally than Buffy did.
*** Though, when you think about it, it would make sense for some spells to be made more powerful with a Slayer sacrifice not to mention the fact
that Slayer blood is said their powers can be used to give a [[OurVampiresAreDifferent Vamp]] a sort of high. fight crime. Those who don't join lack both backup and a Watcher. In other words, they disappear and nobody notices. To sum it up, don't join and you're easy pickings for a Vamp or evil Magic user.
that fail to qualify are allowed to live as normal citizens, but must register as psychics.



* [[StarWars The Jedi Order]] averts this trope. Not all force users are expected to join it, and leaving is allowed, though their indoctrination from childhood means that only twenty masters have (legitimately) left over the thousand generations of the Order's existence. (Of course, Dark Jedi and Sith aren't counted as having left "legitimately", and no information is given on Knights or Padawans.)

to:

* [[StarWars The Jedi Order]] Order in ''StarWars'' averts this trope. Not all force Force users are expected to join it, and leaving is allowed, though their indoctrination from childhood means that only twenty masters have (legitimately) left over the thousand generations of the Order's existence. (Of course, Dark Jedi and Sith aren't counted as having left "legitimately", and no information is given on Knights or Padawans.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Though, when you think about it, it would make sense for some spells to be made more powerful with a Slayer sacrifice not to mention the fact that Slayer blood is said to give a [[OurVampiresAreDifferent Vamp]] a sort of high. Those who don't join lack both backup and a Watcher. In other words, they disappear and nobody notices. To sum it up, don't join and you're easy pickings for a Vamp or evil Magic user.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Here's an idea people, don't name your evil organizations to control that which you don't understand or trust after [[TooDumbToLive evil organizations to control that]] [[ShoutOut which you don't understand or trust from ]] [[BuffyTheVampireSlayer works of fiction]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
schpelling


* Averted in ''BuffyTheVampireSlayer Season Eight''. While Buffy's Slayer organization tries to persuade new Slayers to join, they don't force them to do so, and allow them to slay independently or as an extracirricular activity. They're less nice about Slayers who misuse their powers, like Simone or Gigi, of course.

to:

* Averted in ''BuffyTheVampireSlayer Season Eight''. While Buffy's Slayer organization tries to persuade new Slayers to join, they don't force them to do so, and allow them to slay independently or as an extracirricular extracurricular activity. They're less nice about Slayers who misuse their powers, like Simone or Gigi, of course.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
4400

Added DiffLines:

** And by the end of the show, [[spoiler: half of Seattle has superpowers including almost everyone in NTAC.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This does not stop Apostates and mercenary mages from being dreadfully common, and sometimes absurdly more powerful than mages with formal training.

to:

** This does not stop Apostates and mercenary mages from being dreadfully common, and sometimes absurdly more powerful than mages with formal training. And several members of the Circle are semi-openly cooperating with the illegal mages.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In CthulhuTech, all [[PsychicPowers parapsychics]] (people born with innate abilities, which can range from mind control to having control over gravity) have to register with the [[StateSec Office of Internal Security]], be tested, are subjected to survielence, and if their powers are deemed [[MindRape Invasive]] or Dangerous, they have to wear badges in public to inform people of it. On the other hand, looking at [[CosmicHorrorStory what kind of place]] the Cthulhutech setting is, it's fairly justified.
* WhiteWolf 's ''{{Aberrant}}'' has Project Utopia, who do this very subtly--they're just helpful folks who want to teach you how to control your superpowers and use them for good. Except that they also sterilize you so you don't make more little superhumans and (largely out of ignorance) persuade you to overuse your powers, causing bad mutations and insanity. And they're the good guys.
** Very debatably the good guys. The morality of the setting is far too [[GrayAndGreyMorality gray]] for that.

to:

* In CthulhuTech, all [[PsychicPowers parapsychics]] (people born with innate abilities, which can range from mind control to having control over gravity) have to register with the [[StateSec Office of Internal Security]], be tested, are subjected to survielence, and if their powers are deemed [[MindRape Invasive]] or Dangerous, they have to wear badges in public to inform people of it. In addition, [[GravityMaster gravikinetics]] ''are'' forced to join the NEG or die; they're just too dangerous to leave off a leash. On the other hand, looking at [[CosmicHorrorStory what kind of place]] the Cthulhutech setting is, it's fairly justified.
* WhiteWolf 's ''{{Aberrant}}'' has Project Utopia, who do this very subtly--they're just helpful folks who want to teach you how to control your superpowers and use them for good. Except that they also sterilize you so you don't make more little superhumans and (largely out of ignorance) persuade you to overuse your powers, causing bad mutations and insanity. And they're the good guys.
** Very debatably the good guys. The morality of the setting is far too [[GrayAndGreyMorality gray]] for that.
insanity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Talents don't usually force people in, but they apply fairly aggressive recruitment tactics.


* AnneMcCaffrey's Talents (from the Pegasus and Tower series) avert this in that they don't force anyone to join if they don't want to. No one (mentioned in the books, at least) has actually refused to join when offered, although in a couple of cases, it takes either outright bribes (Jeff Raven) or an appeal to the Talent's more mercenary side (Tirla, who enticed with the promise of all the pretty things and food she wants.) The benefits of being a registered Talent outweigh any drawbacks, to the extent that many people are disappointed that they aren't Talents.

to:

* AnneMcCaffrey's Talents Center, and its successor Federated Telepath & Teleport (from the Pegasus and Tower series) avert this in that they ''generally'' don't force actually ''force'' anyone to join if they don't want to. to, but they do apply a significant amount of pressure and gain legal jurisdiction over all Talents, member or not. No one (mentioned in the books, at least) has actually refused to join when offered, although in a couple of cases, it takes either outright bribes (Jeff Raven) or an appeal to the Talent's more mercenary side (Tirla, who was enticed with the promise of all the pretty things and food she wants.) wants), and it was never presented as an option for the Rowan (who was raised in an FT&T school and groomed to be a Prime virtually from birth). The benefits of being a registered Talent outweigh any drawbacks, to the extent that many people are disappointed that they aren't Talents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
De-nattering.


** They may be mild-mannered when it comes to recruitment, but whether the Order and its policies are benevolent is another question entirely.
*** Not in the films. This applies only in the Expanded Universe, and even then, many consider it to be DisContinuity -- including this troper.
**** And the other 99% don't.
*** Actually, Count Dukuu left the order legitimately in order to claim his place as an heir of some sort, so it IS continuity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->"Somewhere on Beta colony there is an institution. In one room of the institution there is a man who spends his days and nights screaming at things that only he can see. Things we planted in his mind. They have to keep him in a straight jacket 24 hours a day or he'll claw his own eyes out just to make it stop."

to:

-->"Somewhere on Beta colony there is an institution. In one room of the institution there is a man who spends his days and nights screaming at things that only he can see. Things we planted in his mind. They have to keep him in a straight jacket straitjacket 24 hours a day or he'll claw his own eyes out just to make it stop."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rewording to make it sound better.


* TheDresdenFiles: White Council is this if you've got enough magical talent. See the White Council won't bother if you're too magically weak to do much. Magic can be stumbled into though, and if you're powerful enough you might stumble into it by breaking one of the 7 Laws. MindControl is against one of the laws and very easy to do, and very tempting for teenagers in hormones throws to do, even if they think they are doing a minor act of charity in keeping a friend off drugs. All 7 laws exist for a reason, in part that breaking one leads to breaking another due to the addictive nature of black magic. So all 7 laws have the death penalty if you're caught breaking them, even if you never knew of the White Council or anyone else who could do magic. There's not enough recruiters out there to find most potential Wizards leading the world to kinda suck.

to:

* TheDresdenFiles: The White Council is this if you've got enough magical talent. See the White Council in ''TheDresdenFiles''. They won't bother you if you're too magically weak to do much. Magic can be stumbled into though, and if you're powerful enough you might stumble into it The problem is, someone with a lot of power who just happens upon magic by breaking one of accident isn't going to know about the 7 Laws. MindControl is against one Laws of Magic. It's quite possible to break some of them with the laws and very easy best of intentions-- messing with someone's head to do, and very tempting for teenagers in hormones throws to do, even if they think they are doing a minor act of charity in get them off drugs or magically keeping a friend off drugs. All someone alive long enough for an ambulance to get there is good, right? But all 7 laws exist for a reason, reason: BlackMagic in part that ''any'' form is addictive, and breaking one leads is a slippery slope to breaking another due to the addictive nature of black magic. rest. So all 7 laws have you get the death penalty if you're caught breaking violating any them, even if you you'd never knew even heard of the White Council or anyone else who could do magic. There's not enough recruiters out there to find most potential Wizards wizards, leading the world to [[CrapsackWorld kinda suck.
suck]].



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''MassEffect'', Kaidan, a member of humanity's first generation of [[MindOverMatter biotics]], reveals that when news of the BizarreBabyBoom first went public, a military corporation called Conatix "encouraged" all human biotics to go through TrainingFromHell at the hands of hired turian mercenaries. He even implies that Conatix may have deliberately engineered [[AppliedPhlebotinum element zero]] spills to expose pregnant women and create more biotics, but he admits the evidence is merely circumstantial. This practice ceased [[spoiler: when Kaidan killed a particularly sadistic instructor at Jump Zero]], and the Ascension Project was founded. While biotics are no longer required to join the Alliance military, their whereabouts are still monitored, and they're given preferential recruitment in the corps because of their rarity.

to:

* In ''MassEffect'', Kaidan, a member of humanity's first generation of [[MindOverMatter biotics]], reveals that when news of the BizarreBabyBoom first went public, a military corporation called Conatix "encouraged" "[[DoubleSpeak encouraged]]" all human biotics to go through TrainingFromHell at the hands of hired turian mercenaries. He even implies that Conatix may have deliberately engineered [[AppliedPhlebotinum element zero]] spills to expose pregnant women and create more biotics, but he admits the evidence is merely circumstantial. This practice ceased [[spoiler: when Kaidan killed a particularly sadistic instructor at Jump Zero]], and the Ascension Project was founded. While biotics are no longer required to join the Alliance military, their whereabouts are still monitored, and they're given preferential recruitment in the corps because of their rarity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''MassEffect'', Kaidan, a member of humanity's first generation of biotics, reveals that when news of the BizzareBabyBoom first went public, a military corporation called Conatix "encouraged" all human biotics to go through TrainingFromHell at the hands of hired turian mercenaries. He even implies that Conatix may have deliberately engineered [[AppliedPhlebotinum element zero]] spills to expose pregnant women and create more biotics, but he admits the evidence is merely circumstantial. This practice ceased [[spoiler: when Kaidan killed a particularly sadistic instructor at Jump Zero]], and the Ascension Project was founded. While biotics are no longer required to join the Alliance military, their whereabouts are still monitored, and they're given preferential recruitment in the corps because of their rarity.

to:

* In ''MassEffect'', Kaidan, a member of humanity's first generation of biotics, [[MindOverMatter biotics]], reveals that when news of the BizzareBabyBoom BizarreBabyBoom first went public, a military corporation called Conatix "encouraged" all human biotics to go through TrainingFromHell at the hands of hired turian mercenaries. He even implies that Conatix may have deliberately engineered [[AppliedPhlebotinum element zero]] spills to expose pregnant women and create more biotics, but he admits the evidence is merely circumstantial. This practice ceased [[spoiler: when Kaidan killed a particularly sadistic instructor at Jump Zero]], and the Ascension Project was founded. While biotics are no longer required to join the Alliance military, their whereabouts are still monitored, and they're given preferential recruitment in the corps because of their rarity.

Changed: 571

Removed: 199

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Stop saying something is a subversion when it is not.


* Talking with Kaidan in ''MassEffect'' implies that a corporation called Conatix rounded up all human biotics to go through TrainingFromHell at the hands of hired turian mercenaries, and possibly deliberately exposing pregnant women to [[AppliedPhlebotinum element zero]]. This practice ceased [[spoiler: when Kaidan killed a particularly sadistic instructor at Jump Zero]].
** MassEffect actually subverts this in that, while FantasticRacism makes it difficult for biotics to get non-military jobs, they are given preferential treatment in the military due to their rarity.

to:

* Talking with Kaidan in ''MassEffect'' implies In ''MassEffect'', Kaidan, a member of humanity's first generation of biotics, reveals that when news of the BizzareBabyBoom first went public, a military corporation called Conatix rounded up "encouraged" all human biotics to go through TrainingFromHell at the hands of hired turian mercenaries, and possibly mercenaries. He even implies that Conatix may have deliberately exposing pregnant women to engineered [[AppliedPhlebotinum element zero]]. zero]] spills to expose pregnant women and create more biotics, but he admits the evidence is merely circumstantial. This practice ceased [[spoiler: when Kaidan killed a particularly sadistic instructor at Jump Zero]].
** MassEffect actually subverts this in that, while FantasticRacism makes it difficult for
Zero]], and the Ascension Project was founded. While biotics to get non-military jobs, they are no longer required to join the Alliance military, their whereabouts are still monitored, and they're given preferential treatment recruitment in the military due to corps because of their rarity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Expanded B5 example

Added DiffLines:

**** Also note that Kevin Vacit, who was head of Psi Corps while technically being a rogue telepath himself, had a daughter who he deliberately gave away to be raised by other rogue telepaths, because he didn't want his own kid to be exposed to what he was planning to do with the Corps. Puts a whole new twist on "The Corps is Mother, The Corps is Father", doesn't it? Vacit's daughter, Fiona Temple, was the mother of Stephen Kevin Dexter, more commonly known as the Psi Cop Alfred Bester.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** And boy, do they need them, as the Black Tower has been doing a non-stop recruitment drive from when it was first founded, and has about three times the numbers of the White Tower.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** And the other 99% don't.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Actually, Count Dukuu left the order legitimately in order to claim his place as an heir of some sort, so it IS continuity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This was part of the point of sharing the power among thousands of Slayers, avoiding the "girl with the weight of the world thrust on her shoulders" setup of the past. With so many Slayers, some of them are bound to ''want'' to slay, and the rest can do whatever.

to:

** This was part of the point of sharing the power among thousands of Slayers, avoiding the "girl with the weight of the world thrust on her shoulders" setup of the past. With so many Slayers, some of them are bound to ''want'' to slay, be full-time world-savers, and the rest can do whatever.
live more normally than Buffy did.

Changed: 266

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** This was part of the point of sharing the power among thousands of Slayers, avoiding the "girl with the weight of the world thrust on her shoulders" setup of the past. With so many Slayers, some of them are bound to ''want'' to slay, and the rest can do whatever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In this game's ''Going Rogue'' expansion, in the Praetorian Earth parallel world, all metahumans are drafted into the empire's Powers Division. All player characters who start in Praetorian Earth start as new members of Powers Division.

to:

** In this game's ''Going Rogue'' expansion, in the Praetorian Earth parallel world, all metahumans are drafted into the empire's Powers Division. All player characters who start in Praetorian Earth start as new members of Powers Division.
Division. [[spoiler: They may also secretly join the Resistance. Or not.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** In this game's ''Going Rogue'' expansion, in the Praetorian Earth parallel world, all metahumans are drafted into the empire's Powers Division. All player characters who start in Praetorian Earth start as new members of Powers Division.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This does not stop Apostates and mercenary mages from being dreadfully common, and sometimes absurdly more powerful than mages with formal training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Slightly tweaked? Compulsory membership is the heart of the trope.


* AnneMcCaffrey's Talents (from the Pegasus and Tower series) operate one of the rare benevolent and righteous versions of this. It ''is'' slightly tweaked, in that they don't force anyone to join if they don't want to. No one (mentioned in the books, at least) has actually refused to join when offered, although in a couple of cases, it takes either outright bribes (Jeff Raven) or an appeal to the Talent's more mercenary side (Tirla, who enticed with the promise of all the pretty things and food she wants.) The benefits of being a registered Talent outweigh any drawbacks, to the extent that many people are disappointed that they aren't Talents.

to:

* AnneMcCaffrey's Talents (from the Pegasus and Tower series) operate one of the rare benevolent and righteous versions of this. It ''is'' slightly tweaked, avert this in that they don't force anyone to join if they don't want to. No one (mentioned in the books, at least) has actually refused to join when offered, although in a couple of cases, it takes either outright bribes (Jeff Raven) or an appeal to the Talent's more mercenary side (Tirla, who enticed with the promise of all the pretty things and food she wants.) The benefits of being a registered Talent outweigh any drawbacks, to the extent that many people are disappointed that they aren't Talents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Psi Corps from ''BabylonFive'' was the former TropeNamer, back when the page was called TheCorpsIsMother after their expression "The Corps is Mother, the Corps is Father". Psi Corps controls all human telepaths and telekinetics, demanding from them Corps membership, imprisonment or a life on suppressive drugs that cause depression. Many telepaths opt to head for the depths of space.

to:

* Psi Corps from ''BabylonFive'' was the former TropeNamer, back when the page was called TheCorpsIsMother after their expression "The Corps is Mother, the Corps is Father". Psi Corps controls all human telepaths and telekinetics, demanding from them Corps membership, imprisonment imprisonment, or a life on suppressive drugs that cause depression. Many telepaths opt to head for the depths of space.



** The attempt to control telepaths through this organization rather backfired though. Quite quickly they decided they were superior and to take over the world. [[NiceJobBreakingItHero Good job on gathering them all into a convenient group so they can form conspiracies easily]].

to:

** The attempt to control telepaths through this organization rather backfired though. Quite quickly they decided they were superior and to take over the world. [[NiceJobBreakingItHero Good job on gathering them all into a convenient group so they can form conspiracies easily]]. For the Psi Cops, hunting rogue telepaths isn't about serving or protecting mundane society like the propaganda says, it's because no one in their creepy "family" is allowed to leave.

Top