Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ItIsDehumanizing

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This isn't exclusive to Portable.


* Happens in a way in ''VideoGame/Persona3 Portable'' where [[RobotGirl Aigis]] corrects Yukari referring to her as a girl because, well, she's a robot. However, this is used to show how unlike a human she is. At first, at least. Later on, she starts to refer to herself as a "she".

to:

* Happens in a way in ''VideoGame/Persona3 Portable'' ''VideoGame/Persona3'' where [[RobotGirl Aigis]] corrects Yukari referring to her as a girl because, well, she's a robot. However, this is used to show how unlike a human she is. At first, at least. Later on, she starts to refer to herself as a "she".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

** In "The Body", Buffy refers to Joyce as "the body". She is horrified at herself for referring to her deceased mother that way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/BaldursGateIII:''
** The mage Lorroakan refers to "the Nightsong" and "it", despite both of you knowing she's an aasimar called Dame Aylin, and plans to imprison her permanently so he can steal her immortality for himself.
** Subverted with Omeluum, a [[TokenHeroicOrc benevolent mind flayer]] whose pronoun is "it", and whose research partner Blurg therefore means no disrespect by referring to it that way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

** Buffy at first referred to Dawn as "it" after finding out that she is not really human.

Added: 94

Changed: 44

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


** The serial killer Garland Greene is referred to as "that".

to:

** The And there is serial killer Garland Greene Greene's iconic introduction.
--->'''Johnny''': "What the fuck
is referred to as "that".''that''?"
--->'''Starkey''': "That's Garland Greene, man."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


** The serial killer Garland Greene is referred to three times as "that".

to:

** The serial killer Garland Greene is referred to three times as "that".



--->'''The First''': "Not "it". ''Me''."

to:

--->'''The First''': "Not Not "it". ''Me''."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Webcomic/{{Freefall}}'': The Mayor and Mr. Kornada (as seen in the page image) call Florence 'it' because, as an UpliftedAnimal, she's an ArtificialIntelligence product rather than a [[WhatMeasureIsANonHuman legal person]]. The Mayor comes to see the error of her ways, but Mr. Kornada is [[ItsAllAboutMe far too self-centered]] to see ''other humans'' as people, never mind an AI.

to:

* ''Webcomic/{{Freefall}}'': The Mayor and Mr. Kornada (as seen in the page image) call Florence 'it' because, as an UpliftedAnimal, she's an ArtificialIntelligence product rather than a [[WhatMeasureIsANonHuman legal person]]. The Mayor comes to see the error of her ways, but Mr. Kornada is [[ItsAllAboutMe far too self-centered]] to see ''other humans'' as people, never mind an AI.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''The First''': "Not "it". ''Me''."

to:

-->'''The --->'''The First''': "Not "it". ''Me''."

Added: 448

Changed: 265

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* In ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'', the Initiative refers to vampires as "it". Of course, vampires aren't human anyway, but everyone else uses gender-specific pronouns, and since vampires otherwise appear to be human, it would take a bit of mental training to think of one as an "it" by default.

to:

* In ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'', the ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'':
** The
Initiative refers to vampires as "it". Of course, vampires aren't human anyway, but everyone else uses gender-specific pronouns, and since vampires otherwise appear to be human, it would take a bit of mental training to think of one as an "it" by default.default.
** The First is mentioned a couple of times in season seven by the ArcWords "From beneath you, it devours". Until "Conversations With Dead People".
-->'''The First''': "Not "it". ''Me''."

Added: 110

Changed: 161

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* Cleopatra in ''Series/{{Rome}}'' uses "it" to refer to her brother/husband's eunuch advisers.
-->"It must not speak. It must die!"

to:

* ''Series/{{Rome}}'':
** Slaves are treated as objects and are referred to in neutral terms.
**
Cleopatra in ''Series/{{Rome}}'' uses "it" to refer to her brother/husband's eunuch advisers.
-->"It --->"It must not speak. It must die!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

** Arya refers to herself as "a girl" as part of her training as a Faceless Man. When she breaks free of them, she says that "A girl is Arya Stark and I'm going home".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


** Johnny-23 asks "What the fuck is that?" when he first sees the serial killer Garland Greene.

to:

** Johnny-23 asks "What the fuck is that?" when he first sees the The serial killer Garland Greene.Greene is referred to three times as "that".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* In ''Film/ConAir'', Falzone finds Poe's picture of his daughter.
-->'''Falzone''': "What's this shit?"
-->'''Poe''': "That's my daughter".

to:

* In ''Film/ConAir'', ''Film/ConAir'':
**
Falzone finds refers to the picture of Poe's picture of his daughter.
-->'''Falzone''': "What's this shit?"
-->'''Poe''': "That's my daughter".
daughter as "this shit".
** Johnny-23 asks "What the fuck is that?" when he first sees the serial killer Garland Greene.

Added: 259

Changed: 105

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* In the ''Series/{{Angel}}'' episode "[[Recap/AngelS01E13She She]]", male demons from a NoWomansLand refer to females as "it".

to:

* ''Series/{{Angel}}''
**
In the ''Series/{{Angel}}'' episode "[[Recap/AngelS01E13She She]]", male demons from a NoWomansLand refer to females as "it"."it".
** In "A Hole in the World", Knox accidentally outs himself as a worshipper of Illyria by referring to Fred (whose body he has used to house the elder god) as "It".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/ConAir'', Falzone finds Poe's picture of his daughter.
-->'''Falzone''': "What's this shit?"
-->'''Poe''': "That's my daughter".


Added DiffLines:

* In ''Series/HotelDelLuna'', Man-Wol hears from Sanchez that Chan-Sung's girlfriend has arrived from the US. Man-Wol asks again "''What'' arrived?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* Cleopatra in ''Series/{{Rome}}'' uses "it" to refer to her brother/husband's eunuch advisers.
-->"It must not speak. It must die!"

Added: 396

Changed: 60

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* ''Series/ColdCase'':
** Daniela is called "that", "this", and "thing" by Chris's father after finding out that she is trans.
** In "Forever Blue", Jimmy describes his gay attraction to Coop as a "curse" and a "thing".



* ''Series/GameOfThrones'': Reek is constantly referred to as a "pet" and a "creature".

to:

* ''Series/GameOfThrones'': ''Series/GameOfThrones'':
**
Reek is constantly referred to as a "pet" and a "creature".


Added DiffLines:

** Lord Randyll Tarly is furious at his son Samwell for being with the wildling girl Gilly. He refers to her as "it".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/HollowKnight'': Everyone who knows the protagonist's nature, including [[spoiler:their own mother]], refers to them as an "it" when interacting with them. The same goes for [[spoiler:all other Vessels in the game aside from the protagonist, including the titular Hollow Knight]]. This is a plot point as [[spoiler: They were made in an attempt to [[SealedInsideAPersonShapedCan seal the Radiance in a bug-shaped can]], and in order for that to work they had to be [[EmptyShell completely hollow]] so she couldn't influence them. If they were treated as people, then they might get the idea that they were people with wills and desires of their own, and that would leave a weakness for the Radiance to exploit. The current Hollow Knight had such an "idea instilled" because the Pale King raised them as his child, which is why the Black Egg Temple is a LeakingCanOfEvil.]]

to:

* ''VideoGame/HollowKnight'': Everyone who knows the protagonist's nature, including [[spoiler:their own mother]], refers to them as an "it" when interacting with them. The same goes for [[spoiler:all other Vessels in the game aside from the protagonist, including the titular Hollow Knight]]. This is a plot point as [[spoiler: They they were made in an attempt to [[SealedInsideAPersonShapedCan seal the Radiance in a bug-shaped can]], and in order for that to work they had to be [[EmptyShell completely hollow]] so she couldn't influence them. If they were treated as people, then they might get the idea that they were people with wills and desires of their own, and that would leave a weakness for the Radiance to exploit. The current Hollow Knight had such an "idea instilled" because the Pale King raised them it as his child, which is why the Black Egg Temple is a LeakingCanOfEvil.LeakingCanOfEvil... The narrative also leans towards the position that [[WellIntentionedExtremist The Pale King]]'s solution to the Radiance and her infection was untenable: A being ''cannot be'' completely hollow, and attempting to keep a being hollow amounts to nothing aside from acts of pointless cruelty and dehumanization that no-one should have to go through. Better, then, to seek a different solution.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* In Hungarian, there are no gendered pronouns. The pronouns most times aren't even even said out loud, and only present when the subject is really important to the speaker, who wants to stress it, otherwise it is implied by the form or desinence of the verb. In chase of inanimate objects or animals (where an English user would use "it"), the pronoun is almost always implied, only present when there is no other way to form a grammatically correct sentence. However keeping the subject hidden is not dehumanizing or disrespectful when talking about people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Averted in the case of Solas; he repeatedly calls a particular spirit "it" while making it clear he considers the spirit very much a person and a dear friend. He just doesn't believe in assigning it a gender. Interestingly enough, Solas refers to Cole as "he".

to:

*** Averted in the case of Solas; he repeatedly calls a particular spirit "it" while making it clear he considers the spirit very much a person and a dear friend. He just doesn't believe in assigning it a gender. Interestingly enough, Solas refers to Cole as "he"."he", possibly because Solas sees Cole as having gained a gender when he took human form.



* ''VideoGame/HollowKnight'': Everyone who knows the protagonist's nature, including [[spoiler:their own mother]], refers to them as an "it" when interacting with them. The same goes for [[spoiler:all other Vessels in the game aside from the protagonist, including the titular Hollow Knight]]. This is a plot point as they [[spoiler:were all created to be perfect and pure empty voids containing no minds to think with, no wills to break, and no voices to cry suffering. All to be as hollow as possible, to better serve as containers for [[MysticalPlague the infection]]. The reason the Hollow Knight failed as a container was because it was tainted by "an idea instilled": The Pale King, the creator of the Vessels, failed to completely dehumanize it, coming to regard the Hollow Knight as his child]].

to:

* ''VideoGame/HollowKnight'': Everyone who knows the protagonist's nature, including [[spoiler:their own mother]], refers to them as an "it" when interacting with them. The same goes for [[spoiler:all other Vessels in the game aside from the protagonist, including the titular Hollow Knight]]. This is a plot point as [[spoiler: They were made in an attempt to [[SealedInsideAPersonShapedCan seal the Radiance in a bug-shaped can]], and in order for that to work they [[spoiler:were all created had to be perfect and pure empty voids containing no minds to think with, no [[EmptyShell completely hollow]] so she couldn't influence them. If they were treated as people, then they might get the idea that they were people with wills to break, and no voices to cry suffering. All to be as hollow as possible, to better serve as containers desires of their own, and that would leave a weakness for [[MysticalPlague the infection]]. Radiance to exploit. The reason the current Hollow Knight failed as a container was had such an "idea instilled" because it was tainted by "an idea instilled": The the Pale King, the creator of the Vessels, failed to completely dehumanize it, coming to regard the Hollow Knight King raised them as his child]].child, which is why the Black Egg Temple is a LeakingCanOfEvil.]]

Added: 115

Changed: 1559

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixing indentation


* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': In ''Literature/GoingPostal'', when [[MoralGuardians Miss Maccalariat]] objects to {{golem}}s cleaning the ladies' restrooms, the protagonist Moist von Lipwig tries to explain that they often use honorifics like "Mister" with the golems employed at the post office because "it" seems wrong. That said, Miss Maccalariat still has issues because a "Mister" should not clean the lady's restrooms. So Moist gets around this by having the golem who would clean the bathroom as "Miss" and wear dresses. The next time we see this golem in ''Literature/MakingMoney'', [[HumanityEnsues the golem (now called Gladys) is a unique entity]].
** In ''Literature/TheTruth'' [[spoiler:Lord De Worde]] considers any non human this, and after calling [[FriendlyNeighborhoodVampire Otto Chriek]] this, he loses his composure.
-->'''[[spoiler:Lord De Worde]]:''' Keep it away from me!
-->'''[[OurVampiresAreDifferent Otto]]:''' You think I am an "it"? [[VampireVords Vell]], let me ''act'' like an "it"!

to:

* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'':
**
In ''Literature/GoingPostal'', when [[MoralGuardians Miss Maccalariat]] objects to {{golem}}s cleaning the ladies' restrooms, the protagonist Moist von Lipwig tries to explain that they often use honorifics like "Mister" with the golems employed at the post office because "it" seems wrong. That said, Miss Maccalariat still has issues because a "Mister" should not clean the lady's restrooms. So Moist gets around this by having the golem who would clean the bathroom as "Miss" and wear dresses. The next time we see this golem in ''Literature/MakingMoney'', [[HumanityEnsues the golem (now called Gladys) is a unique entity]].
** In ''Literature/TheTruth'' [[spoiler:Lord De Worde]] considers any non human non-human this, and after calling [[FriendlyNeighborhoodVampire Otto Chriek]] this, he loses his composure.
-->'''[[spoiler:Lord --->'''[[spoiler:Lord De Worde]]:''' Keep it away from me!
-->'''[[OurVampiresAreDifferent
me!\\
'''[[OurVampiresAreDifferent
Otto]]:''' You think I am an "it"? [[VampireVords Vell]], let me ''act'' like an "it"!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** By Chapter 18, Curator is internally referring to the Slayer as that ''thing'', much like Mummy did. After seeing him [[NoSell shrug off Volcano's nanomachines and lava strike]], he knows that facing the Slayer [[KnowWhenToFoldEm is outright suicide]] and is [[ScrewThisImOuttaHere forced to retreat alongside the Volcano Thieves, when it becomes clear that the mainland heroes are arriving and the heroes in the ballroom are probably freed by now]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Curator''': There is no need for any unnecessary violence, Nine. The League of Villains will take full responsibility for Wolfram's blunder and we'll ensure that the Steel Sabers are compensated for this unfortunate turn of events.\\
'''Mummy''': Compensation?! Half of our entire organization is ''dead'' because of that ''thing''!

to:

--> '''Curator''': There is no need for any unnecessary violence, Nine. The League of Villains will take full responsibility for Wolfram's blunder and we'll ensure that the Steel Sabers are compensated for this [[UnderStatement unfortunate turn of events.events]].\\
'''Mummy''': Compensation?! [[UnderStatement Half of our entire organization is ''dead'' is]] ''[[UnderStatement dead]]'' [[UnderStatement because of that ''thing''!
that]] ''[[UnderStatement thing]]''!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Curator''': There is no need for any unnecessary violence, Nine. The League of Villains will take full responsibility for Wolfram's blunder and we'll ensure that the Steel Sabers are compensated for this {{Understatement unfortunate turn of events}}.\\

to:

--> '''Curator''': There is no need for any unnecessary violence, Nine. The League of Villains will take full responsibility for Wolfram's blunder and we'll ensure that the Steel Sabers are compensated for this {{Understatement unfortunate turn of events}}.events.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Curator''': There is no need for any unnecessary violence, Nine. The League of Villains will take full responsibility for Wolfram's blunder and we'll ensure that the Steel Sabers are compensated for this [[Understatement unfortunate turn of events]].\\

to:

--> '''Curator''': There is no need for any unnecessary violence, Nine. The League of Villains will take full responsibility for Wolfram's blunder and we'll ensure that the Steel Sabers are compensated for this [[Understatement {{Understatement unfortunate turn of events]].events}}.\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Curator''': There is no need for any unnecessary violence, Nine. The League of Villains will take full responsibility for Wolfram's blunder and we'll ensure that the Steel Sabers are compensated for this [[Understatement unfortunate turn of events.]]\\

to:

--> '''Curator''': There is no need for any unnecessary violence, Nine. The League of Villains will take full responsibility for Wolfram's blunder and we'll ensure that the Steel Sabers are compensated for this [[Understatement unfortunate turn of events.]]\\events]].\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This is the reaction from Nine and his lieutenants in ''Fanfic/MyHeroAcademiaUnchainedPredator''. After [[LockedOutOfTheLoop finding out Wolfram knew about the Slayer and didn't tell them,]] Nine was about ready to kill Wolfram for this catastrophic lapse of judgement. Curator has to intervene before it got bloody.
--> '''Curator''': There is no need for any unnecessary violence, Nine. The League of Villains will take full responsibility for Wolfram's blunder and we'll ensure that the Steel Sabers are compensated for this [[Understatement unfortunate turn of events.]]\\
'''Mummy''': Compensation?! Half of our entire organization is ''dead'' because of that ''thing''!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Series/CallTheMidwife'', a father resorts to calling his disabled baby “it” to provoke his depressed wife into bonding with him. It works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
general clarification on works content


* In ''WebAnimation/{{Glitchtale}}'', Betty is commonly dehumanized and called "it" and "that thing" by all the characters because of her horrible, ''horrible'' actions. It still comes across as mean of them all anyway, if only because no other character gets this treatment.

to:

* In ''WebAnimation/{{Glitchtale}}'', Betty is commonly dehumanized and called "it" and "that thing" by all the characters because of her horrible, ''horrible'' actions. It still comes across as mean of them all anyway, if only because no other character gets this treatment. However, it is partially justified as because of her artificial nature, Betty technically doesn't ''have'' a gender.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''Series/BattlestarGalactica2003'', Cylon characters (even some who were generally recognized as allies by the humans) were often referred to as "it" by human characters. [[FaceHeelTurn Athena's]] growing acceptance by the other characters can be tracked by when people switch from calling her "it" or "thing" to "her" and "you".

to:

** In ''Series/BattlestarGalactica2003'', Cylon characters (even some who were generally recognized as allies by the humans) were often referred to as "it" by human characters. [[FaceHeelTurn [[HeelFaceTurn Athena's]] growing acceptance by the other characters can be tracked by when people switch from calling her "it" or "thing" to "her" and "you".

Top