Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ItIsDehumanizing

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Videogame/GenshinImpact'', in the past the [[CartoonCreature Melusines]] were subject to FantasticRacism by the people of Fontaine. As such, Chief Justice Neuvillette eventually made it outright illegal to refer to them as "It", stating that they must be referred to with [[OneGenderRace female pronouns]]. Thankfully by the time of the game the Melusines have largely integrated into human society and are treated as equal members of their society to the point that treating them like pets (a common mistake for people from other nations) is also illegal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Cotterpin:''' Because you just ran into me, that's why! And I am not an "it". I'm Cotterpin.\\

to:

'''Cotterpin:''' Because you just ran into me, that's why! [[LampshadeHanging And I am not an "it". I'm Cotterpin.\\]]\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Puppet Shows]]
* ''Series/FraggleRock'': FantasticRacism is a major underpinning of the initial interspecies relations in the show. The various central species (Fraggles, Doozers, Gorgs and humans) start out misunderstanding each other at worst, and knowing nothing about one another at best. In the episode "Boober and the Glob", Boober Fraggle trips over Cotterpin Doozer. This conversation results:
-->'''Cotterpin:''' Say, watch where you're going!\\
'''Boober:''' What? Who said that?\\
'''Cotterpin:''' I did! You know, you Fraggles are a real nuisance, always running around, barging into things.\\
'''Boober:''' [[CaptainObvious It's a Doozer!]]\\
'''Cotterpin:''' Good eyes.\\
'''Boober:''' But why is it talking to me?\\
'''Cotterpin:''' Because you just ran into me, that's why! And I am not an "it". I'm Cotterpin.\\
'''Boober:''' Oh, don't tell me it has a name!\\
'''Cotterpin:''' [[DeadpanSnarker Too late. I already told you.]]
[[/folder]]



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Pretty much averted with infants in general. People don't specifically intend to call newborns "it", but new parents can expect to be bombarded with questions like "is it a boy or a girl?", "is it healthy?" or "how much does it weigh?" It's also common to refer to unborn children as "it", especially if the parents choose not to find out the gender until the baby's born.

to:

* Pretty much averted with infants in general. People don't specifically intend to call newborns "it", but new parents can expect to be bombarded with questions like "is it a boy or a girl?", "is it healthy?" or "how much does it weigh?" It's also common to refer to unborn children still in the womb as "it", especially if the parents choose not to find out the gender until the baby's born.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/Fallout4'' uses this with many characters when they talk about [[ArtificialHuman synths]], but one particular instance stands out, that being during the Blind Betrayal quest: [[spoiler:Danse is revealed to be an escaped synth who had his memory wiped, and Elder Maxson tasks you with tracking him down and executing him. Danse had absolutely idea he was a synth and has served the Brotherhood of Steel for years with unquestioning loyalty, but if you convince Danse that he [[TalkingDownTheSuicidal deserves to live despite being a synth]] and then stand up to Maxson in his defense, Maxson disregards the fact that Danse is the best soldier he has and only refers to him as "it". Danse is visibly hurt.]]

to:

* ''VideoGame/Fallout4'' uses this with many characters when they talk about [[ArtificialHuman synths]], but one particular instance stands out, that being during the Blind Betrayal quest: [[spoiler:Danse is revealed to be an escaped synth who had his memory wiped, and Elder Maxson tasks you with tracking him down and executing him. Danse had absolutely no idea he was a synth and has served the Brotherhood of Steel for years with unquestioning loyalty, but if you convince Danse that he [[TalkingDownTheSuicidal deserves to live despite being a synth]] and then stand up to Maxson in his defense, Maxson disregards the fact that Danse is the best soldier he has and only refers to him as "it". Danse is visibly hurt.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/TheShipWho'', humans with severe enough disabilities to be [[ManInTheMachine enclosed in life support "shells"]] are called "shellpeople", and generally go on to be the [[WetwareCPU biological "brains" of spaceships, space stations, and other installations]]. They do ''not'' like to be regarded as equipment or treated like AI, which they find tremendously disrespectful. It grates on Helva when [[BrainsAndBrawn her brawn Teron]], discussing brainships that have mysteriously vanished, refers to them as "it", and while considering the issue herself she has a parenthetical aside calling them "they/she/he never it, please".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the WebAnimation/DoobusGoobus video "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rN58VJlQv3I Gamer Frogs: The Gamer Code]]," the short frog refers to [[VideoGame/{{Metroid}} Samus]] as "it."
-->'''Tall frog:''' What is "it"?\\
'''Short frog:''' The woman.\\
'''Tall frog:''' Are women really just objects to you-\\
'''Short frog:''' Unquestionably, ''un-[[PrecisionFStrike fucking]]-questionably''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Film/TheIncredibleHulk:'' Emil Blonsky initially refers to the Hulk as an "it", mainly because he has no idea ''what'' the Hulk is to begin with, until General Ross sets him straight. By contrast, in ''Film/TheAvengers2012'', Nick Fury refers to the Hulk as "he".

to:

** ''Film/TheIncredibleHulk:'' ''Film/TheIncredibleHulk2008:'' Emil Blonsky initially refers to the Hulk as an "it", mainly because he has no idea ''what'' the Hulk is to begin with, until General Ross sets him straight. By contrast, in ''Film/TheAvengers2012'', Nick Fury refers to the Hulk as "he".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/BeautifulMusicForUglyChildren'', trans man Gabe is harassed and assulted by two men who call him "It," both online and in person.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Radio]]
* ''Radio/JohnFinnemoresSouvenirProgramme:'' In the DeconstructiveParody of ''Thomas the Tank Engine'', a train driver alarmed by the talking train keeps referring to Thomas as "it", which confuses Thomas and the Fat Controller, who wonder why he keeps doing that.

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''The Martian Menace'', a ''Franchise/SherlockHolmes'' novel by Eric Brown looking at the aftermath of ''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds1898'' with {{Martians}} living on Earth in relative peace, Watson acknowledges that the Martians' nature means that they are [[NoBiologicalSex biologically best defined as "it"]], but since he feels such a term demeans the Martians, he generally refers to them as male in the novel.

to:

* In ''The Martian Menace'', ''Literature/TheMartianMenace'', a ''Franchise/SherlockHolmes'' novel by Eric Brown looking at the aftermath of ''Literature/TheWarOfTheWorlds1898'' with {{Martians}} living on Earth in relative peace, Watson acknowledges that the Martians' nature means that they are [[NoBiologicalSex biologically best defined as "it"]], but since he feels such a term demeans the Martians, he generally refers to them as male in the novel.



* Inverted in Ness Brown's space horror novella ''The Scourge Between Stars''. Watson the droid is referred to as "it" by everyone but Dr. Otto, its maker, who calls Watson "she". However, this is actually the ''opposite'' of treating Watson like a person--he's an abusive creep who molests Watson, and calling it "she", far from an indicator of respect, is just another method of forcibly sexualizing it. Jacklyn, our protagonist, only ever calls Watson "it", but treats it far better.

to:

* Inverted in Ness Brown's space horror novella ''The Scourge Between Stars''.''Literature/TheScourgeBetweenStars''. Watson the droid is referred to as "it" by everyone but Dr. Otto, its maker, who calls Watson "she". However, this is actually the ''opposite'' of treating Watson like a person--he's an abusive creep who molests Watson, and calling it "she", far from an indicator of respect, is just another method of forcibly sexualizing it. Jacklyn, our protagonist, only ever calls Watson "it", but treats it far better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''TabletopGame/VampireTheMasquerade'': The Tzimisce Sascha Vykos self-invokes this to show how detached ''it'' is from humanity.

to:

* ''TabletopGame/VampireTheMasquerade'': The Tzimisce Sascha Vykos self-invokes this to show how detached ''it'' is from humanity. In later editions however, Vykos would use they/them pronouns to still maintain being divorced from gender, but now showing a sense of identity (and presumbably to avoid any unfortunate implications in regards to non-binary people).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/GeorgeOfTheJungle'', when Ursula wakes up in George's tree-house, she is immediately freaked out by Ape. When Ape begins to move towards her, she screams, runs to George and asks "What does it want?" in fear. Cue Ape [[DeadpanSnarker snarking]] in a way that only ''Creator/JohnCleese'' can.
--> '''Ape:''' "It", wants "its" physician's desk reference.

to:

* In ''Film/GeorgeOfTheJungle'', when Ursula wakes up in George's tree-house, she is immediately freaked out by Ape. When Ape begins to move towards her, she screams, runs to George and asks "What does it want?" want?!" in fear. Cue Ape [[DeadpanSnarker snarking]] in a way that only ''Creator/JohnCleese'' can.
--> '''Ape:''' "It", "It" wants "its" physician's desk reference.''Physician's Desk Reference'', if you don't mind. Unless of course you'd rather die of dengue fever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/FiveNightsAtFreddysSecurityBreach'', it's telling that Glamrock Freddy, who treats himself and the other animatronics as actual people and spends the game trying to convince Gregory that the others are NotEvilJustMisunderstood (not evil, just reprogrammed is a bit more accurate), refers to the creepy, HatedByAll animatronic the Daycare Attendant as 'it'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''[[OurVampiresAreDifferent Otto]]:''' You think I am an "it"? Vell, let me ''act'' like an "it"!

to:

-->'''[[OurVampiresAreDifferent Otto]]:''' You think I am an "it"? Vell, [[VampireVords Vell]], let me ''act'' like an "it"!

Changed: 96

Removed: 96

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': In ''Literature/GoingPostal'', when [[MoralGuardians Miss Maccalariat]] objects to {{golem}}s cleaning the ladies' restrooms, the protagonist Moist von Lipwig tries to explain that they often use honorifics like "Mister" with the golems employed at the post office because "it" seems wrong. That said, Miss Maccalariat still has issues because a "Mister" should not clean the lady's restrooms. So Moist gets around this by having the golem who would clean the bathroom as "Miss" and wear dresses. The next time we see this golem in

to:

* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': In ''Literature/GoingPostal'', when [[MoralGuardians Miss Maccalariat]] objects to {{golem}}s cleaning the ladies' restrooms, the protagonist Moist von Lipwig tries to explain that they often use honorifics like "Mister" with the golems employed at the post office because "it" seems wrong. That said, Miss Maccalariat still has issues because a "Mister" should not clean the lady's restrooms. So Moist gets around this by having the golem who would clean the bathroom as "Miss" and wear dresses. The next time we see this golem in ''Literature/MakingMoney'', [[HumanityEnsues the golem (now called Gladys) is a unique entity]].



''Literature/MakingMoney'', [[HumanityEnsues the golem (now called Gladys) is a unique entity]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Literature/TheTruth" [[spoiler:Lord De Worde]] considers any non human this, and after calling [[FriendlyNeighborhoodVampire Otto Chriek]] this, he loses his composure.

to:

** In "Literature/TheTruth" ''Literature/TheTruth'' [[spoiler:Lord De Worde]] considers any non human this, and after calling [[FriendlyNeighborhoodVampire Otto Chriek]] this, he loses his composure.

Added: 429

Changed: 96

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': In ''Literature/GoingPostal'', when [[MoralGuardians Miss Maccalariat]] objects to {{golem}}s cleaning the ladies' restrooms, the protagonist Moist von Lipwig tries to explain that they often use honorifics like "Mister" with the golems employed at the post office because "it" seems wrong. That said, Miss Maccalariat still has issues because a "Mister" should not clean the lady's restrooms. So Moist gets around this by having the golem who would clean the bathroom as "Miss" and wear dresses. The next time we see this golem in ''Literature/MakingMoney'', [[HumanityEnsues the golem (now called Gladys) is a unique entity]].

to:

* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'': In ''Literature/GoingPostal'', when [[MoralGuardians Miss Maccalariat]] objects to {{golem}}s cleaning the ladies' restrooms, the protagonist Moist von Lipwig tries to explain that they often use honorifics like "Mister" with the golems employed at the post office because "it" seems wrong. That said, Miss Maccalariat still has issues because a "Mister" should not clean the lady's restrooms. So Moist gets around this by having the golem who would clean the bathroom as "Miss" and wear dresses. The next time we see this golem in in
** In "Literature/TheTruth" [[spoiler:Lord De Worde]] considers any non human this, and after calling [[FriendlyNeighborhoodVampire Otto Chriek]] this, he loses his composure.
-->'''[[spoiler:Lord De Worde]]:''' Keep it away from me!
-->'''[[OurVampiresAreDifferent Otto]]:''' You think I am an "it"? Vell, let me ''act'' like an "it"!
''Literature/MakingMoney'', [[HumanityEnsues the golem (now called Gladys) is a unique entity]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
What's the relevance of that trope?


AsYouKnow, in the English language, pronouns are divided into "he", "she" and the singular "they" for humans and "it" for inanimate objects and wild animals.[[note]]though animals may also be referred to with gendered pronouns.[[/note]] Referring to a person as "it" is usually incredibly rude, as it's considered tantamount to denying they are a real person. (Well, much of the time. "It", as can be seen by its usage with animals, used to be for various non-human entities, entities which are hard to classify as male or female, people who prefer the "it" pronoun, or entities of which you are unsure of. Nowadays, it's mainly only preserved in select sentences, such as "Who is it?")

to:

AsYouKnow, in In the English language, pronouns are divided into "he", "she" and the singular "they" for humans and "it" for inanimate objects and wild animals.[[note]]though animals objects[[note]]animals may also be referred to with gendered pronouns.[[/note]] pronouns or as "it" if their sex is unknown or irrelevant to the discussion[[/note]]. Referring to a person as "it" is usually incredibly rude, as it's considered tantamount to denying they are a real person. (Well, much of the time. "It", as can be seen by its usage with animals, used to be for various non-human entities, entities which are hard to classify as male or female, people who prefer the "it" pronoun, or entities of which you are unsure of. Nowadays, it's mainly only preserved in select sentences, such as "Who is it?")
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ComicBook/AstroCity:'' An alien empire refers to a human woman they've dragged back to their world in chains as "it", as part of their state propaganda machine (in addition to lies such as "humans don't love their families like ''we'' do", or claiming the obviously very normal human woman is a fiendish enemy operative).

to:

* ''ComicBook/AstroCity:'' ''ComicBook/AstroCity'': An alien empire refers to a human woman they've dragged back to their world in chains as "it", as part of their state propaganda machine (in addition to lies such as "humans don't love their families like ''we'' do", or claiming the obviously very normal human woman is a fiendish enemy operative).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "Literature/{{Tattercoats}}": The titular character's mother dies at childbirth, leading the old lord to hate his granddaughter and declare "it might live or die like it liked, but he would never look on its face as long as it lived."

to:

* "Literature/{{Tattercoats}}": ''Literature/{{Tattercoats}}'': The titular character's mother dies at childbirth, leading the old lord to hate his granddaughter and declare "it might live or die like it liked, but he would never look on its face as long as it lived."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Remove extraneous "it"


* Partly {{inverted|Trope}} in ''Literature/TheMurderbotDiaries'': Artificial intelligences like the protagonist are called "it" both by humans and by themselves. While humans have [[AndroidsArePeopleToo a range of opinions]] about the personhood of [=AIs=], the [=AIs=] themselves have NoBiologicalSex and don't [[BecomeARealBoy want to be human]], so "it" suits them just fine. The main character actually mentions in its narration that it prefers to "it" to any human pronouns, since it feels that doing so would be pretending to be more human-like as opposed to being a non-human ''person''.

to:

* Partly {{inverted|Trope}} in ''Literature/TheMurderbotDiaries'': Artificial intelligences like the protagonist are called "it" both by humans and by themselves. While humans have [[AndroidsArePeopleToo a range of opinions]] about the personhood of [=AIs=], the [=AIs=] themselves have NoBiologicalSex and don't [[BecomeARealBoy want to be human]], so "it" suits them just fine. The main character actually mentions in its narration that it prefers to "it" to any human pronouns, since it feels that doing so would be pretending to be more human-like as opposed to being a non-human ''person''.

Added: 346

Changed: 95

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ComicBook/HouseOfM'': Doctor Doom's Fearsome Four has the It, an even more heavily mutated version of Ben Grimm. It's a deliberate insult on Doom's part, and he makes it clear that he doesn't even consider Ben to be sapient despite Ben being shown to be just as intelligent as his normal counterpart but not allowed to express it in any way.



* ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'': In "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS5E7MakeNewFriendsButKeepDiscord Make New Friends but Keep Discord]]", [[BlobMonster the Smooze]] is mostly referred to as "it" or a "thing", including by Discord, who isn't too convincing when he claims that he cares about his guest. The exception is Tree Hugger, who consistently uses male pronouns when talking about it.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'': In "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS5E7MakeNewFriendsButKeepDiscord Make New Friends but Keep Discord]]", [[BlobMonster the Smooze]] is mostly referred to as "it" or a "thing", including by Discord, who isn't too convincing when he claims that he cares about his guest. The exception is Tree Hugger, who consistently uses male pronouns when talking about it. Of course, as a BlobMonster, it's unclear if the Smooze actually does have a gender identity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Okay, now I've realized I didn't properly verify which comic the second example happened in.


** In "To Hel and Back", Helspont tries to break Superman's spirit by giving him a nightmare where the government is hunting him down. The soldiers yell stuff like, "There it is! Shoot it!"

to:

** In "To Hel and Back", another example that occurred during ''ComicBook/New52'', Helspont at one point tries to break Superman's spirit by giving him a nightmare where the government is hunting him down. The soldiers yell stuff like, "There it is! Shoot it!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Touching up the Superman examples a bit. Also, the title I added to the second entry is NOT a misspelling, that's how the title is actually spelled for some reason.


** In a ''ComicBook/New52'' story, Superman gets captured by the government and subjected to torture and experimentation. The scientists and ComicBook/LexLuthor refer to him as "it".
** Later, Helspont tries to break Superman's spirit by giving him a nightmare where the government is hunting him down. The soldiers yell stuff like, "There it is! Shoot it!"

to:

** In a ''ComicBook/New52'' story, Creator/GrantMorrison's run on ''ComicBook/ActionComicsNew52'' took Lex Luthor and General Sam Lane's hatred of Superman gets captured to a new level by the government having them and subjected to torture and experimentation. The scientists and ComicBook/LexLuthor their compliant associates refer to him the Kryptonian superhero as "it".
** Later, In "To Hel and Back", Helspont tries to break Superman's spirit by giving him a nightmare where the government is hunting him down. The soldiers yell stuff like, "There it is! Shoot it!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/PaqueretteDownTheBunburrows'': Pâquerette asks Ophéline to call one bunny by "they" instead of "it" because they are "living creatures".

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS cleanup: not enough context


'''[[CloningBlues Superboy]]:''' ''[annoyed]'' Yes, "''[[ImStandingRightHere he]]''" can!\\

to:

'''[[CloningBlues Superboy]]:''' '''Superboy:''' ''[annoyed]'' Yes, "''[[ImStandingRightHere he]]''" can!\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Webcomic/TheGreenhouse'': The demon 'Red' does not appreciate the way her [[DemonicPossession host]]'s friend [[LoveInterest Liv]] refers to her. In fairness, she is a parasite drinking down Mica's life force, and no one but Mica can actually hear her, which probably contributes to the dehumanization as well. [[spoiler:Her host, Mica, starts using feminine pronouns for her and gives her the nickname Red once they start talking, and Mica starts seeing Red as more than a problem and an antagonist. Soon enough, Liv and her family are doing the same]].
-->'''Red:''' Refer to me as anything but 'it' if you please.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/Fallout4'' uses this with many characters when they talk about [[ArtificialHuman synths]], but one particular instance stands out, that being during the Blind Betrayal quest: [[spoiler:Danse is revealed to be an escaped synth who had his memory wiped, and Elder Maxson tasks you with tracking him down and executing him. Danse had absolutely idea he was a synth and has served the Brotherhood of Steel for years with unquestioning loyalty, but if you convince Danse that he [[TalkingDowntTheSuicidal deserves to live despite being a synth]] and then stand up to Maxson in his defense, Maxson disregards the fact that Danse is the best soldier he has and only refers to him as "it". Danse is visibly hurt.]]

to:

* ''VideoGame/Fallout4'' uses this with many characters when they talk about [[ArtificialHuman synths]], but one particular instance stands out, that being during the Blind Betrayal quest: [[spoiler:Danse is revealed to be an escaped synth who had his memory wiped, and Elder Maxson tasks you with tracking him down and executing him. Danse had absolutely idea he was a synth and has served the Brotherhood of Steel for years with unquestioning loyalty, but if you convince Danse that he [[TalkingDowntTheSuicidal [[TalkingDownTheSuicidal deserves to live despite being a synth]] and then stand up to Maxson in his defense, Maxson disregards the fact that Danse is the best soldier he has and only refers to him as "it". Danse is visibly hurt.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/TransformersAnimated'': In 'This is Why I Hate Machines", when human Captain Fanzone and Autobot Ratchet are mistakenly teleported to Cybertron, many of the Autobots react in disgust and horror at Fanzone and refer to him as "it".
-->'''Grandus:''' (''after seeing Ratchet give Fanzone a ride'') He touched it!

Top