Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / InformedJudaism

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:Theater]]
* Mark from {{Rent}} is said to be Jewish. At midwinter, their is neither a Christmas tree nor a menorah in the apartment. (Presumably, they couldn't afford either.) And Mark seems to know the melody of "O Little Town of Bethlehem", a Christian hymn.
* We must needs mention Shylock from TheMerchantOfVenice. He is constantly called "Jew" and makes a moving "Has not a Jew eyes?" speech. Other than stereotypical greed, he doesn't do anything that marks him as Jewish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** No Jews are kosher, unless you can figure out some way to rewrite the Torah to allow for cannibalism, including a proper target to hit on the neck.

to:

**** No Jews are kosher, unless you can figure out some way to rewrite the Torah to allow for cannibalism, including And then find a proper target to hit on the nice, succulent neck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****No Jews are kosher, unless you can figure out some way to rewrite the Torah to allow for cannibalism, including a proper target to hit on the neck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
very rare case of an "its" that should be "it's"


***** It's generally accepted, from what I've been told, that you can break the rules if its neccesary for your health. And fighting off an alien invasion probably qualifies. Plus, they could be observant, but use electronics and such on Saturday- there are many Conservative Jews that do that.

to:

***** It's generally accepted, from what I've been told, that you can break the rules if its it's neccesary for your health. And fighting off an alien invasion probably qualifies. Plus, they could be observant, but use electronics and such on Saturday- there are many Conservative Jews that do that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This turns out not to be the case. There was no mention of the fish being a Chanukah present.


** She also at one point makes an offhand comment that the aquarium fish that Angel/Angelus killed were a Chanukah present, explaining why she had not had time to get attached to them yet. The statement gets no particular attention.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


All these things can be FanWank -ed by saying that only her father was Jewish, and thus she is not Jewish herself, because Jewish religion is passed by the mother.

to:

All **All these things can be FanWank -ed by saying that only her father was Jewish, and thus she is not Jewish herself, because Jewish religion is passed by the mother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

All these things can be FanWank -ed by saying that only her father was Jewish, and thus she is not Jewish herself, because Jewish religion is passed by the mother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> ''Ross:''' "So I can learn about... Jesus."

to:

--> ''Ross:''' '''Ross:''' "So I can learn about... Jesus."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also this conversation when Ross takes a Bible from a hotel:
--> '''Chandler:''' "You're Jewish! Why do you need a Bible?"
--> ''Ross:''' "So I can learn about... Jesus."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** However, when Ross and Monica visit their parents, and we see the outside of the Gellers' front door, they have a mezzuzah, which is something Jews affix to the doorposts of their homes, and also something few non-Jews would recognize. There is a Christmas episode where Ross and Monica discuss the "Friends" doing a group gift things, where they draw names from a hat, and each person buys just one gift, and each person receives just one, rather than each person buying 5 gifts, and this will be the "Christmas" gift. Ross then adds that he and Monica already got each other Hanukkah gifts. Throughout the show, it is strongly implied, although it is never stated, that Ross and Monica's father is Jewish, but their mother is not, and they grew up in a home where holidays from two different traditions were observed.

to:

*** However, when Ross and Monica visit their parents, and we see the outside of the Gellers' front door, they have a mezzuzah, which is something Jews affix to the doorposts of their homes, and also something few non-Jews would recognize. There is a Christmas episode where Ross and Monica discuss the "Friends" doing a group gift things, where they draw names from a hat, and each person buys just one gift, and each person receives just one, rather than each person buying 5 gifts, and this will be the "Christmas" gift. Ross then adds that he and Monica already got each other Hanukkah gifts. Throughout the show, it is strongly implied, although it is never stated, that Ross and Monica's father is Jewish, but their mother is not, not (this is the case with the actors playing them), and they grew up in a home where holidays from two different traditions were observed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is often a trope that pops up in a number of {{Western Animation}} {{Christmas Episode}}s; due to the [[AnimationAgeGhetto nature of the shows' audience]], the [[ExecutiveMeddling powers that be]] will want to place {{an Aesop}} in to show that the characters keep a [[TokenMinority diverse]] set of friends or peers. As a result, a character?s Judaism is mentioned at some point in the episode, or perhaps a menorah will just be shown in the background, in order to keep up that diverse appearance. After all, [[ViewersAreMorons who really knows]] [[DidNotDotheResearch what other religiously affiliated holidays]] [[SmallReferencePools are celebrated by a large enough group of people]] in the mid to late period of December. This will in fact be the only mention of religion throughout the episode (if not the series) , as Christmas itself ([[YouMeanXMas assuming the name is used at all]] ) will not be depicted as having any religious significance, but rather just be a "[[DoTheyKnowItsChristmasTime Warm, Feel Good Time]]", thus making this revelation of a major character feel shoehorned in.

to:

This is often a trope that pops up in a number of {{Western Animation}} {{Christmas Episode}}s; due to the [[AnimationAgeGhetto nature of the shows' audience]], the [[ExecutiveMeddling powers that be]] will want to place {{an Aesop}} in to show that the characters keep a [[TokenMinority diverse]] set of friends or peers. As a result, a character?s character's Judaism is mentioned at some point in the episode, or perhaps a menorah will just be shown in the background, in order to keep up that diverse appearance. After all, [[ViewersAreMorons who really knows]] [[DidNotDotheResearch what other religiously affiliated holidays]] [[SmallReferencePools are celebrated by a large enough group of people]] in the mid to late period of December. This will in fact be the only mention of religion throughout the episode (if not the series) , as Christmas itself ([[YouMeanXMas assuming the name is used at all]] ) will not be depicted as having any religious significance, but rather just be a "[[DoTheyKnowItsChristmasTime Warm, Feel Good Time]]", thus making this revelation of a major character feel shoehorned in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''PowerRangersZeo'' had a HolidaySpecial where a special guest character celebrated Hanukkah. Being AnAesop, they were all hit with the [[AddedAlliterativeAppeal bias blaster]] and became ethnocentric. Tanya of course celebrated Kwanzaa, despite actually being from Africa.

to:

* ''PowerRangersZeo'' had a HolidaySpecial ChristmasEpisode where a special guest character celebrated Hanukkah. Being AnAesop, they were all hit with the [[AddedAlliterativeAppeal bias blaster]] and became ethnocentric. Tanya of course celebrated Kwanzaa, despite actually being from Africa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''PowerRangersZeo'' had a HolidaySpecial where a special guest character celebrated Hanukkah. Being AnAesop, they were all hit with the [[AddedAlliterativeAppeal bias blaster]] and became ethnocentric. Tanya of course celebrated Kwanzaa, despite actually being from Africa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ziva on ''{{NCIS}}'' is an Israeli Mossad agent and wears a Star of David.

to:

* Ziva on ''{{NCIS}}'' is an [[strike: an]] a former Israeli Mossad agent and wears a Star of David.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[WordOfGod According to]] Elliott S. Maggin, the PreCrisis LexLuthor is ''ethnically'' Jewish, although certainly non-practicing. Maggin himself is Jewish, and always had a slightly more tragic/sympathetic take on Luthor than other writers of the period.

to:

* [[WordOfGod According to]] Elliott S. S! Maggin, the PreCrisis LexLuthor is ''ethnically'' Jewish, although certainly non-practicing. Maggin himself is Jewish, and always had a slightly more tragic/sympathetic take on Luthor than other writers of the period.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[WordOfGod According to]] ElliottSMaggin, the PreCrisis LexLuthor is ''ethnically'' Jewish, although certainly non-practicing. Maggin himself is Jewish, and always had a slightly more tragic/sympathetic take on Luthor than other writers of the period.

to:

* [[WordOfGod According to]] ElliottSMaggin, Elliott S. Maggin, the PreCrisis LexLuthor is ''ethnically'' Jewish, although certainly non-practicing. Maggin himself is Jewish, and always had a slightly more tragic/sympathetic take on Luthor than other writers of the period.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* According to Elliott S. Maggin, the PreCrisis LexLuthor is ''ethnically'' Jewish, although certainly non-practicing. Maggin himself is Jewish, and always had a slightly more tragic/sympathetic take on Luthor than other writers of the period.

to:

* [[WordOfGod According to Elliott S. Maggin, to]] ElliottSMaggin, the PreCrisis LexLuthor is ''ethnically'' Jewish, although certainly non-practicing. Maggin himself is Jewish, and always had a slightly more tragic/sympathetic take on Luthor than other writers of the period.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A few years ago, Ben Grimm of the FantasticFour happened to mention that he's Jewish. Since Ben was always a gentle self-caricature of JackKirby, who was Jewish, this makes sense, and the fans seem to be fine with it. But it still seemed to kind of come out of nowhere after all these decades of never having mentioned it.

to:

* A few years ago, Ben Grimm of the FantasticFour happened to mention that he's Jewish. Since Ben was always a gentle self-caricature of JackKirby, who was Jewish, this makes sense, and the fans seem to be fine with it. it. But it still seemed to kind of come out of nowhere after all these decades of never having mentioned it.



* According to Elliott S. Maggin, the PreCrisis [[{{Superman}} Lex Luthor]] is ''ethnically'' Jewish, although certainly non-practicing. Maggin himself is Jewish, and always had a slightly more tragic/sympathetic take on Luthor than other writers of the period.

to:

* According to Elliott S. Maggin, the PreCrisis [[{{Superman}} Lex Luthor]] LexLuthor is ''ethnically'' Jewish, although certainly non-practicing. non-practicing. Maggin himself is Jewish, and always had a slightly more tragic/sympathetic take on Luthor than other writers of the period.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A few years ago, Ben Grimm of the FantasticFour happened to mention that he's Jewish. Since Ben was always a gentle self-caricature of JackKirby, who was Jewish, this makes sense, and the fans seem to be fine with it. But it still seemed to kind of come out of nowhere after all these decades of never having mentioned it.
* Similarly, during his long run as writer on the Hulk, PeterDavid decided that Doc Samson is Jewish, although it had never been mentioned before.

to:

* A few years ago, Ben Grimm of the FantasticFour happened to mention that he's Jewish. Since Ben was always a gentle self-caricature of JackKirby, who was Jewish, this makes sense, and the fans seem to be fine with it. it. But it still seemed to kind of come out of nowhere after all these decades of never having mentioned it.
* Similarly, during his long run as writer on the Hulk, PeterDavid decided that long-time supporting character Doc Samson is Jewish, although it had never been mentioned before.
* According to Elliott S. Maggin, the PreCrisis [[{{Superman}} Lex Luthor]] is ''ethnically'' Jewish, although certainly non-practicing. Maggin himself is Jewish, and always had a slightly more tragic/sympathetic take on Luthor than other writers of the period.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A few years ago, Ben Grimm of the FantasticFour happened to mention that he's Jewish. Since Ben was always a bit of a gentle self-caricature of JackKirby, who was Jewish, this makes sense, and the fans seem to be fine with it. But it still seemed to kind of come out of nowhere after all these decades of never having mentioned it.

to:

* A few years ago, Ben Grimm of the FantasticFour happened to mention that he's Jewish. Since Ben was always a bit of a gentle self-caricature of JackKirby, who was Jewish, this makes sense, and the fans seem to be fine with it. it. But it still seemed to kind of come out of nowhere after all these decades of never having mentioned it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A few years ago, Ben Grimm of the FantasticFour happened to mention that he's Jewish. Since Ben was always a bit of a self-caricature of JackKirby, who was Jewish, this makes sense, and the fans seem to be fine with it. But it still seemed to kind of come out of nowhere after all these decades of never having mentioned it.

to:

* A few years ago, Ben Grimm of the FantasticFour happened to mention that he's Jewish. Since Ben was always a bit of a gentle self-caricature of JackKirby, who was Jewish, this makes sense, and the fans seem to be fine with it. it. But it still seemed to kind of come out of nowhere after all these decades of never having mentioned it.
* Similarly, during his long run as writer on the Hulk, PeterDavid decided that Doc Samson is Jewish, although it had never been mentioned before.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* A few years ago, Ben Grimm of the FantasticFour happened to mention that he's Jewish. Since Ben was always a bit of a self-caricature of JackKirby, who was Jewish, this makes sense, and the fans seem to be fine with it. But it still seemed to kind of come out of nowhere after all these decades of never having mentioned it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wilson and Cuddy from ''{{House}}''. Wilson mentions he is Jewish but nonobservant in the pilot, and even has to be reminded that he is Jewish in a ChristmasEpisode. Cuddy's religion mostly comes up when House makes fun of her.

to:

* Wilson and Cuddy from ''{{House}}''. Wilson mentions he is Jewish but nonobservant in the pilot, and even has to be reminded that he is Jewish in a ChristmasEpisode. Cuddy's religion mostly comes up when House makes fun of her. In the case of Cuddy, this follows the actor; whether Robert Sean Leonard is Jewish I don't know.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Blair Sandburg in ''The Sentinel''. Mentions that his Swiss Army Knife was a Bar Mitzvah present, and when a guest in the apartment he and Jim share asks if there are any pork chops he says, "Yeah, right next to the whale meat!" But he doesn't seem to observe any other Jewish customs; of course he was raised by a flower child mother and is a cultural anthropologist by training. . .
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In one scene set in s fascist alternate universe, Jake mentions in his narration that Jews are often suspected of being radicals, so he needs to be careful. This was the first mention of it at all, and comes in the same book as the D-Day scene. Jake is also the only character with a confirmed last name, Berenson.

Changed: 343

Removed: 1375

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Ivanova is simply not religious—as the five levels of natter sum up, she's definitely Russian Jewish. So, she doesn't belong on the page.


* Susan Ivanova's Judaism comes up only a few times in ''{{Babylon 5}}'', though she's established early on as not very observant (which is very true of many if not most Russian Jews--[[SarcasmMode thank you]] Soviet Union!). A visiting rabbi is aghast that she simply doesn't care whether [[FantasticReligiousWeirdness alien food is kosher]].
** Of course, he then takes a bite, figuring that if God had intended to forbid it, he would have mentioned some rule about it in the Torah.
** Relieving the informedness somewhat are the following:
*** The custom used to firmly establish her Jewishness is ''Shiva'', the seven-day period of morning Jews are supposed to take after losing a close family member (in this case, her estranged father). This is hardly a well-known custom to non-Jews. Ivanova, ever TheWorkoholic, refuses, saying that spending seven days in mourning would be [[MarriedToTheJob tantamount to dereliction of duty in her own mind]]. The aforementioned rabbi eventually convinces her, and she finds the ceremony [[CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming incredibly]] [[TearJerker moving]].
*** Her constant comments to the effect "that's very Russian" whenever someone else engages in [[BlackComedy black humor]] could very easily changed to "that's very Jewish;" although Russian and Jewish humor have somewhat different roots (for the Jews, it's TheTalmud and their incredibly depressing history; for the Russians, it's MotherRussiaMakesYouStrong), they come to similar (i.e. dark) conclusions.
*** While she isn't observant, she most definitely believes in God (usually), and her attitude towards Him is recognizably Jewish: He is kind of playful, occasionally wrathful, but ''always'' works in mysterious ways.

to:

* Susan Ivanova's Judaism comes up only a few times in ''{{Babylon 5}}'', though she's established early on as not very observant (which is very true of many if not most Russian Jews--[[SarcasmMode thank you]] Soviet Union!). A visiting rabbi is aghast that she simply doesn't care whether [[FantasticReligiousWeirdness alien food is kosher]].
** Of course, he then takes a bite, figuring that if God had intended to forbid it, he would have mentioned some rule about it in the Torah.
** Relieving the informedness somewhat are the following:
*** The custom used to firmly establish her Jewishness is ''Shiva'', the seven-day period of morning Jews are supposed to take after losing a close family member (in this case, her estranged father). This is hardly a well-known custom to non-Jews. Ivanova, ever TheWorkoholic, refuses, saying that spending seven days in mourning would be [[MarriedToTheJob tantamount to dereliction of duty in her own mind]]. The aforementioned rabbi eventually convinces her, and she finds the ceremony [[CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming incredibly]] [[TearJerker moving]].
*** Her constant comments to the effect "that's very Russian" whenever someone else engages in [[BlackComedy black humor]] could very easily changed to "that's very Jewish;" although Russian and Jewish humor have somewhat different roots (for the Jews, it's TheTalmud and their incredibly depressing history; for the Russians, it's MotherRussiaMakesYouStrong), they come to similar (i.e. dark) conclusions.
*** While she isn't observant, she most definitely believes in God (usually), and her attitude towards Him is recognizably Jewish: He is kind of playful, occasionally wrathful, but ''always'' works in mysterious ways.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The custom used to firmly establish her Jewishness is ''Shiva'', the seven-day period of morning Jews are supposed to take after losing a close family member (in this case, her estranged father). Ivanova, ever TheWorkoholic, refuses, saying that spending seven days in mourning would be [[MarriedToTheJob tantamount to dereliction of duty in her own mind]]. The aforementioned rabbi eventually convinces her, and she finds the ceremony [[CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming incredibly]] [[TearJerker moving]].

to:

*** The custom used to firmly establish her Jewishness is ''Shiva'', the seven-day period of morning Jews are supposed to take after losing a close family member (in this case, her estranged father). This is hardly a well-known custom to non-Jews. Ivanova, ever TheWorkoholic, refuses, saying that spending seven days in mourning would be [[MarriedToTheJob tantamount to dereliction of duty in her own mind]]. The aforementioned rabbi eventually convinces her, and she finds the ceremony [[CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming incredibly]] [[TearJerker moving]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** While she isn't observant, she most definitely believes in God (usually), and her attitude towards Him is recognizably Jewish: He is kind of playful, occasionally wrathful, but ''always'' works in mysterious ways.

Added: 970

Changed: 241

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ivanova's Judaism comes up only a few times in ''{{Babylon 5}}'', though she's established early on as not very observant. A visiting rabbi is aghast that she simply doesn't care whether [[FantasticReligiousWeirdness alien food is kosher]].

to:

* Susan Ivanova's Judaism comes up only a few times in ''{{Babylon 5}}'', though she's established early on as not very observant.observant (which is very true of many if not most Russian Jews--[[SarcasmMode thank you]] Soviet Union!). A visiting rabbi is aghast that she simply doesn't care whether [[FantasticReligiousWeirdness alien food is kosher]].
** Of course, he then takes a bite, figuring that if God had intended to forbid it, he would have mentioned some rule about it in the Torah.
** Relieving the informedness somewhat are the following:
*** The custom used to firmly establish her Jewishness is ''Shiva'', the seven-day period of morning Jews are supposed to take after losing a close family member (in this case, her estranged father). Ivanova, ever TheWorkoholic, refuses, saying that spending seven days in mourning would be [[MarriedToTheJob tantamount to dereliction of duty in her own mind]]. The aforementioned rabbi eventually convinces her, and she finds the ceremony [[CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming incredibly]] [[TearJerker moving]].
*** Her constant comments to the effect "that's very Russian" whenever someone else engages in [[BlackComedy black humor]] could very easily changed to "that's very Jewish;" although Russian and Jewish humor have somewhat different roots (for the Jews, it's TheTalmud and their incredibly depressing history; for the Russians, it's MotherRussiaMakesYouStrong), they come to similar (i.e. dark) conclusions.

Added: 270

Changed: 117

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It was implied in an earlier episode that the family was Jewish when Sam's grandmother called her "bubbie;" also, Christian opposition to the occult is based upon Jewish texts, usch as Deuteronomy 18:9-14, possibly meaning they are actually serious about their faith.



* In a ''TheMightyB'' episode where Bessie and Penny keeps sneaking into Bat Mitzvah parties, we learn that Portia Gibbons is (probably) Jewish when Bessie sneaks into the Bat Mitzvah party of Portia's cousin.

to:

* In a ''TheMightyB'' episode where Bessie and Penny keeps sneaking into Bat Mitzvah parties, we learn that Portia Gibbons is (probably) Jewish when Bessie sneaks into the Bat Mitzvah party of Portia's cousin.



* Jude on ''[[{{Sixteen}} 6teen]]'' showed no signs of being Jewish until one of the [[ChristmasEpisode Christmas Episodes]] where he said he had to get home because of Hanukkah.

to:

* Jude on ''[[{{Sixteen}} 6teen]]'' showed no signs of being Jewish until one of the [[ChristmasEpisode Christmas Episodes]] where he said he had to get home because of Hanukkah. There is some irony that Jude was the name of one of Jesus' friends/apostles (and no, he's not the same as Judas).

Top