Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / HealingMagicIsTheHardest

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/{{Othercide}}'', you are a being of incredible power capable of manipulating time and memory as well as summoning "Daughters" through bits of your friend's memory. However you normally can't restore any health to wounded Daughters, except by sacrificing the life of another Daughter.

to:

* In ''VideoGame/{{Othercide}}'', you are play a being of incredible power power, capable of manipulating time and memory as well as summoning "Daughters" through bits memory, and can create ''Daughters'', supersoldiers created from the essence of your friend's memory. However you normally can't restore any health former host and oldest friend. However, the only way to heal a wounded Daughters, except by sacrificing the life of another daughter is to ''sacrifice'' another. Resurrection magic is even worse, as it involves finding a fragile yet divinely pure being... and then murdering them to harvest their energy into a token, which can be spent to save a dead Daughter.



* ''Webcomic/Aurora2019'': According to both of {{Word of God}} and {{All There in the Manual}}; Life Magic is much more dangerous/difficult to use than any of the other types of magic. Probably doesn't help that there's a [[{{Harmful Healing}} plague]] of the raw stuff randomly cropping up...

to:

* ''Webcomic/Aurora2019'': According to both of {{Word of God}} and {{All There in the Manual}}; Life Magic is much more dangerous/difficult to use than any of the other types of magic.magic; the Goddess of Life is ''not'' in a good place, and in her weakened, blinded, and addled state, she was barely able to craft a system that ''constantly'' backfires on its users. Much like real-world evolution, it took ''millions'' of victims before one finally emerged that had the right combination of genetics to wield it without losing herself. Probably doesn't help that there's a [[{{Harmful Healing}} plague]] of the raw stuff randomly cropping up...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All superpowers in ''Manga/ChainsawMan'' are derived from [[OurDemonsAreDifferent devils]] and NoCureForEvil is in full effect. Devils [[HealItWithBlood heal by drinking blood]] but [[DealWithTheDevil make contracts]] just to harm humans via payments, so you're hard-pressed to find a devil willing and able to heal them. The only established cases have involved [[DemonOfHumanOrigin becoming a least partially demonic yourself]] to gain said self-regeneration, which seems very rare (and [[InhumanableAlienRights means you aren't legally human anymore]]). [[spoiler:The real Santa Claus]] needed a contract with one of the most powerful devils in existence to heal her body, though it also gave a very impressive HealingFactor on top of that.

to:

* All superpowers in ''Manga/ChainsawMan'' are derived from [[OurDemonsAreDifferent devils]] and NoCureForEvil is in full effect. Devils [[HealItWithBlood heal by drinking blood]] but [[DealWithTheDevil make contracts]] just to harm humans via payments, so you're hard-pressed to find a devil willing and able to heal them. The only established cases have Power can use her [[BloodyMurder blood manipulation powers]] to provide first-aid, but anything more than that has involved [[DemonOfHumanOrigin becoming making the patient a least partially demonic yourself]] themselves]] to gain said a devil's self-regeneration, which seems very rare (and [[InhumanableAlienRights means you they aren't legally human anymore]]). [[spoiler:The real Santa Claus]] needed a contract with one of the most powerful devils in existence to heal her body, though it also gave a very impressive HealingFactor on top of that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Gnome Princess Mansherry can use her Chiyu Chiyu no Mi/Heal-Heal Fruit power to heal any living thing that is wounded or injured, via SwissArmyTears or floating dandelions. She can only produce so many of the former at a time, while the latter is either temporary or based on EquivalentExchange via EnergyDonation. She can also heal constructs, but it would cost some of the lifespan. Even with these limits, her power is treated as a tremendous asset, and she's almost forced into negating all the work that went into incapacitating Doflamingo's officers.

to:

** Gnome Princess Mansherry can use her Chiyu Chiyu no Mi/Heal-Heal Fruit power to heal any living thing that is wounded or injured, via SwissArmyTears or floating dandelions. She can only produce so many of the former at a time, while the latter is either temporary or based on EquivalentExchange via EnergyDonation. She can also heal constructs, but it would cost some of the her lifespan. Even with these limits, her Mansherry's power is treated as a tremendous asset, and she's almost forced into negating all the work that went into incapacitating Doflamingo's officers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on work content


* ''Franchise/{{Persona}}'': Downplayed. The original ''VideoGame/Persona1'' shows HealingHands Dia line of spells used by Personas, while effective on fellow Persona users and other supernatural entities, don't really work properly on people who have not awakened their Personas. At one point, the party members attempt to heal a schoolmate, and they find that healing spells only give an effect comparable to massaging. ''VideoGame/Persona3'' has Chidori being able to heal dead flowers back to life, but she does so with her unique EmpathicHealer ability rather than the standard HealingHands spells. [[spoiler:The same game also implies Persona users who are rendered unable or unwilling to evoke their Personas are also difficult to heal normally, as Shinjiro and Junpei can attest to.]]

to:

* ''Franchise/{{Persona}}'': Downplayed. Implied. The original ''VideoGame/Persona1'' shows HealingHands Dia line of spells used by Personas, the party members, while effective on fellow Persona users and other supernatural entities, don't really work properly on people who have not awakened their Personas. yet to awaken the Persona. At one point, the party members attempt attempts to heal a schoolmate, and they find that healing spells only give an effect comparable to massaging. ''VideoGame/Persona3'' has Chidori being able to heal dead flowers back to life, but she does so with her unique EmpathicHealer ability rather than the standard HealingHands spells. [[spoiler:The same game also implies Persona users who are rendered unable or unwilling to evoke their Personas are also difficult to heal normally, with ordinary healing, as Shinjiro and Junpei can attest to.]]to]]. ''VideoGame/Persona4'' also has [[spoiler:the Investigation Team cannot do anything to help Nanako recover when in the TV world, as she is not a Persona user]]. The reason it is this trope is because entities ''other'' than human Persona users (Igor, Philemon, Trish) can use healing magic on ordinary humans just fine, showcasing a disparity between ordinary Persona users and actual practitioners of magic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
markup slip


* ''Webcomic/{{Castoff}}'': While Vector thinks Arianna would heal the [[AgonyOfTheFeet cuts on his feet]], the best she can do is clean them with a spell and bandage them. Arianna explains there's no such thing as a healing magic, and, being a competent mage and the story's main source of magic-related {{Exposition}}, she'd know. [[spoiler: Then again, Marina does heal the cuts on Vector's hands a few chapters afterwards. Then ''again'', she's hinted to be exceptional. As we [[ {{flashback}} learn later]], Sage has been somewhat obsessive in trying to invent healing magic in his youth, but there's no indication he succeeded.]]

to:

* ''Webcomic/{{Castoff}}'': While Vector thinks Arianna would heal the [[AgonyOfTheFeet cuts on his feet]], the best she can do is clean them with a spell and bandage them. Arianna explains there's no such thing as a healing magic, and, being a competent mage and the story's main source of magic-related {{Exposition}}, she'd know. [[spoiler: Then again, Marina does heal the cuts on Vector's hands a few chapters afterwards. Then ''again'', she's hinted to be exceptional. As we [[ {{flashback}} learn later]], in a {{flashback}}, Sage has been somewhat obsessive in trying to invent healing magic in his youth, but there's no indication he succeeded.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Webcomic/{{Castoff}}'': While Vector thinks Arianna would heal the [[AgonyOfTheFeet cuts on his feet]], the best she can do is clean them with a spell and bandage them. Arianna explains there's no such thing as a healing magic, and, being a competent mage and the story's main source of magic-related {{Exposition}}, she'd know. [[spoiler: Then again, Marina does heal the cuts on Vector's hands a few chapters afterwards. Then ''again'', she's hinted to be exceptional.]]

to:

* ''Webcomic/{{Castoff}}'': While Vector thinks Arianna would heal the [[AgonyOfTheFeet cuts on his feet]], the best she can do is clean them with a spell and bandage them. Arianna explains there's no such thing as a healing magic, and, being a competent mage and the story's main source of magic-related {{Exposition}}, she'd know. [[spoiler: Then again, Marina does heal the cuts on Vector's hands a few chapters afterwards. Then ''again'', she's hinted to be exceptional. As we [[ {{flashback}} learn later]], Sage has been somewhat obsessive in trying to invent healing magic in his youth, but there's no indication he succeeded.]]

Added: 857

Changed: 670

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Fan Works ]]

to:

[[folder:Fan Works ]]Works]]



* ''Franchise/StarWars'': The Force can supposedly be used to heal, but the ability to do so is extremely specialized and only three onscreen characters ([[spoiler:''Series/TheMandalorian'' having Grogu, and ''Film/TheRiseOfSkywalker'' having Kylo Ren and Rey, and even then Kylo dies by healing Rey after an intense battle]]) have ever demonstrates the power. Darth Plagueis allegedly developed this kind of ability, but even his apprentice Palpatine did not know how it worked. Which kind of sucked for Anakin since he turned to the Dark Side specifically because Palpatine promised to teach him how to do it.

to:

* ''Franchise/StarWars'': The ''Franchise/StarWars'':
** In the ContinuityReboot the
Force can supposedly be used to heal, but the ability to do so is extremely specialized and only three onscreen characters ([[spoiler:''Series/TheMandalorian'' having Grogu, and ''Film/TheRiseOfSkywalker'' having Kylo Ren and Rey, and even then Kylo [[CastFromHitPoints dies by healing Rey after an intense battle]]) battle]]]]) have ever demonstrates demonstrated the power. Darth Plagueis allegedly power.
** In the [[Franchise/StarWarsLegends original continuity]] this power was used much more frequently, but was difficult to master and required intense concentration. Literature/DarthPlagueis
developed this kind of ability, a DarkSide variant so potent it [[{{Necromancer}} could raise the dead]], but even his apprentice Palpatine did not know how it worked. Which kind of sucked for Anakin since he turned to the Dark Side [[{{necromantic}} specifically because Palpatine promised to teach him how to do it.it]].



* This trope is usually played straight in the Franchise/StarWarsExpandedUniverse, where there are many examples of reliable Force healing, but it's often presented as being more difficult than most areas of Force manipulation. In ''Literature/CloneWarsGambit,'' it's noted that Obi-Wan has some skill in this area, but it's difficult and draining, especially since the healer has to experience at least some of the pain of the injured. It's very possible for incautious healers to overexert themselves and burn themselves out.
** One novel included Darth Vader himself attempting to heal his injuries using the Dark Side of the Force, and making at least some progress. But he ultimately failed, as [[ThePowerOfHate the Dark Side is powered by hatred and anger]], and he was unable to sustain those emotions through the healing.

to:

* This trope is usually played straight in the Franchise/StarWarsExpandedUniverse, ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'', where there are many examples of reliable Force healing, but it's often presented as being more difficult than most areas of Force manipulation. In ''Literature/CloneWarsGambit,'' it's noted that Obi-Wan has some skill in this area, but it's difficult and draining, especially since the healer has to experience at least some of the pain of the injured. It's very possible for incautious healers to overexert themselves and burn themselves out.
** One novel ''Literature/ShadowsOfTheEmpire'' included Darth Vader himself attempting to heal his injuries using the Dark Side TheDarkSide of the Force, and making at least some progress. But he ultimately failed, as [[ThePowerOfHate the Dark Side is powered by hatred and anger]], and he was [[BeingEvilSucks unable to sustain those emotions through the healing.healing]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Buddha:''' You are the fool. You think you are powerful because you can kill and destroy. True power lies in healing and restoration.

to:

'''Buddha:''' -->'''Buddha:''' You are the fool. You think you are powerful because you can kill and destroy. True power lies in healing and restoration.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I remember reading this anecdote decades ago, but can't find the specific source today. Still including it because the message fits.

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Mythology and Religion]]
* Anecdotally, Buddha was once accosted by a bandit who threatens to kill him, asking what's so good about Buddhism. So Buddha asks the bandit to break a branch from a tree nearby, which the Bandit does easily. Then Buddha asks the bandit to put the branch back to where it was. The bandit mocks Buddha saying that's impossible, and Buddha retorts back:
'''Buddha:''' You are the fool. You think you are powerful because you can kill and destroy. True power lies in healing and restoration.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender'': Jeong Jeong describes the healing subset of waterbending to Katara as something very few are able to do, and something that only true masters are able to perfect. When the Gaang gets to the enormous city of the Northern Water Tribe, Katara attends a healing class and sees only five other girls in training.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/AvatarTheLastAirbender'': Jeong Jeong describes the healing subset of waterbending to Katara as something very few are able to do, and something that only true masters are able to perfect. When the Gaang gets to the enormous city of the Northern Water Tribe, Katara attends a healing class and sees only five other girls in training. Which is another reason Katara is annoyed that it's [[StayInTheKitchen the only waterbending women are allowed to do]]. She manages it anyway, in addition to learning the combat arts. By ''WesternAnimation/TheLegendOfKorra'', Korra justifies her own healing ability because Katara trained her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/FateRevelationOnline'': Healing magic is the first magecraft to get hit with the DifficultySpike of increased realism. While it starts as simply filling up the HP bar, soon basic anatomy is introduced, requiring healers to seal up the wound and replace lost flesh manually. Then more anatomy is introduced, requiring more skill from the healers, so on and so on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* All superpowers in ''Manga/ChainsawMan'' are derived from [[OurDemonsAreDifferent devils]] and NoCureForEvil is in full effect. Devils [[HealItWithBlood heal by drinking blood]] but [[DealWithTheDevil make contracts]] just to harm humans via payments, so you're hard-pressed to find a devil willing and able to heal them. The only established cases have involved [[DemonOfHumanOrigin becoming a least partially demonic yourself]] to gain said self-regeneration, which seems very rare (and [[InhumanableAlienRights means you aren't legally human anymore]]). [[spoiler:The real Santa Claus]] needed a contract with one of the most power devils in existence to heal her body, though it also gave a very impressive HealingFactor on top of that.

to:

* All superpowers in ''Manga/ChainsawMan'' are derived from [[OurDemonsAreDifferent devils]] and NoCureForEvil is in full effect. Devils [[HealItWithBlood heal by drinking blood]] but [[DealWithTheDevil make contracts]] just to harm humans via payments, so you're hard-pressed to find a devil willing and able to heal them. The only established cases have involved [[DemonOfHumanOrigin becoming a least partially demonic yourself]] to gain said self-regeneration, which seems very rare (and [[InhumanableAlienRights means you aren't legally human anymore]]). [[spoiler:The real Santa Claus]] needed a contract with one of the most power powerful devils in existence to heal her body, though it also gave a very impressive HealingFactor on top of that.



* In the world of ''Manga/JujutsuKaisen'', all magic (known as Jujutsu) is [[ThePowerOfHate powered by negative emotion]], and is thus, in it's natural state, harmful and destructive. The only way to heal a human body with Jujutsu is to reverse Cursed Energy to create Positive Energy, a process so complex that even ''[[WorldsStrongestMan Gojo Satoru]]'', universally regarded as the most powerful wielder of Jujutsu in the current era, can only use it to heal himself. Of all the characters introduced so far; only ''three'' Sorcerers ([[TheMedic Shoko Ieiri]], [[ChildProdigy Yuta Okketsu]], and [[TheArchmage Ryomen Sukuna]]) have displayed full mastery of it.

to:

* In the world of ''Manga/JujutsuKaisen'', all magic (known as Jujutsu) is [[ThePowerOfHate powered by negative emotion]], and is thus, in it's its natural state, harmful and destructive. The only way to heal a human body with Jujutsu is to reverse Cursed Energy to create Positive Energy, a process so complex that even ''[[WorldsStrongestMan Gojo Satoru]]'', universally regarded as the most powerful wielder of Jujutsu in the current era, can only use it to heal himself. Of all the characters introduced so far; only ''three'' Sorcerers ([[TheMedic Shoko Ieiri]], [[ChildProdigy Yuta Okketsu]], Okkotsu]], and [[TheArchmage Ryomen Sukuna]]) have displayed full mastery of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Only in the 3rd and 3.5 editions did Arcane healing spells (i.e. ones that don't require godlike powers) begin to proliferate. Oddly enough, [[SpoonyBard Bards]] (and anyone with shenanigans to take spells from the bard list) are fully able to heal through arcane spells. The other group who can pull that off are dragons, but they are [[SuperiorSpecies dragons]].

to:

** Only in the 3rd and 3.5 editions did Arcane healing spells (i.e. ones that don't require godlike powers) begin to proliferate. Oddly enough, [[SpoonyBard [[TheBard Bards]] (and anyone with shenanigans to take spells from the bard list) are fully able to heal through arcane spells. The other group who can pull that off are dragons, but they are [[SuperiorSpecies dragons]].



*** Mending is a cantrip used to repair a broken object. Cue long arguments between players and DMs on whether a Warforged (sentient golems/robots) can be restored by the spell.

to:

*** ** Mending is a cantrip used to repair a broken object. Cue long arguments between players and DMs [[GameMaster DMs]] on whether a Warforged (sentient golems/robots) can be restored by the spell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While there are still ways of treating injuries with magic in ''Manga/FairyTail'' (for instance, one of Ichiya's perfumes acts as a painkiller and can cure some poison), actual ''healing'' magic is considered a lost art. The only three beings who are shown to possess healing magic are Wendy, Chelia, and [[spoiler:Acnologia]]. The former two are masters of rare Lost Magic involving [[BlowYouAway wind manipulation]] and while they can heal even fatal wounds and heavily implied could even do the same to severed limbs, it drains their own energy to do so which increases with wound severity. The latter [[spoiler:is [[ReallySevenHundredYearsOld over 400 years old]] from a time where it was more common and even his wasn't nearly as impressive as theirs (he could only stop bleeding, not fully heal wounds or even null pain). Plus, he kinda gave up on healing magic after a traumatic event and devoted himself to ''destructive'' magic.]]

to:

* While there are still ways of treating injuries with magic in ''Manga/FairyTail'' (for instance, one of Ichiya's perfumes acts as a painkiller and can cure some poison), poisons, Slayer Wizards can restore stamina and power from consuming their respective elements, Brandish's {{Sizeshifter}} magic can be used to shrink wounds to negligible scratches), actual ''healing'' magic is considered a lost art. The only three beings who are shown to possess healing magic are Wendy, Chelia, and [[spoiler:Acnologia]]. The former two are masters of rare Lost Magic involving [[BlowYouAway wind manipulation]] and while they can heal even fatal wounds and heavily implied could even do the same to severed limbs, it drains their own energy to do so which increases with wound severity. The latter [[spoiler:is [[ReallySevenHundredYearsOld over 400 years old]] from a time where it was more common and even his wasn't nearly as impressive as theirs (he could only stop bleeding, not fully heal wounds or even null pain). Plus, he kinda gave up on healing magic after a traumatic event and devoted himself to ''destructive'' magic.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''TabletopGame/{{Shadowrun}}'' has a variation where magical instant healing becomes harder depending on the target, forcing players to choose between cyberware and the lack of healing potential that comes with [[CyberneticsEatYourSoul essence loss]]. Damaging magic works just fine on everyone.

Top