Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / FreudianExcuseDenial

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''ComicBook/TheImmortalThor'', Dario Agger, when asked about his motivation, muses that he ''could'' spin a story about any manner of other things to explain his rampant CorruptCorporateExecutive ways, before admitting, with pride, that his sole motivation is a whole lot shallower than that.
-->''"Oh... I could make a speech, I suppose. Some Roxxtube-ready blather--pop-fascism for the rubes and the tech bros. I could blame my tragic childhood or the lust for blood and cruelty that never abates...or revenge, of course... You'd believe revenge... But the truth, Thor? Absolute and unvarnished? I like it when the number goes up. That's all. Because that means I win. That means I'm better. And that's all there is."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyMakeYourMark'': In "Roots of All Evil Pt. 2", Misty and Sunny accuse Opaline of being evil [[IJustWantToHaveFriends due to never having friends and the real reason she wanted power was to force others to be hers]], she rebuffs those attempts to reach out to her. Notably when she gives a {{Flashback}} claiming her FreudianExcuse was [[spoiler:Celestia and Luna]] being favored over her, what's shown make it look like it was jealousy of the their friendship and them ignoring her.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyMakeYourMark'': In "Roots of All Evil Pt. 2", Misty and Sunny accuse Opaline of being evil [[IJustWantToHaveFriends due to never having friends and the real reason she wanted power was to force others to be hers]], but she rebuffs those attempts to reach out to her. Notably when she gives a {{Flashback}} claiming her FreudianExcuse was [[spoiler:Celestia and Luna]] being favored over her, what's shown make makes it look like it was jealousy of the their friendship and them ignoring her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/SheRaAndThePrincessesOfPower'': [[ImpliedTrope Implied]] in "[[Recap/SheRaAndThePrincessesOfPowerS3E01ThePriceOfPower The Price Of Power]]", when Bow and Glimmer appeal to Adora that she isn't like Shadow Weaver or the rest of the Horde, she suggests it's only considered such due to her nature as She-Ra. She was just like the Horde until she realized it was wrong and left.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In ''Film/ElCamino'', [[Characters/BreakingBadJessePinkman Jesse Pinkman]] admits that, despite the trauma he went through and his contentious relationship with his parents, his crimes are ultimately no one else's fault but his own and tells them as much in a phone call, which are the last words he ever says to them.

to:

** In ''Film/ElCamino'', [[Characters/BreakingBadJessePinkman Jesse Pinkman]] Pinkman admits that, despite the trauma he went through and his contentious relationship with his parents, his crimes are ultimately no one else's fault but his own and tells them as much in a phone call, which are the last words he ever says to them.



** [[Characters/BreakingBadSaulGoodman Saul Goodman/Jimmy McGill]], in his own series finale, seems set to avoid the vast majority of legal repercussions he'd normally take for his crimes by blaming them on coercion and painting himself as a traumatized victim. But at the last minute, he throws that all away and admits that yes, he was traumatized by his contentious relationship with his brother and the way he died, and yes, he was terrified by criminals repeatedly kidnapping and threatening him to use his services, but none of that was any excuse for what he chose to do next.

to:

** [[Characters/BreakingBadSaulGoodman Saul Goodman/Jimmy McGill]], in [[Series/BetterCallSaul his own series finale, finale]], seems set to avoid the vast majority of legal repercussions he'd normally take for his crimes by blaming them on coercion and painting himself as a traumatized victim. But at the last minute, he throws that all away and admits that yes, he was traumatized by his contentious relationship with his brother and the way he died, and yes, he was terrified by criminals repeatedly kidnapping and threatening him to use his services, but none of that was any excuse for what he chose to do next.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/{{Amphibia}}'': [[Characters/AmphibiaKingAndrias King Andrias]] implicitly inflicts this on ''himself'' when he learns his millennium-long hatred of Leif, and his belief that [[AbusiveParents his father and the Core]] were right about his friendships' worthlessness, were all for nothing. He flat-out admits that regardless of the rather tragic reasons he had for becoming the evil tyrant, he's caused ''far'' too much suffering (to all of Amphibia and to a girl who genuinely cared about him) and has crossed too many moral boundaries to just be forgiven.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/{{Amphibia}}'': [[Characters/AmphibiaKingAndrias King Andrias]] Andrias implicitly inflicts this on ''himself'' when he learns his millennium-long hatred of Leif, and his belief that [[AbusiveParents his father and the Core]] were right about his friendships' worthlessness, were all for nothing. He flat-out admits that regardless of the rather tragic reasons he had for becoming the evil tyrant, he's caused ''far'' too much suffering (to all of Amphibia and to a girl who genuinely cared about him) and has crossed too many moral boundaries to just be forgiven.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Series/ShamelessUS Shameless]], early seasons had Ian in a relationship with his boss Kash: at the time, Kash was 30, while Ian was ''15''. When this is noted later, Ian denies that this was a problem because he was mature for his age and capable of making his own decisions, not seeming to realize that he was essentially groomed by a predator.

to:

* In [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Series/ShamelessUS Shameless]], ''Series/ShamelessUS'', early seasons had Ian in a relationship with his boss Kash: at the time, Kash was 30, while Ian was ''15''. When this is noted later, Ian denies that this was a problem because he was mature for his age and capable of making his own decisions, not seeming to realize that he was essentially groomed by a predator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Series/ShamelessUS Shameless]], early seasons had Ian in a relationship with his boss Kash: at the time, Kash was 30, while Ian was ''15''. When this is noted later, Ian denies that this was a problem because he was mature for his age, not seeming to realize just how troubling a relationship like that is.

to:

* In [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Series/ShamelessUS Shameless]], early seasons had Ian in a relationship with his boss Kash: at the time, Kash was 30, while Ian was ''15''. When this is noted later, Ian denies that this was a problem because he was mature for his age, age and capable of making his own decisions, not seeming to realize just how troubling a relationship like that is.he was essentially groomed by a predator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Series/ShamelessUS Shameless]], early seasons had Ian in a relationship with his boss Kash: at the time, Kash was 30, while Ian was ''15''. When this is noted later, Ian denies that this was a problem because he was mature for his age, not seeming to realize just how troubling a relationship like that is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/HarleyQuinn2019'': At first, it's made look like Harleen was a perfectly sane and respectable person until the Joker's manipulation and abuse transformed her into a psychotic and murderous villainess. However, [[Recap/HarleyQuinn2019S1E5BeingHarleyQuinn Being Harley Quinn]] has her go on a JourneyToTheCenterOfTheMind, which reveals that Harley has had AxCrazy tendencies ever since she was a child, long before Joker ever got to her; her attempts at playing with dolls involved a wife murdering a husband for cheating, she stalked her CelebCrush to the point legal actions needed to be taken, and she [[NoodleIncident may have]] killed a girl at her camp for spreading [[BestialityIsDepraved humiliating rumors]] about her. The final memory reveals that Harley in fact [[spoiler:jumped into the chemical vat of her own volition, but repressed that part since it had always been easier to give agency to the Joker and blame him for her turn to villainy.]] In the end, the Joker didn't corrupt her so much as reawaken [[MaskOfSanity what was already there]] and Harley acknowledges that she is responsible for her own life and had a choice every step of the way. Neither the Joker nor her "fucked up parents" made Harleen Quinzel into Harley Quinn; she made herself.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/HarleyQuinn2019'': At first, it's made look like Harleen [[Characters/HarleyQuinn2019TheCharacter Harleen]] was a perfectly sane and respectable person until the Joker's manipulation and abuse transformed her into a psychotic and murderous villainess. However, [[Recap/HarleyQuinn2019S1E5BeingHarleyQuinn Being Harley Quinn]] has her go on a JourneyToTheCenterOfTheMind, which reveals that Harley has had AxCrazy tendencies ever since she was a child, long before Joker ever got to her; her attempts at playing with dolls involved a wife murdering a husband for cheating, she stalked her CelebCrush to the point legal actions needed to be taken, and she [[NoodleIncident may have]] killed a girl at her camp for spreading [[BestialityIsDepraved humiliating rumors]] about her. The final memory reveals that Harley in fact [[spoiler:jumped into the chemical vat of her own volition, but repressed that part since it had always been easier to give agency to the Joker and blame him for her turn to villainy.]] In the end, the Joker didn't corrupt her so much as reawaken [[MaskOfSanity what was already there]] and Harley acknowledges that she is responsible for her own life and had a choice every step of the way. Neither the Joker nor her "fucked up parents" made Harleen Quinzel into Harley Quinn; she made herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/BlueEyedSamurai'': The ArcVillain of Season 1, Abijah Fowler, tells his DarkAndTroubledPast to Heiji Shindo where as a child during the Nine Years' War and the subsequent Ulster famine in Ireland, both his parents died and he had to cannibalize his sister's corpse to survive. In that same breath however, he makes it perfectly clear he doesn't see it as an excuse or reason for why he became such a monster. In fact, he thinks it simply empowers him to go farther than most reasonably would in an attempt to take what ''he'' believes belongs to him, and given his ambitions, is effectively ''all'' of Japan regardless of the pain he's going to inflict.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/BlueEyedSamurai'': ''WesternAnimation/BlueEyeSamurai'': The ArcVillain of Season 1, Abijah Fowler, tells his DarkAndTroubledPast to Heiji Shindo where as a child during the Nine Years' War and the subsequent Ulster famine in Ireland, both his parents died and he had to cannibalize his sister's corpse to survive. In that same breath however, he makes it perfectly clear he doesn't see it as an excuse or reason for why he became such a monster. In fact, he thinks it simply empowers him to go farther than most reasonably would in an attempt to take what ''he'' believes belongs to him, and given his ambitions, is effectively ''all'' of Japan regardless of the pain he's going to inflict.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/BlueEyedSamurai'': The ArcVillain of Season 1, Abijah Fowler, tells his DarkAndTroubledPast to Heiji Shindo where as a child during the Nine Years' War and the subsequent Ulster famine in Ireland, both his parents died and he had to cannibalize his sister's corpse to survive. In that same breath however, he makes it perfectly clear he doesn't see it as an excuse or reason for why he became such a monster. In fact, he thinks it simply empowers him to go farther than most reasonably would in an attempt to take what ''he'' believes belongs to him, and given his ambitions, is effectively ''all'' of Japan regardless of the pain he's going to inflict.
-->'''Abijah Fowler''': It was the last thing I ever did because I had to, ''I'' control my life now. Every bite.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Contrast FreudianExcuse, where the person on whom the method is used thinks that the experience certainly ''did'' influence them. FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse is when another character says that the first character had a harsh upbringing, but it doesn't justify or make up for their actions. Can possibly overlap with this trope if the first character doesn't believe in the justification themselves.

to:

Contrast FreudianExcuse, where the person on whom the method is used thinks that the experience certainly ''did'' influence them. FreudianExcuseIsNoExcuse is when another character says that the first character had a harsh upbringing, but it doesn't justify or make up for their actions. Can possibly overlap with this trope if the first character person doesn't believe in the influence or justification themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added example(s)


'''Veneer''': Girl, [[SurprisinglyNormalBackground we grew up in the suburbs. Our parents were dentists.]]\\

to:

'''Veneer''': Girl, [[SurprisinglyNormalBackground we grew up in the suburbs. Our parents were dentists.]]\\\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/TrollsBandTogether:'' When her brother and fellow member of the BigBadDuumvirate Veneer displays remorse, Velvet tries to dissuade him by bringing up their DarkAndTroubledPast as poor orphans.
-->'''Velvet:''' Do you want to lose all this and go back to that dark place where we had nothing?!\\
''(Cuts to Velvet and Veneer as [[ShoutOut Oliver Twist-esque orphans]])''\\
'''Young Veneer:''' Please, sir, I want some more.\\
''(Cuts back to present)''\\
'''Veneer''': Girl, [[SurprisinglyNormalBackground we grew up in the suburbs. Our parents were dentists.]]\\
''(Cuts to a flashback of their actual childhood)''\\
'''Velvet and Veneer's father''': ''(offscreen)'' So, how was school today?\\
'''Young Velvet''': STOP ATTACKING ME!\\
''(Velvet flips the table over)''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyMakeYourMark'': In "Roots of All Evil Pt. 2", Misty and Sunny accuse Opaline of being evil [[IJustWantToHaveFriends due to never having friends and the real reason she wanted power was to force others to be hers]], she rebuffs those attempts to reach out to her. Notably when she gives a {{Flashback}} claiming her FreudianExcuse was [[spoiler:Celestia and Luna]] being favored over her, what's shown make it look like it was jealousy of the their friendship and ignoring her.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyMakeYourMark'': In "Roots of All Evil Pt. 2", Misty and Sunny accuse Opaline of being evil [[IJustWantToHaveFriends due to never having friends and the real reason she wanted power was to force others to be hers]], she rebuffs those attempts to reach out to her. Notably when she gives a {{Flashback}} claiming her FreudianExcuse was [[spoiler:Celestia and Luna]] being favored over her, what's shown make it look like it was jealousy of the their friendship and them ignoring her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyMakeYourMark'': In "Roots of All Evil Pt. 2", Misty and Sunny accuse Opaline of being evil [[IJustWantToHaveFriends due to never having friends and the real reason she wanted power was to force others to be hers]], she rebuffs those attempts to reach out to her. Notably when she gives a {{Flashback}} claiming her FreudianExcuse was [[spoiler:Celestia and Luna]] being favored over her, what's shown make it look like it was jealousy of the their friendship and ignoring her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/AllForLuz'', All For One tells Luz he'd most likely still be a tyrannical monster on purpose with his PowerParasite Quirk, even if he didn't suffer from the FantasticRacism in his youth, much to the girl's annoyance.

Added: 321

Changed: 1393

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/BreakingBad''/''Series/BetterCallSaul'': The emotional climax of each protagonist's character arc is basically this.
** [[Characters/BreakingBadWalterWhite Walter White]], asserts that he was forced into committing his crimes by circumstance until the very last episode of the series, when he admits the true reason.
--->'''Walt:''' I did it for me. I liked it. I was good at it. And I was really... I was alive.
** [[Characters/BreakingBadJessePinkman Jesse Pinkman]] in ''Film/ElCamino'' admits that, despite the trauma he went through and his contentious relationship with his parents, his crimes are ultimately no one's fault but his own. He tells them as much in a phone call, which is the last words he ever says to them.

to:

* ''Series/BreakingBad''/''Series/BetterCallSaul'': The In both ''Series/BreakingBad'' and ''Series/BetterCallSaul'', the emotional climax of each protagonist's character arc is basically this.
** In the GrandFinale, [[Characters/BreakingBadWalterWhite Walter White]], asserts after spending the whole series justifying his increasingly crueler and immoral actions as being all for the greater good of ensuring [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes his family]] will have a stable financial safety net after he dies from his cancer, finally admits in an honest conversation with his wife that even though he might've started with a noble goal, he still committed all kinds of criminal actions (made all the more egregious by the fact that he was forced did have a legitimate option to accomplish his goals presented to him early on, which he rejected solely because he didn't want to accept any "charity" from [[NeverMyFault the people he blamed for his own failures]]) and willingly threw himself into committing his crimes by circumstance until the very last episode drug trade because of the series, when he admits power, notoriety, and massive ego boost it gave him.
--->'''Skyler:''' (growling) If I have to hear ''one more time'' that you did this for
the true reason.
--->'''Walt:'''
family-\\
'''Walt:'''
I did it for me. I liked it. I was good at it. And I was really... I was alive.
''alive''.
** In ''Film/ElCamino'', [[Characters/BreakingBadJessePinkman Jesse Pinkman]] in ''Film/ElCamino'' admits that, despite the trauma he went through and his contentious relationship with his parents, his crimes are ultimately no one's one else's fault but his own. He own and tells them as much in a phone call, which is are the last words he ever says to them.



** [[Characters/BreakingBadSaulGoodman Saul Goodman/Jimmy McGill]], in his own series finale, seems set to avoid the vast majority of legal repercussions he'd normally take for his crimes by blaming them on coercion and painting himself as a traumatized victim. But at the last minute he throws that all away and admits that yes, he was traumatized by his brother's death, and yes, he was terrified by criminals repeatedly kidnapping and threatening him, but none of that was any excuse for what he chose to do next.
--->'''Jimmy:''' I was terrified... but not for long. That night I saw an opportunity—a shot at big money—and I grabbed it, and I held it tight. And for the next sixteen months... my every waking moment was spent building Walter White's drug empire... I wasn't there when the meth was cooked. I wasn't there when it was sold. I didn't witness any of the murders. But I damn well knew it was happening. I was more than a willing participant, I was indispensable. I kept Walter White out of jail. I laundered his money, I lied for him, I conspired with him, and I made ''millions''! If he hadn't walked into my office that day, Walter White would've been dead or behind bars within a month. And Agent Schrader, and Agent Gomez, and a whole lot of other people would still be alive.

to:

** [[Characters/BreakingBadSaulGoodman Saul Goodman/Jimmy McGill]], in his own series finale, seems set to avoid the vast majority of legal repercussions he'd normally take for his crimes by blaming them on coercion and painting himself as a traumatized victim. But at the last minute minute, he throws that all away and admits that yes, he was traumatized by his brother's death, contentious relationship with his brother and the way he died, and yes, he was terrified by criminals repeatedly kidnapping and threatening him, him to use his services, but none of that was any excuse for what he chose to do next.
--->'''Jimmy:''' I was terrified... but not for long. That night I saw an opportunity—a opportunity — a shot at big money—and money — and I grabbed it, and I held it tight. And for the next sixteen months... my every waking moment was spent building Walter White's drug empire... I wasn't there when the meth was cooked. I wasn't there when it was sold. I didn't witness any of the murders. But I damn well knew it was happening. I was more than a willing participant, I was indispensable. I kept Walter White out of jail. I laundered his money, I lied for him, I conspired with him, and I made ''millions''! If he hadn't walked into my office that day, Walter White would've been dead or behind bars within a month. And Agent Schrader, and Agent Gomez, and a whole lot of other people would still be alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Fanfic/ThisBites'', after Cross came down from a rage against two bigoted fishmen, Koala asks him "Who was it?", assuming someone close to him was victimized by racism. Cross angrily tells her that he was never personally affected by bigotry and sure as hell doesn't ''need'' a personal reason to hate it fundamentally.

to:

* In A rare ([[ThePiratesWhoDontDoAnything anti-]]) heroic example in ''Fanfic/ThisBites'', after Cross came down from a rage against two bigoted fishmen, Koala asks him "Who "[[DeathByOriginStory Who was it?", it?]]", assuming someone close to him was victimized by racism. Cross angrily tells her that he was never personally affected by bigotry and sure as hell doesn't ''need'' a personal reason [[EveryoneHasStandards to hate it fundamentally.fundamentally]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/PussInBootsTheLastWish'': The Ethical Bug, serving as [[TheSociopath "Big" Jack Horner]]'s conscience, believes that there is good in all people and thus asks Jack about his childhood, hoping to find a FreudianExcuse for his evil behavior. At first, Jack talks about how he didn't have much as a kid but then subverts the cricket's expectations by revealing he had loving parents, a big mansion, and a giant family-owned pie industry. [[SpoiledBrat All of which he considers to be useless crap]], which is why he wants to use the Wishing Star to claim all magic in the world for himself alone. Considering that he doesn't mention to the Ethical Bug that his desire to control magic came from his jealousy of being upstaged by Pinocchio (as seen in his flashback), it's clear that Jack is simply trolling the Ethical Bug for [[GoodCannotComprehendEvil not accepting]] that [[CardCarryingVillain he's an irredeemable monster who's emotionally dead inside]].

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/PussInBootsTheLastWish'': The Ethical Bug, serving as [[TheSociopath "Big" [[Characters/PussInBootsJackHorner "Big"/"Little" Jack Horner]]'s Horner's]] conscience, believes that there is good in all people and thus asks Jack about his childhood, hoping to find a FreudianExcuse for his evil behavior. At first, Jack talks about how he didn't have much as a kid but then subverts the cricket's expectations by revealing he had loving parents, a big mansion, and a giant family-owned pie industry. [[SpoiledBrat All of which he considers to be useless crap]], which is why he wants to use the Wishing Star to claim all magic in the world for himself alone. Considering that he doesn't mention to the Ethical Bug that his desire to control magic came from his jealousy of being upstaged by Pinocchio (as seen in his flashback), it's clear that Jack is simply trolling the Ethical Bug for [[GoodCannotComprehendEvil not accepting]] that [[CardCarryingVillain he's an irredeemable monster who's emotionally dead inside]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** PlayedWith in the episode "[[Recap/TheOwlHouseS2E14ReachingOut Reaching Out]]". While Luz's actions during the episode stem from Luz missing her long-dead father, she admits that she can't use that as an excuse and sincerely apologizes to Amity.

to:

** PlayedWith in the episode "[[Recap/TheOwlHouseS2E14ReachingOut Reaching Out]]". While Luz's actions during the episode stem from Luz missing [[spoiler:it being the anniversary of her long-dead father, late father's death and the first year since he died that she isn't able to be with her mother]], she admits that she can't use that as an excuse and sincerely apologizes to Amity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Maeve Fly'', Maeve repeatedly states that she has no tragic backstory that "made" her a serial killer, she just likes it. Although Maeve's life crumbles over the course of the book, that's doesn't ''cause'' her to be violent--she's already killed several people before anything bad happens to her, and she commits a sadistic sexual assault (penetrating a woman with a curling iron and coming extremely close to turning it on) while she's having a great night. Losing the things that matter to her just gives her specific targets and removes any reason for restraint. As she tells one of her victims, she might just have done all this anyway.

Top