Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / CannotTellALie

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Maura Isles from ''RizzoliAndIsles'' physically cannot tell a lie.
-->'''Jane:''' I thought you said you couldn't lie!\\
'''Maura:''' What do you mean? I can't!\\
'''Jane:''' You did.\\
'''Maura:''' Only ''one'' time, when I said I finished my homework and I hadn't, and I immediately went vasovagal. [''clarifies''] Fainted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The main character of ''LiarLiar'' was forced to never tell a lie for one day, to the point he couldn't speak one, write one, or even ask a question that would lead to a lie. Furthermore, he couldn't even conceal the truth by not speaking, which led to most of the film's humor. Also the fact that the "no lying" thing interfered with his occupation as a lawyer.

to:

* The main character of ''LiarLiar'' was forced to never tell a lie for one day, to the point he couldn't speak one, write one, or even ask a question that would lead to a lie. Furthermore, he couldn't even conceal the truth by not speaking, speaking or telling half-truths, which led to most of the film's humor. Also the fact that the "no lying" thing interfered with his occupation as a lawyer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Folk Lore]]
* GeorgeWashington was said to have remarked, "I cannot tell a lie", and admitting to chopping down his father's cherry tree. However, this is a myth.
** In a Paperinik New Adventures short they have fun with this story. It ends up with a time traveler landing on the tree and little George telling his father that he, George, chopped it down rather than trying to explain the truth.
** The Austrian satirist Roda Roda (1872-1945, born Sándor Friedrich Rosenfeld) parodied this in a story "from an American school primer": Young Abraham Lincoln and a playmate together chop down a cherry tree belonging to Lincoln's father. When the father asks them about it, the playmate fingers young Abe, who says: "I cannot tell a lie, father, I did it." - "That is exemplary behaviour, son, I see that you will become President one day." Turning to the other boy the father added: "You, however, who would not admit..." - "Save your breath, Mr. Lincoln, I'm James Buchanan, US President from 1857 to 1861."
[[/folder]]
Camacan MOD

Changed: 29

Removed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Move extra quote to the quotes page.


->[[ThisIsSPARTA "... I! Can't! LIE!"]]

to:

->[[ThisIsSPARTA "... I! ->''"I! Can't! LIE!"]]Lie!"''



->Truthful, adj: dumb and illiterate
-->-- '''Ambrose Bierce''', ''The Devil's Dictionary''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Plaidder's ''Women on Fire'' series, shriia are required to tell the truth at all times; a shriia who tells a lie permanently loses her ability to do her signature type of magic, making magical fire.

to:

* In Plaidder's ''Women on Fire'' series, shriia are required to tell the truth at all times; a shriia who tells a lie permanently loses her ability to do her make magical fire, the signature type of magic, making shriia magical fire. ability.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Plaidder's ''Women on Fire'' series, shriia are required to tell the truth at all times; a shriia who tells a lie permanently loses her ability to do magic.

to:

* In Plaidder's ''Women on Fire'' series, shriia are required to tell the truth at all times; a shriia who tells a lie permanently loses her ability to do magic.her signature type of magic, making magical fire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In Plaidder's ''Women on Fire'' series, shriia are required to tell the truth at all times; a shriia who tells a lie permanently loses her ability to do magic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''[[JaysJourney Jay's Journey]]'', the character of Puff can't lie, but he can definitely omit information. When asked by a villain if he's seen Jay, he manages to twist the conversation into making it seem as though he has no idea who Jay is, [[ExactWords all without lying]]. Specifically, he points out that he's traveling with [[RalphWiggum a complete moron]], which is true, while failing to point out that he's traveling with about a dozen ''other'' humans.

to:

* In ''[[JaysJourney Jay's Journey]]'', the character of Puff (and other dragons like him) can't lie, but he can definitely omit information. When asked by a villain if he's seen Jay, he manages to twist the conversation into making it seem as though he has no idea who Jay is, [[ExactWords all without lying]]. Specifically, he points out that he's traveling with [[RalphWiggum a complete moron]], which is true, while failing to point out that he's traveling with about a dozen ''other'' humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The guard who tells the truth in ''{{Labyrinth}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The protagonist of William Sleator's ''Others See Us'' cannot lie, at least until he gains telepathy and realizes everyone around him is lying [[strike:even]] ''especially'' to themselves.

to:

* The protagonist of William Sleator's WilliamSleator's ''Others See Us'' cannot lie, at least until he gains telepathy and realizes everyone around him is lying [[strike:even]] ''especially'' to themselves.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**As an aspie, I can say that it is rather easy for me to lie. Of course this is a learned thing, and I do tend to panic if caught in a lie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It's "cannot", not "can not". Even the page title is wrong


Children are prone to it, being [[ChildrenAreInnocent too innocent]] to think of suppressing the truth -- many truths have been blurted out by unwitting children -- but this can not be relied on; most children outgrow it. (Even if they may warn of it by becoming a BadLiar.)

to:

Children are prone to it, being [[ChildrenAreInnocent too innocent]] to think of suppressing the truth -- many truths have been blurted out by unwitting children -- but this can not cannot be relied on; most children outgrow it. (Even if they may warn of it by becoming a BadLiar.)



* In DanAbnett's ''{{Warhammer 40000}} GauntsGhosts'' novel ''Blood Pact'', the witch can not lie. About anything. And foresees the future. And ''babbles'' -- she can not even keep quiet.

to:

* In DanAbnett's ''{{Warhammer 40000}} GauntsGhosts'' novel ''Blood Pact'', the witch can not cannot lie. About anything. And foresees the future. And ''babbles'' -- she can not cannot even keep quiet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Quantum Cop of CaseyAndAndy can't lie - although he eventually gains the ability in the final arc as CharacterDevelopment.

Changed: 37

Removed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter cut.


** They're also pretty easy to trick.
*** However, most people online who claim to have Aspergers usually are lying as it is the most common self diagnosed condition to excuse {{Jerkass}}ery.

to:

** They're also pretty easy to trick.
*** However, most people online who claim to have Aspergers usually are lying as it is the most common self diagnosed condition to excuse {{Jerkass}}ery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Yorick (yes, that Yorick) in ''The Skull of Truth'' from Bruce Coville's ''Magic Shop'' series was "blessed" with the inability to lie. This led him to become a jester, the only position in which one could tell the king the truth and get away with it. It was implied this also led to his painful death, after which he became the title skull.

to:

* Yorick (yes, that Yorick) in ''The ''[[MagicShop The Skull of Truth'' Truth]]'' from Bruce Coville's ''Magic Shop'' {{Bruce Coville}}'s ''MagicShop'' series was "blessed" with the inability to lie. This led him to become a jester, the only position in which one could tell the king the truth and get away with it. It was implied this also led to his painful death, after which he became the title skull.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Due to a cookie-stealing incident as a toddler, Rod Allbright of {{Bruce Coville}}'s ''Aliens Ate My Homework'' cannot lie when asked a direct question. This leads to a number of instances of CassandraTruth once Grakker et al show up, including the titular response to a teacher's asking where his math assignment is.

to:

* Due to a cookie-stealing incident as a toddler, Rod Allbright Albright of {{Bruce Coville}}'s ''Aliens ''{{Aliens Ate My Homework'' Homework}}'' cannot lie when asked a direct question. This leads to a number of instances of CassandraTruth once Grakker et al show up, including the titular response to a teacher's asking where his math assignment is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Due to a cookie-stealing incident as a toddler, Rod Allbright of Bruce Coville's ''Aliens Ate My Homework'' cannot lie when asked a direct question. This leads to a number of instances of CassandraTruth once Grakker et al show up, including the titular response to a teacher's asking where his math assignment is.

to:

* Due to a cookie-stealing incident as a toddler, Rod Allbright of Bruce Coville's {{Bruce Coville}}'s ''Aliens Ate My Homework'' cannot lie when asked a direct question. This leads to a number of instances of CassandraTruth once Grakker et al show up, including the titular response to a teacher's asking where his math assignment is.

Changed: 534

Removed: 293

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The [[TheFairFolk faeries]] in ''TheDresdenFiles'' are unable to tell a direct lie, but that doesn't stop them from being shifty, misleading SOB's.
** Throughout most of the series, Harry himself can't tell a lie -- or, he technically can, but he's so shitty at it that everyone can see right through it. He seems to have gained the ability in later books, possibly as a result of [[spoiler: Lasciel's influence]].

to:

* The Similarly, the [[TheFairFolk faeries]] in ''TheDresdenFiles'' are unable to tell a direct lie, but that doesn't stop them from being shifty, misleading SOB's.
SOB's. It's been noted that when dealing with fae, there ''is'' no "spirit of the law," only [[ExactWords the letter]].
** Throughout most of the series, Harry himself can't tell a lie -- or, he technically can, but he's [[BadLiar so shitty awful at it it]] that everyone can see right through it. He seems to have gained the ability in later books, possibly as a result of [[spoiler: Lasciel's [[spoiler:Lasciel's influence]].



* The Aes Sedai from ''{{The Wheel of Time}}''. (Instead, they don't always tell the ''whole'' truth.) This was a magically-created prohibition to make people trust them. Unfortunately, because they refuse to go along with the spirit of the oath, they have such a reputation for bending the truth that people don't believe anything they say on the basis that they must be {{Literal Genie}}ing.
* Actually, Aes Sedai cleave to the Oath rather faithfully -- they literally ''cannot'' speak a lie, even when that lie would save millions of lives. Most Aes Sedai have found ways around the oath by not ''directly'' speaking a lie, but instead using careful phrasing to sneak around the Oath.

to:

* The Aes Sedai from ''{{The Wheel of Time}}''. (Instead, they don't always tell the ''whole'' truth.) This was a magically-created prohibition to make people trust them. Unfortunately, because they refuse to go along with the spirit of the oath, they have such a reputation for bending the truth that people don't believe anything they say on the basis that they must be {{Literal Genie}}ing.
* Actually, Aes Sedai cleave to the Oath rather faithfully -- they
They literally ''cannot'' speak a lie, even when that lie would save millions of lives. Most This was a magically-created prohibition to make people trust them. Unfortunately, because most Aes Sedai have found ways around the oath by not ''directly'' speaking a lie, but instead using careful phrasing to sneak around the Oath.Oath, they have such a reputation for bending the truth that people don't believe anything they say on the basis that they must be {{Literal Genie}}ing.



* In Tamora Pierce's second and third trilogies of the Tortallen books, one cannot lie around Griffins.

to:

* In Tamora Pierce's second and third trilogies of the Tortallen {{Tortall}} books, one cannot lie around Griffins.Griffins. Even their feathers share some of these properties; Kel uses them to see through illusions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***However, most people online who claim to have Aspergers usually are lying as it is the most common self diagnosed condition to excuse {{Jerkass}}ery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Liar Liar'' is a partial remake of the 1941 Bob Hope comedy ''Nothing But the Truth'', which by contrast has a WillNotTellALie plot: Hope's character bets $10,000 that he can go 24 hours without fibbing.

to:

** ''Liar Liar'' is a partial remake of the 1941 Bob Hope BobHope comedy ''Nothing But the Truth'', which by contrast has a WillNotTellALie plot: Hope's character bets $10,000 that he can go 24 hours without fibbing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is a Truth Serum


* In the episode of KimPossible "Truth Hurts", Kim and her comrade Ron are accidentally blasted by a TruthRay, forcing both of them to speak nothing but the truth. HilarityEnsues with Kim being unable to keep her darkest secrets to herself (including what her father said about his bosses in confidence) while Ron surprisingly gains popularity for a brief time due to saying things he never had the guts to say.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the episode of KimPossible "Truth Hurts", Kim and her comrade Ron are accidentally blasted by a TruthRay, forcing both of them to speak nothing but the truth. HilarityEnsues with Kim being unable to keep her darkest secrets to herself (including what her father said about his bosses in confidence) while Ron surprisingly gains popularity for a brief time due to saying things he never had the guts to say.

Added: 47

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Many people with autism, AspergerSyndrome, or the like have a hard time lying to others. Aspergers can impair the capability to think in 'abstract' concepts, so the concept of deception (which requires the use of abstract thought to effectively construct a believable lie) is often difficult for someone with Asperger's syndrome to grasp. Of course, it varies on a case-by-case basis; people with mild autism/Aspergers can often lie easily, while those with a more sever version often have to enact significant mental preparations before being able to lie, for making things up on the spot is much harder for then.[[/folder]]

to:

* Many people with autism, AspergerSyndrome, or the like have a hard time lying to others. Aspergers can impair the capability to think in 'abstract' concepts, so the concept of deception (which requires the use of abstract thought to effectively construct a believable lie) is often difficult for someone with Asperger's syndrome to grasp. Of course, it varies on a case-by-case basis; people with mild autism/Aspergers can often lie easily, while those with a more sever version often have to enact significant mental preparations before being able to lie, for making things up on the spot is much harder for then.then.
**They're also pretty easy to trick.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** They can't? Why are they used as spymasters? Why did Hawat try to infiltrate the Harkonons?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**They can't? Why are they used as spymasters? Why did Hawat try to infiltrate the Harkonons?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Subverted at the end of the book, though, [[spoiler: when he finally gets a lie out and it's believed... but only because it was a ''believable'' lie, unlike the [[CassandraTruth "aliens ate my homework" lie]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Franklyn from ''VivaPinata'' cannot lie or keep secrets at all, this is played as a running gag in many episodes
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
editing previous addition


->Truthful, adj: Dumb and Illiterate

to:

->Truthful, adj: Dumb dumb and Illiterateilliterate

Added: 54

Changed: 36

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
adding ambrose bierce



to:

->Truthful, adj: Dumb and Illiterate
-->-- '''Ambrose Bierce''', ''The Devil's Dictionary''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The main character of ''LiarLiar'' was forced to never tell a lie for one day, to the point he couldn't speak one, write one, or even ask a question that would lead to a lie. Furthermore, he couldn't even conceal the truth by not speaking, which led to most of the film's humor.

to:

* The main character of ''LiarLiar'' was forced to never tell a lie for one day, to the point he couldn't speak one, write one, or even ask a question that would lead to a lie. Furthermore, he couldn't even conceal the truth by not speaking, which led to most of the film's humor. Also the fact that the "no lying" thing interfered with his occupation as a lawyer.

Top