Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / StarTrekPicardFirewall

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PrivateMilitaryContractors: The Fenris Rangers used to be this alongside LawEnforcementInc. Played more sympathetically than most as they were seasoned professionals who enforced the law for legitimate governments with rules of engagement as well as a devotion to the rule of law. This has degraded due to the fact the government they used to serve no longer exists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LawEnforcementInc: The Fenris Rangers used to be a company of PrivateMilitaryContractors that handled law enforcement in the Qiris Sector. Played a lot more sympathetically than most, they proceeded to continue enforcing justice after the governments that hired them have collapsed. Now they're viewed as vigilantes.


Added DiffLines:

* VigilanteMan: This is how the Fenris Rangers are viewed by Starfleet. There's actually some wiggle room as they were a legitimate bunch of contracted police before but the governments that hired them no longer exist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MorallyBankruptBanker: Zigzagged with the Ferengi. Their banks are helping to launder General Kohgish's stolen wealth, but this is also in the middle of Rom's tenure as Grand Nagus. So, there's the x-factor of Rom's reforms and that impacting [[spoiler:Kohgish and Arastoo Mardani's attempt to recover the money Seven and the Fenris Rangers stole from them.]]

to:

* MorallyBankruptBanker: Zigzagged with the Ferengi. Their banks are helping to launder General Kohgish's stolen wealth, but this is also in the middle of Rom's tenure as Grand Nagus. So, there's the x-factor of Rom's ongoing reforms and that impacting [[spoiler:Kohgish and Arastoo Mardani's attempt to recover the money Seven and the Fenris Rangers stole from them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BothSidesHaveAPoint. Janeway's argument with the FSA Director about Seven's loyalties late in the novel. The Director ''isn't'' wrong about Seven's behavior during VOY Seasons Four and Five and her attempts to return to the Collective (especially prior to turning points of "The Raven" and "Dark Frontier"). Even after Seven chose ''Voyager'', her behavior and actions were still questionable during ''Voyager'''s final years in the Delta Quadrant. But Janeway likewise isn't wrong that Seven was experiencing culture shock and being separated from the only home and family she'd known for most of her life. Seven's more questionable actions were also out of her attempt to protect her surrogate Collective -- context that only the people who were actually aboard ''Voyager'' and saw Seven's struggles and growth firsthand can truly understand and appreciate.

to:

* BothSidesHaveAPoint. Janeway's argument with the FSA Director about Seven's loyalties late in the novel. The Director ''isn't'' wrong about Seven's behavior during VOY Seasons Four and Five and her attempts to return to the Collective (especially prior to turning points of [[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS4E6TheRaven "The Raven" Raven"]] and [[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS5E15DarkFrontier "Dark Frontier"). Frontier"]]). Even after Seven chose ''Voyager'', her behavior and actions were still questionable during ''Voyager'''s the ship's final years in the Delta Quadrant. But Janeway likewise isn't wrong that Seven was experiencing culture shock and being separated from the only home and family she'd known for most of her life. Seven's more questionable actions were also out of her attempt to protect her surrogate Collective -- context that only the people who were actually aboard ''Voyager'' and saw Seven's struggles and growth firsthand can truly understand and appreciate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FixFic: Among other things, Mack fills in the longstanding plot hole from ''Picard'' Season One of why [[spoiler:Bjayzl didn't try to harvest Seven's Borg tech if se was targeting ex-Drones. Seven used the scuffle on Zirat to sell a lie that her nanoprobes and implants had been permanently deactivated. The implication is that Bjayzl believed her -- which then backfired catastrophically as it's implied this is why she chose Icheb as a backup target.]]

to:

* FixFic: Among other things, Mack fills in the longstanding plot hole from ''Picard'' Season One of why [[spoiler:Bjayzl didn't try to harvest Seven's Borg tech if se she was targeting ex-Drones. Seven used the scuffle on Zirat to sell a lie that her nanoprobes and implants had been permanently deactivated. The implication is that Bjayzl believed her -- which then backfired catastrophically as it's implied this is why she chose Icheb as a backup target.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HowTheMightyHaveFallen: A retroactive variation for the Fenris Rangers during ''Picard'' Season One. Mack's take on the Rangers is that they ''were'' a legitimate, sanctioned frontier peacekeeping force prior to the 2380s. But as the Qiris Sector begins falling apart as a consequence of the Romulan Evacuation, they lost their legitimacy. The Rangers who remained to continue the fight are struggling to hold everything with limited resources and allies. Everything gets worse after the UFP abandons the Romulans and the Supernova and the organization's a fractured shadow of its former self by the time of ''Picard'' Season One.

Added: 211

Changed: 127

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ComingOfAgeStory: Mack [[https://atboundarysedge.com/2024/02/27/author-interview-david-mack/ acknowledges]] ''Firewall'' was constructed to be one for Seven (or at least be a Queernormative spin on the trope).



* ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections: Deconstructed. Janeway ''tries'' to use this trope and her favors and connections (both pre and post-''Voyager'' celebrityhood) to advocate for Seven. But in the end, it's just not enough to overcome the long-ingrained institutional hatred and terror everyone in the Federation government and military have towards anything Borg-related.

to:

* ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections: Deconstructed. Janeway ''tries'' to use this trope and her favors and connections (both pre and post-''Voyager'' celebrityhood) to advocate for Seven. If it were any other member of ''Voyager'''s crew, it would've worked. But in the end, it's even Janeway's celebrityhood and influence just not enough to can't overcome the long-ingrained institutional hatred and terror everyone in the Federation government and military have towards anything Borg-related.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Prequel}}: To Season One of ''Picard'', dramatizing how Seven of Nine joins the Fenris Rangers.

to:

* {{Prequel}}: To Season One of ''Picard'', dramatizing how Seven of Nine joins the Fenris Rangers. It's also a very loose prequel to Season One of ''Prodigy'' as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misplaced, moving to the correct tab


* PutOnABus: Aside from Seven and Janeway, none of the other VOY characters appear. This is justified at least with Chakotay (whose chronological status is locked in by the backstory of ''Prodigy'' Season One), the Doctor (due to ''Prodigy'' Season Two), and Tuvok (due to his ''Picard'' Season Three status quo).
* RankUp: According to Janeway's updates on the ''Voyager'' crew, Harry Kim has finally gotten a promotion. From a real-world perspective, it's also possible Mack ''couldn't'' use any other VOY characters to avoid contradicting whatever plans ''Prodigy'' or other projects may have for them.

to:

* PutOnABus: Aside from Seven and Janeway, none of the other VOY characters appear. This is justified at least with Chakotay (whose chronological status is locked in by the backstory of ''Prodigy'' Season One), the Doctor (due to ''Prodigy'' Season Two), and Tuvok (due to his ''Picard'' Season Three status quo). \n From a real-world perspective, it's also possible Mack ''couldn't'' use any other VOY characters to avoid contradicting whatever plans ''Prodigy'' or other current projects may have for them.
* RankUp: According to Janeway's updates on the ''Voyager'' crew, Harry Kim has finally gotten a promotion. From a real-world perspective, it's also possible Mack ''couldn't'' use any other VOY characters to avoid contradicting whatever plans ''Prodigy'' or other projects may have for them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Likewise, Starfleet and the Federation's reactionary response to Seven's Borg heritage also foreshadows how they'll respond to the Synth Attack on Mars and implement the Synth Ban.



** [[spoiler:Ellory Kayd's fate between the end of the 2381 narrative and the 2386 framing device. It's implied she and Seven eventually broke up in the interim, but her exact fate is left unrevealed.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Ellory Kayd's fate between the end of the 2381 narrative and the 2386 framing device. It's implied she and Seven eventually broke up in the interim, but her exact fate is left unrevealed.]]]]
* YouHaveGotToBeKiddingMe: Janeway's reaction when she learns the ''real'' reason Starfleet and the Federation Council rejected Seven's Academy and Citizenship applications. She can't believe the politicos and brass would be ''that'' petty and reactionary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* FatalFlaw: Janeway's UndyingLoyalty to the ''Voyager'' crew -- and Seven in particular. As noble and heartwarming as her quest to advocate for Seven is, Seven isn't wrong that it's giving Janeway tunnel-vision. She's ignoring the very real dangers of trying to advocate for a former Borg Drone and the damage it's doing to her career (to say nothing of the enemies she's making along the way).

to:

* FatalFlaw: Janeway's UndyingLoyalty to the ''Voyager'' crew -- and Seven in particular. As noble and heartwarming as her quest to advocate for Seven is, Seven isn't wrong that it's giving Janeway tunnel-vision.tunnel vision. She's ignoring the very real dangers of trying to advocate for a former Borg Drone and the damage it's doing to her career (to say nothing of the enemies she's making along the way).



** Mack also loosely tackles the plot hole of why Seven was denied entry into Starfleet for her Borg heritage, but Icheb wasn't. [[spoiler:Seven's embracing her Borg identity is cited as ''the'' reason that crystallized Starfleet and the UFP's reactionary responses. Icheb, by conteast, didn't embrace his Bog heritage (and it's also implied Icheb was far less of a PR and political lightning rod compared to Seven.]]

to:

** Mack also loosely tackles the plot hole of why Seven was denied entry into Starfleet for her Borg heritage, but Icheb wasn't. [[spoiler:Seven's embracing her Borg identity is cited as ''the'' reason that crystallized Starfleet and the UFP's reactionary responses. Icheb, by conteast, contrast, didn't embrace his Bog heritage (and it's also implied Icheb was far less of a PR and political lightning rod compared to Seven.]]



* RankUp: According to Janway's updates on the ''Voyager'' crew, Harry Kim has finally gotten a promotion. From a real-world perspective, it'salso possible Mack ''couldn't'' use any other VOY characters to avoid contradicting whatever plans ''Prodigy'' or other projects may have for them.

to:

* RankUp: According to Janway's Janeway's updates on the ''Voyager'' crew, Harry Kim has finally gotten a promotion. From a real-world perspective, it'salso it's also possible Mack ''couldn't'' use any other VOY characters to avoid contradicting whatever plans ''Prodigy'' or other projects may have for them.



* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: Atfer over 2 years of futilely trying to be accepted by the UFP and Starfleet, Seven finally decides to remove herself from Earth.

to:

* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: Atfer After over 2 years of futilely trying to be accepted by the UFP and Starfleet, Seven finally decides to remove herself from Earth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidntThinkThisThrough: [[spoiler:Seven's conversation with Bjayzl in the framing device -- especially once the topic of Borg technology comes up. While she's being circumspect about her own residual Borg technology and implants, the reader knows it won't occur to Seven until it's too late that she's put a target on Icheb.]]

to:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: [[spoiler:Seven's fateful conversation with Bjayzl in the framing device -- especially once the topic of Borg technology comes up. While she's being circumspect about her own residual Borg technology and implants, the reader knows it won't occur to Seven until it's too late that she's put a target on Icheb.Icheb by mentioning him.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: [[spoiler:Seven's conversation with Bjayzl in the framing device -- especially once the topic of Borg technology comes up. While she's being circumspect about her own residual Borg technology and implants, the reader knows it won't occur to Seven until it's too late that she's put a target on Icheb.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FatalFlaw: Janeway's UndyingLoyalty to the ''Voyager'' crew -- and Seven in particular. As noble and heartwarming as her quest to advocate for Seven is, Seven isn't wrong that it's giving Janeway tunnel-vision. She's ignoring the very real dangers of trying to advocate for a former Borg Drone and the damage it's doing to her career (to say nothing of the enemies she's making along the way).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FantasticRacism: Seven's on the receiving end of this as an ex-Borg Drone both in the Federation and outside its borders. But Mack also explores ''why'' Seven got this particular treatment worse compared to Picard after [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E26S4E1TheBestOfBothWorlds "The Best of Both Worlds"]] and Wolf 359 (and despite his own share of anti-Borg backlash from Sisko, Norah Satie, Liam Shaw, and others). Mack's take is the underlying difference between them is that Picard's assimilation lasted mere days -- ''and'' even assimilated, he was still ultimately crucial to stopping the 2366-67 incursion (to say nothing of the later [[Film/StarTrekFirstContact 2373 incursion]]). Seven, by contrast, had been a Drone nearly all her life and also had none of Picard's reputation or cache within Starfleet and the Federation; even Janeway's endorsement and lobbying weren't enough to overcome political and public backlash.

to:

* FantasticRacism: Seven's on the receiving end of this as an ex-Borg Drone both in the Federation and outside its borders. But Mack also explores ''why'' Seven got this particular treatment worse compared to Picard after [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E26S4E1TheBestOfBothWorlds "The Best of Both Worlds"]] and Wolf 359 (and despite his own share of anti-Borg backlash from Sisko, Norah Satie, Liam Shaw, and others). Mack's take is the underlying difference between them is that that, for all intents, Picard had better PR. Picard's assimilation lasted mere days -- ''and'' even assimilated, he was still ultimately crucial to stopping the 2366-67 incursion (to say nothing of the later [[Film/StarTrekFirstContact 2373 incursion]]). Seven, by contrast, had been a Drone nearly all her life and also had none of Picard's reputation or cache within Starfleet and the Federation; even Janeway's endorsement and lobbying weren't enough to overcome political and public backlash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mack also tackles the plot hole of why Seven was denied entry into Starfleet for her Borg heritage, but Icheb wasn't. [[spoiler:Seven's embracing her Borg identity is cited as ''the'' reason that crystallized Starfleet and the UFP's reactionary responses. It's also implied Icheb was far less of a PR and political lightning rod compared to Seven.]]

to:

** Mack also loosely tackles the plot hole of why Seven was denied entry into Starfleet for her Borg heritage, but Icheb wasn't. [[spoiler:Seven's embracing her Borg identity is cited as ''the'' reason that crystallized Starfleet and the UFP's reactionary responses. It's Icheb, by conteast, didn't embrace his Bog heritage (and it's also implied Icheb was far less of a PR and political lightning rod compared to Seven.]]

Top