Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / QuestForFire

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Was [[AdaptationDisplacement famously]] [[TheFilmOfTheBook adapted into a film of the same name in 1981]]. [[Film/QuestForFire The film]] is not a faithful adaptation but is considered [[AdaptationDistillation a classic in its own right]].

to:

Was [[AdaptationDisplacement famously]] [[TheFilmOfTheBook adapted into a film of the same name in 1981]].1981]] by Creator/JeanJacquesAnnaud. [[Film/QuestForFire The film]] is not a faithful adaptation but is considered [[AdaptationDistillation a classic in its own right]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS wick clean-up


* StockDinosaurs: Not true dinosaurs but most of the stock ice age mammals make appearances: woolly mammoths, woolly rhinos, cave bears, cave lions, aurochs, ''Megaloceros'' and saber-toothed cats. Even ''Gigantopithecus'' joins the party decades before its fossils were discovered!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Quest For Fire'' (French: ''La Guerre du feu'', literally ''The War for Fire'') is a 1911 Belgian HistoricalFiction novel by "J.-H. Rosny", a pseudonym of two brothers.

to:

''Quest For Fire'' (French: ''La Guerre du feu'', literally ''The "The War for Fire'') Fire") is a 1911 Belgian HistoricalFiction novel by "J.-H. Rosny", a pseudonym of two brothers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Doesn't fit the trope. It's a very earnest attempt at portraying the Pleistocene.


* OneMillionBC: 100,000 actually. It has aged better than most other examples as many of the author's [[ArtisticLicensePaleontology speculations]] have turned out to be accurate (See the trivia section).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
the species is left ambiguous in the text


* AllCavemenWereNeanderthals: An early aversion of this trope. The protagonists are neanderthals but the various tribes they encounter clearly represent separate species. The afterword of the 2020 English edition identifies the Kzamm, Wah, Red Dwarves, Blue-haired men and Men of the trees as ''Homo antecessor'', ''Homo sapiens'', ''Homo luzonensis'', ''Gorilla''/''Gigantopithecus'' and ''[[AnachronisticAnimal Pierolapithecus catalaunicus]]'' respectively.

to:

* AllCavemenWereNeanderthals: An early aversion of this trope. The protagonists are resemble neanderthals but the various tribes they encounter clearly represent separate species. The afterword of the 2020 English edition identifies the Kzamm, Wah, Red Dwarves, Blue-haired men and Men of the trees as ''Homo antecessor'', ''Homo sapiens'', ''Homo luzonensis'', ''Gorilla''/''Gigantopithecus'' and ''[[AnachronisticAnimal Pierolapithecus catalaunicus]]'' respectively.



* EveryoneHasStandards: The Oulhamr may be a violent horde of neanderthal raiders but they draw the line at cannibalism.

to:

* EveryoneHasStandards: The Oulhamr may be a violent horde of neanderthal primitive raiders but they draw the line at cannibalism.



* FrazettaMan: Played with. The man-eating Kzamms are hairy and bestial with ape-like limb proportions but have somewhat more sophisticated fire-keeping methods than the Oulhamr. The Blue-haired men are even more ape-like but much less bloodthirsty. Aghoo and his brothers are the straightest examples, being brutish and hairy neanderthals, but they are merely three individuals who are despised and feared by the rest of their tribe.

to:

* FrazettaMan: Played with. The man-eating Kzamms are hairy and bestial with ape-like limb proportions but have somewhat more sophisticated fire-keeping methods than the Oulhamr. The Blue-haired men are even more ape-like but much less bloodthirsty. Aghoo and his brothers are the straightest examples, being brutish and hairy neanderthals, hairy, but they are merely three individuals who are despised and feared by the rest of their tribe.



* {{Xenofiction}}: A mild example as they are technically human but the point of view characters are neanderthals who see anatomically modern humans as strange and alien.

to:

* {{Xenofiction}}: A mild example as they are technically human but the point of view characters are neanderthals primitive humans who see anatomically modern humans as strange and alien.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* QuicksandSucks: Some of the Oulhamr are lost to mquicksand as they fle from their enemies in the first chapter.

Added: 145

Changed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EndangeredSpecies: ''Panthera spelaea'' and more surprisingly ''Homo sapiens'' are both portrayed as such.

to:

* EndangeredSpecies: ''Panthera spelaea'' Cave lions and more surprisingly ''Homo sapiens'' modern humans are both portrayed as such.


Added DiffLines:

* SceneryPorn: A good chunk of the word count is devoted to detailed descriptions of the prehistoric environments the character's travel through.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HairyGirl: Gammla's body hair is [[MaleGaze lovingly described]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Megaceros was an accepted name for Megaloceros until 1945 when George Gaylord Simpson revived the original name


* RougeAnglesOfSatin: The deer ''Megaloceros'' is referred to as ''Megaceros'' which is actually a kind of fungus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheDiscoveryOfFire: A variation: The Oulhamr have a basic understanding of how to control fire but their inability to actually start a fire condemns them once the fire they keep burning at all times is extinguished. The Wahs who have fully domesticated fire teach them the final step: how to start a new fire from scratch.

to:

* TheDiscoveryOfFire: A variation: The Oulhamr have a basic understanding of how to control fire but their inability to actually start ''start'' a fire condemns them once the fire they keep burning at all times is extinguished. The Wahs who have fully domesticated fire teach them the final step: how to start a new fire from scratch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ClashOfEvolutionaryLevels: Averted hard. There are many hominid species clashing but none of them are portrayed as inherently superior and the classic neanderthals vs cro-magnons conflict is completely absent.

to:

* ClashOfEvolutionaryLevels: Averted hard. There Averted, as there are many hominid species clashing but none of them are portrayed as inherently superior and the classic neanderthals vs cro-magnons conflict is completely absent.



* HerbivoresAreFriendly: Played straight with the cave bear and giant apes but averted hard with the aurochs who are just plain nasty. The mammoths are portrayed more complexly: They are easily befriended by the human protagonists because they have no fear of predation but they can be downright lethal if provoked.

to:

* HerbivoresAreFriendly: Played straight with the cave bear and giant apes but averted hard with the aurochs who are just plain nasty. The mammoths are portrayed more complexly: They are easily befriended by the human protagonists because they have no fear of predation but they can be downright lethal if provoked.

Added: 4

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

----



* {{Xenofiction}}: A mild example as they are technically human but the point of view characters are neanderthals who see anatomically modern humans as strange and alien.

to:

* {{Xenofiction}}: A mild example as they are technically human but the point of view characters are neanderthals who see anatomically modern humans as strange and alien.alien.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/quest.png]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Cover of the 2020 English translation]]

to:

[[quoteright:350:https://static.[[quoteright:300:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/quest.png]]
[[caption-width-right:350:Cover [[caption-width-right:300:Cover of the 2020 English translation]]
translation.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BearsAreBadNews: The protagonists have two harrowing encounters with bears: one grey bear (Ursus arctos) and later two cave bears. It is noted that the cave bear is usually the less dangerous of the two, being a herbivore, but it becomes terrifying when provoked starvation or sheer anger.

to:

* BearsAreBadNews: The protagonists have two harrowing encounters with bears: one grey bear (Ursus arctos) and later two cave bears. It is noted that the cave bear is usually the less dangerous of the two, being a herbivore, but it becomes terrifying when provoked by starvation or sheer anger.



* CallASmeerpARabbit: The 2020 English edition has an odd case where a tiger is illustrated as a saber-toothed cat. Calling machairodonts tigers is pretty common but it's odd considering the text itself averts this trope. Fauohum clearly differentiates tigers from "saber-toothed beasts" when he lists the various dangers the Oulhamr are vulnerable to without their fire. [[RuleOfCool It's a cool picture though]].

to:

* CallASmeerpARabbit: The 2020 English edition has an odd case where a tiger is illustrated as a saber-toothed cat. Calling machairodonts tigers is pretty common but it's odd considering the text itself averts this trope. Fauohum Fauohm clearly differentiates tigers from "saber-toothed beasts" when he lists the various dangers the Oulhamr are vulnerable to without their fire. [[RuleOfCool It's a cool picture though]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllCavemenWereNeanderthals: An early aversion of this trope. The protagonists are neanderthals but the various tribes they encounter clearly represent separate species. The afterward of the 2020 English edition identifies the Kzamm, Wah, Red Dwarves, Blue-haired men and Men of the trees as ''Homo antecessor'', ''Homo sapiens'', ''Homo luzonensis'', ''Gorilla''/''Gigantopithecus'' and ''[[AnachronisticAnimal Pierolapithecus catalaunicus]]'' respectively.

to:

* AllCavemenWereNeanderthals: An early aversion of this trope. The protagonists are neanderthals but the various tribes they encounter clearly represent separate species. The afterward afterword of the 2020 English edition identifies the Kzamm, Wah, Red Dwarves, Blue-haired men and Men of the trees as ''Homo antecessor'', ''Homo sapiens'', ''Homo luzonensis'', ''Gorilla''/''Gigantopithecus'' and ''[[AnachronisticAnimal Pierolapithecus catalaunicus]]'' respectively.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield Somewhere in Eurasia]][[AmbiguousTimePeriod around 100,000 years ago]], the Oulhamr horde have lost their precious fire in a raid. Not knowing the secret of fire-starting, they send three warriors (Naoh, Nam and Gaw) on the titular quest. Along the way, they encounter fierce beasts and fiercer men.

to:

[[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield Somewhere in Eurasia]][[AmbiguousTimePeriod Eurasia]] [[AmbiguousTimePeriod around 100,000 years ago]], the Oulhamr horde have lost their precious fire in a raid. Not knowing the secret of fire-starting, they send three warriors (Naoh, Nam and Gaw) on the titular quest. Along the way, they encounter fierce beasts and fiercer men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WhereTheHellsSpringfield Somewhere in Eurasia]][[AmbiguousTimePeriod around 100,000 years ago]], the Oulhamr horde have lost their precious fire in a raid. Not knowing the secret of fire-starting, they send three warriors (Naoh, Nam and Gaw) on the titular quest. Along the way, they encounter fierce beasts and fiercer men.

to:

[[WhereTheHellsSpringfield [[WhereTheHellIsSpringfield Somewhere in Eurasia]][[AmbiguousTimePeriod around 100,000 years ago]], the Oulhamr horde have lost their precious fire in a raid. Not knowing the secret of fire-starting, they send three warriors (Naoh, Nam and Gaw) on the titular quest. Along the way, they encounter fierce beasts and fiercer men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Somewhere in Eurasia 100,000 years ago, the Oulhamr horde have lost their precious fire in a raid. Not knowing the secret of fire-starting, they send three warriors (Naoh, Nam and Gaw) on the titular quest. Along the way, they encounter fierce beasts and fiercer men.

to:

[[WhereTheHellsSpringfield Somewhere in Eurasia Eurasia]][[AmbiguousTimePeriod around 100,000 years ago, ago]], the Oulhamr horde have lost their precious fire in a raid. Not knowing the secret of fire-starting, they send three warriors (Naoh, Nam and Gaw) on the titular quest. Along the way, they encounter fierce beasts and fiercer men.


Added DiffLines:

* AmbiguousTimePeriod: "Maybe a hundred thousand years ago" according to the dedication.

Top