Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / HarryPotterandTheDeathlyHallows

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Voldemort's first fatal mistake is underestimating the love of a mother for her child (in this case, not realizing the magical power Lily's sacrifice would imbue in her son). [[spoiler:Voldemort's last fatal mistake is underestimating the love of a mother for her child (in this case, not realizing Narcissa would double-cross him in exchange for information pertinent to her son's safety).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BloodMagic: [[spoiler:Because Voldemort used Harry's blood to rejuvenate himself back in ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire'', he's kept Lily's protective charm on Harry alive with his new body. He anchors Harry to life as long as he lives. As a result, he can't kill Harry. This causes a NegateYourOwnSacrifice for Harry after he willingly lets Voldemort kill him because he is a SoulJar for Voldemort]].

to:

* BloodMagic: [[spoiler:Because [[spoiler: Because Voldemort used Harry's blood to rejuvenate himself back in ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire'', he's kept Lily's protective charm on Harry alive with his new body.body. As long as that enchantment survives, Harry is protected from Voldemort. He anchors Harry to life as long as he lives. As a result, he can't kill Harry. This causes a NegateYourOwnSacrifice for Harry after he willingly lets Voldemort try to kill him because he is a SoulJar [[SoulJar Horcrux]] for Voldemort]].



* NegateYourOwnSacrifice: [[spoiler:Harry has to die, since he himself is a [[SoulJar Horcrux for Voldemort]]. He willingly goes to Voldemort to let him kill him and fully expected it to be a HeroicSacrifice. However, according to Dumbledore in Limbo, Harry's decision to let Voldemort kill him rather than keep fighting was what "made all the difference".]]
** It was a threefer: '''Firstly''', Harry's willingly letting Voldemort strike him with the Killing Curse destroyed the shard of Voldemort's soul within Harry. '''But''', Lily's willing sacrifice for Harry meant that Voldemort could not harm him as long as her blood was present. [[spoiler:Voldemort's use of Harry's blood in his resurrection had the side-effect of anchoring Harry to life as long as Voldemort lived]]. '''Also''', because Harry [[spoiler:''willingly'' leaves Hogwarts and goes into the Forest to confront Voldemort, he essentially does the same thing his mother did, he protects ''everyone currently at Hogwarts'' with the same protective charm]].

to:

* NegateYourOwnSacrifice: [[spoiler:Harry [[spoiler: Harry has to die, since he himself is a [[SoulJar Horcrux Horcrux]] for Voldemort]].Voldemort. He willingly goes to Voldemort to let him kill him and fully expected it to be a HeroicSacrifice. However, according to Dumbledore in Limbo, Harry's decision to let Voldemort kill him rather than keep fighting was what "made all the difference".]]
** It was a threefer: '''Firstly''', Harry's willingly letting Voldemort strike him Voldemort's striking Harry with the Killing Curse destroyed the shard of Voldemort's his soul within Harry. '''But''', Lily's willing sacrifice for Harry meant that Voldemort could not harm him as long as her blood was present. [[spoiler:Voldemort's [[spoiler: Voldemort's use of Harry's blood in his resurrection had the side-effect of anchoring Harry to life as long as Voldemort lived]]. lives]]. '''Also''', because Harry [[spoiler:''willingly'' leaves Hogwarts and goes into the Forest to confront Voldemort, he essentially does the same thing his mother did, he protects ''everyone currently at Hogwarts'' from Voldemort with the same protective charm]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:Bellatrix's stubbourn insistence throughout the last two books that Snape was untrustworthy despite the Dark Lord clearing Severus? She was right.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Bellatrix's stubbourn stubborn insistence throughout the last two books that Snape was untrustworthy despite the Dark Lord clearing Severus? She was right.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HotBlooded: [[spoiler:In the afterlife, Dumbledore cites this as why he made he made the Hallows Quest so difficult for Harry. Dumbledore was counting on Hermione to slow Harry down, worrying that an impulsive Harry would seek out and harness the Hallows before he could understand and respect their power. Dumbledore meant well, fearing Harry would make the same impulsive mistakes he had made years ago when he and Grindelwald sought them out.]]

to:

* HotBlooded: [[spoiler:In the afterlife, limbo, Dumbledore cites this as why he made he made the Hallows Quest so difficult for Harry. Dumbledore was counting on Hermione to slow Harry down, up, worrying that an impulsive Harry would seek out and harness attempt to possess the Hallows before he could understand and respect their power. Dumbledore meant well, fearing Harry would make the same impulsive mistakes he had made years ago when he and Grindelwald sought them out.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Both Lestrange and Riddle discount ThePowerOfLove to their cost.

to:

** Both Bellatrix Lestrange and Tom Riddle discount ThePowerOfLove ThePowerOfLove, to their cost.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "The Prince's Tale" in particular is ''the'' biggest wham episode in the entire series. To summarize:
*** [[spoiler: Snape knew Lily and Petunia when they were all children, Lily and Petunia had a falling out on Lily's first day of school (thus cementing Petunia's hatred of her sister and future nephew), Petunia had contacted Dumbledore previously and had knowledge about Hogwarts, Snape pulled a HeelFaceTurn after Lily's death and has been working with Dumbledore since the beginning of the series, Dumbledore had planned his own death in the last book and specifically asked Snape to do it, Dumbledore reveals Harry is an unintended horcrux and must die to make Voldemort mortal, and the chapter ends with the reveal that Snape was the one who sent the silver doe and planted the Sword of Gryffindor earlier in the book.]] Phew.

to:

** "The Prince's Tale" in particular is ''the'' biggest wham episode in the entire series.''series''. To summarize:
*** [[spoiler: Snape knew Lily and Petunia when they were all children, Lily and Petunia had a falling out on Lily's first day of school (thus cementing Petunia's hatred of her sister and future nephew), Petunia had contacted Dumbledore previously and had knowledge about Hogwarts, Snape was in love with Lily and had pulled a HeelFaceTurn after Lily's death and has her death, meaning he's been working with Dumbledore since the beginning of the series, Dumbledore had planned his own death in the last book and specifically asked Snape to do it, kill him, Dumbledore reveals Harry is an unintended horcrux and must die to make Voldemort mortal, and the chapter ends with the reveal that Snape was the one who sent the silver doe and planted the Sword of Gryffindor earlier in the book.book. Oh yeah, and there's also the reveal that Lupin and Tonks were killed offscreen.]] Phew.

Added: 1548

Changed: 473

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OhCrap: Voldemort goes utterly ballistic when he learns that Harry and his friends broke into Bellatrix Lestrange's vault at Gringotts and stole the cup of Helga Hufflepuff, as it means that Harry knows about the Horcruxes and is actively hunting them, with intent to destroy them and make Voldy mortal again.

to:

* OhCrap: OhCrap:
**
Voldemort goes utterly ballistic when he learns that Harry and his friends broke into Bellatrix Lestrange's vault at Gringotts and stole the cup of Helga Hufflepuff, as it means that Harry knows about the Horcruxes and is actively hunting them, with intent to destroy them and make Voldy mortal again.again.
** Snape has one when [[spoiler: he realizes Voldemort is about to kill him]].
** Snape has an even bigger one when [[spoiler: he realizes Voldemort is planning to kill Lily after the former informed him of the prophecy he overheard]].



* WhamEpisode: Practically every chapter where a major character is killed off. Hell, every chapter from "Malfoy Manor" (the twenty-third out of thirty-six, not counting the epilogue) on.

to:

* WhamEpisode: WhamEpisode:
**
Practically every chapter where a major character is killed off. Hell, every chapter from "Malfoy Manor" (the twenty-third out of thirty-six, not counting the epilogue) on.
** "The Prince's Tale" in particular is ''the'' biggest wham episode in the entire series. To summarize:
*** [[spoiler: Snape knew Lily and Petunia when they were all children, Lily and Petunia had a falling out on Lily's first day of school (thus cementing Petunia's hatred of her sister and future nephew), Petunia had contacted Dumbledore previously and had knowledge about Hogwarts, Snape pulled a HeelFaceTurn after Lily's death and has been working with Dumbledore since the beginning of the series, Dumbledore had planned his own death in the last book and specifically asked Snape to do it, Dumbledore reveals Harry is an unintended horcrux and must die to make Voldemort mortal, and the chapter ends with the reveal that Snape was the one who sent the silver doe and planted the Sword of Gryffindor earlier in the book.]] Phew.

Added: 1268

Changed: 507

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Irony}}: Neville, the other Child of the Original Prophecy that was said to be capable of standing against and fighting Voldemort, [[spoiler:is offered by the BigBad himself to join his side. Neville promptly refuses and is then insulted by Voldemort, and shortly after, he ends up killing Nagini, Voldemort's last Horcrux, rendering him mortal and helping to seal his fate once and for all]]. [[SelfFulfillingProphecy Good job helping Neville]] [[NiceJobFixingItVillain live up to his part of the Prophecy, Voldy!]]

to:

* {{Irony}}: {{Irony}}:
**
Neville, the other Child of the Original Prophecy that was said to be capable of standing against and fighting Voldemort, [[spoiler:is offered by the BigBad himself to join his side. Neville promptly refuses and is then insulted by Voldemort, and shortly after, he ends up killing Nagini, Voldemort's last Horcrux, rendering him mortal and helping to seal his fate once and for all]]. [[SelfFulfillingProphecy Good job helping Neville]] [[NiceJobFixingItVillain live up to his part of the Prophecy, Voldy!]]Voldy!]]
** Draco Malfoy, the hateful, racist, elitist, snobbish, and smug bully that has done everything in his power to make life as difficult for Harry and his friends as possible throughout the entire series, was directly responsible for letting the Death Eaters into the school and getting Dumbledore killed, and whose parents are both Death Eaters fully loyal to Voldemort, [[spoiler: ends up being the entire reason Harry manages to triumph over Voldemort, due to Harry saving his life in the Room of Requirement(giving Narcissa Malfoy incentive to lie to Voldemort about Harry's "death"), and Harry disarming him at Malfoy Manor giving the latter the true loyalty of the Elder Wand, causing Voldemort's Killing Curse to rebound and end him once and for all]].

Added: 998

Changed: 97

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkestHour: The halfway point of the book is by far the darkest and most hopeless moment in the entire series. [[spoiler: Ron walks out on the group, leaving Harry and Hermione to fend for themselves, the two are stuck with the locket Horcrux with no way to destroy it and have no leads on any of the others, they have no idea what's going on with Voldemort or any of their allies that are currently fighting or on the run, and the two are nearly killed by Nagini and Voldemort himself when they go to visit Godric's Hallow.]] The only remotely happy thing that occurs during this stretch of the book is Harry seeing all of the encouraging messages left for him on his old house, letting him know that he is not alone in his fight against Voldemort.



* DirtyCoward: Mundungus Disapparates as soon as Voldemort confronts him during the chase, leaving Moody to die.

to:

* DirtyCoward: DirtyCoward:
**
Mundungus Disapparates as soon as Voldemort confronts him during the chase, leaving Moody to die.die.
** Pansy Parkinson, who immediately points out Harry and demands somebody grab him and hand him over to Voldemort in exchange for her own safety.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Harry and Malfoy have hated each other's guts the entire series, yet [[spoiler: Harry still chooses to save him and Goyle in the burning Room of Requirement]], and he's horrified when he first thinks they're dead, with the narration specifically noting "he [Harry] had never wanted this. What a terrible way to die." This ends up paying off later, when [[spoiler: Narcissa lies to Voldemort about Harry being dead after the latter informs her that her son is still alive, setting the stones for Voldemort's ultimate downfall]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JerkassHasAPoint: While Griphook stealing the Sword of Gryffindor and selling out the trio was uncalled for, he was correct in pointing out that wizards have discriminated against and looked down on goblins for centuries, and proved those ideals are very much still in place when Ron unintentionally offends him while discussing ownership of the sword. Griphook also correctly predicts the trio were planning to go back on their word and keep the sword, thus proving they are no better than any other witch or wizard that has been actively screwing over goblins for centuries.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ICantBelieveImSayingThis: During the Potterwatch broadcast that the trio listens to, one of the twins (presumed to be Fred) urges everyone to stay cautious and not to get lulled into a false sense of security with the rumors of Voldemort being abroad. He ends it by saying "I never thought I'd hear myself say this, but: safety first!"

Changed: 4

Removed: 246

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per wick cleanup. I also removed unnecessary spaces in the spoiler markups.


* BullyTurnedBuddy: Played with in the Epilogue [[spoiler: when Harry and Draco briefly interact at King's Cross Station. While the Trio and Draco have buried the hatchet and are at least cordial, they're also not really friends; too much damage was done during their years at Hogwarts.]]

to:

* BullyTurnedBuddy: Played with in the Epilogue [[spoiler: when [[spoiler:when Harry and Draco briefly interact at King's Cross Station. While the Trio and Draco have buried the hatchet and are at least cordial, they're also not really friends; too much damage was done during their years at Hogwarts.]]



* ForegoneConclusion: It's inevitable that Voldemort's eventually going to realize his Horcruxes have been compromised (and that more of them have been destroyed in the interim since the Diary in ''Chamber of Secrets''). The Trio knows this, which is why they're trying to keep their tactical advantage a secret as long as possible. [[spoiler: The jig's finally up after the Gringotts heist.]]

to:

* ForegoneConclusion: It's inevitable that Voldemort's eventually going to realize his Horcruxes have been compromised (and that more of them have been destroyed in the interim since the Diary in ''Chamber of Secrets''). The Trio knows this, which is why they're trying to keep their tactical advantage a secret as long as possible. [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The jig's finally up after the Gringotts heist.]]



%% * GettingCrapPastThe Radar: Due to overwhelming and persistent misuse, GCPTR is on-page examples only until 01 June 2021. If you are reading this in the future, please check the trope page to make sure your example fits the current definition.



** After the Seven Potters operation nearly goes disastrously astray, the Order fears they have another Snape in their midst and somebody else has turned traitor. Initially, they think it's Mundungus, but grudingly clear him due to major holes in the evidence. [[spoiler: There actually isn't a mole -- or rather, it's a reverse-mole. Snape fed operational details -- specifically the idea to use the decoy Potters -- to a bewitched Mundungus. Snape then used his 'source' to 'discover' the plan and report it to Voldemort both to give Harry a fighting chance and to ensure his own deep cover was preserved.]]

to:

** After the Seven Potters operation nearly goes disastrously astray, the Order fears they have another Snape in their midst and somebody else has turned traitor. Initially, they think it's Mundungus, but grudingly clear him due to major holes in the evidence. [[spoiler: There [[spoiler:There actually isn't a mole -- or rather, it's a reverse-mole. Snape fed operational details -- specifically the idea to use the decoy Potters -- to a bewitched Mundungus. Snape then used his 'source' to 'discover' the plan and report it to Voldemort both to give Harry a fighting chance and to ensure his own deep cover was preserved.]]



** [[spoiler: Bellatrix's stubbourn insistence throughout the last two books that Snape was untrustworthy despite the Dark Lord clearing Severus? She was right.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Bellatrix's [[spoiler:Bellatrix's stubbourn insistence throughout the last two books that Snape was untrustworthy despite the Dark Lord clearing Severus? She was right.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForegoneConclusion: It's inevitible that Voldemort's eventually going to realize his Horcruxes have been compromised (and that more of them have been destroyed in the interim since the Diary in ''Chamber of Secrets''). The Trio knows this, which is why they're trying to keep their tactical advantage a secret as long as possible. [[spoiler: The jig's finally up after the Gringotts heist.]]

to:

* ForegoneConclusion: It's inevitible inevitable that Voldemort's eventually going to realize his Horcruxes have been compromised (and that more of them have been destroyed in the interim since the Diary in ''Chamber of Secrets''). The Trio knows this, which is why they're trying to keep their tactical advantage a secret as long as possible. [[spoiler: The jig's finally up after the Gringotts heist.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WaterIsDry: To enter the Ministry of Magic, the heroes have to stand in a public toilet, and flush themselves in. When Harry steps into the toilet, he knows he has done the right thing, because his feet are perfectly dry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MugglesDoItBetter: Visiting the Lovegood home, Harry sees that Luna has decorated her bedroom ceiling with portraits of himself, Hermione, Ron, Neville, and Ginny. The portraits are inanimate, indicating that Luna used non-magical paint, but Harry finds them incredibly lifelike and all the more moving because of the effort Luna obviously put into them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking new trope

Added DiffLines:

* PictorialLetterSubstitution: There's reference to a letter Albus Dumbledore had written a long time previously, where the first letter of his first name was replaced with what we later find out to be the symbol of the Deathly Hallows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry to fullfil). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). It's inevitible he'll figure it out eventually -- but if word leaks prematurely and Voldemort relocates the remaining Horcuxes before the Trio can find and destroy the SoulJars, they're ''screwed''. The rest of the Order doesn't find out what the Trio's been doing until the climax.

to:

** Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry to fullfil). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). It's inevitible he'll figure it out eventually -- but if word leaks prematurely and Voldemort relocates the remaining Horcuxes before the Trio can find and destroy the SoulJars, {{Soul Jar}}s, they're ''screwed''. The rest of the Order doesn't find out what the Trio's been doing until the climax.



* UnstoppableRage: Voldemort goes utterly ''batshit'' when he learns that Harry and his friends broke into Bellatrix's vault and stole the cup of Helga Hufflepuff, as it most certainly means that they know about his SoulJar ploy. He also fears that if Harry knew about that one, he might've known about (and even destroyed) the others.

to:

* UnstoppableRage: Voldemort goes utterly ''batshit'' when he learns that Harry and his friends broke into Bellatrix's vault and stole the cup of Helga Hufflepuff, Hufflepuff's cup, as it most certainly means that they know about his SoulJar ploy. He also fears that if Harry knew about that one, he might've known about (and even destroyed) the others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry to fullfil). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). It's inevitible he'll figure it out eventually -- but if word leaks prematurely and Voldemort relocates the remaining Horcuxes before the Trio can find and destroy the stragglers, they're ''screwed''. The rest of the Order doesn't find out what the Trio's been doing until the climax.

to:

** Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry to fullfil). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). It's inevitible he'll figure it out eventually -- but if word leaks prematurely and Voldemort relocates the remaining Horcuxes before the Trio can find and destroy the stragglers, SoulJars, they're ''screwed''. The rest of the Order doesn't find out what the Trio's been doing until the climax.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllegianceAffirmation: [[DoubleReverseQuadrupleAgent Severus Snape]] pulls one of these during Literature/HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows, finally confirming where it is that his loyalties ultimately lie.

to:

* AllegianceAffirmation: [[DoubleReverseQuadrupleAgent Severus Snape]] pulls one of these during Literature/HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows, these, finally confirming where it is that his loyalties ultimately lie.lie--namely, to the late Lily Evans Potter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While Harry has absolutely despised Snape the entire series (especially after the events of the last book), even he is horrified by the absolutely brutal and petty way Voldemort murders him, to the point of running over to him to ensure he does not die alone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It was a threefer: '''Firstly''', Harry's willingly letting Voldemort hit him with the Killing Curse destroyed the shard of Voldemort's soul within Harry. '''But''', Lily's willing sacrifice for Harry meant that Voldemort could not harm him as long as her blood was present. [[spoiler:Voldemort's use of Harry's blood in his resurrection had the side-effect of anchoring Harry to life as long as Voldemort lived]]. '''Also''', when Harry [[spoiler:''willingly'' leaves Hogwarts and goes into the Forest to confront Voldemort, he essentially does the same thing his mother did, he protects ''everyone currently at Hogwarts'' with the same counter-charm]].

to:

** It was a threefer: '''Firstly''', Harry's willingly letting Voldemort hit strike him with the Killing Curse destroyed the shard of Voldemort's soul within Harry. '''But''', Lily's willing sacrifice for Harry meant that Voldemort could not harm him as long as her blood was present. [[spoiler:Voldemort's use of Harry's blood in his resurrection had the side-effect of anchoring Harry to life as long as Voldemort lived]]. '''Also''', when because Harry [[spoiler:''willingly'' leaves Hogwarts and goes into the Forest to confront Voldemort, he essentially does the same thing his mother did, he protects ''everyone currently at Hogwarts'' with the same counter-charm]].protective charm]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:While Dumbledore briefed Snape on the fragment of Voldemort's soul inside Harry, he intentionally withheld intel on Voldemort's Horcruxes (and how Lily's blood charm within Voldemort's resurrected body could theoretically keep Harry alive even when the Horcrux destroyed). As with the Order's example above, it's justified for operational security. Again, Dumbledore was both trying to protect their secret advantage ''and'' ensure Harry ''would'' be killed by Voldemort specficially (as it was the ''only'' way to activate the LoopholeAbuse and give Harry a chance at survival).

to:

** [[spoiler:While Dumbledore briefed Snape on the fragment of Voldemort's soul inside Harry, he intentionally withheld intel on Voldemort's Horcruxes (and how Lily's blood charm within Voldemort's resurrected body could theoretically keep Harry alive even when the Horcrux destroyed). As with the Order's example above, it's justified for operational security. Again, Dumbledore was both trying to protect their secret advantage ''and'' ensure Harry ''would'' be killed by Voldemort specficially (as it was the ''only'' way to activate the LoopholeAbuse and give Harry a chance at survival).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler:While Dumbledore briefed Snape on the fragment of Voldemort's soul inside Harry, he intentionally withheld intel on Voldemort's Horcruxes (and how Lily's blood charm within Voldemort's resurrected body could keep him alive even when the Horcrux was destroyed). As with the Order's example above, it's justified for operational security. Again, Dumbledore was trying to protect their secret advantage and ensure Harry ''would'' be killed by Voldemort specficially (as it was the ''only'' way to activate the LoopholeAbuse and give Harry a chance at survival).

to:

** [[spoiler:While Dumbledore briefed Snape on the fragment of Voldemort's soul inside Harry, he intentionally withheld intel on Voldemort's Horcruxes (and how Lily's blood charm within Voldemort's resurrected body could theoretically keep him Harry alive even when the Horcrux was destroyed). As with the Order's example above, it's justified for operational security. Again, Dumbledore was both trying to protect their secret advantage and ''and'' ensure Harry ''would'' be killed by Voldemort specficially (as it was the ''only'' way to activate the LoopholeAbuse and give Harry a chance at survival).

Added: 1379

Changed: 807

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry to fullfil). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). It's inevitible he'll figure it out eventually -- but if word leaks prematurely and Voldemort relocates the remaining Horcuxes before the Trio can find and destroy the stragglers, they're ''screwed''. The rest of the Order doesn't find out what the Trio's been doing until the climax.

to:

* LockedOutOfTheLoop: LockedOutOfTheLoop:
**
Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry to fullfil). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). It's inevitible he'll figure it out eventually -- but if word leaks prematurely and Voldemort relocates the remaining Horcuxes before the Trio can find and destroy the stragglers, they're ''screwed''. The rest of the Order doesn't find out what the Trio's been doing until the climax. climax.
** [[spoiler:While Dumbledore briefed Snape on the fragment of Voldemort's soul inside Harry, he intentionally withheld intel on Voldemort's Horcruxes (and how Lily's blood charm within Voldemort's resurrected body could keep him alive even when the Horcrux was destroyed). As with the Order's example above, it's justified for operational security. Again, Dumbledore was trying to protect their secret advantage and ensure Harry ''would'' be killed by Voldemort specficially (as it was the ''only'' way to activate the LoopholeAbuse and give Harry a chance at survival).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HotBlooded: [[spoiler:In the afterlife, Dumbledore cites this as why he made he made the Hallows Quest so difficult for Harry. Dumbledore was counting on Hermione to slow Harry down, worrying that an impulsive Harry would seek out and harness the Hallows before he could understand and respect their power. Dumbledore meant well, fearing Harry would make the same impulsive mistakes he had made years ago when he and Grindelwald sought them out.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). If word leaks and Voldemort relocates the remaining ones before the Trio can find and destroy them, they're ''screwed''. The rest of the Order doesn't find out what the Trio's been doing until the climax.

to:

* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry).Harry to fullfil). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). If It's inevitible he'll figure it out eventually -- but if word leaks prematurely and Voldemort relocates the remaining ones Horcuxes before the Trio can find and destroy them, the stragglers, they're ''screwed''. The rest of the Order doesn't find out what the Trio's been doing until the climax.

Added: 393

Changed: 86

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForegoneConclusion: It's inevitible that Voldemort's eventually going to realize his Horcruxes have been compromised (and that more of them have been destroyed in the interim since the Diary in ''Chamber of Secrets''). The Trio knows this, which is why they're trying to keep their tactical advantage a secret as long as possible. [[spoiler: The jig's finally up after the Gringotts heist.]]



* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). If word leaks and Voldemort relocates the remaining ones before the Trio can find and destroy them, they're ''scerwed''.

to:

* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). If word leaks and Voldemort relocates the remaining ones before the Trio can find and destroy them, they're ''scerwed''.''screwed''. The rest of the Order doesn't find out what the Trio's been doing until the climax.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LockedOutOfTheLoop: Continuing on from the last book, Ron and Hermione are the only other characters besides Harry who know about the Horcrux Hunt (though Lupin and others in the Order of the Phoenix have correctly guessed Dumbledore left secret orders for Harry). Justified, as the Trio, like Dumbledore, recognize the necessity of operational security given the stakes. Their one secret tactical advantage is that Voldemort doesn't yet know his Horcuxes have been compromised (or that Dumbledore destroyed Morfin Gaunt's Ring). If word leaks and Voldemort relocates the remaining ones before the Trio can find and destroy them, they're ''scerwed''.

Top