Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / BlackBeauty

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
How To Create A Works Page explicitly says "No bolding is used for work titles."


'''''Black Beauty''''' is an 1877 polemic novel by Anna Sewell, tracing the life of the titular fictional horse from colthood to retirement. Today it is considered a classic of children's literature; however, originally it was not written for children, but as an effort to draw attention to the wildly varying treatment of horses in Victorian England. As a result it contains mini-lectures on everything from bits and blinkers to broken knees. Along the way Beauty also provides a horse's perspective on the human capacity for cruelty and kindness, and comparisons between the treatment of animals and the treatment of poor working-class humans.

to:

'''''Black Beauty''''' ''Black Beauty'' is an 1877 polemic novel by Anna Sewell, tracing the life of the titular fictional horse from colthood to retirement. Today it is considered a classic of children's literature; however, originally it was not written for children, but as an effort to draw attention to the wildly varying treatment of horses in Victorian England. As a result it contains mini-lectures on everything from bits and blinkers to broken knees. Along the way Beauty also provides a horse's perspective on the human capacity for cruelty and kindness, and comparisons between the treatment of animals and the treatment of poor working-class humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BeCarefulWhatYouWishFor: In the 1994 film, York tells a circling Black Beauty in his stable to stand still. Beauty does so and by doing so brings his hoof down on York's foot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnimalTalk

to:

* AnimalTalkAnimalTalk: Par for the course in a story like this.

Added: 324

Changed: 369

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulName: Ginger, a chestnut mare, though she is called that because she snaps. Doubles as a StealthPun.
** Also Mr. Thoroughgood, the [[IncrediblyLamePun thoroughly good]] old man who buys beat down working horses like Ladybird and Beauty and gives them a second chance at life by "makes them young again," and finding them nice owners.

to:

* MeaningfulName: MeaningfulName:
**
Ginger, a chestnut mare, though she is called that because she snaps. Doubles as a StealthPun.
** Also On the human side we have Joe ''Green,'' whose youthful inexperience almost causes Beauty's death, and Mr. Thoroughgood, the [[IncrediblyLamePun thoroughly good]] old man who buys beat down working horses like Ladybird and Beauty and gives them a second chance at life by "makes rehabilitating them young again," and finding them nice good owners.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmallRoleBigImpact: Duchess, Black Beauty's mother, who only shows up in the first chapter and in Beauty's memories a few times after that. She was a well-behaved and much-beloved horse, and brought up her children to be docile and obedient to humans. Beauty's behavior throughout the story is defined by her teachings, and his kinder owners recognize immediately what a good temperament he has.

to:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: Duchess, Black Beauty's mother, who only shows up in the first chapter few chapters and in Beauty's memories a few times after that. She was a well-behaved and much-beloved horse, and brought up her children to be docile and obedient to humans. Beauty's behavior throughout the story is defined by her teachings, and his kinder owners recognize immediately what a good temperament he has.

Changed: 241

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmallRoleBigImpact: Duchess, Black Beauty's mother, who only shows up in the first chapter and in Beauty's memories a few times after that. She was a well-behaved and much-beloved horse, and brought up her children to be docile and obedient to humans. Beauty's behavior throughout the story is defined by her teachings, and this was apparently also the case with his brother Rob Roy, who was well-known for being very gentle, obedient, and all-around well-behaved. As another of Duchess's sons, his new owners expected nothing less of Beauty.

to:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: Duchess, Black Beauty's mother, who only shows up in the first chapter and in Beauty's memories a few times after that. She was a well-behaved and much-beloved horse, and brought up her children to be docile and obedient to humans. Beauty's behavior throughout the story is defined by her teachings, and this was apparently also the case with his brother Rob Roy, who was well-known for being very gentle, obedient, and all-around well-behaved. As another of Duchess's sons, his new kinder owners expected nothing less of Beauty.recognize immediately what a good temperament he has.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: Duchess, Black Beauty's mother, who only shows up in the first chapter and in Beauty's memories a few times after that. She was a well-behaved and much-beloved horse, and brought up her children to be docile and obedient to humans. Beauty's behavior throughout the story is defined by her teachings, and this was apparently also the case with his brother Rob Roy, who was well-known for being very gentle, obedient, and all-around well-behaved. As another of Duchess's sons, his new owners expected nothing less of Beauty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptedOut: Inevitable with a story with [[LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters so many characters]], so often only the most notable of Beauty's owners are given any attention while any others (if they are acknowledged at all) tend to be glossed over with some variant of "and then for several years I changed hands frequently." Beauty also meets a number of horses in the book, but generally only his mother, Ginger, and Merrylegs are named or get any real screentime (one cartoon kept Sir Oliver in, possibly the only time another horse is mentioned by name), and no adaptation has ever kept the brief scene of Rob Roy, Beauty's older brother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A third was made by Jetlag productions in the 90's. Of the three, it falls between the other two in terms of faithfulness to the book. Hanna-Barbera's is generally considered to be about as faithful as a 45-minute cartoon could reasonably manage, while Burbank Films' version keeps a few notable scenes but otherwise bears only a passing resemblance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also in the book, Beauty isn't even sure if [[spoiler:the dead horse he sees is Ginger,]] he merely ''hopes'' it is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmplifiedAnimalAptitude: Mostly averted. Once you get past the fact that the horse is narrating his own life story and having weighty ethical and philosophical discussions with other horses, Beauty largely behaves like a normal horse - for instance, being too terrified to leave a burning barn until he's blindfolded and led out.

to:

* AmplifiedAnimalAptitude: Mostly averted. Once you get past the fact that the horse is narrating his own life story and having weighty ethical and philosophical discussions with other horses, Beauty largely behaves like a normal horse and acts mostly on instinct rather than reason - for instance, being too terrified to leave a burning barn until he's blindfolded and led out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the 1995 animated adaptation, the last time Beauty sees [[spoiler:Ginger]] is at a fair where she appears to be in much better health and is being sold to a young girl, implying she got a happy ending in contrast to the original. This is in contrast to the ealrier animated adaption that even includes the scene where Beauty [[spoiler:sees her dead body being pulled away in a cart.]]

to:

** In the 1995 animated adaptation, the last time Beauty sees [[spoiler:Ginger]] is at a fair where she appears to be in much better health and is being sold to a young girl, implying she got a happy ending in contrast to the original. This is in contrast to the ealrier earlier animated adaption that even includes the scene where Beauty [[spoiler:sees her dead body being pulled away in a cart.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FollowTheLeader: Inspired many similar books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OldSoldier: Captain, Jerry Barker's other cab horse, is an equine version. In his prime he was a cavalry mount, and he tells Beauty the story of his experiences in the Crimean War.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AutomatonHorse: Invoked and savagely defied. Black Beauty and other horses clearly aren't, though they occasionally come across humans who think they are. This only causes pain, misery, and occasional crippling for the horses.

to:

* AutomatonHorse: Invoked and savagely defied. Black Beauty and other The novel pulls no punches in depicting how many horses clearly aren't, though they occasionally come across humans suffer at the hands of people who think they are. This only causes pain, misery, and occasional crippling for the horses.treat them like machinery instead of living creatures.



** A drunkard is warned that one of Beauty's shoes has come loose, but he rides him anyway. The shoe eventually comes off en route and Beauy splits a hoof and falls to his knees from the pain, injuring himself and [[AccidentalMurder accidentally throwing his rider to his death]].

to:

** A drunkard is warned that one of Beauty's shoes has come loose, but he rides him anyway. The shoe eventually comes off en route and Beauy splits Beauty gets a hoof and falls to stone lodged painfully in his knees from the pain, injuring hoof, causing him to injure himself and [[AccidentalMurder accidentally throwing throw his rider to his death]].death]] when the pain causes him to stumble and fall on his knees.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Many adaptations cut out the part early on where Beauty with his mother witness a fox hunt going terribly wrong as a horse falls over, killing both him and his rider. Beauty later finds out said horse was his brother.

to:

** Many adaptations cut out the part early on where Beauty with his mother witness a fox hunt going terribly wrong as a when one horse falls over, stumbles into a ditch, killing both him and his rider. Beauty later finds out said horse was his brother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the 1995 animated adaptation, the last time Beauty sees [[spoiler:Ginger]] is at a fair where she appears to be in much better health and is being sold to a young girl, implying she got a happy ending in contrast to the original.

to:

** In the 1995 animated adaptation, the last time Beauty sees [[spoiler:Ginger]] is at a fair where she appears to be in much better health and is being sold to a young girl, implying she got a happy ending in contrast to the original. This is in contrast to the ealrier animated adaption that even includes the scene where Beauty [[spoiler:sees her dead body being pulled away in a cart.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, the soundtrack for the film was composed by none other than DannyElfman. Go to the YMMV page for a list over some of the best samples.

to:

** Also, Many adaptations cut out the soundtrack for the film part early on where Beauty with his mother witness a fox hunt going terribly wrong as a horse falls over, killing both him and his rider. Beauty later finds out said horse was composed by none other than DannyElfman. Go to the YMMV page for a list over some of the best samples.his brother.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Many versions, including the 1994 one, expands on the relationship between Beauty and Joe to being that of best friends. In the book, they don't share much of a relationship, and while their reunion is more of an afterthought, the 1994 film version changed it to be a huge TearJerker.

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: Many versions, including the 1994 one, expands on the relationship between Beauty and Joe to being that of best friends. In the book, they don't share much of a relationship, and while their reunion is more of an afterthought, afterthought. In the 1994 film version changed it to be version, it's a huge ''huge'' TearJerker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 63

Removed: 124

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Similarly, many versions has Ginger being portayed as Beauty's LoveInterest, while she was just his friend in the book.


Added DiffLines:

* PromotedToLoveInterest: Ginger to Beauty in many adaptations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Similarily, many versions has Ginger being portayed as Beauty's LoveInterest, while she was just his friend in the book.

to:

** Similarily, Similarly, many versions has Ginger being portayed as Beauty's LoveInterest, while she was just his friend in the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





''Black Beauty'' is an 1877 polemic novel by Anna Sewell, tracing the life of the titular fictional horse from colthood to retirement. Today it is considered a classic of children's literature; however, originally it was not written for children, but as an effort to draw attention to the wildly varying treatment of horses in Victorian England. As a result it contains mini-lectures on everything from bits and blinkers to broken knees. Along the way Beauty also provides a horse's perspective on the human capacity for cruelty and kindness, and comparisons between the treatment of animals and the treatment of poor working-class humans.

to:

''Black Beauty'' '''''Black Beauty''''' is an 1877 polemic novel by Anna Sewell, tracing the life of the titular fictional horse from colthood to retirement. Today it is considered a classic of children's literature; however, originally it was not written for children, but as an effort to draw attention to the wildly varying treatment of horses in Victorian England. As a result it contains mini-lectures on everything from bits and blinkers to broken knees. Along the way Beauty also provides a horse's perspective on the human capacity for cruelty and kindness, and comparisons between the treatment of animals and the treatment of poor working-class humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Early in the novel a nobleman's son treats ginger like a furry motorcycle to hop on, ride at top speed through long and rigorous race courses, then dump back in the stall. The strain on her body permanently damages her bronchial track to the point that she can never run or jump as well again. Rather than give her the year of pasture rest she needs to heal, she's sold as a work horse, which strains her physical health more and more until [[spoiler: she's driven to an early death]].

to:

** Early in the novel a nobleman's son treats ginger Ginger like a furry motorcycle to hop on, ride at top speed through long and rigorous race courses, then dump back in the stall. The strain on her body permanently damages her bronchial track to the point that she can never run or jump as well again. Rather than give her the year of pasture rest she needs to heal, she's sold as a work horse, which strains her physical health more and more until [[spoiler: she's driven to an early death]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the book, Reuben Smith dies after he rides Black Beauty while intoxicated and ends up falling off. In the 1994 version, he survives and loses his job.

to:

** In the book, Reuben Smith dies after he rides Black Beauty while intoxicated and ends up falling off. In the 1994 version, he survives and survives, but loses his job.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Many versions, including the 1994 one, expands on the relationship between Beauty and Joe to being that of best friends. In the book, they don't share much of a relationship. Notably, their reunion in the book is more of an afterthought that ensures Beauty his final and good home. In the 1994 film version, it's a huge TearJerker.

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: Many versions, including the 1994 one, expands on the relationship between Beauty and Joe to being that of best friends. In the book, they don't share much of a relationship. Notably, relationship, and while their reunion in the book is more of an afterthought that ensures Beauty his final and good home. In afterthought, the 1994 film version, it's version changed it to be a huge TearJerker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Many versions, including the 1994 one, expands on the relationship between Beauty and Joe to being that of best friends. In the book, they don't share much of a relationship. Notably, their reunion at the end is more of an afterthought that ensures Beauty his final and good home. In the 1994 version, it's a huge TearJerker.
** Similarily, the 1994 version also has Ginger being treated as Beauty's LoveInterest, while she's just a friend in the book.

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: Many versions, including the 1994 one, expands on the relationship between Beauty and Joe to being that of best friends. In the book, they don't share much of a relationship. Notably, their reunion at in the end book is more of an afterthought that ensures Beauty his final and good home. In the 1994 film version, it's a huge TearJerker.
** Similarily, the 1994 version also many versions has Ginger being treated portayed as Beauty's LoveInterest, while she's she was just a his friend in the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Many versions, including the 1994 one, expands on the relationship between Beauty and Joe to being that of best friends. In the book, they don't share much of a relationship, though they're still happy to reunite.

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: Many versions, including the 1994 one, expands on the relationship between Beauty and Joe to being that of best friends. In the book, they don't share much of a relationship, though they're still happy to reunite.relationship. Notably, their reunion at the end is more of an afterthought that ensures Beauty his final and good home. In the 1994 version, it's a huge TearJerker.

Top