Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / AgathaHAndTheSiegeOfMechanicsburg

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LaserGuidedKarma: {{Implied|Trope}} in the Prologue, where Von Pinn foreshadows ({{futureshadow|ing}}s?) that Lucrezia will spend centuries in a state of AndIMustScream if she continues her work of trapping people in different bodies. [[spoiler:If [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20150424 this one scene]] in the comic's Vol. 15 is anything to go by, that's exactly what happened]].
--> '''Lucrezia:''' "I mean, it must have been ''terribly'' boring being chained up in that forgotten hallway for over a hundred years."\\
'''Von Pinn:''' "You have no idea what it was like. But I take comfort in knowing that if you continue in this madness, ''you will.''"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForeignLanguageTirade: The prologue mentions that Von Pinn/Otilia cursed Lucrezia (''[[ThisIsUnforgivable "That which you have done here is blasphemy!"]]'') in Old French.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The scene where Gil and Agatha argue on the rooftop mentions (among other cases of Gil acting like NotHimself) that Gil's head twitched when talking to Agatha, with his tone of voice changing between twitches. As if [[spoiler:he was [[SplitPersonality arguing with himself]]]].

to:

** The scene where Gil and Agatha argue on the rooftop mentions (among other cases of Gil acting like NotHimself) that Gil's head twitched when talking to Agatha, with his tone of voice changing between twitches. As if [[spoiler:he was [[SplitPersonality arguing with himself]]]].

Added: 281

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A later scene also reveals that [[spoiler:Clank!Lucrezia ordered Klaus to install the copy of himself into Gilgamesh as an overlay to control him, because she knew Klaus would absolutely hate doing so.]]

to:

** A later scene also reveals that [[spoiler:Clank!Lucrezia ordered Klaus to install the copy of himself into Gilgamesh as an overlay to control him, because she knew Klaus would absolutely hate doing so.]]so]].
** The scene where Gil and Agatha argue on the rooftop mentions (among other cases of Gil acting like NotHimself) that Gil's head twitched when talking to Agatha, with his tone of voice changing between twitches. As if [[spoiler:he was [[SplitPersonality arguing with himself]]]].

Added: 462

Changed: 3

Removed: 485

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
New trope better fits what's being described.


* AdaptationalSympathy: A {{Downplayed|Trope}} example overlapping with AdaptationalExplanation. That part in the comic where Klaus [[spoiler:inflicted [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20121017 mind]]-[[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20130308 control]] on [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20131227 Gil]]]]? In this version, it's shown that [[spoiler:Lucrezia/Anevka made Klaus do it specifically because she knew he'd hate doing it]].



* HeinousnessRetcon: An example overlapping with AdaptationalExplanation. That part in the comic where Klaus [[spoiler:inflicted [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20121017 mind]]-[[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20130308 control]] on [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20131227 Gil]]]]? In this version, it's shown that [[spoiler:Lucrezia/Anevka made Klaus do it specifically because she knew he'd hate doing it]].



* LiteralMetaphor: In the scene (corresponding to [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20110422 Vol. XI p. 76]] of the webcomic) where Gil says that Tarvek "failed '[[Subject101 Ethics in Government 101]]'", a footnote explains that Ethics in Government was an actual class that students aboard Castle Wulfenbach were required to take. Many students had to take the class over and over again until they could at least make it ''look'' like they passed.

to:

* LiteralMetaphor: In the scene (corresponding to [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20110422 Vol. XI p. 76]] of the webcomic) where Gil says that Tarvek "failed '[[Subject101 Ethics in Government 101]]'", 101]],'" a footnote explains that Ethics in Government was an actual class that students aboard Castle Wulfenbach were required to take. Many students had to take the class over and over again until they could at least make it ''look'' like they passed.



* TheReveal: The novelization format explicitly states some details that could only be inferred or guessed from the original comic, such as [[spoiler: Zola explicitly being in control over Lucrezia, even after the beating Higgs gave her, Gil not being a revenant, and Gil having the personality overlay installed by Klaus.]]

to:

* TheReveal: The novelization format explicitly states some details that could only be inferred or guessed from the original comic, such as [[spoiler: Zola [[spoiler:Zola explicitly being in control over Lucrezia, even after the beating Higgs gave her, Gil not being a revenant, and Gil having the personality overlay installed by Klaus.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Footnote:''' He was beginning to think that, like so many other seemingly obvious things, he would have to do it himself.

to:

-->'''Footnote:''' He was beginning to think that, like so many other seemingly obvious things, he would have to do it himself.himself.
* WeAllDieSomeday: It's explained here that Cain Heterodyne specially designed the Doom Bell in such a way that, when it rang, the sound would force the listener to remember their inevitable death. It is this {{existential|Horror}} dread, rather than the volume of the sound, that makes people collapse when it's rung to announce Agatha's accession. Mechanicsburg's people are unnafected by it since they're used to the idea and have a ''joie de vivre'' with knowledge that they had limited time.

----

Added: 953

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:328:Franz giving Agatha a lift]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:328:Franz giving Agatha a lift]]lift.]]



* AdaptationalSympathy: A {{Downplayed|Trope}} example overlapping with AdaptationalExplanation. That part in the comic where Klaus [[spoiler:inflicted [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20121017 mind]]-[[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20130308 control]] on [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20131227 Gil]]]]? In this version, it's shown that [[spoiler:Lucrezia/Anevka made Klaus do it specifically because she knew he'd hate doing it]].



* {{Irony}}: In a rather absurd historical example, the Cobbler's Guild of Mechanicsburg paid a philosopher to write some advertising pamphlets. What he ended up making was an award-winning 600 page treatise on free will vs predestination that uses shopping for shoes as the framework of its arguments, which resulted in the philosopher being kicked to death by cobblers who objected to the enormous printer's bill that resulted. The Heterodyne of the time was impressed by how well the cobbler's boots stood up through the mob beating, so he ordered a new pair for each of his soldiers, which meant that the "pamphlet" really did boost sales for the cobblers.
** What's worse is that he's memorialized in the Plaza of the great Five Ironies so something like this happened four more times.

to:

* {{Irony}}: In a rather absurd historical example, the Cobbler's Guild of Mechanicsburg paid a philosopher to write some advertising pamphlets. What he ended up making was an award-winning 600 page treatise on free will vs predestination that uses shopping for shoes as the framework of its arguments, which resulted in the philosopher being kicked to death by cobblers who objected to the enormous printer's bill that resulted. The Heterodyne of the time was impressed by how well the cobbler's boots stood up through the mob beating, so he ordered a new pair for each of his soldiers, which meant that the "pamphlet" really did boost sales for the cobblers.
**
cobblers.\\
What's worse is that he's memorialized in the Plaza of the great Five Ironies so something like this happened four more times.times.
* LiteralMetaphor: In the scene (corresponding to [[https://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20110422 Vol. XI p. 76]] of the webcomic) where Gil says that Tarvek "failed '[[Subject101 Ethics in Government 101]]'", a footnote explains that Ethics in Government was an actual class that students aboard Castle Wulfenbach were required to take. Many students had to take the class over and over again until they could at least make it ''look'' like they passed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CharacterAlignment: Invoked in a footnote detailing the lengths the Hetrodyne Boys went to eallign the ethical praxis of Mechanicsburg. They largely succeeded, as seen below in ShoutOut instead of cutthroats they're cutpurses now.

to:

* CharacterAlignment: Invoked in a footnote detailing the lengths the Hetrodyne Boys went to eallign reallign the ethical praxis of Mechanicsburg. They largely succeeded, as seen below in ShoutOut ShoutOut; instead of cutthroats they're cutpurses now.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** What's worse is that he's memorialized in the Plaza of the great Fuve Ironies so something like this happened four more times.

to:

** What's worse is that he's memorialized in the Plaza of the great Fuve Five Ironies so something like this happened four more times.

Added: 581

Changed: 15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Lady Vitriox''': They ''all'' do, my Lady . It consists of other men.

to:

'''Lady Vitriox''': They ''all'' do, my Lady .Lady. It consists of other men.



* CharacterAlignment: Invoked in a footnote detailing the lengths the Hetrodyne Boys went to eallign the ethical praxis of Mechanicsburg. They largely succeeded, as seen below in ShoutOut instead of cutthroats they're cutpurses now.



** What's worse is that he's memorialized in the Plaza of the great Fuve Ironies so something like this happened four more times.



* RazorFloss: Played realistically, Zola uses a wire of this to hold Agatha hostage, the footnotes point out that while these are deadly they can't cut someone to little chunks simply by walking through a tangle of them.



** To Creator/GaryGygax, oh sorry, ''Garibaldi Gygax'' who wrote on an ethical system with terms suspiciously similar to the classic ''TabletopGame/DungeonsAndDragons'' CharacterAlignment system. (The Heterodyne Boys referred to it when trying to reform the people of Mechanicsburg from outright thieves and brigands into simple [[SnakeOilSalesman Snake Oil Salesmen]] and [[HonestJohnsDealership shady businesspeople]].)%%InvokedTrope

to:

** To Creator/GaryGygax, oh sorry, ''Garibaldi Gygax'' who wrote on an ethical system with terms suspiciously similar to the classic ''TabletopGame/DungeonsAndDragons'' CharacterAlignment system. (The Heterodyne Boys referred to it when trying to reform the people of Mechanicsburg from outright thieves and brigands into simple [[SnakeOilSalesman Snake Oil Salesmen]] and [[HonestJohnsDealership shady businesspeople]].)%%InvokedTrope)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hey, kids - ask about the Invoked and In Universe tags!


** To Creator/GaryGygax, oh sorry, ''Garibaldi Gygax'' who wrote on an ethical system with terms suspiciously similar to the CharacterAlignment system. (The Heterodyne Boys referred to it when trying to reform the people of Mechanicsburg from outright thieves and brigands into simple [[SnakeOilSalesman Snake Oil Salesmen]] and [[HonestJohnsDealership shady businesspeople]].)

to:

** To Creator/GaryGygax, oh sorry, ''Garibaldi Gygax'' who wrote on an ethical system with terms suspiciously similar to the classic ''TabletopGame/DungeonsAndDragons'' CharacterAlignment system. (The Heterodyne Boys referred to it when trying to reform the people of Mechanicsburg from outright thieves and brigands into simple [[SnakeOilSalesman Snake Oil Salesmen]] and [[HonestJohnsDealership shady businesspeople]].))%%InvokedTrope

Added: 628

Changed: 227

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShipperOnDeck: As mentioned under ScrewThisImOutOfHere, Moloch is eager to get the hell out of Mechanicsburg as soon as things calm down and the siege is finally broken. [[spoiler: Agatha respects his decision at the end of the book, but Moloch is visibly torn when he asks Violetta to escape with him. Oggie then "subtly" bumps Violetta into Moloch's arms, Vanamonde the seneschal talks him into staying one more day (especially after Violetta asks him to dance with her at the party being planned), and Castle Heterodyne quietly orders Van to have the ''second-best'' dressmaker in town make a pretty dress for Violetta.]]



** To Creator/GaryGygax, oh sorry, ''Garibaldi Gygax'' who wrote on an ethical system with terms suspiciously similar to the CharacterAlignment system.

to:

** To Creator/GaryGygax, oh sorry, ''Garibaldi Gygax'' who wrote on an ethical system with terms suspiciously similar to the CharacterAlignment system. (The Heterodyne Boys referred to it when trying to reform the people of Mechanicsburg from outright thieves and brigands into simple [[SnakeOilSalesman Snake Oil Salesmen]] and [[HonestJohnsDealership shady businesspeople]].)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HeelFaceTurn: Played for laughs. After the Doom Bell has rung and Baron Krassimir Oublenmach realizes there ''is'' a lost treasure of the Heterodynes after all (while lying collapsed on the tower roof), he mentally gloats that he's on the cusp of claiming the treasure for himself and winning. The footnote immediately afterwards notes that this ended up starting his storied career as a loyal servant of the Heterodyne family, which he strenuously denies he is in the present day that the in-universe authors are writing the book in, but apparently it worked out really well for him. Then the footnote notes that the story is going to leave him lying there for the rest of the book because he's a relative bit player in Agatha's story and he's not gonna show up again for goodness knows how many more novels anyway.

Added: 675

Changed: 414

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After knocking out Gil while under the effects of the slaver wasp cure Gil mixed up, Bang immediately contemplates either pouring the rest of it down Gil's throat or down the sink, wondering whether it'll annoy him more, whereas in the comic the scene cut out immediately after she knocked him unconscious, with no indication if she potentially fed him the cure. When Gil comes to, he notices has an awful taste in his mouth, implying that she decided on the former.
** A later scene also reveals that [[spoiler:Clank!Lucrezia ordered Klaus to install the copy of himself into Gilgamesh as an overlay to control him, because she knew Klaus would absolutely hate doing so.]]



* SpottingTheThread: [[spoiler:When Klaus claims that Gil was wasped before he even met Agatha, Gil claims she never gave him any orders. Boris immediately realizes that she ''did''--she politely asked them all to leave (which might not have counted) and screamed a BigNo (which ''definitely'' counted). The fact that Gil easily ignored both orders means he can't have been wasped]].

to:

* SpottingTheThread: [[spoiler:When Klaus claims that Gil was wasped before he even met Agatha, Agatha (an impossible claim likely cooked up by Clank!Lucrezia or by Klaus under her orders), Gil claims she never gave him any orders. Boris immediately realizes that she ''did''--she politely asked them all to leave (which might not have counted) and screamed a BigNo (which ''definitely'' counted). The fact that Gil easily ignored both orders means he can't have been wasped. Boris knows that Klaus would certainly have remembered and have come to the same conclusion, and when Klaus sees Boris' reaction to this realization, Boris notices a glimmer of ''relief'' on the Baron's face, as since Klaus' trusted right-hand man has come to that same conclusion, it is confirmation that Gil was never wasped]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AscendedFanon: Agatha's miniature clanks are referred to by their fan nickname of dingbots for the first time in an official Girl Genius material.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnwittingInstigatorOfDoom: Otilla can modulate her voice to find the right frequency that will make people listen and obey her. The issue with this is that it's what gives lucrezia the idea to put a commanding voice in her slaver wasps.

to:

* UnwittingInstigatorOfDoom: Otilla can modulate her voice to find the right frequency that will make people listen and obey her. The issue with this is that it's what gives lucrezia Lucrezia the idea to put a commanding voice in make her slaver wasps.Slaver Wasps and the revenants they create respond to her voice.

Top