Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / Speak

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the movie, the final scene shows Melinda being driven home by her mom after Andy attacks her in the closet. As they arrive home, Melinda’s mom says she doesn’t have to talk about what happened if she doesn’t want to but Melinda says she does in fact want to. As Melinda reveals what happened to her one year before, we see see the subtle pained expression play out on her face as she realizes just how traumatic the last year has been for her daughter. It’s heartwarming to finally see her mother listen and Melinda finally be able to speak about what happened to her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Moreover, in the end, Melinda is finally able to come to terms with what happened to her and no longer blames herself for Andy assaulting her. When she's able to open up to other people, she describes it as feeling like the block in her throat has melted away. In the book, the person she opens up to is Mr. Freeman, the only teacher who encouraged her to let her pain out. In the movie, it's her mother, who was shown to be concerned for Melinda at several points in the story, especially when she woke her up from her nightmare about Andy raping her.

to:

* Moreover, in the end, Melinda is finally able to come to terms with what happened to her and no longer blames herself for Andy assaulting her. When she's able to open up to other people, she describes it as feeling like the block in her throat has melted away. In the book, the person she opens up to is Mr. Freeman, the only teacher who encouraged her to let her pain out. In the movie, it's her mother, who was shown to be concerned for Melinda at several points in the story, especially when she woke her up from her nightmare about Andy raping her.her.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Melinda's disconnected and negectful parents buying her art supplies for Christmas, saying they've noticed she's been getting into art a lot.

to:

* Melinda's disconnected and negectful neglectful parents buying her art supplies for Christmas, saying they've noticed she's been getting into art a lot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Melinda's somewhat distant-seeming parents buying her art supplies for Christmas, saying they've noticed she's been getting into art a lot.

to:

* Melinda's somewhat distant-seeming disconnected and negectful parents buying her art supplies for Christmas, saying they've noticed she's been getting into art a lot.

Added: 43

Changed: 216

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In a scene exclusive to the movie, Melinda shows Mr. Freeman her little sanctuary in the old janitor's closet. The sweet smile he gives her really reinforces it.

to:

* In a scene exclusive to the movie, Melinda shows Mr. Freeman her little sanctuary in the old janitor's closet. The sweet smile he gives her really reinforces it. To those who wished Melinda had told Mr. Freeman about what happened to her instead of her mother, this makes up for the trade-off.



* When Melinda writes Andy's name down on the "Guys to stay away from" section on the BathroomStallGraffiti, it later becomes [[YouAreNotAlone clustered]] with responses from other girls talking about how horrible Andy is. Making it better is that it comes right after Rachel refused to believe her about Andy being a rapist.

to:

* When Melinda writes Andy's name down on the "Guys to stay away from" section on the BathroomStallGraffiti, it later becomes [[YouAreNotAlone clustered]] with responses from other girls talking about how horrible Andy is. Making it better is that it comes right after Rachel refused to believe her about Andy being a rapist.rapist, showing Melinda [[RestoredMyFaithInHumanity not all her words fell on deaf ears]].
-->'''Melinda:''' ...I feel like I can fly.

Added: 1122

Changed: 973

Removed: 281

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes [[YouAreNotAlone clustered]] with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is. Making it better is that it comes right after Rachel refused to believe her about Andy being a rapist.



* Melinda's somewhat distant-seeming parents buying her drawing pencils and a sketchbook for Christmas, because they notice she's drawing a lot.
* In the movie, when Melinda writes the truth for Rachael, the latter expresses genuine shock and concern for her, despite that they are ex-friends. Sure it backfires when she [[CassandraTruth doesn't believe]] who raped Melinda, but in that moment, she was pretty caring for someone who drifted apart from Melinda.
* The ending of the book, where Melinda starts to really open up to other people and tell them about what happened, describing it as feeling like the last shards of ice in her throat had melted. In the book, the person she opens up to is Mr. Freeman, the only teacher who seemed genuinely concerned about her and encouraged her. In the movie? It was her mother, who was shown to be concerned for Melinda at several points in the story, especially when she woke her up from her nightmare about Andy raping her.

to:

* Melinda's somewhat distant-seeming parents buying her drawing pencils and a sketchbook art supplies for Christmas, because they notice saying they've noticed she's drawing been getting into art a lot.
* In a scene exclusive to the movie, when Melinda writes shows Mr. Freeman her little sanctuary in the truth for Rachael, old janitor's closet. The sweet smile he gives her really reinforces it.
* When Melinda tells Rachel that she called the cops because she was raped at the summer party,
the latter expresses genuine shock is horrified and concern for her, despite that they are ex-friends. Sure heartbroken to hear what her former friend went through. Unfortunately, it backfires when she Rachel [[CassandraTruth doesn't refuses to believe]] who raped Melinda, but in that moment, she was pretty caring for someone who drifted apart from Melinda.
* The ending of the book, where
Melinda starts when she reveals that her rapist was Andy (who is Rachel's current boyfriend).
* When Melinda writes Andy's name down on the "Guys
to really stay away from" section on the BathroomStallGraffiti, it later becomes [[YouAreNotAlone clustered]] with responses from other girls talking about how horrible Andy is. Making it better is that it comes right after Rachel refused to believe her about Andy being a rapist.
* At the end of the story, Rachel calls Melinda to apologize to her. While it's left up in the air as to whether they can ever repair their friendship, it's at least a kind gesture on her part and makes it clear that Rachel isn't a bad person.
* Moreover, in the end, Melinda is finally able to come to terms with what happened to her and no longer blames herself for Andy assaulting her. When she's able to
open up to other people and tell them about what happened, describing people, she describes it as feeling like the last shards of ice block in her throat had melted.has melted away. In the book, the person she opens up to is Mr. Freeman, the only teacher who seemed genuinely concerned about her and encouraged her. her to let her pain out. In the movie? It was movie, it's her mother, who was shown to be concerned for Melinda at several points in the story, especially when she woke her up from her nightmare about Andy raping her.

Added: 285

Changed: 360

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes [[YouAreNotAlone clustered]] with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is. Making it better is that it comes right after [[spoiler:Rachel refused to believe her about Andy being a rapist]].

to:

!!Administrivia/SpoilersOff applies to all Heartwarming pages, so all spoilers are unmarked. Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned!
----
* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes [[YouAreNotAlone clustered]] with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is. Making it better is that it comes right after [[spoiler:Rachel Rachel refused to believe her about Andy being a rapist]].rapist.



* In the movie, when Melinda writes the truth for Rachael, the latter expresses genuine shock and concern for her, despite that they are ex-friends. Sure it backfires when she [[CassandraTruth doesn't believe]] [[spoiler:who raped Melinda]], but in that moment, she was pretty caring for someone who drifted apart from Melinda.
* The ending of the book, where [[spoiler:Melinda starts to really open up to other people and tell them about what happened]], describing it as feeling like the last shards of ice in her throat had melted. In the book, the person she opens up to is Mr. Freeman, the only teacher who seemed genuinely concerned about her and encouraged her. In the movie? It was her mother, who was shown to be concerned for Melinda at several points in the story, especially when she woke her up from her nightmare about [[spoiler:Andy raping her.]]

to:

* In the movie, when Melinda writes the truth for Rachael, the latter expresses genuine shock and concern for her, despite that they are ex-friends. Sure it backfires when she [[CassandraTruth doesn't believe]] [[spoiler:who who raped Melinda]], Melinda, but in that moment, she was pretty caring for someone who drifted apart from Melinda.
* The ending of the book, where [[spoiler:Melinda Melinda starts to really open up to other people and tell them about what happened]], happened, describing it as feeling like the last shards of ice in her throat had melted. In the book, the person she opens up to is Mr. Freeman, the only teacher who seemed genuinely concerned about her and encouraged her. In the movie? It was her mother, who was shown to be concerned for Melinda at several points in the story, especially when she woke her up from her nightmare about [[spoiler:Andy Andy raping her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes [[YouAreNotAlone clustered]] with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is.

to:

* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes [[YouAreNotAlone clustered]] with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is. Making it better is that it comes right after [[spoiler:Rachel refused to believe her about Andy being a rapist]].



* Melinda's somewhat distant-seeming parents buying her drawing pencils and a sketchbook for Christmas, because they've notice she's drawing a lot.
* In the movie, when Melinda writes the truth for Rachael, the latter expresses genuine shock and concern for her, despite that they are ex-friends. Sure it backfires when she [[CassandraTruth doesn't believe]] [[spoiler: who raped Melinda]], but in that moment, she was pretty caring for someone who drifted apart from Melinda.
* The ending of the book, where [[spoiler:Melinda starts to really open up to other people and tell them about what happened]], describing it as feeling like the last shards of ice in her throat had melted. In the book, the person she opens up to is Mr. Freeman, the only teacher who seemed genuinely concerned about her and encouraged her. In the movie? It was her mother who was shown to be concerned for Melinda at several points in the story, especially when she woke her up from her nightmare about [[spoiler:Andy raping her.]]

to:

* Melinda's somewhat distant-seeming parents buying her drawing pencils and a sketchbook for Christmas, because they've they notice she's drawing a lot.
* In the movie, when Melinda writes the truth for Rachael, the latter expresses genuine shock and concern for her, despite that they are ex-friends. Sure it backfires when she [[CassandraTruth doesn't believe]] [[spoiler: who [[spoiler:who raped Melinda]], but in that moment, she was pretty caring for someone who drifted apart from Melinda.
* The ending of the book, where [[spoiler:Melinda starts to really open up to other people and tell them about what happened]], describing it as feeling like the last shards of ice in her throat had melted. In the book, the person she opens up to is Mr. Freeman, the only teacher who seemed genuinely concerned about her and encouraged her. In the movie? It was her mother mother, who was shown to be concerned for Melinda at several points in the story, especially when she woke her up from her nightmare about [[spoiler:Andy raping her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ending of the book, where [[spoiler:Melinda starts to really open up to other people and tell them about what happened]], describing it as feeling like the last shards of ice in her throat had melted.

to:

* The ending of the book, where [[spoiler:Melinda starts to really open up to other people and tell them about what happened]], describing it as feeling like the last shards of ice in her throat had melted. In the book, the person she opens up to is Mr. Freeman, the only teacher who seemed genuinely concerned about her and encouraged her. In the movie? It was her mother who was shown to be concerned for Melinda at several points in the story, especially when she woke her up from her nightmare about [[spoiler:Andy raping her.]]

Added: 329

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes clustered with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is.

to:

* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes clustered [[YouAreNotAlone clustered]] with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is.


Added DiffLines:

* In the movie, when Melinda writes the truth for Rachael, the latter expresses genuine shock and concern for her, despite that they are ex-friends. Sure it backfires when she [[CassandraTruth doesn't believe]] [[spoiler: who raped Melinda]], but in that moment, she was pretty caring for someone who drifted apart from Melinda.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Melinda's somewhat distant-seeming parents buying her drawing pencils and a sketchbook for Christmas, because they've notice she's drawing a lot.

to:

* Melinda's somewhat distant-seeming parents buying her drawing pencils and a sketchbook for Christmas, because they've notice she's drawing a lot.lot.
* The ending of the book, where [[spoiler:Melinda starts to really open up to other people and tell them about what happened]], describing it as feeling like the last shards of ice in her throat had melted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* David and Ivy's genuine and unquestioning acceptance of Melinda, a social outcast and supposed 'freak'. Especially in Ivy's case, as we know she was at the party. If nothing else, it's nice to know that not ''all'' teens have to be monsters.

to:

* David and Ivy's genuine and unquestioning acceptance of Melinda, a social outcast and supposed 'freak'. Especially in Ivy's case, as we know she was at the party. If nothing else, it's nice to know that not ''all'' teens have to be monsters.monsters.
* Melinda's somewhat distant-seeming parents buying her drawing pencils and a sketchbook for Christmas, because they've notice she's drawing a lot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes clustered with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is.

to:

* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes clustered with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is.is.
* David and Ivy's genuine and unquestioning acceptance of Melinda, a social outcast and supposed 'freak'. Especially in Ivy's case, as we know she was at the party. If nothing else, it's nice to know that not ''all'' teens have to be monsters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When Melinda writes Andy as a guy to avoid on the bathroom wall, it becomes clustered with responses that agree with Mel and talk about how horrible Andy is.

Top