Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / ProvenGuilty

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* While it's the type of thing that goes under the radar, there is a very moving moment when Harry is using his Sight on one of the victims of the phobophages and he turns to look at Murphy. He sees Murphy with the stains of her life as the head of SI and then: "She smiled at me, a sunny light in it, though her body's face remained a neutral mask." I missed it the first time I read through and it made me do a double take when I reread it because it conveyed faster then almost any scene in the series that Murphy is Harry's friend and loves him.

to:

* While it's the type of thing that goes under the radar, there is there’s a very moving moment when Harry is using his Sight on one of the victims of the phobophages and he turns to look at Murphy. He sees Murphy with the stains of her life as the head of SI and then: "She smiled at me, a sunny light in it, though her body's face remained a neutral mask." I missed it the first time I read through and it made me do a double take when I reread it because it conveyed faster then almost any scene in the series that Murphy is Harry's friend and loves him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Molly's return home, from the same book. Michael's first reaction on seeing his daughter come home with rainbow-coloured hair, dressed "like Frankenhooker", covered in tattoos and with piercings in pretty much every place where it is possible to have one, is to hug her.

to:

* Molly's return home, from the same book. Michael's first reaction on seeing his daughter come home with rainbow-coloured hair, dressed "like Frankenhooker", covered in tattoos and with piercings in pretty much every place where it is it’s possible to have one, is to hug her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Also from the same book, the scene in which Harry finds out that the fetches have taken Molly to Arctis Tor, Mab's capital and one of the major strongholds of Faerie. Harry states that the mission has just gotten more difficult, and he doesn't expect Thomas, Charity or Murph] to still come. Without a word, they step up to his side, willing to do it anyway. To quote Harry: "A bolt of warmth, fierce with joy and pride and gratitude, flashed through me like sudden lightning. I don't care about whose DNA recombined with whose. When everything goes to hell, the people who stand beside you without flinching- they are your family. And they were my heroes."

to:

* Also from the same book, the scene in which Harry finds out that the fetches have taken Molly to Arctis Tor, Mab's capital and one of the major strongholds of Faerie. Harry states that the mission has just gotten more difficult, and he doesn't expect Thomas, Charity or Murph] Murphy to still come. Without a word, they step up to his side, willing to do it anyway. To quote Harry: "A bolt of warmth, fierce with joy and pride and gratitude, flashed through me like sudden lightning. I don't care about whose DNA recombined with whose. When everything goes to hell, the people who stand beside you without flinching- they are your family. And they were my heroes."

Added: 369

Changed: 1109

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
We don't spoil moments pages


* Also from the same book, the scene in which Harry finds out that [[spoiler: the fetches have taken Molly to Arctis Tor, Mab's capital and the stronghold of literally half of Faerie( when she needs to. A considerable yet unknown amount of Faerie is Wyldfae turf. She can Call them into her service if War is declared, but otherwise, its a considerable bit less. Of course, she has considerable ties to the more powerful Wyldfae, and she's so powerful that the Wyldfae defer to her or her sister even at times of peace, so it's probably effectively even more, especially considering the whole "wheels within wheels" thing she - and most other fae - have going on.).]] Harry states that the mission has just gotten more difficult, and he doesn't expect [[spoiler: Thomas, Charity or Murphy]] to still come. Without a word, they step up to his side, willing to do it anyway. To quote Harry: "A bolt of warmth, fierce with joy and pride and gratitude, flashed through me like sudden lightning. I don't care about whose DNA recombined with whose. When everything goes to hell, the people who stand beside you without flinching- they are your family. And they were my heroes."
* Harry plans a location spell to find a kidnapped [[spoiler: Molly]], using an untested magical gizmo he's been working on that may very well blow up in his face with enough power to kill him and destroy his entire lab. It's so dangerous that even Lash is pleading with him not to do it, or at least [[DealWithTheDevil take up the coin]] so he can survive if it does go bad. Harry's response?

to:

* Also from the same book, the scene in which Harry finds out that [[spoiler: the fetches have taken Molly to Arctis Tor, Mab's capital and one of the stronghold major strongholds of literally half of Faerie( when she needs to. A considerable yet unknown amount of Faerie is Wyldfae turf. She can Call them into her service if War is declared, but otherwise, its a considerable bit less. Of course, she has considerable ties to the more powerful Wyldfae, and she's so powerful that the Wyldfae defer to her or her sister even at times of peace, so it's probably effectively even more, especially considering the whole "wheels within wheels" thing she - and most other fae - have going on.).]] Faerie. Harry states that the mission has just gotten more difficult, and he doesn't expect [[spoiler: Thomas, Charity or Murphy]] Murph] to still come. Without a word, they step up to his side, willing to do it anyway. To quote Harry: "A bolt of warmth, fierce with joy and pride and gratitude, flashed through me like sudden lightning. I don't care about whose DNA recombined with whose. When everything goes to hell, the people who stand beside you without flinching- they are your family. And they were my heroes."
* Harry plans a location spell to find a kidnapped [[spoiler: Molly]], Molly, using an untested magical gizmo he's been working on that may very well blow up in his face with enough power to kill him and destroy his entire lab. It's so dangerous that even Lash is pleading with him not to do it, or at least [[DealWithTheDevil take up the coin]] so he can survive if it does go bad. Harry's response?



* Later on in the same book, after [[spoiler: rescuing Molly from Arctis Tor]] a weary Thomas asks Harry and Murphy why they just went through all of that. Harry and Murphy exchange a smile and draw Thomas' attention to [[spoiler: Charity and Molly]]. Thomas' response: "Oh. Right."

to:

* Later on in the same book, after [[spoiler: rescuing Molly from Arctis Tor]] Tor, a weary Thomas asks Harry and Murphy why they just went through all of that. Harry and Murphy exchange a smile and draw Thomas' attention to [[spoiler: Charity and Molly]].Molly. Thomas' response: "Oh. Right."



--> "[[AsTheGoodBookSays Greater love hath no man]]," he said. "Nothing I can say would be enough. [[spoiler:She's my daughter, Harry.]] Thank you."
* Harry eventually reconciling with [[spoiler: Ebenezar]]. It took a couple of books, but considering how difficult Harry finds it to trust someone, forgiving someone for betraying it is a ''really'' big deal for him.
** An addendum to that. [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] has insisted that he wasn't at the council meeting that Harry's trial was conducted at. Harry realizes that not only was [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] fibbing about not being at the council meeting that Harry's trial was conducted at, but that [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] must have argued just as passionately for him as Harry did for [[spoiler: Molly]]. [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] still refuses to come out and say that it's true, but Harry knows.
* By the end of the book, Harry learns [[spoiler:Michael has known Harry has the shadow of Lasciel within him and took the coin to save Michael's youngest since the end of ''Death Masks'', having ''seen'' him pick up the coin. And Michael still saw Harry as family, inviting him to family dinners around Christmas, and even asks him to watch over his family when Michael is away.]]

to:

--> "[[AsTheGoodBookSays Greater love hath no man]]," he said. "Nothing I can say would be enough. [[spoiler:She's She's my daughter, Harry.]] Harry. Thank you."
* Harry eventually reconciling with [[spoiler: Ebenezar]].Ebenezar. It took a couple of books, but considering how difficult Harry finds it to trust someone, forgiving someone for betraying it is a ''really'' big deal for him.
** An addendum to that. [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] Ebenezar has insisted that he wasn't at the council meeting that Harry's trial was conducted at. Harry realizes that not only was [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] Ebenezar fibbing about not being at the council meeting that Harry's trial was conducted at, but that [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] Ebenezar must have argued just as passionately for him as Harry did for [[spoiler: Molly]]. [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] Molly. Ebenezar still refuses to come out and say that it's true, but Harry knows.
** At the beginning, Eb invited Harry out to lunch, and seems disappointed when Harry tells him that he can't. He really does want to reconcile with his apprentice.
* By the end of the book, Harry learns [[spoiler:Michael Michael has known Harry has the shadow of Lasciel within him and took the coin to save Michael's youngest since the end of ''Death Masks'', having ''seen'' him pick up the coin. And Michael still saw Harry as family, inviting him to family dinners around Christmas, and even asks him to watch over his family when Michael is away.]]



** An added moment of heartwarming - despite knowing [[spoiler: that Harry has the shadow of a Denarian in his noggin]], Michael still trusts Harry with his daughter's training.

to:

** An added moment of heartwarming - despite knowing [[spoiler: that Harry has the shadow of a Denarian in his noggin]], noggin, Michael still trusts Harry with his daughter's training.



* Excluding the painful elevator scene, Harry and Murphy's entire interaction during the novel is one big hunk of heartwarming. She is steadfastly supporting him during the investigation and even the siege on Arctis Tor, and what's more is that she accepts the fact that [[spoiler: she's about to lose S.I. for going MIA while they rescued Molly because it was absolutely worth it to save her and to make sure Harry returned safely.]] The hug they share at the end is truly something sweet and special to experience.

to:

* Excluding the painful elevator scene, Harry and Murphy's entire interaction during the novel is one big hunk of heartwarming. She is steadfastly supporting him during the investigation and even the siege on Arctis Tor, and what's more is that she accepts the fact that [[spoiler: she's about to lose S.I. for going MIA while they rescued Molly because it was absolutely worth it to save her and to make sure Harry returned safely.]] The hug they share at the end is truly something sweet and special to experience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* By the end of the book, Harry learns [[spoiler:Michael has known Harry has the shadow of Lasciel within him and took the coin to save Michael's youngest since the end of ''Death Masks''. And Michael still saw Harry as family, inviting him to family dinners around Christmas, and even asks him to watch over his family when Michael is away.]]

to:

* By the end of the book, Harry learns [[spoiler:Michael has known Harry has the shadow of Lasciel within him and took the coin to save Michael's youngest since the end of ''Death Masks''.Masks'', having ''seen'' him pick up the coin. And Michael still saw Harry as family, inviting him to family dinners around Christmas, and even asks him to watch over his family when Michael is away.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> "Greater love hath no man," he said. "Nothing I can say would be enough. [[spoiler:She's my daughter, Harry.]] Thank you."

to:

--> "Greater "[[AsTheGoodBookSays Greater love hath no man," man]]," he said. "Nothing I can say would be enough. [[spoiler:She's my daughter, Harry.]] Thank you."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's very quick and is given no real attention, but Harry kissing Murphy (for the first time that we the audience are aware of, at least) in celebration when she helps him figure out how to track Molly is absolutely ''adorable''.

to:

* It's very quick and is given no real attention, but Harry kissing Murphy (for the first time that we the audience are aware of, at least) in celebration when she helps him figure out how to track Molly is absolutely ''adorable''.''adorable''.
* Harry and Molly having a bit of a bonding moment over their shared story of how they discovered their own respective magic is pretty heartwarming.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Earlier in the book Harry muses about how he's been avoiding Michael since he picked up the coin. He's not afraid that Michael would kill him, or anything like that. Harry's in fact afraid of ''disappointing Michael''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Slightly related to that, the fact that Thomas (of his own free will) had a private conversation about Harry to Murphy to find out what was really going on between them, since he knew full well his brother had feelings for her and vice versa. It's really endearing as hell that Thomas is a ShipperOnDeck from pretty much the get-go.

to:

** Slightly related to that, the fact that Thomas (of his own free will) had a private conversation about Harry to Murphy to find out what was really going on between them, since he knew full well his brother had feelings for her and vice versa. It's really endearing as hell that Thomas is a ShipperOnDeck from pretty much the get-go.get-go.
* It's very quick and is given no real attention, but Harry kissing Murphy (for the first time that we the audience are aware of, at least) in celebration when she helps him figure out how to track Molly is absolutely ''adorable''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Excluding the painful elevator scene, Harry and Murphy's entire interaction during the novel is one big hunk of heartwarming. She is steadfastly supporting him during the investigation and even the siege on Arctis Tor, and what's more is that she accepts the fact that [[spoiler: she's about to lose S.I. for going MIA while the rescued Molly because it was absolutely worth it to save her and to make sure Harry returned safely.]] The hug they share at the end is truly something sweet and special to experience.

to:

* Excluding the painful elevator scene, Harry and Murphy's entire interaction during the novel is one big hunk of heartwarming. She is steadfastly supporting him during the investigation and even the siege on Arctis Tor, and what's more is that she accepts the fact that [[spoiler: she's about to lose S.I. for going MIA while the they rescued Molly because it was absolutely worth it to save her and to make sure Harry returned safely.]] The hug they share at the end is truly something sweet and special to experience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Murphy assuring Harry that he's in control of his own destiny, and the black magic inside can't control him if he doesn't let it.

to:

* Murphy assuring Harry that he's in control of his own destiny, and the black magic inside can't control him if he doesn't let it.it.
* Excluding the painful elevator scene, Harry and Murphy's entire interaction during the novel is one big hunk of heartwarming. She is steadfastly supporting him during the investigation and even the siege on Arctis Tor, and what's more is that she accepts the fact that [[spoiler: she's about to lose S.I. for going MIA while the rescued Molly because it was absolutely worth it to save her and to make sure Harry returned safely.]] The hug they share at the end is truly something sweet and special to experience.
-->'''Murphy''': What about you? You okay?
-->'''Harry''': I, uh. I'll be okay.
-->'''Harry's inner monologue''': She nodded, and then simply stepped forward and hugged me. My arms went around her without me telling them to do it. It wasn't a tense, meaning-laden hug. She was my friend. She was exhausted and worried and suffering, and she'd had what she valued most sullied and stained, but she was worried about me. Giving me a hug. Assuring me, by implication, that everything was going to be alright. I gave as good as I got for a while.
** Slightly related to that, the fact that Thomas (of his own free will) had a private conversation about Harry to Murphy to find out what was really going on between them, since he knew full well his brother had feelings for her and vice versa. It's really endearing as hell that Thomas is a ShipperOnDeck from pretty much the get-go.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** An added moment of heartwarming is that most of the time, when he uses his Sight, Harry sees [[NightmareFuel things like Victor's house and the naagloshi.]] Here, we get a moment of something else that will be forever imprinted in his brain-something beautiful.


Added DiffLines:

** Even when Lash tempts him by arguing that killing himself is just a way of selfishly getting himself out of the way, Harry ''still'' refuses to do so.


Added DiffLines:

* It's kind of subtle and twisted, but Harry says to Michael that if he does go bad, he would prefer that Michael be the one to put him out of his misery. Michael, in turn, promises that if Harry decides to give up his magic, he will be there for Harry every step of the way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** An added moment of heartwarming - despite knowing [[spoiler: that Harry has the shadow of a Denarian in his noggin]], Michael still trusts Harry with his daughter's training.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Harry plans a location spell to find a kidnapped [[spoiler: Molly]], using an untested magical gizmo he's been working on that may very well blow up in his face with enough power to kill him and destroy his entire lab. It's so dangerous that even Lash is pleading with him not to do it, or at least [[DealWithTheDevil take up the coin]] so he can survive if it does go bad. Harry's response?
-->'''Harry''': There's a child out there who needs me. I'd rather die than let her down. I'm doing the spell, period. So fuck off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Harry encouraging Molly to make amends with her mom, and explaining that her mom isn't being overprotective out of malice, but out of worry, because her husband [[InHarmsWay is constantly in the line of fire]] and Charity's natural reaction is to hold on tighter to her family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** An addendum to that. [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] has insisted that he wasn't at the council meeting that Harry's trial was conducted at. Harry realizes that not only was [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] fibbing about not being at the council meeting that Harry's trial was conducted at, but that [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] must have argued just as passionately for him as Harry did for [[spoiler: Molly]]. [[spoiler: Ebenezar]] still refuses to come out and say that it's true, but Harry knows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Also from the same book, the scene in which Harry finds out that [[spoiler: the fetches have taken Molly to Arctis Tor, Mab's capital and the stronghold of literally half of Faerie.]] Harry states that the mission has just gotten more difficult, and he doesn't expect [[spoiler: Thomas, Charity or Murphy]] to still come. Without a word, they step up to his side, willing to do it anyway. To quote Harry: "A bolt of warmth, fierce with joy and pride and gratitude, flashed through me like sudden lightning. I don't care about whose DNA recombined with whose. When everything goes to hell, the people who stand beside you without flinching- they are your family. And they were my heroes."

to:

* Also from the same book, the scene in which Harry finds out that [[spoiler: the fetches have taken Molly to Arctis Tor, Mab's capital and the stronghold of literally half of Faerie.Faerie( when she needs to. A considerable yet unknown amount of Faerie is Wyldfae turf. She can Call them into her service if War is declared, but otherwise, its a considerable bit less. Of course, she has considerable ties to the more powerful Wyldfae, and she's so powerful that the Wyldfae defer to her or her sister even at times of peace, so it's probably effectively even more, especially considering the whole "wheels within wheels" thing she - and most other fae - have going on.).]] Harry states that the mission has just gotten more difficult, and he doesn't expect [[spoiler: Thomas, Charity or Murphy]] to still come. Without a word, they step up to his side, willing to do it anyway. To quote Harry: "A bolt of warmth, fierce with joy and pride and gratitude, flashed through me like sudden lightning. I don't care about whose DNA recombined with whose. When everything goes to hell, the people who stand beside you without flinching- they are your family. And they were my heroes."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And before this revelation, Harry confesses to Michael about how when he had to execute someone and how it made him feel, Michael responds by relating his own experiences and similar feelings, and then goes on to say with absolute certainty that he believes Harry is a good man. It was heartwarming enough that even Harry started to tear up. Like Harry says, Michael is good people.

to:

** And before this revelation, Harry confesses to Michael about how when he had to execute someone and how it made him feel, Michael responds by relating his own experiences and similar feelings, and then goes on to say with absolute certainty that he believes Harry is a good man. It was heartwarming enough that even Harry started to tear up. Like Harry says, Michael is good people.people.
* Murphy assuring Harry that he's in control of his own destiny, and the black magic inside can't control him if he doesn't let it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* By the end of the book, Harry learns [[spoiler:Michael has known Harry has the shadow of Lasciel within him and took the coin to save Michael's youngest since the end of ''Death Masks''. And Michael still saw Harry as family, inviting him to family dinners around Christmas, and even asks him to watch over his family when Michael is away.]]

to:

* By the end of the book, Harry learns [[spoiler:Michael has known Harry has the shadow of Lasciel within him and took the coin to save Michael's youngest since the end of ''Death Masks''. And Michael still saw Harry as family, inviting him to family dinners around Christmas, and even asks him to watch over his family when Michael is away.]]]]
** And before this revelation, Harry confesses to Michael about how when he had to execute someone and how it made him feel, Michael responds by relating his own experiences and similar feelings, and then goes on to say with absolute certainty that he believes Harry is a good man. It was heartwarming enough that even Harry started to tear up. Like Harry says, Michael is good people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Harry eventually reconciling with [[spoiler: Ebenezar]]. It took a couple of books, but considering how difficult Harry finds it to trust someone, forgiving someone for betraying it is a ''really'' big deal for him.

to:

* Harry eventually reconciling with [[spoiler: Ebenezar]]. It took a couple of books, but considering how difficult Harry finds it to trust someone, forgiving someone for betraying it is a ''really'' big deal for him.him.
* By the end of the book, Harry learns [[spoiler:Michael has known Harry has the shadow of Lasciel within him and took the coin to save Michael's youngest since the end of ''Death Masks''. And Michael still saw Harry as family, inviting him to family dinners around Christmas, and even asks him to watch over his family when Michael is away.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> Michael: Harry, am I just too old?
--> Harry: Hey, let he who hath never stonewashed his jeans cast the first stone.

to:

--> Michael: -->'''Michael:''' Harry, am I just too old?
--> Harry: -->'''Harry:''' Hey, let he who hath never stonewashed his jeans cast the first stone.



--> "Greater love hath no man," he said. Nothing I can say would be enough. [[spoiler: She's my daughter, Harry.]] Thank you."

to:

--> "Greater love hath no man," he said. Nothing "Nothing I can say would be enough. [[spoiler: She's [[spoiler:She's my daughter, Harry.]] Thank you."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> "Greater love hath no man," he said. Nothing I can say would be enough. [[spoiler: She's my daughter, Harry.]] Thank you."

to:

--> "Greater love hath no man," he said. Nothing I can say would be enough. [[spoiler: She's my daughter, Harry.]] Thank you.""
* Harry eventually reconciling with [[spoiler: Ebenezar]]. It took a couple of books, but considering how difficult Harry finds it to trust someone, forgiving someone for betraying it is a ''really'' big deal for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* While it's the type of thing that goes under the radar, there is a very moving moment when Harry is using his Sight on one of the victims of the phobophages and he turns to look at Murphy. He sees Murphy with the stains of her life as the head of SI and then: "She smiled at me, a sunny light in it, though her body's face remained a neutral mask." I missed it the first time I read through and it made me do a double take when I reread it because it conveyed faster then almost any scene in the series that Murphy is Harry's friend and loves him.
* Molly's return home, from the same book. Michael's first reaction on seeing his daughter come home with rainbow-coloured hair, dressed "like Frankenhooker", covered in tattoos and with piercings in pretty much every place where it is possible to have one, is to hug her.
--> Michael: Harry, am I just too old?
--> Harry: Hey, let he who hath never stonewashed his jeans cast the first stone.
* Also from the same book, the scene in which Harry finds out that [[spoiler: the fetches have taken Molly to Arctis Tor, Mab's capital and the stronghold of literally half of Faerie.]] Harry states that the mission has just gotten more difficult, and he doesn't expect [[spoiler: Thomas, Charity or Murphy]] to still come. Without a word, they step up to his side, willing to do it anyway. To quote Harry: "A bolt of warmth, fierce with joy and pride and gratitude, flashed through me like sudden lightning. I don't care about whose DNA recombined with whose. When everything goes to hell, the people who stand beside you without flinching- they are your family. And they were my heroes."
* Later on in the same book, after [[spoiler: rescuing Molly from Arctis Tor]] a weary Thomas asks Harry and Murphy why they just went through all of that. Harry and Murphy exchange a smile and draw Thomas' attention to [[spoiler: Charity and Molly]]. Thomas' response: "Oh. Right."
* Michael's reaction after learning that Harry was [[spoiler: willing to take on essentially the entire White Council to protect Molly.]]
--> "Greater love hath no man," he said. Nothing I can say would be enough. [[spoiler: She's my daughter, Harry.]] Thank you."

Top