Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / YoungAvengers

Go To

OR

Added: 376

Changed: 38

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** She's probably meant to be white.



** It was one of the many things she does in her spare time as an idle rich kid, not to mention after her assault expreience she wants to defend herself and others

to:

** It was one of the many things she does in her spare time as an idle rich kid, not to mention after her assault expreience experience she wants to defend herself and othersothers

* Can the future Kang is in in the ''[[ComicBook/TheChildrensCrusade Children's Crusade]]'' oneshot be assumed to have been averted after the events of the actual run? (Namely [[spoiler: the deaths of Stature and The Vision.]]) It seems the specific events could still be possible, given that DeathIsCheap, but it also seems like a hindrance in the face of continuing stories.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Vol. 2 at least solidly confirms him to be staying with the Kaplans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Kate so damn good with a bow and arrow? She just happened to pick them up when scavenging for weapons her first night out fighting and now she's running missions alongside world's greatest marksman Hawkeye. Where did her skill come from?

to:

* Why is Kate so damn good with a bow and arrow? She just happened to pick them up when scavenging for weapons her first night out fighting and now she's running missions alongside world's greatest marksman Hawkeye. Where did her skill come from?from?
** It was one of the many things she does in her spare time as an idle rich kid, not to mention after her assault expreience she wants to defend herself and others

Added: 246

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do Wiccan and Hulkling keep the full extent of their powers a secret at first? When Jessica Jones asks Wiccan, "You generate electricity? Lightning?" he justs says, "Um...yeah. Kinda." He's not being secretive about anything else--he just voluntarily revealed his real name and a bunch of details about his family. Then Hulkling says that he's super-strong, but doesn't mention that he's also a shape-shifter. What is going on here?

to:

* Why do Wiccan and Hulkling keep the full extent of their powers a secret at first? When Jessica Jones asks Wiccan, "You generate electricity? Lightning?" he justs just says, "Um...yeah. Kinda." He's not being secretive about anything else--he just voluntarily revealed his real name and a bunch of details about his family. Then Hulkling says that he's super-strong, but doesn't mention that he's also a shape-shifter. What is going on here?



*** In Hulkling's backstory he bristles at the implication that he's a skrull, and the closest thing he had to a combat application was stretching his hands out into demonic-looking claws. Considering that he didn't make effective use of his shapeshifting powers until later and "I'm like the Hulk but smaller and less dumb" sounds more heroic than "I could be a skrull, and I can make myself look really scary", it's kind of obvious why he would omit that (or not want to confirm his fears). Additionally, Wiccan was still adjusting to his powers, his reality manipution skills were in the realm of "It's something I can sorta maybe do" and his bolts were a lot like lightning. They were yellow and they set something on fire- MUCH LIKE LIGHTNING! Later, his energy bolts were drawn blue and had a different look, but he really had no way of putting a name to them other than "Lightning, kinda" until he started suspecting his connection to the Scarlet Witch.

to:

*** In Hulkling's backstory he bristles at the implication that he's a skrull, Skrull, and the closest thing he had to a combat application was stretching his hands out into demonic-looking claws. Considering that he didn't make effective use of his shapeshifting powers until later and "I'm like the Hulk but smaller and less dumb" sounds more heroic than "I could be a skrull, Skrull, and I can make myself look really scary", it's kind of obvious why he would omit that (or not want to confirm his fears). Additionally, Wiccan was still adjusting to his powers, his reality manipution manipulation skills were in the realm of "It's something I can sorta maybe do" and his bolts were a lot like lightning. They were yellow and they set something on fire- MUCH LIKE LIGHTNING! Later, his energy bolts were drawn blue and had a different look, but he really had no way of putting a name to them other than "Lightning, kinda" until he started suspecting his connection to the Scarlet Witch.



** Chase probably saw the similarites between Wiccan's costume and Thor's thought the joke worked.

to:

** Chase probably saw the similarites similarities between Wiccan's costume and Thor's thought the joke worked.



*** That's been close to proved wrong by now (and you shouldn't hide your theories, by the way. They're not spoliers. They're theories). In the latest issue, [[spoiler: Scarlet Witch comes back, almost goes insane, and calls Wiccan and Speed "my sons" and says she'll try to undo the Decimation form the end of House of M.]] Also, during the Young Masters arc, Coat of Arms was a girl who knew Speed in Ju-V. So he wasn't willed into being too recently, if he was.

to:

*** That's been close to proved wrong by now (and you shouldn't hide your theories, by the way. They're not spoliers.spoilers. They're theories). In the latest issue, [[spoiler: Scarlet Witch comes back, almost goes insane, and calls Wiccan and Speed "my sons" and says she'll try to undo the Decimation form the end of House of M.]] Also, during the Young Masters arc, Coat of Arms was a girl who knew Speed in Ju-V. So he wasn't willed into being too recently, if he was.



** She wanted to "give it back" but Clinton told her somewhere that she may keep it.

to:

** She wanted to "give it back" but Clinton Clint told her somewhere that she may keep it.



** On a related note, how old Hulkling is? He was born after Kree-Skrull War that took place about 10 years before his Young Avenger appearance, but looks 15, at least. It could be chalked up to his alien hybrid physiology, but shouldn't he have noticed that he grew 1,5 times faster than other kids?

to:

** On a related note, how old Hulkling is? is Hulkling? He was born after Kree-Skrull War that took place about 10 years before his Young Avenger appearance, but looks 15, at least. It could be chalked up to his alien hybrid physiology, but shouldn't he have noticed that he grew 1,5 times faster than other kids?



** I think Children's Crusade confirms they are mutants

* Just a minor one, what race is Kate anyways?

to:

** I think Children's Crusade confirms they are mutants

mutants.

* Just a minor one, what race is Kate anyways?anyways?

* Why is Kate so damn good with a bow and arrow? She just happened to pick them up when scavenging for weapons her first night out fighting and now she's running missions alongside world's greatest marksman Hawkeye. Where did her skill come from?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So are Billy and Tommy mutants or what?

to:

* So are Billy and Tommy mutants or what?what?
** I think Children's Crusade confirms they are mutants

* Just a minor one, what race is Kate anyways?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The thing is, this wasn't just any juvenile detention facility - it was one where he specifically indicates they were ''experimenting on him.'' Who in the world would send a kid back to that? It also wasn't long after he joined the team that the Civil War broke out, and they ''all'' became criminals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** On a related note, how old Hulkling is? He was born after Kree-Skrull War that took place about 10 years before his Young Avenger appearance, but looks 15, at least. It could be chalked up to his alien hybrid physiology, but shouldn't he have noticed that he grew 1,5 times faster than other kids?

to:

** On a related note, how old Hulkling is? He was born after Kree-Skrull War that took place about 10 years before his Young Avenger appearance, but looks 15, at least. It could be chalked up to his alien hybrid physiology, but shouldn't he have noticed that he grew 1,5 times faster than other kids?kids?

* So are Billy and Tommy mutants or what?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Magic. Don't question it that much.

to:

** Magic. Don't question it that much.much.
** On a related note, how old Hulkling is? He was born after Kree-Skrull War that took place about 10 years before his Young Avenger appearance, but looks 15, at least. It could be chalked up to his alien hybrid physiology, but shouldn't he have noticed that he grew 1,5 times faster than other kids?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She actually did lose the name and the bow in a shooting contest with Clint, but he decided to let her keep them after she stole the bow back.

to:

** She actually did lose the name and the bow in a shooting contest with Clint, but he decided to let her keep them after she stole the bow back.
back. Most likely because he, like Steve did when he gave Kate the name, saw himself in Kate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Where is DoctorStrange in the "Children's Crusade" mini? Is he going to make a big splashy entrance near the end, or is the point "See, we can do a big magic-oriented storyline without involving Doctor Strange"?

to:

* Where is DoctorStrange Comicbook/DoctorStrange in the "Children's Crusade" mini? Is he going to make a big splashy entrance near the end, or is the point "See, we can do a big magic-oriented storyline without involving Doctor Strange"?


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She actually lose the name and the bow in a shooting contest with Clint, but he decided to let her keep them after she stole the bow back.

to:

** She actually did lose the name and the bow in a shooting contest with Clint, but he decided to let her keep them after she stole the bow back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** She actually lose the name and the bow in a shooting contest with Clint, but he decided to let her keep them after she stole the bow back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** And Heinberg finally let them do it. [[spoiler: not till after Teddy proposed to Billy though]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Magic. Don't question it that badly.

to:

** Magic. Don't question it that badly.much.

Added: 99

Changed: 214

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**Actually is is constantly getting delayed cause Heinberg and Cheung simply aren't that great on getting it out on time.



* How are Billy and Tommy older than their pre-incarnations?

to:

** I think magic w/out Strange is most likely. But who knows.
* How are Billy and Tommy older than their pre-incarnations?pre-incarnations?
** Magic. Don't question it that badly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**Maybe The Avengers told the Juvie people that Tommy doesn't have to go back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In Hulkling's backstory he bristles at the implication that he's a skrull, and the closest thing he had to a combat application was stretching his hands out into demonic-looking claws. Considering that he didn't make effective use of his shapeshifting powers until later and "I'm like the Hulk but smaller and less dumb" sounds more heroic than "I could be a skrull, and I can make myself look really scary", it's kind of obvious why he would omit that (or not want to confirm his fears). Additionally, Wiccan was still adjusting to his powers, his reality manipution skills were in the realm of "It's something I can sorta maybe do" and his bolts were a lot like lightening. They were yellow and they set something on fire- MUCH LIKE LIGHTENING! Later, his energy bolts were drawn blue and had a different look, but he really had no way of putting a name to them other than "Lightening, kinda" until he started suspecting his connection to the Scarlet Witch.

to:

*** In Hulkling's backstory he bristles at the implication that he's a skrull, and the closest thing he had to a combat application was stretching his hands out into demonic-looking claws. Considering that he didn't make effective use of his shapeshifting powers until later and "I'm like the Hulk but smaller and less dumb" sounds more heroic than "I could be a skrull, and I can make myself look really scary", it's kind of obvious why he would omit that (or not want to confirm his fears). Additionally, Wiccan was still adjusting to his powers, his reality manipution skills were in the realm of "It's something I can sorta maybe do" and his bolts were a lot like lightening. lightning. They were yellow and they set something on fire- MUCH LIKE LIGHTENING! LIGHTNING! Later, his energy bolts were drawn blue and had a different look, but he really had no way of putting a name to them other than "Lightening, "Lightning, kinda" until he started suspecting his connection to the Scarlet Witch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** My guess: Either to stretch things out, or to avoid stepping on the toes of ''Fear Itself''.

to:

** My Semi-educated guess: Either Because this is setting up ''Avengers vs. X-Men'', and they need time to stretch things out, or to avoid stepping on the toes of ''Fear Itself''.
wrap up ''ComicBook/FearItself'' first.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Who says he is? Maybe he just prefers him big and muscular.



* Where is DoctorStrange in the "Children's Crusade" mini? Is he going to make a big splashy entrance near the end, or is the point "See, we can do a big magic-oriented storyline without involving Doctor Strange"?

to:

* Where is DoctorStrange in the "Children's Crusade" mini? Is he going to make a big splashy entrance near the end, or is the point "See, we can do a big magic-oriented storyline without involving Doctor Strange"?Strange"?
* How are Billy and Tommy older than their pre-incarnations?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I figured it was just because lightning was the only one of his powers he was confident using at that point, and he didn't want people to be on the lookout for powers that he avoided using and which might just end up blowing up in his face if he pulled them out. He was very leery of using anything else during the first few issues, though they dropped that pretty quickly.

to:

* ** I figured it was just because lightning was the only one of his powers he was confident using at that point, and he didn't want people to be on the lookout for powers that he avoided using and which might just end up blowing up in his face if he pulled them out. He was very leery of using anything else during the first few issues, though they dropped that pretty quickly.

Changed: 376

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* I figured it was just because lightning was the only one of his powers he was confident using at that point, and he didn't want people to be on the lookout for powers that he avoided using and which might just end up blowing up in his face if he pulled them out. He was very leery of using anything else during the first few issues, though they dropped that pretty quickly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** My guess: Either to stretch things out, or to avoid stepping on the toes of ''Fear Itself''.

Added: 434

Changed: 220

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is the super-uber important event where the Scarlet Witch makes a triumphant return being published every other month? Shouldn't that be a monthly thing, or is it just not as marketable as a Blackest Night rip-off?

to:


* Why is the super-uber important event where the Scarlet Witch makes a triumphant return being published every other month? Shouldn't that be a monthly thing, or is it just not as marketable as a Blackest Night rip-off?rip-off?

* Where is DoctorStrange in the "Children's Crusade" mini? Is he going to make a big splashy entrance near the end, or is the point "See, we can do a big magic-oriented storyline without involving Doctor Strange"?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing If You Know What I Mean sinkhole.


** Alternately, *Billy* might like it when Teddy is in his Hulkling form ... IfYouKnowWhatIMean.

to:

** Alternately, *Billy* might like it when Teddy is in his Hulkling form ... IfYouKnowWhatIMean.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There is nothing wrong with having two Moms. It is not even that rare in adoptive children if those feel close to their biological mothers. So we have a biological and an educative mother. That is hardly a problem for the adoptee, rather for the self-image of the mother/s.

to:

** There is nothing wrong with having two Moms. It is not even that rare in adoptive children if those feel close to their biological mothers. So we have a biological and an educative mother. That is hardly a problem for the adoptee, rather for the self-image of the mother/s.mother/s.
* Why is the super-uber important event where the Scarlet Witch makes a triumphant return being published every other month? Shouldn't that be a monthly thing, or is it just not as marketable as a Blackest Night rip-off?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Is anyone else bothered by the way Billy seems to have completely forgotten his biological family in his search for the Scarlet Witch? I can understand him wanting to find out about his past and help the woman who made his existence possible, but calling her "Mom" just seems like a slap in the face to the woman who raised him. Rebecca Kaplan is an awesome mom--remember her reaction to Billy coming out? She deserves better than this.

to:

* Is anyone else bothered by the way Billy seems to have completely forgotten his biological family in his search for the Scarlet Witch? I can understand him wanting to find out about his past and help the woman who made his existence possible, but calling her "Mom" just seems like a slap in the face to the woman who raised him. Rebecca Kaplan is an awesome mom--remember her reaction to Billy coming out? She deserves better than this.this.
** There is nothing wrong with having two Moms. It is not even that rare in adoptive children if those feel close to their biological mothers. So we have a biological and an educative mother. That is hardly a problem for the adoptee, rather for the self-image of the mother/s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** She wanted to "give it back" but Clinton told her somewhere that she may keep it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

***That's been close to proved wrong by now (and you shouldn't hide your theories, by the way. They're not spoliers. They're theories). In the latest issue, [[spoiler: Scarlet Witch comes back, almost goes insane, and calls Wiccan and Speed "my sons" and says she'll try to undo the Decimation form the end of House of M.]] Also, during the Young Masters arc, Coat of Arms was a girl who knew Speed in Ju-V. So he wasn't willed into being too recently, if he was.

Added: 534

Changed: 96

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why is Kate still using the name Hawkeye when Clint is alive and now currently using the name.

to:


* Why is Kate still using the name Hawkeye when Clint is alive and now currently using the name.name?

* Is anyone else bothered by the way Billy seems to have completely forgotten his biological family in his search for the Scarlet Witch? I can understand him wanting to find out about his past and help the woman who made his existence possible, but calling her "Mom" just seems like a slap in the face to the woman who raised him. Rebecca Kaplan is an awesome mom--remember her reaction to Billy coming out? She deserves better than this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Holy crap, that makes so much sense. [[spoiler: Speed doesn't actually exist. He's never seen outside of the group, we certainly never see or hear anything about his private life. Questions like "where is he living?" or "why doesn't he have to go back to jail?" or "who are his parents?" are never even brought up. Billy unconsciously created him from nothing, and he literally doesn't exist when Billy's not actively remembering that he does.]]

to:

*** Holy crap, that makes so much sense. [[spoiler: Speed doesn't actually exist. He's never seen outside of the group, we certainly never see or hear anything about his private life. Questions like "where is he living?" or "why doesn't he have to go back to jail?" or "who are his parents?" are never even brought up. Billy unconsciously created him from nothing, and he literally doesn't exist when Billy's not actively remembering that he does.]]]]
* Why is Kate still using the name Hawkeye when Clint is alive and now currently using the name.

Top