Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / ThreeHundredRiseOfAnEmpire

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Um... where were the actual Persian loyalists? The movie implies the only political intrigue after the previous emperor’s death was between the two siblings. Were there seriously no Persians who questioned two outsider children mobilizing for war?

to:

* Um... where were the actual Persian loyalists? The movie implies the only political intrigue after the previous emperor’s death was between the two siblings. Were there seriously no Persians who questioned two outsider children mobilizing mobilising for war?



** Some people takes too literally the scene of Xerxes entering the water in a cave and coming out fully shaved and dress in gold, which is obviously a visual symbolism… I mean, he even reappears in a whole different location (a pool inside a palace), that's basic editing, but people [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory seems to think that Xerxes magically change inside the water.]] In any case, it was a third character narrating so you can scratch it as just the others imagining what the other was saying.
* Why was Scyllias sent as a spy considering he had fairly Aryan features relative to other Greeks? Surely someone with darker feature would have blended in better.
** In real life, Greeks and Persians are not that different, in fact some Greeks are of darker skin tone than some Persians, contrary to what the movie may make you think (especially the first one), however another explanation is that for that point Persians already had conquest a lot of Greek colonies especially those of Anatolia, so they already have hundreds of ethnic Greeks in their army, not to mention that a lot of ethnic Greeks are very similar to other ethnicities of the Persian Empire, and some Greek kingdoms became willingly allies or members of the Persian Empire, in real life for example Artemisia was the Queen of a Greek Kingdom allied/client state of the Persians.

to:

** Some people takes too literally the scene of Xerxes entering the water in a cave and coming out fully shaved and dress in gold, which is obviously a visual symbolism… I mean, he even reappears in a whole different location (a pool inside a palace), that's basic editing, but people [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory seems to think that Xerxes magically change changed inside the water.]] In any case, it was a third character narrating so you can scratch it as just the others imagining what the other was saying.
* Why was Scyllias sent as a spy considering he had fairly Aryan features relative to other Greeks? Surely someone with darker feature features would have blended in better.
** In real life, Greeks and Persians are not that different, in fact some Greeks are of darker skin tone than some Persians, contrary to what the movie movies may make you think (especially the first one), however one). However another explanation is that for that point Persians already had conquest over a lot of Greek colonies especially those of Anatolia, so they already have hundreds of ethnic Greeks in their army, not army. Not to mention that a lot of ethnic Greeks are very similar to other ethnicities of the Persian Empire, and some Greek kingdoms became willingly allies or members of the Persian Empire, in empire. In real life for example Artemisia was the Queen of a Greek Kingdom allied/client state of the Persians.



** Also keep in mind that Artemisa was raped many times during her childhood and early teens, she might not even know the difference, she might think all sex is always rough or having a twisted idea of sexuality.
* If Themistovles can hit things that far away in high weather, why would he stop shooting that bow ...ever?

to:

** Also keep in mind that Artemisa was raped many times during her childhood and early teens, she might not even know the difference, she might think all sex is always rough or having have a twisted idea of sexuality.
* If Themistovles Themistocles can hit things that far away in high weather, why would he stop shooting that bow ...bow... ever?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Themistovles can hit things that far away in high water, why would he stop shoot ingen that bow ...ever?

to:

* If Themistovles can hit things that far away in high water, weather, why would he stop shoot ingen shooting that bow ...ever?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also keep in mind that Artemisa was raped many times during her childhood and early teens, she might not even know the difference, she might think all sex is always rough or having a twisted idea of sexuality.

to:

** Also keep in mind that Artemisa was raped many times during her childhood and early teens, she might not even know the difference, she might think all sex is always rough or having a twisted idea of sexuality.sexuality.
* If Themistovles can hit things that far away in high water, why would he stop shoot ingen that bow ...ever?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some people takes to literally the scene of Xerxes entering the water in a cave an coming out fully shaved and dress in gold, which is obviously a visual symbolism… I mean, he even reappears in a whole different location (a pool inside a palace), that’s basic editing, but people [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory seems to think that Xerxes magically change inside the water.]] In any case, it was a third character narrating so you can scratch it as just the others imagining what the other was saying.

to:

** Some people takes to too literally the scene of Xerxes entering the water in a cave an and coming out fully shaved and dress in gold, which is obviously a visual symbolism… I mean, he even reappears in a whole different location (a pool inside a palace), that’s that's basic editing, but people [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory seems to think that Xerxes magically change inside the water.]] In any case, it was a third character narrating so you can scratch it as just the others imagining what the other was saying.

Added: 212

Changed: -8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She met with him as an intellectual equal and then laid it on heavy when he arrived. She’s also very capable at lopping heads and was surrounded by her military at the time. If at any moment she was displeased with the exchange, he’d be dead and the movie would have been shorter.

to:

** She met with him as an intellectual equal and then laid it on heavy when he arrived. She’s also very capable at lopping heads and was surrounded by her military at the time. If at any moment she was displeased with the exchange, he’d be dead and the movie would have been shorter.shorter.
** Also keep in mind that Artemisa was raped many times during her childhood and early teens, she might not even know the difference, she might think all sex is always rough or having a twisted idea of sexuality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In real life, Greeks and Persians are not that different, in fact some Greeks are of darker skin tone than some Persians, contrary to what the movie may make you think (especially the first one), however another explanation is that for that point Persians already had conquest a lot of Greek colonies especially does of Anatolia, so they already have hundreds of ethnic Greeks in their army, not to mention that a lot of ethnic Greeks are very similar to other ethnicities of the Persian Empire, and some Greek kingdoms became willingly allies or members of the Persian Empire, in real life for example Artemisia was the Queen of a Greek Kingdom allied/client state of the Persians.

to:

** In real life, Greeks and Persians are not that different, in fact some Greeks are of darker skin tone than some Persians, contrary to what the movie may make you think (especially the first one), however another explanation is that for that point Persians already had conquest a lot of Greek colonies especially does those of Anatolia, so they already have hundreds of ethnic Greeks in their army, not to mention that a lot of ethnic Greeks are very similar to other ethnicities of the Persian Empire, and some Greek kingdoms became willingly allies or members of the Persian Empire, in real life for example Artemisia was the Queen of a Greek Kingdom allied/client state of the Persians.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In real life, Greeks and Persians are not that different, in fact some Greeks are of darker skin tone than some Persians, contrary to what the movie may make you think (especially the first one), however another explanation is that for that point Persians already had conquest a lot of Greek colonies especially does of Anatolia, so they already have hundreds of ethnic Greeks in their army, not to mention that a lot of ethnic Greeks are very similar to other ethnicities of the Persian Empire, and some Greek kingdoms became willingly allies or members of the Persian Empire, in real life for example Artemisia was the Queen of a Greek Kingdom allied/client state of the Persians.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Was the sex scene between Themistocles and Artemisa supposed to be rough sex but consensual or was Themistocles raping her? Is not made clear.

to:

* Was the sex scene between Themistocles and Artemisa supposed to be rough sex but consensual or was Themistocles raping her? Is not made clear.clear.
** She met with him as an intellectual equal and then laid it on heavy when he arrived. She’s also very capable at lopping heads and was surrounded by her military at the time. If at any moment she was displeased with the exchange, he’d be dead and the movie would have been shorter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Um... where were the actual Persian loyalists? The movie implies the only political intrigue after the previous emperor’s death was between the two siblings. Were there seriously no Persians who questioned two outsider children mobilizing for war?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some people takes to literally the scene of Xerxes entering the water in a cave an coming out fully shaved and dress in gold, which is obviously a visual symbolism… I mean, he even reappears in a whole different location (a pool inside a palace), that’s basic editing, but people [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory seems to think that Xerxes magically change inside the water.]] In any case, it was a third character narrating so you can scratch it as just the others imagining what the other was saying.



*** Maybe. When she was losing, she decided to go out fighting rather than be captured.

to:

*** Maybe. When she was losing, she decided to go out fighting rather than be captured.captured.
* Was the sex scene between Themistocles and Artemisa supposed to be rough sex but consensual or was Themistocles raping her? Is not made clear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Furthermore, why did Artemesia call him a coward when he retreated after being caught? Did she expect him to fight the whole Persian army?

to:

** Furthermore, why did Artemesia call him a coward when he retreated after being caught? Did she expect him to fight the whole Persian army?army?
*** Maybe. When she was losing, she decided to go out fighting rather than be captured.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Immunity to pain, perhaps. A massive cut through the face would make others scream. But Xerxes shrugged it off and even had his wounds stitched in an era without anaesthetic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why was Scyllias sent as a spy considering he had fairly Aryan features relative to other Greeks? Surely someone with darker feature would have blended in better.

to:

* Why was Scyllias sent as a spy considering he had fairly Aryan features relative to other Greeks? Surely someone with darker feature would have blended in better.better.
** Furthermore, why did Artemesia call him a coward when he retreated after being caught? Did she expect him to fight the whole Persian army?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The kingdom has a better perception of him as a strong ruler if he's a God-King than "the son of the guy who was killed with a lucky shot". It might have also been a personal thing: the dip into the water and his subsequent emergence as God-King may have mentally strengthened him, making him capable of ruling such a large empire.

to:

** The kingdom has a better perception of him as a strong ruler if he's a God-King than "the son of the guy who was killed with a lucky shot". It might have also been a personal thing: the dip into the water and his subsequent emergence as God-King may have mentally strengthened him, making him capable of ruling such a large empire.empire.

* Why was Scyllias sent as a spy considering he had fairly Aryan features relative to other Greeks? Surely someone with darker feature would have blended in better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So, what exactly did Xerxes ''gain'' by 'becoming a God-King' aside from becoming taller, hairless and having a deeper voice? It's not like he had some actual god-like powers after the transformation which made his invasion of Greece easier, his army was still the same.

to:

* So, what exactly did Xerxes ''gain'' by 'becoming a God-King' aside from becoming taller, hairless and having a deeper voice? It's not like he had some actual god-like powers after the transformation which made his invasion of Greece easier, his army was still the same.same.
** The kingdom has a better perception of him as a strong ruler if he's a God-King than "the son of the guy who was killed with a lucky shot". It might have also been a personal thing: the dip into the water and his subsequent emergence as God-King may have mentally strengthened him, making him capable of ruling such a large empire.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*So, what exactly did Xerxes ''gain'' by 'becoming a God-King' aside from becoming taller, hairless and having a deeper voice? It's not like he had some actual god-like powers after the transformation which made his invasion of Greece easier, his army was still the same.

Top