Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / StarTrekDeepSpaceNine

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Possibly because while they're assigned to various places, they're also expected to be able to do long-range, self-supporting trips that people wouldn't typically use a shipbound shuttlecraft for, like the trip between DS9 and Earth, or doing a bit of exploring around the Gamma Quadrant. So they're semi-independent, but since they're not actually assigned a captain and crew they don't invoke the automatic court martial.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The situation is very ''omerta''-like. He may be a victim of the FCA's tactics, Quark believes in principle in the FCA's authority and isn't going to risk crossing it for fear of further reprisals.

to:

** The situation is very ''omerta''-like. He may be a victim of the FCA's tactics, but Quark believes in principle in the FCA's authority and isn't going to risk crossing it for fear of further reprisals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder: Children of Time is pretty wacky]]

to:

[[folder: Children of Time is pretty wacky]]only works if everyone has sex at the exact same time in round 2]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It seems like they could have at least made a call and referenced it by saying "the SS ____ will be on its way in ___ days." Also it doesn't seem like it takes that long to get to Earth and it also seems like we see starfleet officers on the promenade so one or two ships of some size usually seems to be docked


Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Children of Time is pretty wacky]]
* In order for the Defiant to reproduce the same society 200 years later, they'd have to mate at the exact same points in time so that the exact right sperm and egg pairings could produce the exact right people. For all we know, knowing Kira has a lethal wound could have caused Bashir to devote more effort to her. Additionally, maybe Kira might have decided to freeze her eggs to preserve her legacy if she had advanced notice. Similarly, maybe O'Brien wouldn't have waited ten years to get with that red shirt female crewmember because he wouldn't have needed that time to give up. That would have mean she'd have different eggs when they had sex and that would have thrown everything off. As a result, the society of the future was already doomed anyway.

[[/folder]]


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Amsha is William H. Macy to Richard's Felicity Huffman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Quarantine, for one, and for another it's important to remember that DS9 is on "the frontier"... there's not always going to be a nearby ship, or at least one that can help. Most civilian ships are not going to be equipped to do so, and even most Starfleet ships might not have the necessary equipment. Unless there was a passing medical ship or Galaxy class near enough to make a difference, all calling in another ship would do is risk spreading the infection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He might have been hoping to convince her to join the Maquis. Or using her as a hostage if it became absolutely necessary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Bashir himself says his disability was fairly pronounced. He says something along the lines that when other children were learning to spell "dog" and "cat", he was still struggling with the concepts of a dog or a cat, which is something most toddlers can do. The "prime" universe's Bashir almost certainly would have been developmentally a child all his life, so there's likely some other explanation in the mirror universe. Possibly he had ancestors that were developmentally disabled, but they were augmented or fixed by the less morally-concerned Terrans (or the less morally-concerned prior generations of Bashir parents), so by the time Mirror Julian was born those genes had been removed from his family line. So no genius-level augments but also no mental disability.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Additionally to this, Starfleet has a set of Guarantees that sentient beings accused of a crime are entitled to, which very specifically includes the right not to answer a question because it could implicate you. Presumably any time that the inquest ventured away from the very specific event in question, Garak invoked this Guarantee and the court was obliged to treat that as him not implicating himself in a crime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Star Trek Online'' finally wrapped up this plot point. Bashir had apparently been working on a fix for the microbes as one of his many projects for years, and because they need to bring Opaka back, he, the player character, and Kai Kira return to the planet. Opaka has, in fact, been able to negotiate a peace so Bashir is able to "cure" the nanites without moral issue, and Opaka returns to Bajor and resumes her position, with Kira stepping down to assume a Captaincy in Starfleet. The Enis and Nol-Enis presumably return to Bajor with Opaka.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, we find out later that when the baby Changeling merges back with Odo, it's essentially able to just "reactivate" him as a Changeling himself, meaning that essentially he never stopped being one. More likely the Founders just forced him into that one form and then locked him that way without causing any actual change to the nature of his cells, which means that even if he'd stayed as physiologically a human the disease probably would have eventually started affecting him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alternatively, they just started selling disks of "The Grand Nagus" after Zek was announced to have died, but they were actually disks from some really unpopular and disliked Nagus from 300 years ago that had been sitting around gathering dust in a vault. So yes, you got a disk of a Grand Nagus, you just weren't very careful about making sure which Grand Nagus it was. That way you don't even have to pay for a clone, you just finally move some malingering product for a vastly inflated price.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Presumably Worf would still have to answer why Kurn didn't come back with him, and it would likely disgrace the honor of the ritual to lie. Remember, the whole point of the ritual is that it's an honorable thing... treating it like something to hide or be done in secret would erase the honor.


Added DiffLines:

** Presumably the Mauk-to'Vor is more a matter of personal honor, and would carry significance for Worf and Kurn whether or not the rest of Klingon society acknowledged it. After all the ritual isn't about making the Council forgive them, it's about Kurn wanting to be able to go to Sto-vo-Kor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Emphasis on training for war... they're not meant to be participating directly in the war as cadets. That episode is ''really'' contrived.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The situation is very ''omerta''-like. He may be a victim of the FCA's tactics, Quark believes in principle in the FCA's authority and isn't going to risk crossing it for fear of further reprisals.

Added: 108

Changed: 289

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Recall that we actually see him killed and he does not seem to be anticipating it. It plays like murder.




to:

** Jake can piece together that's a foolhardy, borderline suicidal attack plan, and he knows his father's character even if he doesn't understand all the nuances of the situation. Additionally, raising his father is a tactic to try to get Red Squad to back down (failed, as it turns out).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Considering that Bashir specifically mentions that organic explosives can be made with bio-mimetic gel, it seems likely the idea is that Garak used it to make the bomb (poor Tolar... both murdered and stiffed!).


Added DiffLines:

** Well, he does help them to a degree in "The Way of the Warrior" and later, in "Apocalypse Rising." His humbling after "Indiscretion" is a major factor in making him seem more trustworthy (emphasis on "seem").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The bio-mimetic gel was payment for the alien who programmed the data rod. And Garak implies to Sisko that he killed that alien in addition to the Romulans. Sisko asks "And what about Tolar? Did you kill him too?" And Garak replies, "Think of them both as tragic victims of war." So presumably Garak gave back the bio-mimetic gel, or kept it, or used it in the explosive after taking it from Tolar post-murder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Presumably, they're paying the government of Bajor, which actually owns the station, and provides the majority of personnel for the station's maintenance crew. Starfleet's just there to manage them. There's no reason to think that Bajor's running a charity. That captain is probably paying some manner of port fees and taxes, too.

Added: 1068

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



[[folder: Why is the crew expected to make ship repairs for ships docking]]
* In "Babel" a captain of a freighter is impatient with O'Brien for not repairing his ship soon enough. This is where the show's not-well-thought-out view of capitalism comes in but I digress. Starfleet is an organization that doesn't deal with money as far as I know. So it's the equivalent of a non-profit or a hybrid military government who has volunteered to run a space station. Expecting them to repair your ship faster or anything along those lines is like expecting Habitat for Humanity not just to give you a home but to repair the plumbing inside.
[[/folder]]



** That actually raises more questions of whether Ibudan should have been arrested for murdering a clone if he wasn't a full life. I think the crime was more trying to frame Odo



[[folder: Jake's knowledge of ship logistics]]

to:

[[folder: Jake's knowledge of ship logistics]]logistics in Valiant]]









Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Babel question]]
*If the whole crew was being infected and their crew compliment was going to keep diminishing until everyone was deadly sick, why not call for backup from the nearest ship nearby. To me, that was beyond stupid
[[/folder]]

Added: 271

Changed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS04E16BarAssociation, Quark's employees form a union and Brunt comes in to set things back to the traditional Ferengi way. During this, he and two Nausicaan thugs have Quark beaten up and sent to the hospital. DS9 is not under Ferengi jurisdiction, it's under Federation or Bajoran. Why would they tolerate this, as opposed to throwing Brunt in jail where he belongs?[[/folder]]

to:

* In Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS04E16BarAssociation, Quark's employees form a union and Brunt comes in to set things back to the traditional Ferengi way. During this, he and two Nausicaan thugs have Quark beaten up and sent to the hospital. DS9 is not under Ferengi jurisdiction, it's under Federation or Bajoran. Why would they tolerate this, as opposed to throwing Brunt in jail where he belongs?[[/folder]]
belongs?
* It's all there in the episode:
* ROM: Odo has him and the Nausicaans in a holding cell. He says it's an open and shut case.
* QUARK: It's an open and shut case all right, but I'm not going to press charges.
* ROM: You're not?
* QUARK: Of course not. I'm in enough trouble with the FCA as it is.

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS04E16BarAssociation, Quark's employees form a union and Brunt comes in to set things back to the traditional Ferengi way. During this, he and two Nausicaan thugs have Quark beaten up and sent to the hospital. DS9 is not under Ferengi jurisdiction, it's under Federation or Bajoran. Why would they tolerate this, as opposed to throwing Brunt in jail where he belongs?

to:

* In Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS04E16BarAssociation, Quark's employees form a union and Brunt comes in to set things back to the traditional Ferengi way. During this, he and two Nausicaan thugs have Quark beaten up and sent to the hospital. DS9 is not under Ferengi jurisdiction, it's under Federation or Bajoran. Why would they tolerate this, as opposed to throwing Brunt in jail where he belongs?
belongs?[[/folder]]

Added: 399

Changed: 48

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[folder:So Brunt just walks away for assault?]]
* In Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS04E16BarAssociation, Quark's employees form a union and Brunt comes in to set things back to the traditional Ferengi way. During this, he and two Nausicaan thugs have Quark beaten up and sent to the hospital. DS9 is not under Ferengi jurisdiction, it's under Federation or Bajoran. Why would they tolerate this, as opposed to throwing Brunt in jail where he belongs?

Added: 1484

Changed: 1824

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder: Didn't the Klingons Already Solve That Problem?]]
* In "Call to Arms" O'Brien, Dax, and Rom are discussing the apparently insurmountable task of designing an undetectable anti-spacecraft mine to keep the Dominion from crossing into the Alpha Quadrant. So, whatever happened to that cloaking Klingon mine from "The Sons of Mogh" that was undetectable by "any known sensor array," and could cripple a cruiser ten kilometers away? The Klingons were right there on the station, and this was sort of an emergency, surely the Klingons would have been willing to share the design. They seemed a bit prone to accidents, but the invasion was sort of already sort of in-progress at that point, so it probably would have been worth the risk. Fabricating an existing design probably also would have been easier than designing and building a completely new device from scratch. That's especially true because [=DS9=]'s design had to swarm detonate--20 or 30 per ship, according to Chief O'Brien--so there wouldn't have to be nearly as many of the Klingon model, and they wouldn't have had to worry about making them self-replicating. They could be deployed by cloaked ships, so there was a chance that the Dominion wouldn't have even noticed they were laying a minefield until it was already in place, giving Starfleet a few extra days or weeks to ready itself for war, and maybe even giving Starfleet Command enough time find a couple of extra ships to reinforce the station.

to:

[[folder: Didn't the Klingons Already Solve That Problem?]]
How did Jake have knowledge of his dad's thoughts on Jem Hadar technology?]]
* In "Call "Valiant", the kid Captain devised a plan to Arms" O'Brien, Dax, modify the photon torpedos and Rom are discussing disarm a Jem Hadar cruiser from 300 meters away. Jake happens to be at the apparently insurmountable task group meeting and says "no way, this won't work, my dad would never do something like this." The Captain seems to be speaking fluent technobabble to an audience of designing an undetectable anti-spacecraft mine starfleet officers who have been trained to keep understand it and have been up against Jem Hadar ships. While Jake has lived at the crossroads of the Dominion from crossing into the Alpha Quadrant. So, whatever happened to that cloaking Klingon mine from "The Sons of Mogh" that was undetectable by "any known sensor array," and could cripple a cruiser ten kilometers away? The Klingons were right there War, I don't recall him being present on the station, Defiant or at Ops or sitting in on his dad's strategic briefings at take your son to work day. He's only a recent graduate of Keiko O'Brien's 24th century equivalent of a GED program, I surmise and this was sort of an emergency, surely the Klingons would have been willing to share the design. They seemed is mostly a bit prone to accidents, but the invasion was sort of already sort of in-progress at that point, so it probably would have been worth the risk. Fabricating an existing design probably also would have been easier than designing and building a completely new device from scratch. That's especially true because [=DS9=]'s design had to swarm detonate--20 or 30 per ship, according to Chief O'Brien--so there wouldn't have to be nearly as many of the Klingon model, and they wouldn't have had to worry about making them self-replicating. They could be deployed by cloaked ships, so there was a chance that the Dominion wouldn't have even noticed they were laying a minefield until it was already in place, giving Starfleet a few extra days or weeks to ready itself for war, and maybe even giving Starfleet Command enough time find a couple of extra ships to reinforce the station. full-time writer.


Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Didn't the Klingons Already Solve That Problem?]]
* In "Call to Arms" O'Brien, Dax, and Rom are discussing the apparently insurmountable task of designing an undetectable anti-spacecraft mine to keep the Dominion from crossing into the Alpha Quadrant. So, whatever happened to that cloaking Klingon mine from "The Sons of Mogh" that was undetectable by "any known sensor array," and could cripple a cruiser ten kilometers away? The Klingons were right there on the station, and this was sort of an emergency, surely the Klingons would have been willing to share the design. They seemed a bit prone to accidents, but the invasion was sort of already sort of in-progress at that point, so it probably would have been worth the risk. Fabricating an existing design probably also would have been easier than designing and building a completely new device from scratch. That's especially true because [=DS9=]'s design had to swarm detonate--20 or 30 per ship, according to Chief O'Brien--so there wouldn't have to be nearly as many of the Klingon model, and they wouldn't have had to worry about making them self-replicating. They could be deployed by cloaked ships, so there was a chance that the Dominion wouldn't have even noticed they were laying a minefield until it was already in place, giving Starfleet a few extra days or weeks to ready itself for war, and maybe even giving Starfleet Command enough time find a couple of extra ships to reinforce the station.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder: Jake's knowledge of ship logistics]]
*In "Valiant", the captain asks Nog about some technobabble involving attacking a Jem Hadar ship. Jake knows that his father would never try such a thing. How would Jake know? His interest in ship ops has always been limited


[[/folder]]

Added: 165

Changed: 48

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[folder: Take Me Out to the Holosuite tryouts]]
* They had tryouts and Quark was invited onto the team but the other staff members weren't allowed? Would it have been that hard to throw in a few extras?
[[/folder]]


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I dispute the premise that we're supposed to be okay with genocide against the Founders. It's done by a villainous organization. Our characters act to prevent it. In the end, the implication is that Odo, given his different upbringing, will help guide the Founders to a more peaceful outlook... so they do explicitly get that chance at redemption you are saying is denied. And Laas is a jerk but a complex character since we understand his backstory, and his motivation is largely to be left alone. I don't see a shred of evidence that we are supposed to be even partially okay with the concept of committing genocide against them.

to:

** I dispute the premise that we're supposed to be okay with genocide against the Founders. It's done by a villainous organization. Our characters act to prevent it. In the end, the implication is that Odo, given his different upbringing, will help guide the Founders to a more peaceful outlook... so they do explicitly get that chance at redemption you are saying is denied.denied; we have already seen it happen in microcosm with the female Founder, who agrees to surrender after linking with Odo. And Laas is a jerk but a complex character since we understand his backstory, and his motivation is largely to be left alone. I don't see a shred of evidence that we are supposed to be even partially okay with the concept of committing genocide against them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The way it's ''supposed'' to work is that the computer crosschecks the authorization codes with the user's biometrics. We have seen that happen explicitly a handful of times across the franchise: Kirk needed a retina scan to access data on Project Genesis; Picard and Riker, and Sisko and Kira used handprints to set the autodestruct on ''Enterprise'' and ''Defiant'', respectively; breath print identification was seen being used aboard ''Discovery''--a method that was shown to be ridiculously and predictably easy to defeat. Computer security runs almost entirely on RuleOfDrama in the ''Trek'' universe, though, and so biometric authentication is utterly nonexistent when the script needs it to be. While the writers ''are'' a little more consistent with the computer needing at least voiceprint authentication, they're even willing to forget about it whenever it's convenient: Nog ran amok with O'Brien's access code in "[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS07E06TreacheryFaithAndTheGreatRiver Treachery, Faith, and the Great River]]" and Neelix used an engineering access code he'd overheard with impunity in "[[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS2E20Investigations Invesgtigations]]", which, just... ''[[SwissCheeseSecurity uhg]]''. And, as you said, voiceprint isn't exactly secure on it's own--Data [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS4E3Brothers once]] hijacked the ''Enterprise'' with what was essentially a playback attack.

to:

** The way it's ''supposed'' to work is that the computer crosschecks the authorization codes with the user's biometrics. We have seen that happen explicitly a handful of times across the franchise: Kirk needed a retina scan to access data on Project Genesis; Picard and Riker, and Sisko and Kira used handprints to set the autodestruct on ''Enterprise'' and ''Defiant'', respectively; breath print identification was seen being used aboard ''Discovery''--a method that was shown to be ridiculously and predictably easy to defeat. Computer security runs almost entirely on RuleOfDrama in the ''Trek'' universe, though, and so biometric authentication is utterly nonexistent when the script needs it to be. While the writers ''are'' a little more consistent with the computer needing at least voiceprint authentication, they're even very willing to forget about it whenever it's convenient: Nog ran amok with O'Brien's access code in "[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS07E06TreacheryFaithAndTheGreatRiver Treachery, Faith, and the Great River]]" and Neelix used an engineering access code he'd overheard with impunity in "[[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS2E20Investigations Invesgtigations]]", which, just... ''[[SwissCheeseSecurity uhg]]''.ugh]]''. And, as you said, voiceprint isn't exactly secure on it's own--Data [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS4E3Brothers once]] hijacked the ''Enterprise'' with what was essentially a playback attack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do they give their passwords away when they do their command authorization codes. It wasn't even that hard in the 20th century to impersonate someone else's voice

to:

* Why do they give their passwords away when they do their command authorization codes. codes? It wasn't even that hard in the 20th century to impersonate someone else's voicevoice.
** The way it's ''supposed'' to work is that the computer crosschecks the authorization codes with the user's biometrics. We have seen that happen explicitly a handful of times across the franchise: Kirk needed a retina scan to access data on Project Genesis; Picard and Riker, and Sisko and Kira used handprints to set the autodestruct on ''Enterprise'' and ''Defiant'', respectively; breath print identification was seen being used aboard ''Discovery''--a method that was shown to be ridiculously and predictably easy to defeat. Computer security runs almost entirely on RuleOfDrama in the ''Trek'' universe, though, and so biometric authentication is utterly nonexistent when the script needs it to be. While the writers ''are'' a little more consistent with the computer needing at least voiceprint authentication, they're even willing to forget about it whenever it's convenient: Nog ran amok with O'Brien's access code in "[[Recap/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineS07E06TreacheryFaithAndTheGreatRiver Treachery, Faith, and the Great River]]" and Neelix used an engineering access code he'd overheard with impunity in "[[Recap/StarTrekVoyagerS2E20Investigations Invesgtigations]]", which, just... ''[[SwissCheeseSecurity uhg]]''. And, as you said, voiceprint isn't exactly secure on it's own--Data [[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS4E3Brothers once]] hijacked the ''Enterprise'' with what was essentially a playback attack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder: Why do they say their passwords out loud rather than type them in?]]
* Why do they give their passwords away when they do their command authorization codes. It wasn't even that hard in the 20th century to impersonate someone else's voice
[[/folder]]


Added DiffLines:

** I'm assuming that leading the Bajoran people post-occupation and the sequences in "Rapture" where he told them they shouldn't join the federation yet were also important.


Added DiffLines:

** Bashir wasn't necessarily noticeably disabled. He was diagnosed at a young age so that diagnosis might not have meant he would have grown up to be visibly disabled. My older sister, for example, didn't excel academically at a young age but she ended up an Echol's Scholar, a Fulbright Scholar and is now the youngest dean in her college's history at age 38. Simultaneously, Bashir might have had overly cautious parents.


Added DiffLines:

[[folder: In "Defiant" why did Riker keep Kira on the ship?]]
* He stunned her. Why not beam her back to the station, or continue to stun her with the gun?
[[/folder]]


Added DiffLines:

[[folder: Civil Defense]]
* Didn't Dukat lose all his credibility when he was called upon to rescue the situation and used it to hold Kira hostage? Why did they trust him again up until Season 5 when he joined the Dominion?


[[/folder]]

Top