Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / SnowWhiteAndTheSevenDwarfs

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Since the Queen has Dark Magics, couldn't she have made a Spell that would find her and then either put her to sleep or kill her like [[SleepingBeauty Maleficent]]? Why did she need the disguise and the apple? She could've just made an incantation that would just do what the Apple did, or worse. It's not like she wants to specifically kill her, she just wants Snow White gone, so I doubt it was an ego boosting "only I can kill her" thing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* What was the Queen's reason for giving Snow White a nice dress and sending her out to pick flowers in a peaceful meadow before she died? When viewed a certain way, it might seem like she wanted her stepdaughter to be happy in the final moments before her death, but this seems out-of-character when you consider that the Queen is the one who ''wanted'' her dead, for the horrible crime of happening to be prettier than her. Why not just have the Huntsman take her out into the woods in her begraddled servant's clothes and kill her quickly?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's possible that she did, but it's been suggested that Snow White's beauty both inside and out is what made her fairer than the Queen. Also, it's part of her irrational hatred. Her thought process when she finds out someone's beauty has surpassed hers is not "I'd better try and make myself more beautiful than her," but rather "How ''dare'' she manage to be more beautiful than me?!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I don't know, but I'm against 'em.

to:

** I don't know, but I'm against 'em. ag'in 'em!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I don't know, but I'm against 'em.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Due to the fact that the Queen dwelling in Dark Magic was known well among people(as said by Grumpy), the Huntsman probably thought that the longer time he took for the assassination the odds that the Queen find out about him letting Snow White escaped is higher so it's the best to let her ran away by herself. Escorting her to townspeople or alike probably wouldn't work, as the Queen could have declared her fugitive and had Snow White arrested/executed.

to:

** Due to the fact that the Queen dwelling in Dark Magic was known well among people(as people (as said by Grumpy), the Huntsman probably thought that the longer time he took for the assassination the odds that the Queen find out about him letting Snow White escaped is higher so it's the best to let her ran away by herself. Escorting her to townspeople or alike probably wouldn't work, as the Queen could have declared her fugitive and had Snow White arrested/executed.


Added DiffLines:

* If the Queen could turn herself into a hideous old hag, then why didn't she just make herself more beautiful than Snow White?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Not nessecarily - the book only referred to "Love's first kiss," with no say as to which part of it was most important. Plus, if the emphasis was on "first kiss", then why would the queen want to kiss her anyway? Since love wouldn't have been a requirement, that means it would've woken her up again!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ...What are wicked wiles?

Added: 68

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Not quite sure exactly what you're asking, but the antitode was specifically listed as "Love's first kiss," and it's pretty clear that the queen had no love for Snow White. So even if she tried, her kiss wouldn't have stopped the Prince's kiss from working, if that's what you're suggesting.

to:

** Not quite sure exactly what you're asking, but the antitode antidote was specifically listed as "Love's first kiss," and it's pretty clear that the queen had no love for Snow White. So even if she tried, her kiss wouldn't have stopped the Prince's kiss from working, if that's what you're suggesting.suggesting.
*** It's more the emphasis on the ''first kiss'' than anything else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given the Queen's obsession with beauty, how could she bear to transform herself into such a hideous old hag? Other disguises would certainly have been possible and no such extreme transformation occcurs in the original story. A related question - was the spell to make her look like that meant to be temporary or would she have had to take some kind of antidote to restore her original form had she succeeded in coming back?

to:

* Given the Queen's obsession with beauty, how could she bear to transform herself into such a hideous old hag? Other disguises would certainly have been possible and no such extreme transformation occcurs occurs in the original story. A related question - was the spell to make her look like that meant to be temporary or would she have had to take some kind of antidote to restore her original form had she succeeded in coming back?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not quite sure exactly what you're asking, but the antitode was specifically listed as "Love's first kiss," and it's pretty clear that the queen had no love for Snow White. So even if she tried, her kiss wouldn't have stopped the Prince's kiss from working, if that's what you're suggesting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* So ThePowerOfLove that breaks the spell is a SacredFirstKiss. That begs the obvious question of why the Queen didn't just kiss Snow White after she "died".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----



** To the first question, that's the point. It's intentionally ironic that, over the course of her villainous breakdown, the queen becomes so obsessed with killing Snow White over her beauty that she comes to shed every ounce of her own beauty, in return. (For example, note the scene where Snow White eats the apple - after watching her keel over, the queen proudly proclaims, "Now '''''I'll''''' be fairest in the land!", all while under the guise of a hideous old hag.) For the second question, I think she would've had to have whipped up some sort of antidote - I remember hearing about some sort of outside material where the queen survived the fall she took at the end of the film. She tries returning to the castle, but finds that she can't get inside to change herself back because the guards don't recognize her.

to:

** To the first question, that's the point. It's intentionally ironic that, over the course of her villainous breakdown, the queen becomes so obsessed with killing Snow White over her beauty that she comes to shed every ounce of her own beauty, in return. (For example, note the scene where Snow White eats the apple - after watching her keel over, the queen proudly proclaims, "Now '''''I'll''''' be fairest in the land!", all while under the guise of a hideous old hag.) For the second question, I think she would've had to have whipped up some sort of antidote - I remember hearing about some sort of outside material where the queen survived the fall she took at the end of the film. She tries returning to the castle, but finds that she can't get inside to change herself back because the guards don't recognize her.her.

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given the Queen's obsession with beauty, how could she bear to transform herself into such a hideous old hag? Other disguises would certainly have been possible and no such extreme transformation occcurs in the original story. A related question - was the spell to make her look like that meant to be temporary or would she have had to take some kind of antidote to restore her original form had she succeeded in coming back?

to:

* Given the Queen's obsession with beauty, how could she bear to transform herself into such a hideous old hag? Other disguises would certainly have been possible and no such extreme transformation occcurs in the original story. A related question - was the spell to make her look like that meant to be temporary or would she have had to take some kind of antidote to restore her original form had she succeeded in coming back?back?
** To the first question, that's the point. It's intentionally ironic that, over the course of her villainous breakdown, the queen becomes so obsessed with killing Snow White over her beauty that she comes to shed every ounce of her own beauty, in return. (For example, note the scene where Snow White eats the apple - after watching her keel over, the queen proudly proclaims, "Now '''''I'll''''' be fairest in the land!", all while under the guise of a hideous old hag.) For the second question, I think she would've had to have whipped up some sort of antidote - I remember hearing about some sort of outside material where the queen survived the fall she took at the end of the film. She tries returning to the castle, but finds that she can't get inside to change herself back because the guards don't recognize her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given the Queen's obsession with beauty, how could she bear to transform herself into such a hideous old hag? Other disguises would certainly have been possible and no such extreme transformation occcurs in the original story. Also, what would have been the antidote to restore her original form had she succeeded in coming back?

to:

* Given the Queen's obsession with beauty, how could she bear to transform herself into such a hideous old hag? Other disguises would certainly have been possible and no such extreme transformation occcurs in the original story. Also, what A related question - was the spell to make her look like that meant to be temporary or would she have been the had to take some kind of antidote to restore her original form had she succeeded in coming back?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added two questions.


** The Queen wanted to prepare a fitting end for Snow White, as she saw her as a rival for her beauty. Strangling her doesn't work because, as a frail, old woman, the queen wouldn't be able to get the jump on Snow White without her running away or screaming, wouldn't be able to match pace with her if she escapes, and if the dwarves get so much as a hint that Snow White is in trouble, they'll come riding back to save her, as is shown moments later. Finally, she may have chosen the sleeping death due to its lack of any real antitodes - it's likely the dwarves would've tried searching for any cure they could find if they'd known it was a poison, so the sleeping death was the queen's best way of ensuring that Snow White would die for good (or at least be buried alive).

to:

** The Queen wanted to prepare a fitting end for Snow White, as she saw her as a rival for her beauty. Strangling her doesn't work because, as a frail, old woman, the queen wouldn't be able to get the jump on Snow White without her running away or screaming, wouldn't be able to match pace with her if she escapes, and if the dwarves get so much as a hint that Snow White is in trouble, they'll come riding back to save her, as is shown moments later. Finally, she may have chosen the sleeping death due to its lack of any real antitodes - it's likely the dwarves would've tried searching for any cure they could find if they'd known it was a poison, so the sleeping death was the queen's best way of ensuring that Snow White would die for good (or at least be buried alive).alive).
* Given the Queen's obsession with beauty, how could she bear to transform herself into such a hideous old hag? Other disguises would certainly have been possible and no such extreme transformation occcurs in the original story. Also, what would have been the antidote to restore her original form had she succeeded in coming back?

Added: 460

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why doesn't the Huntsman try going with Snow White to find a place for her to take shelter? It doesn't make much sense that his means of protecting her from the queen is to watch her go running blindly into a dark forest, especially since she's only, what, 14 years old? He could've helped her through the woods to the dwarves' cottage or someplace else, perhaps, sparing her all the nightmarish imagery along the way.

to:

* Why doesn't the Huntsman try going with Snow White to find a place for her to take shelter? It doesn't make much sense that his means of protecting her from the queen is to watch her go running blindly into a dark forest, especially since she's only, what, 14 years old? He could've helped her through the woods to the dwarves' cottage or someplace some place else, perhaps, sparing her all the nightmarish imagery along the way.way.
** Due to the fact that the Queen dwelling in Dark Magic was known well among people(as said by Grumpy), the Huntsman probably thought that the longer time he took for the assassination the odds that the Queen find out about him letting Snow White escaped is higher so it's the best to let her ran away by herself. Escorting her to townspeople or alike probably wouldn't work, as the Queen could have declared her fugitive and had Snow White arrested/executed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why exactly does the queen use this complicated "sleeping death" potion, when she could just use regular poison for the same purpose ? Besides, in real-life the main interest of poisoning rather than murdering more "actively" is that the murder can be set hours prior to the victim's death itself, which reduces chances of being suspected for the murderer, since the poison can very well act while the person is among a crowd. But if giving the poison to Snow White already required the Queen and the princess to be alone together, she could just have strangled or stabbed her. (Alright, stabbing would have been storywise dumb, because we already saw a stabbing earlier and we don't want to see that twice, but my point still stands).

to:

* Why exactly does the queen use this complicated "sleeping death" potion, when she could just use regular poison for the same purpose ? Besides, in real-life the main interest of poisoning rather than murdering more "actively" is that the murder can be set hours prior to the victim's death itself, which reduces chances of being suspected for the murderer, since the poison can very well act while the person is among a crowd. But if giving the poison to Snow White already required the Queen and the princess to be alone together, she could just have strangled or stabbed her. (Alright, stabbing would have been storywise dumb, because we already saw a stabbing earlier and we don't want to see that twice, but my point still stands).stands).
** The Queen wanted to prepare a fitting end for Snow White, as she saw her as a rival for her beauty. Strangling her doesn't work because, as a frail, old woman, the queen wouldn't be able to get the jump on Snow White without her running away or screaming, wouldn't be able to match pace with her if she escapes, and if the dwarves get so much as a hint that Snow White is in trouble, they'll come riding back to save her, as is shown moments later. Finally, she may have chosen the sleeping death due to its lack of any real antitodes - it's likely the dwarves would've tried searching for any cure they could find if they'd known it was a poison, so the sleeping death was the queen's best way of ensuring that Snow White would die for good (or at least be buried alive).

Added: 737

Changed: -8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They found out that animating a realistic character was tricky, because a character who looks like a real person but behaves like if he was made of rubber is at best weird and at worst ''creepy''. They could not animate him freely, they had to respect a very strict code. A male moves a very different way from a female. For Snow White and the Queen, the animators got trained at animating charming woman characters, because it was worth it — what was the point of making a princess movie if you can't animate a princess ? But spending the same amount of time and money for a secondary character was impossible, unless they wanted ''Snow White'' to suffer the same fate as ''The Thief and the Cobbler''…

to:

** They found out that animating a realistic character was tricky, because a character who looks like a real person but behaves like if he was made of rubber is at best weird and at worst ''creepy''. They could not animate him freely, they had to respect a very strict code. A male moves a very different way from a female. For Snow White and the Queen, the animators got trained at animating charming woman characters, because it was worth it — what was the point of making a princess movie if you can't animate a princess ? But spending the same amount of time and money for a secondary character was impossible, unless they wanted ''Snow White'' to suffer the same fate as ''The Thief and the Cobbler''…Cobbler''…
* Why exactly does the queen use this complicated "sleeping death" potion, when she could just use regular poison for the same purpose ? Besides, in real-life the main interest of poisoning rather than murdering more "actively" is that the murder can be set hours prior to the victim's death itself, which reduces chances of being suspected for the murderer, since the poison can very well act while the person is among a crowd. But if giving the poison to Snow White already required the Queen and the princess to be alone together, she could just have strangled or stabbed her. (Alright, stabbing would have been storywise dumb, because we already saw a stabbing earlier and we don't want to see that twice, but my point still stands).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What was it about the Prince that made him so much harder to animate the other characters? Yes, I can see the difference in design between him and the 7 dwarves, but how does that make him harder to animate? Especially since the two characters he resembles more, Snow White and her stepmother, both seem to get ample screen time.

to:

* What was it about the Prince that made him so much harder to animate the other characters? Yes, I can see the difference in design between him and the 7 dwarves, but how does that make him harder to animate? Especially since the two characters he resembles more, Snow White and her stepmother, both seem to get ample screen time.time.
** They found out that animating a realistic character was tricky, because a character who looks like a real person but behaves like if he was made of rubber is at best weird and at worst ''creepy''. They could not animate him freely, they had to respect a very strict code. A male moves a very different way from a female. For Snow White and the Queen, the animators got trained at animating charming woman characters, because it was worth it — what was the point of making a princess movie if you can't animate a princess ? But spending the same amount of time and money for a secondary character was impossible, unless they wanted ''Snow White'' to suffer the same fate as ''The Thief and the Cobbler''…
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That's part of the dwarf's childlike behavior. They aren't really adults, just pretending to be adults; they play being adults, so since adults have a lock they play having a lock. But getting the key with them ? What's the use ? Wouldn't it be handier for the game if the key's next to the place where they will use it ?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do the dwarves lock the door to their mines, only to leave the key hanging right next to it? What's the point of having a lock, then?
* Why doesn't the Huntsman try going with Snow White to find a place for her to take shelter? It doesn't make much sense that his means of protecting her from the queen is to watch her go running blindly into a dark forest, especially since she's only, what, 14 years old?

to:

* Why do the dwarves lock the door to their mines, vault, only to leave the key hanging right next to it? What's the point of having a lock, then?
* Why doesn't the Huntsman try going with Snow White to find a place for her to take shelter? It doesn't make much sense that his means of protecting her from the queen is to watch her go running blindly into a dark forest, especially since she's only, what, 14 years old?old? He could've helped her through the woods to the dwarves' cottage or someplace else, perhaps, sparing her all the nightmarish imagery along the way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do the dwarves lock the door to their mines, only to leave the key hanging right next to it? What's the point of having a lock, then?

to:

* Why do the dwarves lock the door to their mines, only to leave the key hanging right next to it? What's the point of having a lock, then?then?
* Why doesn't the Huntsman try going with Snow White to find a place for her to take shelter? It doesn't make much sense that his means of protecting her from the queen is to watch her go running blindly into a dark forest, especially since she's only, what, 14 years old?
* What was it about the Prince that made him so much harder to animate the other characters? Yes, I can see the difference in design between him and the 7 dwarves, but how does that make him harder to animate? Especially since the two characters he resembles more, Snow White and her stepmother, both seem to get ample screen time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the comic book adaptation, it's said he arrived because he heard of Snow White's beauty. Could he be looking for a wife not unlike the Princes who visit Agrabah in ''Disney/{{Aladdin}}'' aside from not being a jerkass?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What is the Prince in this film the prince of? It can't be Snow White's kingdom, because that'd just be weird. And it wouldn't make sense for him to visiting from another kingdom, would it, with how evil and wicked the Queen is? What was he even doing at the castle?

to:

* What is the Prince in this film the prince of? It can't be Snow White's kingdom, because that'd just be weird. And it wouldn't make sense for him to visiting from another kingdom, would it, with how evil and wicked the Queen is? What was he even doing at the castle?castle?
* Why do the dwarves lock the door to their mines, only to leave the key hanging right next to it? What's the point of having a lock, then?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Actually, no matter what time period people had a pretty good understanding of decomposition; anyone around a dead body would understand rotting within days. The ancient Egyptians actually tried to stop it, hence mummies. The situation with Snow White seems to be more along the lines of the dwarfs not really noticing due to grief or just thinking Snow White was special for some reason (lack of decay but no actual signs of life probably convinced them she was dead). They may have even thought magic was involved thanks to the queen and simply not questioned how it worked. Come to think of it, the whole glass coffin thing might have been in part due to a very slight doubt that she was actually dead along with the film's stated reason (not having the heart to bury her).

to:

*** Actually, no matter what time period people had a pretty good understanding of decomposition; anyone around a dead body would understand rotting within days. The ancient Egyptians actually tried to stop it, hence mummies. The situation with Snow White seems to be more along the lines of the dwarfs not really noticing due to grief or just thinking Snow White was special for some reason (lack of decay but no actual signs of life probably convinced them she was dead). They may have even thought magic was involved thanks to the queen and simply not questioned how it worked. Come to think of it, the whole glass coffin thing might have been in part due to a very slight doubt that she was actually dead along with the film's stated reason (not having the heart to bury her).her).
* What is the Prince in this film the prince of? It can't be Snow White's kingdom, because that'd just be weird. And it wouldn't make sense for him to visiting from another kingdom, would it, with how evil and wicked the Queen is? What was he even doing at the castle?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** People weren't as educated about decomposition back then.

to:

** People weren't as educated about decomposition back then.then.
*** Actually, no matter what time period people had a pretty good understanding of decomposition; anyone around a dead body would understand rotting within days. The ancient Egyptians actually tried to stop it, hence mummies. The situation with Snow White seems to be more along the lines of the dwarfs not really noticing due to grief or just thinking Snow White was special for some reason (lack of decay but no actual signs of life probably convinced them she was dead). They may have even thought magic was involved thanks to the queen and simply not questioned how it worked. Come to think of it, the whole glass coffin thing might have been in part due to a very slight doubt that she was actually dead along with the film's stated reason (not having the heart to bury her).

Added: 59

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If the 7 Dwarfs didn't bury Snow White for months when she was believed to be death then how did they not suspect she was actually alive since her body was still fresh after such long time?

to:

* If the 7 Dwarfs didn't bury Snow White for months when she was believed to be death dead, then how did they not suspect she was actually alive since her body was still fresh after such long time?time?
**People weren't as educated about decomposition back then.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* If the 7 Dwarfs didn't bury Snow White for months when she was believed to be death then how did they not suspect she was actually alive since her body was still fresh after such long time?

Top