History Headscratchers / ShugoChara

4th Aug '16 2:35:54 PM valar55
Is there an issue? Send a Message


----
<<|Headscratchers|>>

to:

----
<<|Headscratchers|>>
----
4th Aug '16 2:34:42 PM valar55
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* What did the Guardians do to the X-Eggs before Amu appeared? She is the only one able to use the "Open Heart" ability. Were they breaking the eggs... [[{{Hypocrite}} even tough they gave all that talk about "breaking people's eggs is destroying their dreams]] [[ThisIsUnforgivable and this is wrong"?]]
** It's fine. The Manga says that they capture and "contain" the X eggs, rather than break them. From this, it's probably good to assume that they, from the form and themes of that X character, decided to look around the town for people with Dreams that fit, and, there - fore, convince them to not give up on said Dream. or, alternately, used the Humpty - Lock to purify it.

to:

* What did the Guardians do to the X-Eggs before Amu appeared? She is the only one able to use the "Open Heart" ability. Were they breaking the eggs... [[{{Hypocrite}} even tough though they gave all that talk about "breaking people's eggs is destroying their dreams]] [[ThisIsUnforgivable and this is wrong"?]]
** It's fine. The Manga says that they capture and "contain" the X eggs, rather than break them. From this, it's probably good to assume that they, from the form and themes of that X character, decided to look around the town for people with Dreams that fit, and, there - fore, therefore, convince them to not give up on said Dream. Dream, or, alternately, used the Humpty - Lock to purify it.
4th Aug '16 10:01:11 AM valar55
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Amu's charas. I see how she would be physically stronger, having more than one, but it's also implied it's supposed to make her stronger in non-physical ways. Just how the indecision that gives birth to so many potentially conflicting 'future selves' lead to greater strength? Am I missing some point here?

to:

* Amu's charas. I see how she would be physically stronger, having more than one, but it's also implied it's supposed to make her stronger in non-physical ways. Just how does the indecision that gives birth to so many potentially conflicting 'future selves' lead to greater strength? Am I missing some point here?



* How was Kiseki able to retain his personality and appearance for such a long time after his egg was Xed? Snopee lost hers imedientally and was transformed right after, and Diamond didn't seem to struggle like this as well. (But, then again, Diamond was testing Amu all along, so her transformation was probably voluntary...)

to:

* How was Kiseki able to retain his personality and appearance for such a long time after his egg was Xed? Snopee lost hers imedientally immediately and was transformed right after, and Diamond didn't seem to struggle like this as well. (But, then again, Diamond was testing Amu all along, so her transformation was probably voluntary...)



<<|Headscratchers|>>

to:

<<|Headscratchers|>>
11th Jun '15 6:59:24 AM tropower
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The Black Diamond [=CDs=]. They're made from X Eggs and when the Guardians confiscated them in school, it's clear that a whole shit load of them were made. Whatever happened to them? I don't think the Guardians were ever told what they really were and we're never shown what they did with them. If they just threw them out or something...
* Dia. How the hell does being born from the feelings of wanting to shine out give you the power to time travel? Important to the plot, yes, but ''way'' too over-powered here. Personal little bugger.

to:

* The Black Diamond [=CDs=]. They're made from X Eggs and when the Guardians confiscated them in school, it's clear that a whole shit truck load of them were made. Whatever happened to them? I don't think the Guardians were ever told what they really were and we're never shown what they did with them. If they just threw them out or something...
* Dia. How the hell does being born from the feelings of wanting to shine out give you the power to time travel? Important to the plot, yes, but ''way'' too over-powered here. Personal little bugger.
5th May '15 7:09:11 AM tropower
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

**** Snoppe is a filler character, so it's a moot point in her case.
4th Dec '14 12:12:03 AM HakaiEve
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe Amu can purify only because she wears the Humpty Lock.
4th Dec '14 12:10:48 AM HakaiEve
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*Character Changes don't make sense to me. How do people not see a crown on your head? Would they think you were bipolar?
17th Oct '13 5:04:03 AM tropower
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** Either way, her name is short for "Diamond" (the name used by the official English version of the manga), or "Daiyamondo" when written / pronounced in Japanese, so both spellings are correct.[[note]]Moreover, Amu's character transformation with her is called "Amulet Dia" (or "Amulet Diamond").[[/note]]
29th Sep '13 1:57:17 PM MagBas
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Can someone please explain when the motive of the manga devolved from "follow your dreams" to "how girls can fight?" Maybe I'm just silly, but I'm pretty sure she'd been fighting for 37 chapters before this. Albeit in a very sparkly way. Apparently though, the only way for a girl to fight is....to hug people, dress everyone within arms reach in silly clothing, and give it a cute costume name? This is at least a personal WallBanger.
** It never did. The moral still stands. A lot. She may have been referring towards how some - one as "gentle" as her, who doesn't like fighting, can fight. [[UnfortunateImplications Of course, using gender nouns within reference towards it is a rather odd term for such a thing,]] but meh. [[FrickinLaserBeams And she didn't just make costumes.]]
** It's even worse in the anime where it has been 99 episodes with lots of extra magical girl style fighting. I can see how Amu would be hesitent in reacting to the Ikuto/Tadase fight and the hug was clearly long overdue but questioning a girl's role when she knows that she is the heroine of a magical girls series just comes off as needless angsting.
** Not to mention, that Ikuto, most likely didn't ''want'' to fight, but he was kinda BrainwashedAndCrazy at the moment. But, apparently, Ikuto and Tadase are only fighting because [[WhatAnIdiot they're boys]].
** Hell, the whole rhetoric sounds like Amu took a [[StayInTheKitchen trip to the kitchen]].



* Dia, is my personal [[TheScrappy Scrappy]]. She has the personality of a wet blanket, comes around every 20 episodes for 10 minutes, [[BrokenRecord babbles about "radiance" for 7 of those minutes]], and is gone just as fast. And also, she's somehow the strongest Guardian charcter of them all.
** And then I met Rikka. The constant [[CreatorsPet shilling]], isn't helping either.
*** I say Saaya is Peach-Pit's scrappy. She really could have been a main character, but she gets X-egged, X-charad, and even ?-charaed.
** You guys have Dia and Rikka, and I have Yua. C'mon, her whole character basis just screams MarySue: extremely popular model, loved by everyone, knows Amu from kindergarden, [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and her song gets to be on the Character Song Collection even though she only appeared in two episodes and had no plot significance whatsoever]]. To me it sounds like something out of a bad fanfic.



<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>

to:

<<|ItJustBugsMe|>><<|Headscratchers|>>
18th Dec '11 7:55:58 AM Liana7
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Maybe something to do with how Utau's chara transforms don't change her hairdo? Amu and Yaya are wearing hats, so they can't have their hair up.

to:

*** Maybe something to do with how Utau's chara transforms don't change her hairdo? Amu and Yaya are wearing hats, wear hats during their chara transforms, so they can't have their hair up.
This list shows the last 10 events of 31. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.ShugoChara