Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / NightOfTheComet

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** If it was deep winter for the majority of land masses when the Earth previously encountered the comet, many animals could have been hibernating in burrows, making their metabolic rates too slow to absorb significant radiation.

to:

** If it was deep winter for the majority of land masses when the Earth previously encountered the comet, many animals could have been hibernating in burrows, making their metabolic rates too slow to absorb significant radiation.radiation.
* How was the Think Tank the only one to figure out the link between this comet's return after 65 million years and the extinction of the dinosaurs? Not a single person at NASA, the European Space Agency or the Kosmicheskaya Programma SSSR noticed this was the same comet responsible for the biggest mass extinction event in Earth's history or thought it warranted any safety precautions? Not a single alarm was raised after communications from parts of the world that had already seen the comet went completely silent?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Also, all the survivors were small enough to hide. just like here, where the survivors were all sheltered in steel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Iridium, not Iradium


** There is a huge "empty" section in the geologic fossil table, and it's rich in Iradium 80, an element not native to Earth.

to:

** There is a huge "empty" section in the geologic fossil table, and it's rich in Iradium Iridium 80, an element not native to Earth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** FridgeBrilliance: They're not throwing away the guns at all, they're ''hiding'' them in a place where it would be counter-intuitive for hostile survivors to look for them. If they're confident that the zombies have all finished disintegrating by now, and don't feel the need to haul heavy weaponry around any longer, then putting the guns in a place where they'll remain undisturbed and are sheltered from the elements isn't a bad plan.

to:

** FridgeBrilliance: They're not throwing away the guns at all, they're ''hiding'' them in a place where it would be counter-intuitive for hostile survivors to look for them. If they're confident that the zombies have all finished disintegrating by now, and don't feel the need to haul heavy weaponry around any longer, then putting the guns in a place where they'll remain undisturbed and are sheltered from the elements (yet ''could'' be retrieved in a pinch) isn't a bad plan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** FridgeBrilliance: They're not throwing away the guns at all, they're ''hiding'' them in a place where it would be counter-intuitive for hostile survivors to look for them. If they're confident that the zombies have all finished disintegrating by now, and don't feel the need to haul heavy weaponry around any longer, then putting the guns in a place where they'll remain undisturbed and are sheltered from the elements isn't a bad plan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And the comet's appearance was hyped as a once-in-a-lifetime event by the media, unaware that it would also be an ''end''-of-a-lifetime event. Even night-shift workers probably took a coffee break to take a look at the sky, and for rough sleepers it'd sound like a rare chance for some free entertainment.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Being underground apparently ''would'' have sufficed to shield the think tank, had they not left their ventilation fans on. Possibly there were burrowing animals that survived because they were under the soil with no air flow in their tunnels, or at least their eggs were buried.

to:

** Being underground apparently ''would'' have sufficed to shield the think tank, had they not left their ventilation fans on. Possibly there were burrowing animals that survived because they were under the soil with no air flow in their tunnels, or at least their eggs were buried.buried.
** If it was deep winter for the majority of land masses when the Earth previously encountered the comet, many animals could have been hibernating in burrows, making their metabolic rates too slow to absorb significant radiation.

Added: 308

Changed: 52

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There is a huge "empty" section in the geologic fossil table, and it's rich in Iradium 80, an element not native to Earth.



** It feeds into the idea of "the burden of civilization resting on their shoulders". They don't cross against the light, and so they also don't litter. But the idea of throwing away the guns is stupid anyways. Even if there's no more zombies, that's not to say that any survivors they meet after this are good people.

to:

** It feeds into the idea of "the burden of civilization resting on their shoulders". shoulders." They don't cross against the light, and so they also don't litter. But the idea of throwing away the guns is stupid anyways. Even if there's no more zombies, that's not to say that any survivors they meet after this are good people.



** I think it had to do with "direct exposure" to both the comet and it's radiation. If you were in an area that wasn't exposed to the outside you were okay. But if you were outside or had a window open, you were exposed. It looks like the people who were outside got the highest exposure and were turned into carbon-dust, while anyone with minimal exposure [[spoiler: like the think-tank scientists]] decomposed at a much slower rate. And I think it was said that the "haze" for the most part was the carbon-dust of the people living in Los Angeles and not actual radiation. When it started raining and the carbon-dust was washed away, the red haze went away too.

to:

** I think it had to do with "direct exposure" to both the comet and it's its radiation. If you were in an area that wasn't exposed to the outside you were okay. But if you were outside or had a window open, or the vents open with the fans going full tilt, you were exposed. It looks like the people who were outside got the highest exposure and were turned into carbon-dust, while anyone with minimal exposure [[spoiler: like the think-tank scientists]] decomposed at a much slower rate. And I think it was said that the "haze" for the most part was the carbon-dust of the people living in Los Angeles and not actual radiation. When it started raining and the carbon-dust was washed away, the red haze went away too.


Added DiffLines:

** There were '''a lot''' of people turned into blood banks at the "Think Tank." The think tank also made a very concerted effort to round up the survivors and make them "brain dead."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** We don't know how early in the night people started disintegrating or roaming around eating people, either. He may well have ''heard'' some of the zombies snarling and chasing victims near his truck in the pre-dawn hours, and set out to find shelter as soon as the coast was clear and there was enough light to see by.

to:

** We don't know how early in the night people started disintegrating or roaming around eating people, either. He may well have ''heard'' some of the zombies snarling and chasing victims near his truck in the pre-dawn hours, and set out to find shelter contact others as soon as the coast was clear and there was enough light to see by.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** We don't know how early in the night people started disintegrating or roaming around eating people, either. He may well have ''heard'' some of the zombies snarling and chasing victims near his truck in the pre-dawn hours, and set out to find shelter as soon as the coast was clear and there was enough light to see by.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
uTIC


* If the comet did indeed wipe out the dinosaurs, how come anything at all survived to evolve into modern lifeforms? It's not like there was an abundance of metal-lined structures to hide in back then.

to:

* If the comet did indeed wipe out the dinosaurs, how come anything at all survived to evolve into modern lifeforms? It's not like there was an abundance of metal-lined structures to hide in back then.then.
** Being underground apparently ''would'' have sufficed to shield the think tank, had they not left their ventilation fans on. Possibly there were burrowing animals that survived because they were under the soil with no air flow in their tunnels, or at least their eggs were buried.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because the focus of the movie is on the teenagers?

to:

** Because the focus of the movie is on the teenagers?teenagers?
* If the comet did indeed wipe out the dinosaurs, how come anything at all survived to evolve into modern lifeforms? It's not like there was an abundance of metal-lined structures to hide in back then.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why aren't there a lot more survivors around? If all it takes to shield someone is a thin metal box, like the garden shed Sam slept in, you'd think there'd be thousands of people who happened to be sheltered in the same way, in a city as big as L.A. Anyone working the night shift in a building with metal walls, for example, or squatters living out of metal cargo containers.

to:

* Why aren't there a lot more survivors around? If all it takes to shield someone is a thin metal box, like the garden shed Sam slept in, you'd think there'd be thousands of people who happened to be sheltered in the same way, in a city as big as L.A. Anyone working the night shift in a building with metal walls, for example, or squatters living out of metal cargo containers.containers.
** Because the focus of the movie is on the teenagers?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why aren't there a lot more survivors around? If all it takes to shield someone is a thin metal box, like the garden shed Sam slept in, you'd think there'd be thousands of people who happened to be sheltered in the same way, in a city as big as L.A. Anyone working the night shift in a building with metal walls, for example.

to:

* Why aren't there a lot more survivors around? If all it takes to shield someone is a thin metal box, like the garden shed Sam slept in, you'd think there'd be thousands of people who happened to be sheltered in the same way, in a city as big as L.A. Anyone working the night shift in a building with metal walls, for example.example, or squatters living out of metal cargo containers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why aren't there a lot more survivors around? If all it takes to shield someone is a thin metal box, like the garden shed Sam slept in, you'd think there'd be thousands of people who happened to be sheltered in the same way, in a city as big as L.A. Anyone working the night shift in underground facilities or basements or sewers or parking garages, for example.

to:

* Why aren't there a lot more survivors around? If all it takes to shield someone is a thin metal box, like the garden shed Sam slept in, you'd think there'd be thousands of people who happened to be sheltered in the same way, in a city as big as L.A. Anyone working the night shift in underground facilities or basements or sewers or parking garages, a building with metal walls, for example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I think it had to do with "direct exposure" to both the comet and it's radiation. If you were in an area that wasn't exposed to the outside you were okay. But if you were outside or had a window open, you were exposed. It looks like the people who were outside got the highest exposure and were turned into carbon-dust, while anyone with minimal exposure [[spoiler: like the think-tank scientists]] decomposed at a much slower rate. And I think it was said that the "haze" for the most part was the carbon-dust of the people living in Los Angeles and not actual radiation. When it started raining and the carbon-dust was washed away, the red haze went away too.

to:

** I think it had to do with "direct exposure" to both the comet and it's radiation. If you were in an area that wasn't exposed to the outside you were okay. But if you were outside or had a window open, you were exposed. It looks like the people who were outside got the highest exposure and were turned into carbon-dust, while anyone with minimal exposure [[spoiler: like the think-tank scientists]] decomposed at a much slower rate. And I think it was said that the "haze" for the most part was the carbon-dust of the people living in Los Angeles and not actual radiation. When it started raining and the carbon-dust was washed away, the red haze went away too.too.
* Why aren't there a lot more survivors around? If all it takes to shield someone is a thin metal box, like the garden shed Sam slept in, you'd think there'd be thousands of people who happened to be sheltered in the same way, in a city as big as L.A. Anyone working the night shift in underground facilities or basements or sewers or parking garages, for example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Since she's still alive by the end of the movie and hadn't turned into a zombie or carbon-dust, then it's safe to say her stress rash was just a red herring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* So was Sam's "infection" just one big red herring? Like, it really was just a stress rash and not the disease?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It ''really'' depends on the type of energy supplying the power. If the city is run on coal nuclear power then the power would go down rather quickly. Oil or hydroelectric energy could sustain a city for several months without anyone running them. And if it's solar-powered, then the power could stay on virtually forever.

to:

** It ''really'' depends on the type of energy supplying the power. If the city is run on coal or nuclear power then the power would go down rather quickly. Oil or hydroelectric energy could sustain a city for several months without anyone running them. And if it's solar-powered, then the power could stay on virtually forever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It ''really'' depends on the type of energy supplying the power. If the city is run on coal nuclear power then the power would go down rather quickly. Oil or hydroelectric energy could sustain a city for several months without anyone running them. And if it's solar-powered, then the power could stay on virtually forever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It feeds into the idea of "the burden of civilization resting on their shoulders". They don't cross against the light, and so they also don't litter.

to:

** It feeds into the idea of "the burden of civilization resting on their shoulders". They don't cross against the light, and so they also don't litter. But the idea of throwing away the guns is stupid anyways. Even if there's no more zombies, that's not to say that any survivors they meet after this are good people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It feeds into the idea of "the burden of civilization resting on their shoulders". They don't cross against the light, and so they also don't litter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He had direct contact with ''multiple'' zombies, and witnessed a couple of them eating a girl. I'm sure he gauged his knowledge of the zombies from this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why aren't the kids in danger from the disease? Isn't the haze in the air going to do anything?

to:

* Why aren't the kids in danger from the disease? Isn't the haze in the air going to do anything?anything?
** I think it had to do with "direct exposure" to both the comet and it's radiation. If you were in an area that wasn't exposed to the outside you were okay. But if you were outside or had a window open, you were exposed. It looks like the people who were outside got the highest exposure and were turned into carbon-dust, while anyone with minimal exposure [[spoiler: like the think-tank scientists]] decomposed at a much slower rate. And I think it was said that the "haze" for the most part was the carbon-dust of the people living in Los Angeles and not actual radiation. When it started raining and the carbon-dust was washed away, the red haze went away too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In their defense, the movie only takes place over the course of ''maybe'' three days. There's a chance that the power goes down shortly after the credits roll.

to:

** In their defense, the movie only takes place over the course of ''maybe'' three days. There's a chance that the power goes down shortly after the credits roll.roll.
* Why aren't the kids in danger from the disease? Isn't the haze in the air going to do anything?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In their defense, the movie only takes place over the course of ''maybe'' three days. There's a chance that the power goes down shortly after the credits roll.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Throwing the guns away in a city garbage can when no one is collecting trash anymore is ''really'' stupid.

to:

* Throwing the guns away in a city garbage can when no one is collecting trash anymore is ''really'' stupid. You'd get the same effect from leaving them in a box in the middle of the street.

Top