Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When the [[MateOrDie Pon Farr]] takes you, little can be done except to hide the children and the infirm.

to:

** When the [[MateOrDie Pon Farr]] takes you, little can be done except to hide the children and the infirm.infirm.
***I think you mean the [[IncrediblyLamePun Pony Farr]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Fun fact fans guess ponies are about three and a half feet high, Celestia is twice there size meaning she's not a pony but a horse
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Except for that it started on /co/ infected /co/ long before /b/ even caught wind.

to:

*** Except for that it started on /co/ and infected /co/ it long before /b/ even caught wind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***Except for that it started on /co/ infected /co/ long before /b/ even caught wind.
**It started on the Comics and Cartoons Board when first released with the general consensus of "Oh look, My Little Pony has a new series and it looks kind of interesting". After that it was sort of "Wow, this is actually not that bad of cartoon", and then it picked up and turned into the obsession that it is now.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Replied to one complaint with a possible solution


* There is a mule in applebuck season. a mule. As in, the sterile offspring of a male donkey and a female horse. That implies quite a bit... and the fan assumption is that donkeys are on the same level as wildlife, meaning some mare in ponyville is very promiscuous. There is no other explanation.

to:

* There is a mule in applebuck season. a mule. As in, the sterile offspring of a male donkey and a female horse. That implies quite a bit... and the fan assumption is that donkeys are on the same level as wildlife, meaning some mare in ponyville is very promiscuous. There is no other explanation.explanation.
** When the [[MateOrDie Pon Farr]] takes you, little can be done except to hide the children and the infirm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Well, they both needed voice actresses that could sound tomboyish, so this is probably why their voices are so alike.

to:

** Well, they both needed voice actresses that could sound tomboyish, so this is probably why their voices are so alike.alike.
* There is a mule in applebuck season. a mule. As in, the sterile offspring of a male donkey and a female horse. That implies quite a bit... and the fan assumption is that donkeys are on the same level as wildlife, meaning some mare in ponyville is very promiscuous. There is no other explanation.

Added: 345

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Also, remember that while Twilight and the group know that Luna is actually not truly evil, most of the world does not and still fears The Mare in the Moon. Were Luna to take a visible and active role in governance, there would likely be a huge public backlash.

to:

**** *** Also, remember that while Twilight and the group know that Luna is actually not truly evil, most of the world does not and still fears The Mare in the Moon. Were Luna to take a visible and active role in governance, there would likely be a huge public backlash. backlash.
*** Luna was trapped for 1000 years, not something you get over quickly. She's probably still resenting Celestia and said "hey, you've been taking care of Equestria without my help for a thousand years, I'm sure you don't need it now, and everypony loves you more than me. So I'll sit back and raise the moon, while you do all that other stuff."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Also, remember that while Twilight and the group know that Luna is actually not truly evil, most of the world does not and still fears The Mare in the Moon. Were Luna to take a visible and active role in governance, there would likely be a huge public backlash.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** How can you tell how many tropers frequent /co/? Besides, how adults act in real life and how they act on the Internet are two VERY seperate things.


Added DiffLines:

** Well, they both needed voice actresses that could sound tomboyish, so this is probably why their voices are so alike.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's not called 'Random' because it's predictable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** This isn't 4chan. And in my experience, actual adults know how to not be inappropriately creepy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This isn't a gripe, but I swear to God Rainbow Dash has the same voice as Spinelli from {{Recess}}. IMDB says otherwise, though.

to:

* This isn't a gripe, but I swear to God Rainbow Dash has the same voice as Spinelli from {{Recess}}. IMDB says otherwise, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's just that good. Simple as that.

to:

** It's just that good. Simple as that.that.
*This isn't a gripe, but I swear to God Rainbow Dash has the same voice as Spinelli from {{Recess}}. IMDB says otherwise, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I'm not sure how much of this is a "just bugs me" but HOW IN HEAVEN'S NAME DID THIS SHOW GET POPULAR ON A BOARD IN 4CHAN? Is it just that good? Is it a carry over from RobotUnicornAttack? Someone explain it to me, because it's BLOWING MY MIND.

to:

* I'm not sure how much of this is a "just bugs me" but HOW IN HEAVEN'S NAME DID THIS SHOW GET POPULAR ON A BOARD IN 4CHAN? Is it just that good? Is it a carry over from RobotUnicornAttack? Someone explain it to me, because it's BLOWING MY MIND.MIND.
** It's just that good. Simple as that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It was inevitable for a show that is popular on 4chan. And besides, [=FiM=] has lot more grown-up fans than older incarnations, and we all know what adult fanbase means on the Internet.

to:

** It was inevitable for a show that is popular on 4chan. And besides, [=FiM=] has lot more grown-up fans than older incarnations, and we all know what adult fanbase means on the Internet.Internet.
* I'm not sure how much of this is a "just bugs me" but HOW IN HEAVEN'S NAME DID THIS SHOW GET POPULAR ON A BOARD IN 4CHAN? Is it just that good? Is it a carry over from RobotUnicornAttack? Someone explain it to me, because it's BLOWING MY MIND.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The prevalence of creepy fans, even on this wiki. The word "bondage" shouldn't even be on the same page as My Little Pony.

to:

* The prevalence of creepy fans, even on this wiki. The word "bondage" shouldn't even be on the same page as My Little Pony.Pony.
** It was inevitable for a show that is popular on 4chan. And besides, [=FiM=] has lot more grown-up fans than older incarnations, and we all know what adult fanbase means on the Internet.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I hate the Internet.


** Nah, it's just a pun for a pony-society. Usually when there is an animal society, they make use of animal sterotypes and what we associate with them, and put it in 'out society'. Like a mouse-society has places all being puns on 'cheese'.

to:

** Nah, it's just a pun for a pony-society. Usually when there is an animal society, they make use of animal sterotypes and what we associate with them, and put it in 'out society'. Like a mouse-society has places all being puns on 'cheese'.'cheese'.
* The prevalence of creepy fans, even on this wiki. The word "bondage" shouldn't even be on the same page as My Little Pony.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Is there a trope for that?


* The mayor addresses the public with "fillies and gentlecolts". Since colt and filly are terms for immature horses, does it mean they never grow up? Not that it couldn't be somewhat plausible in this franchise, but then, what about Granny Smith? (and Pinkie Pie refers to her own grandmother in one of her songs) Also, Rarity mentions "stallion of her dreams".

to:

* The mayor addresses the public with "fillies and gentlecolts". Since colt and filly are terms for immature horses, does it mean they never grow up? Not that it couldn't be somewhat plausible in this franchise, but then, what about Granny Smith? (and Pinkie Pie refers to her own grandmother in one of her songs) Also, Rarity mentions "stallion of her dreams".dreams".
** Nah, it's just a pun for a pony-society. Usually when there is an animal society, they make use of animal sterotypes and what we associate with them, and put it in 'out society'. Like a mouse-society has places all being puns on 'cheese'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Maybe most of the males are just stronger. They didn't intend to go with some stereotype. If they did, all the Wonderbolts would be female, 'cus you know, the stereotype is that males are strong and females fast.

to:

*** Maybe most of the males are just stronger. They didn't intend to go with some stereotype. If they did, all the Wonderbolts would be female, 'cus you know, the stereotype is that males are strong and females fast.fast.
* The mayor addresses the public with "fillies and gentlecolts". Since colt and filly are terms for immature horses, does it mean they never grow up? Not that it couldn't be somewhat plausible in this franchise, but then, what about Granny Smith? (and Pinkie Pie refers to her own grandmother in one of her songs) Also, Rarity mentions "stallion of her dreams".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Executive Meddling.

to:

*** Executive Meddling. According to WordOfGod, kids associate Queens with 'evil' and Princesses with 'good', so that's the reason for her title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** By that logic though that would technically make everybody is Equestria a Miohippus and they basically accelerated evolution using magic for their own means.

to:

** By that logic though that would technically make everybody is in Equestria a Miohippus and they basically accelerated evolution using magic for their own means.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** By that logic though that would technically make everybody is Equestria a Miohippus and they're basically accelerated evolution using magic for their own means.

to:

** By that logic though that would technically make everybody is Equestria a Miohippus and they're they basically accelerated evolution using magic for their own means.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** By that logic though that would technically makes everybody is Equestria a Miohippus and they're basically accelerated evolution using magic for their own means.

to:

** By that logic though that would technically makes make everybody is Equestria a Miohippus and they're basically accelerated evolution using magic for their own means.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** By that logic though that would technically makes everybody is Equestria a Miohippus and they're basically accelerated evolution using magic for their own means.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** What bugs me is that the most males we've seen in one place were during Winter Wrap-Up, doing the hard manual labor. Twilight appeared to be the only mare pushing a snowplow. On the other hoof, two of the three shown Wonderbolts are female (you can tell by the chin).

to:

** What bugs me is that the most males we've seen in one place were during Winter Wrap-Up, doing the hard manual labor. Twilight appeared to be the only mare pushing a snowplow. On the other hoof, two of the three shown Wonderbolts are female (you can tell by the chin).chin).
*** Maybe most of the males are just stronger. They didn't intend to go with some stereotype. If they did, all the Wonderbolts would be female, 'cus you know, the stereotype is that males are strong and females fast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She is LargeAndInCharge. Presumably, she's using the same kind of enchantment Luna used to become Nightmare Moon, except without all the evil.



** You forgot about regular pony number 2: Pinkie Pie, who works at the shop of the couple Cake. And you forgot about Applejack's brother who also works at the farm and does the same things as Applejack. I do not know what you're implying, but there are enough male ponies doing different stuff. They're just not main characters. There isn't anything 'sexist' about anything they do nor their amount. My Little Ponies have always been mostly female, due to it being aimed for girls.

to:

** You forgot about regular pony number 2: Pinkie Pie, who works at the shop of the couple Cake. And you forgot about Applejack's brother who also works at the farm and does the same things as Applejack. I do not know what you're implying, but there are enough male ponies doing different stuff. They're just not main characters. There isn't anything 'sexist' about anything they do nor their amount. My Little Ponies have always been mostly female, due to it being aimed for girls.girls.
** What bugs me is that the most males we've seen in one place were during Winter Wrap-Up, doing the hard manual labor. Twilight appeared to be the only mare pushing a snowplow. On the other hoof, two of the three shown Wonderbolts are female (you can tell by the chin).

Added: 257

Changed: 901

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As it was already mentioned somewhere, Laura Faust herself wanted her to be "queen Celestia" all along, but aparently little girls today see princesess as good and queens as evil for some reason, so she had no choice...

to:

** As it was already mentioned somewhere, Laura Faust herself wanted She's a princess because
*** Equestria is a principality.
*** She's doesn't have absolute authority, since
her sister is her equal.
*** Executive Meddling.
** Luna is probably off doing other stuff. She doesn't have the personal relation that brings Celestia
to be "queen Celestia" Ponyville all along, but aparently little girls today see princesess as good and queens as evil for some reason, so she had no choice...the time.



** The whole assignment was clearly supposed to be more like Celestia's personal favor to Twilight Sparkle who didn't want to leave her new friends and go back to her regular studying in Canterlot. The reports she sends back to the princess are just to inform what new she learned about friendship recently, not for anyone's actual scientific benefit.

to:

** The whole assignment was clearly supposed to be more like Twilight is teaching herself, yes, but at Celestia's personal favor to direction. Celestia probably already knows all the stuff Twilight Sparkle who didn't want to leave her new friends and go back to her regular studying in Canterlot. The reports she sends back to the princess are just to inform what new she learned about friendship recently, not writes about, but lets Twilight discover it for anyone's actual scientific benefit.herself.



** Heck, Celestia is basically a pony-goddess in this series. She's over thousand years old, she raises the sun every day, I would be surprised if she ''wasn't'' different from mortal ponies. And for a creature that is superior to ponies in the land called Equestria, what would be better than a full grown horse?

to:

** Heck, Celestia is basically a pony-goddess in this series. She's over thousand years old, Well, she raises the sun every day, I would is pretty much a goddess. They tend to be surprised if she ''wasn't'' different from mortal ponies. And for a creature that is superior to ponies in the land called Equestria, what would be better than a full grown horse?pretty big.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ever noticed how few male ponies there are? It's easy to miss. Go on, go look back through the first few episodes. The pegasi are the first men we see, and they don't say anything. They just chauffeur other ponies about. Unicorns like Twilight are given special social standing; look how free Twilight is to move about. (When not being ordered about by Celestia, of course.) There is a definite pattern of men being less obvious throughout the first few episodes, and they nearly always appear in roles involving manual labor. Of our main characters, we have two unicorns, who spend their time studying and crafting luxury goods, respectively; two pegasi, who have some duties about town like weather and animal control but are largely allowed to do as they like; and one regular pony, who has to spend all of her time maintaining her farm and working hard to keep her family business going.

to:

* Ever noticed how few male ponies there are? It's easy to miss. Go on, go look back through the first few episodes. The pegasi are the first men we see, and they don't say anything. They just chauffeur other ponies about. Unicorns like Twilight are given special social standing; look how free Twilight is to move about. (When not being ordered about by Celestia, of course.) There is a definite pattern of men being less obvious throughout the first few episodes, and they nearly always appear in roles involving manual labor. Of our main characters, we have two unicorns, who spend their time studying and crafting luxury goods, respectively; two pegasi, who have some duties about town like weather and animal control but are largely allowed to do as they like; and one regular pony, who has to spend all of her time maintaining her farm and working hard to keep her family business going.going.
**You forgot about regular pony number 2: Pinkie Pie, who works at the shop of the couple Cake. And you forgot about Applejack's brother who also works at the farm and does the same things as Applejack. I do not know what you're implying, but there are enough male ponies doing different stuff. They're just not main characters. There isn't anything 'sexist' about anything they do nor their amount. My Little Ponies have always been mostly female, due to it being aimed for girls.

Changed: 903

Removed: 282

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She's a princess because
*** Equestria is a principality.
*** She's doesn't have absolute authority, since her sister is her equal.
*** Executive Meddling.
** Luna is probably off doing other stuff. She doesn't have the personal relation that brings Celestia to Ponyville all the time.

to:

** She's a princess because
*** Equestria is a principality.
*** She's doesn't have absolute authority, since
As it was already mentioned somewhere, Laura Faust herself wanted her sister is her equal.
*** Executive Meddling.
** Luna is probably off doing other stuff. She doesn't have the personal relation that brings Celestia
to Ponyville be "queen Celestia" all the time.along, but aparently little girls today see princesess as good and queens as evil for some reason, so she had no choice...



** Twilight is teaching herself, yes, but at Celestia's direction. Celestia probably already knows all the stuff Twilight writes about, but lets Twilight discover it for herself.

to:

** Twilight is teaching herself, yes, but at The whole assignment was clearly supposed to be more like Celestia's direction. Celestia probably already knows all the stuff personal favor to Twilight writes about, but lets Twilight discover it Sparkle who didn't want to leave her new friends and go back to her regular studying in Canterlot. The reports she sends back to the princess are just to inform what new she learned about friendship recently, not for herself.anyone's actual scientific benefit.



** Well, she is pretty much a goddess. They tend to be pretty big.
* Ever noticed how few male ponies there are? It's easy to miss. Go on, go look back through the first few episodes. The pegasi are the first men we see, and they don't say anything. They just chauffeur other ponies about. Unicorns like Twilight are given special social standing; look how free Twilight is to move about. (When not being ordered about by Celestia, of course.) There is a definite pattern of men being less obvious throughout the first few episodes, and they nearly always appear in roles involving manual labor. Of our main characters, we have two unicorns, who spend their time studying and crafting luxury goods, respectively; two pegasi, who have some duties about town like weather and animal control but are largely allowed to do as they like; and one regular pony, who has to spend all of her time maintaining her farm and working hard to keep her family business going.
** What about Pinkie Pie?

to:

** Well, Heck, Celestia is basically a pony-goddess in this series. She's over thousand years old, she raises the sun every day, I would be surprised if she ''wasn't'' different from mortal ponies. And for a creature that is pretty much a goddess. They tend superior to ponies in the land called Equestria, what would be pretty big.
better than a full grown horse?
* Ever noticed how few male ponies there are? It's easy to miss. Go on, go look back through the first few episodes. The pegasi are the first men we see, and they don't say anything. They just chauffeur other ponies about. Unicorns like Twilight are given special social standing; look how free Twilight is to move about. (When not being ordered about by Celestia, of course.) There is a definite pattern of men being less obvious throughout the first few episodes, and they nearly always appear in roles involving manual labor. Of our main characters, we have two unicorns, who spend their time studying and crafting luxury goods, respectively; two pegasi, who have some duties about town like weather and animal control but are largely allowed to do as they like; and one regular pony, who has to spend all of her time maintaining her farm and working hard to keep her family business going.
** What about Pinkie Pie?
going.

Added: 1379

Changed: 873

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She's a princess because
*** Equestria is a principality.
*** She's doesn't have absolute authority, since her sister is her equal.
*** Executive Meddling.
** Luna is probably off doing other stuff. She doesn't have the personal relation that brings Celestia to Ponyville all the time.



** Twilight is teaching herself, yes, but at Celestia's direction. Celestia probably already knows all the stuff Twilight writes about, but lets Twilight discover it for herself.



* Ever noticed how few male ponies there are? It's easy to miss. Go on, go look back through the first few episodes. The pegasi are the first men we see, and they don't say anything. They just chauffeur other ponies about. Unicorns like Twilight are given special social standing; look how free Twilight is to move about. (When not being ordered about by Celestia, of course.) There is a definite pattern of men being less obvious throughout the first few episodes, and they nearly always appear in roles involving manual labor. Of our main characters, we have two unicorns, who spend their time studying and crafting luxury goods, respectively; two pegasi, who have some duties about town like weather and animal control but are largely allowed to do as they like; and one regular pony, who has to spend all of her time maintaining her farm and working hard to keep her family business going.

to:

** Well, she is pretty much a goddess. They tend to be pretty big.
* Ever noticed how few male ponies there are? It's easy to miss. Go on, go look back through the first few episodes. The pegasi are the first men we see, and they don't say anything. They just chauffeur other ponies about. Unicorns like Twilight are given special social standing; look how free Twilight is to move about. (When not being ordered about by Celestia, of course.) There is a definite pattern of men being less obvious throughout the first few episodes, and they nearly always appear in roles involving manual labor. Of our main characters, we have two unicorns, who spend their time studying and crafting luxury goods, respectively; two pegasi, who have some duties about town like weather and animal control but are largely allowed to do as they like; and one regular pony, who has to spend all of her time maintaining her farm and working hard to keep her family business going.going.
**What about Pinkie Pie?

Top