Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Moonraker

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected English mistakes.


** Who says those guards weren't to his genetic standards? Maybe a few of them were lacking in the apearance department (I don't remember their faces), but as soldiers, and ones Drax trusted to protect his utopia, they had to be pretty physically capable.

to:

** Who says those guards weren't to his genetic standards? Maybe a few of them were lacking in the apearance appearance department (I don't remember their faces), but as soldiers, and ones Drax trusted to protect his utopia, they had to be pretty physically capable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected English mistakes.


*** The mooks are likely astronauts who joined him in the space station, and they were obviously hiding in there only after Drax found out about the flaw (or more likely, after the Moonraker was arranged to be shipped. As to the timetable thing- yes, he ''did'' have one. He would have needed one because the longer he put it off, the greater the chance either his secret launching pad, his space station, or worst of all his WeaponOfMassDestruction would be found out, not to mention his whole plan involved gathering the best of humanity at their physical peak, so the longer he waited the more likely they would succumb to age or injury, not to mention anyone involved might get cold feet and rat the whole thing out. Above all there is his controlling nature, which means faced with the choice of seizing control of the situation or accepting the hand fate dealt him, he'd go with the former. The "attracting suspicion" argument has the same flaw as the "how much did this cost" argument- its a moot point, when within days he expects to succeed in his plan to wipe out mankind. And he's too smug and elitist to even contemplate the possibility that he might not succeed.

to:

*** The mooks are likely astronauts who joined him in the space station, and they were obviously hiding in there only after Drax found out about the flaw (or more likely, after the Moonraker was arranged to be shipped. As to the timetable thing- yes, he ''did'' have one. He would have needed one because the longer he put it off, the greater the chance either his secret launching pad, his space station, or worst of all his WeaponOfMassDestruction would be found out, not to mention his whole plan involved gathering the best of humanity at their physical peak, so the longer he waited the more likely they would succumb to age or injury, not to mention anyone involved might get cold feet and rat the whole thing out. Above all there is his controlling nature, which means faced with the choice of seizing control of the situation or accepting the hand fate dealt him, he'd go with the former. The "attracting suspicion" argument has the same flaw as the "how much did this cost" argument- its it's a moot point, when within days he expects to succeed in his plan to wipe out mankind. And he's too smug and elitist to even contemplate the possibility that he might not succeed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected English mistakes.


** Two reasons:

to:

** Two Multiple reasons:



*** If you're going to ''end human civilization'', do you ''care'' about your unpaid credit card bills? Drax can spend himself bankrupt ten times over if he wants to; its not like his creditors are ever going to collect, and once everybody but the Ark contingent is dead he has the entire wealth of the planet to loot.

to:

*** If you're going to ''end human civilization'', do you ''care'' about your unpaid credit card bills? Drax can spend himself bankrupt ten times over if he wants to; its it's not like his creditors are ever going to collect, and once everybody but the Ark contingent is dead dead, he has the entire wealth of the planet to loot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected spelling


* Drax's evil scheme could have been pulled off without the use of spaceships. Firstly, it would have been much cheaper to build his Ark underground, environmentally sealed, than to build a space station in orbit. Secondly, Drax could have used aircraft to deliver the toxin. Why? Because he runs an '''''aero'''''''space'' company, and he had a radar jamming system for his space station. And even if it couldn't be fitted on a plane, stealth wasn't a complete unknown back then. Putting stuff into space is insanely expensive, up to $10,000 to put ''one kilogram'' into orbit, which is why you didn't take your last holiday at Utopia Planetia, Mars. But I guess this was all discarded in favour of footage of space shuttles docking, undocking, and performing course corrections.

to:

* Drax's evil scheme could have been pulled off without the use of spaceships. Firstly, it would have been much cheaper to build his Ark underground, environmentally sealed, than to build a space station in orbit. Secondly, Drax could have used aircraft to deliver the toxin. Why? Because he runs an '''''aero'''''''space'' company, and he had a radar jamming system for his space station. And even if it couldn't be fitted on a plane, stealth wasn't a complete unknown back then. Putting stuff into space is insanely expensive, up to $10,000 to put ''one kilogram'' into orbit, which is why you didn't take your last holiday at Utopia Planetia, Planitia, Mars. But I guess this was all discarded in favour of footage of space shuttles docking, undocking, and performing course corrections.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Insane, but also a genius. The cost of transporting a mansion from France to the US is infinitely smaller than the cost of putting a giant space station in orbit, building half a dozen space shuttles to supply it, and, say, getting enough people and supplies up there to repopulate the planet. And what about when they have to land? There are only a few airports in the world that have a runway long enough to accommodate a space shuttle, and there would have to be people on the ground waiting for their arrival. So why not have ''everyone'' on the ground? Drax could have built a secret city underneath the Amazon and just used the shuttles to distribute the virus (meaning Bond would have to go up and shoot them down). It's just a blatant cash-in on StarWars, and by God it shows.

to:

*** Insane, but also a genius. The cost of transporting a mansion from France to the US is infinitely smaller than the cost of putting a giant space station in orbit, building half a dozen space shuttles to supply it, and, say, getting enough people and supplies up there to repopulate the planet. And what about when they have to land? There are only a few airports in the world that have a runway long enough to accommodate a space shuttle, and there would have to be people on the ground waiting for their arrival. So why not have ''everyone'' on the ground? Drax could have built a secret city underneath the Amazon and just used the shuttles to distribute the virus (meaning Bond would have to go up and shoot them down). It's just a blatant cash-in on StarWars, ''Franchise/StarWars'', and by God it shows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





to:

\n\n** One of the ones he had planned to use had a fault so he needed a new one, He probobly figured he could finish his plan by the time anyone caught up to him.


Added: 456

Changed: 314

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In my head cannon, she survived but got a good scare.



** The entire reason parachutes are strapped to your back and around your legs is because there is a HUGE jerk when the parachute deploys. Jaws simply wasn't able to keep hold of Bond from the force of the deployment.

to:

*** The guy was still trying to kill him after Bond caught him in mid-air? I doubt that anyone would be foolish enough to try to attack someone as you're drifting to the ground sharing one parachute.
** The entire reason parachutes are strapped to your back and around your legs is because there is a HUGE jerk when the parachute deploys. Jaws simply wasn't able to keep hold of Bond from the force of the deployment.deployment
*** Another reason why the first guy really had a case of the IdiotBall not pulling his zipcord as soon as Bond grabbed onto him?
* Why did Drax steel the Moonraker in the first place?


Added: 460

Changed: 547

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The mid-air parachute sequence. Why did Bond feel that he couldn't even at least attempt to save the guy's life who he stole the parachute from. He was pretty nuetralized. Why would Jaws suddenly fall off Bond once the rip cord was released?

to:

** Dobermans are extremely fast and Drax only gave her a handful of seconds before loosing them on her, and a dog the size of a Doberman can do a fairly slow trot and keep up with a woman running. I would have been much more shocked if she's actually managed to outrun them. And what gave you the idea that they were 'devouring' her? Most attack dogs like Drax had are trained to bring down their targets and then simply go for the throat.
* The mid-air parachute sequence. Why did Bond feel that he couldn't even at least attempt to save the guy's life who he stole the parachute from. He was pretty nuetralized.neutralized. Why would Jaws suddenly fall off Bond once the rip cord was released?


Added DiffLines:

** The entire reason parachutes are strapped to your back and around your legs is because there is a HUGE jerk when the parachute deploys. Jaws simply wasn't able to keep hold of Bond from the force of the deployment.

Changed: 911

Removed: 924

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



* So in ''Moonraker'', lasers are small and lethal enough to be used as an infantry and anti-air (anti-space?) weapon. We also have shuttles that can be launched in under an hour, and marines trained in space-borne operations. Why didn't this show up anywhere else in the franchise?

to:

\n* So in ''Moonraker'', So, lasers are small and lethal enough to be used as an infantry and anti-air (anti-space?) weapon. We also have shuttles that can be launched in under an hour, and marines trained in space-borne operations. Why didn't this show up anywhere else in the franchise?




* The falling out the airplane stunt early in film.... completely ridiculous and totally unnecessary. It looks as if it was added in post-production because the rest of the film was so terrible.

to:

\n* The falling out the airplane stunt early in film....film... completely ridiculous and totally unnecessary. It looks as if it was added in post-production because the rest of the film was so terrible.













* At the beginning of the movie the Moonraker shuttle is being flown from the U.S. to England. After the Moonraker is hijacked, the jet carrying it crashes in the Yukon. Problem: the Yukon is the westernmost part of Canada, just east of Alaska. How exactly did a plane traveling from the U.S. to England end up there? Even assuming the flight started in California where the Moonraker was built, there's no reason for it to ever be over the Yukon.

to:

\n* At the beginning of the movie movie, the Moonraker shuttle is being flown from the U.S. to England. After the Moonraker is hijacked, the jet carrying it crashes in the Yukon. Problem: the Yukon is the westernmost part of Canada, just east of Alaska. How exactly did a plane traveling from the U.S. to England end up there? Even assuming the flight started in California where the Moonraker was built, there's no reason for it to ever be over the Yukon.















** Doberman could easily catch her especially given their trained to hunt and the camera cut away before we see what exactly happens to her

to:

** Doberman Dobermans could easily catch her especially given their trained to hunt and the camera cut away before we see what exactly happens to her
her





*

to:

\n\n*----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Thus, judged by the standards of its time, the movie wasn't ''quite'' as silly as it seems today. For example, it would be perfectly reasonable to expect a shuttle to be launched within 2-4 days in an emergency situation. And it might be feasible for a sufficiently wealthy person to purchase a space shuttle (or 12, which is what Drax did -- he only stole the shuttle that started the whole movie because one was damaged / destroyed or lost [don't remember which]). And constructing an elaborate space station is much more reasonable at $175 / pound to LEO.

to:

*** Thus, judged by the standards of its time, the movie wasn't ''quite'' as silly as it seems today. For example, it would be perfectly reasonable to expect a shuttle to be launched within 2-4 days in an emergency situation. And it might be feasible for a sufficiently wealthy person to purchase a space shuttle (or 12, which is what Drax did -- he only stole the shuttle that started the whole movie because one was damaged / destroyed or lost [don't remember which]).damaged). And constructing an elaborate space station is much more reasonable at $175 / pound to LEO.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Doberman could easily catch her especially given their trained to hunt and the camera cut away before we see what exactly happens to her





to:

\n** Because the guy was trying to kill him. it was kill or be killed. Jaws fell because he lost his grip when the parachute suddenly slowed their fall.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In case if that would happen. It's like ask "Why school need fire alarm, If school might not burn?"

to:

** In case if that would happen. It's like ask "Why school need fire alarm, If school might not burn?"burn?"

* What kind of dogs are there that could have chased down Corinne? Dogs do not have that much endurance (Are these genetically engineered super-dogs?) and can only bite, not devour.

*The mid-air parachute sequence. Why did Bond feel that he couldn't even at least attempt to save the guy's life who he stole the parachute from. He was pretty nuetralized. Why would Jaws suddenly fall off Bond once the rip cord was released?


*
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The 747 crashes because the Moonraker launches off its back by firing its main engines. Leaving aside the minor quibble that the Shuttle's main engines are fuelled from the big External Tank (I suppose Drax could somehow have arranged to have a fuel supply aboard) it's clear that having the engines fire while being carried is A Very Bad Thing and not meant to happen, ever. So why is there an indicator announcing just that in the 747 cockpit?

to:

* The 747 crashes because the Moonraker launches off its back by firing its main engines. Leaving aside the minor quibble that the Shuttle's main engines are fuelled from the big External Tank (I suppose Drax could somehow have arranged to have a fuel supply aboard) it's clear that having the engines fire while being carried is A Very Bad Thing and not meant to happen, ever. So why is there an indicator announcing just that in the 747 cockpit?cockpit?
** In case if that would happen. It's like ask "Why school need fire alarm, If school might not burn?"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Drax is planning to establish himself as god-emperor over his unquestioningly subservient "master race". Why limit himself to one partner when he can have his choice of any partner he wants whenever he wants? It's almost a mathematical certainty that if he wants it, he's going to be boning down with a different hot girl every single night.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Less conspicuous and a decent bokken is, pretty much, a sharpened baseball bat, so I guess that with a good whack or two he could have killed his target, then get rid of the murder weapon easier than with a sword.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Chang attacks Bond in the glass museum, he uses a bokken, a wooden training sword. Why not use a katana? It would be more effective in killing and wouldn't get broken if his target got his hands on a metal weapon like a sword.

to:

* When Chang attacks Bond in the glass museum, he uses a bokken, a wooden training sword. Why not use a katana? It would be more effective in killing and wouldn't get broken if his target got his hands on a metal weapon like a sword.sword.

* The 747 crashes because the Moonraker launches off its back by firing its main engines. Leaving aside the minor quibble that the Shuttle's main engines are fuelled from the big External Tank (I suppose Drax could somehow have arranged to have a fuel supply aboard) it's clear that having the engines fire while being carried is A Very Bad Thing and not meant to happen, ever. So why is there an indicator announcing just that in the 747 cockpit?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* When Chang attacks Bond in the glass museum, he uses a bokken, a wooden training sword. Why not use a katana? It would be more effective in killing.

to:

* When Chang attacks Bond in the glass museum, he uses a bokken, a wooden training sword. Why not use a katana? It would be more effective in killing.killing and wouldn't get broken if his target got his hands on a metal weapon like a sword.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For that matter, why didn't Drax have a breeding partner? Did he not consider himself a "perfect" specimen, or was he just planning on doing a lot of bed hopping? Or was he the first gay Bond villain, albeit a deeply closeted one? Did it bother him that his future Master Race wouldn't actually be descended from him?

to:

** For that matter, why didn't Drax have a breeding partner? Did he not consider himself a "perfect" specimen, or was he just planning on doing a lot of bed hopping? Or was he the first gay Bond villain, albeit a deeply closeted one? Did it bother him that his future Master Race wouldn't actually be descended from him?him?

* When Chang attacks Bond in the glass museum, he uses a bokken, a wooden training sword. Why not use a katana? It would be more effective in killing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Drax hadn't killed her, would Corinne have been part of his Master Race? She was beautiful and she worked for him, and those are apparently the only requirements.
** Further, is it just barely possible that she was supposed to be his mate? It would explain why he kills her in such a horrific way, and it would explain why he doesn't have a mate on the space station at the end.
** For that matter, why doesn't Drax have a partner? Does he not consider himself a "perfect" specimen, or was he planning on doing a lot of bed hopping? Or is he the first gay Bond villain, albeit a deeply closeted one?

to:

* If Drax hadn't killed her, would Corinne have been part of his Master Race? She was beautiful and she worked for him, and those are were apparently the only requirements.
prerequisites.
** Further, is it just barely possible that she was supposed to be his mate? It would explain why he kills killed her in such a horrific way, and it would explain why he doesn't didn't have a mate on the space station at the end.
** For that matter, why doesn't didn't Drax have a breeding partner? Does Did he not consider himself a "perfect" specimen, or was he just planning on doing a lot of bed hopping? Or is was he the first gay Bond villain, albeit a deeply closeted one?one? Did it bother him that his future Master Race wouldn't actually be descended from him?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That, or standard cult brainwashing. If they thought they were at their version of the rapture, you think scientologists or members of the WBC would care much about their non-cult family members?

to:

** That, or standard cult brainwashing. If they thought they were at their version of the rapture, you think scientologists or members of the WBC would care much about their non-cult family members?members?

* If Drax hadn't killed her, would Corinne have been part of his Master Race? She was beautiful and she worked for him, and those are apparently the only requirements.
** Further, is it just barely possible that she was supposed to be his mate? It would explain why he kills her in such a horrific way, and it would explain why he doesn't have a mate on the space station at the end.
** For that matter, why doesn't Drax have a partner? Does he not consider himself a "perfect" specimen, or was he planning on doing a lot of bed hopping? Or is he the first gay Bond villain, albeit a deeply closeted one?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**[[Troper/RoarkTenjouin This Troper]] once read in a book that the closest real-life equivalent to the poison Drax wanted to use was Richin - which doesn't exactly have a long shelf life from what he's found. It could be that he was originally planning on using his own fleet of shuttles, but the shelf life for the poison Drax had was either the same length as/shorter than that of Ricin, and he couldn't get his hands on more.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Don't forget that by Drax's standards, Jaws would have to go. And that's how Bond gets him to change sides

Added: 201

Changed: 424

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the book there's really no need for Drax to [[spoiler:develop the Moonraker and launch his nuclear warhead on London]] when he can just drive it there. M even [[LampshadeHanging lampahades]] this in the last chapter.

to:

!! The book:
* In the book there's There's really no need for Drax to [[spoiler:develop the Moonraker and launch his nuclear warhead on London]] when he can just drive it there. M even [[LampshadeHanging lampahades]] lampshades]] this in the last chapter.
** Apparently he's just so much of a maniac he wants to hit it with the Moonraker rocket for symbolic reasons. [[FridgeHorror If he hadn't been a maniac, he would probably have succeeded!]]

!! The film:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Who says those guards weren't to his genetic standards? Maybe a few of them were lacking in the apearance department (I don't remember their faces), but as soldiers, and ones Drax trusted to protect his utopia, they had to be pretty physically capable.



** Probably. I imagine you don't end up working as a foot soldier in the private army of a guy who plans to blow up the entire world and repopulate it while ruling over everything as a god-emperor without ''some'' tendencies towards sociopathy.

to:

** Probably. I imagine you don't end up working as a foot soldier in the private army of a guy who plans to blow up the entire world and repopulate it while ruling over everything as a god-emperor without ''some'' tendencies towards sociopathy.sociopathy.
** That, or standard cult brainwashing. If they thought they were at their version of the rapture, you think scientologists or members of the WBC would care much about their non-cult family members?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Probably. I imagine you don't end up working as a foot soldier in the private army of a guy who plans to blow up the entire world without ''some'' tendencies towards sociopathy.

to:

** Probably. I imagine you don't end up working as a foot soldier in the private army of a guy who plans to blow up the entire world and repopulate it while ruling over everything as a god-emperor without ''some'' tendencies towards sociopathy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Probably. I imagine you don't end up working as a henchman to a guy who plans to blow up the entire world without ''some'' tendencies towards sociopathy.

to:

** Probably. I imagine you don't end up working as a henchman to foot soldier in the private army of a guy who plans to blow up the entire world without ''some'' tendencies towards sociopathy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes Do none of Drax's guards have families?]] Friends? Lovers? A favorite bartender? I'm reminded of ''Film/AvengersAgeOfUltron'' where Quicksilver and the Scarlet Witch were fine with terrorism but drew the line at [[EvenEvilHasStandards destroying the world]]. Does Drax employ psychological screening to find the most sociopathic henchmen possible?

to:

* [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes Do none of Drax's guards have families?]] Friends? Lovers? A favorite bartender? I'm reminded of ''Film/AvengersAgeOfUltron'' where Quicksilver and the Scarlet Witch were fine with terrorism but drew the line at [[EvenEvilHasStandards destroying the world]]. Does Drax employ psychological screening to find the most sociopathic henchmen possible?possible?
** Probably. I imagine you don't end up working as a henchman to a guy who plans to blow up the entire world without ''some'' tendencies towards sociopathy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes Do none of Drax's guards have families?]] Friends? Lovers? A favorite bartender? I'm reminded of ''Film/AvengersAgeOfUltron'' where Quicksilver and the Scarlet Witch were fine with terrorism but drew the line at [[EvenEvilHasStandards destroying the world]]. Does Drax employ psychological screening to find the most sociopathic henchmen possible?

to:

** * [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes Do none of Drax's guards have families?]] Friends? Lovers? A favorite bartender? I'm reminded of ''Film/AvengersAgeOfUltron'' where Quicksilver and the Scarlet Witch were fine with terrorism but drew the line at [[EvenEvilHasStandards destroying the world]]. Does Drax employ psychological screening to find the most sociopathic henchmen possible?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why did Drax steal a shuttle instead of simply extending his timetable? He's managed to build a fleet of private shuttles. He's managed to build a huge space station. He did that completely undetected even though it would require years worth of trips back and forth for the construction. Why risk something as public as the theft of a multi-billion dollar spacecraft when there was no time crunch to his plan?

to:

* Why did Drax steal a shuttle instead of simply extending his timetable? He's managed to build a fleet of private shuttles. He's managed to build a huge space station. He did that completely undetected even though it would require years worth of trips back and forth for the construction. Why risk something as public as the theft of a multi-billion dollar spacecraft when there was no time crunch to his plan?plan?
** [[EvenEvilHasLovedOnes Do none of Drax's guards have families?]] Friends? Lovers? A favorite bartender? I'm reminded of ''Film/AvengersAgeOfUltron'' where Quicksilver and the Scarlet Witch were fine with terrorism but drew the line at [[EvenEvilHasStandards destroying the world]]. Does Drax employ psychological screening to find the most sociopathic henchmen possible?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He was a good guy when he decided to help James Bond save his girlfriend and the rest of the world. It's called a HeelFaceTurn- he doesn't ''have'' to be a decent human being, but that doesn't mean he isn't doing the right thing.

to:

** He was a good guy when he decided to help James Bond save his girlfriend and the rest of the world. It's called a HeelFaceTurn- he doesn't ''have'' to be a decent human being, but that doesn't mean he isn't doing the right thing.thing.
* Why did Drax steal a shuttle instead of simply extending his timetable? He's managed to build a fleet of private shuttles. He's managed to build a huge space station. He did that completely undetected even though it would require years worth of trips back and forth for the construction. Why risk something as public as the theft of a multi-billion dollar spacecraft when there was no time crunch to his plan?

Top