Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / JudgeDredd

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* What is the penalty for crimes of a sexually perverse nature?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


***** But if Rico's DNA is mutated, how could it have been pinged for Dredd's non-mutated DNA without deliberately tampering with evidence (which, again, is never suggested to have been done here)?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Space. Don't forget, Judge Dredd comics might be focused on Mega-City-One, and the rest of the Mega-Cities to a lesser extent, but they also share a universe with Strontium Dog and several other interstellar comics, depicting an almost endless array of other solar systems full of habitable planets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Except that is {{Artistic License Economics}}. Crime is inherently disruptive to an capitalist economy. A black market has no regulation to ensure stability and is far too chaotic to support an economy, not to mention the constant risk of doing business. And since all transactions occur without transparency or oversight, the currency is harmed by all trade. Taxing automated businesses to pay for welfare makes at least a little sense since customers need money to buy products and support a market.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Smart bullets.

to:

** Smart bullets.bullets.
* How could the huge cyborg mutant sneak up to Judge Fargo to stab him?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One story had giant mutant tapeworms that have eaten growth hormones run amok in the city. After Dredd kills them, he suggests turning them into burgers instead of simply destroying them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[PoliceBrutality Seems a tad cruel]]. The ''Dredd Vs Death'' FPS would [[VideogameCrueltyPunishment set the SJS on you]] for using the incendiary round on criminals.

to:

** [[PoliceBrutality Seems a tad cruel]]. The ''Dredd ''[[VideoGame/JudgeDreddDreddVsDeath Dredd Vs Death'' Death]]'' FPS would [[VideogameCrueltyPunishment set the SJS on you]] for using the incendiary round on criminals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Of course the Judges break their own laws to stay in power. That's one of the themes.

to:

** Of course the Judges break their own laws to stay in power. That's one of the themes. Chief Judge Silver put it best when he told Dredd "On this one you ''write'' the law" before the Democratic March.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**The palm print CAN read through gloves. It's specifically stated so in the story where the third Dredd clone is introduced, when he is being given his Lawgiver.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** In one comic the Judges start to farm a strain of giant mutant rat because it is leaner and more nutricious than the rats they farm allready.

to:

**** In one comic the Judges start to farm a strain of giant mutant rat because it is leaner and more nutricious than the rats they farm allready. In another, a mutant tapeworm that winds up addicted to growth hormones gets loose and Dredd has to take it down. When he's killed it, he tells control to send down people to cut it up and use as meat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Typo


*** Except that is {{Artistic License Economics}}. Crime is inherently disruptive to an capitalist economy. A black market has no regulation to ensure stability and is far too chaotic to support an economy, not to mention the constant risk of doing business. And since all transactions occur without transparency or oversight, the curreny is harmed by all trade. Taxing automated businesses to pay for welfare makes at least a little sense since customers need money to buy products and support a market.

to:

*** Except that is {{Artistic License Economics}}. Crime is inherently disruptive to an capitalist economy. A black market has no regulation to ensure stability and is far too chaotic to support an economy, not to mention the constant risk of doing business. And since all transactions occur without transparency or oversight, the curreny currency is harmed by all trade. Taxing automated businesses to pay for welfare makes at least a little sense since customers need money to buy products and support a market.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In the comics, there is a way to use a fallen judge's Lawgiver, though it's knowledge only available to Senior Judges. [[EverythingIsOnline A central database of registered judges seems somewhat impractical]], especially if the judge goes on an out of city job.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Except that is {{ArtisticLicenseEconomics}}. Crime is inherently disruptive to an capitalist economy. A black market has no regulation to ensure stability and is far too chaotic to support an economy, not to mention the constant risk of doing business. And since all transactions occur without transparency or oversight, the curreny is harmed by all trade. Taxing automated businesses to pay for welfare makes at least a little sense since customers need money to buy products and support a market.

to:

*** Except that is {{ArtisticLicenseEconomics}}.{{Artistic License Economics}}. Crime is inherently disruptive to an capitalist economy. A black market has no regulation to ensure stability and is far too chaotic to support an economy, not to mention the constant risk of doing business. And since all transactions occur without transparency or oversight, the curreny is harmed by all trade. Taxing automated businesses to pay for welfare makes at least a little sense since customers need money to buy products and support a market.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Except that is {{ArtisticLicenseEconomics}}. Crime is inherently disruptive to an capitalist economy. A black market has no regulation to ensure stability and is far too chaotic to support an economy, not to mention the constant risk of doing business. And since all transactions occur without transparency or oversight, the curreny is harmed by all trade. Taxing automated businesses to pay for welfare makes at least a little sense since customers need money to buy products and support a market.

to:

** *** Except that is {{ArtisticLicenseEconomics}}. Crime is inherently disruptive to an capitalist economy. A black market has no regulation to ensure stability and is far too chaotic to support an economy, not to mention the constant risk of doing business. And since all transactions occur without transparency or oversight, the curreny is harmed by all trade. Taxing automated businesses to pay for welfare makes at least a little sense since customers need money to buy products and support a market.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Except that is {{ArtisticLicenseEconomics}}. Crime is inherently disruptive to an capitalist economy. A black market has no regulation to ensure stability and is far too chaotic to support an economy, not to mention the constant risk of doing business. And since all transactions occur without transparency or oversight, the curreny is harmed by all trade. Taxing automated businesses to pay for welfare makes at least a little sense since customers need money to buy products and support a market.

Added: 43

Changed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Maybe it only works on people who keep their face covered less than him. That would explain why Dredd was immune.

to:

*** Maybe it only works on people who keep their face covered less than him. [[WMG/JudgeDredd That would explain why Dredd was immune.
immune]].



** Presumably, it can scan through gloves. In a world where such technologies as time travel, dimension jumping and indestructable plastic exist, this isn't too far out of the realm of possibility.

to:

** Presumably, it can scan through gloves. In a world where such technologies as time travel, dimension jumping and indestructable indestructible plastic exist, this isn't too far out of the realm of possibility.
possibility.

* Shouldn't it be "Walte'''w''' the Wobot"?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** It's a [[CrapsackWorld Crapsack Universe]]. Yes, aliens exist... as they're generally just as dickish as most humans. One story actually does have seemingly benign aliens setting up missions in the poorest parts of Mega City One, ostensibly out of altruism. It turns out they're actually turning the souls of the dead into drugs.




to:

*** Maybe it only works on people who keep their face covered less than him. That would explain why Dredd was immune.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The point wasn't necessarily the best man to play Dredd, just a better choice than Sly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Could have just told people that he'd confiscated this robot which, as they can clearly see, is active and therefore illegal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** RefugeInAudacity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** There is nothing in the movie that says Lawgivers are coded to individual judges. While they may be in the comics, that doesn't necessarily carry over to the movie. In the scene in the pawn shop, the broker exclaims not to touch the Lawgiver because it'll take your hand off if you're not a Judge. Rico responds by picking it up and saying "How about that? I must be a Judge." That's plenty to imply that Lawgivers work for anyone who's in the Judge database. Presumably in the event of a block war where Judges might have to pick up the weapons of their own fallen.


Added DiffLines:

*** No, Hershey tries to claim that it's evidence she wasn't made aware of and that she should have been allowed knowledge of it so a defense could be prepared. She ''claims''. That's not the same thing as Hershey being correct in the setting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How exactly does the Double Whammy round work? Especially since it spreads from the same barrel in the right direction (Who's to say with barrel rifling that the rounds won't fly vertically or diagonally?) at the correct distance to conveniently kill two guys at once.

to:

* How exactly does the Double Whammy round work? Especially since it spreads from the same barrel in the right direction (Who's to say with barrel rifling that the rounds won't fly vertically or diagonally?) at the correct distance to conveniently kill two guys at once.once.
** Smart bullets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** If your standards for a good Dredd are nothing more than "has a deep voice" and "doesn't take his helmet off", I really don't think you're qualified to complain about anyone else's standards. "Well, Dredd just drop-kicked a baby and raped three people, but at least he kept his helmet on when he was doing it, and his voice was nice and gravelly while he mocked his victims..."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Maybe he saves the whole "Gaze into the face of fear" thing for those people he really wants to kill, or it only works on one person at the same time (think [[HarryPotter Boggart]]), so if he tried to use it on more than one person it would just not work.

to:

** Maybe he saves the whole "Gaze into the face of fear" thing for those people he really wants to kill, or it only works on one person at the same time (think [[HarryPotter [[Franchise/HarryPotter Boggart]]), so if he tried to use it on more than one person it would just not work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* For a society that is suppose to be all about following the letter of the law, the Judges(including Dredd) seems to have no problem with breaking the rules if it serves them. For example, it has been repeatedly stated that Mega-City One doesn't have the death penalty, but in the 'Judge Dredd in America' story, Dredd ordered the Judges to open fire on the Total War terrorist even though they have clearly surrendered and should have been arrested instead. Also, in the Judge Anderson story 'Satan', the Judges secretly killed a Christian minister for challenging the Judges system, even though they themselves admit that he he didn't break any laws in giving public speeches, he didn't even resist when Anderson arrested him. And even if he did somehow break the law, they cannot legally kill him, and can only at most give him life in prison. Sometimes it feel like that instead of LawfulNeutral taken to the extreme, the Judges feels more like your average NeutralEvil dictatorship that will break its own laws just to stay in power.

to:

* For a society that is suppose to be all about following the letter of the law, the Judges(including Judges (including Dredd) seems to have no problem with breaking the rules if it serves them. For example, it has been repeatedly stated that Mega-City One doesn't have the death penalty, but in the 'Judge Dredd in America' story, Dredd ordered the Judges to open fire on the Total War terrorist even though they have clearly surrendered and should have been arrested instead. Also, in the Judge Anderson story 'Satan', the Judges secretly killed a Christian minister for challenging the Judges system, even though they themselves admit that he he didn't break any laws in giving public speeches, he didn't even resist when Anderson arrested him. And even if he did somehow break the law, they cannot legally kill him, and can only at most give him life in prison. Sometimes it feel like that instead of LawfulNeutral taken to the extreme, the Judges feels more like your average NeutralEvil dictatorship that will break its own laws just to stay in power.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The point being, that he was closer to the source material than Stallone ever could be, LanternJawOfJustice aside.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Those seem like reasons even sillier than Dredd having a scrappy sidekick.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** Well, you apparently know everything about the movie's setting, you tell us why, then.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** He has full Judge attire, probably let him get away with a lot. Nothing to say no one noticed, but he may have just been able to bluff and bullshit his way by anyone who did see them.

to:

** He has full Judge attire, probably let him get away with a lot. Nothing to say no one noticed, but he may have just been able to bluff and bullshit his way by anyone who did see them.them.
* How exactly does the Double Whammy round work? Especially since it spreads from the same barrel in the right direction (Who's to say with barrel rifling that the rounds won't fly vertically or diagonally?) at the correct distance to conveniently kill two guys at once.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Based on him being NeverBareheaded for a start. Also for being not so [[LargeHam hammy]].

Top