Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / IndianaJonesAndTheLastCrusade

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More accuracy. He had the Israelites make it.


** This is the same God that made the [[Film/RaidersOfTheLostArk Ark of the Covenant]]. He's a bit of a drama queen.

to:

** This is the same God that made that’s behind the [[Film/RaidersOfTheLostArk Ark of the Covenant]]. He's a bit of a drama queen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Indy's a scientist. He pooh-poohs the idea of "magic" and "mysticism" and the supernatural because those imply that these things cannot be explained, and that one has to just give up and accept that there's some kind of big supernatural power or force out there that can never be understood and so you might as well not bother trying. Being a scientist, however, generally comes with the mindset that ''everything'', no matter how inexplicable it might seem, has some kind of explanation that can be reached so long as you apply enough time and rational thought to studying it. Indy sees plenty of things that he cannot easily explain, and he might find some of these things humbling because they remind him that there are limits to his understanding of the world and all it's mysteries. But he's not willing to just pass them off as 'magic' because that would mean conceding that they are ultimately inexplicable, which is anathema to the way he views the world.

to:

** Indy's a scientist. He pooh-poohs the idea of "magic" and "mysticism" and the supernatural because those imply that these things cannot be explained, and that one has to just give up and accept that there's some kind of big supernatural power or force out there that can never be understood and so you might as well not bother trying. Being a scientist, however, generally comes with the mindset that ''everything'', no matter how inexplicable it might seem, has some kind of explanation that can be reached so long as you apply enough time and rational thought to studying it. Indy sees plenty of things that he cannot easily explain, and he might find some of these things humbling because they remind him not to get too cocky and full of himself, that there are limits to his understanding of the world and all it's mysteries. But he's not willing to just pass them off as 'magic' because that would mean conceding that they are ultimately inexplicable, which is anathema to the way he views the world.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Indy's a scientist. He pooh-poohs the idea of "magic" and "mysticism" and the supernatural because those imply that these things cannot be explained, and that one has to just give up and accept that there's some kind of big supernatural power or force out there that can never be understood and so you might as well not bother trying. Being a scientist, however, generally comes with the mindset that ''everything'', no matter how inexplicable it might seem, has some kind of explanation that can be reached so long as you apply enough time and rational thought to studying it. Indy sees plenty of things that he cannot easily explain, and he might find some of these things humbling, but he's not willing to just pass them off as 'magic' because that would mean that they are ultimately inexplicable, which is anathema to the way he views the world.

to:

** Indy's a scientist. He pooh-poohs the idea of "magic" and "mysticism" and the supernatural because those imply that these things cannot be explained, and that one has to just give up and accept that there's some kind of big supernatural power or force out there that can never be understood and so you might as well not bother trying. Being a scientist, however, generally comes with the mindset that ''everything'', no matter how inexplicable it might seem, has some kind of explanation that can be reached so long as you apply enough time and rational thought to studying it. Indy sees plenty of things that he cannot easily explain, and he might find some of these things humbling, but humbling because they remind him that there are limits to his understanding of the world and all it's mysteries. But he's not willing to just pass them off as 'magic' because that would mean conceding that they are ultimately inexplicable, which is anathema to the way he views the world.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Indy's a scientist. He pooh-poohs the idea of "magic" and "mysticism" and the supernatural because those imply that these things cannot be explained, and that one has to just give up and accept that there's some kind of big supernatural power or force out there that can never be understood and so you might as well not bother trying. Being a scientist, however, generally comes with the mindset that ''everything'', no matter how inexplicable it might seem, has some kind of explanation that can be reached so long as you apply enough time and rational thought to studying it. Indy sees plenty of things that he cannot easily explain, and he might find some of these things humbling, but he's not willing to just pass them off as 'magic' because that would mean that they are ultimately inexplicable, which is anathema to the way he views the world.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They can be seen in the background making their way through the Breath of God trial as Indy is working out the Word of God trial, so perhaps they overheard Indy talking through the way to get across.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


* How do Donovan and Elsa get past the Word of God trial? We see that Indy fastened the blades on the Breath of God trial, so they were able to pass that one unscathed, and Indy put sand on the bridge to show anyone who might follow him how the Path of God trial works. But as far as the Word of God trial is concerned, other than destroying the J tile, Indy leaves no indication of how to get past it, and we do not see how Donovan and Elsa do this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Not only that, but it took me years to realize that Indy could have just slipped his arm through his bag's strap and escaped. Classic PlotInducedStupidity.

to:

** Not only that, but it took me years to realize that Indy could have just slipped his arm through his bag's strap and escaped. Classic PlotInducedStupidity.escaped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Maybe none of the Temple of the Sun's discovers had been able to survive the Breath of God trial?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Well, he didn't have much else to do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** This is the same God that made the [[Film/RaidersOfTheLostArk Ark of the Covenant]]. He's a bit of a drama queen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What I want to know is, how does the knight falling over trying to lift his own sword count as being "vanquished" by Indy?

to:

* What I want to know is, how How does the knight falling over trying to lift his own sword count as being "vanquished" by Indy?



* How on earth could the strap on Indy's bag get stuck on the tank's gun barrel during the desert fight? First, said barrel was blown wide open, so he would have had trouble getting the strp there if he tried. Second, the strap is under his jacket in all the other scenes.

to:

* How on earth Earth could the strap on Indy's bag get stuck on the tank's gun barrel during the desert fight? First, said barrel was blown wide open, so he would have had trouble getting the strp there if he tried. Second, the strap is under his jacket in all the other scenes.



** Perhaps he overheard where they were taking them.

to:

** Perhaps he overheard where they were taking them.
him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Grail seems to have that effect on people. A Holy IdiotBall? Divinely, rather than PlotInducedStupidity?

to:

** The Grail seems to have that effect on people. A Holy IdiotBall? Divinely, rather than PlotInducedStupidity?anything else?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This is a thing which I actually like in the Last Crusade, but it always kinda bugs me in a funny way. The movie is set in 1938, and it seems by the weather and surroundings that it is summer in Austria, when they infiltrate that castle. Austria was annexed by Germany in march of 1938. So why is there a cartoonish secret planning facility and base hidden in the castle? Who are they hiding it from and why. They could easily have an open garrison there, or have such facilities in Vienna or anywhere. Its just so funny that ThoseWackyNazis just want to have hidden lairs even if they don't have any need for them.

to:

* This is a thing which I actually like in the Last Crusade, but it always kinda bugs me in a funny way. The movie is set in 1938, and it seems by the weather and surroundings that it is summer in Austria, when they infiltrate that castle. Austria was annexed by Germany in march of 1938. So why is there a cartoonish secret planning facility and base hidden in the castle? Who are they hiding it from and why. They could easily have an open garrison there, or have such facilities in Vienna or anywhere. Its just so funny that ThoseWackyNazis just want to have hidden lairs even if they don't have any need for them.



* This one actually comes from a book on game theory that I was assigned to read in a political science class. So, towards the film's end, Henry Sr. is at death's door and only the true Grail can save him, but a false one will kill any who drink it. Indiana thinks the wooden one is correct but can't know for sure until testing it, so he drinks from it. This book's author points out that Indiana was taking a pointless risk and should have just given it to his father -- the worst case scenario (father dies) would be identical to the result of doing nothing, whereas the worst possible outcome of Indy's plan was that they ''both'' die (and the Nazis manage to get the true Grail, etc). Why did he drink it himself? Of course, I can answer this one myself: Most people in Indy's situation would have done the same thing because they wouldn't want to be directly responsible for killing their own father, whatever a cold strategic algorithm would say. This may be the (rare?) situation where a StrawVulcan would make a better choice than an emotional human.

to:

* This one actually comes from a book on game theory that I was assigned to read in a political science class. So, towards the film's end, Henry Sr. is at death's door and only the true Grail can save him, but a false one will kill any who drink it. Indiana thinks the wooden one is correct but can't know for sure until testing it, so he drinks from it. This book's author points out that Indiana was taking a pointless risk and should have just given it to his father -- the worst case scenario (father dies) would be identical to the result of doing nothing, whereas the worst possible outcome of Indy's plan was that they ''both'' die (and the Nazis manage to get the true Grail, etc). Why did he drink it himself? Of course, I can answer this one myself: Most people in Indy's situation would have done the same thing because they wouldn't want to be directly responsible for killing their own father, whatever a cold strategic algorithm would say. This may be the (rare?) situation where a StrawVulcan would make a better choice than an emotional human.




to:

** Perhaps he overheard where they were taking them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* More to the point, how on Earth does Kazim know where Henry is being held prisoner? The Brotherhood of the Cruciform Sword has nothing to do with the Nazis (heck, they're trying to ''stop'' them, and everyone else for that matter, from finding the Grail). I get why they would be aware that the knight's tomb is under the Venice church (since they've existed for centuries for the sole purpose of protecting the Grail, it makes sense that they'd know where people strongly connected with the Grail are buried) and that due to their purpose they would make a move to stop anyone who gets close to finding it (as Indy does). But knowing where the Nazis took Henry after abducting him in Venice? How could they possibly know that?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It's a biiit more complicated, see [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfB9mX5UUNU here]]. Basically, Romans had a "j" letter that represented a long "i", and, as the speaker in this video notes, the tile Indy breaks could be interpreted as a written "t" just as well, or even a very flourishy Greek tau. What this tropes finds puzzling is how the whole thing stays uncrumbled, if there's only six thin pillars supporting the "right" tiles and absolutely nothing to keep the misleading tiles up but friction. Because misleading tiles being there to mislead is kind of the point. About languages - alphabet and language are not the same. We assume the tiles are in Latin alphabet and that the password is written in Latin, because... it was the language of Church? And the artifact is the Holy Grail? Maybe?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** I just always assumed it was a mod to this being the last (at the time) Indy film. His last adventure, or crusade if you will...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

***Not to mention wearing gloves is practical if you're going to touching objects in a place as old as the temple to avoid getting cut and infected by something.

Top