Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / GundamBuildFighters

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** A question that ties in with the first one. Regarding the parts, some of the changes make sense (The Zaku Amazing's Tank Model kit based Explosive Reactive Armor. Especially since as the Gundam Series has gone on, it's been at least given a nod towards realism with it's technology. I.E. composite armors, using reflective materials or paint coatings to diffuse beam or laser based attacks, etc. So, in regards to things such as Star Build Strike's RG system, how does that work? Even with the Arista crystals wish granting properties, it seems overall there would have to be something reasonable, or concrete way of how the system works, I.E., the Wing Fenice's Beam Mantle having beam emitters, beyond just simply typing in "My Mobile Suit has this". Put more simply, do the more vaguely defined systems have a "What You See is What you Get/Have" rule that's common in Tabletop Wargames regarding equipment?

to:

*** A question that ties in with the first one. Regarding the parts, some of the changes make sense (The Zaku Amazing's Tank Model kit based Explosive Reactive Armor. Especially since as the Gundam Series has gone on, it's been at least given a nod towards realism with it's technology. I.E. composite armors, using reflective materials or paint coatings to diffuse beam or laser based attacks, etc. So, in regards to things such as Star Build Strike's RG system, how does that work? Even with the Arista crystals wish granting properties, it seems overall there would have to be something reasonable, or concrete way of how the system works, I.E., the Wing Fenice's Beam Mantle having beam emitters, beyond just simply typing in "My Mobile Suit has this". Put more simply, do the more vaguely defined systems have a "What You See is What you Get/Have" rule that's common in Tabletop Wargames regarding equipment?equipment?
**** It's possible that some of the technology is incorporating existing stuff from the Gundam series. Using the Star Build Strike as an example, it is possible that the shield contains a derivative of the I-field, seen on suits such as the Big Zam and [[spoiler:Unicorn Gundam]]. Without getting too technical, I-fields basically create a lattice which functions as a negative to megaparticles (which make up beams), dissipating them. Since Plavsky particles are similar enough to Minovsky particles, it is possible that the Build Strike "collects" the dissipated mega particles (This could be done via the use of The Master Gundam's Darkness Finger) and channels them into its beam weapon. Thus, by exploiting existing equipment the builder could get the system to work as they wanted, you would simply need the right combination of parts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Take Japanese employment mindsets into account--in the postwar generation in Japan, it wasn't unusual for an employee to be a lifelong member of a company, no matter how great or small their contribution... and it also wasn't uncommon for TallPoppySyndrome to kick in at the same time. What you get from that kind of system is exactly what PPSE has in its design division: competent but not particularly inspired output. Sure, Mashita isn't actually postwar Japanese, but taking the culture of the production country into account, it explains why there's a bunch of individualistic wunderkinds doing a lot more with the technology than rows upon rows of PPSE designers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** A question that ties in with the first one. Regarding the parts, some of the changes make sense (The Zaku Amazing's Tank Model kit based Explosive Reactive Armor. Especially since as the Gundam Series has gone on, it's been at least given a nod towards realism with it's technology. I.E. composite armors, using reflective materials or paint coatings to diffuse beam or laser based attacks, etc. So, in regards to things such as Star Build Strike's RG system, how does that work? Even with the Arista crystals wish granting properties, it seems overall there would have to be something reasonable, or concrete way of how the system works, I.E., the Wing Fenice's Beam Mantle having beam emitters, beyond just simply typing in "My Mobile Suit has this".

to:

*** A question that ties in with the first one. Regarding the parts, some of the changes make sense (The Zaku Amazing's Tank Model kit based Explosive Reactive Armor. Especially since as the Gundam Series has gone on, it's been at least given a nod towards realism with it's technology. I.E. composite armors, using reflective materials or paint coatings to diffuse beam or laser based attacks, etc. So, in regards to things such as Star Build Strike's RG system, how does that work? Even with the Arista crystals wish granting properties, it seems overall there would have to be something reasonable, or concrete way of how the system works, I.E., the Wing Fenice's Beam Mantle having beam emitters, beyond just simply typing in "My Mobile Suit has this". Put more simply, do the more vaguely defined systems have a "What You See is What you Get/Have" rule that's common in Tabletop Wargames regarding equipment?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Fanon seems to think there's a software scripting system involved with building Gunpla for Gunpla Battle, and that's what the GP Base is for, to declare the pre-programmed functions of the components of a Gunpla.

to:

** Fanon seems to think there's a software scripting system involved with building Gunpla for Gunpla Battle, and that's what the GP Base is for, to declare the pre-programmed functions of the components of a Gunpla.Gunpla.
*** A question that ties in with the first one. Regarding the parts, some of the changes make sense (The Zaku Amazing's Tank Model kit based Explosive Reactive Armor. Especially since as the Gundam Series has gone on, it's been at least given a nod towards realism with it's technology. I.E. composite armors, using reflective materials or paint coatings to diffuse beam or laser based attacks, etc. So, in regards to things such as Star Build Strike's RG system, how does that work? Even with the Arista crystals wish granting properties, it seems overall there would have to be something reasonable, or concrete way of how the system works, I.E., the Wing Fenice's Beam Mantle having beam emitters, beyond just simply typing in "My Mobile Suit has this".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It can also be simply explained by saying the Strike needs an external boost to attain the power levels needed to deploy the discharge system. By shooting its own shield, it'd just be feeding energy that it ''already has stored'' back into itself. It is a lot easier to add more energy capacity than to build a generator capable of sustaining such a gross amount of power indefinitely.

Added: 131

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** After seeing Episode 25, it's evident that if he was using his Gouf R35 it would have been way too strong for training purposes.



** It's not just Plavsky hax -- the "new generation" also demonstrates much more imagination and creativity than the old guard, much like Sei earlier in the show, many of the old guard let Gundam canon constrain them (note most of the canon-fodder so far have been fairly standard kits without any extensive mods). For example the Tallgeese Valkyrie would fit right in the universe of Wing, but the Sengoku Astray is something completely wild compared to its source material. In addition to more creative builds - tactics and strategies have advanced beyond "make a kickass Gunpla and be a good pilot" - The Renato brothers using different suits instead of the same one each battle to keep people guessing, The Kampfer Amazing is basically a swiss army knife, and Team Nemesis is ''outright cheating''.

to:

** It's not just Plavsky hax -- the "new generation" also demonstrates much more imagination and creativity than the old guard, much like Sei earlier in the show, many of the old guard let Gundam canon constrain them (note most of the canon-fodder so far have been fairly standard kits without any extensive mods). For example the Tallgeese Valkyrie would fit right in the universe of Wing, but the Sengoku Astray is something completely wild compared to its source material. In addition to more creative builds - tactics and strategies have advanced beyond "make a kickass Gunpla and be a good pilot" - The Renato brothers using different suits instead of the same one each battle to keep people guessing, The the Kampfer Amazing is basically a swiss army knife, and Team Nemesis is ''outright cheating''.



** Shout out to the original Gundam's "Minovsky Particles" that enabled the compact generators UC Mobile Suits use (see a resemblence now?), though in Universe it might have been Baker's idea to name them (she's the one that knows about Gundam)

to:

** Shout out to the original Gundam's "Minovsky Particles" that enabled the compact generators UC Mobile Suits use (see a resemblence now?), though in Universe it might have been Baker's idea to name them (she's the one that knows about Gundam)Gundam).






Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How exactly does the Gunpla battle system work? I mean yes the Plasky particles bring the Gunpla to "life" and simulate the effects of Gundam battles and damage. But how does it know what does what. I mean the Zaku Amazing is similar but much different unit from a Zaku II gunpla. How does the system know what the differences are, or even what the standard effects are?

to:

* How exactly does the Gunpla battle system work? I mean yes the Plasky particles bring the Gunpla to "life" and simulate the effects of Gundam battles and damage. But how does it know what does what. I mean the Zaku Amazing is similar but much different unit from a Zaku II gunpla. How does the system know what the differences are, or even what the standard effects are?are?
** Fanon seems to think there's a software scripting system involved with building Gunpla for Gunpla Battle, and that's what the GP Base is for, to declare the pre-programmed functions of the components of a Gunpla.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Posing a question.


** Given the ending, I'd say they are. It may have started as simply two people realizing they can both get what they wanted (Mashita being rich, and Baker...um...) from each other. However over time they (or at least Baker) fell for each other. They both seem content with selling the Mocks to people back in Arian.

to:

** Given the ending, I'd say they are. It may have started as simply two people realizing they can both get what they wanted (Mashita being rich, and Baker...um...) from each other. However over time they (or at least Baker) fell for each other. They both seem content with selling the Mocks to people back in Arian.Arian.

*How exactly does the Gunpla battle system work? I mean yes the Plasky particles bring the Gunpla to "life" and simulate the effects of Gundam battles and damage. But how does it know what does what. I mean the Zaku Amazing is similar but much different unit from a Zaku II gunpla. How does the system know what the differences are, or even what the standard effects are?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Providing an answer.


* Is Mashita and Baker [[spoiler:a couple?]] She let him to use her as a lap pillow and [[spoiler:followed him to Arian]].

to:

* Is Mashita and Baker [[spoiler:a couple?]] She let him to use her as a lap pillow and [[spoiler:followed him to Arian]].Arian]].
** Given the ending, I'd say they are. It may have started as simply two people realizing they can both get what they wanted (Mashita being rich, and Baker...um...) from each other. However over time they (or at least Baker) fell for each other. They both seem content with selling the Mocks to people back in Arian.

Changed: 246

Removed: 246

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correcting a previous edit.


** They're bootlegs because they're made by PPSE. And yes they have the patent on Gunpla fight systems, they're not the source of Gunpla. In-Universe that's still probably Bandai, gunpla existed before PPSE as explained in Baker's and Mashita's back story.

Technically PPSE would be in full legal right to sell the product so long as they don't call them gunpla (drones could work, or Mocks as is officially named). But for the characters (Fellini) they see a non-official Gundam knock-off, e.g Bootleg.

to:

** They're bootlegs because they're made by PPSE. And yes they have the patent on Gunpla fight systems, they're not the source of Gunpla. In-Universe that's still probably Bandai, gunpla existed before PPSE as explained in Baker's and Mashita's back story. \n\n Technically PPSE would be in full legal right to sell the product so long as they don't call them gunpla (drones could work, or Mocks as is officially named). But for the characters (Fellini) they see a non-official Gundam knock-off, e.g Bootleg.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
My own explaination of the head scratch.

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

** They're bootlegs because they're made by PPSE. And yes they have the patent on Gunpla fight systems, they're not the source of Gunpla. In-Universe that's still probably Bandai, gunpla existed before PPSE as explained in Baker's and Mashita's back story.

Technically PPSE would be in full legal right to sell the product so long as they don't call them gunpla (drones could work, or Mocks as is officially named). But for the characters (Fellini) they see a non-official Gundam knock-off, e.g Bootleg.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Thinking about it some more, maybe they picked up fans during the preliminaries. Nils had several pretty kickass kills during them (remember the ninja-yoyo, or the takedown of the Psyco Gundam?), and pilots a suit from an EnsembleDarkhorse sidestory. Alia is a cute girl in a skintight outfit and uses one of the more visually unique suits seen in the tournament.


Added DiffLines:

** The negative reaction to "hax" is more of a western fandom thing: Western fandom was introduced to Gundam via stuff like Wing and 08th MS Team which have much less emphasis on Newtypes (or completely lacked them), whereas the original core UC series/movies have had plenty of "hax" from the get-go. Kamille blocking beam blasts with the power of dead Newtypes? Judau force-docking the ZZ with just his rage? Amuro pushing Axis away from Earth with his idealism? The in-show reaction is probably more accurate to the real-life Japanese fandom reaction.


Added DiffLines:

*** [[AndThenJohnWasAZombie And then Mihoshi was the creep.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Shout out to the original Gundam's "Minovsky Particles" that enabled the compact generators UC Mobile Suits use (see a resemblence now?), though in Universe it might have been Baker's idea to name them (she's the one that knows about Gundam)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Still, they're basically intended as stand-ins for actual Gunpla models, so using the terms "bootleg" and "knock off" as derogatory descriptors is not too far off the mark, especially to builders who've spent YEARS perfecting their Gunpla.

to:

*** Still, they're basically intended as stand-ins for actual Gunpla models, so using the terms "bootleg" and "knock off" as derogatory descriptors is not too far off the mark, especially to builders who've spent YEARS perfecting their Gunpla.Gunpla.
* Is Mashita and Baker [[spoiler:a couple?]] She let him to use her as a lap pillow and [[spoiler:followed him to Arian]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is WordOfSaintPaul, but according to both Pixipedia and Nicopedia, Mihoshi's VA has stated on radio that when she was being briefed on the character, she was told to picture Mihoshi as being in her late twenties (!!!); she's getting pretty old for the idol business, so she really needs that popularity to keep her job long enough to get a hit album out. This also explains why she's desperate enough to resort to cheating. Considering how young Sei's mom looks (and she's not even in showbiz), it's not a stretch to assume that Mihoshi is also YoungerThanTheyLook. And given that Fellini's official age is 24 (from the Gundam Try Age card game), it's very much probable that he's younger than she is.

to:

** This is WordOfSaintPaul, but according to both Pixipedia and Nicopedia, Mihoshi's VA has stated on radio that when she was being briefed on the character, she was told to picture Mihoshi as being in her late twenties (!!!); she's getting pretty old for the idol business, so she really needs that popularity to keep her job long enough to get a hit album out. This also explains why she's desperate enough to resort to cheating. Considering how young Sei's mom looks (and she's not even in showbiz), it's not a stretch to assume that Mihoshi is also YoungerThanTheyLook.OlderThanTheyLook. And given that Fellini's official age is 24 (from the Gundam Try Age card game), it's very much probable that he's younger than she is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is WordOfSaintPaul, but according to both Pixipedia and Nicopedia, Mihoshi's VA has stated on radio that when she was being briefed on the character, she was told to picture Mihoshi as being in her late twenties (!!!); she's getting pretty old for the idol business, so she really needs that popularity to keep her job long enough to get a hit album out. This also explains why she's desperate enough to resort to cheating. Considering how young Sei's mom looks (and she's not even in showbiz), it's not a stretch to assume that Mihoshi is also YoungerThanTheyLook. And given that Fellini's official age is 24 (from the Gundam Try Age card game), it's very much probable that he's younger than she is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The thing is hidden in an abandoned space left out by ''Gundam: The Ride'', which is about the size of a ferry. Also, It can only be synthesized in zero gravity so Mashita would know what the substance would react with from his years on Arian, a space colony.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lots of products are launched without backstories with backstories added back for them afterwards, or not require them at all. The Extreme Gundam, for example, or the Beginning Gundam in-universe in its original series. Besides, it's not a knockoff if "automated gunpla battle robot" is exactly what it is. It'd be a great product that would save people everywhere time and money by allowing them to battle against AIs more easily. Bandai themselves also make products that don't appear in any series, mostly in the MSV series. It just seems like a very negative way to look at things, as if they're inherently evil just because the "villain" created them.

to:

** Lots of products are launched without backstories with backstories added back for them afterwards, or not require them at all. The Extreme Gundam, for example, or the Beginning Gundam in-universe in its original series. Besides, it's not a knockoff if "automated gunpla battle robot" is exactly what it is. It'd be a great product that would save people everywhere time and money by allowing them to battle against AIs more easily. Bandai themselves also make products that don't appear in any series, mostly in the MSV series. It just seems like a very negative way to look at things, as if they're inherently evil just because the "villain" created them.them.
*** Still, they're basically intended as stand-ins for actual Gunpla models, so using the terms "bootleg" and "knock off" as derogatory descriptors is not too far off the mark, especially to builders who've spent YEARS perfecting their Gunpla.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lots of products are launched without backstories with backstories added back for them afterwards, or not require them at all. The Extreme Gundam, for example, or the Beginning Gundam in-universe in its original series. Besides, it's not a knockoff if "automated gunpla battle robot" is exactly what it is. It'd be a great product that would save people everywhere time and money by allowing them to battle against AIs more easily. Bandai themselves also make products that don't appear in any series, mostly in the MSV series. It just seems like a very negative way to look at things, as if they're bad just because the "villain" created them.

to:

** Lots of products are launched without backstories with backstories added back for them afterwards, or not require them at all. The Extreme Gundam, for example, or the Beginning Gundam in-universe in its original series. Besides, it's not a knockoff if "automated gunpla battle robot" is exactly what it is. It'd be a great product that would save people everywhere time and money by allowing them to battle against AIs more easily. Bandai themselves also make products that don't appear in any series, mostly in the MSV series. It just seems like a very negative way to look at things, as if they're bad inherently evil just because the "villain" created them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** First, there's no corresponding series for them. Second, [[AllThereInTheManual Background materials]] mention that the drones were intended to be used as cheap, disposable computer controlled enemies.

to:

** First, there's no corresponding series for them. Second, [[AllThereInTheManual Background materials]] mention that the drones were intended to be used as cheap, disposable computer controlled enemies.enemies.
**Lots of products are launched without backstories with backstories added back for them afterwards, or not require them at all. The Extreme Gundam, for example, or the Beginning Gundam in-universe in its original series. Besides, it's not a knockoff if "automated gunpla battle robot" is exactly what it is. It'd be a great product that would save people everywhere time and money by allowing them to battle against AIs more easily. Bandai themselves also make products that don't appear in any series, mostly in the MSV series. It just seems like a very negative way to look at things, as if they're bad just because the "villain" created them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** First, there's no corresponding series for them. Second, [[AllThereInTheManual Background materials]] mention that the drones were intended to be used as cheap, disposable computer controlled enemies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***When Allan orders the A5 his lackey addresses the entire room full of people, and they all cease their activities, indicating they were all working on the A5 at the time. It's clear that the battle system doesn't need upgrading because they've held 7 years' worth of successful gunpla battle tournaments and the system hasn't shown any sign of changing since Takeshi's generation.


Added DiffLines:

*** This is a situation where their collective efforts amount to just about what a single person can do in the same amount of time. IF they're sitting there doing almost nothing anyway, why not just get rid of them all?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** How did he manage to hide the crystal from everyone? That thing was ''huge''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Plavsky crystal might've been what teleported Mashita to Earth, and itself along with him. If the single gem in his pocketwatch was the only thing he stole, he probably wouldn't have been as torqued out as he was... the gem itself being the stolen treasure makes more sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Basically all the gunpla would fit in their source canon, even in their heavily modified "crossover" state. The Kampfer Amazing, Renato Bros gunpla, Amazing Exia, Wing Fenice and Rinascita all could fit within their source canon more or less since they all use conventional weaponry and technology, which is still about the norm. In the last episode we see that the previous generation (Takeshi, Ral, Chinan) are still very competitive and potentially much more destructive than the current generation, so it's not about power or originality since they've had that since Ral's generation. Sengoku Astray and Build Strike still stick out like sore thumbs in their outrageousness, but they're only outliers at most, not worthy of calling it a revolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a headscratcher.


* Unless Domon and Rain have developed [[LikesOlderWomen new]] [[ShotaCon preferences]], their time in Gundam Valhalla isn't going to be as enjoyable as they might have liked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why are the gunpla enemies in the final episode dubbed bootlegs? If they were created by the company that holds a monopoly on gunpla and gunpla battling, aren't they just a new entry to the Gundam universe rather than cheap knockoffs?

to:

* Why are the gunpla enemies in the final episode dubbed bootlegs? If they were created by the company that holds a monopoly on gunpla and gunpla battling, aren't they just a new entry to the Gundam universe rather than cheap knockoffs?knockoffs?
* Unless Domon and Rain have developed [[LikesOlderWomen new]] [[ShotaCon preferences]], their time in Gundam Valhalla isn't going to be as enjoyable as they might have liked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Or it could simply be a matter of bureaucracy within the company keeping talented individuals with great ideas from standing out. The same thing has already happened in the real world in motorsports such as Formula 1 where, back in the late 60s and 70s, the factory team from Ferrari was losing out to smaller British teams simply because talented designers could thrive in the latter but not the former.

to:

** Or it could simply be a matter of bureaucracy within the company keeping talented individuals with great ideas from standing out. The same thing has already happened in the real world in motorsports such as Formula 1 where, back in the late 60s and 70s, the factory team from Ferrari was losing out to smaller British teams simply because talented designers could thrive in the latter but not the former.former.
* Plavsky Particles in general: How did they figure out they reacted only with gunpla plastic? How did Mashita and Baker manage to develop and commercialize the gunpla battle system within a year without raising any questions about where they came from? How did the giant Plavsky crystal find its way to Earth?
* Why are the gunpla enemies in the final episode dubbed bootlegs? If they were created by the company that holds a monopoly on gunpla and gunpla battling, aren't they just a new entry to the Gundam universe rather than cheap knockoffs?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because as their "inventor", Mashita can name them whatever the hell he wants to. Plus "Plavsky" sounds cool.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What exactly does the PPSE works team do? They have at least an entire lab full of people, and yet they seem to turn out very little work. The A5 unit was in development for months and still completely unfinished, and then Allan and the Meijin were able to get the Amazing Exia from that state to 80% complete (already an excellent gunpla in its own right) in a week, and then upgrade it to the completed Amazing Exia with another week's time. Then the Meijin (under mind control, granted) was able to convert that into the Exia Dark Matter in less than a day. Why do the members of the works team still have jobs?

to:

* What exactly does the PPSE works team do? They have at least an entire lab full of people, and yet they seem to turn out very little work. The A5 unit was in development for months and still completely unfinished, and then Allan and the Meijin were able to get the Amazing Exia from that state to 80% complete (already an excellent gunpla in its own right) in a week, and then upgrade it to the completed Amazing Exia with another week's time. Then the Meijin (under mind control, granted) was able to convert that into the Exia Dark Matter in less than a day. Why do the members of the works team still have jobs?jobs?
** It's possible that, as with any unit within a company, developing Gunpla for the tournament isn't all that the scientists there do and they might have other responsibilities as well (e.g. developing the GP bases and other equipment used for Gunpla battles).
** Or it could simply be a matter of bureaucracy within the company keeping talented individuals with great ideas from standing out. The same thing has already happened in the real world in motorsports such as Formula 1 where, back in the late 60s and 70s, the factory team from Ferrari was losing out to smaller British teams simply because talented designers could thrive in the latter but not the former.

Top