Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / GuardiansoftheGalaxy

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** We also don't know what standard he's comparing his lifespan ''against''. Quill may not have "much of a lifespan" compared to the rest of the cast, either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Why would the Collector need Rocket? He's already got a FunnyAnimal in his collection. They drink martinis together in TheStinger.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

8




to:

**Rocket does indeed comment about Groot regrowing limbs, pun intended. They may have been through enough scuffles for Rocket to have observed this. Perhaps Groot explained the regeneration from any situation from small-talk fun fact to "if anything should happen to me, do this." Knowledge would not necessarily soothe Rocket in the event of watching your buddy smashed to kindling, or even reassure said kindling could regenerate. Still, Rocket could give it a shot. Another possibility is Nova Corps knew just enough of the species (having some information on his rap sheet) to mention it to Rocket, or, being the plant geeks they seem to be, just said it was worth a shot. I personally like to think Dey suggested it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**I assumed everyone had the option of a cell. Gamora easily found one, the guards later instruct prisoners to return to their cells, which I assume to be the same as Gamora's. We even see Quill chatting in a similar cell with the gentleman with the much-required prosthetic leg. This all begs the questions, why then sleep in a pile if cells were available? And, Why did Gamora brave leaving her cell?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Or whatever translator takes into account the cultural representations of that planet and translates based on that so wherever Yondu is from is kind of close to Southern-America on his planet. It kind of reminds me of a story I heard about [[TheTerminator The Terminator]] when it was going to be dubbed into German Arnold Schwarzenegger being Austrian asked to do his voice in German. The people in charge, however, said no because they thought he sounded like a farmer. Now obviously to English speakers Arnold Schwarzenegger sounds nothing like a farmer but presumably if you I had some kind of Sci-Fi translator he'd sound like [[https://youtu.be/ScELaXMCVis?t=35 this.]]

to:

** Or whatever translator takes into account the cultural representations of that planet and translates based on that so wherever Yondu is from is kind of close to Southern-America on his planet. It kind of reminds me of a story I heard about [[TheTerminator The Terminator]] when it was going to be dubbed into German Arnold Schwarzenegger being Austrian asked to do his voice in German. The people in charge, however, said no because they thought he sounded like a farmer. Now obviously to English speakers Arnold Schwarzenegger sounds nothing like a farmer but presumably if you I had some kind of Sci-Fi translator he'd sound like [[https://youtu.be/ScELaXMCVis?t=35 this.]]

Changed: 483

Removed: 482

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Or whatever translator takes into account the cultural representations of that planet and translates based on that so wherever Yondu is from is kind of close to Southern-America on his planet.
It kind of reminds me of a story I heard about [[TheTerminator The Terminator]] when it was going to be dubbed into German Arnold Schwarzenegger being Austrian asked to do his voice in German. The people in charge, however, said no because they thought he sounded like a farmer. Now obviously to English speakers Arnold Schwarzenegger sounds nothing like a farmer but presumably if you I had some kind of Sci-Fi translator he'd sound like [[https://youtu.be/ScELaXMCVis?t=35 this.]]

to:

** Or whatever translator takes into account the cultural representations of that planet and translates based on that so wherever Yondu is from is kind of close to Southern-America on his planet.
planet. It kind of reminds me of a story I heard about [[TheTerminator The Terminator]] when it was going to be dubbed into German Arnold Schwarzenegger being Austrian asked to do his voice in German. The people in charge, however, said no because they thought he sounded like a farmer. Now obviously to English speakers Arnold Schwarzenegger sounds nothing like a farmer but presumably if you I had some kind of Sci-Fi translator he'd sound like [[https://youtu.be/ScELaXMCVis?t=35 this.]]

Added: 677

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I always thought that because Peter's mother has a southern accent he mentally associated that with parental figure. Yondou is the closet one he had for the past twenty plus years. So his translator implant mentally gives Youndu his father figure one , that he carried throughout the movie.

to:

** I always thought that because Peter's mother has a southern accent he mentally associated that with the parental figure. Yondou is the closet one he had for the past twenty plus years. So his translator implant mentally gives Youndu his father figure one , one, that he carried throughout the movie. movie.
** Or whatever translator takes into account the cultural representations of that planet and translates based on that so wherever Yondu is from is kind of close to Southern-America on his planet.
It kind of reminds me of a story I heard about [[TheTerminator The Terminator]] when it was going to be dubbed into German Arnold Schwarzenegger being Austrian asked to do his voice in German. The people in charge, however, said no because they thought he sounded like a farmer. Now obviously to English speakers Arnold Schwarzenegger sounds nothing like a farmer but presumably if you I had some kind of Sci-Fi translator he'd sound like [[https://youtu.be/ScELaXMCVis?t=35 this.]]

Added: 291

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Who says that Ronan's army is enough to overthrow the Kree government? Remember that he flees when the Nova Corps are approaching the Kiln, and he feels he needs the Infinity Stone or Thanos's support to destroy Xandar. He's also a fanatic -- his enemy is Xandar, and he's just blinded to any option that doesn't amount to, "Attack Xandar."

to:

** Who says say[s that Ronan's army is enough to overthrow the Kree government? Remember that he flees when the Nova Corps are approaching the Kiln, and he feels he needs the Infinity Stone or Thanos's support to destroy Xandar. He's also a fanatic -- his enemy is Xandar, and he's just blinded to any option that doesn't amount to, "Attack Xandar."


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Why did Gamora get a private room?]]
* Why did Gamora get a private room with a door in the prison, when everybody else ended up sleeping in a cuddle puddle in the middle of the floor? She didn't seem to threaten or kill anyone for it, just walked in and closed the door.

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, just because we don't see them on-screen in this particular movie doesn't mean there aren't other races of Rocket's approximate stature somewhere in the galaxy.

to:

** * Also, just because we don't see them on-screen in this particular movie doesn't mean there aren't other races of Rocket's approximate stature somewhere in the galaxy.galaxy. Snip a hole in the pants for his tail and he's all set.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, just because we don't see them on-screen in this particular movie doesn't mean there aren't other races of Rocket's approximate stature somewhere in the galaxy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Quill was abducted at ''age six''. "Bitch" may simply be the nastiest swear-word he'd yet learned at the time. (Note that the film freely uses "a-hole", but does ''not'' use the full-length word.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Moreover, did ''the Collector'' have more in mind when he offered to buy Groot's carcass than just putting it in a display case?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He may have overheard the scientists who modified him talking among themselves about their "specimen's" characteristics and physiology, life expectancy included.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Since the sequel outright reveals who Peter's father is, this isn't a real Headscratcher anymore.


[[folder: Quill's father]]
* Is it supposed to be Thanos?
** Uh...no. They would have told him straight up if he was the son of the most powerful being in the universe that we know of.
** Pretty sure Thanos has enough clout that he wouldn't need to rely on a bunch of unreliable pirates to retrieve his son.
** Peter's mother also refers to his father as an "angel." Thanos is [[EvilOverlord about as far from an angel as you can get]], which eliminates him as a possibility unless she was lying or he assumed a different form.
** In the comics, Quill's father is not Thanos, he's [[spoiler:J'Son of Spartax, a member of a HumanAlien race who was stranded on Earth for a few months, fell for his mother, then left to become leader of his people. Most likely, they'll go with this guy rather than anyone else.]]
** Alternatively, they could go with Adam Warlock, who is basically Thanos' archnemesis.
** Or Starhawk, who fits most of the described traits and is also a Guardians ( 31st Century edition ) member in the comics.
** Word of God says that the large cocoon seen in the Collector's museum does contain Adam Warlock. This could explain why Quill's father never decided to investigate why the pirates he sent to pick up his son never came back. Since Quill was with the pirates for most of his childhood one would think that he would be an easy person to find, unless you were unable to move.
** I thought they were hinting at him being part Asgardian.
** WordOfGod says that they aren't going to follow the comics when it comes to Quill's father. So it's really anyone's guess as to whose progeny Quill will be.
** His father's a jackass, remember? And one who hires ''space pirates'' to bring him his kid. And very old, possibly of the race who created the Infinity Gems in the first place. Obviously the Collector.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




Added DiffLines:

** The Milano has a 3D printer that can spray complex alien circuitry out of a hose. Whose to say it can't repair a magnetic tape?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Seems indirectly confirmed by Film/GuardiansOfTheGalaxyVol2. The Milano can be repaired by spraying new circuitry out of a hose, which means it has a very advanced 3D printer. Coming up with new clothes may be as simple as spraying someone with said hose after loading the right model.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Guardian of the Galaxy Volume 2 gives another perspective on this issue. Namely, Rocket and Peter are not "half trained noobs," but some of the best pilots in the galaxy. That they may or may not have been experienced piloting the mining craft would have been a minor problem at most considering the sheer skill they have in general at piloting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** what about Loki? It's established in Thor 2 that the Asgard can get to this sector of the galaxy; it's also mentioned more than once that Loki has ways of getting around the World-tree that don't involve the Bifrost. He could very well have made trips to Midgard - in fact, given his personality and the fact that none of the other Asgard have been to Midgard in centuries, he is almost guaranteed to have done so! It wouldn't be OOC for Loki to fund some of his personal projects (and maybe a safehouse or two?) in the wider galaxy by picking up desired items in places he goes to quite easily but where others (like Yongu, and most of the Ravagers) wouldn't be able to easily blend in. After all... Loki did manage to wear an impeccably appropriate outfit for the opera in Berlin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I'd go with "asshole cheapskate". Just because he has the money to pay for a servant doesn't mean he'd actually ''use'' that money for that purpose. It's obvious the only thing he truly cares about is his collection (go figure), and he clearly hands out big rewards for items to add to it. A servant is just an unnecessary expense - why pay to have someone do all the menial jobs like cleaning cages when you can force someone to do it for free? It's not like with the bounty hunters (with whom he needs to keep a good working relationship in order to keep obtaining items for the collection); and even if the slaves want to escape or kill him, he clearly kept them terrified enough to stop them doing it until the opportunity was literally right in front of one of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Badass is no longer a trope


** Meta explanation: when Jim Starlin created her in the mid-70s, ruthless female heroes who were just as capable as male ones were still pretty rare in Marvel comics, so maybe Starlin wanted to emphasize what a BadAss she was? In-universe, Thanos raised Gamora as a living weapon, so maybe he also came up with the "most dangerous woman" legend and helped to spread it, so that people would fear Gamora even more?

to:

** Meta explanation: when Jim Starlin created her in the mid-70s, ruthless female heroes who were just as capable as male ones were still pretty rare in Marvel comics, so maybe Starlin wanted to emphasize what a BadAss Badass she was? In-universe, Thanos raised Gamora as a living weapon, so maybe he also came up with the "most dangerous woman" legend and helped to spread it, so that people would fear Gamora even more?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder: Why does the Collector have slaves instead of paid servants?]]
* Of course, this is only being asked because of what happened with the stone. Still, it seems like he should have the money to pay an actual servant who doesn't want to escape or kill him. Are good servants just that rare (understandable, it being a prison planet and all)? Is he just an asshole cheapskate?
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** That's assuming the rest of the prisoners even ''had'' ships. We have little idea how Xandarian law works, but the ship might be considered more like a personal effect and thus is stored and returned to the prisoner on completion of their sentence. Knowing the guards of the Kiln though it's most likely only there so they can sell it and split the profits.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One explanation in fanfiction is that someone defined "whore" to him as "someone who sells their body", which he took to mean mercenary work rather than sexual favours.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Rocket is not unique. There are lots of racoons on that planet called Earth. There are trees, too, but they can't walk and talk, so Groot is unique. Or no, after all there is [[Literature/TheLordOfTheRings another planet]] with trees that can also walk and talk, but they are not exactly space faring, and the Tolkien state keep them hidden.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It really wouldn't have made sense for him not to pay. He's interested in his collection and wants to expand it. Not paying the people bringing him stuff would make it harder to acquire more.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Yes, but in the example mentioned above he doesn't have any such objects, and yet he survives [[spoiler:Thanos']] attack.

to:

** Yes, but in the example mentioned above he doesn't have any such objects, and yet he survives [[spoiler:Thanos']] Thanos' attack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Meta explanation: when Jim Starlin created her in the mid-70s, ruthless female heroes who were just as capable as male ones were still pretty rare in Marvel comics, so maybe Starlin wanted to emphasize what a BadAss she was? In-universe, Thanos raised Gamora as a living weapon, so maybe he also came up with the "most dangerous women" legend and helped to spread it, so that people would fear Gamora even more?

to:

** Meta explanation: when Jim Starlin created her in the mid-70s, ruthless female heroes who were just as capable as male ones were still pretty rare in Marvel comics, so maybe Starlin wanted to emphasize what a BadAss she was? In-universe, Thanos raised Gamora as a living weapon, so maybe he also came up with the "most dangerous women" woman" legend and helped to spread it, so that people would fear Gamora even more?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Yes, but in the example mentioned above he doesn't have any such objects, and yet he survives [[spoiler:Thanos']] attack.


Added DiffLines:

** Meta explanation: when Jim Starlin created her in the mid-70s, ruthless female heroes who were just as capable as male ones were still pretty rare in Marvel comics, so maybe Starlin wanted to emphasize what a BadAss she was? In-universe, Thanos raised Gamora as a living weapon, so maybe he also came up with the "most dangerous women" legend and helped to spread it, so that people would fear Gamora even more?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** I'll raise this; I'm a drooling philistine who had ''never'' heard of Jackson Pollockand I still got it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Collector asks them "How would you like to get paid?", and when Rocket replies "Units", he opens a drawer full of the little bars that are seen elsewhere being used as currency, and takes some out to count. It looks like he was indeed about to honour the deal and pay them, but then his assistant takes Stones into her own hands...

Top