Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / GenshinImpact

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** An alternative to the Alcor would be Waveriders. They're a lot smaller and more mobile, hence why a big squadron was not present.

to:

** An alternative to the Alcor would be Waveriders. They're a lot smaller and more mobile, hence why a big squadron was not present.present.
* The Moonchase event confirms Xiao wasn't just exaggerating when he said he '''will''' be there if the Traveler calls their name, so why didn't the Traveler call them when they were in trouble in Inazuma then? There were plenty of moments they could have died but only survived due to luck or someone getting lucky and reacting quickly. His presence in the event was also for (in comparison with anarchy or the end of the world) quite trivial, so surely any far more important presence would be grounds for calling him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It has been theorized that Visions only work when exposed, since every single playable character has them exposed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As for how they got there, they could've taken the Alcor.

to:

** As for how they got there, they could've taken the Alcor.Alcor.
** An alternative to the Alcor would be Waveriders. They're a lot smaller and more mobile, hence why a big squadron was not present.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The secret may be the size of Gorou's squadron. It's quite small which is why they could move undetected. All the guards were also knocked out by Sara.

to:

** The secret may be the size of Gorou's squadron. It's quite small which is why they could move undetected. All the guards were also knocked out by Sara.Sara.
** As for how they got there, they could've taken the Alcor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Given that the Traveler was an integral part of her plans regarding Ei in the Archon Quest she might have kept tabs on him and found out about them going to the Fatui hideout and went there to look out for them and possibly acquire their cooperation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How did Gorou and Kazuha's squadron get in front of Tenshukaku ? Last time we heard of the Resistance, the war front was still at Yashiori Island. If they managed to infiltrate Inazuma City, how did they do so in Resistance uniform and no disguises at all ?

to:

* How did Gorou and Kazuha's squadron get in front of Tenshukaku ? Last time we heard of the Resistance, the war front was still at Yashiori Island. If they managed to infiltrate Inazuma City, how did they do so in Resistance uniform and no disguises at all ??
** The secret may be the size of Gorou's squadron. It's quite small which is why they could move undetected. All the guards were also knocked out by Sara.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Food for thought, but why doesn't the Traveler immediately go to Ayaka and relay Neko's request to restore the Asase Shrine? Not only is it the Yashiro Commission's duty to manage the shrines in Inazuma, but no doubt Ayaka would've been delighted to not only honor the Traveler's request but even advertise the Asase Shrine to the citizens of Inazuma, making the place a popular tourist spot.

to:

* Food for thought, but why doesn't the Traveler immediately go to Ayaka and relay Neko's request to restore the Asase Shrine? Not only is it the Yashiro Commission's duty to manage the shrines in Inazuma, but no doubt Ayaka would've been delighted to not only honor the Traveler's request but even advertise the Asase Shrine to the citizens of Inazuma, making the place a popular tourist spot.spot.
* How did Yae Miko just happen to know the Traveler was in the Delusion Factory when she rescued them from Scaramouche ? She later explicitly states she does not communicate with the Resistance.
* How did Gorou and Kazuha's squadron get in front of Tenshukaku ? Last time we heard of the Resistance, the war front was still at Yashiori Island. If they managed to infiltrate Inazuma City, how did they do so in Resistance uniform and no disguises at all ?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That Vision was originally a Masterless one given to her by her teacher. We see in Autumn Winds, Scarlet Leaves that dead visions keep their shell. So the original owner of Mona's Vision was from Mondstadt.

to:

** That Vision was originally a Masterless one given to her by her teacher. We see in Autumn Winds, Scarlet Leaves that dead visions keep their shell. So the original owner of Mona's Vision was from Mondstadt.Mondstadt.
* Food for thought, but why doesn't the Traveler immediately go to Ayaka and relay Neko's request to restore the Asase Shrine? Not only is it the Yashiro Commission's duty to manage the shrines in Inazuma, but no doubt Ayaka would've been delighted to not only honor the Traveler's request but even advertise the Asase Shrine to the citizens of Inazuma, making the place a popular tourist spot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mona traveling to Monstadt and having no residency there indicates she really isn't from there. So why does she have a Vision with the Monstadt decal?

to:

* Mona traveling to Monstadt and having no residency there indicates she really isn't from there. So why does she have a Vision with the Monstadt decal?decal?
** That Vision was originally a Masterless one given to her by her teacher. We see in Autumn Winds, Scarlet Leaves that dead visions keep their shell. So the original owner of Mona's Vision was from Mondstadt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's possible Gnoses aren't common knowledge. Venti had to share that information only when it was relevant, and the Fatui know about it because Signora had them retrieved.

to:

** It's possible Gnoses aren't common knowledge. Venti had to share that information only when it was relevant, and the Fatui know about it because Signora had them retrieved.retrieved, herself operating on the orders of the Tsaritsa, an Archon with such knowledge.



** Baron Bunnies are able to serve as a distraction and decoy target, as well as being able to activate some mechanisms that reaquire the weight of two people. For these reasons, there are benefits to crafting an autonomous explosive doll rather than just a basic bomb.

to:

** Baron Bunnies are able to serve as a distraction and decoy target, as well as being able to activate some mechanisms that reaquire require the weight of two people. For these reasons, there are benefits to crafting an autonomous explosive doll rather than just a basic bomb.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do the people who live in Inazuma wear their visions on public display despite the Vision Hunt Decree? Do they only work when exposed? A lot of RedShirt Vision bearers from Inazuma have pretty peaceful lives that don't involve combat, so why carry them at all?

to:

* Why do the people who live in Inazuma wear their visions on public display despite the Vision Hunt Decree? Do they only work when exposed? A lot of RedShirt Vision bearers from Inazuma have pretty peaceful lives that don't involve combat, so why carry them at all?all?
* Mona traveling to Monstadt and having no residency there indicates she really isn't from there. So why does she have a Vision with the Monstadt decal?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If the Fatui are from the clearly Russia-coded Snezhnaya, why are all the Harbingers named for the very Italian Commedia dell'Arte characters?

to:

* If the Fatui are from the clearly Russia-coded Snezhnaya, why are all the Harbingers named for the very Italian Commedia dell'Arte characters?characters?
* Why do the people who live in Inazuma wear their visions on public display despite the Vision Hunt Decree? Do they only work when exposed? A lot of RedShirt Vision bearers from Inazuma have pretty peaceful lives that don't involve combat, so why carry them at all?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding Spoilers-Off header on top.

Added DiffLines:

!Per wiki policy, Administrivia/SpoilersOff applies here and all spoilers are unmarked. Administrivia/YouHaveBeenWarned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If the Fatui are from the clearly Russia-coded Snezhnaya, why are all the Harbingers bearing Italian names?

to:

* If the Fatui are from the clearly Russia-coded Snezhnaya, why are all the Harbingers bearing named for the very Italian names?Commedia dell'Arte characters?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Baron Bunnies are able to serve as a distraction and decoy target, as well as being able to activate some mechanisms that reaquire the weight of two people. For these reasons, there are benefits to crafting an autonomous explosive doll rather than just a basic bomb.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do some characters carry their Visions behind their backs or dangling off their body? They could easily lose them if not secured properly to their person and visible from their perspective.

to:

* Why do some characters carry their Visions behind their backs or dangling off their body? They could easily lose them if not secured properly to their person and visible from their perspective.perspective.
* If the Fatui are from the clearly Russia-coded Snezhnaya, why are all the Harbingers bearing Italian names?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Given the fire and the wetness are expended instantly, it's not a case of putting out the fire, it's creating a steam burn/steam explosion, which can be pretty nasty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why are Treasure Hoarders called what they are? Both them and the Adventurers' Guild search for treasure and get to keep it so in a sense they both hoard treasure. The only difference is that Treasure Hoarders are willing to commit crimes, so why not just call them bandits?

to:

* Why are Treasure Hoarders called what they are? Both them and the Adventurers' Guild search for treasure and get to keep it so in a sense they both hoard treasure. The only difference is that Treasure Hoarders are willing to commit crimes, so why not just call them bandits?bandits?
* Klee being a child has every reason to make her explosives look like a plush toy. Amber, a grown adult, puts in the time to make Baron Bunnies which is more than just a regular doll. Wouldn't it be a waste of time and extra materials to decorate a bomb?
* Why do some characters carry their Visions behind their backs or dangling off their body? They could easily lose them if not secured properly to their person and visible from their perspective.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How does setting an enemy on fire and then dousing them with water cause 2x the damage? One would expect water to put out the fire...

to:

* How does setting an enemy on fire and then dousing them with water cause 2x the damage? One would expect water to put out the fire...fire...
* Why are Treasure Hoarders called what they are? Both them and the Adventurers' Guild search for treasure and get to keep it so in a sense they both hoard treasure. The only difference is that Treasure Hoarders are willing to commit crimes, so why not just call them bandits?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some weapons are specifically designed for defense of the user, such as a Main-gauche (to stop thrusting attacks) or a Swordbreaker Dagger (for parrying), while still being perfectly usable to attack an opponent (Altough rarely used for that purpose, they were mostly used in conjunction with an offensive weapon). It's not a stretch to imagine weapons such as Whiteblind were specifically designed with a "main" defensive purpose in mind, while still retaining some combat capabilities.

to:

** Some weapons are specifically designed for defense of the user, such as a Main-gauche (to stop thrusting attacks) or a Swordbreaker Dagger (for parrying), while still being perfectly usable to attack an opponent (Altough rarely used for that purpose, they were mostly used in conjunction with an offensive weapon). It's not a stretch to imagine weapons such as Whiteblind were specifically designed with a "main" defensive purpose in mind, while still retaining some combat capabilities.capabilities.
* How does setting an enemy on fire and then dousing them with water cause 2x the damage? One would expect water to put out the fire...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some weapons are specifically designed for defense of the user, such as a Main-gauche (to stop thrusting attacks) or a Swordbreaker Dagger (for parrying), while still being perfectly usable to attack an opponent. It's not a stretch to imagine weapons such as Whiteblind were specifically designed with a "main" defensive purpose in mind, while still retaining some combat capabilities.

to:

** Some weapons are specifically designed for defense of the user, such as a Main-gauche (to stop thrusting attacks) or a Swordbreaker Dagger (for parrying), while still being perfectly usable to attack an opponent.opponent (Altough rarely used for that purpose, they were mostly used in conjunction with an offensive weapon). It's not a stretch to imagine weapons such as Whiteblind were specifically designed with a "main" defensive purpose in mind, while still retaining some combat capabilities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How do weapons increase DEF In-Universe? All weapons have a base attack, which is reasonable. ATK, CRIT DMG and CRIT Rate, and Energy Recharge indicate a weapon is more helpful in certain aspects of combat such as being more powerful, easier to hit weak points, replenish one's energy more, etc. Gameplay aside, how do the Whiteblind, White Iron Greatsword, and Traveler's Handy Sword improve someone's defensive capabilities?

to:

* How do weapons increase DEF In-Universe? All weapons have a base attack, which is reasonable. ATK, CRIT DMG and CRIT Rate, and Energy Recharge indicate a weapon is more helpful in certain aspects of combat such as being more powerful, easier to hit weak points, replenish one's energy more, etc. Gameplay aside, how do the Whiteblind, White Iron Greatsword, and Traveler's Handy Sword improve someone's defensive capabilities?capabilities?
**Some weapons are specifically designed for defense of the user, such as a Main-gauche (to stop thrusting attacks) or a Swordbreaker Dagger (for parrying), while still being perfectly usable to attack an opponent. It's not a stretch to imagine weapons such as Whiteblind were specifically designed with a "main" defensive purpose in mind, while still retaining some combat capabilities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why does refining forged weapons require a duplicate? It's understandable if the weapon were one you didn't forge and found from treasure, but here you have raw materials so why not use that directly?

to:

* Why does refining forged weapons require a duplicate? It's understandable if the weapon were one you didn't forge and found from treasure, but here you have raw materials so why not use that directly?directly?
* How do weapons increase DEF In-Universe? All weapons have a base attack, which is reasonable. ATK, CRIT DMG and CRIT Rate, and Energy Recharge indicate a weapon is more helpful in certain aspects of combat such as being more powerful, easier to hit weak points, replenish one's energy more, etc. Gameplay aside, how do the Whiteblind, White Iron Greatsword, and Traveler's Handy Sword improve someone's defensive capabilities?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In We Will be Reunited, why does Dain charge right after Lumine and the Abyss Herald while carrying the eye of the First Tiller, knowing full well that it should not fall in the hands of the Abyss ?
* Similarly, Aether does not destroy the Defiled Statue at the end of the quest, even though that was the reason he returned to the ruins with Dainsleif.

to:

* In We Will be Reunited, why does Dain charge right after Lumine the Prince/ess and the Abyss Herald while carrying the eye of the First Tiller, knowing full well that it should not fall in the hands of the Abyss ?
Abyss?
* Similarly, Aether the Traveler does not destroy the Defiled Statue at the end of the quest, even though that was the reason he they returned to the ruins with Dainsleif.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
First Person Writing is not allowed, not even on the Headscratchers pages. There's currently a cleanup effort to remove any instances of First-Person Writing on both the Headscratcher and WMG pages.


* Why does refining forged weapons require a duplicate? I understand if the weapon were one you didn't forge and found from treasure, but here you have raw materials so why not use that directly?

to:

* Why does refining forged weapons require a duplicate? I understand It's understandable if the weapon were one you didn't forge and found from treasure, but here you have raw materials so why not use that directly?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's possible Gnoses aren't common knowledge. Venti had to share that information only when it was relevant, and the Fatui know about it because Signora had them retrieved.

to:

** It's possible Gnoses aren't common knowledge. Venti had to share that information only when it was relevant, and the Fatui know about it because Signora had them retrieved.retrieved.
* Why does refining forged weapons require a duplicate? I understand if the weapon were one you didn't forge and found from treasure, but here you have raw materials so why not use that directly?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why did the Traveler not warn Zhongli (or anyone else in Liyue) that the Fatui has been stealing the archons' Gnosises, even after seeing Venti get attacked and learning this information from Venti? He/She was obviously suspicious of Childe from the get-go that he would try to steal Rex Lapis' Gnosis from his Exuvia, shouldn't they have warned someone about it?

to:

* Why did the Traveler not warn Zhongli (or anyone else in Liyue) that the Fatui has been stealing the archons' Gnosises, even after seeing Venti get attacked and learning this information from Venti? He/She was obviously suspicious of Childe from the get-go that he would try to steal Rex Lapis' Gnosis from his Exuvia, shouldn't they have warned someone about it?it?
** Because the Traveler didn't know Zhongli was Morax. Besides, he peacefully made a contract with the Fatui before Traveler even arrived in Liyue, so that one had no hope of recovery.
** It's possible Gnoses aren't common knowledge. Venti had to share that information only when it was relevant, and the Fatui know about it because Signora had them retrieved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why did the Traveler not warn Zhongli (or anyone else in Liyue) that the Fatui has been stealing the archons' Gnosises, even after seeing Venti get attacked and learning this information from Venti? He/She was obviously suspicious of Childe from the get-go, shouldn't they have warned someone about it?

to:

* Why did the Traveler not warn Zhongli (or anyone else in Liyue) that the Fatui has been stealing the archons' Gnosises, even after seeing Venti get attacked and learning this information from Venti? He/She was obviously suspicious of Childe from the get-go, get-go that he would try to steal Rex Lapis' Gnosis from his Exuvia, shouldn't they have warned someone about it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Similarly, Aether does not destroy the Defiled Statue at the end of the quest, even though that was the reason he returned to the ruins with Dainsleif.

to:

* Similarly, Aether does not destroy the Defiled Statue at the end of the quest, even though that was the reason he returned to the ruins with Dainsleif.Dainsleif.
* Why did the Traveler not warn Zhongli (or anyone else in Liyue) that the Fatui has been stealing the archons' Gnosises, even after seeing Venti get attacked and learning this information from Venti? He/She was obviously suspicious of Childe from the get-go, shouldn't they have warned someone about it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In We Will be Reunited, why does Dain charge right after Lumine and the Abyss Herald while carrying the eye of the First Tiller, knowing full well that it should not fall in the hands of the Abyss ?
* Similarly, Aether does not destroy the Defiled Statue at the end of the quest, even though that was the reason he returned to the ruins with Dainsleif.

Top