Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Eyeshield21

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope reworked; see Flawless Token


* All the PositiveDiscrimination Panther gets. I love Panther, I think he's awesome, but really, does people (Sena and Apollo to name two examples) have to start rambling about the superiority of black men in football when it comes to him? I realize Sena has certain physiological limits that Panther doesn't, but...there has to be a better way to say it.
** Even before Panther was introduce people treated the Americans like genetic freak, saying that only Taiyou would stand a chance against the muscle of the american. Plus the world cup arc is ridiculous in how the U.S team are portrayed as born to be perfect player so it's not like Panther stands out that much. Plus you have guys like Gaou, Kakei and Agon who got that same rambling about how their physical ability make them better than everyone else why Panther, who is black but also the guy who ran on rooftops as training, would have no one recognizing that he is a natural sprinter?

to:

* All the PositiveDiscrimination positive discrimination Panther gets. I love Panther, I think he's awesome, but really, does people (Sena and Apollo to name two examples) have to start rambling about the superiority of black men in football when it comes to him? I realize Sena has certain physiological limits that Panther doesn't, but...there has to be a better way to say it.
** Even before Panther was introduce introduced, people treated the Americans like genetic freak, saying that only Taiyou would stand a chance against the muscle of the american. Plus the world cup arc is ridiculous in how the U.S team are portrayed as born to be perfect player so it's not like Panther stands out that much. Plus you have guys like Gaou, Kakei and Agon who got that same rambling about how their physical ability make them better than everyone else why Panther, who is black but also the guy who ran on rooftops as training, would have no one recognizing that he is a natural sprinter?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed links to illegal manga scan sites.


*** [[http://mangafox.me/manga/eyeshield_21/c053/11.html that's his first appearance]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
link to illegal scanslation site


** Sena is canonically bad at English, Mamori translated most of it for him during death march (http://www.mangareader.net/eyeshield-21/83/5), the Gunman coach is an English teacher so he might have taught the team. Not clear why Panther and Sena can understand themselves after being drunk though.

to:

** Sena is canonically bad at English, Mamori translated most of it for him during death march (http://www.mangareader.net/eyeshield-21/83/5), march, the Gunman coach is an English teacher so he might have taught the team. Not clear why Panther and Sena can understand themselves after being drunk though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is actually mentioned in Investigations File 64. The principal decided to not list all the numbers in order.

Changed: 4

Removed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>

to:

\n<<|ItJustBugsMe|>>----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Well yes, narrative convenience is obviously the ''correct'' answer, but that goes for 90% of ''all'' {{Headscratchers}}. In-universe, there's no good reason, you're just [[BellisariosMaxim not supposed to think about it]]. But since the series makes such a big deal of how the Devil Bats' super-offensive style being because they can only ever get 6 points from each touchdown and can't get field goals, it's really just one of the series' bigger {{Plot Hole}}s.

to:

*** Well yes, narrative convenience is obviously the ''correct'' answer, but that goes for 90% of ''all'' {{Headscratchers}}.[[Headscratchers/HomePage Headscratchers]]. In-universe, there's no good reason, you're just [[BellisariosMaxim not supposed to think about it]]. But since the series makes such a big deal of how the Devil Bats' super-offensive style being because they can only ever get 6 points from each touchdown and can't get field goals, it's really just one of the series' bigger {{Plot Hole}}s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They probably forfeited after knowing [[TheDreaded Hiruma]] is there? Besides, even if no one gets rejected, there should be a limit of how many students a school can have in a year.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Something I never quite understood is why Panther's speed is magnified to an extent beyond reason. He's only a tenth of a second faster than Sena over 40 yards, yet he's always portrayed as being [[TheFlash the goddamn Flash]]. A great example- in the Xmas Bowl game, Yamato was able to stop Sena cold in a head to head every time, but in the World Cup Match, despite having the same power as Sena and only a LITTLE BIT more speed, Panther's able to burn past Yamato like he's not even there. I realize the "I can't catch up" factor, but some of it's just ridiculous.

to:

* Something I never quite understood is why Panther's speed is magnified to an extent beyond reason. He's only a tenth of a second faster than Sena over 40 yards, yet he's always portrayed as being [[TheFlash [[Franchise/TheFlash the goddamn Flash]]. A great example- in the Xmas Bowl game, Yamato was able to stop Sena cold in a head to head every time, but in the World Cup Match, despite having the same power as Sena and only a LITTLE BIT more speed, Panther's able to burn past Yamato like he's not even there. I realize the "I can't catch up" factor, but some of it's just ridiculous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Okay so we know that no one got rejected from Deimon due to a low number of applicants so why, when Sena goes to check if he got in do we see that applicants 231, 232, 233, 234, 022, 072, 073, and 074 apparently failed to get in?

Added: 328

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sena is canonically bad at English, Mamori translated most of it for him during death march (http://www.mangareader.net/eyeshield-21/83/5), the gunman coach is an English teacher so he might have taught the team. Not clear why Panther and sena can understand themselves after being drunk though.

to:

** Sena is canonically bad at English, Mamori translated most of it for him during death march (http://www.mangareader.net/eyeshield-21/83/5), the gunman Gunman coach is an English teacher so he might have taught the team. Not clear why Panther and sena Sena can understand themselves after being drunk though.



** Panther had never actually played a game of real football until the Deimon game. While he is known to jump from rooftop to rooftop, Eyeshield was written before recording videos with your phone was commonplace so there's no way anyone Panther could've been recruited by another football team prior to the events of the story.



** His racism toward black is purely because of Morgan but like mr.Don it might be more national racism than Asian with the Japanese.

to:

** His racism toward black blacks is purely because of Morgan but like mr.Mr. Don it might be more national racism than Asian with the Japanese.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Source? And that also doesn't make much sense because the Christmas Bowl is an actual event in Japan, so the structure of tournament can't simply be retconned. Plus, Ojou has never won the spring tournament anyways, Shinryuuji always does. It's also mentioned pretty early on that the Christmas Bowl is important because it's the only time the Kanto champs get to face the Kansai champs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even before Panther was introduce people treated the Americans like genetic freak, saying that only Taiyou would stand a chance against the muscle of the american. Plus the world cup arc is ridiculous in how the U.S team are portrayed as born to be perfect player so it's not like Panther stands out that much.

to:

** Even before Panther was introduce people treated the Americans like genetic freak, saying that only Taiyou would stand a chance against the muscle of the american. Plus the world cup arc is ridiculous in how the U.S team are portrayed as born to be perfect player so it's not like Panther stands out that much. Plus you have guys like Gaou, Kakei and Agon who got that same rambling about how their physical ability make them better than everyone else why Panther, who is black but also the guy who ran on rooftops as training, would have no one recognizing that he is a natural sprinter?



** His racism toward black is purely because of Morgan but like mr.Don it might be more national racism than asian with the Japanese.

to:

** His racism toward black is purely because of Morgan but like mr.Don it might be more national racism than asian Asian with the Japanese.

Added: 48

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's covered in the anime that Hiruma does the kick, it just never goes in. You just see him kicking and missing. And Deimon does not have enough stamina to go two point conversion with the line all up until the christmas Bowl where Kurita can take the whole line down. Otherwise they can just sack hiruma by going through the holes in the line. It's more risky burning Sena for 2 points than keeping him fresh for scoring another touchdown.

to:

* It's covered in the anime that Hiruma does the kick, it just never goes in. You just see him kicking and missing. And Deimon does not have enough stamina to go two point conversion with the line all up until the christmas Bowl where Kurita can take the whole line down. Otherwise they can just sack hiruma Hiruma by going through the holes in the line. It's more risky burning Sena for 2 points than keeping him fresh for scoring another touchdown.


Added DiffLines:

** He wears wigs if his hair isn't how he wants.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I think they gave point off-screen, it mostly served to underline how awesome a moment was for the secondary characters (and by that point Sena's awesomeness was obvious)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*The whole set-up of the mvp score system. Panther wins the MVP title and the 3 million dollar football contract, but in the manga, he's shown to earn 3 points for the MVP title, something that both Monta and Agon also accomplish. Sena for some reason earns zero despite proving himself Panther's equal in the match.

Added: 317

Changed: 55

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sena is canonically bad at English, Mamori translated most of it during death march, the gunman coach is an English teacher so he might have taught the team. Not clear why Panther and sena can understand themselves after being drunk though.

to:

** Sena is canonically bad at English, Mamori translated most of it for him during death march, march (http://www.mangareader.net/eyeshield-21/83/5), the gunman coach is an English teacher so he might have taught the team. Not clear why Panther and sena can understand themselves after being drunk though.


Added DiffLines:

** His racism toward black is purely because of Morgan but like mr.Don it might be more national racism than asian with the Japanese.


Added DiffLines:

*** Because he is even more racist toward Japanese, to the point where he thought it would be a massacre. Deimon was never considered a threat for him that's why he took an insane bet.

Added: 244

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Do the Japanese characters speak English or not? At certain points, Watt has to translate between members of the Devils and the NASA team, but later we see Panther and Sena interact seemingly without a language barrier. Several chapters later, when the Deimon team is in America, the 'Devil's Gunmen' seem to understand that the announcer of the beach contest dubbed them the 'Happy-Go-Lucky Team', and the Kid and another Gunman take offense at her remark about him being old. It's hard to tell whether there's supposed to be any language barrier at all. (Of course, it probably goes without saying that Hiruma understands English pretty well and can speak it- he lived in the US and has several conversations with people who don't know any Japanese. I'm mainly asking about the characters in scenes he's not part of.)

to:

* Do the Japanese characters speak English or not? At certain points, Watt has to translate between members of the Devils and the NASA team, but later we see Panther and Sena interact seemingly without a language barrier. Several chapters later, when the Deimon team is in America, the 'Devil's Gunmen' seem to understand that the announcer of the beach contest dubbed them the 'Happy-Go-Lucky Team', and the Kid and another Gunman take offense at her remark about him being old. It's hard to tell whether there's supposed to be any language barrier at all. (Of course, it probably goes without saying that Hiruma understands English pretty well and can speak it- he lived in the US and has several conversations with people who don't know any Japanese. I'm mainly asking about the characters in scenes he's not part of.)of.
** Sena is canonically bad at English, Mamori translated most of it during death march, the gunman coach is an English teacher so he might have taught the team. Not clear why Panther and sena can understand themselves after being drunk though.

Added: 821

Changed: 75

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Do the Japanese characters speak English or not? At certain points, Watt has to translate between members of the Devils and the NASA team, but later we see Panther and Sena interact seemingly without a language barrier. Several chapters later, when the Deimon team is in America, the 'Devil's Gunmen' seem to understand that the announcer of the beach contest dubbed them the 'Happy-Go-Lucky Team', and the Kid and another Gunman take offense at her remark about him being old. It's hard to tell whether there's supposed to be any language barrier at all. (Of course, it probably goes without saying that Hiruma understands English pretty well and can speak it- he lived in the US and has several conversations with people who don't know any Japanese. I'm mainly asking about the characters in scenes he's not part of.)



* If Apollo is a racist who seems to resent everybody that isn't white, why does he have no issues with letting the Gonzales brothers play? Perhaps I'm simply reading too much into it, but given that both brothers have tan skin and the last name Gonzales, they are most likely Hispanic, and it seems uncharacteristic of Apollo to let them play with no strings attached.

to:

* If Apollo is a racist who seems to resent everybody that isn't white, why does he have no issues with letting the Gonzales brothers play? Perhaps I'm simply reading too much into it, but given that both brothers have tan skin and the last name Gonzales, they are most likely Hispanic, and it seems uncharacteristic of Apollo to let them play with no strings attached. Then again, perhaps he only resents black and Asian people in particular?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* If Apollo is a racist who seems to resent everybody that isn't white, why does he have no issues with letting the Gonzales brothers play? Perhaps I'm simply reading too much into it, but given that both brothers have tan skin and the last name Gonzales, they are most likely Hispanic, and it seems uncharacteristic of Apollo to let them play with no strings attached.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** But if Apollo thought Panther was a superior player to the men on his own team, then why did he not even pay for Panther to come to Japan with them? Even if he is a racist jerkass, wouldn't Apollo want to have the best possible chance of beating the Deimons? He could've paid Panther's way, at the very least.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Seibu's safety doesn't make much sense. By the book it is true that a run is safer than a pass but Kid is too fast to get sacked and Tetsuma would be able to catch a short pass to get out of the end zone.

Added: 401

Changed: 103

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even before Panther was introduce people treated the Americans like genetic freak, saying that only Taiyou would stand a chance against the muscle of the american. Plus the world cup arc is ridiculous in how the U.S team are portrayed as born to be perfect player so it's not like Panther stands out that much.



* It's covered in the anime that Hiruma does the kick, it just never goes in. You just see him kicking and missing. And Deimon does not have enough stamina to go two point conversion with the line all up until the christmas Bowl where kurita can take the whole line down. Otherwise they can just sack hiruma by going through the holes in defense.

to:

* It's covered in the anime that Hiruma does the kick, it just never goes in. You just see him kicking and missing. And Deimon does not have enough stamina to go two point conversion with the line all up until the christmas Bowl where kurita Kurita can take the whole line down. Otherwise they can just sack hiruma by going through the holes in defense.the line. It's more risky burning Sena for 2 points than keeping him fresh for scoring another touchdown.


Added DiffLines:

**** [[http://mangafox.me/manga/eyeshield_21/c053/11.html that's his first appearance]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Is Tatanka good at aerial battle? He is a linebacker who probably never had to jump to intercept a ball.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He does but it's ¸one panel where it shows yards gain. no point in having nobody catching the ball being a main event.

Top