Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / DominicDeegan

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Chaos has a wierd sense of humor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
removing outdated markup


* Come to think of it, Dominic's opinions that Callan is a racist and corrupt regime also JustBugsMe. From what little is shown of Callan in the comics, Callan, while far from perfect, is quite tolerant of other races. Orcs and other races are allowed to live there and make a decent living. Melna lives in Callan because she wanted to ''escape'' the brutality of Maltak. Heck, the ''royal seer'' was an Orc. From what we've seen of Maltak, Orcish society is much more brutal, especially to women. And you don't see any Callanians (or any other race) being allowed to live or work there either. One of the tribe's (admittedly one that even the other Orcs don't like) foreign policy boils down to "kill on sight". Yet Dominic holds Orcs in a higher regard than Callanians simply because he's pen pals with an Orc.

to:

* Come to think of it, Dominic's opinions that Callan is a racist and corrupt regime also JustBugsMe.regime. From what little is shown of Callan in the comics, Callan, while far from perfect, is quite tolerant of other races. Orcs and other races are allowed to live there and make a decent living. Melna lives in Callan because she wanted to ''escape'' the brutality of Maltak. Heck, the ''royal seer'' was an Orc. From what we've seen of Maltak, Orcish society is much more brutal, especially to women. And you don't see any Callanians (or any other race) being allowed to live or work there either. One of the tribe's (admittedly one that even the other Orcs don't like) foreign policy boils down to "kill on sight". Yet Dominic holds Orcs in a higher regard than Callanians simply because he's pen pals with an Orc.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It could always hide out in the plane made entirely out of Chaos. Would also explain why the Demon Lord of Chaos wouldn't show up to try to grab the souls of the Chosen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I think that part of the point of the lack of lead up with the comic or Dominic's manipulation until the end was for us as the readers to not see what was coming. All in all, I never really understood what people hated so much about the comic in general or this arc specifically. Yes, it was silly and juvenile. I got the impression it was supposed to be. The comic is one that makes fun of and openly snarks itself and a multitude of characters have even expressed as such, openly and often. The thing I liked about this series is that it lets all of the characters grow and develop and become stronger--not just the main one. From the girlfriend to the family to the other characters they meet--everyone has some growth and issues to work out. Keep in mind that Greg has, throughout the whole of the comic up to this point, been a rather juvenile person. It was a regular part of his character from the beginning. It's part of the reason Pam broke up with him, after all. When upset, he'd hide in couch forts. If at all possible, he'd try to avoid hurting anyone or allowing anyone to be harmed. His plan to get money involved drawings of himself praying for money to fall from the or selling off organs he kind of needs to live. He was in a lot of ways, child like. And what do kids generally tend to want to be? A super hero. So yes, the Superman expy was actually fairly fitting of him. And stupid. People in the comic have even expressed how stupid it was. It was Greg living out a fantasy of his that actually ended up 1) reminding him of who he wanted to be, 2) kept him from becoming something he definitely did NOT want to be, and 3) through its silliness, ended up resolving what could very well have been a terrible situation (albeit one that they admittedly could have solved in a number of other, less silly ways). Also, looking back, it sort of served as his last hurrah, given what happened later with the Infernomancer and the Beast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Dominic's superior Seer abilities probably would allow him to punch right through any "loss of sensation". But I guess we'll not know unless there is ever a character to objects to "protection scroll" use who isn't a CompleteMonster.

to:

*** Dominic's superior Seer abilities probably would allow him to punch right through any "loss of sensation". But I guess we'll not know unless there is ever a character to objects to "protection scroll" use who isn't a CompleteMonster.Monster.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It's magic, an element that exists within DominicDeegan and not in the real world, so we have no idea how the spell itself might work. Perhaps it works by affecting the man's "magic wand", which could very easily affect sensation. For instance, it could dull the feeling in your special area a bit. As for Dominic not minding, the key factor here is that he loves Luna. Not only does that make him more willing to sacrifice part of the good feelings sex delivers, but some say that sex with someone you love is the best kind.

to:

*** It's magic, an element that exists within DominicDeegan Webcomic/DominicDeegan and not in the real world, so we have no idea how the spell itself might work. Perhaps it works by affecting the man's "magic wand", which could very easily affect sensation. For instance, it could dull the feeling in your special area a bit. As for Dominic not minding, the key factor here is that he loves Luna. Not only does that make him more willing to sacrifice part of the good feelings sex delivers, but some say that sex with someone you love is the best kind.



*** That analogy doesn't really fit Greg's situation. Gregory isn't some guy who's never been in a fight and doesn't have any sort of special powers...even before Super Greg, you ''already knew'' that Greg for all intents and purposes had superpowers via his White Magic, and was experienced in using them. He could fly, give himself super strength, make himself invincible, heal from just about any injury...honestly, he was a superhero in everything but costume and setting. And DominicDeegan has, from the start, basically been an analog to the modern world, only with magic taking the place of technology in a lot of places. So while I can see how it might be jarring and more than a little silly to go into a comic book homage/parody, I still don't see how it's a wall banger. It's a kid with superpowers doing exactly what you'd expect a kid with superpowers to do.\\

to:

*** That analogy doesn't really fit Greg's situation. Gregory isn't some guy who's never been in a fight and doesn't have any sort of special powers...even before Super Greg, you ''already knew'' that Greg for all intents and purposes had superpowers via his White Magic, and was experienced in using them. He could fly, give himself super strength, make himself invincible, heal from just about any injury...honestly, he was a superhero in everything but costume and setting. And DominicDeegan Webcomic/DominicDeegan has, from the start, basically been an analog to the modern world, only with magic taking the place of technology in a lot of places. So while I can see how it might be jarring and more than a little silly to go into a comic book homage/parody, I still don't see how it's a wall banger. It's a kid with superpowers doing exactly what you'd expect a kid with superpowers to do.\\

Changed: 458

Removed: 423

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That was just plain rude. Please avoid that kind of thing in the future.


** For the same reason fat girls don't just eat healthily and exercise to lose the weight? [[Main/TakeThat Oh, wait, was that too much of a cheap shot for some people?]] </sarcasm>
*** that actually might be a lead on it. It's not unheard of that jealous and cruel mothers will deliberately sabotage an overweight daughter's efforts to lose weight; a similar situation could have been at play with Luna and her mother. Perhaps instilling an irrational fear of alterists in her daughter, so that she wouldn't get her problem corrected and mommy dearest could keep working the "ugly daughter" angle on her.

to:

** For the same reason fat girls don't just eat healthily and exercise to lose the weight? [[Main/TakeThat Oh, wait, was that too much of a cheap shot for some people?]] </sarcasm>
*** that There actually might be a lead on it. It's not unheard of that jealous and cruel mothers will deliberately sabotage an overweight daughter's efforts to lose weight; a similar situation could have been at play with Luna and her mother. Perhaps instilling an irrational fear of alterists in her daughter, so that she wouldn't get her problem corrected and mommy dearest could keep working the "ugly daughter" angle on her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Just to interject: Quilt ''does'' look a lot like a Mongrelperson, just less deformed. People might assume that's what he is, or at least that he spent time in the Wild Edge and was affected by the magic there. Presumably, he doesn't smell like rotting corpses, so if he ''is'' the only flesh golem in existence, most people would probably assume he was something else entirely. Admittedly, people outside of Barthis would probably remark on his appearance, but how often does he get out of town?

to:

**** Just to interject: Quilt ''does'' look a lot like a Mongrelperson, just less deformed. People might assume that's what he is, or at least that he spent time in the Wild Edge and was affected by the magic there. Presumably, he doesn't smell like rotting corpses, so if he ''is'' the only flesh golem in existence, most people would probably assume he was something else entirely. (And if flesh golems are more common than we've seen, well, how many of them are friendly, human-sized, and have free will?) Admittedly, people outside of Barthis would probably remark on his appearance, but how often does he get out of town?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Just to interject: Quilt ''does'' look a lot like a Mongrelperson, just less deformed. People might assume that's what he is, or at least that he spent time in the Wild Edge and was affected by the magic there. Presumably, he doesn't smell like rotting corpses, so if he ''is'' the only flesh golem in existence, most people would probably assume he was something. Admittedly, people outside of Barthis would probably remark on his appearance, but how often does he get out of town?

to:

**** Just to interject: Quilt ''does'' look a lot like a Mongrelperson, just less deformed. People might assume that's what he is, or at least that he spent time in the Wild Edge and was affected by the magic there. Presumably, he doesn't smell like rotting corpses, so if he ''is'' the only flesh golem in existence, most people would probably assume he was something.something else entirely. Admittedly, people outside of Barthis would probably remark on his appearance, but how often does he get out of town?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**** Just to interject: Quilt ''does'' look a lot like a Mongrelperson, just less deformed. People might assume that's what he is, or at least that he spent time in the Wild Edge and was affected by the magic there. Presumably, he doesn't smell like rotting corpses, so if he ''is'' the only flesh golem in existence, most people would probably assume he was something. Admittedly, people outside of Barthis would probably remark on his appearance, but how often does he get out of town?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** A recent strip proved that "friend" theory. Basically, Dominic and Luna get married and send out a spell to tell all their friends and family. Dominic mentions that the message for Brian didn't get through, that it "went dark". Then, we see a panel of Rillian holding a tiny version of the message spell. He really does care.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** I think it was to serve as a reminder. The curse was his way of forcing the Callans to remember the war. Also, given the general disdain and even fear that many had towards the Orcs, seeing their own children with the number one defining feature of the Orcish people was probably enough to freak them out.

to:

*** I think it was to serve as a reminder. The curse was his way of forcing the Callans to remember the war. Also, given war and the atrocities committed. Damaske "The Butcher" had a habit of collecting the teeth of orcs he had slain and wearing them as trophies. When he confronted Damaske, Thuen even made a foreshadowing CallBack about the curse, noting the teeth and telling him that he'd be seeing more of them at Callan, meaning that Thuen knew exactly what the curse would do and planned it that way. Given the general disdain and even fear that many had towards the Orcs, seeing their own children with the number one defining feature of the Orcish people was probably enough to freak them out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Exactly. She never actually sacrificed a child. What happened was that she's lost the chance to get pregnant, which she never was in the first place if what they said about Dominic was true. It was never even a choice on her part, it was a result of what was done TO her because of Neilen's attack. That she's not shutting herself away and refusing to live over the children she will not have and instead, actually took measures to help OTHERS who were originally unable to have kids says a lot about her character. Besides, WordOfGod stated that though Luna may not be able to get pregnant, that doesn't mean that she will not be a mother.


Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

** People who were desperate or had no issues with them used alterists. Others tore their own teeth out. All of them ended up feeling like "something" was wrong afterwards.

Added: 1753

Changed: 367

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** And light and darkness.



** The thing is, Luna originally didn't care about her tusks. Flashbacks show that she liked how she looked as a kid. Hell, the alterist her mother called in refused to do anything to Luna because she was happy with the tusks. It was only after years of her self-esteem being crushed that she wanted to change and her mother refused to let her as some sort of payback. By the time Luna was in any real position to DO anything about her tusks, she had made real friends and rebuilt her self-esteem enough that she didn't care to. Which kind of helped with the whole "restoration of Maltak" bit.






*** Let's keep in mind that while Reinholdt has been shown to be a decent person now, it was Dominic's prediction that probably helped to get him that way. He DID make that comment about Luna that suggested a racist attitude towards orcs, something that has been shown to be a major issue throughout the comic, especially given that the torture and horrible treatment of those people was what doomed Siegfried and his father to ending up in hell.



*** I think it was to serve as a reminder. The curse was his way of forcing the Callans to remember the war. Also, given the general disdain and even fear that many had towards the Orcs, seeing their own children with the number one defining feature of the Orcish people was probably enough to freak them out.



*** What she seemed most upset about was that it sounded as though Luna was saying her own life was meaningless without a guy. Though that wasn't what Luna meant, it would probably hit home with Melna that most, if not all of the horrible things that have happened to her are because of that belief that a woman is worthless or is somehow not a woman if she does not have a man.










to:

** Actually, Rillian was even called out on this by one of the others in on his "plan". It was meant to help Dominic relax and prevent mindbreak, but it was also a chance for Rillian to be "Brian" again. And maybe to get to know Dominic and Luna as a friend instead of as the powerful Necromancer who'd have to call on them to help save the world again at some point.

Top