Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / CourageTheCowardlyDog

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Honestly? I think this is so very plausible in ths show's universe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There could be a few explanations for this:

to:

*** * There could be a few explanations for this:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** '''[[Film/MuppetTreasureIsland POLITICS! POLITICS!]]'''
** Speaking of the villains, what’s up with the lineup they chose? Sure, Katz and Le Quack were pretty much mandatory choices, but the rest make little to no sense. The Cajun Fox and Clutching Foot were killed in their respective episodes, the Weremole is a feral beast with no concept of revenge, and while the Queen of the Black Puddle has a bit more reason, in that Courage stopped her from eating Eustace, that very reasoning makes it all the more baffling that Eustace would recruit her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***I remember one episode (I think it was ''Angry Nasty People'') when Muriel mentioned wanting to tell someone that they'd be on TV, so they probably do, which is supposin' she wasn't talking about any friends that she or Eustace might have.


Added DiffLines:

**Another important thing about Eustace, besides him being an idiot, is his pride. He probably does know Courage saves Muriel and his lives behind the scenes but he's not gonna be one to admit it.


Added DiffLines:

***Actually, "Nowhere" is the town they live in. That being said, they've lived in that part of Nowhere for so long that they're not set on going anywhere else.


Added DiffLines:

***There could be a few explanations for this:
## She and Eustace so happened to have the same last name, which wouldn't be too strange, considering that the latter's relatives (Horst, Ikket, and Ma) also share the same last name of "Bagge" and surnames aren't that unique.
##Continuity Error. Perhaps, in the earlier drafts, her married name was intended to be something else but that didn't carry over to the show.


Added DiffLines:

**''Aqua Farmer'' probably came before the Evil Empress episode, canon-wise.

Changed: 254

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** ...the horsemen require nighttime or some other specific timeframe in order to emerge in the first place, regardless of how the windmill stops.

to:

*** ...the horsemen require nighttime or some other specific timeframe in order to emerge in the first place, regardless of how the windmill stops.stops, due to them being undead. It was a really dark night in the episode that they appear; in "Little Muriel" for instance, it was daytime (and a really stormy one) which probably wasn't a good time for them to appear lest they get destroyed by the elements.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another possibility besides Negative Continuity is that either:
*** ...the windmill would have to stop on its own for this to happen rather than someone else making it stop. For instance when the windmill is stopped by the Goose God, a probable reason for the horsemen not appearing is that they either fear the Goose God, think that he will destroy their enemies for them so they don't bother, or otherwise just don't want to join the fray.
*** ...the horsemen require nighttime or some other specific timeframe in order to emerge in the first place, regardless of how the windmill stops.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So... Mad Dog was ''prostituting'' Bunny? I remember either listening to or reading a review/recap of "The Mask", and the reviewer pointed out prostitution as a GettingCrapPastTheRadar moment for when we see Mad Dog and his accomplices return to their hideout with Bunny, to whom, Mad Dog says, "Move yer tail, Bunny!" Maybe I'm naive and not familiar with a lot of that stuff, but is, "Move yer tail," ''really'' some kind of prostitution terminology/phrase/euphemism/whatever? When I was a kid, I simply took it as Mad Dog basically telling Bunny to hurry up and get out of the car and come back inside as if she were just sitting there in the car, or taking too long getting out.

to:

* So... Mad Dog was ''prostituting'' Bunny? I remember either listening to or reading a review/recap of "The Mask", and the reviewer pointed out prostitution as a GettingCrapPastTheRadar moment for when we see Mad Dog and his accomplices return to their hideout with Bunny, to whom, Mad Dog says, "Move yer tail, Bunny!" Maybe I'm naive and not familiar with a lot of that stuff, but is, "Move yer tail," ''really'' some kind of prostitution terminology/phrase/euphemism/whatever? When I was a kid, I simply took it as Mad Dog basically telling Bunny to hurry up and get out of the car and come back inside as if she were just sitting there in the car, or taking too long getting out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It doesn't help that according to "Everybody wants to direct" the Bagge Farm was built over a graveyard and Von Volkheim's carcass was buried in that very graveyard. And so just like the movie ''Film/{{Poltergeist}}'', a house that is built over a graveyard is going to attract evil supernatural stuff that would turn Winston Zeddmore white... literally!

to:

** It doesn't help that according to "Everybody wants to direct" the Bagge Farm was built over a graveyard and Von Volkheim's carcass was buried in that very graveyard. And so just like the movie ''Film/{{Poltergeist}}'', ''Film/{{Poltergeist|1982}}'', a house that is built over a graveyard is going to attract evil supernatural stuff that would turn Winston Zeddmore white... literally!

Added: 362

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**He either has teeth and they aren't seen or they're worn down or he wears dentures.



* A minor headscratcher, but in "Dr. Le Quack, Amnesia Specialist", how was Murial still able to know how to play the sitar after losing her memory?
** Skills-in particular those requiring developing specific neuromuscular (which is often inaccurately referred to as muscle memory) that require specific movements-tend to be the on part of the human brain that degrades the last. This is specifically true if the skillset involved was one that requires a lot of mind-body coordination and agility to perform. There are stories of elderly people with dementia who suddenly stand up from their chair and start dancing in the public areas of the rest homes a style they once did frequently in their youth. And with incredible finesse and grace as though they had been preparing for a live performance for weeks. I heard of an incident of an ex-wrestler who killed his housemate unintentionally because his brain system still remembered the techniques and did it automatically when the other elderly touched him in a certain manner. People with sevre brain damage and extremely bad cases of amnesia still remember basic functions such as eating food with a spoon even if they have degraded to the point of retardation and disabled. So Muriel remembering how to play an instrument is not unrealistic at all. Especially since she played a string instrument which requires a hell lot of hand-midn coordination and speedy flexible movements than most activities.

to:

* A minor headscratcher, but in "Dr. Le Quack, Amnesia Specialist", how was Murial Muriel still able to know how to play the sitar after losing her memory?
** Skills-in particular those requiring developing specific neuromuscular (which is often inaccurately referred to as muscle memory) that require specific movements-tend to be the on part of the human brain that degrades the last. This is specifically true if the skillset involved was one that requires a lot of mind-body coordination and agility to perform. There are stories of elderly people with dementia who suddenly stand up from their chair and start dancing in the public areas of the rest homes a style they once did frequently in their youth. And with incredible finesse and grace as though they had been preparing for a live performance for weeks. I heard of an incident of an ex-wrestler who killed his housemate unintentionally because his brain system still remembered the techniques and did it automatically when the other elderly touched him in a certain manner. People with sevre severe brain damage and extremely bad cases of amnesia still remember basic functions such as eating food with a spoon even if they have degraded to the point of retardation and disabled. So Muriel remembering how to play an instrument is not unrealistic at all. Especially since she played a string instrument which requires a hell lot of hand-midn hand-mind coordination and speedy flexible movements than most activities.


Added DiffLines:

***A previous troper mentioned something about how they came to the idea that Eustace asked the operator for the numbers of who might hate a little pink dog, so that might explain how he got the number of Cajun Fox.


Added DiffLines:

**The Bagges don't seem to have the best memory if that helps.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing pointless natter.


** NegativeContinuity and/or RuleOfDrama. Besides, most fans dislike that episode anyway, so you probably shouldn't defend it.

to:

** NegativeContinuity and/or RuleOfDrama. Besides, most fans dislike that episode anyway, so you probably shouldn't defend it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Eustace doesn't have any teeth at all, so how is he still able to eat stuff like burgers, a lobster, etc?
----

Added: 4

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** I took his shapeshifting as more like a fantasy version of gesticulating, so he's not really shapeshifting, he's gesticulating but it looks like shapeshifting to the viewer.

to:

*** I ***I took his shapeshifting as more like a fantasy version of gesticulating, so he's not really shapeshifting, he's gesticulating but it looks like shapeshifting to the viewer.



** According to Wikipedia and some archaeological evidence, some of the Mayan funeral rituals (by the Classic period) were like mummification in the sense of wrapping their dead, sealing them in a tomb, and the like, so there were mummies, just not like Egyptian mummies (which were embalmed).

to:

** According **According to Wikipedia and some archaeological evidence, some of the Mayan funeral rituals (by the Classic period) were like mummification in the sense of wrapping their dead, sealing them in a tomb, and the like, so there were mummies, just not like Egyptian mummies (which were embalmed).


Added DiffLines:

----

Added: 605

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----



----



----



----



----



----



----



----



----



----



----



----



-----



----



----



----



***I took his shapeshifting as more like a fantasy version of gesticulating, so he's not really shapeshifting, he's gesticulating but it looks like shapeshifting to the viewer.
----



-----



----



-----



----



----



----



** She's cheap ( in more than one sense of the word). Eustace had to get it somewhere.

to:

** She's cheap ( in (in more than one sense of the word). Eustace had to get it somewhere.somewhere.
----



----



**According to Wikipedia and some archaeological evidence, some of the Mayan funeral rituals (by the Classic period) were like mummification in the sense of wrapping their dead, sealing them in a tomb, and the like, so there were mummies, just not like Egyptian mummies (which were embalmed).
----



----



----



-----



----



----



----




to:

----


Added DiffLines:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** NegativeContinuity and/or RuleOfDrama. Besides, most fans dislike that episode anyway, so you probably shouldn't defend it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, Courage is a dog living in America. Perhaps, he thought the Red Army would be more ruthless, and therefore, more ''effective'' in dealing with the threat Kitty presented.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, she ''did'' eat that huge, expanding carrot in one sitting, once... ''The whole thing.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Also, it is outright destroyed when Conway crashes his plane on it as well. No horsemen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They literally live in the middle of Nowhere. It's probably hard to find other houses or it would be too hard to move.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's most likely NegativeContinuity, but then again, lots of people hate this episode anyway.


Added DiffLines:

*** Yes, he finally had a cameo in "Crossover Nexus"!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved from fridge

Added DiffLines:


* Eustace called in the Cajun Fox along with the rest of the villains in "Ball Of Revenge", despite the fact that the Cajun Fox episode was the only episode Eustace doesn't appear in. And he also calls in The Big Toe, even though he himself was The Big Toe.
** About half the villains Eustace teamed up with tried to kill him.
* The banana salesman appears in a later Katz episode even though he's supposed to be stuck in the next millennium.
** Fridge brilliance, they've invented time travel a thousand years from the show's present time, he just hitched a ride back.
* Benton Tarantella's first appearance is in Season 1, specifically the episode "Everyone Wants to Direct". A season or two later, he returns in "Angry Nasty People". Granted the show routinely dips into NegativeContinuity but considering he was wearing the same outfit and ''didn't even bother disguising himself'' the second time, one has to wonder how nobody seemed too perturbed to be reunited with a zombie who tried to kill and eat Muriel in his first appearance. Moreover, how did he get out of the hole he was buried in without anyone noticing?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the episode "The Transplant" how on Earth did Dr. Vindaloo remove the kangaroo monster bone from a now transformed-Courage, if said monsters are impervious to all harm other than that caused by another kangaroo monster?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** Eustace and Muriel, despite their flaws, do show cases of AwLookTheyReallyDoLoveEachOther throughout the series. Eustace isn't evil so much as he is a cranky old man who takes out his frustrations and insecurities (Remember, his mother was quite abusive towards him and he pretty much lived in the shadow of his more-successful late brother) on Courage. For example, in the episode ''Evil River'' he asks if Muriel being the "bait" for Carmen (the MonsterOfTheWeek) was safe hinting that he wouldn't go through with it if he thought Muriel was in any real danger. Likewise, in an episode involving vengeful widow ghost (I forget the name of said episode) Courage helps pull their marriage back together (due to said ghost trying to separate Eustace and Muriel by making Eustace think that Muriel was trying to kill him) and they are shown to be quite happy together. Not only that, but in the same episode, Eustace's Mother (who teams up with said ghost) says that Muriel is a terrible wife with Eustace retorting "You don't know what you're talking about" showing that, despite his JerkAss behavior towards her, he does care for her deep down inside. Plus, I've always seen ''Ball Of Revenge'' as '''HORRIBLY''' [[CharacterDerailment out of character]] for Eustace since, throughout most of the series, he was pretty much apathetically indifferent towards Courage rather than downright hating him...especially since earlier episodes actually showed that Eustace would (though reluctantly, and mostly for money) help Courage with some of his plans ("Kick 'em in the dishpan hoo hoo hoo?").

to:

** Eustace and Muriel, despite their flaws, do show cases of AwLookTheyReallyDoLoveEachOther throughout the series. Eustace isn't evil so much as he is a cranky old man who takes out his frustrations and insecurities (Remember, his mother was quite abusive towards him and he pretty much lived in the shadow of his more-successful late brother) on Courage. For example, in the episode ''Evil River'' he asks if Muriel being the "bait" for Carmen (the MonsterOfTheWeek) was safe hinting that he wouldn't go through with it if he thought Muriel was in any real danger. Likewise, in an episode involving vengeful widow ghost (I forget the name of said episode) Courage helps pull their marriage back together (due to said ghost trying to separate Eustace and Muriel by making Eustace think that Muriel was trying to kill him) and they are shown to be quite happy together. Not only that, but in the same episode, Eustace's Mother (who teams up with said ghost) says that Muriel is a terrible wife with Eustace retorting "You don't know what you're talking about" showing that, despite his JerkAss behavior towards her, he does care for her deep down inside. Plus, I've always seen ''Ball Of Revenge'' as '''HORRIBLY''' [[CharacterDerailment out of character]] character for Eustace since, throughout most of the series, he was pretty much apathetically indifferent towards Courage rather than downright hating him...especially since earlier episodes actually showed that Eustace would (though reluctantly, and mostly for money) help Courage with some of his plans ("Kick 'em in the dishpan hoo hoo hoo?").
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She probably doesn't have anything better to do, if she's still alive. If that sounds too logical, there's (again) the status quo...

to:

** She probably doesn't have anything better to do, do now that she's no longer the empress; if she's still alive. If that sounds too logical, there's (again) the status quo...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
My own explanation...

Added DiffLines:

** She probably doesn't have anything better to do, if she's still alive. If that sounds too logical, there's (again) the status quo...

Top