Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / CloseEncountersOfTheThirdKind

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Null edit

Added DiffLines:

** Just because the two movies' time gap of launching is quite close does not imply these two are canonly interconnected.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Considering that the aliens have abducted many people in the past, there must be a time where the aliens managed to obtain some info about Earth Geometry from one of their subjects.

to:

** Considering that the aliens have abducted many people in the past, there must be a time where the aliens managed to obtain some info about Earth Geometry from one of their subjects.subjects.
* Roy drives his car from Indiana to UsefulNotes/{{Wyoming}}, but one scene while he is in Wyoming shows his car to have a Wyoming license plate.
** The book cleared this up; he flew to Wyoming and rented a car there.
*** He even states offhandedly in the movie that it's "just a rental".
** Also note, Ronnie already took the station wagon earlier, so the one in Wyoming couldn't be Roy's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Longitude coordinates already mentioned


** But isn't it funny that obviously the aliens also determined independently that 0 degrees longitude would run through Greenwich? That's the only way the coordinates would mean anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Speaking of latitude and longitude, how did the aliens come up with longitudinal coordinates to match our own? For latitude, there's a well-defined astronomical equator, i.e. the section perpendicular to the sun during the equinoxes, so it's plausible they would have been able to come up with latitudinal coordinates that matched ours by using the equator as their zero. In contrast, there is no "natural" zero for longitude, it's arbitarily set to the position of Greenwich in England. There's absolutely no reason the aliens would have picked this as their longitudinal zero.

to:

* Speaking of latitude and longitude, how did the aliens come up with longitudinal coordinates to match our own? For latitude, there's a well-defined astronomical equator, i.e. the section perpendicular to the sun during the equinoxes, so it's plausible they would have been able to come up with latitudinal coordinates that matched ours by using the equator as their zero. In contrast, there is no "natural" zero for longitude, it's arbitarily set to the position of Greenwich in England. There's absolutely no reason the aliens would have picked this as their longitudinal zero.zero.
** Considering that the aliens have abducted many people in the past, there must be a time where the aliens managed to obtain some info about Earth Geometry from one of their subjects.

Top