Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / BuffytheVampireSlayer

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


***** In Angel's case, he explicitly states that, even though he has his human soul back, the demon half of him is still inside of him and his current persona is an amalgam of the two. Liam may be the dominant half, but Angelus is still in there and still active. He DID do all the things he was blamed for and enjoyed every moment of it, but getting Liam back gave him back his guilt and inhibitions. As shown in the episode with the starlet that tried to [[ItMakesSenseInContext reverse vampire date rape him]], it was shown that he's capable of Angelus style acts if his inhibitions are removed, soul or no soul.

to:

***** In Angel's case, he explicitly states that, even though he has his human soul back, the demon half of him is still inside of him and his current persona is an amalgam of the two. Liam may be the dominant half, but Angelus is still in there and still active. He DID do all the things he was blamed for and enjoyed every moment of it, but getting Liam back gave him back his guilt and inhibitions. As shown in the episode with the starlet that tried to [[ItMakesSenseInContext reverse vampire date rape him]], it was shown that he's capable of cheerfully performing Angelus style acts if his inhibitions are removed, soul or no soul.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Of course, Angel is aware of an entire species of mercenary demons whose blood turns vampires humans in even very small doses. Granted, its not said to give back the original souls, but one wonders why he didn't try and scrounge up the money (especially as the head of Wolfram and Hart) to hire them for a blood drive or something, on the grounds that sociopathic humans are a lot easier to incarcerate/kill than sociopathic metahumans who can pass that condition on to others. Maybe they're just cautious about the blood being used against them via sympathetic magic or something?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***** In Angel's case, he explicitly states that, even though he has his human soul back, the demon half of him is still inside of him and his current persona is an amalgam of the two. Liam may be the dominant half, but Angelus is still in there and still active. He DID do all the things he was blamed for and enjoyed every moment of it, but getting Liam back gave him back his guilt and inhibitions. As shown in the episode with the starlet that tried to [[ItMakesSenseInContext reverse vampire date rape him]], it was shown that he's capable of Angelus style acts if his inhibitions are removed, soul or no soul.

Added: 655

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** And it's specifically Christian crosses. There was some episode where Willow made a reference to having to hide the crosses from her Jewish family, so obviously non-Christian symbols don't have the same effect. And it seems (unless Plot deems otherwise) that only crosses specifically invoked as a defensive measure worked (otherwise vampires would definately not be hanging around graveyards, Christian crosses are all over the place)
**** Unlikely. Spike seems to be harmed by a cross in a church in season 7, after he's resouled. I doubt that cross was put there for defensive purposes (although with sunnydale, you never know)

to:

*** And it's specifically Christian crosses. There was some episode where Willow made a reference to having to hide the crosses from her Jewish family, so obviously non-Christian symbols don't have the same effect. And it seems (unless Plot deems otherwise) that only crosses specifically invoked as a defensive measure worked (otherwise vampires would definately not be hanging around graveyards, Christian crosses are all over the place)
place).
**** Unlikely. Spike seems to be harmed by a cross in a church in season 7, after he's resouled. I doubt that cross was put there for defensive purposes (although with sunnydale, you never know)know).
**** I'm guessing that the "Christianity appropriated pre-existing anti-vampire rites and artifacts" view is most likely correct. Crosses in general and Crucifixions in specific predated Christ by a good deal, so maybe someone noticed that vampires never tried to turn anyone on a cross and decided to run with it.


Added DiffLines:

***** Though the fact that having a soul effects the vampires one sires suggests that the human side does have at least a tiny bit of influence on vampirism, and humans are theoretically a constantly evolving species. It would at least lead to vampires having different mental capabilities and initial physical structures as time goes on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They might have put a soundproofing spell on their bedroom to keep from freaking out their housemates. Still probably a bad idea in a town like Sunnydale, but hey they might have been high on magic or something equally silly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** One wonders how come a bunch of guys trying to amp Buffy's Slayer powers is portrayed as near rape (starting to go down to waist level after it failed to get in through her nose/mouth), but Willow activating potential Slayers all over the world without their permission is portrayed in a much more empowering fashion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** The're three of the Master's known followers, and apparently dangerous ones. He's just got to their entry in The Big Book of Vampires.

to:

**** The're They're three of the Master's known followers, and apparently dangerous ones. He's just got to their entry in The Big Book of Vampires.



*** How does Buffy "bear half the blame" for her relationship with Riley failing? ''He'' is the one who couldn't cope with his girlfriend being stronger and more durable than he was; ''he'' is the one who decided to try and find what she saw so attractive in the night...by going out and getting suckjobs from vampire whores. And he bitches that he's not getting any attention from her when she clearly has a hell of a lot on her plate already, what with her mother being seriously ill ''and'' a hellgod being after her sister.
Buffy, on the other hand...tried to hold back on her strength and act more feminine, to try and ease the concern she could sense from him. She was openly devoted to him and never cheated on him (despite her mixed feelings about Spike; in fact, her main argument when Riley admits that he's jealous after Angel breezes through Sunnydale is "have I ever given you any reason not to trust me?"). She tried to cut back on the slaying, to try and treat it as just a job (the way it was to him) but failed because it's ''not'' a job for her - it's a calling; she can't just roll over and sleep after hitting a quota for area patrolled and vamps staked for the night, she has to know that she staked all the vamps she could find and covered all the ground she could that night. And when her mom got sick ''and'' Glory started gunning for her sister? She acted the way she normally does under stress: she closed down and withdrew from just about everyone. Everyone else knows she reacts this way and refuses to let her withdraw from them; Riley...just sat around and moped and whined.

to:

*** How does Buffy "bear half the blame" for her relationship with Riley failing? ''He'' is the one who couldn't cope with his girlfriend being stronger and more durable than he was; ''he'' is the one who decided to try and find what she saw so attractive in the night...by going out and getting suckjobs from vampire whores. And he bitches that he's not getting any attention from her when she clearly has a hell of a lot on her plate already, what with her mother being seriously ill ''and'' a hellgod being after her sister.
sister. Buffy, on the other hand...tried to hold back on her strength and act more feminine, to try and ease the concern she could sense from him. She was openly devoted to him and never cheated on him (despite her mixed feelings about Spike; in fact, her main argument when Riley admits that he's jealous after Angel breezes through Sunnydale is "have I ever given you any reason not to trust me?"). She tried to cut back on the slaying, to try and treat it as just a job (the way it was to him) but failed because it's ''not'' a job for her - it's a calling; she can't just roll over and sleep after hitting a quota for area patrolled and vamps staked for the night, she has to know that she staked all the vamps she could find and covered all the ground she could that night. And when her mom got sick ''and'' Glory started gunning for her sister? She acted the way she normally does under stress: she closed down and withdrew from just about everyone. Everyone else knows she reacts this way and refuses to let her withdraw from them; Riley...just sat around and moped and whined.whined.
*** Buffy doesn't bear half the blame, or even a quarter of the blame, but she did handle the situation poorly. That's in character for her, though: when Buffy is in love, she throws herself into it completely, practically without reservation. She shouldn't have tried to "feminize" herself for him, and shouldn't have tried to slay less to assuage his insecurities. But it's understandable that she would, because that's what she does.



** Buffy and Riley spend basically half their time together having lots and lots of sex. It gets them into trouble sometimes, but as they are in college, and therefore horny, screwin' happens a lot. Xander having sex with Faith in "The Zeppo" didn't exactly cost him. Furthermore, Willow sleeping with Oz before the Apocalypse-of-the-Week was obviously a healthy and natural progression of their relationship (he refused to until they were both ready), Willow sleeping with Tara was almost always portrayed positively (it would've been a bit off to try to claim to be so progressive by showing lesbians as main characters if their sex consistently led to [[PhychoLesbian disaster]] -- and before you mention it, the sex in "Seeing Red" wasn't what drove Willow off the edge, it was Tara, y'know, dying), and Willow sleeping with Kennedy had no negative consequences ([[TakeThat other than]] [[TheWesley Kennedy]] being there). In summation, when Buffy has sex it's tragic and/or dramatic, when Xander has sex it's funny, and when Willow has sex it's romantic. Considering the characters and their roles in the show, it fits.

to:

** Buffy and Riley spend basically half their time together having lots and lots of sex. It gets them into trouble sometimes, but as they are in college, and therefore horny, screwin' happens a lot. Xander having sex with Faith in "The Zeppo" didn't exactly cost him. Furthermore, Willow sleeping with Oz before the Apocalypse-of-the-Week was obviously a healthy and natural progression of their relationship (he refused to until they were both ready), Willow sleeping with Tara was almost always portrayed positively (it would've been a bit off to try to claim to be so progressive by showing lesbians as main characters if their sex consistently led to [[PhychoLesbian [[PsychoLesbian disaster]] -- and before you mention it, the sex in "Seeing Red" wasn't what drove Willow off the edge, it was Tara, y'know, dying), and Willow sleeping with Kennedy had no negative consequences ([[TakeThat other than]] [[TheWesley Kennedy]] being there). In summation, when Buffy has sex it's tragic and/or dramatic, when Xander has sex it's funny, and when Willow has sex it's romantic. Considering the characters and their roles in the show, it fits.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Buffy and Riley spend basically half their time together having lots and lots of sex. It gets them into trouble sometimes, but as they are in college, and therefore horny, screwin' happens a lot. Xander having sex with Faith in "The Zeppo" didn't exactly cost him. Furthermore, Willow sleeping with Oz before the Apocalypse-of-the-Week was obviously a healthy and natural progression of their relationship (he refused to until they were both ready), Willow sleeping with Tara was almost always portrayed positively (it would've been a bit off to try to claim to be so progressive by showing lesbians as main characters if their sex consistently led to [[PhychoLesbian disaster]] -- and before you mention it, the sex in "Seeing Red" wasn't what drove Willow off the edge, it was Tara, y'know, dying), and Willow sleeping with Kennedy had no negative consequences ([[TakeThat other than]] [[TheWesley Kennedy]] being there). In summation, when Buffy has sex it's tragic and/or dramatic, when Xander has sex it's funny, and when Willow has sex it's romantic. Considering the characters and their roles in the show, it fits.

Added: 1604

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In Riley's defense, Buffy vears at least half the blame.

to:

*** In Riley's defense, Buffy vears bears at least half the blame.


Added DiffLines:

*** How does Buffy "bear half the blame" for her relationship with Riley failing? ''He'' is the one who couldn't cope with his girlfriend being stronger and more durable than he was; ''he'' is the one who decided to try and find what she saw so attractive in the night...by going out and getting suckjobs from vampire whores. And he bitches that he's not getting any attention from her when she clearly has a hell of a lot on her plate already, what with her mother being seriously ill ''and'' a hellgod being after her sister.
Buffy, on the other hand...tried to hold back on her strength and act more feminine, to try and ease the concern she could sense from him. She was openly devoted to him and never cheated on him (despite her mixed feelings about Spike; in fact, her main argument when Riley admits that he's jealous after Angel breezes through Sunnydale is "have I ever given you any reason not to trust me?"). She tried to cut back on the slaying, to try and treat it as just a job (the way it was to him) but failed because it's ''not'' a job for her - it's a calling; she can't just roll over and sleep after hitting a quota for area patrolled and vamps staked for the night, she has to know that she staked all the vamps she could find and covered all the ground she could that night. And when her mom got sick ''and'' Glory started gunning for her sister? She acted the way she normally does under stress: she closed down and withdrew from just about everyone. Everyone else knows she reacts this way and refuses to let her withdraw from them; Riley...just sat around and moped and whined.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Yeah. Because he's a vampire. I'm not saying that he was a fluffy little bunny; Spike was a remorseless, sadistic killer. But that's not all he was. He wasn't a good guy, but he still ''did good.'' Consciously, by his own free will, for more reasons than "because it might get me a bit of Slayer tail."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** IOW, he was a sociopath, and can do things beneficial to the people around him as long as it falls into his whims. The moment those whims change, or as long as he thinks he can get away with it, he'd still revel in the opportunity to commit sadistic acts of murder.


Added DiffLines:

**** ''They're'' the ones who worship a lady called [[MeaningfulName Glorificus]]. Maybe the vanity isn't new and they thought it was deep enough that she'd be fine with exhibitionism as long as she was properly primped beforehand, or something.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** IIRC, the official Whedonverse definition of a vampire is a human whose soul has been kicked out and then had their corpse possessed by a specific type of demon. Presumably, that demon is the soul and he doesn't have his human soul anymore. OTOH, it would be pretty interesting to find out that, at some point, someone tried to neuter him by giving him back his mortal soul... only to find out that it didn't even slow him down for a second.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****The're three of the Master's known followers, and apparently dangerous ones. He's just got to their entry in The Big Book of Vampires.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**The OP kind of hit on something. It's a form of Hollywood Atheism. If there's a higher power he/she/it is making them put their lives on the line constantly and never freely giving help. Why would they worship he/she/it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Merrick appears in "Becoming," in a flashback.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It wouldn't be that big and messy. Vampires don't have a pulse, so their blood is just kind of there; it wouldn't pour out like it would with a human. The hole in the vampire's shirt would be relatively small, or at least small enough that moving his arms would probably cover the mark in his flesh. Besides, an inch-wide hole just isn't that visible, especially if it closed when the stake was removed, as puncture wounds often do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Evolution necessitates mutation. As far as we can tell, being sired by a vampire means acquiring all the standard strengths and weaknesses of vampirism, even with exceptional circumstances. Drusilla, for example, sired Spike, but he doesn't acquire any of her extra superpowers. Nor does Darla, who was sired by the Master. The only exception is Sam Lawson, sired when Angel had a soul and thus unable to take sadistic pleasure in the various vampiric atrocities, but that was an exceptionally unique case, and we don't know if Sam would have passed his "condition" down if he had sired anyone else. In short, vampires can't evolve because vampirism never changes: being sired is being sired, and you always get the same situation afterwards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The problem is that Angel wasn't ''done'' suffering. He'd just stopped for a second. By phrasing their spell in such a way that his soul would be dismissed if he ever got happy for a second, it meant that he ''would'' be done suffering, since there would be nothing left ''to'' suffer. Even if it was "vengeance" rather than "justice," it was damn stupid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** That doesn't mean he was incapable of good. He turned his mother out of love for her, he stayed utterly and selflessly devoted to Drusilla for more than a century, and after trying to rape Buffy, was repentant enough to go through the Demon Trials. He was capable of good beyond good as a means to an end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The monks thought of nail-polish and make-up? I like that answer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I always thought that the cross and holy water and whatnot were made symbols of divinity 'because' of their ability to repel vampires. How this explains why older religions don't have anti-vampire divine objects is beyond me.

to:

** I always thought that the cross and holy water and whatnot were made symbols of divinity 'because' *because* of their ability to repel vampires. How this explains why older religions don't have anti-vampire divine objects is beyond me.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I always thought that the cross and holy water and whatnot were made symbols of divinity "because" of their ability to repel vampires. How this explains why older religions don't have anti-vampire divine objects is beyond me.

to:

** I always thought that the cross and holy water and whatnot were made symbols of divinity "because" 'because' of their ability to repel vampires. How this explains why older religions don't have anti-vampire divine objects is beyond me.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I always thought that the cross and holy water and whatnot were made symbols of divinity "because" of their ability to repel vampires. How this explains why older religions don't have anti-vampire divine objects is beyond me.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** I thought it was pretty clear that he cared about Dawn in a sort of big brother sort of way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The way I always looked at it (remembering that Whedon said it was meant to be totally random) was that it was sort of a nice tie-in to the rest of the dream elements to make them something the viewers can easier relate to. For example: In most dreams, no matter how linear or how much sense they make, there's usually one or two elements that don't really make sense no matter how you slice it. Thus, we have the dreams experienced by Buffy and the Scoobies, which given the plot line and progression of the episode, make sense in at least some basic way - there's something violent and angry that wants them all to die - and then you get this batshit crazy "cheese guy" vision out of nowhere. My two cents, anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Yeah, but no one but him knew that. They didn't find out he was a vampire until he left that night.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In the episode of Angel where he fights a blind MonsterofTheWeek, it's shown that vampires create heat when they move.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Actually, it's more likely that Warren ''never would have existed at all'' in that scenario. Whedon has mentioned that he originally intended to kill Oz in order to push Willow toward the dark side, and that it only wound up being Tara because Seth Green left the show prematurely. He never said the circumstances would have been exactly the same, or even similar. Oz's death probably would have happened much sooner, as he was already established as Willow's love interest by season four and no additional time was needed to set things up. And as a sidebar, was it ever even established that Oz can only be killed by silver bullets, even in human form? You'd think that would have come up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Silver with gold-flake bullets anointed with holy water on one side, desecrated communion wine on the other, and a hollow-point core full of holly, hemlock, and mistletoe bound with a paste of crushed garlic. You can't be ''[[CrazyPrepared too]]'' prepared when going after a Slayer with a mortal weapon. Tara-verse Warren was going by the assumption that the Slayer gets no powers other than super-strength from whatever causes the slayer line (from what we know, a demonic spirit similar to a bodiless vampire). Buffy had a HealingFactor, and while Warren was right about the Slayer not being able to survive a well-placed bullet, he was wrong about her being only human. ''I'''d have prepared a whole rack of bullets like that as soon as I got the money for the silver (the members of the Trio were rich early in the season, in addition to their OffscreenVillainDarkMatter), and gone after the Slayer using one (or [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill eight]]) of those if I'd wanted to kill her. ...And a cold-iron athame dipped in sea salt in a shoulder holster, [[ProperlyParanoid just in case the bullets didn't end the situation]].

to:

** Silver with gold-flake bullets anointed with holy water on one side, desecrated communion wine on the other, and a hollow-point core full of holly, hemlock, and mistletoe bound with a paste of crushed garlic. You can't be ''[[CrazyPrepared too]]'' prepared when going after a Slayer with a mortal weapon.weapon, especially if she has a werewolf bodyguard in addition to her witch girl-friend ([[AndZoidberg and Xander]]). Tara-verse Warren was going by the assumption that the Slayer gets no powers other than super-strength from whatever causes the slayer line (from what we know, a demonic spirit similar to a bodiless vampire). Buffy had a HealingFactor, and while Warren was right about the Slayer not being able to survive a well-placed bullet, he was wrong about her being only human. ''I'''d have prepared a whole rack of bullets like that as soon as I got the money for the silver (the members of the Trio were rich early in the season, in addition to their OffscreenVillainDarkMatter), and gone after the Slayer using one (or [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill eight]]) of those if I'd wanted to kill her. ...And a cold-iron athame dipped in sea salt in a shoulder holster, [[ProperlyParanoid just in case the bullets didn't end the situation]].

Changed: 1133

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Silver with gold-flake bullets anointed with holy water on one side, desecrated communion wine on the other, and a hollow-point core full of holly, hemlock, and mistletoe bound with a paste of crushed garlic. You can't be ''[[CrazyPrepared too]]'' prepared when going after a Slayer with a mortal weapon. Tara-verse Warren was going by the assumption that the Slayer gets no powers other than super-strength from whatever causes the slayer line (from what we know, a demonic spirit similar to a bodiless vampire). Buffy had a HealingFactor, and while Warren was right about the Slayer not being able to survive a well-placed bullet, he was wrong about her being only human. ''I'''d have prepared a whole rack of bullets like that as soon as I got the money for the silver (the members of the Trio were rich early in the season, in addition to their OffscreenVillainDarkMatter), and gone after the Slayer using one (or [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill eight]]) of those if I'd wanted to kill her. ...And a cold-iron athame dipped in sea salt in a shoulder holster, [[ProperlyParanoid just in case the bullets didn't end the situation]].

Top