History Headscratchers / Blackadder

10th Jun '16 4:55:09 PM malifee
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* In the very first episode, Edmund proclaims himself "the Black Adder", implying that he's first in the dynasty. If that's the case, why is Robin Hood (who was around long before the Wars of the Roses) familiar with a Lord Blackadder in ''Blackadder Goes Forth''?

to:

* In the very first episode, Edmund proclaims himself "the Black Adder", implying that he's first in the dynasty. If that's the case, why is Robin Hood (who was around long before the Wars of the Roses) familiar with a Lord Blackadder in ''Blackadder Goes Back and Forth''?
29th Apr '16 9:24:39 AM AndIntroducingALeg
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Melchett is a senile idiot. He probably named a carrier pigeon "Speckled Jim" after his childhood pet, and then managed to confuse them so that he ended up thinking they were the same pigeon.
17th Feb '16 6:06:11 AM Shadowgazer
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** If one really wishes to give a Watsonian explanation we could argue that messing with time-travelling resulted in alternate histories where the Blackadder family appeared before the main series continuity.
6th Dec '15 5:52:30 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Jons of ''TheSeventhSeal'' looks an awful lot like the original Baldrick. Makes me giggle in the film in parts where I probably shouldn't.

to:

* Jons of ''TheSeventhSeal'' ''Film/TheSeventhSeal'' looks an awful lot like the original Baldrick. Makes me giggle in the film in parts where I probably shouldn't.
5th Dec '15 6:01:54 PM sidhe3141
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** A few lines suggest that Baldrick might not be strictly human, and his family tree in "The Whole Damn Dynasty" has several generations that look like they reproduced asexually.
4th Dec '15 1:35:17 PM AndIntroducingALeg
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Edmund doesn't initially proclaim himself The Black Adder: his first attempt is The Black Vegetable. It is Baldrick who then makes the alternative suggestion. Perhaps he was aware of Edmund's ancestry even if Edmund himself wasn't.
1st Dec '15 12:41:54 PM CrypticMirror
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** He was much more coldly calculating than the others, like when in his first episode he carried out a string of assassinations to fix an election for a minor objective. The second is crueler but still so self-absorbed and petty it comes off as being lighter; the third is a straight-up calculating VillainProtagonist. He's also the only one who got away with everything.

to:

** He was much more coldly calculating than the others, like when in his first episode he carried out a string of assassinations to fix an election for a minor objective. The second is crueler but still so self-absorbed and petty it comes off as being lighter; the third is a straight-up calculating VillainProtagonist. He's also the only one who got away with everything.everything.
** Leaving aside the first Blackadder, and the ones from the one off specials, the Third is the most proactive of the main Blackadders. The second is an oaf, but he was perfectly happy to idle his way through life making fun of Percy and hanging around court and if you left him alone he left you alone. The Fourth joined the army, as many young men of his era did, because it was the sort of thing that young men of a certain class did in order to see the world he was just going along with things too. The Third actively seeks to change his station and is cold and calculating in the way he goes about it, seeing others as obstacles to kill if needed.
1st Dec '15 9:57:57 AM AndIntroducingALeg
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** Not to mention that Dr Johnson would have had something crucial that Blackadder didn't: a secretary.
6th Nov '15 6:39:04 PM ImpudentInfidel
Is there an issue? Send a Message


.

to:

.** He was much more coldly calculating than the others, like when in his first episode he carried out a string of assassinations to fix an election for a minor objective. The second is crueler but still so self-absorbed and petty it comes off as being lighter; the third is a straight-up calculating VillainProtagonist. He's also the only one who got away with everything.
3rd Oct '15 4:55:03 PM cillianflood
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* This page (and I assume a portion of the fandom in general) seem to think the third Black Adder is the most villainous which I find surprising since I found him to be the least villainous (barring the first who's just an idiot). Sure he's willing to kill political rivals and steal but that's a trait common to all the Black Adders. The second Black Adder regularly talked about beating people, executed people early to get half a week of work off and left the sea captain to be consumed by cannibals (he also gave out his piss as a present, not exactly evil but still a rotten thing to do). As for Captain Black Adder it's revealed he joined the army for the express purpose of killing people who can't fight back and happily did it for fifteen years. I can't think of anything noteworthy that the butler version of Black Adder did that would give him a reputation worse than the others.
This list shows the last 10 events of 88. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.Blackadder