Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / BlackMirrorCrocodile

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It likely can't be used on them. The cops note that murdering the baby was a waste because he was blind (Mia just didn't know that) -- they never had any way of using his memories to help find the murderer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Because if she refused, Shazia would call the police like she threatened to do in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why don't the Corroborators have any sort of security to prevent use by unauthorized personnel? For a device with such potentially invasive applications, you'd think there would be something like a security key or password lock, especially since they're now being carried around on a daily basis by everyday people.

to:

* Why don't the Corroborators have any sort of security to prevent use by unauthorized personnel? For a device with such potentially invasive applications, you'd think there would be something like a security key or password lock, especially since they're now being carried around on a daily basis by everyday people.people.
** The device is primitive compared to what we see in episodes set later in the timeline. Chances are the laws haven't caught up to the technology, including safety standards. This is a world that has a very dim, bleak outlook on the value of human life, you can safely assume that there's "no budget" for bodyguards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** She's pre-emptively explaining her apprehension about being questioned in the first place. She wants them to think she's embarrassed to have strangers find out about her viewing habits, not nervous that she's being investigated or has committed a crime.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The cinematic answer is in the title: she doesn't look dangerous, but she's a natural apex predator, the way a crocodile looks like a plain log when resting in the water, but turns into a death machine with the proper motivation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** How hard do you think you need to swing a hammer to hurt somebody? The scene is worse than a stealth sequence in a video game, but if she brained him when she had the chance, her ovaries wouldn't turn the hammer into a squeaky toy on impact, she'd ''brain him with a hammer'', and if that didn't put him down, it'd stun him long enough for her to hit him with it again, and again, until it did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The whole sequence inside the house is one conveniance after another: [[spoiler: when she enters the house he is sitting on the sofa with his back to her, no lights, watching the TV and head exposed at perfect-to-hit position. She doesn't react, though, and a few seconds later he gets up, doesn't see her standing by the door and goes upstairs to take a bath. Even when she gets in the bathroom, slowly rising the hammer, he sees her but doesn't react.]]
* Adding to that the fact she could overpower her old boyfriend even though he's much bigger. His resistance seemed useless.
** Also, why does Rob expire so quickly? Mia appears to keep her forearm on his throat for only 20 seconds tops, but he would more than likely just go unconscious from it, not instantly flatline.

to:

** The whole sequence inside the house is one conveniance convenience after another: [[spoiler: when she enters the house he is sitting on the sofa with his back to her, no lights, watching the TV and head exposed at perfect-to-hit position. She doesn't react, though, and a few seconds later he gets up, doesn't see her standing by the door and goes upstairs to take a bath. Even when she gets in the bathroom, slowly rising the hammer, he sees her but doesn't react.]]
* ** Adding to that the fact she could overpower her old boyfriend even though he's much bigger. His resistance seemed useless.
**
useless. Also, why does Rob expire so quickly? Mia appears to keep her forearm on his throat for only 20 seconds tops, but he would more than likely just go unconscious from it, not instantly flatline.flatline.
*** In the original script Mia was a male character, which explains why they'd be more likely to overpower their victims.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mia puts on a movie while she disposes of Rob's body, presumably to give herself an alibi if the need arises. But why did she pick a porno? Why not pick something more innocuous, like a romantic comedy or an action-adventure film, which would have had the same result without drawing any attention?

to:

* Mia puts on a movie while she disposes of Rob's body, presumably to give herself an alibi if the need arises. But why did she pick a porno? Why not pick something more innocuous, like a romantic comedy or an action-adventure film, which would have had the same result without drawing any attention?attention?
* Why don't the Corroborators have any sort of security to prevent use by unauthorized personnel? For a device with such potentially invasive applications, you'd think there would be something like a security key or password lock, especially since they're now being carried around on a daily basis by everyday people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mia puts on a movie while she disposes of Rob's body, presumably to give herself an alibi if the need arises. But why did she pick a porno? Why not pick something more innocuous, like a romantic comedy or an action-adventure film, which would have accomplished the same result without drawing any attention?

to:

* Mia puts on a movie while she disposes of Rob's body, presumably to give herself an alibi if the need arises. But why did she pick a porno? Why not pick something more innocuous, like a romantic comedy or an action-adventure film, which would have accomplished had the same result without drawing any attention?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Mia puts on a movie while she disposes of Rob's body, presumably to give herself an alibi if the need arises. But why did she pick a porno? Why not pick something more mainstream, like a romantic comedy or an action-adventure film, which would have accomplished the same result without drawing any attention.

to:

* Mia puts on a movie while she disposes of Rob's body, presumably to give herself an alibi if the need arises. But why did she pick a porno? Why not pick something more mainstream, innocuous, like a romantic comedy or an action-adventure film, which would have accomplished the same result without drawing any attention.attention?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Okay, so Mia agreed to let Shazia talk to her to avoid drawing any attention from the police, I can understand that. But when Shazia says she wants to use the Corroborator, why did Mia agree? Why not just insist on staying with a verbal interview? Yes, Shazia tried to reassure Mia that "private stuff is private stuff," but Mia could have easily stood her ground for personal/privacy/religious/ethical reasons -- after all, Shazia was ''not'' a law-enforcement officer and had no way to force Mia to comply.

to:

* Okay, so Mia agreed to let Shazia talk to her to avoid drawing any attention from the police, I can understand that. But when Shazia says she wants to use the Corroborator, why did Mia agree? Why not just insist on staying with a verbal interview? Yes, Shazia tried to reassure Mia that "private stuff is private stuff," but Mia could have easily stood her ground for personal/privacy/religious/ethical reasons -- after all, Shazia was ''not'' a law-enforcement officer and had no way to force Mia to comply.comply.
* Mia puts on a movie while she disposes of Rob's body, presumably to give herself an alibi if the need arises. But why did she pick a porno? Why not pick something more mainstream, like a romantic comedy or an action-adventure film, which would have accomplished the same result without drawing any attention.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Okay, so Mia agreed to let Shazia interview her to avoid drawing any attention from the police, I can understand that. But when Shazia says she wants to use the Corroborator, why did Mia agree? Why not just insist on not using it and staying with a verbal interrogation? Yes, Shazia was trying to reassure Mia that "private stuff is private stuff," but Mia could have easily stood her ground for personal/privacy/religious/ethical reasons -- after all, Shazia was ''not'' a law-enforcement officer and had no way to force Mia to comply.

to:

* Okay, so Mia agreed to let Shazia interview talk to her to avoid drawing any attention from the police, I can understand that. But when Shazia says she wants to use the Corroborator, why did Mia agree? Why not just insist on not using it and staying with a verbal interrogation? interview? Yes, Shazia was trying tried to reassure Mia that "private stuff is private stuff," but Mia could have easily stood her ground for personal/privacy/religious/ethical reasons -- after all, Shazia was ''not'' a law-enforcement officer and had no way to force Mia to comply.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How do memory scanning works for blind persons? In the episode, we only see video-based models, which wouldn't as effectively work for blind persons. Maybe they have special devices for engrams based on other senses such as sound or taste.

to:

* How do memory scanning works for blind persons? In the episode, we only see video-based models, which wouldn't as effectively work for blind persons. Maybe they have special devices for engrams based on other senses such as sound or taste.taste.
* Okay, so Mia agreed to let Shazia interview her to avoid drawing any attention from the police, I can understand that. But when Shazia says she wants to use the Corroborator, why did Mia agree? Why not just insist on not using it and staying with a verbal interrogation? Yes, Shazia was trying to reassure Mia that "private stuff is private stuff," but Mia could have easily stood her ground for personal/privacy/religious/ethical reasons -- after all, Shazia was ''not'' a law-enforcement officer and had no way to force Mia to comply.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Accidentally hilarious error.


* How do memory scanning works for blind persons? In the episode, we only see video-based models, which wouldn't as effectively work for blond persons. Maybe they have special devices for engrams based on other senses such as sound or taste.

to:

* How do memory scanning works for blind persons? In the episode, we only see video-based models, which wouldn't as effectively work for blond blind persons. Maybe they have special devices for engrams based on other senses such as sound or taste.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, why does Rob expire so quickly? Mia appears to keep her forearm on his throat for only 20 seconds tops, but he would more than likely just go unconscious from it, not instantly flatline.

to:

** Also, why does Rob expire so quickly? Mia appears to keep her forearm on his throat for only 20 seconds tops, but he would more than likely just go unconscious from it, not instantly flatline.flatline.
* How do memory scanning works for blind persons? In the episode, we only see video-based models, which wouldn't as effectively work for blond persons. Maybe they have special devices for engrams based on other senses such as sound or taste.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The whole sequence inside the house is one conveniance after another: [[spoiler: when she enters the house he is sitting on the sofa with his back to her, no lights, watching the TV and head exposed at perfect-to-hit position. She doesn't react, though, and a few seconds later he gets up, doesn't see her standing by the door and goes upstairs to take a bath. Even when she gets in the bathroom, slowly rising the hammer, he sees her but doesn't react.]]

Added: 194

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Adding to that the fact she could overpower her old boyfriend even though he's much bigger. his resitance seemed useless

to:

* Adding to that the fact she could overpower her old boyfriend even though he's much bigger. his resitance His resistance seemed uselessuseless.
**Also, why does Rob expire so quickly? Mia appears to keep her forearm on his throat for only 20 seconds tops, but he would more than likely just go unconscious from it, not instantly flatline.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* So, this slender woman with no apparent combat skills needs to kill a large, healthy, adult man, and her plan is to drive to his house, walk in, and hit him in the head with a hammer? Granted that she's desperate, but she had the whole drive to think it over, and that was a terrible idea. The odds of her getting close enough to beat him to death without him noticing are insanely low. The fact that it worked was really unrealistic.

to:

* So, this slender woman with no apparent combat skills needs to kill a large, healthy, adult man, and her plan is to drive to his house, walk in, and hit him in the head with a hammer? Granted that she's desperate, but she had the whole drive to think it over, and that was a terrible idea. The odds of her getting close enough to beat him to death without him noticing are insanely low. The fact that it worked was really unrealistic.unrealistic.
*Adding to that the fact she could overpower her old boyfriend even though he's much bigger. his resitance seemed useless

Added: 435

Changed: 431

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


So, this slender woman with no apparent combat skills needs to kill a large, healthy, adult man, and her plan is to drive to his house, walk in, and hit him in the head with a hammer? Granted that she's desperate, but she had the whole drive to think it over, and that was a terrible idea. The odds of her getting close enough to beat him to death without him noticing are insanely low. The fact that it worked was really unrealistic.

to:

So, ! Headscratchers
*So,
this slender woman with no apparent combat skills needs to kill a large, healthy, adult man, and her plan is to drive to his house, walk in, and hit him in the head with a hammer? Granted that she's desperate, but she had the whole drive to think it over, and that was a terrible idea. The odds of her getting close enough to beat him to death without him noticing are insanely low. The fact that it worked was really unrealistic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

So, this slender woman with no apparent combat skills needs to kill a large, healthy, adult man, and her plan is to drive to his house, walk in, and hit him in the head with a hammer? Granted that she's desperate, but she had the whole drive to think it over, and that was a terrible idea. The odds of her getting close enough to beat him to death without him noticing are insanely low. The fact that it worked was really unrealistic.

Top