Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / XMenDaysOfFuturePast

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not to mention, while Logan's healing factor is in a class by itself, there are plenty of mutants that can be NighInvulnerable (Colossus, Iceman) or just really difficult to deliver a killing blow to (Magneto), or just raw Determinators who keep fighting to their very last breath and then some (Magneto again). Splattering them across the countryside is pretty much TheOnlyWayToBeSure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Perhaps they didn't just need to stop Mystique from killing Trask. They needed to stop, or at least curtail, the "wasted time" Charles and Erik spent fighting each other. Allowing Mystique to see the better path allows Magneto to as well, perhaps stopping the formation of the Brotherhood of Mutants outright (or at least, hastening Magneto's eventual HeelFaceTurn).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* On the first viewing, it may seem puzzling that Bolivar Trask would be imprisoned in the metal-less prison cell that was until now used to hold Magneto. Since he has no power, an ordinary prison would work just fine, right? And then you realize: the special cell is needed not to prevent Trask from escaping, but to prevent Magneto from reaching him. After all, it is highly probable he or other mutants would be planning to murder Trask in order to avenge the torture of several of their kind, not to mention the whole Sentinels plot.



* Hell, Past!Charles ''entire character arc'' fits perfectly alongside the events of First Class. Some fans were confused about the ease with which Charles recovered (mentally) from the [[BreakTheCutie devastation and loss]] that he went through at the climax of First Class. It turns out, ''he didn't''. He likely internalized most of his pain, causing him to [[DespairEventHorizon break completely]] when he lost everything else.

to:

* Hell, Past!Charles ''entire character arc'' fits perfectly alongside the events of First Class. ''First Class''. Some fans were confused about the ease with which Charles recovered (mentally) from the [[BreakTheCutie devastation and loss]] that he went through at the climax of First Class.''First Class''. It turns out, ''he didn't''. He likely internalized most of his pain, causing him to [[DespairEventHorizon break completely]] when he lost everything else.



** Not necessarily, pretty much every incarnation of the X-men establishes some sort of dark future. As Beast states in the 90's series if you destroy one of evil's forms it will likely just take a different form. It's pretty much canon that some form of dark future will happe in the near future, the trick is making it a dark future that can be endured.

to:

** Not necessarily, pretty much every incarnation of the X-men X-Men establishes some sort of dark future. As Beast states in the 90's '90s series if you destroy one of evil's forms it will likely just take a different form. It's pretty much canon that some form of dark future will happe happen in the near future, the trick is making it a dark future that can be endured.






Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not necessarily, pretty much every incarnation of the X-men establishes some sort of dark future. As Beast states in the 90's series if you destroy one of evil's forms it will likely just take a different form. It's pretty much canon that some form of dark future will happe in the near future, the trick is making it a dark future that can be endured.

Added: 525

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Dwarfism is a genetic mutation, that means Trask is a mutant who is hunting other mutants

to:

* Dwarfism is a genetic mutation, that means Trask is a mutant who is hunting other mutantsmutants.
** While genetic mutation for Mutants gives them cool powers like the ability to shoot lasers from their eyes, control metal, read minds, etc. genetic mutation for Trask gave him the super amazing power... of being much shorter than everybody else, for which he was likely bullied and ridiculed for his entire life. Even if he's not conscious of it, Trask's vendetta against the mutants can easily be seen as ultimately the result of a deeply ingrained inferiority complex which drives him to prove himself as their superior.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Hell, Past!Charles ''entire character arc'' fits perfectly alongside the events of First Class. Some fans were confused about the ease with which Charles recovered (mentally) from the [[BreakTheCutie devastation and loss]] that he went through at the climax of First Class. It turns out, ''he didn't''. He likely internalized most of his pain, causing him to [[DespairEventHorizon break completely]] when he lost everything else.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another possibility: Xavier is aware of the events at Alkali Lake and that Stryker will be plotting against them and uses the captured Magneto to not only get information about the mansions defenses but also to catch Xavier and Scott. So if things get bad enough that they start repeating (which they might have given Rogue's presence and interference in ''' The Rogue Cut'''), Xavier could avoid the whole situation by not handing Magneto to the police at the end of the first movie.

to:

** Another possibility: Xavier is aware of the events at Alkali Lake and that Stryker will be plotting against them and uses the captured Magneto to not only get information about the mansions defenses but also to catch Xavier and Scott. So if things get bad enough that they start repeating (which they might have given Rogue's presence and interference in ''' '' The Rogue Cut'''), Cut''), Xavier could avoid the whole situation by not handing Magneto to the police at the end of the first movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another possibility: Xavier is aware of the events at Alkali Lake and that Stryker will be plotting against them and uses the captured Magneto to not only get information about the mansions defenses but also to catch Xavier and Scott. So if things get bad enough that they start repeating ( which they might have given Rogue's presence and appearance) Xavier could avoid the whole situation by not handing Magneto to the police at the end of the first movie.

to:

** Another possibility: Xavier is aware of the events at Alkali Lake and that Stryker will be plotting against them and uses the captured Magneto to not only get information about the mansions defenses but also to catch Xavier and Scott. So if things get bad enough that they start repeating ( which (which they might have given Rogue's presence and appearance) interference in ''' The Rogue Cut'''), Xavier could avoid the whole situation by not handing Magneto to the police at the end of the first movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** ''Alternately'' alternatively, Kitty is still phasing. She's just phasing through a new ''medium'': Space-Time. In many theoretical models space and time are inextricably linked; for one to travel through time, one must also travel through ''space''[[note]]The earth isn't a static object. Not only does it rotate about its axis, but it orbits the sun as well. For that matter the sun itself, and even the Milky Way galaxy are all in motion through the universe. If one were to travel through ''time'' without traveling through ''space'', one might end up at a time only to find there's no ''place'' to be![[/note]] Kitty already phases through space when she uses her powers, allowing herself to pass through physical objects. Since space and time are interconnected, it doesn't take a tremendous leap to imagine Kitty learning to phase someone through space ''and'' time in the 20-odd years since her last appearance in the timeline, rather than merely space.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Nightcrawler shows up in the next film as a teenager, some 20 years after both his comic book parents were members of the Brotherhood. In other words, Raven isn't just seeing autopsy reports of her friends, she's seeing one of her lover.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rogue's power absorbs memories. So when Iceman kissed her, she got the memories of everything he lived through. So she not only learnt how things have gone to hell after whenever she went under, she finds out the boy she loved is in a serious relationship with someone else, and probably gets some of those memories in the process. Not to mention, absorbing Kitty's powers probably brought some of ''her'' memories over as well. Rogue just does not catch a single break.

to:

* Rogue's power absorbs memories. So So, in ''The Rogue Cut,'' when Iceman kissed her, touched her cheek, she got the memories of everything he lived through. So she not only learnt how things have gone to hell after whenever she went under, she finds out the boy she loved is in a serious relationship with someone else, and probably gets some of those memories in the process. Not to mention, absorbing Kitty's powers probably brought some of ''her'' memories over as well. Rogue just does not catch a single break.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Wolverine ends in the Weapon X program in the next film, ''Film/XMenApocalypse'', which may seem contradictory with the ending of this film. Screenwriter Simon Kinberg [[http://www.cinemablend.com/new/How-X-Men-Screenwriter-Resolves-Wolverine-Mystery-From-End-Days-Future-Past-131267.html explained]] that YouCantFightFate, that details may vary but Wolverine ended there because he was meant to end there. As Beast had said, time is immutable. Which means that the victory of this film is not a victory: someday, somehow, the Sentinels will raise anyway, and the world will be destroyed. Wolverine did not twarth destiny, he just delayed it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Headscratchers/XMenDaysOfFuturePast On the headscratchers page]].

to:

[[Headscratchers/XMenDaysOfFuturePast On the headscratchers page]].page]].
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternatively, she is still phasing, she's just learned a [[HeartIsAnAwesomePower new way to do it]]. Instead of phasing people into objects, she's phasing them into themselves at different points in the timeline For a longer explanation see here:[[note]] In the comics, Kitty's explicitly and implicitly been able to leave things inside of other things as she phases, usually using it to kill people. In this instance however, she's phasing a person's intangible consciousness (similar to how she can "walk on air" using her phasing powers to phase through intangible gases) through their different iterations, "leaving" the older consciousness inside the younger one. In order to do this, she obviously must pass through the only connection the "past" consciousness has to the "present": all of the consciousnesses between those two points in time. This is why the film describes it as "stretching", and why the subject retains their memories of the future into the past and the altered timeline. Their consciousness is phased through every point in their timeline, pulled like quantum taffy to get to the point in the past where it can be useful. Now obviously with there being a theoretically infinite number of points between two markers on a timeline, the number of consciousnesses adds up fast (hence why it hurts and why normal people can only go back a few days at most, while Logan's healing factor allows his "taffy" to repair itself as it gets stretched). However, this explanation not only fits all the descriptions given in the film, but also justifies the SanDimasTime and RippleEffectProofMemory experienced by the user. [[/note]]]]

to:

** Alternatively, she is still phasing, she's just learned a [[HeartIsAnAwesomePower new way to do it]]. Instead of phasing people into objects, she's phasing them into themselves at different points in the timeline For a longer explanation see here:[[note]] In the comics, Kitty's explicitly and implicitly been able to leave things inside of other things as she phases, usually using it to kill people. In this instance however, she's phasing a person's intangible consciousness (similar to how she can "walk on air" using her phasing powers to phase through intangible gases) through their different iterations, "leaving" the older consciousness inside the younger one. In order to do this, she obviously must pass through the only connection the "past" consciousness has to the "present": all of the consciousnesses between those two points in time. This is why the film describes it as "stretching", and why the subject retains their memories of the future into the past and the altered timeline. Their consciousness is phased through every point in their timeline, pulled like quantum taffy to get to the point in the past where it can be useful. Now obviously with there being a theoretically infinite number of points between two markers on a timeline, the number of consciousnesses adds up fast (hence why it hurts and why normal people can only go back a few days at most, while Logan's healing factor allows his "taffy" to repair itself as it gets stretched). However, this explanation not only fits all the descriptions given in the film, but also justifies the SanDimasTime and RippleEffectProofMemory experienced by the user. [[/note]]]]user, because in essence all of the future elements of that person are phased into their past self, rather than merely "emailed" as the description of "projecting his past self" implies. [[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alternatively, she is still phasing, she's just learned a [[HeartIsAnAwesomePower new way to do it]]. Instead of phasing people into objects, she's phasing them into themselves at different points in the timeline For a longer explanation see here:[[note]] In the comics, Kitty's explicitly and implicitly been able to leave things inside of other things as she phases, usually using it to kill people. In this instance however, she's phasing a person's intangible consciousness (similar to how she can "walk on air" using her phasing powers to phase through intangible gases) through their different iterations, "leaving" the older consciousness inside the younger one. In order to do this, she obviously must pass through the only connection the "past" consciousness has to the "present": all of the consciousnesses between those two points in time. This is why the film describes it as "stretching", and why the subject retains their memories of the future into the past and the altered timeline. Their consciousness is phased through every point in their timeline, pulled like quantum taffy to get to the point in the past where it can be useful. Now obviously with there being a theoretically infinite number of points between two markers on a timeline, the number of consciousnesses adds up fast (hence why it hurts and why normal people can only go back a few days at most, while Logan's healing factor allows his "taffy" to repair itself as it gets stretched). However, this explanation not only fits all the descriptions given in the film, but also justifies the SanDimasTime and RippleEffectProofMemory experienced by the user. [[/note]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Rogue's power absorbs memories. So when Iceman kissed her, she got the memories of everything he lived through. So she not only learnt how things have gone to hell after whenever she went under, she finds out the boy she loved is in a serious relationship with someone else, and probably gets some of those memories in the process. Not to mention, absorbing Kitty's powers probably brought some of ''her'' memories over as well. Rogue just does not catch a single break.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As all CosmicRetcon stories, this one has a huge ProtagonistCenteredMorality. The very idea of a world that ceases to be, to be replaced by a completely different one, is a huge horror if you stop to think about it for a moment. We have seen dead people who are now alive, and dead couples witch are reunited again, but things may be different elsewhere. What about the people who met and loved in the old timeline, and never met in the new one? What about the children of such unions, who would simply cease to exist? Even more, a cosmic retcon does this ''to the whole universe'', not just to Planet Earth, and [[ButterflyOfDoom who can predict how other worlds would be affected?]]

to:

* As all CosmicRetcon stories, this one has a huge ProtagonistCenteredMorality. The very idea of a world that ceases to be, to be replaced by a completely different one, is a huge horror if you stop to think about it for a moment. We have seen dead people who are now alive, and dead couples witch are reunited again, but things may be different elsewhere. What about the The people who met and loved in the old timeline, and may never met in the new one? What about the one. The children of such unions, who would simply cease to exist? exist. Even more, a cosmic retcon does this ''to the whole universe'', not just to Planet Earth, and [[ButterflyOfDoom who can predict how the consequences for other worlds would may be affected?]]
unpredictable]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* As all CosmicRetcon stories, this one has a huge ProtagonistCenteredMorality. The very idea of a world that ceases to be, to be replaced by a completely different one, is a huge horror if you stop to think about it for a moment. We have seen dead people who are now alive, and dead couples witch are reunited again, but things may be different elsewhere. What about the people who met and loved in the old timeline, and never met in the new one? What about the children of such unions, who would simply cease to exist? Even more, a cosmic retcon does this ''to the whole universe'', not just to Planet Earth, and [[ButterflyOfDoom who can predict how other worlds would be affected?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Many fans found it nonsensical that Charles and Mystique apparently grew up together in ''First Class'', and that the kind-hearted but broken Raven of the past is so different from the murderous, bitter Mystique of the original films. As Future!Charles explains, after Raven killed Trask, she was captured and tortured for who knows how long. By the time she was freed (presumably by someone other than Charles) the torture had started her well down the path of becoming the sadist of the original films. She may have even forgotten, or blocked out, the good memories she had of Charles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ComicBook/{{Quicksilver}} doesn't seem to know SelfDemonstrating/{{Wolverine}}, suggesting that they met in the future, perhaps after the time of any of the previous films. And Wolverine actually confirmed that he only met Peter when the latter isn't so young anymore. Rather depressingly, his absence from the future scenes in ''Days of Future Past'' can be explained by him being among the mutants who've been killed off by then.

to:

* ComicBook/{{Quicksilver}} doesn't seem to know SelfDemonstrating/{{Wolverine}}, ComicBook/{{Wolverine}}, suggesting that they met in the future, perhaps after the time of any of the previous films. And Wolverine actually confirmed that he only met Peter when the latter isn't so young anymore. Rather depressingly, his absence from the future scenes in ''Days of Future Past'' can be explained by him being among the mutants who've been killed off by then.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** It may or may not be intentional by the writers, but Xavier's emotional state in ''First Class'' and ''Days of Future Past'' works well as a metaphor for America's mindset during the time period the movies depict. In 1962, the character's optimism is an extension of the hopeful outlook President Kennedy's administration tended to exude, whereas Charles' melancholia in 1973 is not unlike the general malaise American citizens felt while under the shadow of the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. Xavier's descent into despair began in 1963, which is the same year Kennedy was assassinated--the end of "Camelot" [[note]]Kennedy's presidency is sometimes called this[[/note]] parallels the end of Professor X's school. At least in the AlternateTimeline, Charles starts to piece himself together again shortly after the Paris Peace Accords are signed.

to:

** * It may or may not be intentional by the writers, but Xavier's emotional state in ''First Class'' and ''Days of Future Past'' works well as a metaphor for America's mindset during the time period the movies depict. In 1962, the character's optimism is an extension of the hopeful outlook President Kennedy's administration tended to exude, whereas Charles' melancholia in 1973 is not unlike the general malaise American citizens felt while under the shadow of the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. Xavier's descent into despair began in 1963, which is the same year Kennedy was assassinated--the end of "Camelot" [[note]]Kennedy's presidency is sometimes called this[[/note]] parallels the end of Professor X's school. At least in the AlternateTimeline, Charles starts to piece himself together again shortly after the Paris Peace Accords are signed.

Changed: 19

Removed: 160

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* Trask's idea of using Mystique's DNA to benefit his ''most certainly mechanical'' Sentinels might sound farfetched, but the idea somehow lasted into the BadFuture, where the "Nimrods" somehow exhibit Emma Frost and Darwin's abilities. One even sprouts claws like Wolverine!
** The Sentinel actually displays [[http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/xmenmovies/images/8/8a/YurikoWickedNails-X2.png Lady Deathstrike's claws,]] not Logan's.

to:

* Trask's idea of using Mystique's DNA to benefit his ''most certainly mechanical'' Sentinels might sound farfetched, but the idea somehow lasted into the BadFuture, where the "Nimrods" somehow exhibit Emma Frost and Darwin's abilities. One even sprouts claws like Wolverine!
** The Sentinel actually displays [[http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/xmenmovies/images/8/8a/YurikoWickedNails-X2.png
Lady Deathstrike's claws,]] not Logan's.Deathstrike.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correction edit

Added DiffLines:

** The Sentinel actually displays [[http://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/xmenmovies/images/8/8a/YurikoWickedNails-X2.png Lady Deathstrike's claws,]] not Logan's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It may or may not be intentional by the writers, but Xavier's emotional state in ''First Class'' and ''Days of Future Past'' works well as a metaphor for America's mindset during the time period the movies depict. In 1962, the character's optimism is an extension of the hopeful outlook President Kennedy's administration tended to exude, whereas Charles' melancholia in 1973 is not unlike the general malaise American citizens felt while under the shadow of the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. At least in the AlternateTimeline, Charles begins to piece himself together again shortly after the Paris Peace Accords are signed.

to:

** It may or may not be intentional by the writers, but Xavier's emotional state in ''First Class'' and ''Days of Future Past'' works well as a metaphor for America's mindset during the time period the movies depict. In 1962, the character's optimism is an extension of the hopeful outlook President Kennedy's administration tended to exude, whereas Charles' melancholia in 1973 is not unlike the general malaise American citizens felt while under the shadow of the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. Xavier's descent into despair began in 1963, which is the same year Kennedy was assassinated--the end of "Camelot" [[note]]Kennedy's presidency is sometimes called this[[/note]] parallels the end of Professor X's school. At least in the AlternateTimeline, Charles begins starts to piece himself together again shortly after the Paris Peace Accords are signed.

Added: 621

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It seems a little OutOfCharacter for Charles to suddenly hate and suppress his mutant powers, but consider his situation. Not only was his telepathy affected by his paralysis, but the overall attitude and minds of people around him has probably gotten a lot darker and more cynical. It was most likely much more enjoyable to be a telepath during the more positive early 60's than the negative and depressing early 70's. Not to mention the rather horrifying experience with Shaw and the coin, thanks to his powers. It's also heavily implied that due to his [[BreakTheCutie mental state]] ([[{{WMG}} and maybe his powers becoming stronger in the decade gap]]) he can't block out the voices anymore. Previously, he'd had to concentrate to hear thoughts, but now he just hears everyone within a certain range. And since [[spoiler: he started hearing them while in an isolated mansion]], it's a pretty big range.

to:

* It seems a little OutOfCharacter for Charles to suddenly hate and suppress his mutant powers, but consider his situation. Not only was his telepathy affected by his paralysis, but the overall attitude and minds of people around him has probably gotten a lot darker and more cynical. It was most likely much more enjoyable to be a telepath during the more positive early 60's '60s than the negative and depressing early 70's.'70s. Not to mention the rather horrifying experience with Shaw and the coin, thanks to his powers. It's also heavily implied that due to his [[BreakTheCutie mental state]] ([[{{WMG}} and maybe his powers abilities becoming stronger in the decade gap]]) gap]]), he can't block out the voices anymore. Previously, he'd had to concentrate to hear thoughts, but now he just hears everyone within a certain range. And since [[spoiler: he started hearing them while in an isolated mansion]], mansion, it's a pretty big range.range.
** It may or may not be intentional by the writers, but Xavier's emotional state in ''First Class'' and ''Days of Future Past'' works well as a metaphor for America's mindset during the time period the movies depict. In 1962, the character's optimism is an extension of the hopeful outlook President Kennedy's administration tended to exude, whereas Charles' melancholia in 1973 is not unlike the general malaise American citizens felt while under the shadow of the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. At least in the AlternateTimeline, Charles begins to piece himself together again shortly after the Paris Peace Accords are signed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter.


** Although that could be rectified by the presence of a certain pair of powerful telepaths who knew their Logan well, and could possibly merge what they knew of him with the memories of the Logan that we know.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Although that could be rectified by the presence of a certain pair of powerful telepaths who knew their Logan well, and could possibly merge what they knew of him with the memories of the Logan that we know.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* There's another reason that Scott seems offput at the end when Logan tells him it's good to see him. In addition to it being out of character for Logan to be so warm toward Scott, the two of them live and work in the same building. "Good to see you," is just plain odd to say to someone you see every day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
People weren\'t screaming in agony. Xavier\'s reacting to people screaming at one another for unrelated reasons — all the anger and pain of normal human life overwhelmed him.


* Charles' breakdown when he first tries to use Cerebro is actually terrifying when you think about how many people were screaming in agony, and ''especially'' when you think about older!Charles mentioning to Logan in earlier movies that if he concentrates too hard or is disrupted during the process that he could kill them all. Seeing how unstable past!Charles was at this point, it isn't hard to imagine that something really bad could've happened if he hadn't taken off the helmet or gotten it together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Dwarfism is a genetic mutation, that means Trask is a mutant who is hunting other mutants

Top