Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / ThomasTheTankEngine

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** From what I understand, they're just ripped apart and that kills them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Unless they manage to [[TurnedAgainstTheirMasters rise up]] [[KillAllHumans against their oppressors]]...and Thomas becomes a {{Steampunk}} {{Terminator}}.

to:

*** Unless they manage to [[TurnedAgainstTheirMasters rise up]] [[KillAllHumans against their oppressors]]...and Thomas becomes a {{Steampunk}} {{Terminator}}.Franchise/{{Terminator}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the books this seems to the case; in "Main Line Engines", Gordon's fireman is mentioned to be new on the job.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''Edward's Exploit''. In the televised version, the only damage that Edward sustains is losing his siderods, but in the RWS version, the illustration shows the splashers and running board above Edward's right driving wheels completely churned up, almost macerated by whatever happened to him. It's quite hard to imagine just how much pain the poor engine must have been in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* By going with the narration of the TV Series and the Railway Series, it would seem that it's not just the face and feelings that both engines and humans have; some parts and functions of an engine seem to mirror that of a human. The firebox, smokebox and boiler appear to represent the heart, head/brain and stomach respectively, blowing a safety valve is like having a heart attack, bad coal is like having constipation as a lot of water is needed, boiler sludge is practically excrement and a washout is somewhat akin to an ''enema''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In ''Tale Of The Brave'', when Bill and Ben scare Thomas at the clay pits, he remarks that they nearly made him 'blow a safety valve'. Clearly the writes see this as akin to a heart attack. Recall in Season 1's ''Edward, Gordon and Henry'', Gordon blows his safety valve while pulling the Express. In other words, Gordon overworked himself so much that he gave himself a heart attack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* What even happens when an engine is scrapped? Are they given some sort of special fuel that kills them when burnt, like a cyanide pill, then melted down or ripped apart, or are they dismembered by the giant claw at the Ironworks while still alive and conscious?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** {{Jossed}}. Thomas and Victoria, set around 2007, features Toby, Daisy, and Boco. Also, the show is set between the 1920s and the 1970s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added to slavery section

Added DiffLines:

*** The slavery theory, of course, requires a certain degree of anthropocentrism regarding the psychology of an engine. Any sci-fi writer worth his/her salt will be quick to point out that other sentient beings needs, desires and motivations are different from our own most of the time. The engines genuinely seem to delight in being deemed "really useful", potentially beyond human comprehension. Without actually speaking to a sentient train, I personally would hesitate to assume slavery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Japanese version of "Horrid Lorry", after the lorries are "smashed, broken and sunk", Thomas, just like in the English version, names them for their accidents: ''Pechanko, Enko and Donburako'', respectively. It seems rather straightforward at first, but ''look at the last two letters in each name.'' That's right — ''-ko'' (こ, コ, 子) appears in countless girls' names. ''Thomas was effectively calling the lorries '''sissies''' for getting into trouble without having much of a chance to back up their claims!''

to:

* In the Japanese version of "Horrid Lorry", after the lorries are "smashed, broken and sunk", Thomas, just like in the English version, names them for their accidents: ''Pechanko, Enko and Donburako'', respectively. It seems rather straightforward at first, but ''look at the last two letters in each name.'' That's right — ''-ko'' (こ, コ, 子) appears in countless girls' names. ''Thomas was effectively calling the lorries '''sissies''' for getting into trouble without having much of a chance to back up their claims!''
claims!'' Way to hit it where it hurts, Thomas.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Japanese version of "Horrid Lorry", after the lorries are "smashed, broken and sunk", Thomas, just like in the English version, names them for their accidents: ''Pechanko, Enko and Donburako'', respectively. It seems rather straightforward at first, but ''look at the last two letters in each name.'' That's right — ''-ko'' (こ, 子) appears in countless girls' names. ''Thomas was effectively calling the lorries '''sissies''' for getting into trouble without having much of a chance to back up their claims!''

to:

* In the Japanese version of "Horrid Lorry", after the lorries are "smashed, broken and sunk", Thomas, just like in the English version, names them for their accidents: ''Pechanko, Enko and Donburako'', respectively. It seems rather straightforward at first, but ''look at the last two letters in each name.'' That's right — ''-ko'' (こ, コ, 子) appears in countless girls' names. ''Thomas was effectively calling the lorries '''sissies''' for getting into trouble without having much of a chance to back up their claims!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Japanese version of "Horrid Lorry", after the lorries are "smashed, broken and sunk", Thomas, just like in the English version, names them for their accidents: ''Pechanko, Enko and Donburako'', respectively. It seems rather straightforward at first, but ''look at the last to letters in each name.'' That's right — ''-ko'' (こ, 子) appears in countless girls' names. ''Thomas was effectively calling the lorries '''sissies''' for getting into trouble without having much of a chance to back up their claims!''

to:

* In the Japanese version of "Horrid Lorry", after the lorries are "smashed, broken and sunk", Thomas, just like in the English version, names them for their accidents: ''Pechanko, Enko and Donburako'', respectively. It seems rather straightforward at first, but ''look at the last to two letters in each name.'' That's right — ''-ko'' (こ, 子) appears in countless girls' names. ''Thomas was effectively calling the lorries '''sissies''' for getting into trouble without having much of a chance to back up their claims!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Though the later seasons have slipped on this a bit (more and more after each), the engines really can't do ''anything'' without humans helping them. They need a driver and brakeman to move, the foundry crew to keep them in good repair. The possibility for blackmail is enormous.

to:

** Though the later seasons have slipped on this a bit (more and more after each), the engines really can't do ''anything'' without humans helping them. They need a driver and driver, a brakeman and, in the case of steam locomotives like Thomas, a fireman to move, the foundry crew to keep them in good repair. The possibility for blackmail is enormous.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the Japanese version of "Horrid Lorry", after the lorries are "smashed, broken and sunk", Thomas, just like in the English version, names them for their accidents: ''Pechanko, Enko and Donburako", respectively. It seems rather straightforward at first, but ''look at the last to letters in each name.'' That's right — ''-ko'' (こ, 子) appears in countless girls' names. ''Thomas was effectively calling the lorries '''sissies''' for getting into trouble without having much of a chance to back up their claims!''

to:

* In the Japanese version of "Horrid Lorry", after the lorries are "smashed, broken and sunk", Thomas, just like in the English version, names them for their accidents: ''Pechanko, Enko and Donburako", Donburako'', respectively. It seems rather straightforward at first, but ''look at the last to letters in each name.'' That's right — ''-ko'' (こ, 子) appears in countless girls' names. ''Thomas was effectively calling the lorries '''sissies''' for getting into trouble without having much of a chance to back up their claims!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the Japanese version of "Horrid Lorry", after the lorries are "smashed, broken and sunk", Thomas, just like in the English version, names them for their accidents: ''Pechanko, Enko and Donburako", respectively. It seems rather straightforward at first, but ''look at the last to letters in each name.'' That's right — ''-ko'' (こ, 子) appears in countless girls' names. ''Thomas was effectively calling the lorries '''sissies''' for getting into trouble without having much of a chance to back up their claims!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Mayfly December Friendship seems more likely.


* Barring accident or lack of maintenance, [[TheAgeless engines are effectively immortal, with some over 100 years old]]. This means all but the diesels and the youngest steam engines have probably [[MayflyDecemberRomance outlived their drivers and firemen at least once]].

to:

* Barring accident or lack of maintenance, [[TheAgeless engines are effectively immortal, with some over 100 years old]]. This means all but the diesels and the youngest steam engines have probably [[MayflyDecemberRomance [[MayflyDecemberFriendship outlived their drivers and firemen at least once]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The slavery theory can be best seen in "Train Stops Play". Because some cricket players lost their ball, and no one thought to bring a spare, they take their car (which happens to be sentient) and pushes her far past her limit to catch up with Stepney (who was pulling the truck that the ball was in). By the end she's overheating and smoking. Considering cars can break down much easier than engines, it's a bit disturbing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Hiro goes back to Japan at the end of "Hero of the Railway", but is back on Sodor in the TV series. Discontinuity? Maybe...except that Hiro had previously stated that he was the oldest engine on Sodor, and he wanted to go home to see his friends again. His friends would be as old as he was, and many of them would have had to be scrapped...in other words, he returned to Sodor because all his friends are dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* New train engineers are often told that at some point in their career their train will kill someone. These accidents are almost never the train crew's fault - [[WhatAnIdiot people try to beat trains over crossings]],[[TooDumbToLive play on the tracks]], or just commit suicide. This is traumatic enough for someone sitting in a cab; many engineers suffer from PTSD, and a few have even [[DrivenToSuicide taken their own lives.]] Now imagine being a sentient engine able to ''feel'' the metal crumple under your buffers. How many engines have been traumatized with the knowledge that they accidentally ''killed'' someone?

to:

* New train engineers are often told that at some point in their career their train will kill someone. These accidents are almost never the train crew's fault - [[WhatAnIdiot people try to beat trains over crossings]],[[TooDumbToLive crossings]], [[TooDumbToLive play on the tracks]], or just commit suicide. This is traumatic enough for someone sitting in a cab; many engineers suffer from PTSD, and a few have even [[DrivenToSuicide taken their own lives.]] Now imagine being a sentient engine able to ''feel'' the metal crumple under your buffers. How many engines have been traumatized with the knowledge that they accidentally ''killed'' someone?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Well, in the books Thomas went off the rails and onto the road first before crashing into the house, so it was probably an oversight on the TV producers.

to:

** Well, in the books Thomas went off the rails and onto the road first before crashing into the house, so it was probably an oversight on the TV producers. Then again, that siding near the road had no buffers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Some keen watches have noted that the flashbacks in ''Blue Mountain Mystery'' weren't completely accurate to the episodes they were based on. Of course they weren't; the flashbacks were described by the engines, whose memories were unlikely to accurately recall the minor details.

to:

* Some keen watches fans have noted that the flashbacks in ''Blue Mountain Mystery'' weren't completely accurate to the episodes they were based on. Of course they weren't; the flashbacks were described by the engines, whose memories were unlikely to accurately recall the minor details.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Some keen watches have noted that the flashbacks in ''Blue Mountain Mystery'' weren't completely accurate to the episodes they were based on. Of course they weren't; the flashbacks were described by the engines, whose memories were unlikely to accurately recall the minor details.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Similar cases are shown throughout the series, such as a barber's house and a chocolate factory. Worth noting that none of them even have buffers, just a track leading straight towards the building. TemptingFate enough?

to:

** Similar cases are shown throughout the series, such as a barber's house and a chocolate factory. Worth noting that none of them even have buffers, just a track leading straight towards the building. TemptingFate enough?enough?
** Well, in the books Thomas went off the rails and onto the road first before crashing into the house, so it was probably an oversight on the TV producers.

Top