Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / TheCityWithoutMemory

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The fate of His Rulership isn’t stated in the epilogue since ''there are no big changes in his life''. Because, all things considered, he’s still the best option for a ruler. He knows the political situation (the rememberers, for all their cleverness, only rely on what their spies can spot), he knows the strengths and weaknesses of every fraction in his madhouse of a court, he has survived forty-four plots and three rebellions, and as he sees the rememberers are rising to power and getting help from outer space, he will be able make peace with them, since he is actually well-read himself and understands the value of knowledge.

to:

** The fate of His Rulership isn’t stated in the epilogue since ''there are no big changes in his life''. Because, all things considered, he’s still the best option for a ruler. He knows the political situation (the rememberers, for all their cleverness, only rely on what their spies can spot), he knows the strengths and weaknesses of every fraction in his madhouse of a court, he has survived forty-four plots and three rebellions, and as he sees the rememberers are rising to power and getting help from outer space, he will be able to make peace with them, since he is actually well-read himself and understands the value of knowledge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Veri-Meri’s memory in the epilogue is in a much better state than it appears to be. First, there is the rather confusing description of his memory-wipe execution, concluding with a DisneyDeath, and then the epilogue reveals he has survived after all. Second, there is that SuspiciouslySpecificDenial in the epilogue: he swears he remembers absolutely nothing (and by that moment the readers are aware of [[SarcasmMode the value]] of his sworn word). Finally, by the time of the ending, an actual cure to memory loss is found. Knowing him, he’ll figure it out even if he has really lost his memory (as the author has shown in other cases of AmnesiacResonance, he can hardly lose his brains). So either Veri-Meri has realized that [[CheatersNeverProsper his previous life hasn’t been that great]], or he’s simply biding his time for who knows what opportunities.

to:

** Veri-Meri’s memory in the epilogue is in a much better state than it appears to be. First, there is the rather confusing description of his memory-wipe execution, concluding with a DisneyDeath, DisneyVillainDeath, and then the epilogue reveals he has survived after all. Second, there is that SuspiciouslySpecificDenial in the epilogue: he swears he remembers absolutely nothing (and by that moment the readers are aware of [[SarcasmMode the value]] of his sworn word). Finally, by the time of the ending, an actual cure to memory loss is found. Knowing him, he’ll figure it out even if he has really lost his memory (as the author has shown in other cases of AmnesiacResonance, he can hardly lose his brains). So either Veri-Meri has realized that [[CheatersNeverProsper his previous life hasn’t been that great]], or he’s simply biding his time for who knows what opportunities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Veri-Meri’s memory in the epilogue is in a much better state than it appears to be. First, there is the rather confusing description of his memory-wipe execution, concluding with a DisneyDeath, and then the epilogue reveals he has survived after all. Second, there is that SuspiciouslySpecificDenial in the epilogue: he swears he remembers absolutely nothing (and by that moment the readers are aware of [[SarcasmMode the value]] of his sworn word). Finally, by the time of the ending, in addition to AmnesiacResonance, an actual cure to memory loss is found. So either Veri-Meri has realized that [[CheatersNeverProsper his previous life hasn’t been that great]], or he’s simply biding his time for who knows what opportunities.

to:

** Veri-Meri’s memory in the epilogue is in a much better state than it appears to be. First, there is the rather confusing description of his memory-wipe execution, concluding with a DisneyDeath, and then the epilogue reveals he has survived after all. Second, there is that SuspiciouslySpecificDenial in the epilogue: he swears he remembers absolutely nothing (and by that moment the readers are aware of [[SarcasmMode the value]] of his sworn word). Finally, by the time of the ending, in addition to AmnesiacResonance, an actual cure to memory loss is found.found. Knowing him, he’ll figure it out even if he has really lost his memory (as the author has shown in other cases of AmnesiacResonance, he can hardly lose his brains). So either Veri-Meri has realized that [[CheatersNeverProsper his previous life hasn’t been that great]], or he’s simply biding his time for who knows what opportunities.

Added: 733

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** How did the Moles make it out of the whole mess alive, after being actually sentenced to death and with their ZeroPercentApprovalRating reputation a close second to everybody's hatred for Veri-Meri or Bug the Celestial? However, their unicorns must have found them – the same unicorns who were last seen carrying off Brook and Squirrel. The rememberers are just as mad at the Moles as everyone else, but Squirrel could have interceded on their behalf (as she always does in the novel), and everyone at the Shelter wants to build bridges instead of making more war. That fits nicely with the brothers' whole BreakTheHaughty arc, and probably made them realize (or at least begin to) what a treasure they have for a sister.

to:

** How did the Moles make it out of the whole mess alive, after being actually sentenced to death and with their ZeroPercentApprovalRating reputation a close second to everybody's hatred for Veri-Meri or Bug the Celestial? However, their Their unicorns must have found them – the same unicorns who were last seen carrying off Brook and Squirrel. The rememberers are just as mad at the Moles as everyone else, but Squirrel could have interceded on their behalf (as she always does in the novel), and everyone at the Shelter wants to build bridges instead of making more war. That fits nicely with the brothers' whole BreakTheHaughty arc, and probably made them realize (or at least begin to) what a treasure they have for a sister.


Added DiffLines:

** Veri-Meri’s memory in the epilogue is in a much better state than it appears to be. First, there is the rather confusing description of his memory-wipe execution, concluding with a DisneyDeath, and then the epilogue reveals he has survived after all. Second, there is that SuspiciouslySpecificDenial in the epilogue: he swears he remembers absolutely nothing (and by that moment the readers are aware of [[SarcasmMode the value]] of his sworn word). Finally, by the time of the ending, in addition to AmnesiacResonance, an actual cure to memory loss is found. So either Veri-Meri has realized that [[CheatersNeverProsper his previous life hasn’t been that great]], or he’s simply biding his time for who knows what opportunities.

Changed: -3

Removed: 1154

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This is more like Headscratchers


** It’s doubtful that the kingdom of Radiculitis and the Shelter of the Rememberers are the only inhabited places on the planet. Most likely, there are still hundreds of such little countries scattered around the globe, and bringing them out of MedievalStasis might take much more than the six years that pass between the ending and the epilogue.
** What are the origins of the atani and the Altos birds? The Krinians in ''The End of Atlantis'' make no mention of them. Have they always existed on Krina? Or are they, for instance, the descendants of other aliens who were visiting Krina at the time of the grand memory wipe?
** Are the unicorns sentient? Centipede and her sons seem to be able to communicate with them, and they show remarkable intelligence (they run away because they don’t want the war, then they manage to find Squirrel in a large city, etc.).
** Dr. Crack is an atani with a Krinian name. How did he end up in the Shelter? It’s doubtful that he was stolen from his parents – the atani would have hardly been so nice with people who stole their kids (see the Brilliance section above), and the kidnapping, judging by what we know about the pygmies, would have been nigh impossible. Was he an abandoned or orphaned child? Or was he bought at a slave market by an agent of the Shelter? Or was he maybe a slave in a Krinian household who got kidnapped along with the master’s children? Or did he initially find the Shelter because he fell in love with one of the agents (now his wife)?

to:

** It’s doubtful that the kingdom of Radiculitis and the Shelter of the Rememberers are the only inhabited places on the planet. Most likely, there are still hundreds of such little countries scattered around the globe, and bringing them out of MedievalStasis might take much more than the six years that pass between the ending and the epilogue. \n** What are the origins of the atani and the Altos birds? The Krinians in ''The End of Atlantis'' make no mention of them. Have they always existed on Krina? Or are they, for instance, the descendants of other aliens who were visiting Krina at the time of the grand memory wipe?\n** Are the unicorns sentient? Centipede and her sons seem to be able to communicate with them, and they show remarkable intelligence (they run away because they don’t want the war, then they manage to find Squirrel in a large city, etc.).\n** Dr. Crack is an atani with a Krinian name. How did he end up in the Shelter? It’s doubtful that he was stolen from his parents – the atani would have hardly been so nice with people who stole their kids (see the Brilliance section above), and the kidnapping, judging by what we know about the pygmies, would have been nigh impossible. Was he an abandoned or orphaned child? Or was he bought at a slave market by an agent of the Shelter? Or was he maybe a slave in a Krinian household who got kidnapped along with the master’s children? Or did he initially find the Shelter because he fell in love with one of the agents (now his wife)?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If Alice and Pashka hadn't discovered the Krinian explorers in ''The End of Atlantis'', the planet would have still remained forgotten. Which means there would have been no SpannerInTheWorks to thwart Radiculitis's plans of a great war with the Shelter. The rememberers aren't quite so helpless (for instance, they have the Altos avians on their side, and they have already discovered electricity), but they're outnumbered by the poklons plus the AngryMob. Anyway, no matter who'd have won, there would have been a huge loss of life. And no chance of breaking the MedievalStasis anytime soon.

Added: 778

Changed: -4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Shelter and the atani have some official sort of truce, which includes "you leave our adults in peace and we don’t kidnap your kids”.



** Are the unicorns sentient? Centipede and her sons seem to be able to communicate with them, and they show remarkable intelligence (they run away because they don’t want the war, then they manage to find Squirrel in a large city, etc.).

to:

** Are the unicorns sentient? Centipede and her sons seem to be able to communicate with them, and they show remarkable intelligence (they run away because they don’t want the war, then they manage to find Squirrel in a large city, etc.).).
** Dr. Crack is an atani with a Krinian name. How did he end up in the Shelter? It’s doubtful that he was stolen from his parents – the atani would have hardly been so nice with people who stole their kids (see the Brilliance section above), and the kidnapping, judging by what we know about the pygmies, would have been nigh impossible. Was he an abandoned or orphaned child? Or was he bought at a slave market by an agent of the Shelter? Or was he maybe a slave in a Krinian household who got kidnapped along with the master’s children? Or did he initially find the Shelter because he fell in love with one of the agents (now his wife)?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** How did the Moles make it out of the whole mess alive, after being actually sentenced to death and with their ZeroPercentApprovalRating reputation a close second to everybody's hatred for Veri-Meri or Bug the Celestial? However, their unicorns must have found them – the same unicorns who were last seen carrying off Brook and Squirrel. The rememberers are just as mad at the Moles as everyone else, but Squirrel could have interceded on their behalf, and everyone at the Shelter wants to build bridges instead of making more war. That fits nicely with the brothers' whole BreakTheHaughty arc, and probably made them realize (or at least begin to) what a treasure they have for a sister.

to:

** How did the Moles make it out of the whole mess alive, after being actually sentenced to death and with their ZeroPercentApprovalRating reputation a close second to everybody's hatred for Veri-Meri or Bug the Celestial? However, their unicorns must have found them – the same unicorns who were last seen carrying off Brook and Squirrel. The rememberers are just as mad at the Moles as everyone else, but Squirrel could have interceded on their behalf, behalf (as she always does in the novel), and everyone at the Shelter wants to build bridges instead of making more war. That fits nicely with the brothers' whole BreakTheHaughty arc, and probably made them realize (or at least begin to) what a treasure they have for a sister.

Added: 1531

Changed: 1494

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeBrilliance: The fate of His Rulership isn’t stated in the epilogue since ''there are no big changes in his life''. Because, all things considered, he’s still the best option for a ruler. He knows the political situation (the rememberers, for all their cleverness, only rely on what their spies can spot), he knows the strengths and weaknesses of every fraction in his madhouse of a court, he has survived forty-four plots and three rebellions, and as he sees the rememberers are rising to power and getting help from outer space, he will be able make peace with them, since he is actually well-read himself and understands the value of knowledge.
* FridgeHorror: All the DeliberateValuesDissonance that gets glossed over for the sake of the series' younger readers.

to:

* FridgeBrilliance: FridgeBrilliance:
**
The fate of His Rulership isn’t stated in the epilogue since ''there are no big changes in his life''. Because, all things considered, he’s still the best option for a ruler. He knows the political situation (the rememberers, for all their cleverness, only rely on what their spies can spot), he knows the strengths and weaknesses of every fraction in his madhouse of a court, he has survived forty-four plots and three rebellions, and as he sees the rememberers are rising to power and getting help from outer space, he will be able make peace with them, since he is actually well-read himself and understands the value of knowledge.
** How did the Moles make it out of the whole mess alive, after being actually sentenced to death and with their ZeroPercentApprovalRating reputation a close second to everybody's hatred for Veri-Meri or Bug the Celestial? However, their unicorns must have found them – the same unicorns who were last seen carrying off Brook and Squirrel. The rememberers are just as mad at the Moles as everyone else, but Squirrel could have interceded on their behalf, and everyone at the Shelter wants to build bridges instead of making more war. That fits nicely with the brothers' whole BreakTheHaughty arc, and probably made them realize (or at least begin to) what a treasure they have for a sister.
* FridgeHorror: All the grim implications, and especially the DeliberateValuesDissonance that gets glossed over for the sake of the series' younger readers.



** The slave market. Hundreds of atani families get broken apart due to being sold to different owners. And the prospective buyers frown at the high prices because atani slaves ''die like flies''.

to:

** The slave market. Especially for the pygmies: if a Krinian slave can hope to rise above their status (Veri-Meri advertises Iria as a possible wife for a rich man – not the worst fate for a woman in this reality), an atani can't (Veri-Meri being the only known exception). Hundreds of atani families get broken apart due to being sold to different owners. And the prospective buyers frown at the high prices because atani slaves ''die like flies''.
** The initial memory wipe in the past: everyone on the planet becoming a BlankSlate in an instant, without any warning. How many people must have died in the course of the very first ''hours''? Hundreds must have simply fallen into a river, like poor Mercury, or out of a window; and that's without bringing up electrocution, vehicle crashes, etc. And what about especially high-risk areas, such as atomic reactors, medical labs, or safari parks? If you think about it, it's a wonder that anyone had survived at all and that the survivors managed to develop all the way to the medieval stage (most probably, thanks to the fact that some memories, reflexes and skills can be retained).

Added: 1139

Changed: 23

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeHorror: All the DeliberateValuesDissonance that gets glossed over for the sake of the series' younger readers.
** Centipede’s marriage. It turned the beautiful kind girl into an obese ugly woman who doesn’t care for her daughter, hardly tries to influence her sons and "is tired of everyone" – one can only imagine what went on in-between.
** Squirrel’s life before she escapes. For sixteen years she is abused, physically and psychologically: her father beats her, her brothers bully her, and her mother ignores her. Veri-Meri is the only one to keep her company… and constantly tries to either coax or frighten her into marrying him (on top of the rest, he is at the very least fifteen years her senior). And one can’t help thinking whether the MindRape could get physical too, because there’s that moment when Brook says (in an already friendly chat) he won’t hurt Squirrel, tries to stroke her hair, and she instantly jerks away.
** The slave market. Hundreds of atani families get broken apart due to being sold to different owners. And the prospective buyers frown at the high prices because atani slaves ''die like flies''.



** It’s doubtful that the kingdom of Radiculitis and the Shelter of the Rememberers are the only inhabited places on the planet. Most likely, there are still hundreds of such little countries, and bringing them out of MedievalStasis might take much more than the six years that pass between the ending and the epilogue.

to:

** It’s doubtful that the kingdom of Radiculitis and the Shelter of the Rememberers are the only inhabited places on the planet. Most likely, there are still hundreds of such little countries, countries scattered around the globe, and bringing them out of MedievalStasis might take much more than the six years that pass between the ending and the epilogue.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->''No, this planet needs a large separate expedition.''
-->--'''Pashka Geraskin'''
!! Warning: Unmarked spoilers ahead
* FridgeBrilliance: The fate of His Rulership isn’t stated in the epilogue since ''there are no big changes in his life''. Because, all things considered, he’s still the best option for a ruler. He knows the political situation (the rememberers, for all their cleverness, only rely on what their spies can spot), he knows the strengths and weaknesses of every fraction in his madhouse of a court, he has survived forty-four plots and three rebellions, and as he sees the rememberers are rising to power and getting help from outer space, he will be able make peace with them, since he is actually well-read himself and understands the value of knowledge.
* FridgeLogic:
** It’s doubtful that the kingdom of Radiculitis and the Shelter of the Rememberers are the only inhabited places on the planet. Most likely, there are still hundreds of such little countries, and bringing them out of MedievalStasis might take much more than the six years that pass between the ending and the epilogue.
** What are the origins of the atani and the Altos birds? The Krinians in ''The End of Atlantis'' make no mention of them. Have they always existed on Krina? Or are they, for instance, the descendants of other aliens who were visiting Krina at the time of the grand memory wipe?
** Are the unicorns sentient? Centipede and her sons seem to be able to communicate with them, and they show remarkable intelligence (they run away because they don’t want the war, then they manage to find Squirrel in a large city, etc.).

Top