Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / RogueOne

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why the Death Troopers are not mentioned or seen in any other canon of the franchise? Well, since they are cyborgs, it is likely that they cost a fortune to create and train, making their menbership of the Imperial Army very small, so it's possible that the ones in Scariff when Tarkin ordered the planet's destrucction were all of them. Another possibility was that the instructions to create them were also on Scariff, so when Tarkin blew the planet those were also destroyed and the Empire didn´t know how to make more, making any survivor irreplaceable after being destroyed. Any way, the Death Troopers are doomed to canonical extinction.

to:

* Why the Death Troopers are not mentioned or seen in any other canon of the franchise? Well, since they are cyborgs, it is likely that they cost a fortune to create and train, making their menbership membership of the Imperial Army very small, so it's possible that the ones in Scariff when Tarkin ordered the planet's destrucction destruction were all of them. Another possibility was that the instructions to create them were also on Scariff, so when Tarkin blew the planet those were also destroyed and the Empire didn´t know how to make more, making any survivor irreplaceable after being destroyed. Any way, the Death Troopers are doomed to canonical extinction.




to:

* Jyn bluffs Krennic when they finally meet because as we see later, she hadn't send the data yet. From her point of view she could probably see Cassian coming up behind him and went with that lie to throw him off and keep him from doing something till Cassian acted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* (This may have been shown in some other materials, but it’s really well showcased in this movie) In Rogue One, we finally find out why Star Destroyers are named Star Destroyers. It’s because Imperials like parking them ''over'' troublesome cities like Jedha. This has the sheer intimidation factor of ''blotting out the sun'', which to lesser species, ''is'' destroying a star.

to:

* (This may have been shown in some other materials, but it’s really well showcased in this movie) In Rogue One, we We finally find out why Star Destroyers are named Star Destroyers. It’s because Imperials like parking them ''over'' troublesome cities like Jedha. This has the sheer intimidation factor of ''blotting out the sun'', which to lesser species, ''is'' destroying a star.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He may also just have been ''[[TranquilFury angry]]''. His orders are to keep the death star a secret, to the point where - as discussed earlier on this page - the empire may have had to present Scarif as a rebel victory. Combined with Scarif's [[TheGuardsMustBeCrazy absolutely pathetic ground troops]] ''and'' [[IDidWhatIHadToDo his own act of destroying the empire's archives]], his decision to vaporize Alderaan may have been motivated by sheer ''[[EvilIsPetty pettiness]]'' -- he ordered the deaths of [[MisplacedRetribution millions of innocents]] to ''[[ItsPersonal vent]]'', knowing if the empire complained he'd have an excuse ready.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The AT-ACT taken down by a U-Wing also has a precise explanation in the ExpandedUniverse: between the sheer size and the weight of both vehicle and (when loaded) cargo, the AT-ACT is more unstable and structurally fragile than the AT-AT and needs tensor fields in the knee joints for the legs to not snap and collapse under the vehicle's own weight, and when the U-Wing gunner spotted a loaded one [[AttackItsWeakPoint he used his technology-disabling ion blaster precisely to disable a tensor field]]. And when that happened, the unsupported knee had to sustain nearly the entire weight of the walker and the ''thousands of tonnes of cargo''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** According to the novelization, that is actually one of the factors at play: Scarif was seen as an easy posting, and most of the Imperials there had grown lazy, with the officers expecting that if it ever happened anything it would be swiftly dealt by the orbiting Star Destroyers and the shield, not realizing the Star Destroyers' crews had also grown lazy (enough to not maintain a CAP and to fail to scramble their [=TIEs=] during the battle). The only Imperials who were actually up to standards were the Dark Troopers, who weren't actually part of the local garrison, and ''the rank-and-file crew of the gate station'', who had taken the initiative to drill themselves into peak efficiency while their officers lazed away. Thus while the gate station reacted swiftly to the attack and nearly screwed the Rebel attack when their fighters scrambled and engaged the Rebels', the ground garrison panicked and performed badly, and only started reacting decently when Krennic, an outsider, saw the mess and took over.

to:

*** According to the novelization, that is actually one of the factors at play: Scarif was seen as an easy posting, and most of the Imperials there had grown lazy, with the officers expecting that if it ever happened anything it would be swiftly dealt by the orbiting Star Destroyers and the shield, not realizing the Star Destroyers' crews had also grown lazy (enough to not maintain a CAP and to fail to scramble their [=TIEs=] during the battle). The only Imperials who were actually up to standards were the Dark Death Troopers, who weren't actually part of the local garrison, and ''the rank-and-file crew of the gate station'', who had taken the initiative to drill themselves into peak efficiency while their officers lazed away. Thus while the gate station reacted swiftly to the attack and nearly screwed the Rebel attack when their fighters scrambled and engaged the Rebels', the ground garrison panicked and performed badly, and only started reacting decently when Krennic, an outsider, saw the mess and took over.

Added: 1316

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The visual guide confirms that the Imperials by large did ''not'' expect a battle there, and that if anyone were to attack Scarif they would be ineffective due the presence of the planetary shield and two Star Destroyers. As a result, most of the Imperial troops, including the Star Destroyers' crews, react sluggishly and slowly and are caught unprepared, with the only ones operating as they should being Krennic, who is an outsider and in trouble with the higher-ups, his Death Troopers, who are not only outsiders but [[EliteMook some of the best troops the Empire has]], and the gate station ''rank and file'', [[ProperlyParanoid who took the initiative of holding drills and training to keep themselves up to par in case the Rebels actually attacked]] and actually performed well, first locking the shield almost as soon as the Rebels arrive (though not in time to keep some of Blue Squadron to pass through) and then scrambling their [=TIEs=] in just a few minutes, the latter almost dooming the Rebel fleet to destruction when they kept most of their fighters from making runs on the otherwise unstoppable Star Destroyers (Gold Squadron mentions specifically an opening before hitting the ''Persecutor'' with the ion torpedoes, having lucked out on that) and even making their own runs on the Rebel ships.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A part of it is that what the Rebels used on Hoth and Scarif were much different vehicles: on Hoth the Rebels used the airspeeder equivalent of ''technicals'' ([[TechnicallyATransport the T-47 being originally an unarmed cargo handler equipped only with a magnetic harpoon launcher and tow cable to move cargo containers that the Rebels uparmored and equipped with laser cannons) supported by antiquated anti-vehicle cannons intended to deal with much lighter and smaller targets, but on Scarif they used actual military vehicles, that is [=UT60D=] U-Wings (heavily armed assault transports) and X-Wings (multi-purpose fighters capable of engaging light ''warships'' with their guns alone). The Imperial force on Hoth was dealing with weapons barely able to scratch the paintjob and was effectively unstoppable, while the one on Scarif was savaged by the heaviest weapons the Alliance had.

to:

** A part of it is that what the Rebels used on Hoth and Scarif were much different vehicles: on Hoth the Rebels used the airspeeder equivalent of ''technicals'' ([[TechnicallyATransport the T-47 being originally an unarmed cargo handler equipped only with a magnetic harpoon launcher and tow cable to move cargo containers that the Rebels uparmored and equipped with laser cannons) cannons]]) supported by antiquated anti-vehicle cannons intended to deal with much lighter and smaller targets, but on Scarif they used actual military vehicles, that is [=UT60D=] U-Wings (heavily armed assault transports) and X-Wings (multi-purpose fighters capable of engaging light ''warships'' with their guns alone). The Imperial force on Hoth was dealing with weapons barely able to scratch the paintjob and was effectively unstoppable, while the one on Scarif was savaged by the heaviest weapons the Alliance had.

Added: 892

Changed: 1701

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A part of it is that what the Rebels used on Hoth and Scarif were much different vehicles: on Hoth the Rebels used the airspeeder equivalent of ''technicals'' (the T-47 being originally an unarmed ''cargo handler'' equipped only with a magnetic harpoon launcher and tow cable to move cargo containers that the Rebels equipped with laser cannons) supported by antiquated anti-vehicle cannons intended to deal with much lighter and smaller targets, but on Scarif they used actual military vehicles, that is [=UT60D=] U-Wings (heavily armed assault transports) and X-Wings (multi-purpose fighters capable of engaging light ''warships'' with their guns alone). The Imperial force on Hoth was dealing with weapons barely able to scratch the paintjob and was effectively unstoppable, while the one on Scarif was savaged by the heaviest weapons the Alliance had.

to:

*** According to the novelization, that is actually one of the factors at play: Scarif was seen as an easy posting, and most of the Imperials there had grown lazy, with the officers expecting that if it ever happened anything it would be swiftly dealt by the orbiting Star Destroyers and the shield, not realizing the Star Destroyers' crews had also grown lazy (enough to not maintain a CAP and to fail to scramble their [=TIEs=] during the battle). The only Imperials who were actually up to standards were the Dark Troopers, who weren't actually part of the local garrison, and ''the rank-and-file crew of the gate station'', who had taken the initiative to drill themselves into peak efficiency while their officers lazed away. Thus while the gate station reacted swiftly to the attack and nearly screwed the Rebel attack when their fighters scrambled and engaged the Rebels', the ground garrison panicked and performed badly, and only started reacting decently when Krennic, an outsider, saw the mess and took over.
** A part of it is that what the Rebels used on Hoth and Scarif were much different vehicles: on Hoth the Rebels used the airspeeder equivalent of ''technicals'' (the ([[TechnicallyATransport the T-47 being originally an unarmed ''cargo handler'' cargo handler equipped only with a magnetic harpoon launcher and tow cable to move cargo containers that the Rebels uparmored and equipped with laser cannons) supported by antiquated anti-vehicle cannons intended to deal with much lighter and smaller targets, but on Scarif they used actual military vehicles, that is [=UT60D=] U-Wings (heavily armed assault transports) and X-Wings (multi-purpose fighters capable of engaging light ''warships'' with their guns alone). The Imperial force on Hoth was dealing with weapons barely able to scratch the paintjob and was effectively unstoppable, while the one on Scarif was savaged by the heaviest weapons the Alliance had.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Aside from the obvious DoubleMeaningTitle, why would the writers call the team Rogue One when there's [[NamesTheSame the similarly named]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rogue_squadron Rogue Squadron]]? Well, considering all the main cast die at the end of this film, Rogue Squadron is almost certainly named as a tribute to the fallen heroes. Based on the tone, setting, and characters -- from the slightly-firmer science, the martial focus, and the hard-edged RagtagBunchOfMisfits -- this movie's team and operation could be seen as the [[SpiritualSuccessor Spiritual Predecessor]] of the [[Literature/XwingSeries Rogue and Wraith Squadron novels' heroes]] and ''VideoGame/RogueSquadron'' games. Said novels and games are considered non-canon and part of the ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' brand now, but the Rogue Squadron does exist canonically, first appearing in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'', which takes place some time after the destruction of the Death Star.

to:

* Aside from the obvious DoubleMeaningTitle, why would the writers call the team Rogue One when there's [[NamesTheSame the similarly named]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rogue_squadron Rogue Squadron]]? Well, considering all the main cast die at the end of this film, Rogue Squadron is almost certainly named as a tribute to the fallen heroes. Based on the tone, setting, and characters -- from the slightly-firmer science, the martial focus, and the hard-edged RagtagBunchOfMisfits -- this movie's team and operation could be seen as the [[SpiritualSuccessor Spiritual Predecessor]] of the [[Literature/XwingSeries [[Literature/XWingSeries Rogue and Wraith Squadron novels' heroes]] and ''VideoGame/RogueSquadron'' games. Said novels and games are considered non-canon and part of the ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' brand now, but the Rogue Squadron does exist canonically, first appearing in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'', which takes place some time after the destruction of the Death Star.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Aside from the obvious DoubleMeaningTitle, why would the writers call the team Rogue One when there's [[NamesTheSame the similarly named]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rogue_squadron Rogue Squadron]]? Well, considering all the main cast die at the end of this film, Rogue Squadron is almost certainly named as a tribute to the fallen heroes. Based on the tone, setting, and characters -- from the slightly-firmer science, the martial focus, and the hard-edged RagtagBunchOfMisfits -- this movie's team and operation could be seen as the [[SpiritualSuccessor Spiritual Predecessor]] of the [[ComicBook/XwingSeries Rogue and Wraith Squadron novels' heroes]] and ''VideoGame/RogueSquadron'' games. Said novels and games are considered non-canon and part of the ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' brand now, but the Rogue Squadron does exist canonically, first appearing in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'', which takes place some time after the destruction of the Death Star.

to:

* Aside from the obvious DoubleMeaningTitle, why would the writers call the team Rogue One when there's [[NamesTheSame the similarly named]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rogue_squadron Rogue Squadron]]? Well, considering all the main cast die at the end of this film, Rogue Squadron is almost certainly named as a tribute to the fallen heroes. Based on the tone, setting, and characters -- from the slightly-firmer science, the martial focus, and the hard-edged RagtagBunchOfMisfits -- this movie's team and operation could be seen as the [[SpiritualSuccessor Spiritual Predecessor]] of the [[ComicBook/XwingSeries [[Literature/XwingSeries Rogue and Wraith Squadron novels' heroes]] and ''VideoGame/RogueSquadron'' games. Said novels and games are considered non-canon and part of the ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' brand now, but the Rogue Squadron does exist canonically, first appearing in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'', which takes place some time after the destruction of the Death Star.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** KieronGillen's superlative ''Darth Vader'' series bridged the gap between ''A New Hope'' and ''The Empire Strikes Back'', demonstrating that Vader's suddenly more confident, menacing role came about after finding out he had a son and finding new purpose in the quest to find said son, establish a coup within the Empire and seize control for himself. The series also includes The Emperor chewing Vader out for his lack of initiative and failure to protect the Death Star. By that logic, we can surmise that the years between the events of ''Revenge of the Sith'' and ''A New Hope'' had him passionless and demotivated - and this film gives us a glance at that. Whether it's his own decision or the Emperor's, he spends all his free time in a Bacta Tank on Mustafar because he literally has nothing else to do; he's a living weapon that the Emperor points at things to make them go away. He gets his mojo back briefly when he has the chance to intimidate/threaten/pursue/destroy things, but otherwise, without loved ones, he sees no point in making the effort.

to:

** KieronGillen's Creator/KieronGillen's superlative ''Darth Vader'' series bridged the gap between ''A New Hope'' and ''The Empire Strikes Back'', demonstrating that Vader's suddenly more confident, menacing role came about after finding out he had a son and finding new purpose in the quest to find said son, establish a coup within the Empire and seize control for himself. The series also includes The Emperor chewing Vader out for his lack of initiative and failure to protect the Death Star. By that logic, we can surmise that the years between the events of ''Revenge of the Sith'' and ''A New Hope'' had him passionless and demotivated - and this film gives us a glance at that. Whether it's his own decision or the Emperor's, he spends all his free time in a Bacta Tank on Mustafar because he literally has nothing else to do; he's a living weapon that the Emperor points at things to make them go away. He gets his mojo back briefly when he has the chance to intimidate/threaten/pursue/destroy things, but otherwise, without loved ones, he sees no point in making the effort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** There's also a third reason for Tarkin to not use the full power of the Death Star on Jedha: by showing "mercy" on the lesser target he's prompting the Rebels to give up and surrender in hope of being spared. A strategy that, as we know, ''was actually working'' until the destruction of the Death Star changed the game.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** This also explains why Tarkin wanted to attack Yavin 4 directly, rather than simply destroying Yavin itself. The Battle of Yavin was the Death Star's first public attack on a military base, and Tarkin wanted to show the rebels that his weapon could withstand any attempt to destroy it. Oops.

Added: 1243

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's also two more [[PragmaticEvil practical]] reasons to use the full power on Alderaan and not Jedha and Scarif: the first is visibility, as Alderaan is a rich and politically important Core World and a founding member of the Republic, so its utter annihilation would have much more impact than a Mid Rim desert moon only important to the few who still believed in the Force (Jedha) or a nearly unknown Outer Rim planet in an exclusion zone used as a stronghold (Scarif); the second is that Alderaan has a fully functional planetary shield (that actually resists for all of a tenth of a second before the Death Star's superlaser penetrates and blows up Alderaan), and casually blowing up a planet through a defense meant to resist for days against hundreds of warships throwing at it everything they have has much more effect than doing it to a planet with a compromised shield (Scarif, whose shield was malfunctioning after the gate's destruction) or an unshielded moon (Jedha). The latter is likely one of the reasons Leia would believe Tarkin when he let her think he'd spare Alderaan if she gave up the Rebel base' location: Dantoiine, being an important world and a location of a battle in the Clone Wars, likely had a shield too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When the heroes are running like hell for their ship to escape the wave of destruction from the ''Death Star'''s annihilation of Jedha City, Chirrut stays right on Baze's heels, much closer than the pair usually stick together. With so much noise generated by cracking, tumbling bounders grinding and crashing against one another, Baze's familiar footsteps are probably the ''only'' tangible cue the blind Chirrut has to direct his own flight to safety.

Added: 128

Changed: 16

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Aside from the obvious DoubleMeaningTitle, why would the writers call the team Rogue One when there's [[NamesTheSame the similarly named]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rogue_squadron Rogue Squadron]]? Well, considering all the main cast die at the end of this film, Rogue Squadron is almost certainly named as a tribute to the fallen heroes. Based on the tone, setting, and characters -- from the slightly-firmer science, the martial focus, and the hard-edged RagtagBunchOfMisfits -- this movie's team and operation could be seen as the [[SpiritualSuccessor Spiritual Predecessor]] of the [[ComicBook/XwingSeries Rogue and Wraith Squadron novels' heroes]] and ''VideoGame/RogueSquadron'' games. Said novels and games are considered non-canon and part of the ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' brand now, but the Rogue Squadron does exist canonically, in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'', which takes place some time after the destruction of the Death Star.

to:

* Aside from the obvious DoubleMeaningTitle, why would the writers call the team Rogue One when there's [[NamesTheSame the similarly named]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rogue_squadron Rogue Squadron]]? Well, considering all the main cast die at the end of this film, Rogue Squadron is almost certainly named as a tribute to the fallen heroes. Based on the tone, setting, and characters -- from the slightly-firmer science, the martial focus, and the hard-edged RagtagBunchOfMisfits -- this movie's team and operation could be seen as the [[SpiritualSuccessor Spiritual Predecessor]] of the [[ComicBook/XwingSeries Rogue and Wraith Squadron novels' heroes]] and ''VideoGame/RogueSquadron'' games. Said novels and games are considered non-canon and part of the ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' brand now, but the Rogue Squadron does exist canonically, first appearing in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'', which takes place some time after the destruction of the Death Star.Star.
** It's been since canonically confirmed that, indeed, Rogue Squadron was named as such as a tribute to the heroes of Rogue One.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Aside from the obvious DoubleMeaningTitle, why would the writers call the team Rogue One when there's [[NamesTheSame the similarly named]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rogue_squadron Rogue Squadron]]? Well, considering all the main cast die at the end of this film, Rogue Squadron is almost certainly named as a tribute to the fallen heroes. Based on the tone, setting, and characters -- from the slightly-firmer science, the martial focus, and the hard-edged RagtagBunchOfMisfits -- this movie could be seen as the [[SpiritualSuccessor Spiritual Predecessor]] of the [[ComicBook/XwingSeries Rogue and Wraith Squadron novels]] and ''VideoGame/RogueSquadron'' games. Said novels and games are considered non-canon and part of the ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' brand now, but the Rogue Squadron does exist canonically, in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'', which takes place some time after the destruction of the Death Star.

to:

* Aside from the obvious DoubleMeaningTitle, why would the writers call the team Rogue One when there's [[NamesTheSame the similarly named]] [[http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Rogue_squadron Rogue Squadron]]? Well, considering all the main cast die at the end of this film, Rogue Squadron is almost certainly named as a tribute to the fallen heroes. Based on the tone, setting, and characters -- from the slightly-firmer science, the martial focus, and the hard-edged RagtagBunchOfMisfits -- this movie movie's team and operation could be seen as the [[SpiritualSuccessor Spiritual Predecessor]] of the [[ComicBook/XwingSeries Rogue and Wraith Squadron novels]] novels' heroes]] and ''VideoGame/RogueSquadron'' games. Said novels and games are considered non-canon and part of the ''Franchise/StarWarsLegends'' brand now, but the Rogue Squadron does exist canonically, in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack'', which takes place some time after the destruction of the Death Star.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To add even more similarities, in the Legends-continuity novelization of ROTJ, Moff Jerrjerrod has orders of turning the superlaser of the Second Death Star onto the moon if the shield is deactivated.

to:

** To add even more similarities, in the Legends-continuity novelization of ROTJ, Moff Jerrjerrod has orders of turning the superlaser of the Second Death Star onto the moon if the shield is deactivated.deactivated, and indeed the superlaser is ''facing'' Endor at the time of its destruction (the ''Millennium Falcon'' flies towards the camera, with the laser face-on in the background, with the very next shot showing it flying towards the moon, with no sign of it turning between shots)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A part of it is that what the Rebels used on Hoth and Scarif were much different vehicles: on Hoth the Rebels used the airspeeder equivalent of ''technicals'' (the T-47 being originally an unarmed ''cargo handler'' equipped only with a magnetic harpoon launcher and tow cable to move cargo containers that the Rebels equipped with laser cannons) supported by antiquated anti-vehicle cannons intended to deal with much lighter and smaller targets, but on Scarif they used actual military vehicles, that is [=UT60D=] U-Wings (heavily armed assault transports) and X-Wings (multi-purpose fighters capable of engaging light ''warships'' with their guns alone). The Imperial force on Hoth was dealing with weapons barely able to scratch the paintjob and was effectively unstoppable, while the one on Scarif was savaged by the heaviest weapons the Alliance had.

Changed: 126

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Battle of Endor goes smoothly for the Empire at first because they ''learned'' from their experience on Scarif. The Empire was caught with their pants down when the Rogue One launched an unexpected ground assault, which was also a diversion for Jyn, Cassian, and Kaytoo to sneak into the Citadel to steal the plans. Meanwhile, the Rebel fleet led by Admiral Raddus launched a surprise attack on the unsuspecting Imperial Fleet above the planet and dealt a devastating blow. Even though most of the Rebels were annihilated, they were successful in their mission. Fast forward to Endor, the Empire ''knows'' the Rebels are desperate for any information regarding their superweapons, no matter how unreliable they are, so the Emperor deliberately creates a 'Scarif 2.0' situation, albeit this time the Empire sees it coming. He lets the Rebels take the Death Star II plans, killing quite a few Bothans to make the attempt convincing. He lets an Imperial Shuttle get stolen, knowing that it will be used to transport a small Rebel strike force to destroy the shield generator planetside. Then he lays the trap for them all. The Empire's 'best troops' wait for the Rebels to sneak inside the bunker (which limits their escape routes) before they spring the trap. The full might of the Imperial Fleet ambushes the Rebel fleet as soon as they break out of hyperspace. It all played out perfectly and the Empire has essentially won... except for one little minor detail. ''[[SpannerInTheWorks Scarif doesn't have Ewoks.]]'' The Rebels making friends with the Ewoks, leading to them assisting the Rebellion on the forest moon, was the one thing the Empire didn't see coming and didn't prepare for.
** To add even more similarities, in the Legends-continuity novelization of ROTJ, Moff Jerrjerrod plans on turning the superlaser of the Second Death Star onto the moon before the station is destroyed.

to:

* The Battle of Endor goes smoothly for the Empire at first because they ''learned'' from their experience on Scarif. The Empire was caught with their pants down when the Rogue One launched an unexpected ground assault, which was also a diversion for Jyn, Cassian, and Kaytoo to sneak into the Citadel to steal the plans. Meanwhile, the Rebel fleet led by Admiral Raddus launched a surprise attack on the unsuspecting Imperial Fleet above the planet and dealt a devastating blow. Even though most of the Rebels were annihilated, they were successful in their mission. Fast forward to Endor, the Empire ''knows'' the Rebels are desperate for any information regarding their superweapons, no matter how unreliable they are, so the Emperor deliberately creates a 'Scarif 2.0' situation, albeit this time the Empire sees it coming. He lets the Rebels take the Death Star II plans, killing quite a few Bothans to make the attempt convincing. He lets an Imperial Shuttle get stolen, knowing that it will be used to transport a small Rebel strike force to destroy the shield generator planetside. Then he lays the trap for them all. The Empire's 'best troops' wait for the Rebels to sneak inside the bunker (which limits their escape routes) before they spring the trap. The full might of the Death Squadron (the Imperial Fleet Fleet's elite, consisting of far more than the ''Executor'' and its escort) ambushes the Rebel fleet as soon as they break out of hyperspace. It all played out perfectly and the Empire has essentially won... except Except for one little minor detail. ''[[SpannerInTheWorks Scarif doesn't have Ewoks.]]'' The Rebels making friends with the Ewoks, leading to them assisting the Rebellion on the forest moon, was the one thing the Empire didn't see coming and didn't prepare for.
** To add even more similarities, in the Legends-continuity novelization of ROTJ, Moff Jerrjerrod plans on has orders of turning the superlaser of the Second Death Star onto the moon before if the station shield is destroyed.deactivated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And it's practically a ChekhovsGun to see Raddus's tactic work so well. Nearly forty years of ''Star Wars'', and we '''finally''' got to see why it's not smart to position your space warships in a tight formation when ''they're shaped like giant knives''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The vast majority of the people who hear that story are never going to be anywhere near Jedha or have any real idea of the level of destruction there. This isn't an example of, "It's plausible, therefore the mining equipment must be on an apocalyptic scale!" It's an example of, "This is an obvious cover story that nobody's going to check on close enough to doubt."


* It's a good thing (for the Rebel cause, at least) that the bulk of, if not all the Empire's Death Troopers were wiped out in the annihilation of Scarif. These relentless, coldly efficient and inhumanly resilient soldiers (that actually HIT what they're aiming for more often than not) would have made things considerably harder for Luke and co. through the course of the trilogy. ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'' in particular would have gone very differently if the Ewoks faced Death Troopers rather than the increasingly ineffective Stormtroopers.
* The Empire passes off the destruction of Jedha as a "mining catastrophe". There's every indication that they expect this story will be deemed entirely believable by the galaxy's unsuspecting civilian inhabitants. If a "mining catastrophe" can plausibly blast ''a huge chunk of planetary crust into orbit'', then what the freakin' hell kind of demolitions - never mind, safety standards - are routinely utilized in mining operations in the ''Star Wars'' 'verse?

to:

* It's a good thing (for the Rebel cause, at least) that the bulk of, if not all the Empire's Death Troopers were wiped out in the annihilation of Scarif. These relentless, coldly efficient and inhumanly resilient soldiers (that actually HIT what they're aiming for more often than not) would have made things considerably harder for Luke and co. through the course of the trilogy. ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'' in particular would have gone very differently if the Ewoks faced Death Troopers rather than the increasingly ineffective Stormtroopers.
* The Empire passes off the destruction of Jedha as a "mining catastrophe". There's every indication that they expect this story will be deemed entirely believable by the galaxy's unsuspecting civilian inhabitants. If a "mining catastrophe" can plausibly blast ''a huge chunk of planetary crust into orbit'', then what the freakin' hell kind of demolitions - never mind, safety standards - are routinely utilized in mining operations in the ''Star Wars'' 'verse?
Stormtroopers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's a good thing (for the Rebel cause, at least) that the bulk of, if not all the Empire's Death Troopers were wiped out in the annihilation of Scarif. These relentless, coldly efficient and inhumanly resilient soldiers (that actually HIT what they're aiming for more often than not) would have made things considerably harder for Luke and co. through the course of the trilogy. ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'' in particular would have gone very differently if the Ewoks faced Death Troopers rather than the increasingly ineffective Stormtroopers.

to:

* It's a good thing (for the Rebel cause, at least) that the bulk of, if not all the Empire's Death Troopers were wiped out in the annihilation of Scarif. These relentless, coldly efficient and inhumanly resilient soldiers (that actually HIT what they're aiming for more often than not) would have made things considerably harder for Luke and co. through the course of the trilogy. ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'' in particular would have gone very differently if the Ewoks faced Death Troopers rather than the increasingly ineffective Stormtroopers.Stormtroopers.
* The Empire passes off the destruction of Jedha as a "mining catastrophe". There's every indication that they expect this story will be deemed entirely believable by the galaxy's unsuspecting civilian inhabitants. If a "mining catastrophe" can plausibly blast ''a huge chunk of planetary crust into orbit'', then what the freakin' hell kind of demolitions - never mind, safety standards - are routinely utilized in mining operations in the ''Star Wars'' 'verse?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Not to mention that it gives weight to the theory that in spite of all that ''he was still only toying with Obi-Wan.'' He wanted to make him suffer like he suffered. Too bad [[HeroicSacrifice Obi-Wan found another way.]]

to:

** Not to mention that it gives weight to the theory that in spite of all that ''he was still only toying with Obi-Wan.'' Obi-Wan,'' the way he did with his son on Bespin. He wanted to make him suffer like he suffered. Too bad [[HeroicSacrifice Obi-Wan found another way.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Vader's not the only one in a bad mood in ''Film/ANewHope''. When Ponda Baba and Dr. Evazan are just itching to pick a fight with Luke, they're ''pissed'' at failing to pick a fight with Jyn a day or two earlier. Not to mention almost getting vaporised from orbit on Jedha. On that note, ancillary materials tell us precisely why they have death sentences in so many systems: they have been plying their trade for Saw Guerra's Partisans, making meat droid fighters out of captured imperials by plugging droid brains onto partially decapitated heads, which are later shows in ''Film/SoloAStarWarsStory''.

to:

* Vader's not the only one in a bad mood in ''Film/ANewHope''. When Ponda Baba and Dr. Evazan are just itching to pick a fight with Luke, they're ''pissed'' at failing to pick a fight with Jyn a day or two earlier. Not to mention almost getting vaporised from orbit on Jedha. On that note, ancillary materials tell us precisely why they have death sentences in so many systems: they have been plying their trade for Saw Guerra's Partisans, making meat droid fighters out of captured imperials by plugging droid brains onto partially decapitated heads, which are later shows shown on-screen in ''Film/SoloAStarWarsStory''.''[[Film/SoloAStarWarsStory Solo]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Vader's not the only one in a bad mood in ''Film/ANewHope''. When Ponda Baba and Dr. Evazan are just itching to pick a fight with Luke, they're ''pissed'' at failing to pick a fight with Jyn a day or two earlier. Not to mention almost getting vaporised from orbit on Jedha. On that note, ancillary materials tell us precisely why they have death sentences in so many systems: they have been plying their trade for Saw Guerra's Partisans, making meat droid fighters out of captured imperials by plugging droid brains onto partially decapitated heads, which are later shows in ''SoloAStarWarsStory''.

to:

* Vader's not the only one in a bad mood in ''Film/ANewHope''. When Ponda Baba and Dr. Evazan are just itching to pick a fight with Luke, they're ''pissed'' at failing to pick a fight with Jyn a day or two earlier. Not to mention almost getting vaporised from orbit on Jedha. On that note, ancillary materials tell us precisely why they have death sentences in so many systems: they have been plying their trade for Saw Guerra's Partisans, making meat droid fighters out of captured imperials by plugging droid brains onto partially decapitated heads, which are later shows in ''SoloAStarWarsStory''.''Film/SoloAStarWarsStory''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Vader's not the only one in a bad mood in ''Film/ANewHope''. When Ponda Baba and Dr. Evazan are just itching to pick a fight with Luke, they're ''pissed'' at failing to pick a fight with Jyn a day or two earlier. Not to mention almost getting vaporised from orbit on Jedha. On that note, ancillary materials tell us precisely why they have death sentences in so many systems: they have been plying their trade for Saw Guerra's Partisans, making meat droid fighters out of captured imperials by plugging droid brains onto partially decapitated heads.

to:

* Vader's not the only one in a bad mood in ''Film/ANewHope''. When Ponda Baba and Dr. Evazan are just itching to pick a fight with Luke, they're ''pissed'' at failing to pick a fight with Jyn a day or two earlier. Not to mention almost getting vaporised from orbit on Jedha. On that note, ancillary materials tell us precisely why they have death sentences in so many systems: they have been plying their trade for Saw Guerra's Partisans, making meat droid fighters out of captured imperials by plugging droid brains onto partially decapitated heads.heads, which are later shows in ''SoloAStarWarsStory''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fridge isn't What If, and this isn't anything we didn't already know decades ago.


* Darth Vader's MookHorrorShow against the Rebel squad at the end of this film sheds a new, terrifying light on his future confrontation with Han Solo in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''. Here, Vader goes through a heavily armed contingent of Rebel troops like they were nothing; if he didn't need Han and the rest as (living) bait for Luke Skywalker, he could have killed one of the cagiest, most bad ass gunslingers in the Star Wars lore with a wave of his gloved, cybernetic hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The blast door wasn't jammed. Vader ''was holding the door closed'' with The Force.

Added: 543

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Darth Vader's MookHorrorShow against the Rebel squad at the end of this film sheds a new, terrifying light on his future confrontation with Han Solo in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''. Here, Vader goes through a heavily armed contingent of Rebel troops like they were nothing; if he didn't need Han and the rest as (living) bait for Luke Skywalker, he could have killed one of the cagiest, most bad ass gunslingers in the Star Wars lore with a wave of his gloved, cybernetic hand.

to:

* Darth Vader's MookHorrorShow against the Rebel squad at the end of this film sheds a new, terrifying light on his future confrontation with Han Solo in ''Film/TheEmpireStrikesBack''. Here, Vader goes through a heavily armed contingent of Rebel troops like they were nothing; if he didn't need Han and the rest as (living) bait for Luke Skywalker, he could have killed one of the cagiest, most bad ass gunslingers in the Star Wars lore with a wave of his gloved, cybernetic hand.hand.
* It's a good thing (for the Rebel cause, at least) that the bulk of, if not all the Empire's Death Troopers were wiped out in the annihilation of Scarif. These relentless, coldly efficient and inhumanly resilient soldiers (that actually HIT what they're aiming for more often than not) would have made things considerably harder for Luke and co. through the course of the trilogy. ''Film/ReturnOfTheJedi'' in particular would have gone very differently if the Ewoks faced Death Troopers rather than the increasingly ineffective Stormtroopers.

Top