Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / PuellaMagiMadokaMagicaTheMovieRebellion

Go To

OR

Added: 229

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It took me 3 re-watches to realize this : "No matter what sin i commit and what form i take, it's all right as long you are near me". [[spoiler: This is the moment when Homura finally lose it and breaks down. And this is the moment in which Homura decide she will turn into Devil.]]

to:

* It took me 3 re-watches to realize this : "No matter what sin i commit and what form i take, it's all right as long you are near me". [[spoiler: This is the moment when Homura finally lose it and breaks down. And this is the moment in which Homura decide she will turn into Devil.]] ]]
* It seems a lot of people were puzzled by the scene when Homura, during her last talk with Sayaka, was showing her hands a lot. [[Spoiler: She is showing that she doesn't have her contract ring nor the fingernail mark anymore.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* It took me 3 re-watches to realize this : "No matter what sin i commit and what form i take, it's all right as long you are near me". [[spoiler: This is the moment when Homura finally lose it and breaks down. And this is the moment in which Homura decide she will turn into Devil.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Some viewers get the impression that [[spoiler: ''Rebellion'' betrays the point of the original series. ''Of course it does!'' With a movie titled ''Rebellion'', how could anyone expect anything less?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Madoka had the power to remake the universe as the raison d'être for countless timelines. [[spoiler:She wasn't the only one. All of Madoka's massive karmic potential was just riding Homura's wake.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And just in case that wasn't obvious enough, in TheStinger she [[spoiler:willingly falls off a cliff.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It was mentioned in the earlier season that Sayaka is the only magical girl who dies in ''every single timeline'', either by turning into Witch or by overusing her magic. Even Madokami couldn't do anything with since it would mean that Kyosuke would land back in hospital. [[spoiler: Homuniverse is the first timeline ever in which Sayaka is alive and yet Kyosuke's hand is still healed.]]

to:

* It was mentioned in the earlier season that Sayaka is the only magical girl who dies in ''every single timeline'', either by turning into Witch or by overusing her magic. Even Madokami couldn't do anything with it since it would mean that then Kyosuke would land back in hospital. [[spoiler: Homuniverse is the first timeline ever in which Sayaka is alive and yet Kyosuke's hand is still healed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Wonder how [[spoiler: Homura's witch barrier LotusEaterMachine was able to alter the memories of Mami and Kyoko]]? Go back to episode 4. Remember when Madoka gets sucked into Elly's barrier? She gets caught by Elly's familiars and is then ''altered''. Her body changes to resemble the art-style of the barrier. Morever, Madoka is shown images of Mami's death, which suggests Elly is reading her mind. In fact, Madoka only returns to normal when Sayaka attacks Elly. The implication is that anyone "invited" into a witch's barrier is brought under their power. [[spoiler: There's no reason to believe they can't do this to magical girls...but it's easy to see they wouldn't want to since magical girls can fight back.]] In ''Rebellion'', [[spoiler: when Kyubey is giving his explanation we see scenes of Mami and Kyoko doing ordinary things before Homulilly's Clara Doll familiars appear behind them. The Clara Dolls are powerful enough to take on a magical girl, so they must have been able to overpower Mami and Kyoko and bring them to Homulilly's barrier. Once caught by the barrier Mami and Kyoko were "altered" like Madoka was in Elly's barrier...but the alteration was done to their ''memories''.]]

to:

* Wonder how [[spoiler: Homura's witch barrier LotusEaterMachine was able to alter the memories of Mami and Kyoko]]? Go back to episode 4. Remember when Madoka gets sucked into Elly's barrier? She gets caught by Elly's familiars and is then ''altered''. Her body changes to resemble the art-style of the barrier. Morever, Madoka is shown images of Mami's death, which suggests Elly is reading her mind. In fact, Madoka only returns to normal when Sayaka attacks Elly. The implication is that anyone "invited" into a witch's barrier is brought under their power. [[spoiler: There's no reason to believe they witches can't do this to magical girls...but it's easy to see they wouldn't want to since magical girls can fight back.]] In ''Rebellion'', [[spoiler: when Kyubey is giving his explanation we see scenes of Mami and Kyoko doing ordinary things before Homulilly's Clara Doll familiars appear behind them. The Clara Dolls are powerful enough to take on a magical girl, so they must have been able to overpower Mami and Kyoko and bring them to Homulilly's barrier. Once caught by the barrier Mami and Kyoko were "altered" like Madoka was in Elly's barrier...but the alteration was done to their ''memories''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Wonder how [[spoiler: Homura's witch barrier LotusEaterMachine was able to alter the memories of Mami and Kyoko]]? Go back to episode 4. Remember when Madoka gets sucked into Elly's barrier? She gets caught by Elly's familiars and is then ''altered''. Her body changes to resemble the art-style of the barrier. Morever, Madoka is shown images of Mami's death, which suggests Elly is reading her mind. In fact, Madoka only returns to normal when Sayaka attacks Elly. The implication is that anyone "invited" into a witch's barrier is brought under their power. [[spoiler: There's no reason to believe they can't do this to magical girls...but it's easy to see they wouldn't want to since magical girls can fight back.]] In ''Rebellion'', [[spoiler: when Kyubey is giving his explanation we see scenes of Mami and Kyoko doing ordinary things before Homulilly's Clara Doll familiars appear behind them. The Clara Dolls are powerful enough to take on a magical girl, so they must have been able to overpower Mami and Kyoko and bring them to Homulilly's barrier. Once caught by the barrier Mami and Kyoko were "altered" like Madoka was in Elly's barrier...but the alteration was done to their ''memories''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* At one point Madoka says it's been a month since Homura transferred in. It's generally believed by fans that the anime took place over the course of a month (in each alternate timeline). [[spoiler: At the end of the month, Walpurgis Night appears. In other words, Homura's search for the truth is the equivalent of Walpurgis Night's appearance.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It was mentioned in the earlier season that Sayaka is the only magical girl who dies in ''every single timeline'', either by turning into Witch or by overusing her magic. Even Madokami couldn't do anything with since it would mean that Kyosuke would land back in hospital. Homuniverse is the first timeline ever in which Sayaka is alive and yet Kyosuke hand is still healed.

to:

* It was mentioned in the earlier season that Sayaka is the only magical girl who dies in ''every single timeline'', either by turning into Witch or by overusing her magic. Even Madokami couldn't do anything with since it would mean that Kyosuke would land back in hospital. [[spoiler: Homuniverse is the first timeline ever in which Sayaka is alive and yet Kyosuke Kyosuke's hand is still healed.
healed.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* It was mentioned in the earlier season that Sayaka is the only magical girl who dies in ''every single timeline'', either by turning into Witch or by overusing her magic. Even Madokami couldn't do anything with since it would mean that Kyosuke would land back in hospital. Homuniverse is the first timeline ever in which Sayaka is alive and yet Kyosuke hand is still healed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternatively [[spoiler: Love is Homura herself.]]

to:

** Alternatively [[spoiler: Love is Homura herself. This seems to be supported by the clothes "Love" wears is identical (except for being bald) to the one Homura wears prior Homulilly's resurrection. So either "Love" is marking redemption, or "Love" already died and the so-called arrival will never arrive.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And look above it. [[spoiler: There's a bow and arrow.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Take a look at the scene where Sayaka and Homura are talking [[spoiler: in Homura's new world. Homura is acting every bit like a villain, but pay attention to what the familiars are doing. [[HeelRealization Not only do they throw tomatoes at her]], but before that there's a scene where the familiars are jumping off a ledge with empty shoes on it. In Japan ''[[DrivenToSuicide this is a metaphor for suicide.]]'' It's suggests that Homura is just putting on another persona, and that she's really in her own SelfInflictedHell]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Homura's [[spoiler: barrier has been extended to cover the entire universe. Considering what its inside is like, that's not a good news for anyone who lives in the universe... [[CaptainObvious which is everyone]]. What if Homura's Nightmares begin to plague the entire cosmos? What if the Nightmares have become exacerbated due to Homura's extreme guilt? What if the Nightmare grow proportionally to Homura's guilt, which will eventually become too monumental for anyone to deal with, magical girls or no?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Alternatively, [[spoiler: Homura's a pumpkin because she's really a witch.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* During the MotiveRant, [[spoiler: Kyubey]] says that magical girls have infinite possibilities. [[spoiler: He's right. [[LaserGuidedKarma Horribly]] [[GoneHorriblyRight right.]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Alternatively [[spoiler: Love is Homura herself.]]

to:

* ** Alternatively [[spoiler: Love is Homura herself.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Alternatively [[spoiler: Love is Homura herself.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


!!FridgeHorror

* Homura's [[spoiler: familiars have splendid names like "Arrogance," "Sadsack," "Liar," "Coldheartedness," "Selfishness," "Badmouther," "Dunce," "Jealousy," "Lazybones," "Vanity," "Cowardice," "Fool," "Bias," and "Obstinance." And the last familiar? Its name is "Love," and it has ''yet to arrive.'' One can naturally conclude why Homura would want to surround herself with representations of her perceived negative qualities but not one of love.]]
** [[spoiler: On the other hand, the eventual arrival of "Love" may actually point towards an optimistic ending in the franchise, and that hope still exists for Homura, preserving the original theme of the series.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Take a good look at [[spoiler: Demon Homura's]] dress. There's a [[RuleOfSymbolism heart]], [[LoveHurts broken down the middle.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Remember in episode 6 of the anime when Madoka asks her mother for advice about how to help Sayaka? Junko tells Madoka that doing the right thing doesn't always create a happy ending, and suggests that Madoka do something wrong for Sayaka. Junko also warns that it won't be a neat and tidy resolution, and that Sayaka might misunderstand Madoka's intentions. [[spoiler: Now apply this to the ending of ''Rebellion''. Homura believes that Madoka's ascension is keeping her from being happy, and so she does something wrong - extremely wrong - in order to ensure Madoka's happiness. The resolution is not neat or tidy.]]

to:

* Remember in episode 6 of the anime when Madoka asks her mother for advice about how to help Sayaka? Junko tells Madoka that doing the right thing doesn't always create a happy ending, and suggests that Madoka do something wrong for Sayaka. Junko also warns that it won't be a neat and tidy resolution, and that Sayaka might misunderstand Madoka's intentions. [[spoiler: Now apply this to the ending of ''Rebellion''. Homura believes that Madoka's self-sacrificial ascension is keeping her from being happy, and so she does something wrong - extremely wrong - in order to ensure Madoka's happiness. The resolution is not neat or tidy.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Remember in episode 6 of the anime when Madoka asks her mother for advice about how to help Sayaka? Junko tells Madoka that doing the right thing doesn't always create a happy ending, and suggests that Madoka do something wrong for Sayaka. Junko also warns that it won't be a neat and tidy resolution, and that Sayaka might misunderstand Madoka's intentions. [[spoiler: Now apply this to the ending of ''Rebellion''. Homura believes that Madoka's ascension is keeping her from being happy, and so she does something wrong - extremely wrong - in order to ensure Madoka's happiness. The resolution is not neat or tidy.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sayaka is a raspberry as a [[ActorAllusion nod]] to [[FreshPrettyCure CureBerry]] and their matching elements.

to:

** Sayaka is a raspberry as a [[ActorAllusion nod]] to [[FreshPrettyCure CureBerry]] Cure Berry]] and their matching elements.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Kyoko is an apple because it is now her TrademarkFavoriteFood with boosted significance from ''The Different Story''.

to:

** Kyoko Kyouko is an apple because it is now her TrademarkFavoriteFood with boosted significance from ''The Different Story''.



* After the bus scene, the next we see of Kyoko is her in the arcade, in her casual outfit from the series, playing a dance game. This could probably mean that she's quit school and gone back to her old time-wasting habits since [[spoiler:she and Homura found out that they're in a fake world, and have had their minds tampered with to fit in]].

to:

* After the bus scene, the next we see of Kyoko Kyouko is her in the arcade, in her casual outfit from the series, playing a dance game. This could probably mean that she's quit school and gone back to her old time-wasting habits since [[spoiler:she and Homura found out that they're in a fake world, and have had their minds tampered with to fit in]].

Added: 23

Changed: 63

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


FridgeBrilliance:

to:

FridgeBrilliance:-----
!!FridgeBrilliance



* If one pays reaaallllyyyy close attention to the details in the illusionary world, its easy to tell its [[spoiler:a world of illusion made by Homura.]] Madoka's hair when down is longer in the movie than in the beginning of the anime, alluding to Madokami. Similarity the classroom was a lot more golden in the movie. When Homura enters, she is confident rather than shy but still her moe self, alluding to the fact that she wants to be confident but not the ultimate protector. On hindsight it gives us a really good insight on Homura's psyche.
* At the conclusion of their battle with a Nightmare, the magical girls have to ''sing'' to it. They all sit in a circle and sing a cutesy, repetitive song about cake and fruit. It seems completely silly and ridiculous--Madoka isn't a musical!--until you realize it's a ''lullaby''. Only natural that you'd need one to defeat a Nightmare.

to:

* If one pays reaaallllyyyy ''really'' close attention to the details in the illusionary world, beginning sequences, its easy to tell its [[spoiler:a world of illusion made by Homura.]] Madoka's hair when down is longer in the movie than in the beginning of the anime, alluding to Madokami. Similarity the classroom was a lot more golden in the movie. When Homura enters, she is confident rather than shy but still her moe self, alluding to the fact that she wants to be confident but not the ultimate protector. On hindsight it gives us a really good insight on Homura's psyche.
* At the conclusion of their battle with a Nightmare, the magical girls have to ''sing'' to it. They all sit in a circle and sing a cutesy, repetitive song about cake and fruit. It seems completely silly and ridiculous--Madoka isn't a musical!--until you realize it's a ''lullaby''. Only natural that you'd need one to defeat a Nightmare.Nightmare.

-----

Added: 864

Changed: 771

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I don\'t know what the official translation is, but Madoka flat out says melons get split.


* When the Cake Song is sung, Homura says she's a pumpkin. A story surrounding the pumpkin involves the origin of the Jack-O-Lantern, in which [[spoiler:a man was able to trick the devil into sparing his life by asking him to fulfill a last request, only to trap him with a crucifix when he does it. Who is often seen as the devil in ''Madoka Magica''?]]
** Similarly, Madoka's line in the Cake Song says that she's a melon. Melons are usually split into half, or pieces. [[spoiler:Now, what happens in the ending of the movie? Madoka is ''split'' from Madokami, like a melon, and forced to return to her human form, now without her goddess powers, though there is still an uneven connection.]]

to:

* When While the level of seriousness varies, every entry in the Cake Song [[EverybodyIsJesusInPurgatory means something]] to the character singing.
** Sayaka
is sung, a raspberry as a [[ActorAllusion nod]] to [[FreshPrettyCure CureBerry]] and their matching elements.
** Kyoko is an apple because it is now her TrademarkFavoriteFood with boosted significance from ''The Different Story''.
** Mami is cheese, Bebe's favorite food. Bebe likes Mami, too, and has eaten her in another timeline.
**
Homura says she's a pumpkin. A story surrounding the pumpkin involves the origin of the Jack-O-Lantern, in which [[spoiler:a man was able to trick prevent the devil into sparing Devil from claiming his life soul by asking him to fulfill a last request, only to trap him with a crucifix when he does it. Who is often seen as crucifix. He could neither go to Heaven or Hell afterward. Some fans have pointed out the devil in ''Madoka Magica''?]]
Dark Orb's shape resembles a pumpkin.]]
** Similarly, Madoka's line in the Cake Song Madoka says that she's a melon. Melons are usually melon, split into half, or pieces. to bring sweet dreams. [[spoiler:Now, what happens in the ending of the movie? Madoka is ''split'' from Madokami, like a melon, Madokami and forced to return to her human form, now without her goddess powers, though there is still an uneven connection.connection to her goddess powers.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When the Cake Song is sung, Homura says she's a pumpkin. A story surrounding the pumpkin involves the origin of the Jack-O-Lantern, in which [[spoiler:a man was able to trick the devil into sparing his life by asking him to fulfill a last request, only to trap him with a crucifix when he does it. Who is often seen as the devil in ''Madoka Magica''?]]
** Similarly, Madoka's line in the Cake Song says that she's a melon. Melons are usually split into half, or pieces. [[spoiler:Now, what happens in the ending of the movie? Madoka is ''split'' from Madokami, like a melon, and forced to return to her human form, now without her goddess powers, though there is still an uneven connection.]]
* After the bus scene, the next we see of Kyoko is her in the arcade, in her casual outfit from the series, playing a dance game. This could probably mean that she's quit school and gone back to her old time-wasting habits since [[spoiler:she and Homura found out that they're in a fake world, and have had their minds tampered with to fit in]].
* If one pays reaaallllyyyy close attention to the details in the illusionary world, its easy to tell its [[spoiler:a world of illusion made by Homura.]] Madoka's hair when down is longer in the movie than in the beginning of the anime, alluding to Madokami. Similarity the classroom was a lot more golden in the movie. When Homura enters, she is confident rather than shy but still her moe self, alluding to the fact that she wants to be confident but not the ultimate protector. On hindsight it gives us a really good insight on Homura's psyche.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

FridgeBrilliance:
* At the conclusion of their battle with a Nightmare, the magical girls have to ''sing'' to it. They all sit in a circle and sing a cutesy, repetitive song about cake and fruit. It seems completely silly and ridiculous--Madoka isn't a musical!--until you realize it's a ''lullaby''. Only natural that you'd need one to defeat a Nightmare.

Top