Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / CharlieAndTheChocolateFactory

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:FridgeLogic]]

*Willy Wonka can't say "parents" but can say "moms and dads" which is weird since he's shown to have a problem specifically with his dad so he should have more issues with saying the latter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** In the 2005 version grandpa Joe tells Charlie that Willy Wonka invented chocolate ice that doesn't melt in the sun - right before he tells a story about a Sheik who hired Wonka to build him a castle out of chocolate, which Wonka knew would melt. Guess what gave him the idea of never melting ice cream?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** That is, assuming Augustus [[ITasteDelicious doesn't eat himself first]].

Added: 324

Changed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[AC:FridgeHeartwarming]]

* Willy Wonka's glass elevator has a button for where his father lives. This means that the moment Wonka tracked down where his father moved his practice, he ''immediately'' installed a button that would take him there when he found the strength. All that time, he was hoping he'd someday be ''brave'' enough to come back...

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It is also a test aimed at his grandfather who was one of the former employees in his factory who wanted to steal one and sell it to his business rivals. Ironically Charlie's grandfather also would cause his own son's misery by releasing a product that would cause endless toothaches. Charlie was tempted by his obligation to his family and knowing when he was going too far to set them for life

Added: 458

Changed: 83

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To a lesser extent, the other kids failed by taking something they wanted: chocolate, gum, squirrels, and screentime. Charlie was the only one who was ''giving'' something; when he sees Wonka's ideas, he starts adding new ones to the notebook, not caring if Wonka would just take them as his own. Wonka was impressed that Charlie wasn't tempted to steal the recipes and show them to Prodnose or Slugworth, which a less-conscientious kid would have done.



** It adds credience in the 2017 Broadway version, as it's implied that Wonka has gotten bitter and thus why his actions are the way they are; he went from a man who was inspired to do many great things but gets wrecked by people who aren't exactly great for imaginative people like him. Thus he grew bitter and cold towards the world, but something in Charlie reawakened a part of him.

to:

** It adds credience in the 2017 Broadway version, as it's implied that Wonka has gotten bitter and thus why his actions are the way they are; he went from a man who was inspired to do many great things but gets wrecked by people who aren't exactly great for imaginative people like him. Thus he grew bitter and cold towards the world, but something in Charlie reawakened a part of him when Charlie happily collects Wonka bar wrappers and says they provide joy for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 78

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Wonka mentions at one point that about 20 Oompas died of the chewing gum. Why did the first victim's partners not wisen up and never eat the gum again? Simple; they did, and were then forced into balls so that the others could practice their choreography.

to:

** Wonka mentions at one point that about 20 Oompas died of the chewing gum. Why did the first victim's partners not wisen wise up and never eat the gum again? Simple; they did, and were then forced into balls so that the others could practice their choreography.choreography.
** He never said they ''died''; he only said ''they turned into blueberries.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's why ''also'' Willy brushed off Augustus's question about the lack of introductions. He wasn't being aloof; he just ''already'' knew their names.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* If you subscribe to the theory that Augustus didn't just end up covered in chocolate, but was actually turned into living chocolate, then the story of Prince Ponidicherry is a stark reminder of what Augustus' ultimate fate will be unless his parents either move somewhere that's cold all year-round, or somehow throw together a Mr. Freeze-style suit for Augustus to live in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Despite repeated queries regarding how the Oompa Loompas knew the rotten children's names while singing about them in spite of not having been introduced and Wonka's attempts to dodge the question by passing it off as improv, it makes perfect sense given that the four children (not counting Charlie, who doesn't get a song because he wasn't eliminated) were interviewed on live television, thus allowing Wonka and the Oompa Loompas to learn their names and to recognize their flaws by observing their behavior simply by watching them on TV (especially since they have a Television Room). This would then allow them to come up with musical numbers that directly call out the respective child on their weaknesses.

Added: 855

Changed: 123

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Each of the songs is lifted from the book, but their musical style is representative of the character getting a send-off:
**Augustus Gloop's song is a big band Bollywood dance number, representing his overweightness with heavy drums and trumpets.
**Violet Beauregarde's sendoff is a jazzy rock song out of a Michael Jackson music video, and the Oompa Loompas even dance in a victory dance with the hands pointing up and then pointing down.
**Veruca Salt's song is a very soothing and relaxing Beatles-style song, like one were in a luxurious garden and swaying in a hammock, living the life of luxury, signifying her status of being incredibly rich. There's even a use of Indian string instruments usually used when displaying scenes of royalty in Indian plays.
**Mike Teavee's song is a heavy metal piece, representing his violent tendencies and how you're supposed to bob your head up and down aggressively when hearing that kind of music. Exactly the kind of thing he would do.

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Is Willy Wonka telling the truth about the Oompa Loompas, or is "Loompaland" a coverup in which Wonka has taken regular people, miniaturized, and enslaved them? But then again, it's not like he has inventions that change one's appearance (Violet) or can shrink people (Mike)...

to:

* Is Willy Wonka telling the truth about the Oompa Loompas, or is "Loompaland" a coverup in which Wonka has taken regular people, miniaturized, people and brainwashed, miniaturized and enslaved them? But then again, [[SarcasmMode it's not like like]] he has inventions that change one's appearance (Violet) or can shrink people (Mike)...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It adds credience in the 2017 Broadway version, as it's implied that Wonka has gotten bitter and thus why his actions are the way they are; he went from a man who was inspired to do many great things but gets wrecked by people who aren't exactly great for imaginative people like him. Thus he grew bitter and cold towards the world, but something in Charlie reawakened a part of him.

to:

** It adds credience in the 2017 Broadway version, as it's implied that Wonka has gotten bitter and thus why his actions are the way they are; he went from a man who was inspired to do many great things but gets wrecked by people who aren't exactly great for imaginative people like him. Thus he grew bitter and cold towards the world, but something in Charlie reawakened a part of him.him.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Either that or sweat, washing, etc.


Added DiffLines:

*** "Into that sort of thing"? She's a kid!


Added DiffLines:

*** Seeing as the juice got squeezed out of her and it includes her hair and teeth, she's probably not blue because of juice. And if it being squeezed out of her was harmless, the juice probably never replaced her blood. She'd probably bleed normally, although it might be blue.

Changed: 18

Removed: 3791

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fridge Logic goes on Headscratchers


[[AC:FridgeLogic]]
* Applies to both films, really, with a bit of NewMediaAreEvil thrown in for good measure. Think about it: the Oompa Loompas are singing a morality song about TV rotting your brain... ''in a movie''. Slightly excusable in that they're kind of saying it's an '''excess''' of TV that's bad, but it's still a little "Huh?".
** It gets even funnier when the movie is being aired on TV. (The song in the book pretty much says any TV is bad, period.)
** Making chocolate bars smaller. Pointed out in a ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' [[CharlieAndTheChocolateParody parody]] with Al Gore:
-->'''Glen Wonka (Al Gore) to his brother Willy:''' Wait! I almost forgot! There's that billion dollars you spent on that machine that turns giant candy bars into tiny chocolate bars. Help me wrap my brain around that one 'cause I'm missing the big profit opportunity!
*** Hang on, he's got a machine that can miniaturise ANYTHING, even living things. It would have innumerable applications in electronics, where years of research has been put into making smaller components. And that doesn't include the fact that he's invented a way to teleport any matter to a network of pre-existing recievers (all the TV sets in the world). Kind of useful...
** It's actually pointed out in the second movie when they shut down the room once the scene ends, implying that the whole thing served no purpose than to get that brat to shrink himself.
** The point was presumably to turn giant candy bars into ''millions'' of candy bars across the country, which would introduce the FridgeLogic of ReedRichardsIsUseless.
*** Thoroughly explained in the book as Willy Wonka trying to reach a new market. Back when Dahl first wrote the book, television for the general public was still a fairly new concept. It's ridiculous, yes, but then so are the Square Sweets That Look Round - Willy Wonka clearly has money to burn on ridiculous concepts like making giant candy bars and shrinking them down one at a time via an awkward giant camera setup.
** Chocolate doesn't have to make sense.
*** That's why it's chocolate.
* The logic behind the kids' "punishments" was always kind of interesting to me. While all four are spoiled, it's only Veruca's parents who are punished alongside her. This is apparently because, as the song says, they share the blame for her character flaw. With the others, however, this is apparently not so. While the text does make it clear that the Gloops, Beauregardes, and Teavees either encourage or turn a blind eye to their childrens' flaws, the punishment eventually falls on the kids alone - it is Augustus who is sucked painfully up the pipe, it is Violet who is permanently blue, and it is Mike who is now a Slender-Man-esque freak of nature, while the parents only look on with dismay. Augustus's song especially makes it clear that he's just a loathsome human being (though we don't get too much evidence of that in his behavior besides, you know, his gluttony). But why do their parents, unlike Veruca's, get off scot-free?
** Possibly because Mr. Salt has the distinction of having a ''direct'' role in Veruca's brattiness, while the Gloops, Mrs. Beauregarde, and the Teevees are only responsible ''indirectly'', by not stopping the bad habits.
* Charlie Bucket only found the fifth Golden Ticket on Jan 31, the night before the event. Which means no media circus, and no time for the Oompa-Loompas to rehearse a jaunty little death-and-dismemberment song for Charlie. Maybe that's the "real" reason he was the last child standing.
* "We need the money more than we need the chocolate." But going already guarantees a lifetime supply of chocolate even before the special prize is revealed. They can still sell the chocolate after the factory tour. (Of course, they don't know yet what the tour will involve.)

to:

[[AC:FridgeLogic]]
* Applies to both films, really, with a bit of NewMediaAreEvil thrown in for good measure. Think about it: the Oompa Loompas are singing a morality song about TV rotting your brain... ''in a movie''. Slightly excusable in that they're kind of saying it's an '''excess''' of TV that's bad, but it's still a little "Huh?".
** It gets even funnier when the movie is being aired on TV. (The song in the book pretty much says any TV is bad, period.)
** Making chocolate bars smaller. Pointed out in a ''Series/SaturdayNightLive'' [[CharlieAndTheChocolateParody parody]] with Al Gore:
-->'''Glen Wonka (Al Gore) to his brother Willy:''' Wait! I almost forgot! There's that billion dollars you spent on that machine that turns giant candy bars into tiny chocolate bars. Help me wrap my brain around that one 'cause I'm missing the big profit opportunity!
*** Hang on, he's got a machine that can miniaturise ANYTHING, even living things. It would have innumerable applications in electronics, where years of research has been put into making smaller components. And that doesn't include the fact that he's invented a way to teleport any matter to a network of pre-existing recievers (all the TV sets in the world). Kind of useful...
** It's actually pointed out in the second movie when they shut down the room once the scene ends, implying that the whole thing served no purpose than to get that brat to shrink himself.
** The point was presumably to turn giant candy bars into ''millions'' of candy bars across the country, which would introduce the FridgeLogic of ReedRichardsIsUseless.
*** Thoroughly explained in the book as Willy Wonka trying to reach a new market. Back when Dahl first wrote the book, television for the general public was still a fairly new concept. It's ridiculous, yes, but then so are the Square Sweets That Look Round - Willy Wonka clearly has money to burn on ridiculous concepts like making giant candy bars and shrinking them down one at a time via an awkward giant camera setup.
** Chocolate doesn't have to make sense.
*** That's why it's chocolate.
* The logic behind the kids' "punishments" was always kind of interesting to me. While all four are spoiled, it's only Veruca's parents who are punished alongside her. This is apparently because, as the song says, they share the blame for her character flaw. With the others, however, this is apparently not so. While the text does make it clear that the Gloops, Beauregardes, and Teavees either encourage or turn a blind eye to their childrens' flaws, the punishment eventually falls on the kids alone - it is Augustus who is sucked painfully up the pipe, it is Violet who is permanently blue, and it is Mike who is now a Slender-Man-esque freak of nature, while the parents only look on with dismay. Augustus's song especially makes it clear that he's just a loathsome human being (though we don't get too much evidence of that in his behavior besides, you know, his gluttony). But why do their parents, unlike Veruca's, get off scot-free?
** Possibly because Mr. Salt has the distinction of having a ''direct'' role in Veruca's brattiness, while the Gloops, Mrs. Beauregarde, and the Teevees are only responsible ''indirectly'', by not stopping the bad habits.
* Charlie Bucket only found the fifth Golden Ticket on Jan 31, the night before the event. Which means no media circus, and no time for the Oompa-Loompas to rehearse a jaunty little death-and-dismemberment song for Charlie. Maybe that's the "real" reason he was the last child standing.
* "We need the money more than we need the chocolate." But going already guarantees a lifetime supply of chocolate even before the special prize is revealed. They can still sell the chocolate after the factory tour. (Of course, they don't know yet what the tour will involve.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fridge Logic goes on Headscratchers


[[AC:FridgeLogic]]
* When Wonka reopens his factory and won't let anyone in, how does he market his wares without having to deal with workplace safety and food health regulations?
** Money.
** Can't say anything about the second film, but keep in mind that the original book was written seven years before OSHA existed, and the first film was released the same year OSHA was officially established.[[note]]And the latter actually included a number of on-set incidents that would likely get the studio in legal trouble today, like Veruca's actress cutting herself on a rock in the chocolate room and everyone having a bad reaction to the "soap"(actually fire extinguisher foam) in the Wonka-Wash scene.[[/note]] Presumably, as long as there wasn't a rash of people getting ill from his products, no-one saw a reason to investigate.
* Augustus is described as being very thin after being squeezed in the pipe. How is that possible?? Is his flesh just hanging off him loosely? And for that matter, how do the physics of the entire pipe scene work?
** That pipe is not the only physics-defying object owned by Willy Wonka: the elevator that goes to space is another. If we don't want to apply thought-stopping mantras like AWizardDidIt or the MST3KMantra, we could infer that Willy Wonka possesses SufficientlyAdvancedTechnology. As to ''why'' he does, it could be that he is actually an alien. In keeping with the spirit of Wiki/TVTropes, we could guess that he is a JustForFun/TimeLord, and the factory is his [=TARDIS=]. From this, we could even understand how he deals with workplace safety and food health regulations: the inside of his factory actually ''does'' conform to safety and hygiene rules, but whenever children come to visit it, he activates a combination of holograms that make it look like a crazy theme park. In other words, nothing of what the children see is real.
** The pipes work in the same way that the taffy-puller can restore Mike Teavee to human height if not human proportions; the juicing room can 'fix' blueberrification; and the Television Chocolate device somehow renders TV screens insubstantial as a side effect of its teleportation power - ''they shouldn't.'' But they do. This is one of those 'sense of childlike wonder' things that Wonka's 'fairyland' expects you to accept.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trimming This Troper, also cut a poorly written and punctuated piece. Fridge pages are not forums.


** If you look at most of Roald Dahl's books, the hero kids tend to be fairly quiet and well-behaved. Even when they're living in awful situations, they rarely, if ever, complain. I don't want to say Dahl disliked children, but he does appear to have disliked loud ones.

to:

** If you look at most of Roald Dahl's books, the hero kids tend to be fairly quiet and well-behaved. Even when they're living in awful situations, they rarely, if ever, complain. I don't want to say Dahl disliked children, but he does appear appears to have disliked loud ones.children.






** Well ,I think there are two reasons why Charlie had that thougt. 1.There was already people who make offer on that ticket ,and it's the last ticket ,on the last day before the dealine ,so of course there are a tons of people who is willing to pay any price for it. While the "guarantees" of a lifetime supply (place the item), at least IRL , usually means a fix amount of the item that by the corp's "calculation"(Including RDA(Recommended Dietary Allowance) and life expectancy....sort of things) is what "a lifetime supply" that probaly has the "complimentary - not for sale" wrote in the fine prints....which not only came in a limited number , but also has a fixed resale prices....So, in short, didn't have the same "money making" chance than just sold the ticket. 2.It's the traditional "Water afar off quencheth not fire." kind of situation, reselling the candy(even if it didn't came with "complimentary - not for sale" wrote all over it) ,will take a relatively long time and make relatively small money. While just sold the ticket may of may not let the Buckets make a relatively large money, in a surly short time ,that can used to pay the already due bills and at least survive for maybe days or weeks...maybe rest of the year(or life).

to:

** Well ,I think there are two reasons why Charlie had that thougt. 1.There was already people who make offer on that ticket ,and it's the last ticket ,on the last day before the dealine ,so of course there are a tons of people who is willing to pay any price for it. While the "guarantees" of a lifetime supply (place the item), at least IRL , usually means a fix amount of the item that by the corp's "calculation"(Including RDA(Recommended Dietary Allowance) and life expectancy....sort of things) is what "a lifetime supply" that probaly has the "complimentary - not for sale" wrote in the fine prints....which not only came in a limited number , but also has a fixed resale prices....So, in short, didn't have the same "money making" chance than just sold the ticket. 2.It's the traditional "Water afar off quencheth not fire." kind of situation, reselling the candy(even if it didn't came with "complimentary - not for sale" wrote all over it) ,will take a relatively long time and make relatively small money. While just sold the ticket may of may not let the Buckets make a relatively large money, in a surly short time ,that can used to pay the already due bills and at least survive for maybe days or weeks...maybe rest of the year(or life).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** If you look at most of Roald Dahl's books, the hero kids tend to be fairly quiet and well-behaved. Even when they're living in awful situations, they rarely, if ever, complain. I don't want to say Dahl disliked children, but he does appear to have disliked loud ones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Well ,I think there are two reasons why Charlie had that thougt. 1.There was already people who make offer on that ticket ,and it's the last ticket ,on the last day before the dealine ,so of course there are a tons of people who is willing to pay any price for it. While the "guarantees" of a lifetime supply (place the item), at least IRL , usually means a fix amount of the item that by the corp's "calculation"(Including RDA(Recommended Dietary Allowance) and life expectancy....sort of things) is what "a lifetime supply" that probaly has the "complimentary - not for sale" wrote in the fine prints....which not only came in a limited number , but also has a fixed resale prices....So, in short, didn't have the same "money making" chance than just sold the ticket. 2.It's the traditional "Water afar off quencheth not fire." kind of situation, reselling the candy(even if it didn't came with "complimentary - not for sale" wrote all over it) ,will take a relatively long time and make relatively small money. While just sold the ticket may of may not let the Buckets make a relatively large money, in a surly short time ,that can used to pay the already due bills and at least survive for maybe days or weeks...maybe rest of the year(or life).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The vehicles slowly get smaller as the film goes on. This means that [[spoiler: Wonka not only knew which rooms would take out which kids, but he also knew how many people they would lose per room.]]

to:

* The vehicles slowly get smaller as the film goes on. This means that [[spoiler: Wonka not only knew which rooms would take out which kids, but he also knew how many people they would lose per room.]] Also, in the Television Room, there are only enough pairs of glasses for the people who ended up there, but there are none for the other members of the tour who got removed by the incidents. Wonka knew exactly how many people would make it to that point.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Can't say anything about the second film, but keep in mind that the original book was written seven years before OSHA existed, and the first film was released the same year OSHA was officially established.[[note]]And the latter actually included a number of on-set incidents that would likely get the studio in legal trouble today, like Veruca's actress cutting herself on a rock in the chocolate room and everyone having a bad reaction to the "soap"(actually fire extinguisher foam) in the Wonka-Wash scene.[[/note]] Presumably, as long as there wasn't a rash of people getting ill from his products, no-one saw a reason to investigate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed typo


** On another note, cam you imagine the process of "squeezing" done on Violet? Being pressed from all sides until all the juice is out is NOT fun.

to:

** On another note, cam can you imagine the process of "squeezing" done on Violet? Being pressed from all sides until all the juice is out is NOT fun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That pipe is not the only physics-defying object owned by Willy Wonka: the elevator that goes to space is another. If we don't want to apply thought-stopping mantras like AWizardDidIt or the MST3KMantra, we could infer that Willy Wonka possesses SufficientlyAdvancedTechnology. As to ''why'' he does, it could be that he is actually an alien. In keeping with the spirit of Wiki/TVTropes, we could guess that he is a TimeLord, and the factory is his [=TARDIS=]. From this, we could even understand how he deals with workplace safety and food health regulations: the inside of his factory actually ''does'' conform to safety and hygiene rules, but whenever children come to visit it, he activates a combination of holograms that make it look like a crazy theme park. In other words, nothing of what the children see is real.

to:

** That pipe is not the only physics-defying object owned by Willy Wonka: the elevator that goes to space is another. If we don't want to apply thought-stopping mantras like AWizardDidIt or the MST3KMantra, we could infer that Willy Wonka possesses SufficientlyAdvancedTechnology. As to ''why'' he does, it could be that he is actually an alien. In keeping with the spirit of Wiki/TVTropes, we could guess that he is a TimeLord, JustForFun/TimeLord, and the factory is his [=TARDIS=]. From this, we could even understand how he deals with workplace safety and food health regulations: the inside of his factory actually ''does'' conform to safety and hygiene rules, but whenever children come to visit it, he activates a combination of holograms that make it look like a crazy theme park. In other words, nothing of what the children see is real.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When Mr. Salt tries to talk down Veruca in the Nut Room, Wonka ''smiles.'' When he fails, Wonka frowns again and allows the plan to proceed. From this one moment, it's clear that Wonka hopes that none of these disasters will need to happen to the children, but of course, they all do, and they just have to learn the hard way.



* When Mr. Salt tries to talk down Veruca in the Nut Room, Wonka ''smiles.'' When he fails, Wonka frowns again and allows the plan to proceed. From this one moment, it's clear that Wonka hopes that none of these disasters will need to happen to the children, but of course, they all do, and they just have to learn the hard way.

to:

* When Mr. Salt tries to talk down Veruca in the Nut Room, Wonka ''smiles.'' When he fails, Wonka frowns again and allows the plan to proceed. From this one moment, it's clear that Wonka hopes that none of these disasters will need to happen to the children, but of course, they all do, and they just have to learn the hard way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I think once you find out that the whole purpose of the Golden Tickets was to find a child to name as heir, it moves past being just "implied" that Wonka set the entire tour up to weed out the bad kids. Each one of them was specifically placed in situations that suited their respective vices and each one of them gave in to their temptations. Except Charlie. Of course the Oompa-Loompas had songs prepared. They probably had one ready for Charlie as well. The "good at improvising" line is a SuspiciouslySpecificDenial, after all...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When Mr. Salt tries to talk down Veruca in the Nut Room, Wonka ''smiles.'' When he fails, Wonka frowns again and allows the plan to proceed. From this one moment, it's clear that Wonka hopes that none of these disasters will need to happen to the children, but of course, they all do, and they just have to learn the hard way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Over at the Headscratchers page, it's been asked why, in all versions, Mr. Wonka chose to close his factory and sack his workforce when he discovered his recipes were being stolen when he might have instituted tighter security measures, etc. instead. This version, without stating it outright, actually provides an interesting explanation if one thinks things through: This Wonka became a confectioner ForHappiness, believes in DoingItForTheArt, and is terribly sensitive about his work (as artists tend to be). Realizing that rivals were stealing/ripping off the wonderful confections he poured his imagination and heart into -- out of envy and greed, seeing it only as a commodity -- would have been absolutely soul-crushing for him, perhaps serving as a CynicismCatalyst. His emotional distress, in conjunction with his established eccentricity, might well have driven him to the extreme measure of closing the factory and only reopening it once he'd found a way to (via the self-contained Oompa-Loompa workforce as it turned out) make his factory virtually self-sufficient, that he might continue to make that outside world a happier place with his creations yet NeverBeHurtAgain by those who would find ways to exploit his gifts.

to:

* Over at the Headscratchers page, it's been asked why, in all versions, Mr. Wonka chose to close his factory and sack his workforce when he discovered his recipes were being stolen when he might have instituted tighter security measures, etc. instead. This version, without stating it outright, actually provides an interesting explanation if one thinks things through: This Wonka became a confectioner ForHappiness, believes in DoingItForTheArt, and is terribly sensitive about his work (as artists tend to be). Realizing that rivals were stealing/ripping off the wonderful confections he poured his imagination and heart into -- out of envy and greed, seeing it only as a commodity -- would have been absolutely soul-crushing for him, perhaps serving as a CynicismCatalyst. His emotional distress, in conjunction with his established eccentricity, might well have driven him to the extreme measure of closing the factory and only reopening it once he'd found a way to (via the self-contained Oompa-Loompa workforce as it turned out) make his factory virtually self-sufficient, that he might continue to make that outside world a happier place with his creations yet NeverBeHurtAgain by those who would find ways to exploit his gifts.gifts.
** It adds credience in the 2017 Broadway version, as it's implied that Wonka has gotten bitter and thus why his actions are the way they are; he went from a man who was inspired to do many great things but gets wrecked by people who aren't exactly great for imaginative people like him. Thus he grew bitter and cold towards the world, but something in Charlie reawakened a part of him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That pipe is not the only physics-defying object owned by Willy Wonka: the elevator that goes to space is another. If we don't want to apply thought-stopping mantras like AWizardDidIt or the MST3KMantra, we could infer that Willy Wonka possesses SufficientlyAdvancedTechnology. As to ''why'' he does, it could be that he is actually an alien. In keeping with the spirit of TVTropes, we could guess that he is a TimeLord, and the factory is his [=TARDIS=]. From this, we could even understand how he deals with workplace safety and food health regulations: the inside of his factory actually ''does'' conform to safety and hygiene rules, but whenever children come to visit it, he activates a combination of holograms that make it look like a crazy theme park. In other words, nothing of what the children see is real.

to:

** That pipe is not the only physics-defying object owned by Willy Wonka: the elevator that goes to space is another. If we don't want to apply thought-stopping mantras like AWizardDidIt or the MST3KMantra, we could infer that Willy Wonka possesses SufficientlyAdvancedTechnology. As to ''why'' he does, it could be that he is actually an alien. In keeping with the spirit of TVTropes, Wiki/TVTropes, we could guess that he is a TimeLord, and the factory is his [=TARDIS=]. From this, we could even understand how he deals with workplace safety and food health regulations: the inside of his factory actually ''does'' conform to safety and hygiene rules, but whenever children come to visit it, he activates a combination of holograms that make it look like a crazy theme park. In other words, nothing of what the children see is real.

Top